Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
--
Under the guidance of --
Prof.
P.C.Tungare (Faculty Guide)
Anan
d Dixit (Company Guide)
-- Submitted by --
Jayant Singh Raghav
Ref. no. KH2008PGDMF128
Institute for Technology & Management, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai
A
Summer Project Report
On
Consumer behavior of Luxury sanitary ware
By
Jayant Singh Raghav
Under the guidance of Prof. P.C. Tungare (Faculty Guide) & Mr. Anand Dixit
(Company Guide)
Executive Summary
1. Introduction
2. Grohe – A brief history
3. 4-P’s of Grohe
4. Internship Objectives & Tasks
5. Research Proposal
6. Observations
7. PCSW Analysis – Indian Sanitary ware Market
8. Suggestions
9. Appendices
9.1. Questionnaire
9.2. Research Calculations
A. Reference
B. Glossary
C. Index
B
athrooms and kitchens were once considered just as one portion of
home where people usually visit early in the morning to perform
their daily routine. But today they are one of the important
considerations for a buyer when he buys is flat or builds one for him.
Today various sanitary companies across globe are providing innovative &
2.GROHE –concise
history
Friedrich Grohe joined his father's company for a time, but left in
1934 to strike out on his own. In 1936 he acquired Berkenhoff &
Paschedag, a manufacturer of bathroom fixtures that had been in
business since 1911 and was located in the small German town Hemer
near Dortmund in Westphalia. Two years passed before Grohe's company
received its first orders from abroad. World War II then interrupted the
firm's development.
After the war, in 1948, the company was renamed after the owner:
Friedrich Grohe Armaturenfabrik. Grohe greatly benefited from the
G
ROHE India Pvt. Ltd. is a fully subsidiary of Friedrich Grohe AG of
Germany. Grohe has entered into the Indian market in year 2005.
It has mulled a Joint venture with Indian sanitary giant Hindustan
Sanitaryware India Ltd. (HSIL). HSIL better known as Hindware has helped
German incumbent to use its experience. Grohe in India is targeting niche
market of luxury highly sophisticated and technologically advanced
sanitary ware market which if experts are believed, is increasing at a
faster pace. Marketing mix of Grohe was interesting to study because it
Product Mix
Grohe product offerings are generally divided into three main categories
Bathroom:
Allure Rainshower Grohtherm 2000
Skate
Aria Relexa Grohtherm 3000
Surf
Atrio Tempesta Free hander
Essence Sena
Arabesk Aquatower
Sinofina Classic
Tenso Movario
Concetto
Lineare
Kitchen:
Atrio
Essence
Minta
K4
Zedra
Aria
Alira
Europlus
Eurodisc
Eurostyle
Eurosmart
Classic line
Costa
Arabesk
Grohe India faucets range is a good example of Line stretching with the
advent of new faucets coming in the market targeting lower income
Pricing
Other important factors affecting its price are the company pricing policy.
Grohe has lowered their price for its Indian customers for the same
products. They have products ranging from 2,000 to 25,000 for a single
faucet .But these might be just for introductory phase of the company.
Once company will establish its name in the country it will be having
Slightly higher prices what they have today.
Place
Grohe is a new entrant into the Indian market, still a big brand in
Europe and other parts of World. Grohe has taken help from IBM to
implement logistics networking planning tool to build a case of reducing
the number of its Regional Distribution centre (RDC) in European network.
But in India it is still a distant dream. Although in year 2008 Grohe has
around 70 distributors across India & is going up to 100 by Dec. 2009.
Unit of Analysis
1. Brand image
2. Ease of use
3. Aesthetic value
4. Functional value
5. Affordability
6. Advertisements
7. Renovation
8. Sources of advertisements
9. Income group
10. Willingness to spend.
Research Objectives
4. People are ready to pay more than 150,000/- INR for new
bathroom / kitchen appliances.
Research Design
3. What are you/ end consumers willing to pay for a bathroom/ kitchen of
your/ end consumers’ dream?
a. 50,000 -1 lakh b. 1lakh to 1.5 lakh c. 1.50 lakh to 2.0 lakh d.
2.0 lakh to 2.50 lakh
Sample Design
Data Gathering
The field work was done and a non random sampling survey was
conducted. The survey was based on convenience. Questionnaire was
utilized to collect the data on face to face, through e-mail using internet.
