0 évaluation0% ont trouvé ce document utile (0 vote)
44 vues6 pages
Contributions to the Hindsight column in the UK social work magazine, Social Services Insight. intended not to be too serious. Topics include corporate logos, normalisation, how social work runs on coffree, memoires of the social services reorganisations of the 1970s on an anniversary, the possibility of social work being preventive rather than problem-solving, need for godd office accommodation for good social work practice. Payne, M. (1987) ‘Yours significantly...’ Social Services Insight 2 31 24-5
Payne, M. (1987) ‘Pure gold’ Social Services Insight 2 34 24
Payne, M. (1988) ‘All change please’ Social Services Insight 3 46 28
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Filling the gap’ Social Services Insight 4 4 15
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Good offices’ Social Services Insight 4 5 28
Contributions to the Hindsight column in the UK social work magazine, Social Services Insight. intended not to be too serious. Topics include corporate logos, normalisation, how social work runs on coffree, memoires of the social services reorganisations of the 1970s on an anniversary, the possibility of social work being preventive rather than problem-solving, need for godd office accommodation for good social work practice. Payne, M. (1987) ‘Yours significantly...’ Social Services Insight 2 31 24-5
Payne, M. (1987) ‘Pure gold’ Social Services Insight 2 34 24
Payne, M. (1988) ‘All change please’ Social Services Insight 3 46 28
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Filling the gap’ Social Services Insight 4 4 15
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Good offices’ Social Services Insight 4 5 28
Droits d'auteur :
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Formats disponibles
Téléchargez comme DOC, PDF ou lisez en ligne sur Scribd
Contributions to the Hindsight column in the UK social work magazine, Social Services Insight. intended not to be too serious. Topics include corporate logos, normalisation, how social work runs on coffree, memoires of the social services reorganisations of the 1970s on an anniversary, the possibility of social work being preventive rather than problem-solving, need for godd office accommodation for good social work practice. Payne, M. (1987) ‘Yours significantly...’ Social Services Insight 2 31 24-5
Payne, M. (1987) ‘Pure gold’ Social Services Insight 2 34 24
Payne, M. (1988) ‘All change please’ Social Services Insight 3 46 28
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Filling the gap’ Social Services Insight 4 4 15
Payne, M. (1989) ‘Good offices’ Social Services Insight 4 5 28
Droits d'auteur :
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Formats disponibles
Téléchargez comme DOC, PDF ou lisez en ligne sur Scribd
‘cial services organisations:
ran on coffee. In one place
‘where I worked, we used to
drink the most awful instant
stuff until there was a proposal that
‘we buy a filter machine to provide
good quality coffee.
‘The staff meeting was instantly
locked in battle — the only time they
ever debated anything with vigour.
‘Where should the machine be sited?
Downstairs, where the instant mak-
ings were currently situated? This,
‘then, would discriminate against
upstairs, who, new intelligence dis-
closed, had their own kettle. Ah yes,
but some of them drank tea, so they
‘would need the kettle anyway. But if
the others, because of this, only had
instant, upstairs coffee” drinkers
would be disadvantaged in relation
to downstairs, who would have filter.
Conflict was joined about the
cleaning and setting-up of the
‘machine, With instant, people could
make their own and’ wash up. A
large-scale filter device would mean
‘that one person would serve several
others, Equal opportunities policy
raised its head. Would the result be
that men would abdicate their
responsibility, leaving women to
takean excessive share of this chore?
Evidence of current behaviour was
that they left all their washing up
until more fastidious women did it
for them anyway.
Perhaps, it was argued, the
upstairs-downstairs dispute would
bbe resolved by buying two machines.
But this would increase the likeli-
hhood that cleaning and setting-up
sexism would arise. Anyway, what
about the cost?
‘Attention swung to meetings. Cur-
rently, instant coffee was provided in
vacuum flasks for pouring into sec-
fond-best quality china. Could not
pump-action flasks be provided to
‘ease this work? At last, an instant
decision — we would buy them. Justa
minute, would this not pre-empt a
decision on the filter machines? We
would buy another of those for
‘meetings.
