CONFIDENTIAL

CERTIFIED REPORT OF NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING

Customer Address

Arizona Public Service

Date

03/31/08

Control No. or Report No.

Four Corners Generating Station Fruitland, NM

Job or Project Location

N/A
Plan or Dwg. No.

Unit 5 Outage
Surface Condition Heat No. Heat Treat

N/A
Type of Material Temperature

Power Buffed
Type of Examination

N/A

N/A
Acceptance Standard

P22
NDT Procedure or Code

Ambient
Unit Serial Number

Ultrasonic

Client Specification

C-UT-07 Rev 2

040261512
Sensitivity Level

ULTRASONIC EXAMINATION
Equipment Transducer Test Block Method Scanning Method

Epoch 4
Part or Item No.

0.5 2.25 MHz, 45 , 60

Total Length Examined
Feet Inches

APS 018

Shear wave

Manual/Contact
No. of Item Accepted

10% ID Roll On Exam Item

Type of Work

No. Items Rejected

East Outlet Girth Weld To GE 90 Elbow

N/A

N/A

Maintenance Inspection for service induced cracking

Flaw Code
C=Crack P=Porosity NF=Non Fusion LI=Linear Indication S=Slag LA= Laminations O=Others (Specify)
Part or Item No. Accepted Rejected Flaw Code Remarks

East Outlet Girth Weld To GE 90 Elbow

No Relevant Indications Noted

See Attached Calibration sheets and UT Plot and Profile sheet for Examination Coverage

Technician _Richard Cook_______________________________ Level ____II___________ Technician ____________________________________________ Level _______________ Customer _____________________________________________ Date ________________
Due to the subjective nature surrounding the interpretation of the results of non-destructive examination, PetroChem Inspection Services does not and will not certify that any interpretation provided by its personnel to be final and conclusive. Such interpretation is only provided for further evaluation by our clients. The responsibility for the acceptance interpretation lies solely with PetroChems client or that party so designated by our client. Therefore, PetroChem will not be liable for the ramifications (financial or otherwise) of impropriety or incorrectly interpreted examination results.

Confidential--Protected Materials Pursuant to California Public Utilities Commission Decisions and Applicable Law. Public Disclosure Restricted.