This is the authors version of a work that was submitted/accepted for publication in the following source:

Reiter, Sebastian, Stewart, Glenn, & Bruce, Christine S. (2011) A strategy

for delayed research method selection : deciding between grounded theory and phenomenology. Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods, 9(1), pp. 35-46.
This file was downloaded from: http://eprints.qut.edu.au/48527/

c Copyright 2011 Academic Conferences Ltd

Notice: Changes introduced as a result of publishing processes such as

copy-editing and formatting may not be reflected in this document. For a
definitive version of this work, please refer to the published source:

!"#$%&$'()"*+%",'-&)'."/'0'&%12"3'$2+."#'-'1$4+56"
,'14.45("7'$8''5"9%+:5.'.";2'+%)"&5."<2'5+='5+-+()"
#'>&0$4&5"/'4$'%?"9-'55"#$'8&%$"&5."@2%40$45'"7%:1'"
A:''50-&5."B54C'%04$)"+*";'125+-+()?"7%40>&5'?"!:0$%&-4&"
;3N1;=518O:35=3:PQF=O32FO1F$
GO;=3C1:=PQF=O32FO1F$
0ON:F03PQF=O32FO1F$
$
!>0$%&1$6$ L?5;$ @1@3:$ @:3;38=;$ 1$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 58$ 1$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ 58=3:@:3=5R5;=$
:3;31:0?O$ /8$ 3S34@J1:H$ 01;3$ 23=15J;$ ?7C$ 3S@J7:1=5R3$ 58=3:R53C;$ C3:3$ 23;5G832$ 182$ 0782F0=32$ 58$ 1007:21803$
C5=?$ 1$ @1:125G4$ @:57:$ =7$ 2305258G$ C?3=?3:$ =7$ 127@=$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 7:$ @?3874387J7GH$ 97:$ 21=1$ 181JH;5;O$ L?3$
970F;$ ?3:3$ 5;$ =7$ 23=3:4583$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ :3;31:0?$ ;=:1=3GH$ 58$ =?5;$ 01;3$ =?3$ 43=?727J7G501J$ 9:1458G$ =7$
0782F0=$:3;31:0?$182$:3@:3;38=$958258G;B$N7=?$79$C?50?$1:3$ 23=15J32O$>3;31:0?$122:3;;58G$0F::38=$4181G3438=$
5;;F3;$ :3QF5:3;$ N7=?$ 1$ 9J3S5NJ3$ 9:143C7:T$ 182$ =?3$ 01@1N5J5=H$ =7$ 078;523:$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ @:7NJ34$ 9:74$ R1:57F;$
18GJ3;B$ =7$ 23:5R3$ =18G5NJ3$ :3;FJ=;$ 97:$ 10123451$ C5=?$ 5443251=3$ 1@@J501=578$ =7$ NF;583;;$ 234182;O$ >3;31:0?3:;B$
182$58$@1:=50FJ1:$87R503;B$79=38$;=:FGGJ3$=7$230523$78$18$1@@:7@:51=3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;F5=1NJ3$=7$122:3;;$=?35:$
:3;31:0?$ @:7NJ34O$ L?5;$ 79=38$ 1@@J53;$ =7$ 58=3:@:3=1=5R3$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?$ C?3:3$ 5=$ 5;$ 87=$ 1JC1H;$ 5443251=3JH$
0J31:$C?50?$5;$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$43=?72$=7$F;3B$1;$=?3$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3;$;?59=$182$0:H;=1JJ5V3$7R3:$=543O$L?5;$
@1@3:$F;3;$18$3S34@J1:H$01;3$=7$:3R31J$?7C$=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$078=:5NF=3;$=7$
2305258G$C?3=?3:$=7$127@=$G:7F8232$=?37:H$7:$@?3874387J7GH$58$=?3$585=51J$@?1;3$79$1$M?I$:3;31:0?$@:7U30=O$!8$
=?5;$01;3B$;345(;=:F0=F:32$58=3:R53C;$C3:3$F;32$97:$21=1$G383:1=578$9:1432$58$18$58=3:@:3=5R5;=$1@@:710?B$;5=F1=32$
58$ 1$ NF;583;;$ 078=3S=O$ >3;31:0?$ QF3;=578;$ 97:$ =?5;$ ;=F2H$ C3:3$ =?7:7FG?JH$ 2395832$ 182$ 01:39FJJH$ 9:1432$ 58$
DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH UHVHDUFK SDUDGLJPV SULQFLSOHV ZKLOH DW WKH VDPH WLPH HQVXULQJ WKDW WKH UHTXLUH438=;$ 79$
N7=?$@7=38=51J$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$C3:3$43=O$L?3$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$@?3874387J7GH$43=?72;$ C3:3$074@1:32$
182$ 078=:1;=32$ =7$ 23=3:4583$ =?35:$ ;F5=1N5J5=H$ 182$ C?3=?3:$ =?3H$ 433=$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 7NU30=5R3;$ N1;32$ 78$ 1$ @5J7=$
;=F2HO$ L?3$ ;=:1=3GH$ @:7@7;32$ 58$ =?5;$ SDSHU LV DQ DOWHUQDWLYH WR WKH PRUH WUDGLWLRQDO DSSURDFK ZKLFK LQLWLDOO\
;3J30=;$ =?3$ 43=?727J7G501J$ 97:4FJ1=578B$ 97JJ7C32$ NH$ 21=1$ G383:1=578O$ !8$ 0780JF;578B$ =?3$ ;FGG3;=32$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$
23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$58=382;$=7$?3J@$:3;31:0?3:;$5238=59H$182$1@@JH$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$43=?72$=7$
=?35:$:3;31:0?O$L?5;$;=:1=3GH$5;$N1;32$78$3S@J7:1=578;$79$21=1$ G383:1=578$182$181JH;5;$58$7:23:$=7$23:5R3$915=?9FJ$
:3;FJ=;$9:74$=?3$21=1$G383:1=32O$
$
D')8+%.06$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578B$QF1J5=1=5R3$:3;31:0?B$G:7F8232$=?37:HB$@?3874387J7GH$

EF" G5$%+.:1$4+5"
>3;31:0?$43=?72;$1:3$ WUDGLWLRQDOO\$0?7;38$ @:57:$=7$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$N1;32$78$=?3$81=F:3B$154;$182$
G71J;$79$=?3$:3;31:0?$@:7U30=O$W7C3R3:$=?3$ WUDGLWLRQDO$ @:703;;$79$ 1$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$41H$
J545=$9J3S5N5J5=H$58$:3R5;58G$7:$0?18G58G$=?3$;3J30=32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$1=$1$J1=3:$;=1G3O$L?5;$018$J312$=7$
@7=38=51J$54@J501=578;B$;F0?$1;$;?7:=07458G;$58$=?3$:3;31:0?$23;5G8$182$?3803$:3;FJ=;$79$=?3$;=F2HO$!8$
1225=578$ :3038=$ ;=F253;$ 79=38$ 915J$ =7$ 23=15J$ =?3$ @:703;;$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ C?5J3$ N358G$
3S03JJ38=$58$23;0:5N58G$=?34O$L?3H$:1=?3:$0:5=5QF3$=?3$43=?72;$078R38=5781JJH$1@@J532$182$34@?1;5V3$
78$=?3$83G1=5R3$1;@30=;$58;=312$79$@:7@7;58G$1J=3:81=5R3;$7:$5887R1=5R3$;7JF=578;O$
$
"F0?$;?7:=07458G;B$@15:32$C5=?$=?3$8332$97:$:5G7:7F;$182$:3J3R18=$:3;31:0?$=7$122:3;;$=?3$8332;$79$
R1:57F;$ ;=1T3?7J23:;B$ ;FGG3;=;$ 47:3$ 1==38=578$ N3$ @152$ =7C1:2;$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ ;3J30=578O$ !8$
1225=578B$ 4FJ=5@J3$ ;=1T3?7J23:;$ ;F0?$ 1;$ 10123451B$ @:10=5=5783:;B$ 182$ 582F;=:H$ @1:=83:;$ 580:31;3$ =?3$
074@J3S5=H$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ 234182;B$ 7NU30=5R3;$ 182$ 3S@30=32$ :3;FJ=;O$ XF:=?3:47:3B$ @:10=5=5783:;$ 182$
582F;=:H$ @1:=83:;$ =382$ =7$ J77T$ 97:$ =18G5NJ3$ :3;FJ=;$ =?1=$ 018$ N3$ 31;5JH$ =:18;93::32$ 182$ 1@@J532$ =7$
@:10=503O$L?F;B$10123451$4F;=$87=$N3$83GJ30=32$58$;=:5R58G$97:$:5G7:$182$:3J3R1803$Y>7N3H$182$K1:TF;$
%++Z[$ >5G7:7F;$ :3;31:0?$ 58$ @1:=50FJ1:B$ 018$ N3$ 10?53R32$ 87=$ 78JH$ =?:7FG?$ 01:39FJJH$ ;3J30=58G$ 182$
1@@JH58G$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$NF=$1J;7$23=15J58G$5=;$3S30F=578O$
$
>3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$5;$23@38238=$78$=?3$05:0F4;=1803;$182$7NU30=5R3;$79$=?3$:3;31:0?$:1=?3:$
=?18$23:5R58G$9:74$@?5J7;7@?H$Y?7C$C3$=?58T$1N7F=$5=[$7:$43=?727J7GH$Y?7C$C3$;=F2H$5=[$YW1443:;J3H$
%+++AZ)[O$ "3J30=58G$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$4F;=$N3$2:5R38$NH$=?3$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578$
182$0F::38=$N72H$ 79$T87CJ32G3$58$ =?3$ 1:31$:3;31:0?32$ Y\H83T77@$182$>F;;7$ %++'[$1;$ C3JJ$1;$=?3$
21=1$ 1003;;5NJ3$ =7$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:O$ ]897:=F81=3JHB$ :3;31:0?3:;$ 1:3$ 79=38$ 0789:78=32$ C5=?$ 18$
7R3:C?3J458G$8F4N3:$79$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$182$:3GFJ1:JH$;=:FGGJ3$=7$230523$78$=?3$47;=$;F5=1NJ3$783O$
!""#$%&''(')*+$
,-$
./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$
>393:3803$=?5;$@1@3:$1;A$
>35=3:B$ "B$ "=3C1:=B$ D$ 182$ E:F03 & /$ "=:1=3GH$ 97:$ I3J1H32$ >3;31:0?$ K3=?72$ "3J30=578A$ I305258G$ E3=C338$
D:7F8232$L?37:H$182$M?3874387J7GH!"#$%&#'()*+,'$-*.)+/&$*0$1.2,+#22$3#2#/)'"$4#("*52$6*&.7#$8$922.#$:$
;<::$=>>$?@ABCDE$/F/,&/G&#$*+&,+#$/($HHHI#JG)7I'*7$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
L?35:$;3J30=578$5;$79=38$N1;32$78$1;;F4@=578;$1N7F=$=?3$3S@30=32$:3;FJ=;B$589JF38032$NH$=?35:$@:3R57F;$
3S@3:53803;$7:$=?3$;F@3:R5;7:H$=314$58$=?3$01;3$79$M?I$7:$:3;31:0?$;=F238=;O$L?5;$1@@J53;$@1:=50FJ1:JH$
=7$ 58=3:@:3=1=5R3$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?B$ C?3:3$ 5=$ 5;$ 87=$ 1JC1H;$ 5443251=3JH$ 0J31:$ C?1=$ 5;$ =?3$ 47;=$
;F5=1NJ3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$=7$F;3$ 1;$=?3$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3;$;?59=$182$0:H;=1JJ5V3$ 7R3:$ =543O$M7;5=5R5;=$
:3;31:0?$78$=?3$7=?3:$;523$97:$3S14@J3$79=38$273;$87=$?1R3$=?5;$5;;F3$182$5;$F;F1JJH$47:3$078=:7JJ32$
182$;=:15G?=97:C1:2O$
$
D5R38$=?3$4FJ=5@J3$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$1R15J1NJ3B$0?77;58G$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$5;$87=$
18$31;H$=1;TO$_R38$C?38$J545=32$=7$QF1J5=1=5R3$58=3:@:3=1=5R3$43=?72;B$=?3:3$1:3$;=5JJ$8F43:7F;$7@=578;$
YK5J3;$ 182$ WFN3:4188$ %++&[$ =7$ N3$ 078;523:32O$ E1;501JJH$ 310?$ @7;;5NJ3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ?1;$
12R18=1G3;$ 182$ 25;12R18=1G3;$ YE38N1;1=B$ D7J2;=358$ 182$ K312$ %+Z'[$ C?50?$ 8332$ =7$ N3$ =1T38$ 58=7$
1007F8=O$`=?3:$=?18$=?3$T87CJ32G3$182$N10TG:7F82$79$=?3$:3;31:0?3:B$=?3$589JF3803$79$=?3$:3;31:0?$
=314$182$=?3$01@1N5J5=H$79$?F418$5897:41=578$@:703;;58G$018$N3$1$J545=1=578$1;$C3JJO$/007:258G$=7$R78$
\:5G?=$ Y%+'+[$ =?3$ ?F418$ ;?7:=$ =3:4$4347:H$ 5;$ :3;=:50=32$ =7$ -$ ab($ *$ 7N;3:R1=5781J$ F85=;$ C?50?$ J545=;$
7F:$ =1S7874HO$ `8$ =?3$ 7=?3:$ ?182B$ L3;0?$ Y%++)[$ :393:;$ =7$ *'$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ L?3;3$
45G?=$N3$@3:035R32$58$25993:38=$ C1H;$ NH$ 25993:38=$ @37@J3$ 58$=?3$;143$41883:$1;$25993:38=$25;05@J583;$
91R7:$ 25993:38=$ =H@3;$ 79$ 43=?72;$ 1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$ =?3$ F;3$ 79$ 25993:38=$ R701NFJ1:H$ 97:$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?O$
L?5;$:31;78$9F:=?3:$?5G?J5G?=;$=?3$8332$97:$1$;=:1=3GH$=7$;3J30=$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$:3;31:0?$43=?72O$
$
K1;78$ Y*))*A*^[$ ;FGG3;=;$ =?3$ 0:31=578$ 79$ 18$ 7R3:R53C$ 79$ @7=38=51J$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 182$ 21=1$
;7F:03;$ 58$ =?3$ 585=51J$ :3;31:0?$ ;=1G3$ 580JF258G$ =?3$ 783;$ C?50?$ 45G?=$ N3$ :3U30=32O$ "?3$ 9F:=?3:$
?5G?J5G?=32$ =?1=$ NH$ G383:1=58G$ 21=1$ 182$ 181JH;58G$ 21=1$ @15:32$ C5=?$ =?3$ 3S@3:53803$ G15832$ NH$
:3;31:0?3:$=?:7FG?7F=$=?5;$@:703;;$=?3$:3;31:0?$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$43=?72$07FJ2$N3$;3J30=32O$!8$=?5;$
;=F2H$1$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$C5JJ$N3$95:;=JH$ 23=15J32$97JJ7C32$NH$ 23;0:5N58G$
=?3$1@@J501=578$79$18$3S34@J1:H$01;3O$L?3$@1@3:$=?3:3$19=3:$0780JF23;$C5=?$1$25;0F;;578$182$7F=J77T$
=7$9F=F:3$:3;31:0?O$

