Report On The Innovatives Measures Regarding Wp3 To Wp7 in The Participating Countries

D3.1 D4.1 D5.1 D6.1 D7.
Esms
With the support of
The sole responsibility for the content of this publication lies with the authors. It does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the European Union. Neither the EACI nor the European Commission are responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.
REPORT ON THE INNOVATIVES MEASURES REGARDING WP3 TO WP7 IN THE PARTICIPATING COUNTRIES
ESMS WORK SCIENTIFIC

PARTNER
DELPHIS
Julien Bonnet Francis Deplace
DATE
07.06.2012
CONTENT
Version 1.0 Draft
ZRMK
Marjanna Sijanec-Zavrl Marta Skubic
29.06.2012
Version 1.1 add WP5 inputs
STU-K
Tomas Vimmr
29.06.2012
Version 1.2 Comments and inputs WP4 Version 1.3 add inputs WP6 Version 1.4 Comments and inputs WP3
SCHOLE/SITI
Arianna Dongiovanni
1.07.2012
CSTB
Pierre Boisson Orlando Catarina Marc Colombard-Prout.
1.07.2012
IWU
Britta Stein Iris Behr
01.07.2012
Version1.5 Additions to WP7 Suggestions for chapter O and chapter1. Version 2.0 Collecting Scientific Partners Inputs. Proofreading. Final comments. Version 2.0 proofreading and WP2 leader validation. Validation 2.0
DELPHIS
Julien Bonnet Francis Deplace
02.07.2012
AAA
Elsebeth Terkelsen
01.07.2012
SHOs
July 2012
ESMS CONTENT
0. INTRODUCTION - REMINDER : AFTER STAKES 1. REMINDER: OBJECTIVES OF THE PROCESS OF THE PRE-SELECTION OF ESMs
1.1. OBJECTIVES OF THE PROCESS: 1.2. IDENTIFICATION OF THE PRIORITY TOPICS 5 6 2.1. TENANTS INFORMATION 2.2. ENERgY MONITORINg 2.3. CONTRACTINg AND PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES 2.4. ENERgY MANAgER
2. WORK PACKAGE 3: OPERATING MANAGEMENT
WORK PACKAGE 3: 22 FACTSHEETS 3. WORK PACKAGE 4: RUNNING MAINTENANCE
11
3.1. THE REPAIR/MAINTENANCE OF TEMPERATURE CONTROl DEVICES AND REPAIR/MAINTENANCE OF HYDRAUlIC CONTROl DEVICES (FlOW/PRESSURE). 3.2. THE OPTIMIZATION AND THE MAINTENANCE OF THE DIFFERENT ElEMENTS OF THE HEATINg SYSTEM. 3.3. THE MAINTENANCE OF THE VENTIlATION SYSTEM (lINk WITH THE INDOOR AIR QUAlITY) 3.4. WATER-SAVINg kITS 3.5. lIgHT CONTROl SYSTEMS
22
WORK PACKAGE 4: 20 FACTSHEETS 4. WORK PACKAGE 5: REPLACEMENT OF SYSTEMS
25
4.1. O&M ASPECTS FOR lOW TEMPERATURE BOIlERS AND CONDENSINg BOIlERS 4.2. REPlACEMENT OF DISTRICT HEATINg SUBSTATION 4.3. REPlACEMENT OF VENTIlATION SYSTEMS 4.4. REPlACEMENT OF HOT WATER TANk 4.5. REPlACEMENT OF OlD BOIlER WITH WOOD BIOMASS DISTRICT HEATINg SYSTEM 4.6. INSTAllATION OF SOlAR PANElS
36
WORK PACKAGE 5: 24 FACTSHEETS 5. WORK PACKAGE 6: REFURBISHED BUILDINGS

5.1. ExTERNAl THERMAl INSUlATION OF THE BUIlDINg SHEll 5.2. WINDOW SUBSTITUTION 5.3. VENTIlATION SYSTEM
38
50
WORK PACKAGE 6: 20 FACTSHEETS 6. WORK PACKAGE 7: LOW-ENERGY BUILDINGS WORK PACKAGE 7: 12 FACTSHEETS
52
64 66
ESMS 0. INTRODUCTION
REMINDER : AFTER STAKES
STAKE 1: ACT GLOBAL
Identifying the Energy Saving Measures for the different types of buildings AFTER aims at identifying energy saving measures and actions that can be immediately and easily implemented both in existing buildings and recently delivered buildings. AFTER focuses on the management and maintenance topics. The project covers a large scale of the housing stock. The project gives priority to a general understanding and action of what could be energy performance practices at a global scale of the stock. analyzing the on-field constraints and scenarios. - To identify relevant types of partners collaborating with the Social Housing Companies and to share information and data (price information, quality assessment, etc.)
STAKE 4: A COLLECTIVE TOOL FOR ASSESSING ENERGY SAVING MEASURES
Assessing the energy performance of the housing stock. AFTER, participating members will build a common definition of the energy performance using economic, energy and social (tenants awareness, usability, supportability) concerns. Using on field experiences, AFTER will also permit to share and to set up common indicators that will assess the effective performance of the energy saving measures implemented in the housing of our participating members.
STAKE 2: CREATE A DATA BASIS FOR THE COMPANIES STRATEGIC POSITIONING

Reading the general strategies implemented by participating companies regarding the energy performance
The aim of AFTER is also to highlight the main strategic choices implemented by Social Housing Companies regarding energy performance. AFTER supports the portfolio management process of a housing company. (Remember the EU-project ESAM= Energy Saving Asset Management).
STAKE 3: A COLLECTIVE TOOL FOR DISSEMINATING KNOWLEDGE
Resource sharing, experience feedback and best practices among technical services This approach follows different paths: - To constitute a database of standardized practices with positive feedback. To prevent eventual difficulties
ESMS OBJECTIVES OF 1. REMINDER:

THE PROCESS OF THE PRESELECTION OF ESMs
1.1. OBJECTIVES OF THE PROCESS:
The objective of the Pre-selection- process of ESMs is to give a first overview for the different ESMs collected in the Inventory. In order to obtain this overview, DElPHIS asked to all the partners from the SHOs and their scientific partners to select, among the ESMs inventoried for every WP, those 5 ESMs identified as the most relevant. Usefulness: The objective of this document is to build upon the drafted Factsheets to prepare and monitor the pending ESM selection. The partners, both Social Housing Companies/National Housing Associations and Research Institutes, will identify the most significant ESMs collected. This identification process will help us: To know what are the main tendencies for the partners regarding the different WPs and to identify priorities at a large scale. To make the coordination easier for the ESM selection stage ensuring that the selected ESMs will give a good overview of the main topics regarding energy efficiency in the housing stock. To support the Factsheets process (which is an iterative progress a set of questions and answers: questions coming from the scientific partners to secure the global approach and answers coming from the SHOs securing the main objective of AFTER: looking for cost effective energy saving measures immediately and easily to be implemented) identifying the most relevant and useful Factsheets to complete. Process: The implementation phase of AFTER will test on-site optimum standards for ESMs regarding O&M of the housing stock. The process focuses on optimization measures relevant to be implemented. The identified ESMs will represent interesting tendencies to contribute to the global energy efficiency of the stock. As a consequence, the identified ESMs have to be selected using complementary criteria: their strategic role in the management and maintenance of the housing stock (professional knowledge). Their known efficiency and performance and their dissemination potential as a standardized solution (Inventory + professional knowledge). Their optimization potential. The process aims at giving priorities according to the experience and the professional knowledge of the SHOs and their scientific partners. These professional skills should complete the existing ESMs collection and the data collected in it. The Inventory has to be used as a list to name and identify the relevant ESM. The document gives clues regarding the main characteristics to identify relevant ESMs: - The ESM perimeter: number of flat and gross m2 - The ESM investment: Initial investment + Expected 0&M costs - The ESM energy impact: kWh/m2.year before and after the ESM implementation (weighted using HDD) - The satisfaction of the SHO which has experimented the ESM
ESMS OBJECTIVES OF 1. REMINDER:

THE PROCESS OF THE PRESELECTION OF ESMs
These data helps to have a first assessment of the different ESMs regarding the economic impact, the energy performance and the management opportunity for every inventoried measure. Even if the data can be incomplete in the Inventory, the t partners will complete the assessment using their professional knowledge to identify what are the priorities to experiment during the implementation phase of the AFTER project. This pre-selection process gives a qualitative evaluation and assessment of the ESMs reported in the inventory. It consists of the professional inputs of the SHOs and their scientific partners. It represents an important coordination tool to synthetize but also to orientation the ESM selection phase and to anticipate the implementation stage. Main themes are classified regarding the 5 work packages of AFTER: WP3 - OPERATINg MANAgEMENT / WP4 - RUNNINg MAINTENANCE / WP5 - REMPlACEMENT OF SYSTEMS / WP6 -RECENTlY REFURBISHED BUIlDINgS / WP7 - RECENT lOW ENERgY BUIlDINgS / For each WP the document gives an overview of the most popular ESMs and a short description of the ESMs including identification according to the Inventory. The ESMs and stakes in this document dont cover all the topics identified in the Inventory but signal main trends to investigate during the implementation phase (testing at the pilot sites). In this document the SHOs and NHAs pre-selection has been completed with comments from the Scientific WP leaders, indicating the main potential for optimization linked to the different proposed ESMs.
1.2. IDENTIFICATION OF THE PRIORITY TOPICS

