SERVICES

PLUS+ SUBSCRIPTIONS

DIGITAL NEWSPAPER

PLACE AN AD

MIAMI.COM

MOMSMIAMI

EL NUEVO HERALD

PUBLIC NOTICES

Guantnamo Special Coverage

Saturday, 01.19.13

Weather | Traffic

HOME NEWS SPORTS ENTERTAINMENT BUSINESS LIVING OPINION JOBS CARS REAL ESTATE SHOP CLASSIFIEDS Miami-Dade | Broward | Keys | Florida | Nation | World | Americas | Cuba | Haiti | Politics | Schools | Obituaries | WLRN
The Miami Herald > News > Americas > Guantnamo > Guantnamo Special Coverage
Posted on Tuesday, 12.28.10

12

email

print

comment

reprints

Miami Herald

Web Search powered byY AHOO! SEARCH

WikiLeaks: How U.S. tried to stop Spain's torture probe

Like 0
BY CAROL ROSENBERG CROSENBERG@MIAMIHERALD.COM

Search: Horoscopes | Comics & Games | Data Sleuth

MIAMI It was three months into Barack Obama's presidency, and the administration -under pressure to do something about alleged abuses in Bush-era interrogation policies -- turned to a Florida senator to deliver a sensitive message to Spain: Don't indict former President George W. Bush's legal brain trust for alleged torture in the treatment of war on terror detainees, warned Mel Martinez on one of his frequent trips to Madrid. Doing so would chill U.S.-Spanish relations. Rather than a resolution, though, a senior

Newscircles are a quick, convenient way to create and publish your own customized

Related Content Complete Guantnamo coverage On the web | Wikileaks search engine Follow reporter @CarolRosenberg on Twitter Link | The April 17, 2009 State Department cable from Spain Link | Ambassador calls judge "storied and controversial figure" on Dec. 21, 2007

Spanish diplomat gave the former GOP chairman and housing secretary a lesson in Spain's separation of powers. "The independence of the judiciary and the process must be respected,'' then-acting Foreign Minister Angel Lossada replied on April 15, 2009. Then for emphasis, "Lossada reiterated to Martinez that the executive branch of government could not close any judicial investigation and urged that this case not affect the overall relationship.'' The case is still open, on the desk of a Spanish magistrate, awaiting a reply from the Obama administration on whether it will pursue a probe of its own. But the episode, revealed in a raft of WikiLeaks cables, was part of a secret concerted U.S. effort to stop a crusading Spanish judge from investigating a torture complaint against former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and five other senior Bush lawyers. It also reveals a covert troubleshooting role

news portals... Get the most up to date breaking new stories as they happen across the globe...

Choose an industry to view realtime news organized from over 25,000 sources...

Get the Deal!

$69 for a LumiFacial with LumiLift at Hemi Day Spa (a $199 value)

WikiLeaks cables indicate Cuba sought 'secret channel' to U.S.

$69.00
Value: Discount: You Save: $199 65% $130

played by Martinez. Now a banker, he won't discuss it. ACCUSATION The cause for alarm at the U.S. Embassy was what a U.S. diplomat called a "well documented'' 12-inchtall dossier compiled by a Spanish human rights group. In the name of five Guantnamo captives with ties to Spain, it accused the Bush legal insiders of laying the foundation for abuse of detainees in the months following the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. Of particular concern was that a swashbuckling Spanish magistrate, Baltasar Garzn, might get the probe under Spain's system, which gave judges extraordinary investigative powers. Garzn had earlier made headlines by swearing out arrest warrants for Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet while he was getting medical attention in London, and Osama bin Laden. U.S. ambassador Eduardo Aguirre Jr. cast him as a publicity hound with an ``anti-American streak'' in one confidential cable. Sign up for the daily deal email:
Enter your email here

Get Deals!

