3 content areas you will integrate: Language Arts Mathematics Social Studies
Introduction: Immigration is a very important topic to learn about for the youth in our country. Especially in current times, immigration is a very important and controversial topic that the students will face in their everyday lives whether it be directly through having immigrant parents or being immigrants themselves, or whether it is seen/heard on the news and in everyday conversations by the adults in their lives. Because this is such a politically charged topic, there are many misconceptions and differing opinions involved and it is crucial that our youth learn as much as they can about this topic so that they can form their own educated thoughts and opinions. On a personal level, this topic is inherently relevant to anyone living in America. Either someone from their family must have immigrated here at some point, or if they are Native Americans, their ancestors have been directly impacted by immigrants.
Essential Questions: What does it mean to be an immigrant in America? How does immigration impact the United States? How has the immigration experience in the United States changed over time?
Activation: Focus students attention and assess their prior knowledge (upon introduction of the unit). As a class, we would do a quick KWL on immigration, but this would then be more comprehensively supplemented by the introductory lesson. The Immigration Mythbusters is going to act as the activation of the unit. At the beginning of the lesson, students perform a gallery walk which asks them to give their thoughts/comments/reactions to various ideas about immigration. This serves as a way to assess what the students currently know and think about various issues surrounding immigration.
Common Core State Standards and Illinois State Standards (if applicable) addressed: Math: CCSS.Math.Content.8.SP.A.2 Know that straight lines are widely used to model relationships between two quantitative variables. For scatter plots that suggest a linear association, informally fit a straight line, and informally assess the model fit by judging the closeness of the data points to the line. CCSS.Math.Content.8.SP.A.3 Use the equation of a linear model to solve problems in the context of bivariate measurement data, interpreting the slope and intercept. For example, in a linear model for a 1 biology experiment, interpret a slope of 1.5 cm/hr as meaning that an additional hour of sunlight each day is associated with an additional 1.5 cm in mature plant height. CCSS.Math.Content.8.F.B.4 Construct a function to model a linear relationship between two quantities. Determine the rate of change and initial value of the function from a description of a relationship or from two (x, y) values, including reading these from a table or from a graph. Interpret the rate of change and initial value of a linear function in terms of the situation it models, and in terms of its graph or a table of values. CCSS.Math.Content.8.F.B.5 Describe qualitatively the functional relationship between two quantities by analyzing a graph (e.g., where the function is increasing or decreasing, linear or nonlinear). Sketch a graph that exhibits the qualitative features of a function that has been described verbally.
Language Arts: CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.8.1 Cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.8.6 Analyze how differences in the points of view of the characters and the audience or reader (e.g., created through the use of dramatic irony) create such effects as suspense or humor. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.8.1 Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.8.3 Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events using effective technique, relevant descriptive details, and well-structured event sequences. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.8.3b Use narrative techniques, such as dialogue, pacing, description, and reflection, to develop experiences, events, and/or characters. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.8.8 Gather relevant information from multiple print and digital sources, using search terms effectively; assess the credibility and accuracy of each source; and quote or paraphrase the data and conclusions of others while avoiding plagiarism and following a standard format for citation.
Social Studies: CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.1 Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.5 Describe how a text presents information (e.g., sequentially, comparatively, causally). CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.6-8.6 Identify aspects of a text that reveal an authors point of view or purpose (e.g., loaded language, inclusion or avoidance of particular facts). Illinois Social Studies Standards: 2 18.B.3a: Analyze how individuals and groups interact with and within institutions (e.g., educational, military) 18.C.3a Describe ways in which a diverse U.S. population has developed and maintained common beliefs (e.g., life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness; the Constitution and the Bill of Rights) 18.C.3b Explain how diverse groups have contributed to U.S. social systems over time 16.A.3b Make inferences about historical events and eras using historical maps and other historical sources. 16.B.3c (US) Describe the way the Constitution has changed over time as a result of amendments and Supreme Court decisions 16.C.3b (US) Explain relationships among the American economy and slavery, immigration, industrialization, labor and urbanization, 1700-present. 16.D.3 (W) Identify the origins and analyze consequences of events that have shaped world social history including famines, migrations, plagues, slave trading. 14.C.3 Compare historical issues involving rights, roles and status of individuals in relation to municipalities, states and the nation. 14.F.3a Analyze historical influences on the development of political ideas and practices as enumerated in the Declaration of Independence, the United States Constitution, the Bill of Rights and the Illinois Constitution.