The objective of the Pre-selection process is to give a first overview of the different ESMs collected in the Inventory. In order to obtain this overview, DElPHIS asked the different partners to select each 5 ESMs for every WP. The ESMs should be selected among the ESMs in the Inventory, identified as the most relevant and as having the best potential to increase the energy performance of the social housing stock using O&M. This pre-selection has been done regarding to the elements included in the Inventory, but also using the knowledge and professional experience of the AFTER partners. Its aim was to link the ESMs listed in the Inventory with identified stakes regarding the energy efficiency of the buildings.
ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

OPERATING MANAGEMENT
The different ESMs collected in the Top 5 of every partner highlight 4 main topics regarding the Operating Management of the housing stock: - The monitoring online of the energy consumption. - The general topic of the tenants information/training with several solutions that have to be experimented. - The optimization of the contracts with ESCOs. - The figure of the energy manager as a potential human solution regarding energy issues. The first two categories of ESMs aim at providing information to improve behaviour or skills, wether the recipient is a tenant or a maintenance staff. The lats two ESMs focuse on SHO energy management optimization. The topic of heat cost allocators to individualize the energy consumption creates a controversy. ESMs linked with it have been selected by some partners (Slovenia, Italy) whereas they meet opposition from other partners (France, Czech Republic, etc.). It appeared that buildings where heat cost allocators had been dissemated displayed energy efficiency results significantly different from one country to another.This status is linked with some legal national conditions and should be discussed deeper by the partners. Quick overview of the main selected topics: ESM #26 (collected by Bauverein germany) Handbook for tenants - how to handle the ventilation system and how to live in a passive house ESM #27 (collected by Bauverein germany) Handbook for tenants to handle the ventilation system and how to live in a low energy house after refurbishment The other material formats of communication ESMs #10 (collected by SPl Slovenia) Energy number : Palmejeva 8,10,12,18,20,22,28,30,32:Energy-number is the ratio between the annual amount of (re) used or useful energy. People become aware of their wastefulness and they improve their behavior to the energy consumption. Direct and personal training with the tenant ESM #33 (collected by Bauverein germany) Personal advising on energy savings (for all the buildings the energy certificate allows the personal to explain and inform about the energy demand of the building) ESM #34 (collected by Bl Denmark) Climate Ambassadors: Educating tenants (womennetwork of non-Danish background) in energy-friendly and environmental-friendly behavior. ESM #36 (collected by Bl Denmark) Climate Agents: Training of tenants. Method: Personal visit and advice. Purpose: guiding tenants to a behavioral change/saving money. The tenants information and all the measures targeting a better awareness of the user have been indicated as priorities by all the participating partners. Most of SHO have been improving energy efficiency
2.1. TENANTS INFORMATION

If SHO energy efficiency action plan have been focusing technology, interesting pure awareness services provided through tenants information were inventoried and selected through different experiences: The Handbook for tenants ESM #6 (collected by le Toit Angevin France) Energy Handbook given to every tenant
8

through technology but this perspective overlooks the importance of implementing energy services in cooperation with tenants to change behaviour. One of the main objectives of the implementation phase will be to test how to optimize this information. The tenants involvement in energy saving measures has been analyzed using different trends: - the way and level of training and awareness : complete supervision, direct monitoring, complete autonomy - measures and its implementation scale - the improvement of dissemination formats and media The experiments on this topic will help to highlight what are the most interesting solutions to standardize and disseminate regarding the tenants involvement in the European social housing stock. The monitoring of the energy consumption is an important measure to improve and to test. Different questions are link with this item and can participate in optimization clues: - What is metered and monitored? - Who benefits from the information (tenants, administrators, caretakers, etc)? - How and when the information is given? - How to influence the consumption thanks to the information? These questions should be some interesting points to go into in depths during the implementation phase. The energy monitoring is a major topic in operating management strategies. What should be the improved measures to experiment in order to obtain efficient standards?
2.2. ENERGY MONITORING

This topic is linked with several ESMs inventoried, for example: ESM #4 (collected by le Toit Angevin France) On-line monitored hot, cold and central heating water metering for tenants (EFFINEO). ESM #11 (collected by SPl Slovenia) Website www.mojupravnik.si allowing residents to monitor their consumption of energy in the building. These ESMs have been identified as priorities by different SHOs and NHAs (#1 for Denmark and Czech Republic, identified as a priority by ATC/FEDERCASA and SPl). The WP leader for WP3 (CSTB) signals the ESM in its Top 3 (#3).
2.3. CONTRACTING AND PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES

The topic of the contract has been particularly collected among the French operations of le Toit Angevin: ESMs #1 and #2 (collected by le Toit Angevin France) Implementation of the energy supply & operation contract with an energy saving objective. ESM #3 (collected by le Toit Angevin France) Contract review aimed at decreasing the operation cost of central heating or/and water-heating installations. These ESMs have been identified as priorities by different SHOs and NHAs even if other ESMs relative to the contract review have not been particularly selected. The WP leader (CSTB) indicates it as the main priority. This item has been indicated #1 by all the French

partners and also by the Danish partners. The contracting issues are very interesting to identify regarding the link with ESCOs but also the other subcontractor. Information is widely provided in some countries to disseminate energy contracting. These measures can have both an economic and energy impact as pure service contracting are mostly self financed. The ambition is also to understand how to develop performance objectives for the different partners of the SHOs and how to guarantee them. The contract is a direct management tool that has to be clearly understood and implemented as an energy saving measures. In order to have a complete overview of the ESMs collected by the AFTER participating partners regarding WP3 Operating Management, refers to the table WP3: https://docs.google.com/ spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AvudJIc3TkbdG1QWktKOTY4M2VTcUFOUkdZSGtqRUE
2.4. ENERGY MANAGER

This topic is linked with one major ESM inventoried: ESM #45 (collected by MRA Czech Republic) Energy officer of MRA is in charge of: following of energy consumption per houses; ensures replacement and calibration of apartment water meters in accordance with legislation; ensures replacement of TRVs and regulation of heating; dealing with complaints of tenants concerning heating and water. This topic has been identified by the Danish partners, the Czech partners and the WP leader (CSTB) as a major priority. It tackles the question of the place and the management means regarding the energy performance in the Social Housing Companies and the impact of improving empowerment through single management.
10

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #1
Social Housing Organization
Le Toit Angevin (FR)
Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Performance contracting, ESCO : implementation contract with an energy saving objective. Maintenance measures: operation, running maintenance, heating water treatment, sludge removal, quartely indoors temperature recordings, balancing, improvement with energy-saving equipments ; 1/3 of energy costs (compared to theoritical needs within limit of 15%) allocated to the ESCO.
Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Les Capucins 1: 30-32-34-36-38 square des Capucins 49100 ANGERS. 40 dwellings. 2654 m2 A_C living.
FACTSHEET #2

Contract review aimed at decreasing the operating cost of central heating and/or water-heating installations.

Salpinte (15) - 44 rue Tardat ; 42 rue Tardat ; 1, 2, 3, 4 rue Syndic ; 5 rue Syndic ; 9, 11, 13 rue Alix ; 10, 12, 14 rue Alix ; 12, 14, 16, 18 rue Fourcade ; 11,13 rue Frouin ; 15, 17 rue Frouin - 49000 Angers 156 dwellings.
11

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #3

Energy monitoring: regular electric load-sheddings managed by subcontractor (VOLTALIS)

Le Haut Chne (160) - 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, 22, 24 ; 28, 30, 32 rue du Haut Chne - 49000 Angers. 100 dwellings. 7,072 m A_C_living.
FACTSHEET #4

Energy monitoring: online monitored hot, cold and central heating water metering for tenants (EFFINEO).

: Le Haut Chne (160) - 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, 22, 24 ; 28, 30, 32 rue du Haut Chne - 49000 Angers. 100 dwellings. 7,072 m.
12

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #5
SPL (SI) - National Housing Association

Subcontractor/ caretaker education: District heating maintenance manual for subcontractors /Training subcontractors to secure that the energysaving goals are reached.

Pleieva ulica 35,37,39,411000-Ljubjlana. 88 dwellings. 4818,30 m2.
FACTSHEET #6
SPL (SI) - National Housing Association Association

Individual billing/heat cost allocators: Implementation of heat cost allocators to monthly monitor owners heating energy consumption. These individual consumptions are then used to calculate each owners heating energy consumption share.

