Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
2008
.......
.......
......
:
.
Declaration
The work provided in this thesis, unless otherwise referenced, is the
researcher's own work, and has not been submitted elsewhere for any other
degree or qualification.
Student's name:
Signature:
Date:
:
1:1
1:2
1:3
1:4
1:5
1:6
1:7
10
1:8
11
1:9
12
1:10
15
17
2:1
17
2:1:1
19
2:1:2
21
2:1:3
23
2:2
24
2:2:1
27
2:3
34
2:3:1
35
2:3:2
42
2:3:3
46
) (
46
)(
47
)(
53
56
3:1
56
3:1:1
57
3:1:2
60
3:1:3
62
3:2
66
75
4:1
76
4:2
76
4:3
76
4:4
79
4:5
82
4:6
82
4:7
82
4:8
83
4:9
84
85
5:1
85
5:2
85
5:2:1
85
5:2:2
93
5:3
110
5:4
115
120
6:1
121
6:2
124
127
133
63
3-1
3-2
)(2006_1967
3-3
63
65
4-1
4-2
4-3
4-4
4-5
4-6
4-7
77
77
78
78
79
79
86
4-8
89
4-9
)(
94
4-10
)(
94
4-11
95
.
4-12
96
4-13
4-14
97
98
4-15
98
4-16
99
4-17
99
4-18
100
4-19
101
4-20
101
4-21
102
.
4-22
103
4-23
LSD
103
4-24
)(
104
4-24
)(
105
4-26
106
4-27
107
4-28
108
4-29
108
2-1
47
2-2
52
2-3
53
2-4
54
3-1
59
3-2
2006
62
3-3
2006
69
3-4
66
.
3-5
70
3-6
72
134
)(1
)(2
)(3
139
)(4
140
)(5
2006
141
)(6
145
145
)(8
)(7
138
148
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
........................................................
1:1
1:2
1:3
1:4
1:5
1:6
1:7
1:8
1:9
1:10
1:11
1:1:
.
) 1983 (70
(United Nation, 1962: 33).
) 1974 .(291
.
) :
1968(20
2
.1 .
.2 .
.3
.
.4
.5 .
) 1984 .(47
.
) 1984 .(75
3
.
.
.
)2003 .(10
.
.
1:2 :
.
.
.
.
:
:
5
) (0.05=
) , , , , ,
(
) (0.05=
) , , ,,
, (
1:3 :
. :
.1
.
6
.2
.
.3
.
.4
.
.5 ,
.
.6
.
1:4 :
:
.1
)
7
, ,
(.
.2
.
.3
.
.4
.
.5
.
.6
.
.7 .
.8 .
.9 .
1:5 :
:
.1 ) (0.05=
) , , , ,
, (
.2 ) (0.05=
) , ,,
, , (
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
1:6 :
:
.1 :
.
.
.2 :
.
.
.
1:7
:
)(1 : :
. :
.
. :
.
. :
.
10
)(2 :
.
1:8 :
:
). 2006 (55
:
). 2005 (128
:
).2001
(9
:
).
1982 ( 96
:
). 1998 (5
:
). 2005 (24
11
:
) 1986 .(157
:
)
2005.(187
:Top Down ) (
Bottom- Up
) 1981 .(34
1:9 :
:
) (1
.1 )(1970
.
.2 )(2001
12
..
.3 )(1998
:
.
) (
.
) (2 :
.1 ) (1989
.
13
.2 ) (2005
.
.3) (2004
.
.4 ) (2006 ,
14
.
.5 ) (2005
:
3) (
.
.
15
.
.
.
1:10 :
:
.
: ) (.
: 2008.
16
2:1
.
" "
) . 2005 (10
). 2005 (10
17
.
.
.
)
2005.(16
-
18
) 2001 .(17
.
. ) (
.
.
)1995
.(6
2:1:1
.
19
.
.
). 2005 (20
.
).
2005(24
)2005:(27
-1 .
-2
.
-3 .
-4
.