MORE GUANTNAMO SPECIAL COVERAGE $40 million fiber-optic link to Navy plans Guantnamo base Base DJs riff Fidel Castro for fun, not profits Web Extra | A prison camps primer Guantnamo is going green Guantnamo: the most expensive prison on earth CIAs Bay of Pigs foreign policy laid bare

If those efforts are any guide, a Spanish prosecution of the so-called Bush Six seems unlikely. Britain never turned Pinochet over to Spain for a war crimes trial, and bin Laden is still at large. Rather, indictments would undermine U.S. diplomatic credibility on human rights and likely ground the six Bush lawyers in the United States, for fear of arrest overseas. Another, April 1, 2009, cable shows the U.S. Embassy's political officer and legal advisor discussing Garzn with his boss, chief prosecutor Javier Zaragoza, who expresses his displeasure with the case. Separately, a third U.S. diplomat told a senior Spanish Justice Ministry official ``for international judicial cooperation'' that the U.S. government considered the potential for a prosecution ``a very serious matter.'' 'DRAMATIC' Civil rights attorney Michael Ratner, whose Center for Constitutional Rights has championed Guantnamo detainee rights, called the cables taken together ``quite dramatic.'' "The U.S. prides itself on our own independent judiciary,'' Ratner said. ``But here you have the hypocrisy of the U.S. government trying to influence an independent judicial system to bend its laws and own rules.'' "And it's the Obama administration doing it to protect Bush people,'' he said. NOT SPEAKING Martinez, a former trial lawyer, said through two spokeswomen at JP Morgan Chase, where he's Florida chairman, that he would not comment. Nor would Bush's political appointee, Ambassador Aguirre, who is now a Houston-based consultant and like Martinez came from Cuba as a teen through the Pedro Pan movement. International prosecutions aren't unprecedented. Bush's father had U.S. forces invade Panama in 1989 to capture Manuel Noriega, then prosecuted him for allowing Colombian drug runners to ship cocaine through his country to the United States. Last year, a Miami judge gave Chuckie Taylor, a U.S. citizen, a 97-year sentence for torturing hundreds of Liberians as commander of his president-father's security unit from 1999-2003. But by the time Spain's Association for the Dignity of Prisoners filed the torture complaint that U.S. diplomatic circles found so troubling, the Obama White House was resisting calls to set up a Truth Commission or assign a special prosecutor to examine the legal framework that set up Guantnamo and permitted ``enhanced interrogation techniques'' that included waterboarding high-value detainees.

CIAs Bay of Pigs foreign policy laid bare More VIDEOS

VIDEO Armstrong Emotional in 2nd Part of Intervie

More video ON FACEBOOK

Find us on Facebook The Miami Herald

Like 41,454 people like The Miami Herald.

Fac ebook soc ial plugin

``Generally speaking, I'm more interested in looking forward than I am in looking backwards,'' Obama said on Feb. 9, 2009. SECRET MEMO In January 2002, Gonzales, as White House counsel, wrote a secret memo declaring portions of the Geneva Conventions ``quaint'' and ``obsolete'' after 9/11, such as limits on questioning prisoners and giving commissary privileges. Critics said he dismissed international law and laid the legal foundation for abuses. As a senator, Obama opposed his nomination for attorney general in 2005. Martinez by contrast devoted his first Senate floor speech, Feb. 3, 2005, to defend Gonzales, making history as the first senator to address the chamber in Spanish. ``El Juez Gonzales es uno de nosotros,'' he said, addressing his remarks to Hispanic America, ``Judge Gonzalez is one of us.'' By the time Martinez was campaigning against charging Gonzales, Spain's Supreme Court had already in 2005 overturned the conviction of a terror suspect the media had dubbed ``The Spanish Taliban'' on grounds his Guantnamo interrogations were tainted by conditions the court called ``impossible to explain, much less to justify.'' The American Civil Liberties Union unearthed, through the Freedom of Information Act, Gonzales' ``quaint'' memo as well as Justice Department opinions by Bush lawyers John Yoo, now a Berkeley law professor, and Jay Bybee, now a federal judge in California, that authorized the CIA to use the near drowning technique called waterboarding that is widely condemned as torture. Others named in the Spanish suit include former Vice President Dick Cheney's counsel, then chief of staff, David Addington; then-Defense Department General Counsel William ``Jim'' Haynes and Doug Feith, a Pentagon undersecretary who handled policy issues for Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. Garzn, the activist judge, has been suspended for allegedly overstepping his authority in another crimes against humanity case, this one on home turf: The execution or disappearance of more than 100,000 civilians during the dictatorship of Gen. Francisco Franco. But by then it was assigned to Judge Eloy Velasco, a Garzn colleague who has three times asked the U.S. government to say whether it envisions a similar investigation at home, which would supersede his efforts. ``They've never answered. From the record of this case they've ignored that it even existed,'' said Katherine Gallagher, a staff attorney at the New York Center for Constitutional Rights who is now collaborating with Spanish lawyers seeking Guantnamo prosecutions. Her boss, Ratner, says news of the meddling may cause blow-back to the U.S. political effort.
Recommendations Sign Up