Ulica Iga Grudna 9, SI 1000-Ljubjlana. 23 dwellings. 1020,49 m2.
13

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #7
SPL (SI) - National Housing Association

Tenant information: Energy number : Palmejeva 8,10,12,18,20,22,28,30,32:Energy-number is the ratio between the annual amount of (re) used or useful energy. People become aware of their wastefulness and they improve their behavior to the energy consumption.

Palmejeva ulica 8,10,12;18,20,22;28,30,32 1000-Ljubjlana 126 dwellings. 7155,91 m2.
FACTSHEET #8

Web tool: Web site www.mojupravnik.si :residents can monitor their consumption of energy in the building. All the bills are accessible on the web site.

Available to all SPL costumers-residents (owners, tenants), some dwellings. 1500 users.
14

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #9
SPEKTER (SI)

Implementation of heat cost allocators to monitor tenants heating energy consumption. These individual consumptions are then used to calculate each tenants heating energy consumption share.

Opekarna 7, Trbovlje. 40 dwellings. 2550,45 m2.
FACTSHEET #10
Bauverein AG (GE)

Tenant handbook: handbook for tenants - how to handle the ventilation system and how to live in a passive house

Elisabeth-Selbert-Strae 6-8. Darmstadt. 44 dwellings. 3690 m2.
15

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #11
Bauverein AG (GE)

Tenant handbook: handbook for tenants to handle the ventilation system and how to live in a low energy building with a high insulation and a new heating system after a refurbishment.

Darmstadt, Holzhofallee 18-20, Darmstadt. 20 dwellings. 941 m2.
FACTSHEET #12
Bauverein AG (GE)

Energy monitoring: monitoring of the heating system: Installtion of the adaptherm modul to controll and adapt the supply temperature of the heating system

Darmstadt, Schiebelhuthweg 19-25, Darmstadt. 40 dwellings. 2530 m2.
16

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #13
Bauverein AG (GE)

Energy monitoring - Heating check: Energy monitorimng to get a better efficiency of the heating system

Bessunger Strae 182-188, Darmstadt. 32 dewllings. 1541 m2.
FACTSHEET #14
Bauverein AG (GE)

Personal advising on energy savings: For all our buildings we have the energy certificate, so that our personal can explain and inform about the energy demand of the building

All buildings.
17

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #15
BL (DK)

Tenant education - Climate Agents: Training of tenants. Method: Personal visit and advice. Purpose: guiding tenants to a behavorial change/saving money.

SHO Boligkontoret Danmark, Denmark. 25.600 dwellings. 1.710.837 m2.
FACTSHEET #16
BL (DK)

Water saving direct campaign towards tenants: Campaign towards tenants aiming at behavorial change. Including: letters/ information, articles in tenants news, catalogue with suggestions/ideas, competion, web-based calculator for savings and opportunity of getting personal consultation from professionals.

SHO Boligforeningen 3B, Copenhagen. 11.341 dwellings. 855.744 m2
18

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #17
BL (DK)

Tenant education - Climate Ambassadors: Educating tenants (women-network of non-danish background) in energy-friendly and environmental-friendly behavior.

Dyvekevaenget, 2300 Copenhagen SHO 140 dwellings. 10.246 m2.
FACTSHEET #18
ATC (IT)

Smart metering and monitoring system: Smart metering with future improvement with Adapterm

Via Riesi 525, Orbassano (Turin). 51 dwellings dwellings.
19

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #19
ATC (IT)

Individual billing/ heat cost allocators: Implementation of heat cost allocators to monitor tenants heating energy consumption.

Via Biglieri 44-46-50-52, Turin. 161 dwellings.
FACTSHEET #20
MRA (CZ)

Individual billing/heat cost allocators - Measurement of individual heating energy consumption per apartment on the basis of heat cost allocators installed on every radiator. These individual consumptions are then used to calculate each tenants heating energy consumption share.

J.Jaburov 1,3,5, Havrov. 36 dwellings. 1760 m2.
20

22 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #21
MRA (CZ)

Personal advising: Education of tenants about correct use of TRVs in case of complaints of tenants on high consumption or insufficient temperature in apartment etc., personal visit of local caretaker in apartment explaining functionality of TRV. Within planned check of functionality, exchange of TRVs

Mld 25, Havrov. 66 dwellings. 3498 m2.
FACTSHEET #22
MRA (CZ)

Energy manager: Energy officer of MRA is in charge of: following of energy consumption per houses; ensures replacement and calibration of apartment water meters in accordance with legislation; ensures replacement of TRVs and regulation of heating; dealling with complaints of tenants concerning heating and water.

7700 dwellings.
21

RUNNING MAINTENANCE
The different ESMs collected in the Top 5 of every partner highlight several recurring topics regarding the Running Maintenance of the housing stock: - The repair/maintenance of temperature control devices and repair/maintenance of hydraulic control devices (flow/pressure). - The optimization and the maintenance of the different elements of the heating system. - The maintenance of the ventilation system (link with the Indoor Air Quality). - Water-saving kits. - light-control. This topic is essential as it concerns directly the regular maintenance of the buildings. It allows identifying simple solutions concerning the monitoring of the heating system in order to enhance the just-intime processes and to compare the performance of the recent equipment (Annex 1. p.36). Quick overview of the main selected topics: ESM #10 (collected by SPEkTER Slovenia) Hydraulic balancing of the heating system: different types of valves and pressure regulators were installed on heating systems flow lines, valves on radiators were replaced with thermostatic valves system was balanced and regulated with all the new installation. ESM #11 (collected by SPEkTER Slovenia) Analog regulator was changed with digital regulator and district heating station was connected to remote control. ESM #17 (collected by Bauverein germany) Repair heating control: renewal of the control thermostats (37584) This item is essential to improve the efficiency of the heating system but also the comfort of the tenants. The impact will be very relevant regarding the reporting of the failures of the system and will help to highlight what the best practices are concerning the regulation of the heating system which is the major item of energy consumption in the housing stock.
3.1. THE REPAIR/MAINTENANCE OF TEMPERATURE CONTROL DEVICES AND REPAIR/MAINTENANCE OF HYDRAULIC CONTROL DEVICES (FLOW/PRESSURE).
The topic of tenants information has been inventoried and selected through different experiences: ESM #5 (collected by le Toit Angevin France) Installation of balance valves on all heating columns. ESM #6 (collected by MRA Czech Republic) Regulation of pressure: 149 valves out of 243 valves were replaced head type 99-Rk, valve VE4262H, the manual valve STAF DN80 installed in the basement, differential pressure regulator DA516 size DN80 including installation works
22
3.2. THE OPTIMIZATION AND THE MAINTENANCE OF THE DIFFERENT ELEMENTS OF THE HEATING SYSTEM.
This topic has been inventoried and selected through different experiences: ESM #3 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Exchange of the heating circulating pumps including mixers and sliders (29611) ESM #18 (collected by Bauverein - germany) Exchange of the heating circulating pumps including mixers and sliders (29611)

RUNNING MAINTENANCE
ESM #20 (collected by Bauverein - germany) New torch for the natural gas heating system (28893) ESM #22 (collected by SPl Slovenia) Cleaning two boilers (removing sediment, dirt) This item has been particularly signaled by the WP leader (STU-k). It gathers the two points mentioned in the Annex 1 (p.36) for the WP4: the assessment of the recent maintenance system and the comparison between the recent equipment. This topic collects several types of measures relating to the heating systems: the objective exposed in the Annex is to improve the monitoring concerning the replacement and the maintenance of these different parts of the system and to see how their efficiency can improve the global energy efficiency of the building. French SHOs of DElPHIS, the tenants representatives (ClCV) have also positioned this issue as the #1 for the WP4. Issues regarding ventilation systems and their maintenance are mentioned in the Annex 1 (p.36) The prevention of the misuse of the ventilation systems by the tenants. The optimization of the ventilation 0&M aspects cant be reduced to the involvement of the tenants. Technical solution and best practices have also to be highlighted in order to improve the energy consumption and the investments linked with this topic; but also to focus on the Indoor Air Quality topic.
3.4. WATER-SAVING KITS

This topic has been inventoried and selected through 2 experiences: ESM #1 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Installation of Eco-Techniques 2070 kits including : a 5 l/mn or 10 l/mn dual flow frother on kitchen sinks taps ; a VENTURI 5 l/mn frother on washbasins taps , a 7 l/mn VENTURI shower head ; 2 toilet tanks leak chip. ESM #1 (collected by Bl - Denmark) Installation of water-efficient heads and aerators for showers and faucets (the installation was organized as a 7 month experiment by the SHO in cooperation with an energy company and a producer of water-efficient heads and aerators). Water-saving kits have been identified by almost all the partners as a priority. Even if water-saving kits are not identified as the main priority, different SHOs and NHA have selected them in their top-5 (Denmark #3, Czech Republic #4, Italy #4, France #3, Tenants representatives #4). This ranking shows us that even if this topic is maybe not the most efficient regarding energy efficiency (heating systems are the main priority) water-saving kits can allow to implement in
23
3.3. THE MAINTENANCE OF THE VENTILATION SYSTEM (LINK WITH THE INDOOR AIR QUALITY)
The topic of the ventilation can be considered as a crossroad between the WP4 (Running Maintenance) and the WP5 (Replacement of systems). The ESM collected by Aarhus kommune presents a replacement of old ventilation system, but this particular example will be used to mention also the maintenance imperatives regarding ventilation systems. ESM #13 (collected by Aarhus kommune - Denmark) New ventilation system, VEx2.5, gENVEx gE2000 & gE1000, in 25 dwellings and the common areas The topic has been identified as a priority by different partners notwithstanding its particular position between WP4 and WP5. The maintenance of ventilation systems is priority #2 for the Danish partners and the