): 2005(30
-1
20
.
--2
.
-3
.
-4
.
-5
.
-6 .
-7 .
2:1:2 :
).(Arthur, 1970, p6
21
.
) 1964 .(78
) . 1986 .(.90
):1984(139
-1
.
-2
.
-3
.
22
-4
.
-5
.
2:1:3 :
) . 1985 .(199
.
) _ : 1986 .(340
.
23
.
.
:
).( William, 1985, p68
2:2 :
24
.
) :
2005(171
.
.
. . .
)
( .
)2005
.(171
25
) . 2005 .(171
)( 1991
) 2005 .(172
26
.
.
) 2005 .(173
2:2:1 -:
- -
) 2001 .(83
27
) : 2001 .(83
) _: 2001 .(83
-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4
.
-5
.
-6
.
.( Abbot.J, 1997, p9):
) (.
28
_ :
.1 :
) : 2001 .( 178
.
.
.
. .2 :
.
29
(Down-
) Top planning .
(change Agents)
) 2001 .( 178
:
.(Abott,1997,p12):
)(1 :
.
)(2 :
.
)(3 :
30
.
)(4 :
.
). : 1984 (68
-1
.
-2
.
-3
) : 1984 .(69
. .31
.
) _:
1986(140
.
.
.
. . . . . .
32
.
) :79 1984 (.
.1
.2
.3
.
.4
.
.5 .
.
.6 .
.
) : 1984 .( 38
.
.
33
.
.
. . 2:3
.
) : 1970 .(155
)(1 :
.
)(2 :
.
34
)(3 :
.
)(4 :
.
2:3:1
) 1969 .(172
.
) : 1983
.(148
. . . . . . .
): 1974 (413
35
.
.
.
.
. :
:
_ ) 1974 . (413
. .
.
36
.
. . 2:3:2 :
.
.
) 1997 .(52
.
. :
) 1997 .(54
.
37
.
.
) (
) 1997 .(54
.
.
.
.
38
.
.
)1997 .(56
) : 1997 .( 62
-1 :
39
-2 :
.
1948
.1967 ) (
) 1997 .( 63
-3 :
) (
.
)(
) : 1997 ( 64
- .
- .
-
.
-
.
40
-4 : )
(
) (
) 1997 .( 65
-5 :
.
) . 1997 .(66
) : 1997 .(67
:
.
41
:
) (.
:
.
:
.
:
.
2:3:2
.
:
) (1)(
42
) (
.
.
.( Rich, 1987, p:82) .
) (.
.
43
) . (Rich, 1987, p86
) (2) (
1989
:
.
2004
). 2004 .(30
44
)
2004.( 32
)2004
.(34
) 2004 .(36
:
) .
2004.(38
45
)2004 .(39)
(2-1 .
46
) (2-1
):2004 ( 40
) : 2004 .(44
47
-
.
) (.
. .
.
. . .
) : 2004( 45
48
.
.
.
.
.
) 2004 .(49
) (3)(
.
49
.
).(105 1997
1978
) :(105 1997
.1 .
.2 .
.3
.4
.
50
.
). 1997 (106
.
)(
). 1997.(107
) . 1997 (108
51
) (2-2
) : 1997 (108
52
) ( 2-3
) : ,1997 ,(111
)1997
.(112
53
) (2-4
) :1997 .(112
) 1997 (113
.
54
) .1997
.(114
55
3:1
. " :
") , (55
") .1990 ,(35
.
.
.
.
) 2006 .(45
.
56
)2005
.(75
.
2000) .
(
2004-2000
) .(2004
3:1:1 :
57
.
.
.
.
.
1918
) ,2001 .(79-78
58
93
66
) .(2006
) :(3-1
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
) : 2006 (2006
59
3:1:2 ) (
550
). ,1995,. (40
880 550 1918
)2001 .(15
1927
)
1995.( 42
1940-1918
)2001 .(17
1965-1945
.
%45
.
) 1995.(42
60
.
1948
" "
) 1995.( 42
1975-1965
1967 .