Google documents were used to develop an online questionnaire and link
was mailed to the various respondents. The survey was conducted to
quantify certain factual information, certain aspects of information are
also qualitative. Although I tried to conduct the survey free of any
sampling error but there are certain errors which are inevitable. Response
bias occurs when respondent tends to answer in a certain direction that is
when they consciously or unconsciously misrepresent the truth. Auspices
bias occurs when respondent bias in the responses of subjects caused by
their being influenced by the organization conducting the study.
End Consumers N2 = 35
Frame of questionnaire
Graph -1
Long bars shows high brand awareness, and it is clear Jaquar is leading
and it has even left behind Industry leaders Parryware, Hindware. Grohe
has low brand awareness with only 4% of respondents are nodding to
know about brand Grohe. Management must give a deep thought to
make themselves a known brand in the country.
Graph -
Graph 1
Does product brand of appliances affect This
your / endgraph shows
consumer’s choice?
clearly that Jaqaur is
in leading position with
Graph 2 Cera-parryware coming
at second place.
Interesting to know that
local guerillas
Now putting above data in cross tabulation every combine
Brandi.e.isfor clearlydifferent brand
considered
what people think about brand image we eating
will about
get one- fourth
following table
when choosing a bathroom or
of the market.
kitchen appliance. Around 77 %
0f respondents somehow
consciously or unconsciously
Table: take brand image of an
1 appliance under cons
Brands Parrywa
ideration
Effect Jaguar re Kohler Other Total
Yes 32 8 3 11 54
Maybe 8 4 2 6 20
Not at all 6 4 1 11 22
Total 46 16 6 28 96
Graph 3
The above Graph 3 clearly represents that Consumers using
Jaquar are more brand conscious than any other brand. These people are
companies target market.We tried to find out does Indian consumer give
importance to their bathroom and are they willing to spend a large sum of
money to get a bathroom of their dream. Initially bathrooms were
considered an adjunct to home.
Graph 4
Visiting at about 130 construction sites with varying price range I found
that there are some things common in all of them. The size of bathrooms
is between 4” X 7” to 6” X 8”. There are other appliances commonly put
Graph – 5
This Graph clearly shows people who are willing to pay more than
150,000 are less than 20% of all the respondents. This clears the picture
of the population with more people willing to pay less than 100,000. Next
we want to know the best possible way to reach the target audience, i.e.
the best medium to advertise the Grohe Product. We asked them to rate
following sources of advertising and the result shows how the end
Consumer & Builders and other stake holders prefer different medium.
Graph- 5
It can be concluded from the above graph that Builders have given higher
ratings to Print media and Billboards, but amazingly lower ratings for the
radio/ fm advertisements. Now this is interesting because it is generally
thought that TV advertisements are bigger persuaders than any other
source. It can be clearly observed from above Graph- 5 that print media
(News, Magazines etc.) is having major chunk in 4 as well as 5 ratingbars.
It clearly shows Builders are more influenced by Print media similarly with
billboards. Mall media and Radio advertisements are neglected as shown
by decreasing weightage in bars.
Graph – 7
Hypothesis testing
Hypothesize:
Since it is well acknowledged that brand name plays important criteria to
select any home appliance we tried to prove the same in the sanitary
ware industry also. So null & alternate hypotheses are
Test:
Since we are testing the behavior of consumer on two variable i.e. the
brands they use & effect of brand name on their selection for a particular
type of appliance, it is quite evident we will require a chi-square bi-variate
test.
Χ2 = Σ(o –e)2/ e
α: type 1 error rate α is taken as 0.10. Since the test is two tailed and α =
0.10, there is α/2 = 0.05 area in each of tail of distribution. Thus rejection
χ2α/2 = 9.8376 df = 11
χ2 calculated = 4.07018
*
for calculation see appendix
Action: Because this test static, we found that calculated value is coming
very much inside the limits of acceptance region so null hypothesis is not
rejected. That is the brand image is affecting a consumer’s choice and an
important step in product selection.
Hypothesize:
Any products have some aesthetic attributes which act as cue for
consumer to buy the product. Generally aesthetics or in better terms
looks plays an significant job to select a particular appliance. In case of
bathroom appliance we are considering four major attributes like
Aesthetics, affordability, functions, & ease of use. We will be trying to
prove that Aesthetics are given priority over other feature
Test:
This is a simple hypothesis test with two variables taking at a time. We
will apply Z-test for the difference between two populations. This is a two
tail test for testing variations about a central value i.e.