RUNNING MAINTENANCE
a short-term some interesting savings for the SHOs. Even if we can consider it as a second rank ESM regarding the topics of the ventilation or the heating systems, water-saving kits are interesting to develop during the implementation phase as they represent efficient solutions having good feedback, quite easy and quick to implement. Their impact on the hot water consumption is also an interesting aspect to link with the other topics. In order to have a complete overview of the ESMs collected by the AFTER participating partners regarding WP4 Running Maintenance, refers to the table WP4: https://docs.google.com/a/delphis-asso.org/spreadsheet/c cc?key=0AurVrSgKOagDdDI0ZnJzZzNUQkNjZDI1NXMxWlFq Snc#gid=0
2.2.5. LIGHT CONTROL SYSTEMS

This topic has been inventoried and selected through 2 experiences: ESM #1 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Installation of 360 array lighting sensors (6 units) in garages in place of permanent lighting (46 bulbs of 20 W each) ESM #16 (collected by Aarhus kommune - Denmark) ligthcontrol and sensors in all hallways. The item has been identified as a priority by several partners, even if this priority seems to be a second rank priority regard heating and ventilation systems (#4 Denmark, #3 Czech Republic, #5 Italy, #3 Italy, #1 and #3 Slovenia). light Control presents similarities with Water-saving kits as they represent low-cost solutions having a quick effect on the electric consumption. The energy savings allowed by these ESMs are second rank savings regarding the energy savings in the heating system, first energy consumption item.
24

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #1

Water-saver kits: installation of Eco-Techniques 2070 kits including : a 5 l/mn or 10 l/mn dual flow frother on kitchen sinks taps ; a VENTURI 5 l/mn frother on washbasins taps , a 7 l/mn VENTURI shower head ; 2 toilet tanks leak chips. Maintenance measures: control, repair and replacement of all basic and mixer taps, valves, flush mechanisms ; removal of shower switchers ; control and replacement of water frothers ; cleansing and descaling of water savers and frothers ; control and replacement of cartridge filters and any tap element ; replacement of used shower flexibles ; repair of leaks from individual meters to taps.

Guynemer I (98) - 9, rue Guynemer ; 10, rue Roland Garros - 49000 Angers 58 dewellings. 3,702 m
FACTSHEET #2

Lighting sensors: installation of 360 array lighting sensors (6 units) in garages in place of permanent lighting (46 bulbs of 20 W each).

Les Justices (127) - 25, 27, 29, 31, 33, 35, 37, rue de la Baraterie - 49000 Angers 114 dwellings. 2,558 m.
25

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #3
LE TOIT ANGEVIN (FR)

Draining of heating pipes / draining and injection of SENTINEL X400 sludge remover product.

Le Chteau (37) - 1, 3, 5, 7, rue des Saules ; 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, rue des Ptroles ; 1, 5, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 33, 39, 41, 43, 49, 51, 55, 57, rue du Boulet - 49080 Bouchemaine a 25 houses estate. 2,393 m.
FACTSHEET #4

isolation & balance valves: installation of valves on all heating columns.

La Roseraie L31 (50) - 57, 59, rue du Marchal Juin - 49000 Angers 85 dwellings. 4,596 m.
26

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #5
MRA (CZ)

Regulation of heating system: Ze 243 ventil bylo vymnno 149 typ hlavice 99-RK, ventil VE4262H, v suternu run regulan ventil STAF DN80, diferenn regultor tlaku DA516 ve velikosti DN80 vetn monte

Mld 25, Havrov 66 dwellings. 3498 m2.
FACTSHEET #6
MRA (CZ)

Replacement of cold and hot water pipes, regulation of DHW systems: Replacement of water pipes.

Aktova 1, Havrov 32 dwellings. 1653 m.
27

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #7
MRA (CZ)

Thermal insulation of heating pipes and DHW pipes in the unheated areas: Replacement of CW, HW water pipes and waste pipes.

Tolsteho 2,4,6, Havrov. 34 dwellings. 1711 m2.
FACTSHEET #8
MRA (CZ)

Thermal insulation of heating pipes and DHW pipes in the unheated areas: Replacement of CW, HW water pipes and waste pipes.

Tolsteho 2,4,6, Havrov. 34 dwellings. 1711 m2.
28

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #9
SPEKTER (SI)

Change of regulation in district heating station: Analog regulator was changed with digital regulator and district heating station was connected to remote control.

Trg revolucije 1, Trbovlje. 14 dwellings. 1051.38 m2.
FACTSHEET #10
SPEKTER (SI)

Hydraulic balancing of the heating system: Different types of valves and pressure regulators were installed on heating systems flow lines, valves on radiators were replaced with thermostatic valves, system was balanced and regulated with all the new installation.

Trg revolucije 16, Trbovlje 52 dwellings. 2969.73 m2.
29

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #11
AARHUS KOMMUNE (DK)

CTS control , Danfoss energi +: Optimization and adjustment of automation and systems.

Localcenter Skelager.
FACTSHEET #12
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Repair heating control: Renewal of the control thermostats (37584).

Waltherstrae 7-17 / Esselbornstrae 10, 3250 Darmstadt. 2084 dwellings. 5998 m2.
30

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #13
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Circulating pumps: Exchange of the heating circulating pumps including mixers and sliders (29611).

Anton-Bruckner-Strae 10-12, 3660 Dieburg. 12 dwellings. 1158 m2.
FACTSHEET #14
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Repair heating control: New heating control system

Fritz-Daechert-Weg 1-9, 3250 Darmstadt. 30 dwellings. 1630 m2.
31

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #15
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Exchange of the torch: New torch for the natural gas heating system (28893).

Albert Lortz-Strae 3-7, 3840 Dieburg. 20 dwellings. 1660 m2.
FACTSHEET #16

Thermal insulation of heating pipes: thermal insulation of heating pipes in the unheated common areas.

Lavriceva ulica 15 12 dwellings. 546 m2.
32

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #17

Cleaning boilers : cleaning two boilers (removing sediment, dirt).

Mali trg 3,4,5,6,7,8. 38 dwellings and 9 business (shops, offices). 3639.98 m2.
FACTSHEET #18

Replacement of circulating pump: replacement of circulating pump in heating station.

Povetova 14,16,18. 68 dwellings. 3529 m2.
33

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #19

Change of regulation: Change of regulation in common heating station.

Polje cesta V/1,2,3,4,5,7,9. 140 dwellings and 9 business (shops, offices). 7825.98 m2.
FACTSHEET #20
ATC (IT)

central heating substitution of plant with new boiler rooms and new smart metering system.

Via Riesi 5 - Orbassano (TO). 51 dwellings.
34

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #19

Change of regulation: Change of regulation in common heating station.

Polje cesta V/1,2,3,4,5,7,9. 140 dwellings and 9 business (shops, offices). 7825.98 m2.
FACTSHEET #20
BL (DK)

Water saving measure (hot water): Installation of water-efficient heads and aerators for showers and faucets. (The installation was organized as an 7 month experiment by the SHO in cooperation with an energy company and a producer of water-effecient heads and aerators)