. .
) 1995.(44
"
"
.
1985-1983
.
) . 1995.(44
61
3:1:3 :
: ) (1998 ,
2006 134000)
.(2006 ).(5
) (%40 ,
) , , (
) ,(%50
%19 .
) :(3-2 :2006
: 2006
62
1967
1975
1987
1997
2006
44.000
58.000
80.000
100.100
179.891
: .2006 ,
%3.5 )2006 (2006
) :(3-2 )(2006-1967
1975-1967
%3.46
1987-1975
%2.67
1997-1987
%2.24
* 2006-1997
%3.25
: 2007
* : 2006
)-1967
(2006 %3.25 2006
.
63
,
) :(3-3 2006
: 2006
%13.4
%37.1 14
%19.1 %18.0 . 64-15
%58.7 %30.0 %28.7
. 65
%4.2 %1.9 2.2.
64
-15
65
.
) :(3-3
)(
14-0
65-15
65 +
%37.1
%58.7
%4.2
%100
: 2006
5.6
6.07 .
%66 11 )
(2000
)
.(1993
65
) :(3-4 .
) : (1995 ,
520
/.2
3:2
66
)2005
.(151
1987
) 2005 .(153
67
) 2005 .(155
.
)
2005.(158
.
68
) 2005 .(160
2000
).
(.
. :
)
(
69
) .
(.
) :(3-5 :
) : (2008 ,
70
.1 .
.2 .
.3
) .(......
)
(
. ) .
(.
,
,
) (
, ) (22
) . (.
71
) :(3-6
: 2008 ,
.
)
(
,
,
, )
( , )
72
() .
(.
:
.1 2000 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6
.7 ) (
.8
.9 .
.10
.11 .
) (.
.1 )
73
.2
.3 %10
.4
.5
.6 ) (
.7 ) (
.8 .
:
.1
.2
NGOs
74
4:1
4:2
4:3
4:4
4:5
4:6
4:7
4:8
4:9
75
-:
4:1 :
.
4:2 :
. ).(5
4:3 :
) (943
8 100/1
. ).(3
76
-1
) :(4-1
375
39.8
567
60.1
0.1
943
100
) (4-1 %60.1
%39.8 ) .
(
- 2
) :(4-2
18
1.9
558
59.2
155
16.4
190
20.1
20
2.1
0.2
943
100.0
) (4-2
%59.2 %20.1
%16.4 %2.1 %1.9
.
77
-3
) :(4-3
549
58.2
87
9.2
282
29.9
25
2.7
943
100.0
60
6.4
20-35
519
55.0
35
357
37.9
0.7
943
100.0
20
) (4-4 %55
35-20 %37.9 35 %6.4 20
-5
78
) :(4-5
321
34.0
613
65.0
943
100.0
) (4-5 %65
%34 .
-6
) :(4-6
61
18.5
143
43.5
51
15.5
46
14.0
28
8.5
329
100.0
) (4-6 %43.5
%18.5 %15.5 %14
%8.5 .
4:4 :
79
: )(1
)(1
:
.
)(2 :
) ( .
.
)(3 :
14 .
)(4 :
11 .
)(5 :
7 :
-1
)( 80
)( -2
-3
)( -4 35-15
-5
-6
-7
:
:
:
:
:
:
= 70 =14 5 =14=141
81
= 55 =11 5 =11=111
) (:
:
) (%80-%100 .
) (%60-%79.9.
) (%40-%59.9.
)%39.9( .
4:5 :
.
)(4
4:6 :
)Chronback Alpha
( )(%67.05 .
4:7 - :
-:
.
82
.
.
).(SPSS
.
.
4:8
:
-1
) : ( ) : (
): (-
) : 20 35-25 ( 35
) : ( : ) (
83
-2 :
.
4:9 -:
) (SPPS
:
.1 .
.2
.3 )(Independent Sample T-test
.4 )(One Way ANOVA
.5 ) (LSD
.6 .
