Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
(6D(,sI,o,pan?(sS3ap(,v,sa\p,,=,?nI,nIXrXn`s8,GP(n?D,n/,`6a(I?,p,(IO`p,X((-`Spapp(/,Iw(PapS\Is,l(n?,,Ss(,an,`psps(,nA??,,(,nEOp(l ,oXp,r=p,p,/(Da(`(p?d,?ss,
(D,,sipkXOO,=(pka,/pa,(,`p,?,, owXa,(,p(,kp
?,,pa,9((D`,I(X(,p?a((p=(,,,p??Xp,/nOI(,(,,,9XpI(,D(,pds,D,,Z,,aLxnn=?,X/p/XIs
,(aD,,(/ppknZ(9XD(pZX,9nn,(Io(DX ,?px,n?((,II((=D,`/pp(Ip=,#/p,?(dI3a??,I/,p,, pB(Z(9
n6((ZpX(,,Pr,((,LapI#(nIsPD,PO/(p (Ip ,/((,vO?/p (,a?(p,x?np(np,,,I(X,Ipd,/nppX,(Gp/,/Ipd,(?n(?zs((/ZI,nD, DI,#,p,(l/vXpp,z3(pD,( (?Dps
s9(D/I(((akp,,(=Z((?(((Xd`XD9pn(?((#psnwp,`
?a(p?np,(p=Eps(X`Is,,XpX `ppDB(w,Zp(9ppPsZ,Xa,?!n(,(, ^ S 9,(,/?,E
! "#
) 1 2354687:96;23541<>=@?ACB:7ED19;F)GH2>IJ0B!KL2NMOP9Q"R#S"=@?IT?357:2L2G
&-.
42>Ad?Dfe
* g
&# W
0/
_-+ & - :- `'ab P( )23c4687:96823c4
_: _. `:@ & ' * h- +* -.
lnmco%pqcrs:turvwxyxwz%{Eo%rs|qcw|}|Ez.~.~rs{:p;h.P{Eopcwsp;pns_qcws^z..pns{Eopwsp;p;fpn.{}z%pns}cXL:Lw%
{Eo%p+[,>#d.vswL|:{Es:z%;{Ez.spsw.{cz0%.pns{Eo%pwLsp;p;pn.{[zpns[XL:LL0
l
I ,
a
v, I
Z vv n ,
,
k ( U
Z X
&.Y
Multimedia Workstation
Multimedia Workstation
END-TO-END QoS
System Architecture
System Architecture
GUARANTEES
Application Level
Application Level
System Level
System Level
(Operating System
Communication
Protocols)
(Operating System
Communication
Protocols)
Network Level
Network Level
Gateway
Hub
ATM Network
Fast Ethernet
Multimedia PC
Multimedia Workstation
v, v ?I
Z Z , ,
v v, Z
Z
,
?,
, /
D ` 3 / ?
I
v
I ,v
v
L I O
?
P
?
v,
`
n Z
n
, 8 n
`
? a
l ,
I Z
k
Z Z ?
Z P
?
` n , ?
I ?, Z ? v Z
,
n
`
,
?,
Z
, L,
n
,
=
,
n `
,
X
`
?#
Z
v,
?I ?
Z , /
`
k
?, /
Z 9
n
l
A ?P
Z
n
vv
Z ,
?,
Z
,
,
I
,
, ` v
D `
v n
v n
, , #
Z v
Z Z,v
v
?
9 n
?,
,
D, ?
Z,v 9 Z L, ?,
, L, l I Z
Z
Z `"
, I
, ?,
-
* j ( ) + ,
g -.
hb + - & P ` "he
-L
+
U
&
,
T! .Y h* + ,
^ & g
g- - U ,
+
$
.YZ
L\
+/0
(:e
b-. .
U
ef "b
- +* -.
U
V -L
CD
-
k
V V , 0
g
( 0
- /_(
,
-L
! e
"
"
;
"[/`
=
L\@
-/B %e^`U
1 "*.
1 `
;ke `
h
f
** &* ,
- g- U g E L./
k-
M@
eP
Y-g
"
`
;
,
GH9AC=7EB:93'
k` /eU
;e /( Yy`Y/ +_
+-.
( ;h ?g k % & '-LU
(
e *
g `U
+L\@
+ e
4+>Y:g`" b
- "
$-L +h-L
!#"%$
)Z5
./}eP -LV
*- &Xe &
.( Yy`Y/_:
"#
(
$ I2L?A687EB*2U2%7:2>3GLB!93Ghe
[/
,
(b
( 0.Y
L,
, ?I
, , n,
n
?,
n,
,
n, , `
`
v
, , Iv,
, P ?
v ?,
n v `
v n
Z ?
Z
Z
Z
v n
?,
Z
?,
` ?,
?, l
v ?I
n
?
Z
, 9
,
Z
Z `
Z
, `
, `
, P P
Z
v
v n
vv n, vv w
X
v n
, I Z
nI
, `
, ?,
Z I ,
` ,
I
`
v ?,
n Z
I
D
x Z
?
Z ?I n, vv
,
v ?I
, ?,
/ Z
?,
?I
, `
?,
Z, I P
L,
! Zv ! , ` `,
?
z I
` v
I ,
n E
L, a Z
,
k ? n ,
? v
I
,
?
` Z,v, k L i
? vv
?,
n ,
,
?, v ,
Z
,, ?,
`
` Z,vI i ?
`
v ?I
n
, z
Z ?
z
`
v L,
D n
Z
, I
!v
i
l
`
Z
n ?,
?
nv
v
,
n ?,
Z
i Z , ,
Z ?
n i
v L, A n
?, ,
?
, ,
n
,
,
, , Z
Z ,
v ?,
? p v,
`
I ?,
l ,
?,
v,
,
n
`
Z
Z n v
n
,v Z
v ?, I
"-/
- "
:-
)
+eX
;: +1 `
)- -
C
L
b
g N "
1
!
g
` .Y
- +
:-
g
!-
%e
-
&
"X
# `
g
&fec(
."[/
*
"[Y
# `
"[/ ! - ./
(
."X
-.
efUeP
) &U
`[/c -0/c - ' ) h ` 65-. g- `
&
; !g
) : -+
g
E L
!
CD
-
-L
&
-L
# ` .Y
C
V
& ,
C
efU
"
- #
-.
k ;e
"
-
h(-.
-.
V
- g
/g
( 0X
Xe
U `
*
(
L ,
1:-
Xab
U Y
" ;/P
U:
[Y
`
!
P
*+
C
-
&
g X X "-ha ./-k- &U# " ++ , - &
& + (
g"
Vk `
C
, ;:
E @
g "8 .eP ' "-k# ` , ;:
( V
-.
: -
V-. k
ke
eP -LV-. N(U
[/+
'
&eP
-
U-LX
&-
U
[Y
$ C#"-(%ChL
-.
P" ;
-,+D "g! g V
- 65-.
eP !C#"/ - +#
k
(
e
g + -.Y
A9.?4"?A2
, T!
/-.
g "8 .eP ' "-k# ` , ;:
P
O=@?A
)?35/c- " h
+ h -*h `X
+e
-.
e
-. (
g
- "
0/[-.
&
:
f
& [Y ^ -+ b &- " ./
g c/_`
"[/
c: _
&` -_-*
'/0 ;ef "5/0 _+ g
-- `
-gU
`e^ -+ / "` e
"-P-L./ g " - (& 15`L bE ;h- c - -.
?,
? , P
Z
n
,
Zk
,,
` ,
?
L
, ?,
?
,
Z
, , , ?,
av
av
Z Z `
v,
I, ` `
I , O
v ?I
P
Z
9
Z w
l
k
/v 9 `
Z
v L,
I ,
v ?I
v ?I
,
n
L,
?,
n
?, O n
v ?I
,v ,I
` I z
` I X, l , L `
! ? ! vv
v
? p
, vv
,
,v
z
Xv
,
, l ` O n `
v, v L,
v
? l
I Z
n, /
v
,
v ?I
` Z !v
z
Z
`
v n z
v,
?, n n,
nI
P
, , d Z
Z d
v n
n,
,
n, Z
nI
?,
n,
` l
Z P
` ?, n L
n, , 3
v
, v
v n
n, "!
L
nI
#
$
&
%')(+*-, .0/+.21Od .435,& ,76.98:.; ( d </s= .d .
vv
Z
vI
?I ? , I
vI v ?I
A Z Z
D i
`
n
,
? v
Z P
z v `
?,
I
E
Z
Z ,
Z
D
I ? lv
,
L,
,
`
i nI
!
Z
! Z / ,
` v n
A
`
v n v
`
v,
?I v n
,
v,
*
+.Y
#
L
b
VeP
, ;:
2 .B
A2./
)GKL?A?A2
P`"
(h(-.
P & eP
-
%
N / "
*
b
#
`
), -
;b
'
-.
k
5
V
h %e
"n
-L
+
V- &
eP
V
U
`
&
&
- P9+-
! ^*
u
+ L a 8
"
&e Y
h
'eke _ -g )
V -k+ b
he
k,
-+ g -g
AV
-
P-
-
"<J)
-
"
- +* -.
& # -
-
-
"
=]Y
"
- (
V "
L\ &-*e
&
-.
++ L
#
-L '
X )a
;+ --(%g I+
& `** E
h- +* -.
./ e'
&' ) %e
- (
"
.Y
V .Y
U -
`
, 0./
g M
[Y
`
&f-.
1
&eP Y "
Va !
+ , 0
g
&
& * k
h
e
L\ (
g
h-L
&e
".YB"
b +
" ;
-,+eP -LX
& %e^ h *
--h
U- " g U [
U(
' ( N
-.
&1
-g AV 7g "8 0eP + -UU `"
(-.
& %
+#
&hab ;
./
/
$ ! -*a V -
& b-.
) -- `
"[Y
e
+ 0Y
"n
& -
>?A@
X -L
" g
, -+
'
BDCE;F0CG2HI
I
,
n I ?, X
AJ K
? , ? 3I 2L D
v
n
* -L
- Y
Z vv `
` X
n
Z
,
L
`I v n,
e &- &
+42.7:2>I4kBE3BEGH7EB:KhG @2LKB fKL?7EB:93'
+ 0/eP g +
e &(h U(b
g.
*(
g-
&
NSUTWV
eP
& [
d
?
v
`
n n
,
P ,
, &M ONQ
I
PMPORQ
J
n ?, /
Z
, ,I n ?
n ?I
` L, v J
MPORQ"M ONQ L M ONQ
M ONQ L "M ONQ
X
f "#
& .
*(0Y
&%a
8g -e (
f- 65* ( '
^ `
M ONQ
e
MPONQ
+_
- 65-.
&
0
`"
(MPORQ
e & e
M ONQ
b/
P( X
P
MPORQ Y VUe &
)GLBE3bSA2+J?A=@2
+e
/
+P P %e^
?BEIUJ%?A=2
V?"KKL2 57:?
A2k<=?AB!7ED+I2S"B!93
G!(
( +
( +
+
UZ `=Y
Frame Rate
30fps
15 fps
1 fps
q_max
Acceptable Region
q_min
Unacceptable
Region
80x40
Z ?,
360x240
640x480
Resolution
n
v
n
Z
Z ,
v L, n a ?
n Z Z
?
J
#
, #
n ?, n
Z l
v L, l Z n A ?
` !v
I
!
n
!! "
l
, Z
D z z n l i
,
v n
(
v n
` v /
,
N" !