HF" #$%&$'()"*+%".'-&)'."%'0'&%12"='$2+."0'-'1$4+5"
L?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$154;$=7$?3J@$58$=?3$@:703;;$79$;3J30=58G$=?3$47;=$
1@@:7@:51=3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ UHODWHG WR WKH SUREOHP DQG VWDNHKROGHUV LQWHUHVWV 58$ 7:23:$ =7$ 23:5R3$
915=?9FJ$:3;FJ=;O$/==38=578$5;$=?3:3NH$@152$95:;=JH$=7$=?3$:3;31:0?$;3==58G$182$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578B$;30782JH$
78$=?3$4723$79$21=1$G383:1=578$182$J1;=JH$=?3$47;=$;F5=1NJ3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$=7$N3$;3J30=32$N1;32$78$
=?3$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 182$ 21=1$ @:3(181JH;5;$ Y@5J7=$ ;=F2H[O$ L?3$ 25993:3803$ =7$ =?3$ WUDGLWLRQDO$ :3;31:0?$
43=?72$;3J30=578$5;$58$=?3$;3QF3803B$182$078;523:1=578$79$=?3$N397:3$438=57832$1;@30=;O$

HFE" /'0'&%12"0'$$45("
M:57:$=7$1@@JH58G$=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578B$=?3$:3;31:0?$078=3S=$1;$C3JJ$1;$
=?3$ @F:@7;3$ 182$ 3S@30=32$ :3@:3;38=1=578$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ 958258G;$ ?1R3$ =7$ N3$ 0J31:JH$ 1:=50FJ1=32$ 182$
2395832O$L?5;$580JF23;$9F821438=1J$078;523:1=578;$38074@1;;58G$=?3$0F::38=$;=1=3$79$1:=$58$=?3$953J2$79$
58R3;=5G1=578B$ :3J1=32$ J5=3:1=F:3B$ N10TG:7F82B$ 3S@3:53803$ 182$ T87CJ32G3$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:O$ L?3$
:3;31:0?$@F:@7;3$3S@J158;$=?3$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3;$182$59$3S5;=58G$:3QF5:3438=;$79$=?3$:3;31:0?$@:7U30=$
;@78;7:$ 7:$ @1:=83:$ 1:3$ 1@@J501NJ3O$ XF:=?3:$ =?3$ 58=38232$ F85=$ 79$ 181JH;5;$ N358G$ 97:$ 3S14@J3$ 18$
5825R52F1JB$7:G185V1=578B$1:=3910=$7:$;@305950$05:0F4;=1803$8332$=7$N3$0J31:JH$2395832$182$;=1=32O$L?3$
1N5J5=H$=7$1003;;$182$G383:1=3$F;31NJ3$21=1$5;$1$T3H$078;523:1=578$=7$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578O$
/8$1225=5781J$3J3438=$5;$=?3$3R1JF1=578$79$=?3$G383:1=32$21=1$58$=3:4;$79$5=;$074@7;5=578$58$QF1J5=H$1;$
C3JJ$1;$QF18=5=HO$"@3051J$1==38=578$?1;$=7$N3$@152$=?3:3NH$=7$;14@J58GB$C?50?$8332;$=7$N3$=?7:7FG?JH$
1J5G832$ C5=?$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ @1:125G4$ :3QF5:3438=;O$ 678;3QF38=JH$ 1R15J1NJ3$ 21=1$ ?1;$ =7$ N3$ 0J31:JH$
3R1JF1=32$@:57:$=7$@:3(;3J30=58G$18$1@@:7@:51=3$:3;31:0?$43=?72O$

HFH" /'0'&%12"I:'0$4+5"
L?3$239585=578$79$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578;$5;$=?3$47;=$54@7:=18=$;=3@$ C?38$F823:=1T58G$18H$:3;31:0?$ Yc58$
*)),A'[$1;$=?3H$G5R3$25:30=578$=7$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$1@@J532O$!8$7:23:$=7$23J1H$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$
;3J30=578B$ :3;31:0?$ QF3;=578;$ 1:3$ ;FGG3;=32$ =7$ N3$ T3@=$ 1;$ N:712$ 1;$ @7;;5NJ3$ 182$ 1;$ 23=15J32$ 1;$
8303;;1:HO$6780F::38=JHB$=?3$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578;$8332$=7$N3$1J5G832$C5=?$=?3$:3;31:0?$@1:125G4$182$
:3QF5:3438=;$ 79$ =?3$ J1=3:$ @:3(;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;O$ /8$ 3S@J7:1=7:H$ 1@@:710?$ =7$ 3S14583$ 182$
81::7C$ 27C8$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 7NU30=5R3$ 5;$ =?3:397:3$ 1@@:7@:51=3O$ L?5;$ :3QF5:3;$ 18$ 7@38(4582$ C?5J3$
9:1458G$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ QF3;=578O$ /=$ =?3$ ;143$ =543B$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ 5;$ :3QF5:32$ =7$ 9145J51:5V3$ C5=?$
@7=38=51J$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 182$ NF5J2$ 1C1:383;;$ 79$ =?35:$ :3QF5:3438=;O$ W3803$ =?3$ GF5258G$ :3;31:0?$
QF3;=578;$585=51JJH$:34158;$78$1$?5G?$J3R3JO$
CCCO3UN:4O074$

,^$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$

<#=-0%)-(*1#)%#&*#%*-">$

HFJ" 3+.'"+*".&$&"('5'%&$4+5"
KFJ=5@J3$21=1$;7F:03;$1:3$;FGG3;=32$=7$N3$F;32$:1=?3:$=?18$78JH$783$;7F:03$=7$01@=F:3$=?3$078=3S=F1J$
074@J3S5=H$ 79$ =?3$ 1:31$ F823:$ 58R3;=5G1=578O$ c58$ Y*)),AZ^[$ ;FGG3;=32$ =?3$ 078R3:G3803$ 79$ =?3$ 6L[
VRXUFHV RI (YLGHQFH$ 8143JH$ 270F438=1=578B$ 1:0?5R1J$ :307:2B$ 58=3:R53C;B$ 25:30=$ 7N;3:R1=578B$
@1:=505@18=(7N;3:R1=578$ 182$ @?H;501J$ 1:=5910=;O$ E3;523;$ =?3$ 2745818=$ 4723$ 79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578B$ 7=?3:$
;7F:03;$;?7FJ2$N3$078;523:32$=7$01@=F:3$=?3$078=3S=F1J$074@J3S5=HO$L:518GFJ1=578$79$21=1$;7F:03;$182$
25993:38=$ 4723;$ 79$ G383:1=578$ =?3:3NH$ 381NJ3$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ =7$ 7N;3:R3$ =?3$ 7NU30=$ 79$ 58R3;=5G1=578$
9:74$ 25993:38=$ 18GJ3;$ Y#3F418$ %++'A%-%[O$ L?3$ 58=3:R53C$ =30?85QF3$ YdR1J3$ %++^e$ M1==78$ *))*[$ 5;$
074478JH$ F;32$ 58$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ ;=F253;O$ !8=3:R53C58G$ 5;$ 79=38$ ;338$ 1;$ ;H878H47F;$ =7$ QF1J5=1=5R3$
58QF5:53;B$ C?5J3$ ?1R58G$ ;545J1:$ 078;=:F0=578;$ 5::3;@30=5R3$ 79$ =?3$ 43=?727J7G501J$ @7;5=578$ Y\54@388H$
182$ D1;;$ *)))[O$ W7C3R3:$ =?3$ 97:4$ 182$ 97:41=$ 79$ =?3$ 58=3:R53C$ 0782F0=$ R1:53;$ 23@38238=$ 78$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$@1:125G4$182$=7$=?3$;3J30=32$:3;31:0?$43=?72O$L?3:3$1:3$;5G8595018=$25993:3803;$58$23;5G8B$
0782F0=B$ :7J3$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:B$ 97:4FJ1=578$ 79$ QF3;=578;$ 182$ 181JH;5;B$ 23@38258G$ 78$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$
43=?72O$L?3;3$8332$=7$ N3$01:39FJJH$078;523:32$1;$3R38$;J5G?=$23R51=578;$45G?=$54@10=$=?3$:3;31:0?$
:3;FJ=;O$ K7;=$ 54@7:=18=$ 910=7:$ 58$ =?3$ 4723$ 79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 5;$ =?3$ 1R15J1N5J5=H$ 182$ =?3$ 1003;;$ 79$
1@@:7@:51=3$ 21=1O$ L?3;3$ =C7$ 910=7:;$ 018$ 23=3:4583$ 1$ :3;31:0?$ @:7G:14$ 3;@3051JJH$ 1;$ QF1J5=1=5R3$
:3;31:0?$ 5;$ 23@38238=$ 78$ :50?$ 182$ 915=?9FJ$ 21=1$ 97:4$ =?3$ ;7F:03;$ 1R15J1NJ3O$ L?3$ 970F;$ 79$ QF1J5=1=5R3$
:3;31:0?3:$ LV WKHUHE\ QRW WR VLPSOH ILQG GDWD LQ D FROOHFWDEOH VWDWH$ 58;=312$ =?3$ 970F;$ 5;$ 78$ ?7C$ =7$
G383:1=3$21=1$9:74$=?3$0?7;38$21=1$;7F:03;$YK1;78$*))*[O$

HFK" <%'L0'-'1$4+5"+*"%'0'&%12"='$2+.0"
4XDOLWDWLYH UHVHDUFK LV FKDUDFWHULVWLFDOO\ H[SORUDWRU\ IOXLG DQG IOH[LEOH GDWDA5),F#+$ /+5$ '*+(#K($
VHQVLWLYH$YK1;78$*))*A*&[O$EH$078;523:58G$=?3$:3;31:0?$;3==58GB$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578$182$4723$79$21=1$
G383:1=578B$ =C7$ =7$ =?:33$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ ;?7FJ2$ N3$ @:3(;3J30=32$ 97:$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2HO$ /$
074@:3?38;5R3$ 7R3:R53C$ 79$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 5;$ G5R38$ NH$ L3;0?$ Y%++)[$ 7:$ K5J3;$ 182$
WFN3:4188$Y%++&[O$\?38$074@1:58G$=?3$@:3(;3J30=32$@7=38=51J$:3;31:0?$43=?72;B$;@3051J$1==38=578$5;$
@152$ =7$ =?3$ 3S@30=32$ :3;FJ=;B$ =?3$ 4723$ 182$ 0782F0=$ 79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$ :3QF5:3438=;$ 97:$
21=1$ 181JH;5;O$ X7JJ7C58G$ =7$ =?3$ @:3(;3J30=578$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;B$ 1$ @5J7=$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 182$ @:3(
181JH;5;$5;$0782F0=32$=7$=3;=$=?35:$;F5=1N5J5=H$182$1J5G8438=O$