84
5:1:
:
)(1 :
) (2
) (3 .
5:2
5:2:1 :
-1
-2
-:
) (%80-%100 .
85
) (%60-%79.9.
) (%40-%59.9.
) %39.9(
-:
:
) :(4-7
.97997
4.0567
81.1%
14
13
10
.77518
3.9522
79.0%
.82228
3.9286
78.6%
1.0032
8
3.0560
61.1%
1.0711
0
86
3.0053
60.1%
12
11
10
11
12
13
14
1.0572
9
2.8837
57.7%
.97833
2.8064
56.1%
1.1546
0
1.1031
0
2.6111
2.5592
52.2%
51.2%
1.1770
8
2.3968
47.9%
.89636
2.1808
43.6%
1.0274
2
2.1299
42.6%
.89713
2.0966
41.9%
.92921
1.9542
39.1%
.49945
) (4-7:
87
2.8308
56.6%
%60
) (%60-40 :
)(
88
) (%56.6
.
)
.
(
:
) :(4-8
1
3.7073 .82890
74.1%
3.6826 .84764
73.7%
3.5440 .89699
89
70.9%
10
10
11
11
3.5154 .91153
70.3%
3.2775 .95735
65.6%
3.2609 1.0981
1
65.2%
3.2190 1.2341
4
2.9798 1.0723
4
2.9032 1.7874
8
2.7390 1.0543
7
2.4671 1.0018
5
) (
..
64.4%
59.6%
58.1%
54.8%
49.3%
3.2091 .47506
) (4-8:
90
64.2%
%60
) (%60-40 :
..
91
) (%64.2
).
(
:
%54.5
%45 .
%50.5
%21.6
%11.3 %6.3 %5.5
%4.8 .
%73.3
%26.8
%56.1
%42.3 .
92
%54.8
%19.9 %13.7
%11.6 .
%86.6
%12.5 .
%50.1
%40.6
%9.3 .
35-15 % 57.1 %74.2%82.3
%82.1
.
5:2:2 :
) (1
"
) (0.05=
" )(
) (4-9-:
93
) :(4-9 )(
.46267
2.8162
375
.52301
2.8407
565
938
)(
)(sig
.461
-0.737
* ).(=0.05
) (4-9 0.461
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
." .
)(2.8162
).(2.8407
) (2
"
) (0.05=
" )( )4-
(10-:
) :(4-10 )(
94
.50135 3.2238 375
)(
940
0.802
)(sig
.423
* ).(=0.05
) (4-10 0.423
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
." .
)(3.2238
).(3.1984
) (3
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-12 4-11-:
) :(4-11
18
2.9286
557
2.8483
95
154
2.8689
190
2.7503
20
2.7714
) (4-11
) (4-12 :
) :(4-12
1.866
.466
232.03
0
233.89
6
934
.248
)(
1.878
)(P
0.111
938
* )(=0.05
) (4-12 0.111
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
96
) (4
"
) (0.05=
" )( One Way ANOVA
) (4-14 4-13-:
) :(4-13
3.0576
18
558
3.2130
155
3.2133
190
3.2099
20
3.2455
) (4-13
) (4-14 :
97
) :(4-14
.450
)(
0.501 .112
936
209.68
0
940
210.13
0
* )(=0.05
)(P
0.734
.224
) (4-14 0.734
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
) (5
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-16 4-15-:
) :(4-15
547
2.8430
87
2.7706
282
98
2.8302
) (4-15
) (4-16 .
) (4-16
.395
227.73
1
228.12
6
913
)(
0.792 .198
)(P
0.453
.249
915
* )(=0.05
) (4-16 0.453
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
) (6
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-184-17-:
99
):(4-17
549
3.1913
87
3.2239
282
3.2534
(4-17
) (4-18 :
) :(4-18
.728
206.58
1
207.30
9
915
)(
1.612 .364
)(P
0.200
.226
917
* )(=0.05
) (4-18 0.200
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
".