,
n
` 9 ` n , d I ,,
n
? ,,
, Z
?,
,
`
n
n
, I a
v,
?, v n
, I
?
v ?, ,
n
)
!
Z ,
? l Z J J
vv Z
J)J
Z
!
,
, ?,
3 n
vv
n
, L,
?, ?/
, n Z
v ?I
,
n
Z
,
z
,
J
L,
n
, /
D
Z ?
I
!
Z v
J
$# %
, Z
Z,
,
v n
&
('
Q*)"+-,
%
n l
Z, I
/.%
n
D `
, , ` n
, , , v ?,
Z `= 8^
`
8
&
"
(
V(
e
:*
g- h
0\
e^ -
` [Y
0\
X d\@
U d\@k 5
g
U
- 65
` P
- !
)(
0!_e
' d\@0Y
fL /W
ACB:KL?7EB!93
OP9Q
OP9Q
(:Y `Y/ J
&
(&
( ;e
-
8e h "P-
0 h+ ` 65-.
@2IKL2 57E=?AOP9Q
OP9Q
(:Yy`
Y/
(:Yy`
Y/ i
k -L
-
,
1b
& '
U+'
1-b-,+k
OP9Q
- &`
- :
35207
9I
' ePNab ;
(
k(
8e
@?IT?
207:2ILG -L
g AV [/ !g "8 0eP -PU `+ [, ;: )Y
-.
* -.
& [/c -
[/
)/[
) ;ef "X,
0,FGIH (K8Y1" Pef*
efh-. U g
& - `
- .Y gh
- e
P- ` f
-- `
FI?*2
OP9Q
2>3546;7:9682>354*4"2A?D
?+( ;e
I93B .?"7EB!93+G
2 7
(
?+g P ;
& .Y
l
?,
g
n ?,
,
Z
;
-.
- 65-.
"
"
b
+ A@
I
I
a +
?,
"* &-.
-
X,
0
b-L M@.
+
g
-
)+
&
+
+
A@.
?,
"* &-.
- A@
X, 0
v L,
(
g -.
X
.%
Q ) +-,
%
# %
"e
jh`
V %
+ L
P
(
?
, L,
, ,
, ,
L, n
?,
`v,
?, P,
,
!, v L,
,
n ,
,
n ?
,
,
n
b- `
g
V
.
HNC!#"H F0CG2HI
Z
?
D ` ,
Z v
Z
n ,
n l ,I
,
,
v '
n, vv
A X
Z
?
, , , , v
Z %$
Z
Z I
, ,,
,v P , ,
?,
D
n
Z ! d Z , ? Z
,v
?,
`
?, D
?I !v
?I Z ? / , ,
,
L, ` Z
'&
9
, I 9 ? ,
t
J
v Z
I
, L !v
, ' , v `
?I
vI
?,
n,
v Z
n I
M ONQ)( +* MPONQ
"M ONQ - MPONQ
-,
n
v Z
, v , ?
, P
I ? l ,
Z Z `
` v A l, , `
n Iv, /#
?,
Q*)"+-,
$.
n ?,
. 0/ )1
+201
31 41 6587 :9 ;1
%1 <2 41 ;1
>? >
k
( 0" `g:-
`"
) +.Y
XZ &`
Y
' - '
( h* + ,
_
eP -L
-
- +
Xe
F E'#
L\
g` _ & ePP % k U= 3B FH9I4
V
*KAB:2357
GH2>IJ2I
`
, e
`
-.
"
&
9042A
"
- "-
[Y
L
"
{Eo y
KAB:23c7 I9.KL2GLGY
M@[`
Y
+
-
k .Y
J.B:2
"
e
+/
+L% E 1g
U L
sp8|:rz.s;pfr0pnx
CLIENT
Request for
Request for
Resource Work
response
(QoS guaranteed,
or QoS degradation)
request
(event)
Resource Brokerage
response
(QoS contract)
request
(event,QoS-spec)
deal profile
Resource Scheduler
Timing Control
Negotiation/
Renegotiation
Event Control
degradation notification
Admission
Resource
Controller
Resource
Broker
Resource Worker
(Scheduler)
SERVER
Shared Resource
`
v Z
/
nI v Z
, ?I l ,
?,
vv,
v Z
,
, `
,
?
, ?
n a `
l ,
Z k
n ,
? vv / ?
l , ` Ev , 3
` ,
, z,
? ?
v Z
, Z
v
/ ?, A J
?/ D
v ?I I ?,
Z n l , L, ,,
,
` , av/
J K
v ` v
Z a
i
, `
&
, I ,
Z
X `
n k
i
n
,
v ?, Z /,
Z2 `
?
L, l
` `
J K
P Z
v,
L, pv9
l
, ?
v 3
i ` v ,
Z /
I
v I
I
?, l ,
, ?,
, ?I
L P
n ,
I
n l v Z
Z
v Z v z
Z
Z ` ,vI
?,
,
Z,
Z
v Z
n Z l, l
` , v n,
v Z , v Z
I
,
, l
Z
` ?,
Z
!
n,
v L,
Z
a
41 1
+/
1
/
+/
1
/ 1
%
1 1
1
7 1 2
1 1
2
1
1
%1
41
Z `
*L\
-.
( &
(b
X( 0" `
!-
`"
;:
b- `
+* u
-.
U`
b-
-
.
& %
"U
Y
&
OP9Q
- Y
&-
L
;: `
! "#
! "#
&
[/
X + -
I9BE3bS)G2ILJ.B:K2
I9 A20Y
- &
P
&-h P &
e
;
`
# e
!
-
( 0
(:Yy`Y&/
HLJK U
*
!. (
- `
- " _ -g `"Y h -g( 0"f- "* &-.
g +% ,
-
1b e
FG
&
! -g $+
g , 1g
*^- 65
,
`X
(b
!
- .Y
' d!
h -h( 0Pe^ -U- &P: P b- ` -- `
&
L
`
IT2>GH9=bIKL2*GK 2L4= A2Ih- h ;ef + * -+- &
I2G9=bIKL2'KL9357EI9AEA2I 0
eP`*
(
`"
`
[/
- _ '.Y "-( 0_T! [
h* ^ ."
: U
( 0g:
,
*OP9QK9357EI?K.7(
;ef
0Y
k-
-
y "`
y^
`
+( 0 ./-
+
, l
Z I
h-
U
e
- nY
vv
Z , X
t1 = 0 ms
START
Send
send signal
Resume sending
t(send_tac) = 20ms
no
start timer
no
yes
yes
Condition
tv1=0ms
send signal
t(recv_tac) = 10ms
Condition
PLAY tactile
data
Resume
send signal
Receive
t(send_vid)=33ms
stop timer
Send
tv2=200 ms
PLAY video
STOP
t2 = 1000 ms
Stop timer
Z ,
/ ` )
Z
Z `
c -.
e
+
e
- " Y
v v
Z/ P ,vI
ZX , ,
& & e1- "Y *
.Y
v ,
Z
?I n
`
n, vv
?,
vv
>?
B I F
" )H" ! H G PI )"H H
F I
HG
H
,
k v ?,
v,
!
d
9
I
v ?,
Z
Z
L v
,
X
n
n
Z ,
,
n
vv
,
Z `
?I ` D ` P n Z
v ?I n vv `
?,
,
Z
D ` v n ,
` ?
* "
X(
;ef
- (
Y V'-.
(:kZ `
0+Y
"
C
! "#
( &-.
" )H"
$
?, v
,
n
? Z ?
Z
I
Z
`
` `
v ?,
l /
v d
` Z
c( LP
U "-h- &- +* -.
Pe
V "
, L P
*
k (
^! "
* -*- " ' $ef "h-. U- "):( -4
* ;e U( 0"u V ;ef "U - g
-L
`L +
&[ - " c -. c & g -P-LX !'/
hb
* *
( 0"f *--.
- 65-Pa
;'- "
*
O=?A
+:
[Y
5 U
?37kB:44 A2
?I2
(:
g "8 .eP * -*# `+ PE ;: +
,
0Ue g($ &
*- &%Q
2IL352>A5 %e^
Application
Controller
Application
Broker
(Application
Management)
Application Level
Disk Server
Comm. Server
Broker
Broker
Broker
Broker
Control
Control
Control
Control
QualMan
Mem. Server
Middleware
System Level
Network
Controller
Network
(Connection
Management)
Broker
Network Level
,
Z `&
?,
v n v
1 -
n ?
[ 0;%zeP
X
l
l ` !v P
v ?, J)J
, nv J)J
k
A
l
kv
, ,
?,
P
,
Z ?, A n
,
Z n ? 9 Z
Z 6v
, ` D ` 9
v d J J
d `
n P
v ?I
,
/ Z
`
Avk
?
n, vv,
3
n
v ?,
,
n
n i Z
?P
,v '
,
n n
?, Z
? ?,
,
A
n l v
, ?, ?
z
` I ?, n z
I ?, n
, ,
P nP
v
, ?,
?,
?l
Iv
L,
?,
P L
?I
?
,v
U
,
?,
v
n n
X
,
, n
?v
?,
L
?v
` n
?,
, v n
?,
Z Z, i &
,
?I
31
/
41 1 2 +/
1 41 1
8
1
1
1
/
1
1
41 +2
1
%1 +2 </
%1
1 2 1
1 1
Z `
Y
eP -.
ACB:KL?7EB!93
(%
; -fe
OP9Q
/] `
[/
k" `
+GDG7:2
OP9Q
"
Y
AB!KL?7EB:936nGDG7:2
eP
h
g
B,3c7:2IEFH?KL2
"Y
EL: e`" } " -[ 'g "8 0eP -# ` ./
-L
h
E .".Y
( ;e
- +L\
7EI?3
GA?7EB:93)( ;e
;h '?
(b
AB!KL?7EB:93OP9Q
g
++ `
+
"X( ;e
&( <g
( 0
, ` `Y
N`
)`
E
FGIC
- '
K
(g - U
+ &[Y_Z `!J ePf
(P.
b- *-
'(
;ef
*
eP -L
- " L -
Y
)
I2G2ILJ%?7EB:93
"X( ;e
b-.
"` +
b-
&
Uh
)-
I2G9= ITKL2
& V
*
"
U eP
1L\
OP9Q
-.
/ eP
.Y
pq yxyx8r%;pn.{EswL{:pr
.p;frsgwh8rLz0 ;w{ r*|:pns pns| p;8wz%|:p{Eo%p;|:pwspnz.s:spn.{Ex h{Eo%pr|:{[| ;w.{8rL
~rpn.{:| y'rz0s|:|:{:p8g[mcop |Et |[x r;wx o%pn8p{Eopf
w%hp;rsg;r.{Esrxrv5wL8;p;|:| y%g{Eo%p .x p;|r'{Eo%p |Et'wsp|Ez P pn.{
{:rgw o p p^rrkwL8;p;|:|{ p;|{:rg{Eo%p |Et
rq5p Lpns bqcpwspqcrs:t yhrkw rsppx wrswL{:pP |Et |:pns pns y ;w|:p{Eopf |Etksp8| 0p;|
sp;r{:pnx L
H
P v lv
jh
h
D X
lv n L
Brokerage Initiator
, , X Z
Brokerage Initiatee
P1
P3
requested
reserved reserved
Mem.
R.
reserved
reserved
reserved
reserved
CPU
R.
Mem.
R.