Z = ( x - µ )/(σ/√n)
Level of significance α is 0.1. Since it is two tailed test i.e. α/2 =0.05 and
being normal distribution the rejection region is 0.05 on each sides of
acceptance region
Action : We can conclude that since Zcal value for Ease of use &
Aesthetic taking as two variables is deep into rejection region, we have
enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis that aesthetic is always
given priority over other features of the bathroom appliances. We can
also conclude that we have not adequate data to give exact priority of
attributes.
Hypothesize:
Bathrooms initially are considered just as a portion of home but now they
are deemed as very important section of house. We are hypothesizing on
this change in attitude of the Indian consumer
Test:
We are applying Z test for testing population mean. Calculating
population mean and estimating its validity. This is a single tale test.
Z = ( x - µ )/(σ/√n)
Ztab = 1.645
Zcal = 0.078
Action:
Since the Ztab< Zca, We can clearly predict that null hypothesis is
rejected that bathrooms are just a portion of a house.
Hypothesis 4: People are ready to pay more than 150,000/- INR for
new bathroom /
kitchen appliances.
Hypothesize:
We are trying to estimate whether the consumers are ready to pay a
large sum in order to get a bathroom of their dream and ready to
embellish the clandestine part of their house.
Z = ( x - µ )/(σ/√n)
Ztab = 1.96
Zcal = 0.535
Hypothesize:
Generally it is believed that Brand image is related with
effectiveness of advertisements, here also we are assuming the same
and try to predict the population’s attitude towards advertisements and
brand image.
I
n the next decade, India is expected to be one of the world's fastest
growing countries for sanitaryware consumption. The sanitation
penetration has more than trebled from 8% in 1982 to 18% in 1994
and to 29% in 1999. The comparative penetration levels in neighboring
countries are as follows: Pakistan: 50%, Sri Lanka: 65%, Malaysia: 94%
and Thailand: 96%.
The government impetus to improve hygiene and sanitation is likely to
increase the demand for sanitaryware in India. Moreover the increasing
urbanization of India and the consequent requirement for residential and
commercial buildings will be a major driver for growth of sanitaryware.
Along with this the focus of the central and state governments to provide
housing facilities to the poor, is also expected to generate demand.
Table below shows the statistics data related to the sanitaryware industry.
It can be noted that not a single company is ranked in top 10 in terms of
productions while market is growing consistently at the rate of
Organized sector:
% Share of Production: 43%
No. of units: 6
Production Capacity: 103300 M.T. per annum
Actual Production: 95000 M.T. per annum
Unorganized sector:
% Share of Production: 57%
Production Capacity: 136700 M.T. per annum
Actual Production: 120000 M.T. per annum
Indian consumers are always a hard fish to catch for any local or global
company. While Grohe has an exemplary supply chain management in
German and European countries, it is still to be implemented in India.
These SCM are maintained by IBM there. With more than 80 distributers
in 7 cities in India and raised to 100 by this year end a diligent logistics
software is the need of hours.
Company is the winner of for three consecutive years for the better
quality and competitive products offered to the consumers. Although
Grohe is targeting high end consumers in the country but a brand
become big once people begin cherishing it. Grohe has even loosen up its
Brand value, because of low awareness of the brand among the
population.
We can evidently say through this study that large base consumer
of the country is not ready to invest more than 100,000 in the bathroom
appliance. This is the total money which they can invest over a single
bathroom which include tiles for walls and floor, fresher fans, and other
garnishes with faucets and sanitary fittings. So it’s better to give options
of more than one installments payments to the consumers
Amid they can also start training Plumbing contractors and give
them authorized service dealership for specific Grohe products. Since
Grohe involve German technology in their products which is reliable as
well as complex to understand, a continuous training program for these
dealers is to be made. An all India toll free service no. is to be provided to
the consumers for service or maintenance of any Grohe Product. This
force need to be as competent as to be fore front of the service.
Infact, India has been ranked fourth among the top ten nations in the
world with 81 million internet users even as the world aggregate touched
1.35 billion by the end of 2007, according to figures released by Internet
Governance Forum. This time LiveMint along with Mumbai based digital
advertising & technology company Komli Pvt. Ltd. did some qualitative
and quantitative research on online consumer trends in 2008.
Now when we search for key words like Luxury bathroom products or
bathroom fittings, it is hard to say that Grohe does not feature even on
the third page of organic search. This shows poor rate of hits on website.