Create an account or log in to see what your friends a

North Dade man claims self-defense in killing of intruder 48 people recommended this.

SOUTH BEND, Ind.: Notre Dame to Te'o: Time to speak up 5 people recommended this.

BBC Murders kills it at the Parker Playhouse - Performing 211 people recommended this.

Facebook social plugin

QUICK JOB SEARCH Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category All United States All Job Categories

Advanced Job Search Search by Category

``Now that it's been brought out that there were efforts to compromise the Spanish judiciary they're going to have to show their independence,'' he said. Still unclear is how Martinez, a former trial lawyer, joined the effort to derail the investigation. Gonzales told The Miami Herald ``I had no knowledge'' about the activities of Martinez. Yoo said the same in an email reply. Neither would discuss the investigation itself. Moreover, Gonzales argued it would be wrong to assume that Martinez, who quit the Senate four months later, was acting on behalf of any administration -- even though the cable describes the future banker as delivering the message to the foreign minister in tandem with Charge d'Affaires Arnold Chacon. ``Sen. Martinez may have been simply expressing an opinion or view,'' said Gonzales, who like the ambassador calls Martinez ``a friend.'' But a former Bush-era State Department official said, on condition of anonymity, that Martinez got a briefing from the Embassy each time he visited Madrid, either on a congressionally funded trip or as head of an influential Miami-based nonprofit, the United States-Spain Council. KING CARLOS Given his pedigree as a Bush insider and 2006-2007 Republican Party chairman, Martinez had greater access than most senators in Madrid. He would invariably offer, said the official, ``Is there a message you'd like me to deliver?'' If he agreed with the message, he'd convey it -- in visits that at one point took him to the palace to greet King Juan Carlos. "Mel was loyal to President Bush and loyal to the people who were loyal to President Bush,'' said the former Bush-era diplomat. "He didn't look at whether it's the Bush administration or the Obama administration. He asked himself, `Is it the right thing to do?' ''
Like 0 14 0 12

READ MORE GUANTNAMO SPECIAL COVERAGE STORIES FROM THE MIAMI HERALD
EXCLUSIVE | NAVY BASE GUANTANAMO

Navy plans $40 million fiber-optic link to Guantnamo base

Base DJs riff Fidel Castro for fun, not profits

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover the best free real-time news, networking and information portal on the web...

Newscircles are a quick, convenient way to create and publish your own customized news portals...

Get the most up to date breaking new stories as they happen across the globe...

Choose an industry to view real-time news organized from over 25,000 sources...

Get the Miami Herald's Americas News

VIA EMAIL
Enter email address

Join the

DISCUSSION
The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts. The Miami Herald uses the Disqus commenting system. This allows readers the option of signing in using their Facebook, Twitter, Disqus or existing MiamiHerald.com username and password. Note: Miami Herald Plus+ members, your Plus+ username and password can not be used to log in to the commenting system. To learn more click here.