CPU
R.
allocated
allocated
requested
allocated
allocated
allocated
Net.
R.
allocated
Disk
R.
P6
P4
P5
P2
X
, ? Z
?,
Z `J
"
,
&
L,
& b-.
`
5 h` b
v
!-
8E
`
eP -L
: +e cY
8
.X
`
,
`
Z /
!
-L
&
-
`
-
g
v ?I
I2G9= ITKL2
-
`&*
#
2"M
&
&
E 0
`
V4B,G @?"7:K
g- (
!">$
&
7 -
: e `k(-
c_
8
,
I90K2>GG2G
b-'
"
=/
k-
+Z `
Y
' H~0sr8p;p; y
[
-0Y !1
Z, ?
PJ
P(
-L[/?K.7EBEJ%2
7:?A2./
.Y
Z
Z
g N`
?vO
I
n,
I n,
v Z ?
AJ
&
?
X
/ ?/ l, l
Z
?
,
, ` ,
n,
v,
,
, ,
L,
k ^
>I9 2>IH/
5R I90K2>GG2GeP -LheP
- "
;
,
( 0
G
& ?IBE3bS
M _Q"R
J IT90K2>GG2GY k
'
V
-
+h .Y!
-L
I9>B,3 S
./
-
U
U
J
P
z z
Z `
X AJ &
v , `
, `Iv t
Z
Z
I , , a, Z
` , n ? z
l Z
,I L d
2
1 1 87
%1
UU .W
-L+(b
% .
, !v
a
v n
`
l Z L z `
Z i
, D
J
%)& J K
2 1
68KL9JAB!?357:Y
Zv ?, LP
$jh. -
z Z ?
? i L,
l
l n v '
nI v
, ,
.YD"V
& [/e
- (
[Y
^*(
+
=
=!
=
-! "j
0=
)
)N )
0=
!
?
(&=
(Y
C H
?A@
n
,
v Z
v Z
X l ,
Z , $
6 k
, z,
,
, 9 L
S k
v Z
n l
n
v Z
v/
/
` ?v,
iva ?vI , Iv
,
v
,v Z
a
,, l P AJ
&
L
, ,v
, I ?
, X, v
n
,
P
v `
, I
D
l ?v
Z
, ,v
n ? 9
O , Av
? , J &
X ?X l I
vv / ,X
,
?, P,
/v
n , l ?
l ,
vv z ,
,
v #
?
, ,v
?,
? i J &
i &
i
`I ? ?
J &
v
?,
v
, n ,
?
v Z
, , , n
, ?!
l , ,
?
k Z
, ,v
?
l
Z
`
` Z
?
, , ?
? >
" I H
J &
n
,v
P z
J &
d
?
/ ,
n Z
,vI
? P
Z ?
?
, v
I
, 3
?I
Z `
!
n
,
?
v Z
!
" - S $ S "! # !
v ` ? 9P,
? k
L
?2J %$ ! &
'$
D) ))N )) L J $9" (&
)$
"
? l P
D ? ` L
Z L
I
)%*
" #
` l
,v , L
,
`
3
? ,
?
g - ( L- &a :
-
/eP
/8
-
e
*eP
eP
'L\-
+/
&`8
-k(
b-
"
(
1-L,
( & ;
I9
"2I' b-
U 8
*
-
"
" ;Y ' L
+/-
)(U
, :.
-g*
5\@
X
Y
-L
(
+ *
Pe
- &
5\
ge
-, ( ;
&
b
>IT9 2I
8
U
" ;'eP
-
&
-g 8
-.Y"
u 8
h- "
^- L
22K>=@7EB:93V7EB *2
(& =/I=
.W
-L
U
+- '-L'
2^: P
--
+g
2ILB!904
- "
[ -4"
">$
8
`8
0=
@2>IB:9.4 =
-
+ b-.Y
( &
22K>=@7EB:93)7EB *2
& -.
b-.Y "
b
& -L8
'
P _
P
+&+/
U -g
eP
&*
eP'(
h
-L
./ (
g!he^ -++.
`
`U ;Y
#
0*
[
-
N.
#5\8
*eP
8
h- !8
f }
g . +P4BEG ?7:K 2>I b-.Y P.
&
+,+
":
-h
. &`
-. V(+-L[Y
b "(
15&P
(:- -
Pb
P( 0 b- f g b k - `
:
U
- L
`k%
&
*(keP
`
+ b-.Y
, ,
,
?
,
8
-
`"
8
-,
+-,
8
8 `8
YY
P ^
,
, Iv
v ?I E
E
! "8
;
I
-.
-
U -
?v,
v Z n
`
e
(
j -L
&`
8
b-
./
n
- L
`*-.
$(*
" 2H
AJ
&
,
L , ,
, ,v
?
? z
v/ Z
, d P
I
,
n ? v
?
Z ?
?
D ` 3 ?
? D , , , k ? /
P
D , a v
, ,
AJ &
? ? l k
v
? l
? P
I ,v
v
L
LP
I ,
, , Lv,
Lv v
v LP
, I
, ,
P ?vI , Iv l nI
?9
,
, ,v
, Iv
, ,v , n l
L
,
? t
` P n Lv, , ,v , A
a, ,
?
#
?
, ,v
I ?
v
l , Iv, , / ? ,
,
Z ,
$
v z
,
,,
9 9J
J
Z
?, ,,
Z
v ?,
L,
` ! v l P
Z
v
Iv 9 A
?
, v
,v
, ?
v ? ,
n
I
? l !
v , , I, ? ? Z
a
,
I ,
l ?
l
`
v
?
-
)Y
8
( 0
g ` P
&(5\U " ;Y h &
-L
& )eP
- `
U(
-
&
.Y
*(
` `
8
-
*L\
-.Y
+4B,G @?"7:K
*` )
A?7:23cKDY
&
e
-L
! "
-L
U-&
k L g
L\ h
(1
*L\
h-.
h k
U
% Y
`
(&5\ 8/
5\ 8
(:-. &
U
-L
+/
W
`
.Y
-Lk !!#"%$kY
8
b-Ue
-
8
k
(
;ef
+-L `
(
`U
-
*
-
X 8
65-.
&
kL\
- "
`#"%$ 0
">$
#
ke
+k-L
-
b-e
H0J K8Y
-L `
0Y
/8
18
PeP
;)-L `;F
P
+f `
Y " *
H K5
'U
%
& [Y
* .
[Y
'-L./
Yy`Y&/
h+
`" +.Y
$e + - &`P -h -L[ ` _: e `L\ +Y c _ -
(
P b &- 8
e
(=
+P
`'
&
[Y
+e
-L2+Y
?
P
I ,v ,
? v k
`/8
v
e
z ?,
n , ,
k
+ b-
0=
eP
I ,v
-L2+Y
z
`
k-L
- L\
Z L
l
,
?
z
,
? ?
kI
`
=
Z n , ,v ,
,
!
9
Ov , v
, I
Z
Z
?
` P ? O a
, , Z Z
i ?
v n ,
,
, ? 3 z
,
v
D / n n
L
n a Z Z
,
P
v
D X
E ? , v ?
, , dv I Z
L l ? v
D
,
I ? l
x I
X
n n
?
n Z `
?k
9v
E ?
P, ,
P
I ,v
`I , , v , Z k L
l n
, , #
Z
n
D `I
v ?,
`
, l, k Lkv
A
v ` , Pv Z ,
v ?I ! ' dvX Z
?, , n , `
v
I ? P
v
?I P ?v
, , ? 9v n
, P,
?
I H G C
C 2I
v Z ,
,
n ?, J $ S & (' J
'$
d n L, S ! % 0 *
? "
!%*
!
n ?I
v A
,
X
Z
,
`
- b*`
h+
e
0 &
- "
"n* .
`
'
-
`b (
-.Y
-h
.Y1"
-
g
%
U
eP
yb
&-.
a
+ 8
l ?
?, `
C
8
-k
-
k+
/8
!
-8
N ;
b-
+
+ U -L
-.
+
^ - "
L`
,
2g g
- 65-.
- 65-.
" @2ILB:9.4
;(
*=7EBEACB
+Y
0?7EB!93*B,3 2IK2>357:?S 2
-+g+.
*(
k/
'
X
:
UZ ` Y
A
-
8
UY*Z
'L\
+/
L\-
-.Y
b-.Y
g hab } :
# "u ke
^L\@
- `+-
^ P0/
-
- L\
-. &.Y
L\ & b[Y &- g -e & P e
e^ -
& b-
' 1=
b-
(g( U(
-L
&
'X
^
+
h
+
* (
X ` " (%+ "P-. Y ' (%+-. `"
`"
! "
h-
?,
,I
v
l
, ,
I n
+ `
*-
, , 5 v
?, Z i
v ?I
,v,
?
` v
, n
?
?, I
`9 , 9
! `
?
I
,
, ` n
,
v
P v Z v ?, n
L ,, ?,
I ,
I Z
?,
I
v ?,
v ?, v
?I
3 n
P, $
Z
, iI
, I X
P &J K
n L v v ?, ? ,I
?
) # ,
O
)O
!v z
Z , ?
, N" "
?
I ?, ,
N !!
v t
/
d v Z v L,
/
, ?,
k
?,
$
?I d , S
"
Z
V %
I S )
, , n, P
d I ,
, , , ,
,
/
k, v
` !v n ` , v L,
3 .98 % .X
.8
, 3I
v Z
, ?
Z Z, P
v,
v ,
a
,
n
,
, , 9
z
&
l l
X
?
, I ? , I
vI v
n
a
`
=
` ?
?
l ?
v
, k
?v
,
!v l
L,
` n 9
9 3 I v
v
n
`
,! Z
,I L
Z X
?
L, Pv , `
Ov L
Z
n
I v
, a , %
? % $ % !#"%$%& *
? P l
I
%
')(+*+,.-.( /1012 0 /4310 % !5"6$%& *
k l , t ,
X
$ %
n
/ 7/
283 9: !
zv ?
` iv k /)283 98:
%
P
` ,
I
, O
,
?
Z
,< ;=/)23 98:?>
249@10
A
?
L,
.B.-.(( *.CD;EA
, n
n l
L,
I
Xv
F298@G0 Z
/
283 98:
P
?
z
&
k
L
` H298@10 , I2KJ4B9:MLN2EJB1'10 OH;QP10SR?>
249@10
A
dv , T2KJ4BUC8O)(D;V2KJ4B9:W>YXSZ[ \G]4^S_UA
#
3
?,
` Z v
` v
?v n
Z
, Z ?
z
, /
- `
+
./
^-/
V(
U-.
&(
: +P
[
&-.
- `
)
eP
0=%\ =
P
* &e^
-
V(
, ;:
&`1b 0Y
OP9Q
&
*-
"
8
L\-
"
"
& b -
y 8
, A@)e
( +
`
-.
'e
+4+/
(:, ;:
I
8B
Y
-,
-. V- +
/
u!L
P- + k,
0
P e(
+ P b+ A@/ eP &-*-.
(
U
&
U
&h V.
-. /8
X
A@.
UU &
&
I9 2>IPeP
8
[Y
b-g-.
k
- 65V
" ++ 'ab
&
/} bk
;:
&
U
I+
-4
cY
b-0/[
U
ab ./
;:
-.
_ `
+>Y g-
h b-^e
!