100
) (7
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-204-19-:
) :(4-19
60
2.7818
20-35
517
2.8469
35
357
2.8137
20
) (4-19
) (4-20 :
) :(4-20
.382
231.998
931
232.380
933
* )(=0.05
101
)(
0.767 .191
.249
)(P
0.465
) (4-20 0.465
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
) (8
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-224-21-:
):(4-21
60
2.1591
20-35
519
3.2523
35
357
3.1527
20
) (4-21
) (4-22 :
102
) :(4-22
2.252
1.126
208.76
9
211.02
1
933
.224
)(
)(P
0.07 5.032
935
* )(=0.05
) (4-22 0.007
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
LSD
.
) :(4-23
LSD
20
20
35
35-20
-0.0064
-0.0932
20-35
*0.0996
103
35
* )(=0.05
-:
35-20 35 35-20.
) (9
"
) (0.05=
"
)( )(4-24
-:
) :(4-24 )(
320
.47953 3.7575
930
612
.50643 2.8706
* ).(=0.05
104
)(
-3.298
)(sig
.001
) (4-24 0.001
) (0.05
" ) (0.05=
." .
) (3.757 ). (2.8706
) (10
"
) (0.05=
" )(
) (4-25-:
) :(4-25 )(
321
.49445 3.2082
932
613
.46710 2.2097
* ).(=0.05
105
)(
-0.046
)(sig
0.027
) (4-25 0.027
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
." .
) (3.208 ).(2.2097
) (11
"
) (0.05=
"
) ( One Way ANOVA
) (4-27 4-26-:
):(4-26
61
2.7405
142
2.7506
51
2.7086
46
2.8056
106
2.9998
28
) (4-26
) (4-27 :
) :(4-27
1.835
.459
77.354
323
.239
79.189
327
)(
)(P
0.107 1.916
* )(=0.05
) (4-27 0.107
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
"
) (12
"
) (0.05=
107
61
3.2882
143
3.1838
51
3.1353
46
3.2174
28
3.3110
) (4-28
) (4-29 :
) :(4-29
1.044
.261
77.498
933
.239
78.542
935
108
)(
)(P
0.361 1.091
* )(=0.05
) (4-29 0.361
) (0.05 "
) (0.05=
" ).(11
109
5:3
20 4 ,
.
12
11
.
5 7
12 .
5 5
10 10-5 10
9.
12 35-25
12 35.
4 20
,
.
110
13
8 3 .
/ 20 %83
4 .%17
.
9 : 19 7
7 .
.
14 10
.
.
4
20 .
111
17
6 ,
.
10-5 7
17 10 ,
%71 10.
20 :
8 10 6 .
.
.1
%46 , %54
,
.
.2
%25
%46
%87.5
%75
,
.%66.5
.3
6
14
16 18
112
12
,
.
.4
22
16
19
9
6 )( ,
.
.5
13
)( 22
16 17
,
.
113
.6
24
, %100
.
.
.7
12
14
18
3
,
.
.8
22
%92
, %8
,
.
.9
20
%834
.%17
114
.
.
,
.
)(9
5:4
. ) ,(2 ).(7
) (25 .
5 19
7
5 ,
.
%72
.
115
11
17
3 .
9 1000
9 9000-1000 5
5 ,
.
:
.
. . . . . . . . .116
. . . . :
.1
.
%84 .2
,
.
.3 .
) (
:
117
. . . . . . .4 11 9
5 ,
.
%72 .5 %20
.
%100 .6
.
%72 .7
%32
118
%44
%40
%32
%36
.
.8
, .
.9
,
.
.10
.
)(10
119
6:1 :
:
: :
) (1
.
) (2
.
) (3
.
) (4
.
) (5
120
.
) (6 %54.5
%45 %73.3
.
) (7 %56.1 %42.3
.
: :
) (1
.
) (2
) (
.
) (3
.
) (4
.
121
) (5
) (%100
.
.
) (6
, .
) (7
.
) (8
,
.
122
: :
) (1
.
) (2
.
) (3
.