HFM" ,&$&"('5'%&$4+5"
I1=1$ G383:1=578$ 5;$ 585=51JJH$ 0782F0=32$ C5=?$ 1$ 431858G9FJ$ @5J7=$ ;14@J3$ Y8f,(-[O$ /$ 03:=158$ 23G:33$ 79$
97:41J5V1=578$ 5;$ ;FGG3;=32B$ 580JF258G$ @:7032F:3;$ ;F0?$ 1;$ 1$ 23=15J32$ @:7=707J$ 7F=J5858G$ =?3$ ;=3@;$
YW7C1:2(D:38R5JJ3[$182$21=1$G1=?3:32$YC?1=[$2F:58G$=?3$58=3:R53C;$7:$78(;5=3$R5;5=;O$,QHDFKFDVH\RX
H,&&$ +##5$ (*$ /2L$ M*.)2#&0$ H"#("#)$ M*.$ "/F#$ N#+#)/(#5$ 5/(/$ *0$ />>)*>),/(#$ *)5#)E$ 0)*7$ ("#$ )#&#F/+($
UDQJHRIVRXUFHVDQGZLWKDGHTXDWHFRYHUDJHWRIDVKLRQWKHNLQG RIDUJXPHQW \RXGHVLUH$YK1;78$
*))*A%'&[O$L?:7FG?7F=$21=1$G383:1=578$=?3$:3;31:0?3:$5;$3807F:1G32$=7$:3R5;5=$=?3$:3QF5:3438=;$79$1JJ$
@:3(;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 58$ 7:23:$ =7$ 38;F:3$ =?3H$ 1:3$ ;=:50=JH$ 97JJ7C32O$ !8$ =?3$ 01;3$ 79$ 18H$
23R51=578$=?3$0782F0=$79$21=1$G383:1=578$?1;$=7$N3$;=7@@32$182$12UF;=32O$L?5;$@?1;3$38;F:3;$=?1=$=?3$
;3=$79$:3QF5:3438=;$23=3:45832$NH$=?3$@:3(;3J30=32$43=?72;$:3G1:258G$=?3$21=1$QF1J5=H$182$QF18=5=H$5;$
43=O$

HFN" ,&$&"O%'L&5&-)040"
L?3$21=1$@:3(181JH;5;$@?1;3$078038=:1=3;$78$1@@JH58G$310?$79$=?3$@:3(;3J30=32$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$=7$
=?3$21=1$;14@J3$9:74$=?3$@5J7=$;=F2HB$=7$074@1:3$=?3$:3;FJ=;$182$=?35:$:3@:3;38=1=578$C5=?$=?3$:3;31:0?$
7NU30=5R3;O$L?5;$;=1G3$ 5;$=7$@5J7=$182$07895:4$=?3$;F5=1N5J5=H$182$1@@:7@:51=383;;$79$07JJ30=32$ 21=1$1;$
C3JJ$1;$=7$38;F:3$=?1=$=?3$:3QF5:3438=;$79$@:3(;3J30=32$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$1:3$43=O$L?5;$580JF23;A$/:3$
=?3$QF3;=578;$@?:1;32$1007:258G$=7$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$@:5805@J3;g$/:3$=?3$07JJ30=32$21=1$;F5=1NJ3$
97:$ 9F:=?3:$ 181JH;5;g$ /8H$ 45;1J5G8438=$ C7FJ2$ J312$ =7$ 35=?3:$ 1$ 23(;3J30=578$ 79$ =?3$ 43=?72$ 7:$ 18$
F8F;1NJ3$21=1$;14@J3O$

HFP" ,'-&)'."0'-'1$4+5"+*"$2'"%'0'&%12"='$2+."
/9=3:$ =?3$ G383:1=32$ 21=1$ 5;$ :3R5;5=32$ 182$ 5=;$ QF1J5=H$ 0?30T32$ 182$ 181JHV32B$ :3;FJ=;$ 1:3$ 01:39FJJH$
074@1:32$C5=?$=?3$@:3:3QF5;5=3;$182$:3QF5:3438=;$79$=?3$@:3(;3J30=32$:3;31:0?$43=?72;O$L?3$970F;$5;$
=?3:3NH$ =7$ 3R1JF1=3$ C?50?$ 79$ =?3$ @:3(;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 5;$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ 97:$ =?3$ 21=1$
181JH;5;$ 182$ ;FN;3QF38=JH$ =?3$ 0782F0=$ 79$ =?3$ ;=F2HO$ #3S=$ =?3$ QF1J5=H$ 182$ QF18=5=H$ 79$ =?3$ G383:1=32$
21=1$ 5;$ 3R1JF1=32O$ I3:5R32$ :3;31:0?$ 958258G;$ 1:3$ 1;;3;;32$ 1G158;=$ =?3$ 3S@30=32$ QF1J5=H$ 182$
CCCO3UN:4O074$

,'$

!""#$%&''(')*+$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
:3@:3;38=1=578O$!8$1225=578B$343:G58G$=?343;$182$@:57:5$:3;FJ=;$018$N3$:3@7:=32$1=$=?3$;143$=543O$L?3$
9581J$;=1G3$79$=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$5;$=7$;3J30=$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$182$
;F5=1NJ3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72O$ L?5;$ @:703;;$ 25993:;$ 9:74$ =?3$ WUDGLWLRQDO$ 1@@:710?$ C?3:3$ 58$ 078=:1;=$ =?3$
97:4FJ1=578$79$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578;$182$078;523:1=578$79$=?3$:3;31:0?$;3==58G$5;$97JJ7C32$NH$23=3:45858G$
=?3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ @:57:$ =7$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 182$ 181JH;5;O$ !8$ =?3$ 97JJ7C58G$ X5GF:3$ %$ 5JJF;=:1=3;$ =?3$
@:703;;$79$=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578O$

/'0'&%12"0'$$45(

/'0'&%12"I:'0$4+5

3+.'"+*".&$&"
('5'%&$4+5

<%'L0'-'1$4+5"+*"
%'0'&%12"='$2+.0

,&$&"('5'%&$4+5
Q<4-+$"0$:.)R

,&$&"O%'L&5&-)040
Q<4-+$"0$:.)R

,'-&)'."%'0'&%12"
='$2+."0'-'1$4+5
$
S4(:%'"E6$M:703;;$79$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$

JF" @&0'"
L?5;$;30=578$23=15J;$18$3S34@J1:H$01;3$79$1$QF1J5=1=5R3$;=F2H$97JJ7C58G$=?3$58=3:@:3=5R3$=:125=578$YdJ358$
182$ KH3:;$ %+++[$ 182$ :3R31J;$ ?7C$ =?3$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 1;;5;=;$ 58$

CCCO3UN:4O074$

,Z$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$

<#=-0%)-(*1#)%#&*#%*-">$

2305258G$78$=?3$47;=$1@@:7@:51=3$182$;F5=1NJ3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$58$=?3$585=51J$@?1;3$79$1$M?I$:3;31:0?$
@:7U30=O$

JFE" /'0'&%12"0'$$45("
L?3$ 3S34@J59532$ :3;31:0?$ @:7U30=$ 5;$ ;5=F1=32$ 58$ 1$ NF;583;;$ 078=3S=$ 15458G$ =7$ 23:5R3$ 1$ 81::1=5R3$
9:143C7:T$ 7:$ 1$ ;3=$ 79$ @:7@7;5=578;$ 1@@J501NJ3$ =7$ N7=?$ 10123451$ 182$ @:10=5=5783:;O$ /8$ 3S@J7:1=7:H$
58R3;=5G1=578$154;$=?3:3NH$=7$25;07R3:$=?37:H$79$0FJ=F:1J$39930=;$182$=?35:$58=3:10=578$78$GJ7N1J$@:7U30=;O$
K7:3$ ;@3059501JJHB$ 5=$ 5;$ 15432$ =7$ 95:;=$ F823:;=182$ =?3$ 074@J3S$ 078;=:F0=$ F823:$ 58R3;=5G1=578B$ N358G$
GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=;O$"30782$5;$ =7$3S@J158$ 700F::58G$0FJ=F:1J$39930=;$182$5=;$58=3:10=578;$78$GJ7N1J$@:7U30=;$
C?3:3NH$=?3$F85=$79$181JH;5;$N358G$=?3$GJ7N1J$@:7U30=O$!8$=?3$95:;=$;=1G3B$=?3$1:31$F823:$58R3;=5G1=578$5;$
23=3:45832$ 182$ 81::7C32$ 27C8O$ /$ ?5G?(J3R3J$ @:3J54581:H$ J5=3:1=F:3$ :3R53C$ 5;$ 0782F0=32$ 10:7;;$ N7=?$
10123450$182$@:10=5=5783:$;7F:03;$=7$5238=59H$T87CJ32G3$G1@;$182$0F::38=$0?1JJ38G3;$1;$C3JJ$1;$ =?3$
8332;$3S@:3;;32$NH$=?3$:3;31:0?$182$@:10=5=5783:$0744F85=HO$L?3$J5=3:1=F:3$:3R53C$15432$=7$95:;=JH$=7$
N3==3:$ F823:;=182$ =?3$ 953J2$ 79$ 58R3;=5G1=578$ 182$ ;30782JH$ :3R5;3$ 182$ 239583$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 7NU30=5R3;$
182$ GF5258G$ :3;31:0?$ QF3;=578;O$ L?3$ 0?539$ 58R3;=5G1=7:$ Y95:;=$ 1F=?7:[$ 10T87CJ32G3;$ ?5;$ N51;3;$ 79$
274158$ T87CJ32G3$ 58$ =?3$ 1:31$ F823:$ 58R3;=5G1=578$ G5R38$ ?5;$ ;FN;=18=5R3$ @:793;;5781J$ C7:T58G$
3S@3:53803$ C7:T58G$ C5=?$ 4FJ=581=5781J$ 7:G185V1=578;$ 78$ GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=;O$ /=$ =?3$ ;143$ =543$ ?3$ C1;$ 1$
87R503$ :3;31:0?3:$ C?38$ 34N1:T58G$ =?5;$ :3;31:0?$ @:7G:14B$ GF5232$ NH$ ?5;$ ;F@3:R5;7:H$ =314$ Y07(
DXWKRUVDQGOHDUQLQJVIURPFRXUVHZRUNRQTXDOLWDWLYHUHVHDUFKPHWKRGV$

JFH" /'0'&%12"I:'0$4+5"
>3;31:0?$QF3;=578;$97:$=?5;$;=F2H$C3:3$585=51JJH$T3@=$N:712$=7$100744721=3$=?3$:3QF5:3438=;$79$N7=?$
@7=38=51J$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;O$ /8$ 3S@J7:1=7:H$ 1@@:710?$ C1;$ 0?7;38$ =7$ 3S14583$ =?3$ 700F::58G$ 39930=;$
182$ =?35:$ 58=3:10=578$ 58$ GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=;O$ L?5;$ :3QF5:32$ 9J3S5N5J5=H$ 182$ 18$ 7@38(4582$ =7$ 9:143$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$ QF3;=578;O$ EH$ 074@1:58G$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ :3;31:0?$ =30?85QF3;B$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ N30143$ 47:3$
1C1:3$79$=?3$:3QF5:3438=;$79$ 582F0=5R3$QF1J5=1=5R3$58=3:@:3=1=5R3$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$;F0?$1;$=?3$8332$
87=$=7$N3$N51;32$NH$3S5;=58G$=?37:53;$182$:3;31:0?O$W3803$=?3$GF5258G$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578$:3415832$1=$
1$?5G?$J3R3JB$;F0?$1;A$O"/($/)#$("#$'.&(.)/&$#00#'(2$#K>#),#+'#5$GM$2#+,*)$7/+/N#7#+($>)/'(,(,*+#)2$
ZRUNLQJRQJOREDOSURMHFWV"$

JFJ" 3+.'"+*".&$&"('5'%&$4+5"
"345(;=:F0=F:32$58=3:R53C;$C3:3$0?7;38$97:$21=1$G383:1=578B$2F3$=7$=?3$3S@J7:1=5R3$81=F:3$79$=?3$;=F2H$
182$ 3S03JJ38=$ 1003;;$ =7$ 58=3:R53C33;O$ !8=3:R53C33;$ C3:3$ ;3J30=32$ N1;32$ 78$ =?35:$ 3S@3:=5;3$ 182$
N10TG:7F82$ 79$ C7:T58G$ 78$ GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=;$ =7$ 38;F:3$ =?1=$ =?3H$ :3@:3;38=$ =?3$ =1:G3=32$ 58=3:R53C33;$
G:7F@$ Y<332H$ 182$ `:4:72$ *))-A%&'[O$ /003;;$ =7$ 21=1$ 58$ 97:4$ 79$ 4FJ=5@J3$ 5825R52F1J;$ 58$ ;3857:$
J3123:;?5@$ @7;5=578;$ C7:T58G$ 97:$ R1:57F;$ 4FJ=581=5781J;$ 7:$ @:793;;5781J$ ;3:R503$ 95:4;$ C1;$ G5R38$ 182$
3S033232$ 585=51J$ 3S@30=1=578;$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ =314O$ M:57:5=H$ C?5J3$ ;3J30=58G$ 58=3:R53C33;$ C1;$ ;3=$ 78$
QF1J5=HB$?1R58G$78JH$1$93C$NF=$=?3:397:3$47:3$@7C3:9FJ$58=3:R53C33;$:1=?3:$=?18$QF18=5=HO$