(/(
5/
&[Y
ab .Y7":' /
U 1++
Y
"
(:Y `Y/
)
U
#
`
-0Y
*2*9ILD P -.Y P-. f g *+ h`+ _
- `
`
h-L-4
/_
L -
&
k b-
Y"
/ nYyY/
L\@-
8
( h
X -ab &
+# 0\ *
-0Y 'S"Ad9
?A IT2>GH2>IJ2P "U(k-L U-.
L:+
-
Uab
k
*2*9ILDI2>GH2>IJ2e
eP -LX
-(` &fe
+ U:
( Yy`Y/
+.Y
`)
+
"
-k
`"Y
b- `
"[Y
-
5
'+ *g- & g I9 "2I
)Z `
) *
*-L
$!e
[Y
PL\-
]/
* (
V%
&
k g
.=
0=0\2=
" ' e
U
+.
+h:
b+
*
-- )
jh `
V )e
+4+Y
"
- +
%
` U
/
A@.
eP
& [Y
U 0 `k `
% & 81
% ` )YcZ "L\ &/ 0 `"f b- `
`
&
1/P
I
)%
(
V- +
(b *
+:
'G ?I2L4
h `
-
++ U.Y
*
Z i
?,
A
v ?,
n l 9 n
`
9
v Z,
'
` Xv
?, !
I vI ? v
L,
?,
?A@
HI C 7H HH C " H N H G+F4H C) H RH H
L, n
k
, v
vI
P D n
, , k
, , Z
?,
I
?
n
, I nk
?
v,
/
, , Z
v ?,
Z
n
I
/ n
?,
Z
z
Z ?I
v l ?
Z
,
?
,
n
A ?
n Z
/
k
n
, v `
?,
?
n
av
n
k z
v Z
? >
E II
II C "
C
? [ 4[ %-1(4( *1C;KA ! ` Ov
, ?
?
3 l ,
`
i
I
n
[ \4\G]4^ X S[
` I
v [ \4\G]4^ X [
I z ! t
, ?I
a "!
n / Z
Z , !
, ! Z
, ?
P!
` !v P ! Z
? P a
I
Z
I
? v z
`
Z ?I v z
Z
? v l X , Xv ,v
+
$U- U
V
P
b
! "
,
1 "
++ )
f )
!
Y
"
(-.
- " [ 5+ - `
h -
, *+
-. h
+
%
_
) - k+ )
`"X
"`X%
k
* UL
+ `"
)Y)Z *L\
+/
-.
e _ -
"g!
8e &5/
- b0/c &,
0 b--(: g
4+eP &-
++
` +e
: +
: h)e
-. )- `
b-.Y
!
U
( -4
-.
[Y-g /
UL\@
L
=
*
(b
D
`+ .Y
`
++ +`
`
X
N+
U-
-. e
-.
& V )-. +- "+ + V++ +` [Y
/
Yy`Y/3= +( 0/
- b
V
!
+ .Y
!
+
( ) hW & h+ "*%
e
-. V
" yY
% + -X
+
& [Y
( [
.Y
+Y
"[/b(
! `
'Z & Z
-S/1-8B
0 O10S/
2
01-U(8OG-.(
0
2KJ4B2R)2 =2EJB9!1* E2 JB4B
-" #E[$
2KJ4B2R)2 =2EJB9!1* E2 JB4B!U9 #&&
2KJ4B2R)2 =2EJB9 !1* E2 JB2 0 ' '
+e
k V+
XG'4'G0.28OG0S:1-1(
0
%S
[$
#&&&
#&&
n I
?I
I L, , d
, 5
n ?
v v ?s
z ,
n
`
t P 2EJB28R
2 Q2EJ4BU9 1* 2KJ4BB
-
,
Z 12EJB28R
2 Q2EJ4BU9 1* 2KJ4BB 9
`I
2EJB2R)2 Q2EJB9 1* 2EJ4BU2 0 ' k
Z
n
v
, l , ? z /
n P
,
Z 0 O)C 428R
28OG0+B
L,
(&
"n
/ , g
g# %\
(
`
(
`+ ./
!
*)
b
)
L -.
*- 5`
!
b
!
(g f
- 5`
&
(
5Y
(
!
"
b*(
_
65./
`+
h -.Y & L
h
5Y
(
?
! "
v lv ?,
Z ?s /
,
P k L
i P
?
Z ,
`
z ?!vk v v
,
` !v ?, , a
Ov ,
`
v ?
`
-v v P ?! ,
Z n
v lv L, v i L
?, A z v
v
L ?, # P v v ,
,
?
Z v ,
Z
?,
i
Z ?s
L/
v ?,
v lv ?,
v
?I
?I P ` ,
,
Z
?
,
v
` l
8 8 3/, , w, % .X
.X
Z l
D
, I w
`
l
# X
lv
, ? n
t
AJ J
?I
?
Z
L
n
Z X P
L,
}
&
0h:
nY/"n
L: /
& 69+-
+ "
P
&
he
++
&
g V
k=bA7EB
Z `
2L4B:?682
"
(-.
-. X(
- +Pe
>I9 2>IH/ceP
- ".W-
2?
[/- "-
U [/+
& 1e
(*j+
-.
65-.
(>8
- 4+
[/
8
- +* -.
7EB *2L9=@7L
& %
-.
`*- -
ge
g- 65
"
- "
-
-
?,
vv
-.
,
n , `
? v
?
?,
n
n
"V( 0U
8
I
v ?,
/
U - [
9
g +L\ " L\[/}IT2>AB!?>B,AB:7ED' : -L
'eP -L
Y
8
- 65+ e
`
2+Y
g cY
eP ':
: U
j
n ?d X,
nI n p
Z
l I `
n
,
? vv
9 v ?I n v
L,
9 , a ?X
n
l , v, n #
,
?I
l I
*, 00Y
[/c
( 0!
N` *e
, /
;b
*
U(
`
?354>=bILG7 L
?3c4
B!4"7
(
.Y
f/_23c4687:96;23c4U42A?D
+ k
*2L?3
g V
=
N
! "
'- "-
`"
vI v ?I
v Z I v
n
Z, L, O l
? n i lv,
n,
n
L,
v Z
a J & &
(& $ / $% *
' X
%
. % J K
nv ,
` nv
,,
?, "L
" n
Z
v vv
?
?, v z
v Z v ?I
v Z 9 l
nI
,
?,
:
&-V
` &
)* * ,
.Y g
- !V
)( 0
NN
[Y
'-.
1(
X
L\ '
h
u
U
`b
P+ 65-.
`+ 0Y V
& [++ k )Y ^ ef"./ gef "U. X *L:. P
+
k L -4
&+
"P 65-.
* -.
h &X (g-. ( ;*eP -LU P- P
65-.
P A"
UeP -L
- V
`+
+
P h -.
-.
(
h "f``
X
, 0b0Y
k
n,
&
l , v, $ !
nI 3
I
n
v ?I
n,
&
#
!
& ?3c4
B:47(&)?J%?B,A?>B,AB:7ED/ k
- -
?,
Z
- +* -.
!
P
, ?
X- -
, J
v
&
V
&
, 0
I9
K AB,3 SkGHK 2*2.Y
"
!
!!
/]eP
j
A@/c b
"[Y/g
"
#"
!
! *- -
h
)
=!
,
l , Z
,
=!
=
!
LJ
`
,
. %
,
n
,, ?,
/ , ?I
n Z a, k ` L
Z Ev k n n .%
,, ? . %
n L P ,
? A
, ,
,
P I $
n
L l P,
L
`
n A
P, / `
L L $ # ,
Z,
Z
3 , .
Z '
Z ,I ?, 3 /
.
,, ? , l ,
A , A,
` ,v i
n Z
Z v Z P
O
.%
L L$ .
.
`
d
Z
X
,
Z n
, L
v
,
, P P
n
? ,
O
n
? X /
3
? n
l ,
Z O
(&
?,
` n
?,
?,
I
, , - %
P
I
,
Z ?,
9
?,
Z
, S d k
,X
I
? V %
n k , - %
, 9
)1
)1
1 1
1 1 1
1 1
<
2
1
7
1
)1 41 +2
7 )1 <42 1 +2 1 41 1 )1 1 ;1 1 1 201 1 1 1 1
1 0/ 1
1
1 1
1
! 41 1
"
1
7# $&%
('
1
)
41 -1
+/
1
1 1 </ /
12
(&
jh! "f
X2>3546;7:9682>354k42>Ad?D*M
&
:
Pe^ -
(
+
& `
j
Bj
'(
h :
` +(b
%
P-*e
A@
! " Bj
U
"
(
eP -L
+
j+
+
+
a
g -1( j;
j+ %Y
+
j
(
P
- ( j
+ /"eP
(
Y
j
& ! #
+
*
-Yjh
h 69-
-.
(
j
;e Y P-/ j
j
U, 0* g` U - b eP`" .Y
(&/
+ N, 0
&
- ^
[Y
Z
+
?354 B:47
?354
*2*9ILD?J%?B,A?>B,AB:7ED
j^
P U:
- "
`
&
/ U- "* &-.
Y
: U
)( Lk- L -
*
(
&b(:Yy`
Y/`"
_Y ^
N:
A@
&
&b
mco%pcw.q 0{EouwL;{Ez%wxyx spn~.sp;|:pn.{:|c{Eo%pcw.q 0{Eou|E~p; %;w{ r';wx nz0x w{:p;^vCsrLV{Eop[w~0~.x ;wL{ r'|:{Esp;wLV:owswL;{:ps |:{ ;|}~.xyz|
{Eo%p_op;w0ps_r pns:op8wL.|}8rL y%vsrL{Eop{Esw|E~rs{c~0sr{:r;rx@w%^vsrN{Eo%p_ m
x wLps|;cmcop[sp;wL|:r |[{Eow{c{Eop
rz.
|P{EopPw.q 0{EoXw o p p;UwL{{Eo%pgm
x wpns+mco%pgw o p Lp8+w.q 0{Eo y#{EopPz|:pns |E~w;p |~r|:| y0x pk{:r'.p;{:pns y%p c.z{ {
.pn~pn%0|r'{EopwL8{Ezwx5
x rwL'w%'
%w%0q .{Eo*w w yx w yx C{E vrs ;rLz. ;w{ r*w;{
{ p;| yk{Eo%ppn~r y.{; _p;p { |
%rL{[wspnx w0x pz.~0~ps:&rz.
mco |c~0sr 0x p |[|:{Esr%x ^~.x wL{Evdrs1.pn~pn%0p.{;cmw.x p |Eo%rq}|5p;wL|Ez.sp;p.{z%| y%^rz0s m
L " [
~.x wL{Evrs w qcpcz|:p
{Eo%p{:w.x pw|}w'p .wL~0x p{:r|Eo%rqX{Eo%p_~0sr 0x y%h;r%;pn~%{;
|_qcp.p;|:ns ypx w{:pns brz.swL:t%rqcx p;.Lfpn.{|::op;fpz%|:p;|srz0~ wL:t%rqcx p;.Lfpn.{qco o |_|:p.{wv{:pnswxyxm _| pnx r% y%
{:r{Eo%p;r%| .pnsp;'
%wsp_sp;8p Lp;
Z
Z n,
, # k
,
,
=
?,
$
S %
n L,
j
& -
&g ?
&
Yjh `
-.