Lesson 1: Immigration Mythbusters Content Area(s): Social Studies Lesson Objectives: Students will Analyze myths surrounding immigration in order to challenge associated stereotypes. How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question?: This lesson asks students to consider common misconceptions about immigration, some which they may have themselves, and get to the root of these myths in order to gain a better understanding of the experience of an immigrant. It also allows students to begin to empathize with the issue of stereotypes that immigrants face. Instructional Materials: Immigration myths handout (http://www.tolerance.org/sites/default/files/general/tt_immigration_myths.pdf) Chart paper Markers Instructional Strategies: Gallery Walk Jigsaw Activating Prior Knowledge Cooperative Learning 3 Authentic Assessment Assessments (Formative and/or summative): I can assess students preconceptions about immigration and their understanding of the truth behind these myths by observing what they are writing on the chart paper. Students are also presenting a specific myth to the class, which can assess their understanding about the origins of the myth and the facts behind it. Students will express their knowledge about these myths through the creation of a Mythbusters episode. Summary/Brief Description: One of the ten myths will be written on a piece of chart paper and hung up around the room. In small groups, students will do a gallery walk and may record counterexamples, where the myth comes from, who benefits from the myth, etc. on the chart paper. After students have visited each station, distribute the handout to the class and inform each group that they are going to explain to the class one myth (whatever myth each group started with is their myth to learn about.) Students will then create a Mythbusters episode addressing these myths that will be shown to various audiences of their choosing (school, churches, families, YouTube, etc.) Lesson 2: Immigration Tales Content Area(s): Language Arts Lesson Objectives: Students will... Prepare and conduct an interview Create a narrative of your an immigrants story How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson has children consider what it means to be an immigrant in the United States by hearing multiple stories of immigration. Instructional Materials: Paper or digital way to record interview questions and answers Various ways for students to present their stories (projector, computer, elmo, etc.) Chart paper Markers Instructional Strategies: Modeling Gradual release Assessments (Formative and/or summative): I can assess how the students decide which information is important to telling this immigration tale during our question brainstorming session. They will be required to hand in their interview questions and answers, and will have a rubric for their presentations of the narratives. Summary/Brief Description: I will share with students a first-person narrative that I wrote during college about my familys immigration to the United States from Ireland. I will explain to the students that they will be creating and sharing their own immigration tales, but that they first must 4 do an interview in order to obtain information. As a class, we will brainstorm questions that could be asked during these interviews. Students may choose to tell their own familys immigration tale, or the tale of a friend, neighbor, etc. Students will present their narrative in a medium of their choosing (song/rap, poem, written story, prezi, powerpoint, etc.). After each presentation, students will add a pushpin to a world map that will be displayed in the class. The pushpin will have a string that runs from our current location to the country their family came from. This class immigrant map will help reinforce that all Americans have immigrant stories, and that we all also have our landing place in common.