JFK" <%'L0'-'1$4+5"+*"(%+:5.'."$2'+%)"&5."O2'5+='5+-+()"
>3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 5;$ 0:F051JB$ P./&,(/(,F#$ )#2#/)'"$ 5#2,N+2$ ,+F/),/G&#$ +##5$ (*$ /&&*H$ 0*)$
0&#K,G,&,(ME$/+5$0*)$5#',2,*+A7/L,+N$(*$(/L#$>&/'#$/2$("#$)#2#/)'"$>)*'#22$>)*FHHGV$YK1;78$*))*A&-[O$
!823@38238=$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 7F=J3=$ N358G$ 1$ @33:(:3R53C32$ 07893:3803$ 7:$ U7F:81J$ =?3$ :5G7:$ 58$ =?3$
3S30F=578$79$:3;31:0?$?1;$=7$N3$;?7C8O$!8$@1:=50FJ1:$270=7:1J$:3;31:0?$1;T;$97:$1$:5G7:7F;B$;=:58G38=$
182$ 0J31:$ @:703;;$ 9:74$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ @:7NJ34$ 5238=59501=578$ 7R3:$ =?3$ 23;0:5@=578$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$
;3==58GB$:3;31:0?$QF3;=578;B$21=1$G383:1=578$182$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$1;$C3JJ$1;$=?3$3S30F=578$
182$ @:3;38=1=578$ 79$ 958258G;O$ X7:$ =?3$ 0782F0=$ 79$ =?5;$ ;=F2H$ 182$ GF5258G$ =?:7FG?$ =?3$ M?I$ :3;31:0?$
@:7U30=B$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 182$ @?3874387J7GH$ C3:3$ @:3(;3J30=32$ 19=3:$ 58R3;=5G1=58G$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$
QF3;=578;$ 182$ :3;31:0?$ ;3==58G$ G5R38$ =?3H$ 1:3$ N7=?$ 582F0=5R3$ 182$ =?35:$ 585=51J$ ;=3@;$ 1:3$ 1J47;=$
5238=501JO$ L?3;3$ 0?1:10=3:5;=50;$ 1JJ7C32$ 1$ @5J7=$ ;=F2H$ 182$ 23J1H$ 79$ =?3$ 239585=3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$
;3J30=578O$X7:$=?5;$;=F2H$N7=?$43=?72;$C3:3$58=3:@:3=32$1;$58=3:@:3=1=5R3$QF1J5=1=5R3$:3;31:0?$15458G$=7$
25;07R3:$ =?37:H$ YD:7F8232$ =?37:H[$ :3;@30=5R3JH$ 431858G$ 79$ J5R32$ 3S@3:53803;$ YM?3874387J7GH[O$ /$
=?5:2$ 43=?72$ 078;523:32$ 585=51JJH$ N358G$ 3=?87G:1@?H$ C1;$ 83GJ30=32$ 58$ =?3$ 31:JH$ ;=1G3$ 1;$ 87$
4FJ=581=5781J$ 7:G185V1=578$ :F8858G$ 1$ GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=$ C1;$ 1003;;5NJ3$ =7$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ =314$ 97:$ 9FJJ(=543$
7N;3:R1=578$182$58=3:R53C$@F:@7;3;O$
$
*URXQGHG WKHRU\ HYROYHG LQ WKH V ZLWK 7KH GLVFRYHU\ RI JURXQGHG WKHRU\ 6WUDWHJLHV IRU
TXDOLWDWLYHUHVHDUFK$YDJ1;3:$182$"=:1F;;$%+^'[O$!=$5;$DQLQGXFWLYHWKHRU\GLVFRYHU\PHWKRGRORJ\WKDW
CCCO3UN:4O074$

,+$

!""#$%&''(')*+$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
/&&*H2$ ("#$ )#2#/)'"#)$ (*$ 5#F#&*>$ /$ ("#*)#(,'/&$ /''*.+($ *0$ ("#$ N#+#)/&$ 0#/(.)#2$ *0$ ("#$ (*>,'E$ H",&#$
VLPXOWDQHRXVO\JURXQGLQJWKHDFFRXQWLQHPSLULFDOREVHUYDWLRQRIGDWD$YK1:=58$182$LF:83:$%+Z^A%&%[O$
!8$G:7F8232$=?37:HB$=?37:H$343:G3;$9:74$=?3$21=1$58$1$81=F:1J$;3==58Ge$5=$5;$DORJLFDOO\FRQVLVWHQWVHWRI
5/(/$'*&&#'(,*+$hG383:1=578i$DQGDQDO\VLVSURFHGXUHV DLPHGWR GHYHORSWKHRU\$Y6?1:41V$*))%A*&-[O$
QR"#+*7#+*&*N,'/&$ )#2#/)'"$ ,2$ ("#$ 2(.5M$ *0$ #22#+'#2Q$ YR18$ K1838$ %++'A%)[O$ M?3874387J7GH$ 5;$
07803:832$1N7F=$3S@3:53803;$58$?F418$J593e$QO#$'/+$*+&M$L+*H$H"/($H#$#K>#),#+'#Q$YWF;;3:JB$%+%,[O$
M?3874387J7GH$ 34@?1;5V3;$ 78$ F823:;=18258G$ =?3$ 3S@3:53803$ 79$ @37@J3$ 58R7JR32B$ C?3:3NH$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 1:3$ =?3$ 43=?72;$ 79$ @?5J7;7@?H$ Y\5J;78$ *))*[O$ M?3874387J7GH$ 1J;7$ ;=:3;;3;$ =?3$
81=F:3$79$?F418$3S@3:53803$182$=?3$431858G$=?1=$@37@J3$1:3$1==10?32$=7$=?35:$3S@3:53803;O$!8$7=?3:$
C7:2;B$@?3874387J7GH$5;$1N7F=$=?3$3S@3:53803$79$7=?3:;O$
$
L?3$ 4723$ 79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578$ 182$ 23;5G8$ 79$ 58=3:R53C$ QF3;=578;$ 5;$ 915:JH$ ;545J1:$ 97:$ N7=?$ :3;31:0?$
43=?72;$ 58$ =?3$ 31:JH$ ;=1G3B$ C5=?$ =?3$ 07:3$ 5;;F3$ N358G$ =?3$ G383:1=578$ 79$ :50?$ 182$ 915=?9FJ$ 21=1O$ L?3$
7NU30=5R3;$97:$21=1$181JH;5;$1:3$25993:38=B$3R38$=?7FG?$41:G581J$58$=?3$585=51J$@?1;3O$D:7F8232$=?37:H$
154;$=7$38QF5:3$182$;=1=3$?7C$10=7:;$58=3:@:3=$:31J5=HB$:1=?3:$=?18$=3;=58G$?H@7=?3;3;$Y"F221NH$*))^[$
182$ 5;$ =?3:3NH$ 47:3$ 1==38=5R3$ =7$ ?7C$ =?37:H$ 343:G3;$ 9:74$ ;FNU30=5R3$ 3S@3:53803;O$ M?3874387J7GH$
78$ =?3$ 7=?3:$ ;523$ 5;$ 47:3$ 07803:832$ 1N7F=$ =?3$ 5825R52F1J;$ 3S@3:53803$ Y"F221NH$ *))^e$ M1==78$
*))*A%)&[O$E7=?$43=?72;$1:3$074478JH$;338$1;$1@@:7@:51=3$97:$4181G3438=$;=F253;$ Y_?:50?$*))-e$
X382=$182$"10?;$*))Z[O$L1NJ3$%$N3J7C$G5R3;$18$582501=578$79$0:5=3:51$1G158;=$C?50?$G:7F8232$=?37:H$
182$ @?3874387J7GH$ 58$ =?5;$ ;=F2H$ C3:3$ 074@1:32O$ W7C3R3:$ =?3$ 0:5=3:51$ 41H$ ?31R5JH$ 23@382$ 78$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$ ;3==58G$ 182$ @:3(;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 182$ @7=38=51JJH$ 8332$ =7$ N3$ 47259532$ 97:$ 7=?3:$
;=F253;O$
;&>-'"E6$674@1:5;78$79$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$@?3874387J7GH$
\?1=$
>3;31:0?$
QF3;=578$

D:7F8232$L?37:H$
QO"/($("#*)M$#7#)N#2$0)*7$2M2(#7/(,'$
'*7>/)/(,F#$/+/&M2,2$,2$N)*.+5#5$,+$
0,#&5H*)L$2*$/2$(*$#K>&/,+$H"/($"/2$G##+$
/+5$,2$*G2#)F#5SQ$YM1==78$*))*A%,,[O$

M?3874387J7GH$
QO"/($,2$("#$7#/+,+NE$2().'(.)#E$/+5$#22#+'#$
*0$("#$&,F#5$#K>#),#+'#$*0$(",2$>"#+*7#+*+$
0*)$(",2$>#)2*+$*)$N)*.>$*0$>#*>&#SQ$YM1==78$
*))*A%,*[O$

>3@:3;38=1=578$
79$958258G;$

7KHRU\DERXWYK7:;3$182$>50?1:2;$
*))*A,^[O$

I1=1$
G383:1=578$

!8=3:R53C;B$7N;3:R58G$;7051J$58=3:10=578;$
NH$J5;=3858G$=7$C?1=$5897:418=;$;1H$1N7F=$
=?34;3JR3;$182$7=?3:;O$L?3$;3J30=578$79$
@1:=505@18=;$182$7=?3:$21=1$;7F:03;$5;$1$
9F80=578$79$343:G58G$?H@7=?3;3;B$=?3$
;14@J3$;5V3$1$9F80=578$79$=?37:3=501J$
074@J3=383;;$YE1T3:B$\F3;=$182$"=3:8$
%++*[O$
M:3;0:5N32$182$;H;=341=50$43=?72$79$
07258G$=?3$21=1$58=7$01=3G7:53;$182$
5238=59H58G$58=3::3J1=578;?5@;e$078=58F1J$
58=3:C31R58G$79$21=1$G383:1=578$182$21=1$
181JH;5;e$078;=:F0=578$79$1$=?37:H$9:74$
01=3G7:53;$182$58=3::3J1=578;?5@;$Y<332H$
182$`:4:72$*))-A%&&[O$
#7=$3S=38;5R3$J5=3:1=F:3$:3R53C$@:57:$=7$=?3$
;=F2H$T*+&MT$19=3:$=?37:H$5;$343:G58G$97:4$
=?3$21=1O$EF=$G:7F8232$=?37:H$5;$87$
3S0F;3$=7$5G87:3$J5=3:1=F:3$Y"F221NH$
*))^[O$
_S@3:53803$58$=?3$953J2$018$N3$18$
12R18=1G3B$?7C3R3:$5=$?1;$=7$N3$
25;=58GF5;?32$N3=C338$T87CJ32G3$182$
589JF38058G$18$58=3:R53C33$=?:7FG?$
T87CJ32G3$2F:58G$21=1$G383:1=578$YX382=$
182$"10?;$*))Z[O$

!8(23@=?$:39J30=5R3$23;0:5@=578$79$=?3$
Y3S@3:53803[$OOO$YK7:;3$182$>50?1:2;$
*))*A,^[O$
!8(23@=?B$F8;=:F0=F:32$J38G=?H$58=3:R53C;$
C?50?$1:3$47:3$;545J1:$=7$1$078R3:;1=578$
:1=?3:$=?18$1$=H@501J$58=3:R53C$=1JT58G$=?3$
58=3:R53C33$182$J5;=3858G$=?3$:3;31:0?3:$
Y<332H$182$`:4:72$*))-A%,+[O$L?3$
58=3:R53C33$182$=?3$:3;31:0?3:$79=38$C7:T$
=7G3=?3:$2F:58G$=?3$58=3:R53C$Q/)),F#$/($("#$
"#/)($*0$("#$7/((#)Q$YL3;0?$%++)A%&'[O$
"31:0?$97:$PHDQLQJRIXQLWV$=?1=$:39J30=$
R1:57F;$1;@30=;$79$=?3$3S@3:53803e$58=3G:1=578$
79$=?3$431858G$F85=;$58=7$1$W\SLFDO$
3S@3:53803$Y<332H$182$`:4:72$*))-A%&&[O$

I1=1$181JH;5;$

<5=3:1=F:3$
:3R53C$

E10TG:7F82$79$
=?3$:3;31:0?3:$

CCCO3UN:4O074$

&)$

>3R53C$79$@:793;;5781J$182$:3;31:0?$
J5=3:1=F:3$=7$@:3@1:3$97:$=?3$;=F2HO$L?3$970F;$
5;$=?3:3NH$@:57:$:3J3R18=$;=F253;e$
25;=58GF5;?3;$=?35:$23;5G8B$43=?727J7G53;B$
182$958258G;$YK7F;=1T3;$%++&A%%%[O$
L?3$:3;31:0?3:$018$?1R3$@3:;781J$
3S@3:53803$58$=?3$@?38743878$79$
58R3;=5G1=578B$C?5J3$N:7123858G$?5;$7C8$
F823:;=18258G$NH$=?3$3S@3:53803$79$7=?3:;$
=?3$:3;31:0?3:$018$=?18$G383:1J5V3$9:74$1$
58;523:$@3:;@30=5R3$TH"/($2*7#(",+N$,2$&,L#T$
Y<332H$182$`:4:72$*))-A%,+[O$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$