+:
&( =
-
X
`
"
v P
I9
P,
i
`
, ,
,
j^e
P
v 9
I
, ,
,
L,
( 0+
*
( 0:
(b
1
"( `
#
Y -
, ,
,
,
n Z
X
& &-
.Y
nI n z
I ?, n t
?,
D `Iv, z
I ?, 3
n, l , v ,
n U
n
n, n
,9
?I
X v, ?
v Z v ?,
n, n z X ! X , E P , ?
v Z /
v v
n
l v, ?
l I Z
n
X , P ,
Z v, ?
J
,
a vI ? ,
l I / , # , a ,9
? k v, ? I Z k v, ?
v `
n, n D
v
J
n Z
/ , ? ,
n
n, n
?I
v
n,
n
,
n, ?/
,
i ?
n
k
n,
vI (
9
X
nI
?I
Z
/, v
Z
n, ?X
n,
v,
?9
k
X Z
n,
, v,
n,
?,
, Z n,
?k
i Z
I vv E
?,
I
I
Z
nI
,
Z
`
,
?
Z
,
-h`
"U( ;e
- "* &-.
.Y
i!
g * L *
0Y
P- -
*- "-
"
,
&
h
kZ `"
V( L "#
* *(
h f
N- -
( e & [Y g- ^- N( e 1 & b-.
& '
UI2nSBEGH7:2>I
- -
N
&
--;:
'
#
- "-
L 9-g `
[
&
-- .g
h(
1(
[/ !
g- -
U
#
#
+- `Y
+
e
(&Ue
.Y ^
-
2+>Y
, "!8
,
( Le
g- -
- -
!8
E h:
e
- 65
- -
:
"X
P eP
+
-Y
Machine A
Sender
(Initiator)
Machine B
Broker
Broker
Receiver
(Initiatee)
RegisterService
OpenConnection
OpenConnection
AcceptedRequest
AcceptedRequest
ListenForConnection
n,
Z `&! "-
, v J
J
Z , iv
, ? d
n D
v, L
D
?
,
v J
K
` Z
n, n # n Z X
g( - #
, " g
L `ge
- -
J
Z l P / vI ?
, !v
v
/ I vv l
Z ? d P ?
Z vI ? , ?v `I
he
n,
U` Uab ;Y
U ( ;
, [Y
= .)
v ,
n,
"
./
? , ?
,
?
?
"X
u
j
,
'(
?,
'
t
v
v , l
l
Z L
n,
k
?,
,,
n, i
n, i `, v ,
lv v ?, ! D ,
A v ,
" `
- -
& .Y-
+
- -
" `
"
. VL\
# g 0% , (k -'e^* +- -
5[/ h+
(
!$
V e
&
! "
"
L
;:
?
-&
+ b( !
!
-*
.Y
-
Z "
k W
`
k
k
-
-.
"
, 0k
L " 'L\ "a * 1 " ,
"+ X * 9- k , ( ;U-. ( & ;XeP &-
: -P
-.
0Y
&, 0h
a 8)
+ " g $a + 0/ k* * , % 9-
+
bV
&
h
&(h`
Y
!"
& X
`
&
;e P-
&
TRANSPORT LAYER
Application
Application
Timestamp
List
Send
Data
Recv
Queue
Recv
Thread
Retry
Recv
Thread
Thread
ATM Network
I
Z `H
!
[ 0
)+*
v ?, L
` i Z
, X
nI
? n, v, O
,
k
?, L ` A
?
vI
,
,
n `
U
&
-
-
& [Y"
jP0Y
L
"
A@k
j
-
&
&
! "
?
Z ?
"
g,
0./]+
j
k
-L U
` ,
Z
?
?
P) ) ;v
?, D
,
, a ?
D
v ?,
,
`
Z
9 `
n lv,
`I v ?,
, X
P , L l
Z
Z
? a ?
`!
N ` Z A , X
N Z
, n,
n, ?
,v
Z v
/ ,
?I
vI
, i v , v ,! n , a L, l
n vI
/ ?I ,
?, X
l
, ,
P P,
, X
, ?, ,, ?I
n l I
=
l
lv,
Z , Lv
n
X
J J
' n
n, Z
Z
n
8
n
l
n P a
v ,
J
n
z n
n
n
n vI
A,
n , A
n ,
?
l, L "
E ,
/ #
`
I
I
I ,,
, P L
, I P a l I
i n lv,
, l ,, , a ?
P n 9
Z Z l n
,
/,
O
,
I
k , l ,,
I
n v l I
9
n
v
X
n
` ? L
n
n `
1 411
42 1 1 )1 4 1 1
1 <2 0/ 1
;
1
<
2
%
1
1
1 1
41 <2 1 ;1 1
1 1 1 1 1 <1/
1 <2 !1
11
0
)1
1
01
)
(
(
(
k -
j
j'Y
*(
'
:e
&
[Y
^-. U(
j
h
&
h -.
SI9=
b
-.
(
*
--
h.
j
: +
g
k
5\
+
(b .Y
&
*
h &`
0P(
- U(
f
j
L ;
(
+
j
ge _: f
g:
9GB:7EBEJ%2g?K
359
A24>S0*23c7M
! "#
(
k.
-L
j
*-LX
hb*(
P
j
[Y"n ! #
-
j
+ j
- bU
.Y
& ! #
( L+
k -.
j'Y
[Y
&
j
- I
U
Y ' &`+!-
&P-L' 0 &
R .C !
U -C
C !
2
:-
j^.Y
(:(2+
S"IT9=
352nSb?7EBEJ%2
ab-
)
*
+ (
hb
h
&
('
--
C#!
C#!
[Y
j^
+
-g- &
U c
"
C#!
R
?K
359
A2L4S0*23c7kM
f
jP j
0'(
[/
[Y
L "
2 kYI
C !
"
-g- X
mco%pnspwsp{EswL.p;r |_z| y%g{Eo |_|::o%p;pL[mco%pwL w.{:wLp |_{Eo%wL{ yv5 )| ;p |}x wsLp b{Eo%pngx wsLp:oz0.t.|_rvc
~%wLx rwL
w spg%rL{P;r~ p8"Xmcophr pns:op8wL |P{Eophw0 { r%wxx |:{grv
~%ws{:| qo :oUqcpnsp r Lpnsqcs {:{:pnU.*{Eo%ph{Esw%|E~rs{o%p;wL.pns|^vdrs
sp;{Esw|: |:| rk~.z0s:~r|:p;|;mco |_r Lpns:o%p;w ||:wxyxw%h{Eo |fp;{Eor |p P pn.{ yvc{Eo%p
! i
v ,
I n ,
,
n lv,
, n ,
9
X
, l i
)
Z,
Z
a
z
?,
Z
n, n l ,
z
` A n
I n l ,
,
, ,
n l I
jP
-
`
,
&
/ 8
T!
k
(
!
A@
&
M@
n
k-
&
n ` ,
n Z
v `
? Z
I
,
v ?,
/ i
n Z n, n
n `
i
L,
v ?,
? v ,
?
P
, X
l ,
?
n
I ,
n
, ?,
n Z n, n w
n
v L,
d
, # ,
D
n
vX ,
? L
n
, ? Dv
- & .Y '
L
[
X M@':
(
&-.
YB
+-LbI *(
- `h:-
! "#
n Z
k (
U. -L
!C#!
h
&
Pv
h
Y
- I
-
,
?a
n l I
P
? v
V k-L
[/
' U-+
*+ U,
(
eP .
: U
!-
-.
g- -
& %
#
j
abY
& Uh
U
h.Y
ZP
z
Z nv
C !
*
X.Y
!v
I
C !
-j
Z ? P
- &
PP P X - b eP&` _: P f " heP g j
"[Y
h
n Z
n ,
,
v ?I
k ?I
z l n n ,v,
v ?,
` n Z n, n v
D i A
` v ?,
& j^ ( &h `
-.
k- `a *
)-
n
P. + P & j^- ` h &-.
+
0Y/" b
j
k-LbI
[Y
"
)-LbI
I Z l
?
l
,
? P
v
X
, l
n
,P
! z, l
v vv
v
I i
l
n I, v
(& ` Y
j
++ Y
"fE ./
(
_
# ` k
a
Z l ,
,
I
L
L,
n Z , n,
, ` /
n Iv, n `
Z ?
?, n
, P
E n ` n,
P
n ` /
X
.
j'Y
`
Y
`+
(b
&
& .Y
[Y
-
ab
-&
, l ,I
.Y
P- &` &
_-.
c- ` j^
8
/#! g
! ! N ) ) *
5 h
KP
+ ; ``
1C !
*-
- 5
h U
E
P e./
jP.Y
f2AB:?BEAB!7ED
n
`
IT2>AB!?>A2'+ bY
V
- !
`
k(
"n
L\-
&
"
+#
"
&`
V:65
+- +
U
J@?I7EB:?A,AD
Z
P
Z , ,
A ?
Z ?
i
,
`X`"
.Y
U
N
*"1(b
'
d ,
` /
v vv
v
,
?,
n
l
,
?
I
v l , n I,
Z P l , X
L
, ? v
i
v X Z
P ,
, ! 9 L P Z v ` Z
I
v z v
v l I L O
, ,
vv
Z
v ?,
, , v
,
v
L, v l
? D
,
a
,
v ` ,
v ?,
&
J
Zd
,
X, Z
/ ! ,
,
,
n9 ? `9 , k
k ?
n , ,,
n ? v
n v , v n
vv
n,
n ?
n v ,
n 9
,
Z
?, n X
?,
n,
I
nI
` ?
?, z
,
v ?, Z,
n ? v ` ,
,
I
?
`
n Z
?
nI v Z ? ? v
v ,
,
('
, 9
L /
`
v lv L, a
`
` L, 9 L
n
D
?,
l
a , X
P
?,
,
Z
vv P P /
,
, X
z , X
k
I ,
, , l
a
l
,+/
&
GH2>354
`+` L
I2LK2>B,J2h L
&P- 65[Y
"*--X
-.
N(U
- 65[Y
+ b
:
+
*(
' L
[/(
* ( ;
U. e
*L\-
5+e
V b-
- , +e
h -4 ^e
-L
*
`
-
g,
0geP
- -
g-
`
` P- "
X
[
*b
-
PE
."
& [Y
h -4" Pe
"* b
b
-. '
g V
) - , e
he
h-. )(
.Y
- 65-.
&
&k:
(
Y
g
- -
(&
f "
u207:?K ?
A2P42>GHK>IB 57:9ILG
U 0\ *
, 0'* k*-L) )
[
^:
* "
L -
-
0Y
) + `
,
0.Y
NGB
_Y g
'- 5`"
j
-.
X(
- "5`)b
++
*-L `
-. Y
&!.
j
,
0.Y ' A@
^ e./
&
`
P
A@./
(b
&
"*-.
j
A@
-. [Y
.* #
N
,
v, , l
' v I
?
?,
P 'v , , X
,
? P, Ov L
v /,
/ Z, n ?I
z n , Z L , Z ?
A n ` ,
,
!
a , # L L , lv
?
av , k ?, 9
/I Z
L,
i
?, a, 9 Z
,
` !
v ?,
/,
n l I P z
9
L,
n, L /
?,
Z,
`
n
P n vX
3 l
P, / n, a
,
? av /I
, ,
l, / n3 t
k
Z3I
Z v ?I
, , l
?
/,
I Z
n l ,
v , `
?, X
n
L
, ?
, i
n, L
(
-
Q523c42IL6GLB:42
_B*24689=7E684?"7:?
gB,GK?IT4
"
&
1G23c4U L
(L:
D35?
