The American Scholar

How We Came Together

UNION: The Struggle to Forge the Story of United States Nationhood

BY COLIN WOODARD

Viking, 432 pp., $30

THE ANTHROPOLOGIST Sally Falk Moore thought that some portion of legal reasoning was really masquerade. Studying colonial East Africa, she found that legal changes billed as rational reforms were, when viewed over a century, simply mirroring economic and political changes.

The implication? Seemingly disinterested law is a cover for politics. Judges and lawyers may not realize it, Moore wrote, but their careful arguments of legal norms really function as a means of displacing responsibility. Those involved are not reasoning; they are unwittingly disguising the exercise of power behind a vague abstraction called The Law.

I kept thinking of Moore’s argument while reading Colin Woodard’s an exploration of the ideas that guided the country from its first days as

Vous lisez un aperçu, inscrivez-vous pour en lire plus.

Plus de The American Scholar

The American Scholar4 min de lecture
Let America Be America Again
FOLLOWING DONALD TRUMP’S election, a poem by Langston Hughes started trending on social media and, in the aftermath of the death of George Floyd and others in police custody, the poem has found new urgency. Perhaps it was the word again that first dr
The American Scholar7 min de lecture
The Poet Who Painted
“MY LIFE IS A TANGO, my heart a Grand Guignol,” declared Max Jacob in his poem “Romantic Allusions to Mardi-Gras.” He could have listed many other such contradictions. Born in Brittany in 1876 to a secular Jewish shopkeeping family, Jacob was a conve
The American Scholar8 min de lecture
A Mind on Fire
HENRY DAVID THOREAU liked to compare himself to a rooster whose crowing wakes his neighbors, calling them back from sleep to an awareness of the present. “We cannot afford not to live in the present. He is blessed over all mortals who loses no moment