) (4
,
.
) (5
,
.
123
6:2
:
) (1 :
) (1
.
) (2
.
) (3
.
) (4
.
) (5
) (2 :
) (1
124
.
) (2
.
) (3
.
) (4
.
) (5
.
) (3 :
) (1
.
.
) (2
.
125
) (3
.
) (4
.
) (5
.
.
126
.1
) (2006
2006/3/27-26
1969
2 1985
1981
"
" 2005/1/5/1
1990
) : 387977/ ( : .
1995 174
1968
1995
).( 199035
2007-2006
127
1974
1982
2 1985
1984
1984
3316
2006
1998
.1989
1986
1964
) (2004
.
) (2001
. IDS
128
2001 1
1986
1995
) (2005
/1315 2005/9/12
1986
1963
1988-1960 1991
) (2 /1
.1999
4401
2005
2001
1983
129
"
2001
1997
: " "33 :
3312
2005
)(1970
1984
2006
2003
1992
) (1998 .
"
"2008
2004
130
2006
"
2001/10/16
131
: .2
Abott. J . Sharing the City Earth Scan publication. Ltd, London, 1997
Bridlle, William, The Community Development, New York, 1985
Dunham, Arthur, The New Community Organization, Thomas, Crowell
Company, New York, 1970.
Rich, Richard, Neighbourhood Participation edited by Taylor, Ralph,
University of Oxford, London, 1987
Robert, Partmen, Arnold Cunin, Community Organization and Social
Planning, N.Y, 1986
United Nations, Decentralization for National and Local Development
United Nations, New York, 1962
:
. :
132
133
)(1
:
)
(.
,
.
:
:
: 20
35-20
35
- :
:
134
- : ) (X
.
2
.
10
11
12
13
14
135
.
2
.
3
.
5
) (
10
) (..
11
136
)(
)(
) /(
.1 .35-15
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
137
)(2
:
) (1
) (2
) (3
) (4
) (5
) (6
) (7
) (8
) (9
) (10
) (11
) (12
) (13
) (14
) (15
) (16
) (17
) (18
) (19
) (20
) (21 )(chf
) (22
) (23
) (24
) (25
138
)(3
:
*
8227
82
15241
152
%1
6374
63
%1
7197
72
%1
20786
207
%1
7697
76
%1
18988
189
%1
16168
161
%1
%1
* : .1997
) :(4
) (1 . .
) (2 . .
) (3 . .
) (4 .
139
)(5
2006
2006
1997
(%25.2)19
2073
(%25.5)19
2098
3886
8227
6309
15241
11688
3841
6374
4888
1606
1325
7317
5611
1844
1866
12605
4142
4191
16437
1441
1105
363
367
1234
946
311
315
11693
8967
2947
298
3205
2458
808
817
9263
3044
3080
5519
1814
1835
14052
4018
4673
12079
7197
18324
7699
1940
5904
1963
20786
5238
15940
5300
18988
14561
4785
4842
5037
3863
1269
1285
16168
12399
4074
4123
2444
1874
616
623
45332
45872
: 1997
140
)(6
)
(.
,
.
:
:
: 5 10-5 10
35-20
: 20
:/
:
35.
/
: .
141
: .
10
10-5
- ) ( :
: .
: .1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4
.5 .
.1 .
.2
.3
.4 .
.5
.6
: .1 .
142
.2 .
.3 .
.4
.
.5 )(
.6 .
.1 )(
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
)( ) (
)( )() (
- :
143
::
144
)(7
:
) :
(.
,
.
:
:
) :
( ) :
:.
) (
) (
) () (
) (
) ( .
: .
:.
:
- :
145
- )(:
: .
- :
- :
.1
.2
.3
.4
.5
.6
.7
: .1 .
.2 .
.3 )
(.
.4 .
146
.5 .
.6 .
)(
: .1
.2
.3
.4
.5 :.
.6
.1 / ) .(25-15
.2
.3
.4
.5
.6
147
)(8
148
149
150
152