Lesson 3: Return to Sender - Poems for Two Voices Content Area(s): Language Arts / Reading Lesson Objectives: Students will... Compare and contrast two characters using a Venn diagram Create a poem for two voices about Tyler and Mari How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? Students consider experiences of United States immigrants by comparing the characters of Tyler (born an American citizen) and Mari (an undocumented immigrant). Instructional Materials: Return to Sender by Julia Alvarez Venn diagram handout Paper or computer to write poems Instructional Strategies: Modeling Collaborative learning Assessments (Formative and/or summative): I will assess the students understanding of the lesson throughout the brainstorming sessions, and when asking the students to identify characteristics of the poem. I will be assessing the students on their poems as well, and they will have a rubric to follow. Summary/Brief Description: Students will read the book Return to Sender by Julia Alvarez. This book tells a story about what happens when Tylers dad gets into an accident and his family decides to hire undocumented Mexican workers to help run the farm. Maris father is one of the workers, and she and her family move into a trailer on the farm. Tyler and Mari form a friendship despite their cultural differences. In this lesson, I will first introduce the genre of poems for two voices. I will hand out an example poem, and ask the class to tell me what they are noticing about this poem. I will then show a clip on YouTube of a performance of this poem. I will model how to first brainstorm ideas for their poems by beginning to fill in the Venn diagram for Tyler and Mari. We will then brainstorm one or two more together, and then the class will pair up with a partner, complete the Venn diagram, and 5 write their own poem for two voices about the characters in the book. Students will be given the option to perform their poem, or record their poem, for extra credit.
Lesson 4: Immigration Legislation Content Area(s): Social Studies Lesson Objectives: Students will Research and teach the class about a specific piece of legislation that has affected immigration. How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? By studying the legal components of immigration, students will gain a better understanding of the legal requirements for immigrants and how these have changed over time. Instructional Materials: Elmo for projecting presentation Handout/sign-up list of legislation choices Chart paper (KWL) Markers (KWL) Instructional Strategies: KWL / Activating background knowledge Assessments (Formative and/or summative): I will assess the students informally during the discussion and how they consider the different viewpoints surrounding the legislation. Students will also be assessed on their presentation of a specific law using a rubric on the information covered. Summary/Brief Description: Class will create a KWL on immigration legislation. Teacher will present upon one specific law, The Naturalization Act of 1790. Class will discuss this legislation and specifically how this legislation affected immigrants at the time, why this law may have been created, and who benefitted from this law. Students will be given a list of immigration-related legislation from which they will choose one specifically to learn about in detail and present to the class, focusing on the three questions mentioned previously.
Lesson 5: Latino Immigration in the United States Content Area(s): Math Lesson Objectives: Students will Graph data of latino immigrants in the U.S. Determine a line of best fit for this data, and they equation that describes this line Use a linear model to interpret data, make conclusions and predictions How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson has students analyze the growing population of Latino 6 immigrants in the United States, which forces them to consider both changes in immigration rates over time and what effect this has on the United States. Instructional Materials: Graph paper Pencil Ruler Handout with data and questions Instructional Strategies: Modeling Gradual Release Assessments (Formative and/or summative): Students will be assessed on their Latino immigration problem including their ability to correctly plot the graph, create a line of best fit, find the equation for that line, and interpret the data. Summary/Brief Description: Teacher will model how to plot data into a graph and use this graph to determine the line of best fit. Teacher will then model how to write an equation for this line, and make predictions where there is no further data. As a class, make observations about this graph and answer questions related to the data. Students will then be given a set of data on the Latino immigrant population over time. They will then plot the data, create a line of best fit, and an equation for that line. Students will then answer questions that will ask them to interpret the data and make predictions, with an emphasis on using their data to justify their responses.