<#=-0%)-(*1#)%#&*#%*-">$

JFM" G5$'%C4'8"1+5.:1$"
"345(;=:F0=F:32$58=3:R53C;$1:3$97:$N7=?$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$@?3874387J7GH$=?3$47;=$074478$4723$
79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578O$ !8=3:R53C$ QF3;=578;$ =?3:397:3$ C3:3$ 01:39FJJH$ @?:1;32$ 1007:258G$ =7$ =?35:$
:3QF5:3438=;O$ L?3$ 31:JH$ ;=1G3$ 79$ 58=3:R53C58G$ 5;$ 915:JH$ ;545J1:$ 97:$ N7=?$ @:3(;3J30=32$ 43=?72;$ NH$
@?:1;58G$QF3;=578;$;F0?$1;$3OHDVHGHVFULEH\RXUH[SHULHQFH$III$$58$7:23:$=7$F897J2$=?3$953J2$79$58QF5:HO$
!8$ 078=58F1803$ @?3874387J7G501J$ 58=3:R53C58G$ =382;$ =7$ N3$ 251J7G501JB$ :1=?3:$ =?18$ 7N;3:R1=5781JB$ =?3$
431858G$ 79$ J5R32$ 3S@3:53803$ 5;$ 1$ :3;FJ=$ 79$ 07(0:31=578$ N3=C338$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ 182$ =?3$ :3;31:0?32$
Y\54@388H$182$D1;;$*)))[O$!8$25993:3803$=7$G:7F8232$=?37:HB$C?3:3$=?3$95:;=$58;=1803$79$58=3:R53C58G$
DLPV WR UHFRXQW WKH LQWHUYLHZHHV H[SHULHQFH YDJ1;3:$ 182$ "=:1F;;$ %+^'A'-('^[B$ C?5J3$ ;FN;3QF38=$
58=3:R53C;$ 2F:58G$ =?37:3=501J$ ;14@J58G$ C5JJ$ N3$ 47:3$ 970F;32$ 182$ =15J7:32$ =7$ =?3$ 343:G58G$ =?37:HO$ #7$
41==3:$ C?1=$ ;=1G3$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ N7=?$ 43=?72;$ 79$ @?3874387J7GH$ 182$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ :3QF5:3$
58=3:R53C$ QF3;=578;B$ C?50?$ 27$ 87=$ 54@7;3$ 18H$ R53C$ 79$ =?3$ @?38743878$ F823:$ 58R3;=5G1=578$ =7$ =?3$
58=3:R53C33O$
$
M5J7=$58=3:R53C;$Y&[$C3:3$0782F0=32B$58(@3:;78$182$R51$=3J3@?783O$"@3051J$34@?1;5;$C1;$95:;=JH$@F=$78$
87=$N51;58G$=?3$58=3:R53C33O$7KHUHVHDUFKHUVUROHLVWKHUHE\VHHQDVGLVWDQWH[SHUW$YDJ1;3:$%++*[$7:$
FRASURGXFHU Y6?1:41V$ %++-[$ 97:$ G:7F8232$ =?37:HB$ C?5J3$ 97:$ @?3874387J7GH$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ 5;$
;F@@7;32$ =7$ ;F;@382$ 18H$ @:3078035R32$ 87=578;$ 1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$ @3:;781J$ 3S@3:53803;$ FDOOHG EUDFNHWLQJ
YR18$K1838$%++'A%'-[O$"30782JHB$C?38$0782F0=58G$58=3:R53C;B$1==38=578$C1;$@152$=7$0?18G3;$=?:7FG?$
:3C7:258G$ 182$ :3(;3QF38058G$ 79$ QF3;=578;$ 2F:58G$ =?3$ 58=3:R53C$ 1;$ =?5;$ 018$ J312$ =7$ @:7NJ34;$ C?38$
074@1:58G$ :3;@78;3;$ YM1==78$ *))*A,&+[O$ !8=3:R53C$ QF3;=578;$ C3:3$ 01:39FJJH$ @?:1;32B$ ;F0?$ 1;A$
3OHDVHGHVFULEHHIIHFWVUHODWHGWRFXOWXUH\RXH[SHULHQFHGZKLOHZRUNLQJRQJOREDOSURMHFWV"$

JFN" <%'L&5&-)040"+*"45$'%C4'80"
L?3$ F=47;=$ 54@7:=18=$ 0:5=3:51$ 97:$ 18H$ :3;31:0?$ 5;$ =?3$ 4318;$ 79$ 21=1$ 181JH;5;O$ !8$ =?5;$ 01;3$ 1;$ N7=?$
43=?72;$ 1:3$ 79$ 582F0=5R3$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ 81=F:3B$ 01=3G7:53;$ C5JJ$ 343:G3$ 9:74$ 21=1$ YK7:;3$ 182$ >50?1:2;$
*))*A%,&[O$ D:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 5;$ =?3:3NH$ 47:3$ 1==38=5R3$ =7$ ?7C$ =?37:H$ 018$ 343:G3$ 9:74$ ;FNU30=5R3$
H[SHULHQFHV ZKLOH SKHQRPHQRORJ\ LV PRUH FRQFHUQHG DERXW WKH LQGLYLGXDOV H[SHULHQFH Y"F221NH$
*))^[O$$
$
!8$ =?3$ 95:;=$ ;=3@B$ 58=3:R53C$ ;F441:53;$ C3:3$ C:5==38$ 5443251=3JH$ 19=3:$ 310?$ 58=3:R53C$ Yc58$ *)),A'^e$
K5J3;$ 182$ WFN3:4188$ %++&[B$ C?5J3$ 1F257$ :307:258G;$ C3:3$ R3:N1=54$ =:18;0:5N32$ 182$ 181JH;32$ 58$
;3QF3803O$X7JJ7C58G$=7$=?5;B$=?3$58=3:R53C;$C3:3$181JH;32$@:57:$=7$0782F0=58G$=?3$83S=$58=3:R53CO$L?5;$
1JJ7C32$=?3$5807:@7:1=578$79$958258G;B$12UF;=438=;$79$QF3;=578;$3OGO$59$QF3;=578;$C3:3$87=$F823:;=772$
58$ 078;30F=5R3$ 58=3:R53C;O$ L?3$ 0H0J3$ 79$ 21=1$ G383:1=578;$ 182$ 181JH;5;$ C1;$ 58(J583$ C5=?$ G:7F8232$
=?37:HB$ 58$ 7=?3:$ C7:2;$ 310?$ 58=3:R53C$ C1;$ 181JH;32$ N397:3$ =?3$ 97JJ7C58G$ C1;$ 0782F0=32O$ L?5;$
1@@:710?$ ;33432$ N3$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ 58$ =?3$ G5R38$ :3;31:0?$ ;3==58G$ N358G$ 3S@J7:1=5R3B$ C?5J3$ 1JJ7C58G$ =7$
12UF;=$25:30=578$=?:7FG?7F=$:3;31:0?$0782F0=O$
$
L?3$21=1$G383:1=32$C1;$58$=?3$95:;=$@1;;$DQDO\VHGE\*>#+$'*5,+N97JJ7C58G$G:7F8232$=?37:HB$C?3:3$
=?3$:3;31:0?3:$9582;$1;$418H$01=3G7:53;$1;$@7;;5NJ3$NH$J1N3JJ58G$=?3$=3S=$79$310?$58=3:R53C$1;$2395832$
NH$ DJ1;3:$ Y%++*A,Z[O$ /$ ;30782$ @1;;$ =?:7FG?$ =?3$ 21=1$ C1;$ F823:=1T38$ 58$ 1007:21803$ =7$
@?3874387J7GH$ 1@@:710?$ NH$ ;31:0?58G$ 97:$ =?3$ PHDQLQJ RI XQLWV$ :39J30=58G$ R1:57F;$ 1;@30=;$ 79$ =?3$
58=3:R53C33;$3S@3:53803$Y<332H$182$`:4:72$*))-A%&&[O$L7$EUDFNHW$7C8$3S@3:53803$182$T87CJ32G3$
5;$ =?3:3NH$ 0:F051JB$ 58$ 7:23:$ =7$ F823:;=182$ =?3$ 21=1$ 07JJ30=32B$ ;F0?$ 1;$ 3S@3:53803$ 79$ =?3$ @1:=505@18=;$
YM1==78$*))*A&Z-[O$E:10T3=58G$C1;$10?53R32$NH$C:5=58G$27C8$1JJ$:3J1=32$3S@3:53803;$79$=?3$:3;31:0?3:$
@:57:$=7$0782F0=58G$=?3$58=3:R53CO$L?F;B$=?3$:3;31:0?3:$018$38=3:$=?3$58=3:R53C$C5=?7F=$@:3;F@@7;5=578$
1;$ =?3H$ C3:3$ @F=$ 1;523$ =7$ 38;F:3$ =?1=$ =?3$ T().#T$ @?38743878$ C1;$ :3R31J32$ YK7:;3$ 182$ >50?1:2;$
*))*A&'[O$ 7KLV DOORZHG VHJUHJDWLQJ EHWZHHQ WKH UHVHDUFKHUV H[SHULHQFH ZKLFK LV EHQHILFLDO IRU
F823:;=18258G$=?3$:3;31:0?$078=3S=$182$=?3$343:G58G$958258G;$9:74$=?3$21=1$G383:1=32O$
$
L1NJ3$ *$ 074@1:3;$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 182$ @?3874387J7GH$ :3G1:258GA$ \?38$ 273;$ 1N;=:10=578$ 700F:g$
\?3:3$273;$1N;=:10=578$700F:g$W7C$5;$1N;=:10=578$2783g$182$\?1=$5;$=?3$G71J$79$1N;=:10=578g$
$
#3S=$=7$=?3$43=?727J7G501J$QF3;=578;$=?3$958258G;$G15832$9:74$=?3$@:3(181JH;5;$79$=?3$G383:1=32$21=1$
?3J@$ =7$ 9F:=?3:$ F823:;=182$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ ;3==58G$ 182$ 5=;$ 078=3S=O$ _43:G58G$ 958258G;$ :3@7:=32$ =7$ 182$
R3:59532$NH$N7=?$1478G;=$;0?7J1:;$182$58$=?3$@:10=5=5783:$0744F85=H$H53J2$=7$N3$58;5G?=9FJO$!8$1225=578$
=?3$:3;31:0?3:$9145J51:5V32$?54;3J9$C5=?$N7=?$@?3874387J7G501J$182$G:7F8232$=?37:H$21=1$181JH;5;$5=;$
@:5805@J3;$182$J545=1=578;O$
CCCO3UN:4O074$

&%$

!""#$%&''(')*+$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
;&>-'"H6$/N;=:10=578$79$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$@?3874387J7GH$127@=32$9:74$K7:;3$j$>50?1:2;$Y*))*[$
/N;=:10=578$
\?38$

D:7F8232$L?37:H$
/N;=:10=578$5;$9:74$=?3$21=1$NF=$018$N3$
5897:432$NH$@:3R57F;JH$23:5R32$=?37:53;O$

M?3874387J7GH$
#7=$F8=5J$783$?1;$=?3$21=1A$M:3R57F;$5231;$182$
T87CJ32G3$1:3$N:10T3=32O$

\?3:3$

61=3G7:53;$23:5R32$9:74$21=1$Y7N;3:R1=578$
7:$J583(NH(J583$181JH;5;$79$=3S=[e$078;=18=$
074@1:5;78$C5=?$7=?3:$;5=F1=578;$7:$;3==58G;O$

L?343;$182$431858G;$58$1007F8=;B$=3S=;O$

W7C$

L?37:3=501J$;38;5=5R5=He$;33T58G$07803@=;$
182$=?35:$25438;578;e$7@38$07258GB$
25438;5781J5V58GB$4347$C:5=58GB$
251G:14458GO$