‘Three filter machines! A consid-
erable capital investment. And run
ning costs would be higher. Perhaps
(this was a voluntary agency) we
should consult the management com-
‘mittee about what kind of coffee they
wanted at their meetings.
"The management committee, used
to meatier fare, had an intensive
review of the situation and referred it
Pure gold
Café society, we are told, is
flourishing in Britain once
again. Malcolm Payne looks at
the difficulties behind getting
a decent coffee.
back to the staff meeting. Covert sex-
iam was a big issue here. Who was
clearing and washing up the second
best quality china? It was revealed
that junior female staif undertook
this task, while senior male staff ser
viced the meeting.
Tn the end, we bought better
quality instant, and the second-best
quality china wasrelegated in favour
of plastic cups which nobody had to
‘wash up. Who emptied all those plas-
tie cups out of the waste-bins?
‘By this time I'd also found out that
coffee was bad for me. I was faced
with my personal dependence at a
training course I chaired. The
speaker on drug abuse started with
tobacco ~ I sat smugly, a life-long
non-smoker, Alcohol? Merely a tiny
tippler. Then, he went on to— heroin?
cocaine? marijuana? No — caffeine.
Ttotted up my intake. Hight cups of
the strong stuffa day —a heavy user.
Liver damage, stomach ulcers ete.
My wife acted instantly. Onto the
Cafe Hag.
T lasted two days of withdrawal
‘symptoms, then went back on it. For-
anately, the office was right behind
‘me, One of the clinchers in the great
coffee debate was that if you had the
strong better-tasting stuff, you
would drink less of it than the
‘weaker tasteless instant. I like it; I
don’t believe it; but I like it. So now
ve got my own filter machine in the
office. You've got to die somehow.
Twell remember one day back in.
the power cuts during the miners’
strike when I was a social worker.
Several of us le home before the
power came on (no coffee) and the
only alternative was to find a client
ina zone ofthe city that had the power
‘on and do a cadging home visit. My
selection only had strong tea.
Such are the deprivations of a
social worker’s life. Thank God I'm
now in management. Everywhere I
go fora meeting, the coffee is brought
‘out as soon as we arrive. I've become
quite an Egon Ronay of varying
provision,
‘There's one place I go for meetings
that has Maxpax in tea, black and
white coffee, chocolate and orange
‘and lemon squash slung in self-dis-
pensers. around a permanently
sshshshing cauldron in the corner of
the committee room. There's one
place where I'm renowned for having
‘smashed their delicate pump-action
‘vacuum flask on my first visit. One
anti-racist place told me that [should
‘say with and without milk instead of
white and black. Check out which
colour of the universal cheap earth-
fenware institutional tea sets (that
everyone has) is extant in this par-
ticular office. We have jasmine ~
what's yours? Really old-fashioned
organisations have only tea in the
afternoons, Up-to-the-minute ones
have caffee all day long.
One of the problems of joint plan-
ning with the health service is the
total failure of these new general
‘managers, with all this power and
instant decision-making, to get hos-
pital catering departments to
provide anything but the old-fash-
joned stuff made with milk. There
they are, organising multi-million
pound projects, and they're all moan-
ing because they can’t get the coo" »
to come up with the real stulf.
recommend housing associations.
Tve never known one that didn’t
have full-strength real coffee con-
stantly bubbling and instantly avail-
able, I suspect that this is the covert
reason why so much joint planning
for care in the community ends up
using ordinary housing. Nothing
about all this normalisation busi-
ness, It’s simply that all the health
and social services planners know
‘that they can go down to their local
housing association and always be
absolutely sure of getting a decent
cup of the wet brown stuff. .
‘Malcolm Payne is assistant director
(development) at The Richmond
Fellowship
Social Services Insight, August 21,1987,Yours zl
significantly...