Hammelstruphus, Damagervej 9-21, 2450 Copenhagen SV 56 dwellings. 3610,8 m2.
35

REPLACEMENT OF SYSTEMS
The different ESMs collected in the Top 5 of every partner highlight several recurring topics regarding to replacement of the systems: - Replacement of old boiler with new low temperature boiler and condensing boiler - Replacement of district heating substation - Replacement of Ventilation Systems - Replacement of hot water tank - Replacement of old boiler with wood biomass district heating system - Installation of solar panels This topic aims at assessing the performance before and a replacement but also to identify on-fields the different optimization clues linked with O&M measures that can improve the energy efficiency of a new system after its implementation. Quick overview of the main selected topics: Improvement of natural gas boilers (with thermostat and pilot flame) with low temperature, accumulation, CHAFFOTEAUx Serelia 24 VMC boilers; improvement of thermostats (CHAFFOTEAUx CM07P) ESM #46 (collected by ATC- Italy) Installation of a new Condensing boiler: N 2 VIESSMANN VITOCROSSAl 200 ESM #43- #45 (collected by ATC- Italy) Installation of a new Condensing boiler: N 3 ElCO THISION 35 ESM #49 (collected by ATC- Italy) Installation of a new Condensing boiler: N 1 YgNIS VARFREE 10 low temperature and condensing boilers have been identified by several SHOs and NHAs as the priority #1 and #2. The WP leader (ZRMk) has identified lowTemperature boilers ESM #1 and a Condensing boiler ESM #2. low temperature boilers and condensing boilers represent major investment within the Social Housing Stocks. As a consequence, the implementation of these new boilers has to be assessed in order to obtain standardized information format regarding the different models but also to enhance and to identify the best practices regarding 0&M for these equipment. This ESM has been chosen by different partner (8).
4.1. O&M ASPECTS FOR LOW TEMPERATURE BOILERS AND CONDENSING BOILERS
This topic has been inventoried with several experiences: ESM #6, #9, #10 (collected by Bauverain - germany) Replacemnet of boiler with new low temperature boiler ESM #12 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Central heating and water-heating renovation: improvement of the previous boiler with 2 condensation VIEMANN Vitrocrossal 300 (power 470 kW) and Vitotronic regulation. ESM #13 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Central heating and water-heating renovation: improvement of the previous boiler with 1 condensation VIEMANN Vitrocrossal 200 boiler and Vitotronic regulation ESM #19 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France)
36
4.2. REPLACEMENT OF DISTRICT HEATING SUBSTATION

This topic has been inventoried with experiences: ESM #33 (collected by SPEkTER- Slovenia) ESM #34 (collected by SPEkTER- Slovenia) ESM #35 - #38 (collected by SPEkTER- Slovenia) ESM #2 (collected by Bauverain - germany) Replacement of obsolete district heating substation represents significant energy savings. In case of major renovation of building envelope it highly recommended

REPLACEMENT OF SYSTEMS
to do the proper sizing. This ESM has been chosen by different partner (4). new low energy building that will reduce the heating consumptions).
4.3. REPLACEMENT OF VENTILATION SYSTEMS

As explained for the WP4, ventilation systems are a major stake for the energy efficiency but also the comfort of the tenants. If WP4 focused on the maintenance, ventilation systems are also important to assess in the WP5 (which anticipate the WP4). This topic has been inventoried with 2 experiences focusing on a particular ventilation system the Control Mechanical Ventilation: ESM #15 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) Installation of 3 Controlled Mechanical Ventilation groups in attics and aeration grids. ESM #53 (collected by SPl - Slovenia) Installation of mechanical ventilation system with heat exchange This ESM has been chosen by different partner (4). Same partners have indicated Ventilation systems as a priority.
4.5. REPLACEMENT OF OLD BOILER WITH WOOD BIOMASS DISTRICT HEATING SYSTEM
ESM #50 (collected by SPl - Slovenia) Old oil boiler was replaced with wood biomass district heating system. This ESM has been chosen by different partner (3). It is interesting implementation because of use a biomass (low, Predictable Energy Costs , Better Air Quality , incomes of the local Economy, Use of a Plentiful & Renewable Resource, Reduced Environmental Risks) and because of district heating (user friendly system and more efficient).
4.6. INSTALLATION OF SOLAR PANELS

This topic has been inventoried with one particular experience: ESM #16 (collected by le Toit Angevin - France) solar panels improvement for heating and water-heating (this is probably replaced by the system). This ESM has been chosen by different partner.(3) In order to have a complete overview of the ESMs collected by the AFTER participating partners regarding WP5 Replacement of systems, refers to the table WP5: https://docs.google.com/a/delphis-asso.org/spreadsheet/c cc?key=0AurVrSgKOagDdDI0ZnJzZzNUQkNjZDI1NXMxWlFq Snc#gid=0
4.4. REPLACEMENT OF HOT WATER TANK

This topic has been inventoried with one particular experience: ESM #1 (collected by Bauverein- germany) Exchange of the hot water tank with a better insulation With a central heating system; exchange of the hot water tank with a better insulation This ESM has been identified as a priority by different partner (3). It may be an interesting implementation to develop regarding the growing place of the hot water in the global energy consumption of a building (linked to a better airtightness in the refurbished and
37

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #1
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of hot water tank: with a central heating system; exchange of the hot water tank with a better insulation.

Triere Strae 2, Darmstadt. 44 dewellings. 3354 m2.
FACTSHEET #2
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of district heating substation: Exchange of the district heating station and the hot water tank with a better insulation.

Esselbornstrae 1-5, Darmstadt. 25 dwellings. 1741 m2.
38

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #3
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of boiler: with a central standard boiler from 1982; new gas calorific value boiler and adaption of the performance.

Heinheimner-Strae 57-61. Darmstadt, 30 dewellings. 1610 m2.
FACTSHEET #4
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of boiler: with two central standard boiler from 1990; new low temperature boiler and adaption of the performance.

Darmstadt, Klner Strae 18-18c, Darmstadt. 32 dwellings. 2326 m2.
39

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #5
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of boiler: with a central boiler from 1981only for heating; new low temperature boiler only for heating and adaption of the performance.

Viktoriastrae 42, Darmstadt. 17 dewellings. 948 m2.
FACTSHEET #6
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Replacement of boiler: with a central standard boiler from ; new gas calorific value boiler.

Parsevalstrae 8-18, 455 Griesheim. 40 dewellings. 3498 m2.
40

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #7

Replacement of boiler: central heating and water-heating renovation: improvement of the previous boiler with 2 condensation VIEMANN Vitrocrossal 300 (power 470 KW) and Vitotronic regulation.

Cit Branly (44) - Violettes, Marguerites, Roses ; Muguets, Lilas - 49800 Trlaz. 44 dwellings. 2428 m2.
FACTSHEET #8

central heating and water-heating renovation: improvement of the previous boiler with 1 condensation VIEMANN Vitrocrossal 200 boiler and Vitotronic regulation.

Le Haut Chne (160) - 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, 22, 24 ; 28, 30, 32 rue du Haut Chne - 49000 Angers. 42 dwellings. 3031 m.
41

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #9

Replacement of boiler: central heating and water-heating renovation: improvement of the previous boiler with 2 condensation VIEMANN Vitrocrossal 300 (power 470 KW) and Vitotronic regulation.

Cit Branly (44) - Violettes, Marguerites, Roses ; Muguets, Lilas - 49800 Trlaz. 44 dwellings. 2428 m2.
FACTSHEET #10

Installation of Controlled Mechanical Ventilation: installation of 3 Controlled Mechanical Ventilation groups in attics and aeration grids.

Le Vaugareau (19) - 21, 25, 27, rue du Roussillon - 49100 Angers. 40 dwellings. 1042 m.
42

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #11

Heating boiler and DHW solar panels: previous system : underfloor basic heating with solar panels and supplementary heating with convectors and off-heating period DHW by solar panels. New system : heating with natural gas boilers and DHW with new solar panels.

Dtrich (140) - 5, 7, 9, 11, 12, 13, 16, 20, boulevard Charles Dtrich - 49000 Angers. a 8 houses estate. 664 m2.
FACTSHEET #12

Water-heaters improvement: heat pumps (water-heaters) using R22 gas (obsolete in 2015) replaced with ATLANTICs Aeraulix CMV thermodynamic water-heaters (200 liters ; water-heater power 1,800 W ; heat pump power 400 W ; ventilator power 14 W ; noise 34 dB(A) ; up to 75 % of energy for water-heating and up to 10 % of energy for heating saved according to ATLANTIC).

Le Pont Besnard (122) - 1, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, alle des Muguets ; 1-6 et 8-10, impasse des Bleuets - 49370 Bcon les Granits. A 15 houses estate. 1301 m2.
43

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #13

Replacement of boiler: improvement of 25 atmospheric boilers (with thermostat, without pilot flame) with CHAFFOTEAUX Niagara C Green 25 FF gn condensation boilers. Existing thermostats conserved.

Le Chteau (37) - 1, 3, 5, 7, rue des Saules ; 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, rue des Ptroles ; 1, 5, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 33, 39, 41, 43, 49, 51, 55, 57, rue du Boulet - 49080 Bouchemaine. a 25 houses estate. 2,393 m.
FACTSHEET #14

Replacement of boiler: improvement of natural gas boilers (with thermostat and pilot flame) with low temperature, accumulation, CHAFFOTEAUX Serelia 24 VMC boilers ; improvement of thermostats (CHAFFOTEAUX CM07P). Maintenance measures: 1 visit/year including : cleansing, overview, check, setting of heating elements, condensor, pump, burner, pilot flame, gas filter, gas flow, regulation, security and draining devices, ventilator and pad ; check and clamping of electric connections and protections ; cleansing of aeration grilles ; check and repair of boilers burned gas outlet stack and air intake ; check of thickness and manoeuvrability of gas tap and repair. Check of fixing and lapsing date of the natural gas hose ; refixing of loosy devices ; check and setting of the thermostat, replacement of its batteries ; check and repair of leaks between heating circuit and radiators ; sweeping and check of chimney (with sweeping certificate) ; cleansing of the junction duct ; testing of boilers security ; supply and installation of any boilers faulty spares, gas certificate for burned gas outlet stacks connection ; replacement of faulty or out of order bleeders and radiators taps ; replacement of faulty radiator caps and hand wheels, thermostats, valves and HDW inverters (if buff water-heater) ; supply and installation of inspection panels on chimneys

Belle Poigne, Legludic (179) - 2 bis, rue Belle Poigne ; 3, 5, rue Legludic - 49100 Angers. 21 dwellings. 1397 m2. 44

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #15
AARHUS KOMMUNE (DK)

Renovation of old ventilations system: New ventilation system. Envistar flex (size 240) with heat exchanger and integrated automation - in the common area, cafeteria and kitchen.