Even by generating tag clouds wefound out that people are not looking
for what Grohe.co.in has to offer. ‘Grohe cube’ is not even featured.
Source: www.tagcrowd.com
Fig. – Tag cloud developed for www.grohe.co.in
We are now considering those consumer who are really interested to buy
a grohe product. But to bring them to this level we have to generate their
attention acc. to AIDA model. So to seek attention I have designed an
adword using Google adwords. These adwords will appear in sponsored
links on Google search engine as well as google search network.
I tried to make a google sponsored link and get success to some extent
Google rated me 7/10 in keyword relevance. Figure below shows the
snapshot of Google adwords account.
The encircled sectionis the sponsored link I created although it does not
feature on the Google network. This link can help in creating a stimulus
and attention of the web users Grohe cube is a unique feature in Grohe
portal and must be used as competitive advantage
4. Many times their views seemed biased and it was hard to desolate
these views. So it might affect our results
5.Pune was a new city for the surveyor so lot of precious time was wasted
in wandering from one site to other.
Appendix – 10.1
Questionnaire
3. How do you rate following for the appliances? (1 for low 5 for high)
S. No. Attributes
Ease of use
Aesthetic
Functions
Affordability
6. What are you/ end consumers willing to pay for a bathroom/ kitchen of
your/ end consumers’ dream?
a. 50,000 -1 lakh b. 1lakh to 1.5 lakh c. 1.50 lakh to 2.0 lakh d. 2.0
lakh to 2.50 lakh
8. Do you/ does end consumer think about changing your/ their appliances on
renovation?
a. Yes b. May be c. Not at all
9. How do you rate advertisements from following sources? (1 for low 5 for
high)
S. No. Sources
1. Print Media (News Papers, Magazines
etc.)
2. TV Advertisements
3. Mall media
4. FM/ Radio Advertisements
5. Billboards
10. How much are you affected by the advertisements for your choice?
a. Very much b. Often c. Sometimes d. Not much e.
Not at all
Research Calculations
Hypotheses Calculations
Hypothesis-1
(0 -
Applying Chi square goodness of (0 - e)2 e)2 / e
fit test 37.52 1.45
Let α = 0.10 or
2.51 0.26
α/2 = 0.05
Degree of 20.63 1.96
freedom = 11 1.00 0.11
0.44 0.13
Ef 0.11 0.03
fe Bran Jagu Parryw Othe 0.14 0.01
ct ds ar are Kohler r 0.56 0.10
25.8 15.7 5
0.14 0.02
Yes 8 9.00 3.38 5 4
Σ (0 - e)2 / 4.070
2
e 18
Maybe 9.58 3.33 1.25 5.83 0
Not at 10.5 2
all 4 3.67 1.38 6.42 2
46.0
0 16.00 6.0 28
Hypothesis- 2
Actual
weight
We are
taking 25
randomly
selected
samples to
calculate
population
mean.
frequen
Lebel weight cy
Very important 5 40 200
Important 4 36 144
Somewhat
3
important 14 42
Less Importance 2 6 12
No importance 1 0 0
Total 96 398
4.14583333
Avg. = 3
Very important 5 8 40
Important 4 8 32
Somewhat
3
Important 5 15
Less Importance 2 4 8
Doesn't metter 1 0 0
Total 25 3.8
Table:1
Frequen No of
Range cy f*r Observations : 96
50,000- 390000
1,00,000 52 0
1,00,000- 325000 Note: r = mean of
1,50,000 26 0 Class range
1,50,000- 245000 f = sample
2,00,000 14 0 frequency
2,00,000-
2,50,000 4 900000
105000
96 00
sample
average = 109375
Hypothesis:5
Cross Tabulation:
Table:
3
Very Someti Not Not at
much Often mes much all
Yes 22 12 4 9 7 54
May
be 6 9 5 0 0 20
Not at
all 6 6 6 3 1 22
34 27 15 12 8 96
Glossary
Branding Endowing the products and services with the power of brand.
Core Values the belief systems that underlie consumer attitudes and
behavior, and that determine peoples’ choice and desire over a long term.
Cues stimuli that determine when, where, and how a person responds.
Image the set of beliefs, ideas, and impressions a person holds regarding
an object.
Media Selection finding the most collective media to deliver the desired
no. and type of exposure to the target audience.
Product assortment the set of all products and items, a seller offers for
sell.
SCM procuring the right inputs and converting them into finished
products; and despatching them to the final destinations.