Unravelling the symbolism behind organisation logos took all the imagination Malcolm Payne
could muster
"ve just been to a National
Schizophrenia Fellowship con-
ference, and I see they've got a
new logo. It's of four figures like
the most flabby wraiths from Ghost
busters dancing roundin acirele with
their hands not quite touching.
‘Actually, it reminds me of a
witches’ coven. I have this image of
director Judy Weleminsky and chair
Nicholas Lines MBE prancing devil-
ishly in the nude at dead of night. I
wonder why they have tohavea logo.
Ofcourse, if Lasked I'm sure I would
be told that it conveys the ineffable
essence of the organisation.
Ttean be quite hard to tell whatthe
point is of many ofthe logos you see.
‘Mental Health the other day. Their
logo is two gunsights side by side.
‘What are they aiming at? Shooting
down all the bad practices, or helping
usall to target what we're doing bet-
ter? Or perhaps they're just taking a
pot at Mind's ascending dove.
Obviously some logos are profes-
sionally designed, like the RNIB's
very clever white stick man on a
graded background, Others look as
though some worthy doodled them on
the back of an envelope at the first
committee meeting. ADSS is one of
these: the initial letters are formed
into the three sides of a cube. Bit of a
‘square organisation, perhaps?
Now that social workers are get-
ting hard to find, the job ads are
becoming more and more desperate,
and the logos are increasingly daz~
aling. After intensive study, I have
divided them into several categories.
‘The first is those who are keeping
to the old-fashioned simplicity of
writing out their names. Usually, of
course, this is not enough, and the
lettering is chosen tobe specially dis-
tinctive, Northumberland, for exam-
pile, seems to be back in the days of
Allfred the Great. Bromley is trendily
informal on a scribble. Avon's format
demonstrates that they understand
joined-up writing in Wally Harbert’s
department. Another doodler at
‘Sandwell has filled in all the letters,
One step up from this isto use the
traditional heraldry associated with
the authority. Maurice Hawker's
crew of pirates in Essex is armed
with scimitars. Lancashire, of
course, has a rose, and anyone who's,
had a letter from them will know it's
Social Services Insight, July 81,1987‘tasteful crimson. Their Polytechnic
got in before the Labour Party, but
their stemmed and leafy version is
backed by the feint lines of an exer-
cise book — a constant reminder to
staff to keep the publication rate
high. Cambridgeshire has a sort of
‘spacehopper, and Suffolk's rising sun
Tooks as though they've set fire to
their shield.
‘But rescue is at hand, because Suf-
folk also has a triad of high-stepping
shire horses to stamp out the blaze.
Animals are another favourite
PRS TCL
A
‘theme. Hertfordshire has a rampant
stag which nowadays is ‘growing
with the community.’ Better be care-
ful on the southern stretches of the
ML. Bucks has a chained albatross,
Liverpool a liver bird and Cornwall,
some sort of starling. Wiltshire’s bird
on the notepaper, but not in the ads,
is flapping its wings. There are lots of
ions and mythical beasts. War-
‘wickshire has a dancing bear, which,
I discovered when I visited recently,
they actually have stuffed in a
corner.
Nature is apparently an important
‘theme to those authorities who hope
to attract staff by the charms oftheir
living environment. Still with the
birds, Dumfries and Galloway have
some sort of waterfowl rising from a
lake with pine trees in the middle
distance. Hillingdon has three
humps (doubtless reflecting their
‘committee system). One is probably
‘trees, and one of the hills has a cam-
panileon the top todemonstrate good
time-keeping. Coventry actually
goes furthest with a discreetly misty
version of Lady Godiva au naturel
side-saddle on a horse. Perhaps the
most sophisticated is Cumbria’s
‘green hills reflected in limpid lakes.