I33@$5443:;578B$970F;B$=?7:7FG?$:31258GO$

\?1=$

L7$5238=59H$1$07:3$01=3G7:H$182$=?37:H$
G:7F8232$58$=?3$21=1O$

L7$23;0:5N3$=?3$3;;3803$79$1$@?38743878O$

JFP" ,'-&)'."0'-'1$4+5"+*"(%+:5.'."$2'+%)"&0"&OO%+O%4&$'"%'0'&%12"='$2+."
L?3$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ ?3J@32$ 58$ @1:=50FJ1:$ 2F:58G$ =?3$ @:703;;$ 79$ 21=1$
G383:1=578$ 182$ 21=1$ @:3(181JH;5;$ 79$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2H$ =7$ 230523$ 78$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ 182$ ;F5=1NJ3$
:3;31:0?$43=?72O$D:7F8232$=?37:H$=?3:3NH$0:H;=1JJ5V32$=7$N3$=?3$47:3$ ;F5=1NJ3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$97:$
=?5;$ M?I$ :3;31:0?$ @:7U30=O$ L?3$ :31;78;$ 97:$ 0?77;58G$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 7R3:$ @?3874387J7GH$ 1:3$
25;0F;;32$58$=?3$97JJ7C58GO$
$
I1=1$G383:1=578$;?7C32$=?1=$58=3:R53C33;$@:7R5232$1225=5781J$25:30=$182$5825:30=$21=1$83S=$=7$=?3$21=1$
G1=?3:32$ =?:7FG?$ ;345(;=:F0=F:32$ 58=3:R53C;B$ =?3$ 4158$ ;7F:03$ 79$ 21=1O$ L?5;$ 580JF232$ @:7U30=$
270F438=1=578;$ 7:$ :3@7:=;$ Y25:30=[$ 7:$ :393:3803;$ Y5825:30=[$ @:7R5232$ NH$ =?3$ 58=3:R53C33B$ 1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$
270F438=;$ 182$ 5897:41=578$ :3=:53R32$ NH$ :3;31:0?58G$ =?3$ 7:G185V1=578B$ @:7U30=B$ 182$ =?3$ 58=3:R53C33$
Y5825:30=[O$ L?5;$ 1@@31:32$ =7$ N38395=$ =?3$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 43=?72B$ C?50?$ 5893:;$ 9:74$ J5;=3858GB$
7N;3:R1=578;B$ :31258G;$ 7:$ 783;$ @1;=$ 3S@3:53803;$ YE1T3:B$ \F3;=$ 182$ "=3:8$ %++*[O$ !8$ 7=?3:$ C7:2;$
3R3:H=?58G$5;$21=1$=7$=?3$ G:7F8232$=?37:5;=$ Y"=3:8B$ /JJ38$182$K7SJ3H$%+Z*[B$1JJ7C58G$ =?3$9J3S5N5J5=H$79$
F=5J5V58G$ 25993:38=$ 21=1$ ;7F:03;O$ M?3874387J7GH$ 78$ =?3$ 7=?3:$ ?182$ 078038=:1=3;$ 78$ ?1R58G$
58=3:R53C33;B$C?50?$3S@3:538032$=?3$39930=;$182$=?35:$58=3:10=578;$78$GJ7N1J$@:7U30=;$1;$78JH$J3G5=541=3$
;7F:03$79$21=1$YE1T3:B$\F3;=$182$"=3:8$%++*[O$L?3$;=:38G=?$79$G:7F8232$=?37:H$5;$=?3$074N581=578$79$
=?3$23@=?$ 79$58QF5:H$182$=?3$F854@15:32$58=3:@J1H$ 79$=?37:3=501J$ 182$ 34@5:501J$21=1$ YD5N;78B$D:3G7:H$
182$>7N58;78$*))-[O$_R38$=?7FG?$C3$C3:3$1C1:3$79$=?3;3$25993:3803;$N3=C338$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$
@?3874387J7GH$@:57:$ 34N1:T58G$ =?5;$;=F2HB$ C3$252$87=$ 18=505@1=3$;F0?$;F@@7:=$182$7@3883;;$79$=?3$
LQWHUYLHZHHV$58$18;C3:58G$=?3$QF3;=578;$@7;32$58$=?3$95:;=$58;=1803O$
$
L?3$;14@J58G$9F:=?3:$;FGG3;=32$1@@JH58G$=?3$G:7F8232$=?37:H$43=?72B$G5R38$=?1=$1J47;=$1JJ$01:39FJJH$
;3J30=32$ 58=3:R53C33;$ 1G:332$ =7$ @1:=505@1=3B$ ?1R58G$ ,Z$ 58=3:R53C33;$ =7$ 21=3O$ KFJ=5@J3$ 58=3:R53C33;$
3R38$ :3074438232$ 07JJ31GF3;$ C5=?$ 1$ ;545J1:$ N10TG:7F82$ 182$ 3S@3:53803$ =7$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ =314$ 97:$
=?5;$;=F2H$@:7R5258G$1$;41JJ$@77J$79$QF1J5=H$21=1$;7F:03;O$L?5;$;F@@7:=32$=?3$1:GF438=$7KHVHOHFWLRQ
*0$ >/)(,',>/+(2$ /+5$ *("#)$ 5/(/$ 2*.)'#2$ ,2E$ ("#)#0*)#E$ /$ 0.+'(,*+$ *0$ #7#)N,+N$ "M>*("#2#2$ /+5$ ("#$
VDPSOH VL]H D IXQFWLRQ RI WKHRUHWLFDO FRPSOHWHQHVV YE1T3:B$ \F3;=$ 182$ "=3:8$ %++*[O$ L?5;$ 5;$ 58$
078=:1;=$=7$=?3$@?3874387J7GH$43=?72$C?3:3$=?3$;14@J3$;5V3$5;$T3@=$78$@F:@7;3$;41JJO$K7:37R3:$=?3$
:3QF5:3438=$79$@?3874387J7GH$U758=$07JJ1N7:1=578$182$:3@31=32$58=3:R53C;$7R3:$=543$1@@31:32$=7$N3$
87=$ 931;5NJ3$ 2F3$ =7$ =543$ 182$ 1003;;$ J545=1=578;O$ <545=1=578;$ 58$ =543$ 700F::32$ N301F;3$ 87=$ 1JJ$
58=3:R53C33;$ 07FJ2$ 07445=$ =7$ 9F:=?3:$ 58=3:R53C;$ 182$ 58=3:R53C33;$ 5238=59532$ C3:3$ @:32745818=JH$
5823@38238=$ 5825R52F1J;$ :1=?3:$ =?18$ G:7F@;O$ 7KLV GHYHORSPHQW FRXOGQW EH SUHGLFWHG DV WKH LQLWLDO
@J18858G$C1;$=7$0782F0=$=C7$=7$=?:33$58(23@=?$J78G5=F2581J$01;3$;=F253;$58$18$7:G185V1=5781J$;3==58GO$
$
IF:58G$ =?3$ 21=1$ @:3(181JH;5;$ 79$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2H$ =C7$ 47:3$ 1;@30=;$ F823:J5832$ =?3$ 2305;578$ =7$ 0?77;3$
G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 7R3:$ @?3874387J7GHO$ X5:;=JH$ =?3$ 05:0F4;=1803$ =?1=$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ @:7R523;$ 0J31:$
GF523J583;$ 97:$ N7=?$ =?3$ 0782F0=$ 79$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 182$ 58=3:@:3=1=578$ 79$ =?3$ :3;FJ=;$ 5;$ R3:H$ ?3J@9FJ$ 97:$ 1$
87R503$:3;31:0?3:$ YX382=$182$"10?;$*))Ze$6?1:41V$ *))%[O$I3;@5=3$=?3$3S@3:53803$182$;3857:5=H$79$
=C7$;F@3:R5;7:;$C5=?$N7=?$43=?72;B$=?3$0J31:$GF523J583;$79$G:7F8232$=?37:H$C3:3$47:3$1@@31J58G$182$
074@1=5NJ3$=?18$ =?3$ R1GF3$2395832$58;=:F0=578;$ 79$@?3874387J7GH$ =7$=?3$ 0?539$58R3;=5G1=7:$182$M?I$
0182521=3O$ !8$ 910=$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 273;$ 87=$ :3JH$ 78$ 23;0:5@=5R3$ 1007F8=;$ 074@1:32$ =7$
@?3874387J7GH$182$5=$5;$47:3$9J3S5NJ3$YX382=$182$"10?;$*))Z[O$"30782JHB$=?3$1@@:710?$79$078;=18=$

CCCO3UN:4O074$

&*$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$

<#=-0%)-(*1#)%#&*#%*-">$

074@1:5;78B$23R3J7@438=$79$343:G58G$=?343;$97JJ7C32$NH$@F:@7;39FJ$21=1$G383:1=578$97:$=?37:3=501J$
;14@J58G$1;$;FGG3;=32$NH$G:7F8232$=?37:HO$$
$
<77T58G$ 97:$ ;@305950$ 21=1B$ 97:$ ;@305950$ @F:@7;3;$ 1@@31:32$ =7$ N3$ 47:3$ @:745;58G$ =7$ 23:5R3$ 915=?9FJ$
:3;FJ=;O$ 7KHRUHWLFDO VDPSOLQJ LV WKH >)*'#22$ *0$ 5/(/$ '*&&#'(,*+$ UN#+#)/(,*+V$ 0*)$ N#+#)/(,+N$ ("#*)M$
H"#)#GM$ ("#$ /+/&M2($ J*,+(&M$ '*&&#'(2E$ '*5#2E$ /+5$ /+/&M2#2$ ",2$ 5/(/$ /+5$ 5#',5#2$ H"/($ 5/(/$ (*$ '*&&#'($
QH[WDQGZKHUHWRILQGWKHPLQRUGHUWRGHYHORSKLVWKHRU\DVLWHPHUJHV$YDJ1;3:$%+'ZA,^[O$!8$1225=578$
=?5;$ 5;$ 1J5G832$ C5=?$ =?3$ 7R3:1JJ$ :3;31:0?$ ;3==58G$ 182$ =?3$ 1R15J1NJ3$ @77J$ 79$ 21=1$ ;7F:03;B$ ?1R58G$
8F43:7F;$ VLJQLILFDQW$ 5825R52F1J;$ Y58=3:R53C33;[$ ;?1:58G$ =?35:$ 3S@3:53803;$ 79$ 4181G58G$ 182$ C7:T58G$
78$GJ7N1J$@:7U30=;O$
$
>3;FJ=;$23@50=32$2F:58G$=?3$@:3(181JH;5;$79$=?3$@5J7=$;=F2H$3S@J7:58G$=?3$39930=;$182$5=;$58=3:10=578$78$
GJ7N1J$@:7U30=;$:395832$=?3$:3;31:0?$25:30=578B$C?5J3$1=$=?3$;143$=543$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3;$C3:3$9F:=?3:$
23=15J32O$ L?3;3$ :3;FJ=;$ ;FGG3;=32$ 78$ NF5J258G$ F@$ =?3$ 343:G58G$ =?343;$ 182$ 9F:=?3:$ 23=15J$ 182$ R3:59H$
=?34$ 58$ @:7033258G$ 58=3:R53C33;$ =5JJ$ =?37:3=501J$ ;1=F:1=578$ 5;$ :310?32O$ L?3$ 1J5G8438=$ N3=C338$ =?3$
958258G;$79$=?3$21=1$@:3(1QDO\VLVDWKHRU\DERXW$182$=?3$343:G58G$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3$1$=?37:H$79$
39930=;$ 54@10=58G$ GJ7N1J$ @:7U30=;B$ ;FGG3;=32$ =7$ 1@@JH$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 7R3:$ @?3874387J7GH$ =7$ =?5;$
;=F2HO$ D:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 154;$ =7$ 18;C3:$ =?3$ ZKDW$ QF3;=578;$ 58$ =?3$ 3S@J7:1=5R3$ =?37:H$ 23R3J7@438=$
@?1;3$182$=?3$KRZ$QF3;=578;$58$=?3$=?37:H$:39583438=$@?1;3$YK7:;3$182$>50?1:2;$*))*A,^[O$
$
L?3$ GHOD\HG$ 2305;578$ 78$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ 182$ ;F5=1NJ3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ?3J@32$ NH$ =1T58G$
078;523:1=578;$ 58=7$ 1007F8=$ 1;$ ?5G?J5G?=32$ 1N7R3B$ C?50?$ 3R7JR32$ 2F:58G$ =?3$ ;=F2H$ 182$ C3:3$ 87=$
18=505@1=32$@:57:$=7$074438058G$=?3$;=F2HO$678;3QF38=JH$5=$C7FJ2$87=$?1R3$N338$@7;;5NJ3$=7$078;523:$
=?34$ NH$ 1@@JH58G$ =?3$ WUDGLWLRQDO$ 1@@:710?$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578O$ !8$ =?3$ ;143$ C1H$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$ 7NU30=5R3$ 9F:=?3:$ 23R3J7@32$ 182$ =?3$ ;07@3$ 0:H;=1JJ5V32$ =?:7FG?7F=$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2H$ 0782F0=B$
C?5J3$;54FJ=1837F;JH$23:5R58G$95:;=$:3;FJ=;$97:$25;0F;;578$182$:3=:53R58G$9332N10TO$
$
/$074N581=578$79$@?3874387J7GH$182$G:7F8232$=?37:H$1;$;FGG3;=32$NH$/883JJ;$Y*))^[$7:$\5J;78$182$
WF=0?58;78$ Y%++%[$ C1;$ 078;523:32O$ W7C3R3:$ J545=1=578;$ 58$ =3:4;$ 79$ =543$ 182$ :3;7F:03;$ :15;32$
078;=:158=;$79$931;5N5J5=HO$!8$1225=578$1$4FJ=5(43=?72$1@@:710?$C7FJ2$87=$38;F:3$1$?5G?3:$100F:10H$182$
:3J3R1803$79$:3;FJ=;O$
$
!8$ ;F441:H$ =?3$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ ?3J@32$ 95:;=JH$ =7$ G158$ 1$ @:797F82$
F823:;=18258G$79$G:7F8232$=?37:H$182$@?3874387J7GHB$=?35:$0?1:10=3:5;=50;$182$1@@J501=578;$@:57:$=7$
2305258G$78$783$43=?72O$<RXZLOOQHHGWRHQVXUHWKDW\RXUPHWKRGVRIWKHGDWDJHQHUDWLRQDQG\RXU
UHVHDUFK SUDFWLFH LQ JHQHUDO HQDEOH \RX WR DGRSW WKH DSSURSULDWH IRUPV RI GDWD DQDO\VLV KHUH
YK1;78$ *))*A%'Z[ 8QOLNH WKH WUDGLWLRQDO DSSURDFK UHTXLUHPHQWV RI WKH VWXG\ ZHUH WDNHQ LQWR
1007F8=$ 182$ 122:3;;32$ NH$ ;3J30=58G$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 1;$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72O$
"30782JH$0782F0=58G$1$@5J7=$;=F2HB$580JF258G$21=1$G383:1=578$182$21=1$@:3(181JH;5;$@:7R5232$58;5G?=$=7$
QF1J5=HB$ :3@:3;38=1=578$ 182$ :3J3R1803$ 79$ @:57:5$ :3;FJ=;O$ L:15J58G$ N7=?$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ @:7R3;$ =7$ N3$
N38395051J$NH$3S@3:538058G$=?3$21=1$G383:1=578$182$G3==58G$1$933J58G$97:$=?3$21=1B$@:7;@30=5R3$:3;FJ=;$
1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ ;3==58GO$ K7:37R3:$ 5=$ 1JJ7C;$ =7$ N3==3:$ 1:GF3$ 182$ UF;=59H$ =?3$ ;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$
43=?72$ G5R38$ =?3$ G15832$ 3S@3:53803$ C5=?$ N7=?$ 58$ @1:=50FJ1:$ 5=;$ ;F5=1N5J5=H$ 7:$ F8;F5=1N5J5=H$ =7$ =?5;$ 21=1$
;3=B$ :3;@30=5R3JHO$ <1;=JH$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ G15832$ =543$ 182$ 9J3S5N5J5=H$ =7$ :39583$ 182$ 9F:=?3:$ :32F03$ =?3$
UHVHDUFK VFRSH DV ZHOO DV DGGUHVV VWDNHKROGHUV UHTXLUHPHQWV PRUH DSSURSULDWHO\ ZLWKRXW EHLQJ
J545=32$ NH$ 1$ @:3(2395832$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72O$ !8$ 074@1:5;78$ =7$ =?3$ WUDGLWLRQDO$ 1@@:710?B$ =?3$ @:7@7;32$
;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 1JJ7C32$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ =7$ G3=$ 9145J51:$ C5=?$ =?3$
:3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ 1=$ =?3$ ;143$ =543$ 1;$ 0782F0=58G$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2HO$ L?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2H$ =?3:3NH$ 1JJ7C32$
=3;=58G$ 79$ =?3$ @:3(;3J30=32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ F@78$ =?35:$ 1@@:7@:51=383;;B$ C?5J3$ 23:5R58G$ =?3$ 95:;=$
:3;FJ=;O$

