Cook's Illustrated

Overhauling Sloppy Joes

When my kids were little, making Sloppy Joes was a win-win situation. They loved eating them, and I loved sneaking bites off their plates. Eating a full portion of the filling, however, was off the table, since it was one-dimensional and cloyingly sweet.

That said, those few bites were such a guilty pleasure that I’ve often wondered if I could give the sandwich an overhaul so that it could satisfy adults and kids alike. After all, the filling couldn’t be any easier to make: Just sauté some chopped onion (and sometimes celery, carrot, and bell pepper) in a skillet before adding ground beef to brown, and then finish with a ketchup-based sauce. And who knows? Maybe techniques that we normally apply to highbrow foods would come in handy here, too.

The Meat of the Matter

It’s no wonder that the sauce for Sloppy Joe filling is often candy-sweet, since it contains anywhere from ½ cup to 1 cup of ketchup

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Cook's Illustrated

Cook's Illustrated7 min read
Ingredient Notes
For all its extraordinary umami, dashi (page 6) requires only water and two ingredients: kombu, or dried kelp, and katsuobushi, also known as bonito flakes. Here are a few tips for purchasing and storing these products so you can make this type of h
Cook's Illustrated4 min read
Green Shakshuka
Afew years back, I developed a recipe for shakshuka—a one-skillet meal of eggs gently poached in a robust tomato–red pepper sauce. As you scoop up savory mouthfuls with swaths of bread, the runny yolks and ruddy sauce merge in a delicious demonstrati
Cook's Illustrated6 min read
Kitchen Notes
If you’re peeling a potato and see green under the skin, keep peeling until there’s no more green. While the tint itself isn’t a problem, the color indicates the presence of a toxin on the potato flesh. Here’s what’s going on: When a potato is expose

Related