B:Kk7EB *2>I
%
+ `V
%
)
$
+ 0L ` `
P b
"
-+Y
j
L * "`
+.Y
LL . `
+
"
&
&Y
)
[Y
+/
-
U
.
L
_:
-
hb
"
k:
U
Y
[Y
gI2KL2BEJ%2_
` 0Y
=0=
g
:
&
k &
N
kI2LK2>B,J2 L
[Y
kG23c4h
&-.
*;:
?4 L= GH7*23c7 E
+
*,
0
-. -g)e
-.
"
"
*-LU
+
+
z
Z
v n
,
,
?, I
I ?, ,
, ,v
$
,
I
, Iv
I
Z ?
, ,v
$
k l
I ,v
!
? , ,v l &
I ,v 7)! l ?vI , ,v /
?v, , ,
l
,
, Iv ,
X
, ,v,
v
, ,v 4\P ,
, ,v
, 1/
9 *1C 1O
(;KA ,
,
)
L ?
Z v 1/)9+*.C 1O)(D;EA
`
,
Z , 2 0 O)9O)9EB.0S/ ;EA n P,
*
Z L
v
,v
L L
? > E 7H" " 4 H 7C DF0H C) E H H
v n
, ,
,
,
I
,
v
l
A
!
2
k
l ?, `
, , Z
, ?v v, n P ,
O x
D `
`
Z &
O
` ,
,
l
!! !! !! !
2
= Z
L
` ,
l l Z P
v Z ,
av Av ` ,
` z Z
` , ?
v ,
Z Z ? k
,
,
Z ` L k
, I
?
` Z ?
?
?
L,
n / v nv9 i , n
?
?,
k
H[G0+B %-1(4(+*.C;KA
v D
? E 7H" " 4 H 7C C " C 4E H H
X
`
?,
d ` ? !v
`
n
?I
,
!!
n
! v
!v
v
, v
nv
,
!*
A
! )
`
,
k ?k 9
?,
I
n, v
)$
?I
n, v !*
!
$ ?,
,
` L, z ` ? a
, Z
n
,/ $% *
n
. 41 )1 2
)1 ;1 1
<2 1
2 1
1
)1
V)
0
gL
Y - , !gL
/
/
(
& ;
$
`
;'-, 8
'
heP
`' & ;
!
k `
-.Y
0=
k- -4
U [Y
0H/
e
!
+'&
U(
-b-1(
"[/
+ - [
h `h
- b
- bk `X
` .
+
'(
'U
&-.
*(
h g(bk- + `h
-. -k
]/
-. -+
1(%=
& k
L: /cek X h k X-. -L*U `+ h`" Y
k.
:e
-L
( 0" &+
&`h 8
&.Y
:
( 0 0HL+/
L (Y
+
E =Y
k &
Y V*
& Y heP
* (
& %e
(
N `
L
-
0J]/
/
^ ef"./ k 8
+:
+
'- "
(:
U"
_`+ L\ ./c
-4c/c
/c
V &(
0/
)+ /
h+
L\-
"
- 5Y
-.
3(:Yy`
Y/e
- +* -.
"
-.
g
& &-
g
`
-L
)
IE^=
k
E 4+/ !
-.
! "
.
d
"[YXZ
+ /_
I28B
Ne
++
)e
1(
[/Yy`
Y/
)(
U/geP -L
)(
U. 1(
h-.
k h
8e &5/
I 8'
$Z:8#
-
[ 0
j
. .Y
`
|cwuw pnswLp}%w%0q
"
Xe
-.
mco |
& &1Z:8
-[Y he
V( e
! " ke
P P [Y
$P=
3II#!
+>Y,"n*-L'-.
0/ +
-.
/
( e
)
L
,
n ?I /
$ n
vI
0$<$
` n,
Z ?,
n
n, !
I
, /
N
n
X
?I
, l
E
,
,
)
Z
X
Z
N
v
nI
eP.
-
h
.
(
e
)(
&f
1)(4+
:
!
U
( e
;".
! *,
!
`
(
e
-
[Y
N(
# %\
-.
h
+(k
5 X
*U 0\ *
P-. U(
;! "#
-P [
)(./
)(./PeP &-
;! "#
-
=
P
9
g( e
8e `
;: U
-./ P `h
b-
./
+
)(
' b- ./! h - &*( e & .Y g"*( e # eP
-
( e &
(
kL\]
+/
Z
? d , , A
#
!
n,
, v
Ov
i n
I 9
,
/ ?X v ?, n
?,
,
?,
l
Z
`
- +* -.
.Y
)(P "
: U
):
(
'
X
+ +( e
h P
;! "#
-
(0Y?g eP
45
Transport Protocol
Fore AAL3/4
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
0
Z `
?
& -
( +k%
&
?,
-.
..
1 " 7 )1 <2
20
25
30
Reserved bandwidth (mbps)
35
40
45
50
(>
_\- `-g.
2+^ .Y -L
( e
P Z P A
n
Z
?,
n
,
X
n
?,
?, X
1 <2
)417 )1 )1 1 $ 1 8201
41
)1 /
"`
+
&`
&
15
10
!
? `
?,
U+
<2 /
1 1 0/
`
++ b
5-.
+ b
)+ 7g
+ U. -.
& *
mco%p
g0~%|P;rs:sp8|E~r%0| {:r {Eo%pgr pns:op8wL+z..pns E{ opPvrxyx rq y% w|:|Ez~{ r| wxyx
.p;rkvswp;|{Esw|: {:{:p8+r Lpns {Eo%p
;r0%p;;{ r|[wsp "vswp;|
w,rz.s h
m
~0sr{:r;rxb|:p;pn.{:|
y.{:rw|:p;{rvbm
_|qo : oPwnsp;w{:p
w.z0s|:{c%w%0q .{Eokr pns w|Eors{}~ps rhrv{ p %w%g{Eo |}.
z0s|:{[w.q 0{Eo'fwPp_x wspns{Eo%wu{Eopfp;w w.q 0E{ o %rs
=N
?, Z
Z
P P Z P A
, a
P
? v
?,
&
9
? ` a
&
n, v Z &
? Z
v Z n,
, ? /
,
P ` ?
Z ,
?
?,
Z
k
v `
X I ?,
I v v
`
n, a n ` ?
=D(p# ,,?XXs3Dn?#?,r(a,S
? #I+?a=,P /, ,I(
4 I/(,,np(?`I#Gw??,I
as,pP ?s?Dn ?? = `4/ , (? ?=
s ?,9p?,p(rp#Dn
sp ,IoD,? /, p? ?=
s D?I9(?,((rpX,,?,
vp(=D?,,( p /,p/P ,
,DwO,n
/I(p/(
9 ,6s
,p/ nZ, ,p,, ,I DDn , (I=`?(ss (/,p(I,n(p/^(X,p,,(
?p#(Z,,D?^
^(a,pn
r,pD oXp` \
! `I ?`"#s"% $ pnUXU Op
,p,/IoPD ,,I ,?(,& # LI,?,D n? ??I?\s,6s ,,,,(IoDp (
,-D ?n , s n#aL(4sk D,nGw((D ,(p
'
! ,- D(Z\8 s ,DPndXO Op
,,DD ,p, p s p, sD^oZ,?`4 XO',,np( rp#D?,,
rp, p/ P($ ,, ( I,?, ??I\s
,IDoDn I,?n,& ##LL4s Dn ??,6s
,- ?, s
'
,aD,P r r, ,)X)X,I,,p ( 4 ?=`^4 ,XrO,',,,an(p( ,In((
,p / In 4 r,,p/,p(,,np(
*- +* -.
`
_
* `
I2S"B,G7EI?7EB:93
KL93
352LK.7EB:93X2G7:?ABEG
(& %e
k -
&
i
[/
2>357
?354
`
&`
V
Ujh# - & P- YZ h '
K93
352LK.7EB:93X7:2L?I6;49
3cY gB " &f-.
,
_ eP_ e
9- &
=)
&
+' "`
[Y
Video Server
Video Client
SUN Sparc 10
SUN Sparc 10
, Z n
Z `
.Xd 8
vI
, P
?A@ EH H H I
I
,
v
, , 9
v ?, l
.
(
e^ " ++
"
_\ +
s=1
, Z
n Z
U `
%e
*e
18
+`
= E
- + g `L
+ "
X
n
E&+`
V
'- &`/
-. (cW
./]
++
Z `
+
=I(:-,+g
0:
=I(:-,+g %e^
= (:2+P %e
`L
=
+`
, 0h `
.
1 1
{:{:ps
:
+
^
| ;rL~0z%{:p;hwL|
=0J
h "
(: ': +
+`
(
.Y
Y P `
,+>/eP -L
Y
+' "
k
^ b--
-&
J
-Lke
=^!
P
(
!#"%$
">$
%" =
0:g
`
-
`
-. (&W
5
E .
L (g `
- g
`
i1-. b "
&
- 651 b
[Y+Z `"
, ?,
, `
(: 1=Y }
+ ,
0b i
g `L
=) %e^
">$
./
? /+ ,
O , P a v ,
` ,
?
I
P
Z `
l,
l
X
v
v
X
v d
!v !*
!
I
v I ,vI $ !! ZX
,
Z
!
)
I Iv, 9 7 ! 9
9I l
,
, ,vI
!
L
I Z
, `
, , X
9 L
Z
L ! P
n
#
, `
` `
, t 3
/
v
!v
X
v !
v !%*
)
P
*
!
,
D,
%1
1
1 $ % %
Z &`
g-.
(
% V
(E:4+Y
"
, 0' `
I ?,
I Z
,,
ef "b
Z !v
,
I
, , Z
`
v ?I
?
v ?I
,
, Z
V
0
;! "'
b*(
[ bL\ [e
`7 ,
/=Y Y
, ,
, , U
X
Z
v,
v ?I
n
h 1
)
\@
+ ;
;e *+`
=
.Y+Z `
/5
=I(:2+
!
- `/
:
-. (
800
800
10fps
700
700
600
600
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
10fps
500
400
300
500
400
300
200
200
100
100
0
0
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
500
600
700
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
w
500
600
800
800
4fps
8fps
700
700
600
600
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
4fps
8fps
500
400
300
500
400
300
200
200
100
100
0
0
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
500
600
700
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
P =
+' " * J
Z
, k !
, ,vI
v ,
)!
n ` v
!L
: +
E .
=
0
&-. (5W
`
!
Vk 0
` "(
/ P
5
=1E
[Y
J)
=
0:
U
600
700
=)
(
.Y
Z ?
/I
O
I
,
I
: +
P
v,
l
,+ J
0Y
!v
v L,
L hb
&,
A
!g
`
%
0J
+,+heP -L
( !
,
&** &P+`
#
!+`
v
e
_\ ; +
- _ fL
,vI
)!
! P
?,
&-. (W
/#
_\ + ; Y"
U
k n v A
`
nI
,
` Z,
I Z
I , w
k 3 `
I z
v
e
*
0:g
`
U, `" PW
( 0 .Y
(%J
500
X
`
!,
Iv,
)!
Zk
, )
)
,
, Iv,
/ , D Z v
Z
? > F0H C) E H H H I
/ ,
, Z
, I Z
z
, Z
Z &`
700
E .
`L
3
, v
?I
i
, l P
X
,
`X
,,
N
, Z
, Z
, , #
l
v ?I 9 l
? !
, `
i `
, '
n
!v
!