10 Comments

ADD NEW COMMENT

Login

Real-time updating is paused. (Resume)

SHOWING 10 COMMENTS

Sort by oldest first

K1MJS
This is really rich. We have Mel Martinez trying to strong-arm the Spanish officials to not investigate the litany of crimes committed by George W. Bush, Alberto Gonzalez, and a host of others. This is like a rich father trying to convince the local chief of police to not arrest his reckless son and his friends after they plowed their car into a crowd of innocent by-standers, killing them all. What incredible arrogance. And who do you suppose paid for then-Senator Mel Martinez's frequent trips to Spain? Just look in the mirror. The U.S. taxpayers, of course!

Addy Yeow
Thanks for the roundup! Available now for public access, http://dazzlepod.com/cable/, is created to allow readers to easily catch up with upcoming WikiLeaks cables. The site grants you the access to all WikiLeaks cables in a nicely formatted table and search feature to look for cables based on your entered keywords. To know more, head over to the Facebook app page: http://apps.facebook.com/cable...

Stuwb
This is utterly embarrassing. The moral high ground that we tell everyone we have is starting to look like an illusion. It seems our leaders do everything as corrupt as those we chastise. It seems the difference is that other governments are not taking ours to task, as we do theirs.

davidcayjohnston
Thank you, Carol Rosenberg, for your careful, nuanced and dogged reporting.

janinsanfran
Thank you for your dogged reporting of the shameful, lawless behavior of government officials, past and present.

prayforjustice
Is Bush and Cheney above the law they both committed crimes against humanity, along with the six lawyers who participated in there crimes are just as guilty and should be punished!!!!!

moogley
I wish Spain said piss off.

David Sketchley
Phillipe Sands, professor of international law at University College London, actually documented the entire case in his book Torture Team, and Garzon's case was based on that. To anyone with half a brain, which just about excludes 90% of Americans, the Bush administration rode roughshod over international law and the lawyers were the enablers. Only when all of these people are in the dock facing charges for crimes against humanity, will justice be served. the US is a rogue state.

Freetruth
This is first rate stuff Carol. Seriously, I'm talking Pulitzer. Excellent writing, insightful and unique among the corporate (mainstream) media outlets. Your principled stand on civil rights and justice is inspired and clear headed. You are linked as an example of an exception to the official/typical WikiLeaks blather at Salon by the heroic Glenn Greenwald: http://www.salon.com/news/opin... As always, follow the money. Why would JP Morgan Chase hire an ex-Senator/Governor/Lawyer? For his financial expertise and experience in banking or his proven abilities and experience as a political enforcer/fixer? The revolving door between government and big banks is pretty crowded. I look forward to reading more of your work on this leaked informaton. You are one of "those who shine a light on what the most powerful factions do in the dark and who expose their corruption and deceit." It will also be very interesting to see what WikiLeaks releases in the Bank of America e-mails.

Archie1954
The US government has become so used to obstructing justice within its own borders that it now believes it can do it anywhere with impunity.

M Subscribe by email S RSS

54-Year-Old Mom Looks 27 Follow this 1 weird tip and remove 20 years of wrinkles in 20 days .
theSmartC onsumerLivi

Stock Market Tips Mutual Funds Don't Have To Be Complicated. Get Beginner Tips Now.
beckercap.com

Mortgage Rates Hit @ 2.5% If you owe under $729k you may qualify for 2.90% APR Govt Refi Plans !
Refinance

ADS BY YAHOO!

NEWS

SPORTS

ENTERTAINMENT

BUSINESS

LIVING

OPINION

CLASSIFIEDS

SERVICES

Site Map

RSS |

My Yahoo | Newsletters | Mobile | Alerts | Twitter

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | About our ads | Copyright | About The Miami Herald | About the McClatchy Company | Corrections | Contact Us | Advertise | Work for Us Partners: El Nuevo Herald | Newspaper in Education | WLRN | Miami Herald News | CBS4 WFOR-TV | More
Copyright 2013 Miami Herald Media Co. All rights reserved