Localcenter Abildgrden . 27 dwellings + administration. 279 m2.
FACTSHEET #16
SPEKTER (SI)

Replacement of district heating substation. Old heating sub/station was removed, new heating sub/station was installed (regulations, pumps, calorimetres, accumulators, electrical installation, safety). Maintenance measures: periodic inspection and testing, replacement of equipment if necessary.

Gimnazijska cesta 15b, Trbovlje. 76 appartments. 5374, 6 m2.
45

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #17

Replacement of boiler: exchange of heating device, replacement energy source (oil-gas).

Dolenjska cesta 34, 36,38,40, Ljubljana. 96 dwellings. 4575 M2
FACTSHEET #18

Replacement of old oil boiler with wood biomass district heating system: old boiler was replaced with new bolier, energy source is wood, district heating.

Prijateljev trg 3, Ribnica. 25 appartments. 1439 m2.
46

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET 19

Installation of a central heating with a renewable energy source: old oil boiler was replaced with new heat pump air-water TCZ ZV 23 EVT Termotehnika.

martno 68, martno pri Slovenj Gradcu. 6 dwellings. 352 M2
FACTSHEET #20

installation of a central heating with a renewable energy source- pellets. old oil boiler was replaced with new biomass boiler, energy source are pellets KWB MULTIFIRE USV D 50.

Sejmice 7, Mislinja. 10 appartments. 582 m2.
47

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #21

installation of mechanical ventilation system with heat exchange. Implementation of mechanical ventilation system with heat exchange, residents instructions for proper use of equipment.

Steletova 8, Ljubljana. 60 dwellings. 4180 m2.
FACTSHEET #22
ATC (IT)

Replacement of boiler: installation of a new Condensing boiler: N 3 ELCO THISION 35.

Pasubio 78 - RIVOLI. 24 dwellings. 728 m2.
48

24 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #23
ATC (IT)

Central heating substitution of plant with new boiler rooms: new smart metering system.

Via Calvino 31 - Orbassano (TO). 51 dwellings.
FACTSHEET #24
ATC (IT)

Substitution of individual heating with central heating system (district heating connections): Heating, hot water and elecrticity integrated system. Some building with photovoltaic with future smart metering system.

Via Arquata 15, 23,22, 16, 14, 2, 4, 13. Turin. 500 dwellings.
49

REFURBISHED BUILDINGS
The different ESMs collected for the WP6 identify different refurbishment strategies, all of them interesting to assess. The selected ESMs pursue both the objectives identified in the Annex 1 (p.46): to identify punctual actions on the shell and to assess their impact on the energy consumption of the building, in order to give a feedback on the global retrofitting experiences. Quick overview of the main selected topics: - External thermal insulation of the building shell: a. Roof insulation b. Ceiling insulation - Window substitution - Ventilation system ESM #23 Insulation of the facade (30 cm) ESM #24 Insulation of the cellar ceiling (10 cm) ESM #38 (collected by SPl D.D. Slovenia ljubljana,Runkova ulica 2) Concrete prefabricated building, flat roof, balconies, 13 storeys, basement External thermal insulation with 10 cm of Styrofoam. External thermal insulation A lot of different ESMs regarding the external insulation have been selected by the partners. Efforts regarding refurbishment lead to turn the attention to the insulation techniques and potential optimizations. The implementation will help to know how to optimize these ESMs regarding: choices of the insulation material (materials and prices: what are the conditions of the investment? quality and preservation of the materials, maintenance regarding the different types of insulation materials and techniques), the couple thermal insulation + ventilation systems in order to prevent moisture issues and to guarantee a satisfying indoor air quality (demand controlled ventilation techniques, turnover and replacement, air filters maintenance, etc.), the involvement and the awareness measures regarding users.
5.1. EXTERNAL THERMAL INSULATION OF THE BUILDING SHELL

This topic has been inventoried with several experiences: ESM #29 (collected by Bauverein germany Darmstadt, Beckstrae 81-85 ) 3 storey apartment building from the 50s with a commercial unit in the ground floor, simple design A building from the 50th with no insulation on the roof Insulation of the roof in the frame of a global refurbishment. Insulation of the roof ESM #23-24 (collected by Bauverein germany Darmstadt, Holzhofallee 18-20) 3 storey apartment building from the 50s, simple design A building from the 50s with no insulation on the cellar ceiling.
5.2. WINDOW SUBSTITUTION

This topic focuses on the window substitution. The ESM collected is the following one: ESM #22 (collected by ATC Italy - Venaria Reale- via PICCO 53-55-62-64) Traditional buildings 4 floors In the frame of retrofitting, an insulated 80mm coat was applied to an existing building from 1960s. Existing single glazing were substituted with high performance double glazing.
50

REFURBISHED BUILDINGS
Window substitution ESM #12 (collected by MRA Czech Republic - Jedlova 2, Havrov Panel apartment building, tower house, national type OP1.13, 12 overground floors, 60 apartments, external walls made from panels. Replacement of old wooden windows with plastic ones with U<=1,4 W/m2k New plastic windows The replacement of windows has been identified by different partners as a priority interesting for the implementation phase: Czech Republic #1, Slovenia #2 and #3, DElPHIS #2 and Italy #4. The replacement of windows represents an interesting opportunity to implement low-cost investment and to improve a buildings airtightness without needing to recourse to external insulation. This ESM is also very interesting to individualize in order to assess the different performances between external insulation + replacement of windows and a single replacement of windows. A controlled ventilation system provides an adequate supply of fresh air and recovers heat from exhaust air. A controlled ventilation system is useful not only in winter but also in summer, when the weather is very hot. The advantages of controlled ventilation are: energy saving in total needs for heating; indoor comfort and hygiene, due to the continuous and gradual introduction of fresh air; improved summer comfort due to the air cooling through heat exchanging heat with the outside. There are two kind of ventilation systems: centralized, for the whole building decentralized, for single rooms. Both systems can be equipped with a heat recovery system that allows to transfer the heat from the exhaust outlet air to the fresh inlet air. In order to have a complete overview of the ESMs collected by the AFTER participating partners regarding WP6 Recently refurbished buildings, refers to the table WP6: https://docs.google.com/a/delphis-asso.org/spreadsheet/ ccc?key=0AvudJIc3Tkb-dFFiRnE3Sng4RTI3cjYwc0ttQU1nR2c &hl=en_GB
5.3. VENTILATION SYSTEM

The ventilation system have selected regarding one inventoried ESM: ESM #30 (collected by BAUVEREIN germany Darmstadt, Mathildenstrae 36-40 3 storey apartment building, which was destroyed in World war II and rebuilt in the 50s, simple design. A building from the 50s with no ventilation system. Ventilation system with supply air through the window frame.
51

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #1

Flat roof insulation replacement: 333,68 m of 135 mm thick expanded polystyrene insulation (R = 3,70 m.K/W) then covered with a new tightness.

Estienne dOrves (66) - 14, boulevard dEstienne dOrves - 49100 Angers. 28 dwellings. 2,363 m.
FACTSHEET #2

External insulation (gables and roof): additional insulation on gables (285 m, R = 2,55 m.K/W) and sloping roof (1 265 m, R = 5,5 m.K/W).

La Baudrie (80) - 32, 34, rue Coubertin ; 12, 14, 16, rue de Verdun ; 19, 21, 23 rue de la Marmitire - 49124 Saint Barthlmy dAnjou. 88 dwellings. 5,358 m.
52

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #3

New windows with double heat protection glass (619 m of single-glazed wooden carpentries replaced with double-glazed 4/16/4 Therm + CPV carpentries (Uw = 1,7 W/m.K) with rolling shutters) & ceiling insulation (1 089 m of garage ceiling insulated with a 100 mm thick airplaced flaked mineral fibre (R > 2,4 m.K/W)).

Guynemer I (98) - 9, rue Guynemer ; 10, rue Roland Garros - 49000 Angers. 58 dwellings. 3702 m.
FACTSHEET #4

Flat roof insulation (2 462 m flat roof insulation (R = 3,6 m.K/W)) & new heating system with a low temperature central boiler (Remplacement of electric heating ceilings with natural gas heating radiators).