L,
!*
)
?I
?,
* )!
?,
D
I Z
ZX
Iv,
!
, ` a !
, Z !
#
, Z "
, Z 7
?
, Z v
,
Z
?
C
" C H I
/ ,
?,
k n v
i
n
, Z k
n,
n
n
?, , l ` n,
X v, n
I
?, Z
, Z
L,
, Z
`
`,
v Z `
Z
Z
v Z
n I
,
,
z
Z
`
Z `
v L,
?
I I
v `
Z P ,
P , , `
, ` ?
v `
` v
z v Z L X
`
v
?, X
l v Z
v
?,
!!%* !
n
!v
?I
"* ! '
n
v
?, D, Iv,
!
Z ?9 ,
,
Iv, 7 ! v
?I , ,,
!!
D
v Z
I Z
I Z , ,
Z
?
X
X v `
!v
, X
k
v Z
?I
*
n
!v
?I
N *
n
` v
?,
%*
n
?, ?
*
n
?I , Iv,
X
v Z
Z ? P, '
Iv,
v `
`
k
vv,
?X ? dv
L,
Iv, I v !
v Z
v
v Z
,
v /
v Z
,
L, l
, n I k
Iv,
Z
I
`
, I
I ,
v, n
, Z z Z
?,
v a
- 65* b
[/
ke
*
(A! U/
!+4+P )
g
!
,
J
# "
, 0
#
`
%
U 1
)
/(%J
+
(
+
' 0L `W
Z `
#
:
Eg/f
_\ + ;=: 0:+`
_\ + ;=: :+`
V
"
."
! "
- (
Y H+
-
U &
5Y
"n
!L ^ ,
&
k `L
, 0* `L
& [Y
Z `"
)(4+k
`
& -(%
+
`
U/
E
&-
;(%
E
& ( P
U
E . `)
X%
U/ J0J
(%
-. (W
`L +(
+
+ }+
Y
E
H
&
- +
[/
e W
+
&-. ( W
( +Y
YGJ)(4+
! " !J0:
&
:'-
"u (%
_
:
Eg/
YGJ)(4+>/
& %e1L Y
E
U/ JLJ
E /]
P b--0Y
, 0
U/
=
(%
c++
Eg/;
_\ ;=0+ - " c ;e f- "- [
`
, 0+
[/
:
[/
`
+/ +`
f =
L+
.
V%
(%#
]Y )
(4+Y
,
0 `
-. (W
J0:P- Pe
P 0be
\@
+
hL ^
"[/b
(%%
(:-,+
C
8
!.Y_Z `"
V%
%
V'e
k `
(
- ./
- .Y
:.YgZ `
(:(2+k
P + -
B5 L\@
+ B(%%
X#
%
Y =+
++ b 65-.
E++`
:
E Y V
[Y
\@- !
'
, 0
_\ & ;= =Y +
L - h & U ` P `X ) 'U - &.Y * U' "`
:4+/
E ( 0 .Y
Y L=
\@
+ ;=
f
%!
/# %
X
/# %
= (:(2+/e
;ef $
`
U/=
# "
/ = +4+k
_\ + ;=0+}-
+`
GH
\@
+ ; Y7" +.
`"
1
P
- 65U b
[/
e
C
(b
.
+`
/
e'
0k;: +
&
e
, 0 +c `
U+.Y
"1
800
800
10fps
700
700
600
600
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
10fps
500
400
300
500
400
300
200
200
100
100
0
0
50
100
150
200
Frame Number
250
300
350
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
w
500
600
800
800
3fps
6fps
700
700
600
600
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
3fps
6fps
500
400
300
500
400
300
200
200
100
100
0
0
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
500
600
700
100
200
300
400
Frame Number
Z `
500
600
700
v !v
k,
Z v Z
n
Z
k Z,
v, v Z ?
! ,
Z
/
, !
, I Z
, `
`
,I Z
?
I l n,
Z v Z
z
v Z
Z
I 9
?X v Z , X X v Z
v
X / v `
v
?,
"* ! ' n
v
?,
* ! ' n
)
`,
!
,
?,
Z NA, '
av
P
, `
, Z
I , k
` v Z a ? ,
?
!
? i
l
Z P `
v Z
l
v ` X
700
UP+`
X Ue
l
v Z
\
?,
(
?,
*
%
U/
(%
+
0:( J)(4+}:
&
2(:(2+^
/ -
_Y
-L
\@
+ ; +
%:!
- "1L\@
+
- _ Y_Z ` 2( L+c - k "` +ce
& [Y
ab
, &U* &h- ' ' +*-L) `h( e V &`
J
"
(>
( +Y
_\ & ;=0+g-
=0H
U/
+
k bk
\
J)(4+h
( !
b--k
k +h
g & '"f
+- "`
+ *(
+,+
ka
8 -18
g
( 0
! +
.
^
+
+
;e &
Y J
YGHN"
JY 0
J
JY
:4+
Y ) L
=! Y k
, 0+ `
v Z
v
?, X
P
v
?,
"* ! ' n
Z
v
* ! " n
z v `
v
?I
!%* !! '
v
?,
* ! ' n !
D,
!! =
, v Z
Z ,
?,
?,
v v
,
t
D
`
,
v
, x
l
, Z Z
, a,
, n
,
vI ,
I
v
? E "!C
C
H I
I J
& ('
,
L,
l n
'
v
, ?,
Z
I
I ,
?
n
Z
3 # I
`
, N"
?
v z
v
L !
, , ` v
z
!%*
Z
`
, , v D Z l Z v `
X 8 , ?
Z ? v Z ,
v ? '
A I
v
L, 7! !!
)
, 1 * 9
k l
v lv
!v
,
` ?,
1
Iv,
Z /
A
Z ?,
`
, `
Z ,
/ v Z v
?,
v Z ,
v, Z ,
v
I
N"
? !
l
n
v Z ,
, ` A X
Z k
,
` ?, . ! 1 *
z
v
?
Z v
Z
v ?, v A
n
n n ?
n
,
?,
Z
( -,+h
2
v Z
,
n !
Iv,
U-
- `L
"
h+`
e k . +,(%J
! N !4+
0= Y =0*
HY Y H*
!Y = 0=Y "0 *
ef k . +,(
Y !)+
(>
*
%
eP.
J)(4+/[
!
`L
+ .
+,+ ! "
C
V) 0
7(%#
efh 0'
ACB
)%
U/G=
0:
+ 0
7(%
+
:ab
U/G=
)(4+YP
*
-. (
[Y
-
-
b- P ^e
2(:2+
U k eP
- b `
;!- *-.
E
(
C
"
- .Y
GD35K
[Y)Z &`
%!P `L
$
J)(4+/
U/
(%#
0:h
( ;ef
k &
"
+
&
jh
+
U/
)(4+
;ef
I!
^ %
e
& .Y
` e
+:.Y
&
15 hL\@
+ g
k
C
h X( - `
' (
f
+
e
`
`1(
e
%
k $ 8e &
k P:
) E
0=0\2=
HLH
`
L++FGIH
GHLJ
*- &
:
he
-+ '&e
( - ` 1 [Y
XZ `"
&e
% &
&
*`
N+
"
*
` #
eP ge
: +
(:(2+/
ke
'- )L\@
+ ./
eP
^- `
\@&
\
0=0\2=
#
C
$
h
(
0+_+e
%
-
^ &
9-Y
*- NL\@
+ '
& e
- +)e
i!gj
L\- g:
-.
+
& Ue
L+P+.Y
X -
500
500
10 fps
450
450
400
400
350
350
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
10 fps
300
250
200
300
250
200
150
150
100
100
50
50
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Frame Number
350
400
450
500
100
200
300
Frame Number
w
400
400
350
350
Intra-frame time in ms
Intra-frame time in ms
5 fps
10 fps
450
300
250
200
300
250
200
150
150
100
100
50
50
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
Frame Number
300
350
400
450
100
200
300
Frame Number
X Z
v
/+. ,
.9
?A@ BDCE8 H
` ,,
,
,
L,
!
)C
U .
Z `
I
nv
Z I
K8/" '
C
A
,
?,
--f
b
3F
v
- 3( +_ ;e
`
=
, &!=Y Y -
E ;
" -,
./ #
-
8BH0J K;Y
v ?,
Z
?
9
` i
&
&
,
/ ,,, A `
,
D a v , n
, ,,, P
`
-- +
-I!
600
8
-.
& h
V(b)"
` ".Y/C %
/3Ch /_
Vi 7FGCC i H0J K ++
500
[Y
`g
FG !H
400
+f+. [: - +- * ' ` +e
g kb
600
500
5 fps
10 fps
450
500
500
Z `
400
g
-, -.
gB:2I?IK
B:KL?A
:
Q5K 24=bA2I
20
20
without-cross-traffic
with-cross-traffic
10
10
5
Skew in ms
15
Skew in ms
15
-5
-5
-10
-10
-15
-15
-20
-20
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Frame Number
700
800
900
1000
100
200
300
400
w
500
600
Frame Number
700
800
900
1000
X
?,
?,
v X
9
?,
v X
?,
v !
, L v
n
nI 9v
n,
k i
Iv A
?, 9
n ` ?
,v
?
?
O Z ?
n I,v,
` #
L n
` L, ?, 9
,
? ,
?
n ` v ?,
` 9 ?
n
Z
?I
, `
I nv I
v
n ,
,I i ,
? O
d
` P
J
, nI
L, ,
Z ,
,
vv
, `
I , I3
J
J
,
?,
v
I
, n v
?, I
Z ,
, ,
D
I v
,
,
, X P
?
Z,
, ` k,
, , ?
, ` ?,
?,
I P
,a , n,
z
?
, v `
n
,
Z
, L Z
v A
?,
d
Iv
n
?
, v , Z
, lv ,
O
? 3 ,
A ? Av n
?
J
) U
O,
?
` 3 ,
I
X
n P n I I ? Z
! n , L, Z
A n , l , ? Z
Z ?
,I
,,
,
l , Z
?, 2 av
Z
Z
L, P
,
d
` J n
,
Z `
e
8%
-, -.
`
Q57:?I7E687EB*2
P
+e
"(bW-
P
-
-.
&
h
"
&e
eP &-
U(
L
"U
++
b-L M@.
('-L +
& g +` L a h h- 65-' + ?
(kL\-
& b-.
&' "
U
&e
,
-
f2>GH2>IJ2Gf ( -
k:
8BH0J Kh
+b
-g ;
8 .
&
.W +
-Y
1=
8
GH?S 2kBE3
`
e
Y
%
&-
he
Y;
I9.KL2GLGH9I
ab
-
!#"%$
g
+Y
P- -
+:
`"
? @?K>B!7ED
- + ".F
&
h
( - "
2ILB!904/
IT2>GH2>IJ2g '
P &
E
c9
23
g
&
k ( -
[/}-1
8P L &
8
FG
gL\-
K &f
.
. 0Y
& b-.
/8
!
65-.
- )
&
+# -
&
-
h -
k
`
[BEI7E=@?A A90K B
g` )Y
-L b-
- 65P
hg
#
jh `
=@K
2.7:Y '
--L
X
I2L<=2G7:24
b- `
+:
[
8
[
h(
H ,K ++
F
@2>ITKL23c7:?Sb2^ `
- +
0b
V -;g
-L
&
k-& eP
-&.Y "
- - P
[Y P-
++
&
-.Y
2?A B *2
@KL?AEA M
]R
"
^ 4EB j
!#"%$
k "
I /
, l 9
v ` L
Z
k L , P
I ,
,
L a
l
I z ?