JFT" !00+14&$'.">'5'*4$0"&5."*:%$2'%"5+$'0"
L?3$0?539$58R3;=5G1=7:$C1;$F8=:15832$58$0782F0=58G$58=3:R53C;$9:74$18$10123450$@3:;@30=5R3$C?5J3$58$
?5;$@:793;;5781J$N10TG:7F82$?3$?12$233@$3S@3:53803$07@58G$C5=?$5825R52F1J;$182$7:G185V1=578;$58$182$
9:74$ 4FJ=5@J3$ 182$ 25R3:;3$ 0FJ=F:1J$ ;3==58G;O$ L?:7FG?7F=$ =?3$ 58=3:R53C$ 0782F0=$ ?3$ 10QF5:32$ 9F:=?3:$
274158$ T87CJ32G3$ C?50?$ C1;$ NF5J2$ F@$ =7$ 54@:7R3$ ?5;$ ;T5JJ;$ 58$ 58=3:R53C58G$ ;F0?$ 1;$ ?7C$ =7$ 58=3:10=$
C5=?$=?3$58=3:R53C33$7:$=?3$25993:38=$4723;$79$58=3:R53C$0782F0=$3OGO$58(@3:;78B$=3J3@?783$7:$R5237$182$
5=;$1@@:7@:51=383;;O$L?3;3$:31;78;$1:3$58(J583$C5=?$3S@3:53803$23;0:5N32$58$J5=3:1=F:3$Y3OGO$KH3:;$182$
#3C418$*))'[O$!=$07FJ2$N3$1:GF32$=?1=$1$47:3$@:305;3$@:3@1:1=578$182$58=:72F0=578$=7$QF1J5=1=5R3$21=1$
G383:1=578$C7FJ2$?1R3$N338$1@@:7@:51=3$1;$23;0:5N32$NH$=?3$3S14@J3;$79$K1;78$Y*))*[O$W7C;73R3:$
CCCO3UN:4O074$

&,$

!""#$%&''(')*+$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
=?3$N38395=;$79$G383:1=58G$21=1$182$G15858G$3S@3:53803$58$QF1J5=1=5R3$58=3:R53C58G$7F=C35G?$3R38$C?38$
=?3:3$ C1;$ 1$ :5;T$ 58$ G383:1=58G$ 21=1$ 87=$ F;31NJ3$ 97:$ 181JH;5;O$ !8$ 1225=578$ G383:1=58G$ 21=1$ ?3J@32$ =7$
N3==3:$F823:;=182$=?3$953J2$182$G158$;FNU30=$41==3:$3S@3:=5;3O$
$
L?3$ F=5J5V1=578$ 79$ 074@F=3:(1;;5;=32$ QF1J5=1=5R3$ 21=1$ 181JH;5;$ ;79=C1:3$ Y6/kI/"[$ 58$ =?5;$ 01;3$ =?3$
#l5R7Z$;79=C1:3$@:7R5232$58R1JF1NJ3$1;;5;=1803$=7$01@=F:3B$;193$182$074@1:3$21=1$58$074@1:5;78$=7$
WKHROG(IDVKLRQHGDQGPDQXDOZD\RIFDUGVDQGSRVW(5=;$7:$4FJ=5@J3$;@:312;?33=;O$L?5;$5;$2F3$=7$=?3$
910=$ =?1=$ N7=?$ 43=?72;$ 79$ @?3874387J7GH$ 182$ G:7F8232$ =?37:H$ 018$ N3$ 31;5JH$ 074@1:32$ 182$
FRQWUDVWHG,QDGGLWLRQ&$4'$6DOVRDOORZVPXOWLSOHFRGHUVHQVXULQJLQWHUFRGHUUHOLDELOLW\ZKLFKLV
187=?3:$N38395=O$ /$@7=38=51J$545=1=578$ =7$ N3$=1T38$58=7$ 1007F8=$5;$=?3$=543$:3QF5:32$=7$9145J51:5V3$ C5=?$
=?3$6/kI/"$@10T1G3$NF=$=?5;$5;$1J;7$=?3$01;3$97:$418F1J$1@@:710?O$

KF" ,401:004+5"+*".'-&)'."%'0'&%12"='$2+."0'-'1$4+5"
L543$182$23J5R3:H$79$:3;FJ=;$1;$C3JJ$1;$:5G7:$182$:3J3R1803$:34158$=7$N3$=?3$07:3$910=7:;$97:$:3;31:0?$
@:7U30=;$ 2:5R38$ NH$ ;=1T3?7J23:;B$ ;F@3:R5;7:;$ 182$ =?3$ 38G1G32$ NF;583;;O$ 8OWLPDWHO\ ZKDW \RX GR
7.2($ 5#>#+5$ .>*+$ ("#$ H/M$ M*.$ "/F#$ 0)/7#5$ M*.)$ )#2#/)'"$ P.#2(,*+2E$ ("#$ >",&*2*>",'/&$ /+5$
7#("*5*&*N,'/&$>*2(.)#$H",'"$("#M$#+'/>2.&/(#E$("#$ H/M$M*.$"/F#$5#2,N+#5$M*.)$>)*J#'($(*$2.>>*)($
("#2#E$/+5$("#$)#/&,(,#2$*0$("#$)#2#/)'"$>)*'#22$("/($M*.$"/F#$>.)2.#5$YK1;78$*))*A*),[O$!8$078=:1;=$
=7$ =?3$ F:G380H$ 79$ @:7U30=$ 074@J3=578B$ @1=53803$ ?3J@;$ :3;31:0?3:;$ =7$ 23:5R3$ :5G7:7F;$ 182$ @7=38=51J$
:3J3R18=$ :3;FJ=;$ 58$ :3;31:0?O$ L?3$ @:7@7;32$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 381NJ3;$
:3;31:0?3:$ =7$ 10?53R3$ =?5;$ NH$ 1=$ 95:;=$ :3R53C58G$ @7=38=51J$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 97JJ7C32$ NH$ 21=1$
G383:1=578$ 182$ @:3(181JH;5;$ 79$ =?3$ @5J7=$ ;=F2HB$ N397:3$ ;FN;3QF38=JH$ ;3J30=58G$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$
:3;31:0?$ 43=?72O$ L?5;$ 100744721=3;$ 58$ @1:=50FJ1:$ =?3$ 05:0F4;=1803;$ =?1=$ :3;31:0?$ QF3;=578;$ 182$
7NU30=5R3;$ 23R3J7@32$ 7R3:$ =543$ 45G?=$ 3R38$ 0?18G3$ 58$ =?3$ 585=51J$ @?1;3$ 79$ :3;31:0?$ @:7U30=;O$ `8$ =?3$
7=?3:$?182$=?3$:3;31:0?$;3==58G$;7J525953;$182$234182;$3R7JR32$2F:58G$=?3$0782F0=$79$1$@5J7=$;=F2HO$/=$
=?3$;143$=543B$47:3$:1@52$23R3J7@438=$79$;F5=1NJ3$QF3;=578;$182$=?3$38G1G3438=$C5=?$=?3$:3;31:0?$
@1:=83:;B$4158=158;$=?35:$58=3:3;=$182$07445=438=$=7$=?3$;=F2HO$
$
/2R18=1G3;$79$=?3$@:7@7;32$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$1:3$8F43:7F;O$!=$GF523;$
=?3$ :3;31:0?3:B$ C?5J3$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ 1=$ =?3$ ;143$ =543$ 3S@J7:3;$ 01@1N5J5=53;$ 79$ R1:57F;$ :3;31:0?$
43=?72;$182$=?35:$J545=1=578;$2F:58G$=?3$:3;31:0?$43=?72$@:3(;3J30=578$182$=?3$@5J7=$;=F2HO$!8$1225=578$
=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$43=?72$;3J30=578$25;0J7;3;$F897:3;338$@:7;@30=;$97:$21=1$181JH;5;O$
K7:37R3:$3R38$=?7FG?$87=$25:30=JH$:3J1=32$=7$=?3$:3;31:0?$7NU30=5R3$=?3$;=:1=3GH$97:$23J1H32$:3;31:0?$
43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ @:7R523;$ 1$ 078=58F7F;$ =:15858G$ 97:$ =?3$ :3;31:0?3:$ 79$ 074@1:58G$ 182$ 078=:1;=58G$
R1:57F;$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 79$ ;545J1:$ 81=F:3O$ L?5;$ ?3J@;$ =7$ T87C$ =?3$ 25993:3803;$ N3=C338$ ;545J1:$
:3;31:0?$ 43=?72;B$ =?35:$ 1@@J501=578B$ J545=1=578;B$ 7N;=10J3;$ 182$ @:3;38=1=578$ 79$ :3;FJ=;O$ L?5;$ 5;$ 58$
FRPSDULVRQ WR WKH WUDGLWLRQDO DSSURDFK RI 1$ ;=:58G38=$ 182$ 589J3S5NJ3$ @J18$ 97:$ 3S30F=578B$ C?50?$ 45G?=$
8332$ =7$ N3$ :3R5;32$ J1=3:$ 2F:58G$ =?3$ :3;31:0?$ 0782F0=O$ XF:=?3:47:3$ 5=$ 1JJ7C;$ 121@=1=578$ =7$
:3QF5:3438=;$NH$=1T58G$=?3$07JJ30=32$21=1$58=7$1007F8=$1;$C3JJ$1;$F897:3;338$05:0F4;=1803;$;F0?$1;$
7@@7;58G$958258G;$3R7JR58G$2F:58G$=?3$21=1$181JH;5;O$

MF" @+51-:04+5"
L?5;$ @1@3:$ ;FGG3;=;$ 1$ ;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ =?1=$ 58=382;$ =7$ ;F@@7:=$
:3;31:0?3:$ =7$ 5238=59H$ 182$ 1@@JH$ =?3$ 47;=$ 1@@:7@:51=3$ 43=?72$ 97:$ 21=1$ 181JH;5;O$ L?3$ 7NU30=5R3$ 5;$
=?3:3NH$ =7$ 23:5R3$ 915=?9FJ$ 182$ :3J3R18=$ :3;FJ=;$ 9:74$ =?3$ 21=1$ 07JJ30=32$ 58$ 1$ :5G7:7F;B$ :3@31=1NJ3$ 182$
=:1031NJ3$41883:O$/$:3@7:=32$01;3$;=F2H$;?7C;$=?5;$ 3S34@J1:HB$1J=?7FG?$ 1245==32JH$ R3:H$ N:539O$L?3$
;=:1=3GH$ 97:$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 5;$ ;FGG3;=32$ =7$ N3$ 1@@J532$ C?38$ 0?77;58G$ N3=C338$
;545J1:$:3;31:0?$43=?72;$:1=?3:$=?18$7@@7;58G$783;O$!=$5;$18=505@1=32$=?1=$87R503$:3;31:0?B$3;@3051JJH$
M?IB$ 7:$ :3;31:0?$ ;=F238=;$ 58$ =?35:$ 585=51J$ ;=1G3B$ C?50?$ 79=38$ 27$ 87=$ ?1R3$ 1$ ;7J52$ T87CJ32G3$ 182$
N10TG:7F82$ 3S@3:53803$ 58$ 4FJ=5@J3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 1;$ C3JJ$ 1;$ =?35:$ ;3J30=578$ C5JJ$ N38395=$ 9:74$
1@@JH58G$ =?5;$ ;=:1=3GHO$ K7:37R3:$ =?5;$ ;=:1=3GH$ 5;$ 7@38(458232$ 182$ 87=$ N51;32$ NH$ 18H$ @1:=50FJ1:$
:3;31:0?$43=?72;$N1;32$78$@:3R57F;$3S@3:53803;O$
$
M?5J7;7@?501J$ @7;5=578;$ 1:3$ 87=$ 23=15J32$ 58$ =?5;$ @1@3:B$ ?7C3R3:$ =?3;3$ C5JJ$ N3$ =1T38$ 58=7$ 1007F8=$ 58$
97:=?07458G$ C7:TO$ !8$ =?3$ ;143$41883:$ =?3$ ;3J30=578$ 79$4FJ=5@J3$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72;$ 97:$ 21=1$ 181JH;5;$
182$=?35:$@7=38=51J$074N581=578$79$4FJ=5@J3$@1:125G4;$Y3OGO$<3C5;$182$D:543;$%+++[$C5JJ$N3$078;523:32$
58$ 9F=F:3$ C7:TO$ L?3$ @:7@7;32$ ;=:1=3GH$ 79$ 23J1H32$ :3;31:0?$ 43=?72$ ;3J30=578$ 5;$ 3S@30=32$ =7$ N38395=$
4FJ=59103=32$ J1:G3$ ;01J3$ :3;31:0?$ @:7U30=;$ 58$ =?35:$ 585=51J$ @?1;3$ C?3:3$ 25993:38=$ 1;@30=;$ 8332$ =7$ N3$
=1T38$58=7$1007F8=B$7:$:3;31:0?$C?50?$5;$074N5832$25993:38=JH$78$@F:@7;3$=7$9:143$QF3;=578;$97:$J1=3:$