La Baudrie (80) - 32, 34, rue Coubertin ; 12, 14, 16, rue de Verdun ; 19, 21, 23 rue de la Marmitire - 49124 Saint Barthlmy dAnjou. 138 dwellings. 10 183 m.
53

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #5

Attic insulation (removal of previous glass wool and laying of 4,472 m of 200 mm thick ROCKWOOL Easyrock rock wool (R = 5 m.K/W) on a framework upon rafters) & new windows with double heat protection glass (replacement of single glazed attic windows with double-glazed VELUX GGL 3076 C02 Comfort attic windows).

Salpinte (15) - 44 rue Tardat ; 42 rue Tardat ; 1, 2, 3, 4, rue Syndic ; 5, rue Syndic ; 9, 11, 13, rue Alix ; 10, 12, 14, rue Alix ; 12, 14, 16, 18, rue Fourcade ; 11,13, rue Frouin ; 15, 17, rue Frouin - 49000 Angers. 154 dwellings. 9081 m.
FACTSHEET #6

Sloping roof insulation: removal of slates, external laying of 120 mm thick EFISOL TMS GF polyurethan panels (R = 5,2 m.K/W) on concrete sloping roof (509 m), then cover with new slates (sarking method).

Les Allumettes (545) - 243, rue Jean Jaurs - 49800 Trlaz. 5 houses. 465 m.
54

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #7
MRA (CZ)

Global retrofitting: Insulation of building envelope, roof and exchange of windows.

Mnesova 24,26,28, Havrov. 36 dwellings. 1767 m.
FACTSHEET #8
MRA (CZ)

New plastic windows: Replacement of old wooden windows with plastic ones with U<=1,4 W/m2K.

Uzavren 2,4,6, Havirov. 36 dwellings. 1780 m.
55

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #9
MRA (CZ)

Global retrofitting: Insulation of building envelope, roof and exchange of windows.

Moskevsk 1E, Havrov. 72 dwellings. 2977 m2.
FACTSHEET #10
ATC 5IT)

External insulation and windows substitution: in the frame of a global retrofittig, a 1967 pre-fabricated building with no insulation has been insulated with external 200mm insulation.

Via Artom 55, Turin. 80 dwellings.
56

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #11
ATC 5IT)

External insulation, window substitution : in the frame of a global retrofittig, a 1960s pre-fabricated building with no insulation has been equipped with external double skin wall having 100mm insulation under 6mm ceramic finishes. Existing single glazing windows have been substituted with double glazing high performance windows giving a U Value of 2.16 and 2.29 for small size windows located at balconies.Corso Molise 18, and Via Parenzo are part of an integrated project and present similar characteristics.

Via Parenzo 55 (1), Turin. 44 dwellings.
FACTSHEET #12
ATC 5IT)

External insulation, window substitution: in the frame of retrofitting, an Insulated coat of 80mm was applied to an existing building of 1950s. Existing single glazing were substituted with high performance double glazing.

Via Ressia 23 a-b-c, Carignano. 18 dwellings.
57

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #13
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Insulation of the facade (30 cm): a building from the 50th with no insultion on the facade.

Holzhofallee 18-20, Darmstadt. 20 dwellings. 941 m2
FACTSHEET #14
BAUVEREIN (GE)

New windows with Double Heat protection Glass: a building from the 50th with double glass windows / U value around 3,00 W/Km & Ventilation system with supply air through the window frame: a building from the 50th with no ventilation system.

Mathildenstrae 36-40, Darmstadt,. 19 dwellings. 1282 m2.
58

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #15
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Insulation of the facade (14 cm): a building from the 50th with no insultion on the facade.

Holzhofallee 24-24a, Darmstadt. 20 dwellings. 1174 m2
FACTSHEET #16
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Insulation of the facade (10 cm) & Insulation of the roof: a building from the 50th with no insulation on the roof.

Darmstadt, Beckstrae 81-85. 30 dwellings. 1649 m2.
59

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #17
AARHUS KOMMUNE (DK)

Total renovation - upgrading to low-energy housing: 14 houses for senior housing from 1984 are going through a total renovation to upgrade it to a lowenergy housing (Insulation / Roof, Insulation / Walls, Insulation / Foundation, Windows & Frames / Insulation, Windows & Frames / Sun Protection, Photovoltaics, Ventilation and heat recovery & District heating)

Centervej 30-56, Lystrup. 14 dwellings. 980 m2
FACTSHEET #16
SPEKTER (SI)

External insulation: Reinforced concrete building with 6cm insulation additionally insulated with 7cm insulation.

Trg Franca Fakina 2a, Trbovlje. 31 dwellings. 2072 m2.
60

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #17
SPEKTER (SI)

External insulation: Brick walls building with no insulation insulated with 10cm insulation.

Dom in vrt 45, Trbovlje. 20 dwellings. 1065 m2
FACTSHEET #18
SPL (SI)

External thermal insulation: external thermal insulation with 8 cm of styrofoam.

Glinkova plocad 23, Ljubljana. 20 dwellings. 1135 m2.
61

20 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #19
SPL (SI)

External thermal insulation: external thermal insulation with 10 cm of styrofoam.

Dom in vrt 45, Trbovlje. 96 dwellings, 4 businesses. 7725 m2.
FACTSHEET #20
SPL (SI)

Thermal insulation of external walls and parapets on a total of 15 cm, thermal protection of basement ceiling 8 cm, thermal insulation against the roof with 22 cm, windows with modern energy efficient (U = 1.5 W/m2 K): instalation of mechanical ventilation system with heat exchange.

Steletova 8, Ljubljana. 60 dwellings. 4180 m2.
62
63

LOW ENERGY BUILDINGS
Contrary to the other work packages the WP7 ESMs relate to a whole building. However these buildings as set out below consist of several relevant components which are stressed differently in the different low energy buildings. This broadens the range of selection as it can be seen in the following presentation of selected ESMs. Due to the complex structure of low energy buildings and the interdependence between the different equipment and systems the WP leader (IWU) identified different and the following buildings with its each particular components. Here is a link to WP 3 and 4. The there described ESMs are of similar quality as they are in WP7. ESM #2: Via Pertini/Bia Burolo - Ivrea (TO) (listed by ATC Italy) New low energy building, built in 2011, 21 dwellings, 1.470 m of gross floor area, solar thermal system for water heating, photovoltaics. ESM #3: kildevang, langballevej 9A-9H Marslet (listed by AARHUS Denmark) Eight new low energy buildings (replacement of existing buildings from 1974), built in 2011, 65 m per dwelling/house, special target group elderly people, ventilation with heat recovery, district heating, photovoltaics. ESM #8: Herning, H2-College (listed by Bl Denmark) New passive house (first passive house for Danish SHOs), built in 2009, 66 dwellings, 2.498 m living area, special target group students, heavily insulated pre-fabricated building elements, low energy windows, double flow ventilation system, geothermal heat system, hot water and electricity from hydrogen plant (not working yet). ESM #9-10: Darmstadt, Elisabeth-Selbert-Strae 6-8 (listed by bauverein germany) Two new passive house buildings, built in 2010, 44 dwellings, 3.690 m living area, co-housing project, district heating, photovoltaics.
64
ESM #12: Slovenia: Svinjska cesta 9b, Trbovlje (listed by SPEkTER Slovenia) New low energy building, built in 2006, 13 apartments, 944 m living area, district heating, natural ventilation. The selection of ESMs is not limited to technical components as just described. A selection criteria are the different target groups. There are lEBs for elderly people, students, highly motivated target groups or average households. As the construction, management and operation of lEBs and users behaviour in a lEB requires a certain knowledge resp. awareness both of the craftsmen and the staff and also of the tenants living in the lEB the focus is on the target groups that use the lEB : The differentiation of target groups is used for investigation whether there are qualitative differences between different target groups. The use of an lEB by a highly motivated target group, that is well informed and attached to energy saving and climate protection issues might show differnt bahaviour and consumption pattern. The => Comparison can be drawn with the BECA project that focusses on tenants behavour, too. Also the soft- non technical activities that operate in the lEB are of particular relevance and are a selection criteria. It matters if the human operation of a lEB is assisted by information material and individual support or incentives for proper resource (energy and water) related behaviour. Here is a link to WP3 and the described activities(=>2.1.1-2.1.2-2.1.4) . In addition to the inventory more detailed information about the thermal envelope, the installed windows, the installed mechanical ventilation systems with heat recovery, the installed supply systems (especially heat and hot water), and the energy demand resp. consumption of the above named buildings have been

LOW ENERGY BUILDINGS
collected in the form of 5 fact sheets. Apart from that, a complementary questionnaire WP7 Questions on Management,Operation and Maintenance of Recent low Energy Buildings indicating the O&M aspects for these buildings has been filled in by the SHOs concerned. The results of these questionnaires should lead to optimization clues for the implementation phase. The different optimization clues refer to ESMs identified also in WP3 and WP4 also in WP5 and WP6, but are adapted to the specific components of new low-energy buildings. In order to have a complete overview of the ESMs collected by the AFTER participating partners regarding WP7 Recent Low-energy buildings, refers to the table WP7: https://docs.google.com/a/delphis-asso.org/spreadsheet/ ccc?key=0AvudJIc3Tkb-dDI0MkVOZ3VqY3N3dFUxOC1YNEg yQXc#gid=4
65