,v
i l n v
n X
?
, , l 9
,
&J
J
,
#
` 3
&
,
'
'
, ,v ,
I ,v
v
z n 3
I ,v L
, I v
,
Z , Z ? D
v
v
I ?,
?,
Z
v n
? F0H C)
, L, ,
` n I
d L
, ?
#
I
z N
BU( *.CPH;!-S:4:/W> ( 0 A > B (+*.CPH;- :4:/W> ( 0 DA I
Q- :4:4/ -S::4/.( 0 TBU( *.CP1-1(4(;KA > B U( *.CP1-1(4(;KA
9
`
,
(+*.CPH;* A ,
L
Z 9
Z ,
v v
, ?
,
, ?
,
v
Z,
? ,,
I
/v
D
,
,
` ,
!v
, Z Z
v ?,
I `
L, ,
, ! J
(& &
v
`
? I ,v O a J
(& &
n
? , Iv ! D , ,v
v
v I ,v
D `I
? ,,
,
, Iv
!
n,
? F I UHG C " C C C " C I
,
Z
,
,
, D
v,
,
, , n
`
!
n D v
,
I
& &I N , L, , 7 D Z 7 n )
&
` L,
v n
)
v n
Z n Z ? Z
)!
, L, a
?,
# Z
v,
n Z
, D ! I
Z
` l
n P
v ?,
v , 9 D
L
, ,
n
,
J
) X
D , I
n i
n
? ?, Z
?, I Z Z , i
n '
v Z
`
'
n l I
Z
n
l I
)
, Z n, ' A `
v
? v !v
n Z
Z
v
b &
&b.Y
-L8
L\@-
P
, *
'
k 65
- ( ;
h -8
L\-
-
8-L
VU
%
&
*(
I7 , &?g
[G2IL6A2J2A
"%$kY
`
^
F
-,H
b
P &
-Y
`/
e .Y
"
8
& [/
- & `U ;e
HLJb/BEH K8/ [
-.
FGE IH
!
/j
^i
/j
e )e
`
b
k (
IT9"7:9.KL9A G7:?K /
F IH
F H
( +
FG# !H
2
9ID
hb
"+- )Y
b- " -
K8/_
):
[/]ef
h?7EB,J2
8
;e -
[BEIH7E=?A
( [ P . + b- ": * &* ,
-
h2*?3c46 ?Sb2L4
b
&-.
-
I2>G 9Ad4
IB:9ILB!7ED'7
K8Y
8
+ L
-.
9-
*
X
,
k( - ^`.
P
b-./ h
b
;P& %e
+
!
!
b- `'
F b4H K[
ILB!9ILB:7ED#7
"
b \g
!
Fyj
k*-
FGEZ
! 5Y
I!
;
- Y
!
-.
-. & e P b- g -4h- L '`
K8Y
-4 -4 L\ f "f h`" &U+ Y h+
5\@
8^
!
8
"
`
b -
8 ^
[Y
, /=Y Y
b-./
g N -L
F IH
-
!
K u
"
, T!
(%=0+h
( + &
+ , 0
8e &
P(b
e
M@
- 65-.
&
y
N- 65- (
&L
-
`[Y
'
&(
X Ve
-
(b
K8/^
*
+ L\@&
(% +)
-
P .( 0+
- nY
,
?
, d k
, I
Z
,
L,
,
?
2
v
,
Av n, vv v v
`I l n,
'
Z ?s
n
?I `
,
vI
, , ,, ,
,
D
?I I
J
/ `
Z n
v ?,
Z
?,
,
' v l ?
Z
L, X Iv,
, ? Z ,
?, I n
X , ` I
` v
,
a
?
n,
L,
Z ?I
,
n
n,
, l
v n
` v n n
Z
?,
, I
Z
Z Z,v
v
Ld
n
J
I
P P
, ? l
)
k B
v Z ?
v ?,
` v ,
, ? `
, ?,
I
I , Z
,
Z , P
n, n
I
l ?, d , k ` v
n, vv z
vv, k
&
(&
J
?
v ?,
I , d
Z I
l I Z
9
Z ? ,
n
? vv L
k ,
,
` ,d
I w
X Z
v
v nv
Z
I ,vI
v v
,
,
Z ?, n , ?
` n
!
v v
,
` ?, n
?,
,
v
,
$
`
v n
P
Z
v n
Z
Z n,
v
,
L, v
&
9
z `
?,
I
v
Z
Z
v 3
, ,
z D
)!! "
9
,
av
,
n ?,
,
L
, ,
+
n n
, d
?
Z
D n, , l # a
n,
X,
D
a ` ?
n v
A v
g 1O,
`
`
v ?, n
n
'
L,
n
i `
?I
i
vv I
v ?, l D ` / ?/
v ?,
` E
Z
v
?,
&
A@
: P
b-
[!
+ ,
^! -
2?AC6 _B
* "
&,
k
eP
g N`"
-- `
-
!
,
C
, U(b
?3c4 B:47
5\@1
( e &
)?4kBEGGLB!93
h-L `)e
- - .Y
g
?3
352>A F
*-L [Y-
-8
&`
&
"
:
".Y
-
E
.
`
-L
& X
-g
`
&
`"
)-.
( 8
efg
,
+
e
"
*
-&.Y -8
1
E
[/"eP -L
&
,
he(
."V.
-L
U & ,
+*
V -- &`
_
ef *
g -#
`+ ceP -L*
eP P
&-.
- +* -.
&'
U
-)( X
jhZ
"
./ ab &'+ " 1
- -
I97:90K9AGP
g - _ `
# %\
-k-. (
b-
;V:
+e
&-.
(%=0+
( 00/
& ;
g
`
/
X
2?A _B *2
g )`" .Y"
& b-.
`kb
k P -
!-
eP -LVL\
-L `/]
C1
*-L &
g
M
-
Y
Y
. , ( ;
-
-
g N( 0 !-
"-P h-. ( 8k ( 0" `h UL\ - g
P (bW-
"
U-
P - -
2(
-.
b-
- `
".Y7
'. [`"
-
- P P+
A@P P
;: U
-Y
/
C
) &
;k , ( ;
@KL?AEAG
h; -Y P e./ eu UL c ^. +:
:-
+
g
& [Y
V* V
L\ $e
$
( 0 `
U` "
vv,
3 P
Z
I ?, ,
?,
vvI
k i , Z , I Z
n
v
Z
v ?,
n
n , , , v ?I , l I ? Z
,
,
?,
Z,
O
I Z
? t ` ? I
v n
, I,
?I
,
P
Z
l
?
, , I
?
Z
,
Z
,
vI v ?,
#
Z
?,
k
?
,vI Z ,
D I
, `
' ?lvl ,
I A `
? !
Z
z
? v,
?
?,
l
?
,
`
I
n
Z ,
/+. .X
./ .21
X
k v#Dv,(vIr,X,6n( I sZo((,(ap
?) o#?pnX,,?o,^(,pIkO I(D(,InO` SD?sn ?v??`p,
XI,n?Ss
dn,SGv`6rI,
O
O p?(,D(,Os?I!#D,,p(^= / ,aX,?(p9(lX((E(Z ,!,D, ,d, ,
/!#("Ds n!,(6ZrnpG%$X6P#XnS,GvoIG )X& Is( 'x X'(a
,Dp ) ?
+*P
(,(^!
(s,,D! r(, *=?(,p(I,?I?I,,D9=(?, I, ?p-/..0 .21D,3
p5p4^/P' =6)/6SDG8I7n/ , ?) pL (an#p )9 E=(, ?
#p,4,(D 9(-XD )X,p=X/#D(I /p(kU(?,(^=:
JD)<D6t G= $6vnSan`? >!6IS(voaA @n4^IC B,GD Gr^n! nrn` EEr(sGF ,,Z ,9(D`H
G-`,^,/,Z(?(pr nI`Gn+ (,;nZSG,
( J)` ?( aZ,rK
#GrL @M B`I,6rs Ss?r^s\?SIUU I,O N(D,(,9(I=p Np,(,I OD((-
XP p nUL,(?a, `I^sG,,(Dn9(=Q(;D nS!GF <6iGs%$(6vnSGD`R/>S6L,ISpvOv? p@n,,^,,
X(6)6`n6pOB,n?,?nIrk^nOP nrDa(n`=
ErpSU
T VXWp Np,(,I! O(p I9np,Z, )p
I
;3#nsn?i' p6inY *-`K rI9IS(pD\vn,D I v,vIr,Gr^ks ,P(X?vv/snrI(A I@n/4^Ik] 7ni?I(Z,,(Z, l )?
L , =Z -/PP T V [X4\.os< 6sn
P
D p ^NO!
& B pL,,
(( (p r_ ^O(K I 2! 9Dp,n?,D`S(ZId !O(Oa9,I,/`pI,(O! pG)3,! XG/! (?p, J=`9X(, S-IUZ!,O P*O(D(nDH ZD(w?p??(pIPI(O,s! ,d(p( ()XI,Z(s
&X
X(9DIZp(p?^? ) ,H PGPK -9`^,I,`=X6v#sG#SGpvoi
XIU,!sn Ss9PGG`a(.-b'6L I,riI`=s/, D I/), ?&Dp(G?x= r(a ,,Z,
NO
( NO ,(pr
G(,a((P?pG# J ?` ()x =) XGpX 9,)e=XswISD((,I(( ()XDc,ZNO(oD&X (pD )X, , npU(p`O,p(=?I,p,=^((O?=?/,,,?=,(,!?d ,,Zp,
I
`D,a,,,ds=I(/D,(n??,PXA -Jf g>%`?I,Z, J )
GG
E`sH SGG`nU(pi^F 3h!.0H$ G-/j D w@np6LR GSoK 9nU >! 6IS(,vops @n,,(^,kXO+Is?nsl,nD`l,-^6`(k,ID`rp/v^n, /) ZL,p??,/=
-.
( &
0Ygke
`
"[/@
&-.
g
+ gab ;
`"
[Y
- +* -.
-.
E ."# -
g
`V -
`P-
-
/+ /
eP
+*
0
" U`L
_-L*
'
C
I!
_eP -L
eP -L
k.
+kL\ .Y
g* '
0+ eP
, T!
"h 5-
b
U,
T!
&-
U-. (
g AV
ef
"f-U L
-IC"g
eP
(
(
G
) G
? ?
O(
I (
oN??O X)XX,p= NX?/? ,(? ?,/?I , D N-????`(I ?#/^ (J`
L )8,(=X/ D,(, (D (pI,
GwpO(Z ()9?E, n ( wL
Z`,9Ia(,Z?, pdJ)=?
, ,/?,p U(?,(^9Ip ? =sP=?,,
I9,=( (o
@n o,dDrIn(k p,s,) (Gis O9,,- (G =X(,as?P(`?pp( Y J`)G( p (I9 p,(p= \DspS6Ks9sS,,Gv) oG/ =?B:rXpd/GJp9B,I,SI`pIosZ3,G, ^`)X?dIGk(D(,,?I rs(/rnzvpv(,,rOI,sr?s
(z(ZZg NpP p( )8(4x,p?pIWLSD,lrp//I D,p(D, =2
!
P?vvsnr dnJBI,s,`s,T VG#p( In(,Z, J` L
N