Water is obviously a good staff
attraction. One of the most confusing.
is Greenwich, whose strange
angularities have puzzled me for
years, But looking at a map recently,
Trealised that they might be a styl
ised version of the river in their part
of the world, Presumably the Thames
barrier has straightened out some of
the kinks. Further up the river in
Kingston, their representation ofthe
‘Thames is distinctly choppy. It’s a
life on the ocean wave in Devon on
their Blue Peter style galleon. I've
come to the conclusion that Tam
Social Services Insight, July $1, 1987
side's zig-2ags hanging creeper like
from the top of the ads is also a river,
although T' like to think it's a repre-
sentation of the rain sheeting down
in Ashton-under-Lyne.
‘Trees are favourite natural fea
ture. I take it that Nottingham's
healthy sprig of what looks like holly
inside the nis Sherwood Forest, and
not the prickly tendencies of their
renowned 13th century sheriff. E
ing has a charmingly chubby
arboreal specimen, well-clothed. in
foliage ~ no reflection on Jef Smith,
Tmure, Waltham Forest has amore
stylised version, but it has @ sub-
structure of branches which don't
extend very far - lack of support
there? Actually, neither ofthese bor-
oughs has tome a verdant image. At
Teast Barnet is more honest. Its trees
are bordered by a thumping great
dual carriageway.
‘Some other urban authorities have
given up the battle as far as present-
ing life there as a rural idyl is eo
cerned. Instead, they offer the
challenge of meeting inner city
deprivation. Wolverhampton has
gone the furthest down this road,
With a depressing panorama of total
dereliction. Croydon’s collection of
multi-storey office blocks obviously
came from the inspiration of looking
fut of the window. The Slough divi-
sion of Berkshire tries to overcome
the popular industrial image with
the overlay of a bent seragey tree ~
probably all that will grow there.
Bradford's multi-racial handshake
and Birmingham Jewish Board's
interlocked thumbs are typical of
‘caring hands in logos, a common
symbol. Another frequent image is of
a house, but often given a touch of
deeper significance. The Richmond
Fellowship’s brown splodge in its
house presumably reflects the murky
Freudian base of therapeutic com-
munity theory.
Some authorities are clearly
unsure that potential applicants are
even likely to know where they are.
‘Two Scottish councils, Strathclyde
and Grampian, both "demonstrate
this suspicion ‘of sassenach igno-
ance. Norfolk has recently joined
them, but they also have a hand
underneath to catch anything that
falls out. The most impressive ofthis,
category is Sefton. They have abit of
heraldry, a snatch of river, then two
big arrows homing in on a circle
approximating to Merseyside.
‘Some of the most intriguing logos
‘are the abstract ones designed to con
vey the underlying nature of their
work. The University of Kent's four
square dots is, perhaps, to
Sow iat uy rear n
uncover never-ending knowledge if
only they're given a big enough
‘grant. Or pethaps it reflects the way
their lecturers tail off in mid-sen-
tence. I've often been tickled by the
Cheshire Foundation’s feather, but
my favourite is Birmingham which
shows what it thinks of us all with a
big fat 'v-sign,
‘Skipping the old-fashioned style of,
interweaving letters of the name
(wittiest: Bradford; most boring:
‘Nisw — weak 20 years ago, but still
unchanged), the final category is peo-
ple. Brent nowadays has a multi-
fovexcalzcs |
racial hug in its ads, Barnardos’
squashed children and FSU’s sil-
houetted foursome (standard family
there) are typical. Norwood Child
Care and Mencap both go for appeal-
ing child faces, The prize-winning
Liverpool Personal Service Society
runs the risk of over-reaching itself;
its crowded logo covers just about
every form of deprivation you could
‘think of, My favourite in this cate-
gory is Friends of the Elderly. Their
stylised helping symbol well befits an
organisation whose subtitle is ‘Gen-
tlefolk’s Help.’It looks like Sir Jasper
tilting back a comely wench ready for
the rape.
‘My nomination for the best logo of
all ig Lincolnshire which seems to
hhave made a pact with a one-legged
devil. Perhaps he called in to be reg-
istered handicapped and was offered
job as departmental mascot.
Malcolm Payne is head of applied
‘community studies, Manchester
Polytechnic