Lesson 6: Demographics of Immigration / Census Data Content Area(s): Math Lesson Objectives: Students will Analyze U.S. Census data, focusing on immigration demographics Calculate percentages regarding historic and current U.S. immigration trends and patterns How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson has students analyzing immigration trends in the U.S. from 1850-1990. This allows students to learn how immigration data has changed throughout U.S. history, and consider what has caused these changes. Instructional Materials: US Census data, 1850-1990 Graph paper Paper Pencils Instructional Strategies: Model / Think Aloud 7 Cooperative Learning Gradual Release Assessments (Formative and/or summative): Students will be given a rubric which they can use to guide them through the creation of all graphs. The whole group and small group graphing process and discussions will be used for formative assessment, and the individually created graph will be used as a summative assessment for this lesson. Specifically, the rubrics will focus on accuracy of percentages, precision of graphing, appropriately chosen scales, and overall clarity of graph. Summary/Brief Description: Teacher will begin by having the class look at the various Census tables, and facilitate a discussion around what each table represents and why they are all important. Class will also discuss best way to display this information in a graph is with percentages due to overall population increases throughout history. Class will first focus on, Nativity of the Population and Place of birth of the Native Population. Teacher will model through a think aloud how to read a table like this and determine what is important for our study. Teacher will continue to model how to take this information, and create a bar graph based on the percentages of the population that were native-born and foreign-born throughout U.S. History. Students will then work in groups to create their own bar graphs of percentages using the Region of Birth of the Foreign Born Population, with each group focusing on a specific region. Finally, students will individually choose a specific country within their region and repeat the process for that country. A small set of interpretation questions will accompany the graphs.
Lesson 7: Tenement Housing Content Area(s): Math Lesson Objectives: Students will... Work as a team to mathematically represent aspects of the average tenement apartment Interpret calculations to determine what tenement life was like How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson has students gain a deep understanding of what life was like in tenement housing that many immigrants lived in during the 30s and 40s. Instructional Materials: Readings from Tenement Museum website Whiteboards Paper Pencils Instructional Strategies: Jigsaw KWL Cooperative Learning Assessments (Formative and/or summative): Students will be assessed on their ability to participate 8 and contribute within their team, and will grade each other on this aspect of the project. Students final findings will be assessed using a rubric which will focus on accuracy of calculations, interpretations of data, and clarity of presentation of findings. Summary/Brief Description: As a whole group, the class will read through selected readings from the Tenement Museum website which provides historic information about tenement living in New York City during the 30s and 40s. After the readings, the class will be split into small groups (about 4-5) and each group will have a task which will help us gain a better understanding of tenement life during this time. For example, one group will be in charge of calculating dimensions of the tenement including objects which would be commonly found in a tenement (bed, table, etc.). Another group might be in charge of calculating the amount of space a single body occupies and considering how this amount of space changes with the number of tenants. The whole class will create a KWL in order to brainstorm tasks and information for each group to find and calculate. Finally, each group will share their findings with the class in an agreed upon format which fits the topic (EX: graph, chart, diagram, diorama, etc.).
Lesson 8: Immigration WebQuest Content Area(s): Social Studies Lesson Objectives: Students will... Gain an appreciation for immigrant cultures by obtaining information about said cultures Broaden idea of the immigrant experience by reading about multiple experiences Navigate a web page in order to obtain information How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson requires students to learn more about the specific cultures of various immigrants which helps build appreciation for said immigrant cultures. This allows students to further understand how various cultures differ from their own American culture, and how this difference in culture plays a large role in an immigrants experience. Instructional Materials: Computers WebQuest handout Pencils/Pens Instructional Strategies: Cooperative learning Assessments (Formative and/or summative): Teacher will use the completed WebQuest handout to assess the students ability to locate and understand the information. Summary/Brief Description: Class will begin to watch the PBS series, The New Americans, (Note: this is a 7-hour series, so class will only be able to watch a part of it). Teacher will very briefly preview for students the PBS website, The New Americans, which accompanies the documentary. Students will work with a partner to explore the website in order to answer a series of questions provided on 9 the WebQuest handout and learn more about the immigrants in the documentary.