CCCO3UN:4O074$

&&$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$

<#=-0%)-(*1#)%#&*#%*-">$

181JH;5;$C5=?$4FJ=5@J3$43=?72;O$XF:=?3:47:3$=?3$@:7@7;32$182$5887R1=5R3$;=:1=3GH$5;$3S@30=32$=7$ N3$
1@@J501NJ3$=7$58=3:25;05@J581:H$;30=7:$10:7;;$4FJ=5@J3$1@@J501=578;$58$R1:57F;$953J2;$79$:3;31:0?O$

/'*'%'51'0"
/883JJ;B$KO$Y*))^[$mL:518GFJ1=578$79$QF1J5=1=5R3$1@@:710?3;A$?3:4383F=501J$@?3874387JGH$182$G:7F8232$=?37:HmB$
-*.)+/&$*0$W5F/+'#5$X.)2,+NB$l7JO$-^B$#7O$%B$@@O$--(^%O$
E1T3:B$6OB$\F3;=B$nO$182$"=3:8B$MO#O$Y%++*[$mK3=?72$;JF::58GA$=?3$G:7F8232$=?37:H$b$@?3874387J7GH$3S14@J3mB$
-*.)+/&$*0$W5F/+'#5$X.)2,+NB$l7JO$%'B$@@O$%,,-(%,^)O$
E38N1;1=B$!OB$D7J2;=358B$IOdO$182$K312B$KO$Y%+Z'[$mL?3$61;3$>3;31:0?$"=:1=3GH$58$"=F253;$79$!897:41=578$
"H;=34;mB$49Y$Z./)(#)&MB$l7JO$%%B$#7O$,B$@@O$,^+(,ZZO$
6?1:41VB$dO$Y%++-[$mD:7F8232$L?37:HmB$58$3#A(",+L,+N$7#("*52$,+$>2M'"*&*NMB$32;$"45=?B$nOB$W1::3B$>O$182$
<18G38?7R3B$<OB$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$<78278B$]dB$@@O$*'(&+O$
6?1:41VB$dO$Y*))%[$mD:7F8232$=?37:H$58$=?3$*%;=$038=F:HA$/@@J501=578;$97:$12R18058G$;7051J$UF;=503$;=F253;mB$58$
!"#$W7#),'/+$!)/5,(,*+$,+$Z./&,(/(,F#$3#2#/)'"B$R7JO$*B$32;$I38V58B$#OdO$182$<5807J8B$cOB$"1G3B$<78278B$
@@O$*&&(*Z-O$
_?:50?B$<O6O$Y*))-[$m>3R5;5=58G$@?3874387J7GHA$!=;$@7=38=51J$97:$4181G3438=$:3;31:0?mB$R)*'##5,+N2$["/&&#+N#2$
*)$*)N/+,2/(,*+2$,+$N&*G/&$7/)L#(2E$1),(,2"$W'/5#7M$*0$4/+/N#7#+($[*+0#)#+'#O$
X382=B$nO$182$"10?;B$\O$Y*))Z[$mD:7F8232$L?37:H$58$K181G3438=$>3;31:0?mB$\)N/+,]/(,*+/&$3#2#/)'"$4#("*52B$
l7JO$%%B$#7O$,,B$@@O$&,)(&--O$
D5N;78B$EOB$D:3G7:HB$nO$182$>7N58;78B$MODO$Y*))-[$mL?3$58=3:;30=578$N3=C338$;H;=34;$=?37:H$182$G:7F8232$
=?37:HA$L?3$343:G3803$79$=?3$G:7F8232$;H;=34;$7N;3:R3:mB$Z./&,(/(,F#$Y*',*&*NM$3#F,#HB$l7JO$%B$#7O$*O$
DJ1;3:B$EODO$Y%+'Z[$!"#*)#(,'/&$Y#+2,(,F,(M^$W5F/+'#2$,+$("#$7#("*5*&*NM$*0$N)*.+5#5$("#*)MB$"7057J7GH$M:3;;B$
K5JJ$l1JJ3HB$6/B$]"O$
DJ1;3:B$EODO$Y%++*[$%7#)N#+'#$F2I$_*)',+N^$1/2,'2$*0$`)*.+5#5$!"#*)M$W+/&M2,2B$"7057J7GH$M:3;;B$K5JJ$l1JJ3HB$
6/B$]"O$
DJ1;3:B$EODO$182$"=:1F;;B$/O$Y%+^'[$!"#$5,2'*F#)M$*0$N)*.+5#5$("#*)M^$Y()/(#N,#2$0*)$P./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'"B$/J2583$
MFNJ5;?58G$674@18HB$#3C$c7:TB$]"O$
W1443:;J3HB$KO$Y%+++[$mI3078;=:F0=578$=?3$kF1J5=1=5R3(kF18=5=1=5R3$I5R523mB$58$Z./&,(/(,F#$3#2#/)'"B$R7JO$%B$32;$
E:H4188B$/O$182$EF:G3;;B$>OB$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$<78278B$]dB$@@O$')(Z,O$
W7C1:2(D:38R5JJ3B$nO/O$Y*))-[$mL?3$@3:;5;=3803$79$9J3S5NJ3$7:G185V1=5781J$:7F=583;A$L?3$:7J3$79$1G380H$182$
7:G185V1=5781J$078=3S=mB$\)N/+,]/(,*+$Y',#+'#B$l7JO$%^B$#7O$^B$@O$^%ZO$
dJ358B$WOdO$182$KH3:;B$KOIO$Y%+++[$m/$"3=$79$M:5805@J3;$97:$6782F0=58G$182$_R1JF1=58G$!8=3:@:3=5R3$953J2$"=F253;$58$
!897:41=578$"H;=34;mB$49Y$Z./)(#)&MB$l7JO$*,B$#7O$%B$@@O$^'(+&O$
dR1J3B$"O$Y%++^[$9+(#)6,#H2^$W$,+()*5.'(,*+$(*$P./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'"$,+(#)F,#H,+NB$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$L?7F;182$
`1T;B$6/B$]"O$
<332HB$MOIO$182$`:4:72B$nO_O$Y*))-[$R)/'(,'/&$3#2#/)'"^$R&/++,+N$/+5$a#2,N+B$Z=?$328B$M31:;78$K3::5JJ$M:38=503$
W1JJB$]@@3:$"122J3$>5R3:B$#nB$]"O$
<3C5;B$KO\O$182$D:543;B$/OnO$Y%+++[$mK3=1=:518GFJ1=578A$EF5J258G$=?37:H$9:74$4FJ=5@J3$@1:125G4;mB$W'/5#7M$*0$
4/+/N#7#+($3#F,#HB$l7JO$*&B$#7O$&B$@@O$^'*(^+)O$
K1:=58B$MOcO$182$LF:83:B$EO/O$Y%+Z^[$mD:7F8232$L?37:H$182$`:G185V1=5781J$>3;31:0?mB$!"#$-*.)+/&$*0$W>>&,#5$
1#"/F,*.)/&$Y',#+'#B$l7JO$**B$#7O$*B$@@O$%&%(%-'O$
K1;78B$nO$Y*))*[$Z./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'",+NB$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;$<=2B$L?7F;182$`1T;B$6/O$
K5J3;B$KOEO$182$WFN3:4188B$KO/O$Y%++&[$Z./&,(/(,F#$5/(/$/+/&M2,2^$/+$#K>/+5#5$2*.)'#G**LB$*82$328B$"1G3$
MFNJ501=578;B$L?7F;182$`1T;B$6/B$]"O$
K7:;3B$nOKO$182$>50?1:2;B$<O$Y*))*[$3#/57#$0,)2($0*)$/$.2#)T2$N.,5#$(*$P./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'"B$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$
L?7F;182$`1T;B$6/B$]"O$
K7F;=1T3;B$6O$Y%++&[$R"#+*7#+*&*N,'/&$3#2#/)'"$4#("*52B$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$L?7F;182$`1T;B$6/B$]"O$
KH3:;B$KOIO$182$#3C418B$KO$Y*))'[$mL?3$QF1J5=1=5R3$58=3:R53C$58$!"$:3;31:0?A$_S145858G$=?3$0:19=mB$9+0*)7/(,*+$
/+5$\)N/+,]/(,*+B$l7JO$%'B$#7O$%B$@@O$*(*^O$
#3F418B$\O<O$Y%++'[$Y*',/&$3#2#/)'"$4#("*52^$Z./&,(/(,F#$/+5$Z./+,(,(/(,F#$W>>)*/'"#2B$,:2$328B$/JJH8$j$
E1078B$#332?14$W35G?=;B$K/B$]"O$
M1==78B$KOkO$Y*))*[$Z./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'"$/+5$#F/&./(,*+$7#("*52B$,:2$328B$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$L?7F;182$`1T;B$
6/B$]"O$
>7N3HB$IO$182$K1:TF;B$KO<O$Y%++Z[$mE3H782$:5G7:$182$:3J3R1803A$@:72F058G$078;F41NJ3$:3;31:0?$1N7F=$
5897:41=578$;H;=34;mB$9+0*)7/(,*+$3#2*.)'#2$4/+/N#7#+($-*.)+/&B$l7JO$%%B$#7O$%B$@@O$'(%-O$
"=3:8B$MO#OB$/JJ38B$<O$182$K7SJ3HB$MO$Y%+Z*[$mL?3$8F:;3;$1;$1$G:7F8232$=?37:5;=$?5;=7:HB$@:703;;3;B$182$F;3;mB$
3#F,#H$-*.)+/&$*0$R",&*2*>"M$/+5$Y*',/&$Y',#+'#B$l7JO$'B$@@O$*))(*%-O$
"F221NHB$>O$Y*))^[$mX:74$=?3$325=7:;A$\?1=$G:7F8232$=?37:H$5;$87=mB$W'/5#7M$*0$4/+/N#7#+($-*.)+/&B$l7JO$&+B$
#7O$&B$@@O$^,,(^&*O$
L3;0?B$>O$Y%++)[$Z./&,(/(,F#$)#2#/)'"^$W+/&M2,2$(M>#2$/+5$2*0(H/)#$(**&2B$X1J43:B$#3C$c7:TB$#cB$]"O$
l18$K1838B$KO$Y%++'[$3#2#/)'",+N$&,F#5$#K>#),#+'#^$b.7/+$2',#+'#$0*)$/+$/'(,+$2#+2,(,F#$>#5/N*NMB$L?3$
/J=?7F;3$M:3;;B$<78278B$]dO$
l78$\:5G?=B$nO$Y%+'+[$m`8$=?3$J545=1=578;$79$?F418$5897:41=578$@:703;;58G$Y!?45;38$=53278T1;5==3JHTHRH8$
:1U75=FT;51[mB$W'/5#7,/$Y',#+(,/).7$_#++,'/E$6.*2,L,)J/$A$c#/)$1**LB$@@O$%^,(%'%O$
\5J;78B$WO"O$182$WF=0?58;78B$"O/O$Y%++%[$mL:518GFJ1=578$79$kF1J5=1=5R3$K3=?72;A$W3523GG3:518$W3:4383F=50;$182$
D:7F8232$L?37:HmB$Z./&,(/(,F#$b#/&("$3#2#/)'"B$l7JO$%B$#7O$*B$@@O$*^,(*'^O$
CCCO3UN:4O074$

&-$

!""#$%&''(')*+$

!"#$%&'()$*+',&(-"*'.*/,0)(#00*1#0#-&$2*3#%2'40*5'",6#*7*800,#*9*:;99*
$
\5J;78B$LOIO$Y*))*[$m/J9:32$"0?FJVB$M?3874387J7GH$182$>3;31:0?$K3=?7272J7GH$97:$!897:41=578$E3?1R57F:$
>3;31:0?mB$58$_*.)("$9+(#)+/(,*+/&$[*+0#)#+'#$*+$9+0*)7/(,*+$Y##L,+N$,+$[*+(#K(B$<5;N78B$M7:=FG1JO$
\54@388HB$MO$182$D1;;B$nO$Y*)))[$m!8=3:R53C58G$58$@?3874387J7GH$182$G:7F8232$=?37:HA$5;$=?3:3$1$25993:3803gmB$
-*.)+/&$*0$W5F/+'#5$X.)2,+NB$l7JO$,%B$#7O$^B$@@O$%&Z-(%&+*O$
\H83T77@B$nO<O$182$>F;;7B$#O<O$Y%++'[$m"=F2H58G$"H;=34;$I3R3J7@438=$K3=?727J7G53;A$/8$_S14581=578$79$
>3;31:0?$K3=?72;mB$9+0*)7/(,*+$YM2(#72$-*.)+/&B$l7JO$'B$#7O$%B$@@O$&'(^^O$
c58B$>OdO$Y*)),[$[/2#$Y(.5M$3#2#/)'"^$a#2,N+$/+5$4#("*52B$,:2$328B$"1G3$MFNJ501=578;B$L?7F;182$`1T;B$6/B$
]"O$
$
$

CCCO3UN:4O074$

&^$

./0123450$67893:3803;$<=2$