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #1
ATC 5IT)

The building layout is a C shape facing south towards the courtyard and it is asymmetric with the short sides. The two streets that border the lot to the west and north facilitate the two main access points and give the same hierarchy as well as the orientation of the building has been to prioritize the north side for direct pedestrian access to the stairwells, while the west side for direct vehicular access to parking attributable to the brim placed on the property. The vertical distribution system consists of the two stairwells and elevators on, distributed to third parties for the development of the main body. 7 dwellings are located on each floor. The courtyard is located in the area between the southern border and the blocks of the building. The free area, created around the building and enclosed by the fence that defines the lot, home to the 21 parking spaces. External insulation with 10cm wood fiber panels. Walls in blocks of aerated concrete. Thermal solar panel for water heating. Double glazed windows in PVC Photovoltaic panels

Via Pertini/Via Burolo - Ivrea (TO) . 21 dwellings. 1470 m2.
FACTSHEET #2
AARHUS KOMMUNE (DK)

14 houses for senior housing from 1984 are going through a total renovation to upgrade it to a low-energy housing. Older homes are at 1 level. Erected as through brick building in red brick and a 20-degree unilateral lattice truss structure covered with red tiles. The 14 elderly housing gross area is approx. 980 m2 and the total volume of new additions is approx. 168 m2. Ex. roof tiles replaced with new red interlocking tiles. Roof with post-insulation. Ex. slab beaten up and replaced with new suppl. insulation and underfloor heating. Ex. installations replaced. Ventilation systems installed. All door and window panels replaced with new ones. Solar panels mounted on the roof.

Centervej 30-56, Lystrup. 14 dwellings. 980 m2. 66

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #3
AARHUS KOMMUNE (DK)

8 houses for senior housing from 1974 has been removed, and on the same ground 8 new lowenergi houses are beeing build. Insulation 445mm / Roof, Insulation 200mm / Walls, Insulation 300mm / Foundation, Windows & Frames / Insulation, Windows & Frames (U=1,20 w/m2*k incl. frame and sash) / Sun Protection, Photovoltaics (Solar panels on the roof 7.66 per m2. house (0.154 kW/ m2 Peak power and system efficiency of 0.752).), Ventilation and heat recovery & District heating

Langballevej 9A-9H Mrsle, Kildevang . 8 dwellings. 520 m2.
FACTSHEET #4
BL (DK)

Wood construction (FSC-certified wood) Located for max. sunlight. Sustainable materials. Pre-fabricated elements. Double flow Ventilation System, air to air heat pump, Passive solar heating, heat from residents bodies and households.

The Larch Garden III, Lystrup. 32 dwellings. 2852 m2.
67

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #5
BL (DK)

Wood construction (FSC-certified wood) Located for max. sunlight. Sustainable materials. Pre-fabricated elements. Double flow Ventilation System, heavily insulated, heat loss to the soil is reduced by using smaller pipes which are better insulated. In addition, lower operating temperatures are used in district heating systems.

Langballevej 9A-9H Mrsle, Kildevang . 40 dwellings. 3354 m2.
FACTSHEET #6
BL (DK)

Wood construction (FSC-certified wood) Located for max. sunlight. Sustainable materials. Pre-fabricated elements. LED-lighting, Phase Change Materials (PCM), High insulation 425-450 mm mineral wool, low energy windows: double and triple glazed.

Lystrup, The Larch Garden I. 50 dwellings. 3977 m2.
68

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #7
BL (DK)

College buildings. Located for max. sunlight. Pre-fabricated elements. Hydrogen Plant connected but is not working.This is a pioneers work - first passive house building for Danish SHOs. Double flow Ventilation system, heavily insulated, low energy windows and geothermal heat-system. Production of hot water and electricity from own Hydrogen Plant.

H2-College, Herning. 66 dwellings. 2498 m2.
FACTSHEET #8
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Multi-family building with 44 residential units spread over two buildings. Triple Heat protection Glass. Insulation cellar ceiling.

Elisabeth-Selbert-Strae 6-8, Darmstadt. 44 dwellings. 3690 m2.
69

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #9
BAUVEREIN (GE)

Multi-family building with 11 residential units - one building. Ventilation System. Double Heat protection Glass. Insulation facade (14 cm). Insulation roof. Insulation cellar ceiling. Heating System with power plant

Holzhofallee 24c, Darmstadt. 11 dwellings. 1112 m2.
FACTSHEET #10
SPEKTER (SI)

5 storey building made of reinforced concrete with 10cm insulation, gable roof. The newly built building with 10cm EPS shell insulation, min. 10cm EPS roof/ceiling insulation and 8cm EPS basement floor insulation. Double glazed windows. No heat recovery or ventilation systems.

Savinjska cesta 9b, Trbovlje. 13 dwellings. 944 m2.
70

12 FACTSHEETS
FACTSHEET #11

3 and 5 floors Low Energy Buildings ; insulated flat roof ; STO external facades insulation (R > 3,75 m.K/W) ; SOTRAVER doubleglazed INSTALLUX aluminium external carpentries ; natural gas central heating (2 VIEMANN Vitodens 300, 60 KW, condensation boilers) ; 2 ALDES C.vec micro-watt + 2500 CMV (735 W) ; in dwellings : FINIMETAL radiators with 2990 DANFOSS thermostatic taps, thermostat. Dual energy AO SMITH system : a natural gas powered buffer tank (300 l.) and a 2000 l. tank powered with 16 WEISHAUPT WTS - F1 solar panels. External Insulation (12 to 15 cm thick). Building orientation design to improve free solar energy (ie : large windows south oriented). Installation of caps on building facades and directional Venetian blinds on windows. Solar panels for eletricity production - 50m - Solar Century SC 185

Les Chlets - Angers . 29 dwellings. 1888 m2.
FACTSHEET #12

3 floors Very High Energy efficiency building (energy consumption 20 % less than French Strandards) ; all concrete walls and floors insulated ; 20 cm tightness rock wool flat roof insulation (R = 5 m.K/W) ; 4/16/4 argon double-glazed CPV external windows (Uw = 1,6 W/m.K) ; class B hygrovariable ALDES Bahia micro-watt simple flow CMV ; individual electric water-heaters ; electric towel convectors and radiant panels. Multilayer precast panels: InovMur 15 JOUSSELIN precast walls (www.jousselin.fr) : 15 cm expanded polystyrene TH38 insulation embedded between 2 concrete panels (internal 7 cm, external 16 cm) for R = 4,25 m.K/W.

Chatenay (600) - 108 bis, rue Victor Chatenay - 49100 Angers. 18 dwellings. 998 m2.
71
72
73
ESMS
With the support of
The sole responsibility for the content of this publication lies with the authors. It does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the European Union. Neither the EACI nor the European Commission are responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.

Report On The Innovatives Measures Regarding Wp3 To Wp7 in The Participating Countries

Transféré par

Informations du document

Titre original

Copyright

Formats disponibles

Partager ce document

Partager ou intégrer le document

Options de partage

Avez-vous trouvé ce document utile ?

Ce contenu est-il inapproprié ?

Droits d'auteur :

Formats disponibles

Report On The Innovatives Measures Regarding Wp3 To Wp7 in The Participating Countries

Transféré par

Droits d'auteur :

Formats disponibles

D3.1 D4.1 D5.1 D6.1 D7.

ESMS WORK SCIENTIFIC

Version 1.1 add WP5 inputs

2. WORK PACKAGE 3: OPERATING MANAGEMENT

WORK PACKAGE 3: 22 FACTSHEETS 3. WORK PACKAGE 4: RUNNING MAINTENANCE

WORK PACKAGE 4: 20 FACTSHEETS 4. WORK PACKAGE 5: REPLACEMENT OF SYSTEMS

WORK PACKAGE 5: 24 FACTSHEETS 5. WORK PACKAGE 6: REFURBISHED BUILDINGS

STAKE 4: A COLLECTIVE TOOL FOR ASSESSING ENERGY SAVING MEASURES

STAKE 2: CREATE A DATA BASIS FOR THE COMPANIES STRATEGIC POSITIONING

STAKE 3: A COLLECTIVE TOOL FOR DISSEMINATING KNOWLEDGE

ESMS OBJECTIVES OF 1. REMINDER:

ESMS OBJECTIVES OF 1. REMINDER:

1.2. IDENTIFICATION OF THE PRIORITY TOPICS

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

2.1. TENANTS INFORMATION

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

2.2. ENERGY MONITORING

2.3. CONTRACTING AND PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

2.4. ENERGY MANAGER

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM

ESMS PACKAGE 3: 2. WORK

Description of the Energy Saving Measure

Identification of the building: Number of dwellings. Surface for the ESM