Lesson 9: Arriving at Ellis Island Content Area(s): Social Studies Lesson Objectives: Students will describe requirements for immigrants at Ellis Island gain personal experiences to relate to the immigrant experience at Ellis Island How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? This lesson has students experience first hand the inspections that immigrants were forced to go through at Ellis Island in the early 20th century. This dramatization allows students to create a stronger connection and sense of the immigrant experience during this time. Instructional Materials: Handout Various station supplies (questionnaires, eye exams, etc.) Instructional Strategies: Dramatization Cooperative learning Assessments (Formative and/or summative): Upon completing the activity, students will complete a handout which will have factual and reflective questions about each station. We will also debrief as a class about the experience, and students will share their thoughts. Summary/Brief Description: Teacher will tell the students that there has been a new policy passed and in order to go to high school, they must pass a series of mental and physical inspections (use examples similar to ones listed the book If your name was changed at Ellis Island), and if they do not pass they must stay in 8th grade. Teacher then will ask if students have any questions about this, and after acting for a short while, inform students that this was a joke, but that it was not a joke for immigrants at Ellis Island in the early 20th century. Students will each be given a passport and grouped into families (some students will also be assigned various illness and ailments). The students will then make their way through stations (Interview, Medical exam, math exam, reading exam, etc.) which will be run ideally by parent volunteers. If they pass a checkpoint, they will move to the next; however, if they do not pass they must make their way to an area of the room considered detainment/hospital, or return to the ship. Students who make it all the way through will have to pay, and will be welcomed to America.
Lesson 10: Political Cartoons Content Area(s): Language Arts Lesson Objectives: Students will 10 Interpret political cartoons Determine importance of political cartoons and when/why they are used Identify elements of political cartoons How does this lesson adhere to your essential question(s) and how does it empower your students to further consider the question? Students must recall and reflect upon the various immigration aspects and experiences they have learned about in order to interpret and create the political cartoons. Instructional Materials: Minimum of three immigration political cartoons Historical background handouts to accompany cartoons Handout with cartoon and guiding questions to answer Paper Markers, colored pencils, etc. Instructional Strategies: Modeling / Think aloud Gradual release Cooperative learning Assessments (Formative and/or summative): The students handout with questions which was completed with a partner will be collected and assessed, as well as their created political cartoon. Students will be assessed on their ability to portray an immigration event/issue and include/identify various language arts skills used. Summary/Brief Description: Show any example of a political cartoon, and model with a think-aloud how to interpret the cartoon. Then introduce and explain what a political cartoon is, when they are used, and some language arts tools commonly used in them. Introduce a series of questions that can be used when analyzing political cartoons (i.e. what images do you see? what event is this referring to? what is the artist trying to say?). Be sure to also identify the language arts skills included in the cartoon. Provide a new political cartoon involving immigration to introduce, and give a brief background and details surrounding the event being portrayed. As a class, interpret the cartoon and use the previous questions as a guide. Students will then pair up and decipher a third immigration cartoon (teacher should provide historical background again). Students will then individually create their own immigration-themed political cartoon, along with a brief description of the message they were creating and what language arts skills they used.
What do you see as a culminating project that would demonstrate students growth in their understanding of the underlying concepts of the unit (i.e. your essential questions)?
As a culminating project, I want students to be able to have an element of choice in how they present 11 their understandings of the unit concepts. We will host a Melting Pot night where all parents, family, and community members will be invited to come and have the students show them what they have learned. Students will be given a list of ideas for their contribution to the night (EX: making a PSA, researching how another culture has blended with American culture, performing a poem/song/rap, etc.) and will also have the option to create their own idea with approval from the teacher. There will be a general rubric to follow for the project and the project must address one of the essential questions that we have been studying throughout the unit. The purpose of the night will be to bring faculty, students, families, and communities together under the idea of immigration and promote the common bonds that we all share as Americans.
Resource Bibliography: Book: Alvarez, J. (2009). Return to sender. New York: Alfred A. Knopff. PBS Documentary: The New Americans PBS Website: http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/newamericans/ Immigration Myths handout from tolerance.org: http://www.tolerance.org/lesson/immigrationmyths Immigrant to interview Family volunteers for Ellis Island Experience lesson U.S. Census Data: census.gov Readings from tenement website: http://www.thirteen.org/tenement/ Political cartoon: The Mortar of Assimilation (1889) Political cartoon: The Anti-Chinese Wall, by F. Graetz Political cartoon: Show Me Your Papers (2010), by Mike Luckovich