mv‡qÝ Bb ÔnwjÕ eyK

‡gv: Rvwgjyj evmvi

m¤cÖwZ B‡Ëdv‡K cÖKvwkZ R‰bK djR n‡Ki GKwU cÖwZ‡e`b W: wec−e cv‡ji †L`g‡Z wfbœ g‡Z cvVv‡bv n‡qwQj| cÖwZ‡e`bwUi g~j
cÖwZcv`¨ wQj †h, m¤cÖwZ weÁvb Avwe¯‹…Z gnv wek¦ m¤úmvi‡Yi K_v †Kviv‡b D‡j−L Av‡Q Ges Zvi mZ¨vmZ¨ cÖgvb Ki‡Z weÁvbx‡`i
14 kZ ermi mgq †j‡M‡Q BZ¨vw`|

Zvi wei“‡× wec−e cvj D‡j−wLZ wk‡ivbv‡g Lmov e¨envihy³ cÖwZ‡e`bwU cÖKvk K‡ib| ïay ZvBB bq wZwb e¨w³MZfv‡e Avgvi Kv‡QI
Av‡iv we¯—vwiZ mgv‡jvPbv cvVvb; †mLv‡b GI e‡j‡Qb †h, weÁvb, M‡elYv Ges Dnvi Z_¨ I ZË¡ Zvi cÖPzi Rvbv Av‡Q wKš‘ Rvwgjyj
evmv‡ii gZ GKRb Bwj−Uv‡iU †gvj−vi Kv‡Q Zv ejv cÖ‡qvRb g‡b K‡ib bv, BZ¨vw`|

eveyi †jLvi cÖ‡Z¨KwU jvBbB cvVK mgv‡jvPK‡`i Kv‡Q Ag~j¨ n‡jI bZzb wKQy bq| cv‡ji gZ cixw¶Z eyw×gvb weÁvbxMY cybt
cybt G·‡cwi‡g‡›Ui GKB ev wbwðr dj Qvov †Kvb wKQy MÖnY eR©b bv Kivi LZ& w`‡qB wZwb Ges Zviv wc GBP wWÕi mb` MÖnY K‡i‡Qb
e‡jB ˆeÁvwbK G¨¯‹‡cwi‡g›Uvj ‡jLvwUi wKQy wew¶ß mgv‡jvPbv wb‡æ:

evey Zvi †kl cvivq e‡jb:

1. When we took our degree in science, we all take the oath that we would remain faithful to the
practice of science-clearly the PhDs who are writing articles on science in religion have
violated their oaths. Universities must confiscate science degree from those individuals who
would try to discover science in religious books because such attempts are clear indication of
their poor training in science and therefore they do not qualify for a science degree. Atheists
must push this issue politically to stop the nonsense of science in religion.

K. D‡j−wLZ weei‡Y cÖKvk †h be¨ weÁvbxMY weÁvb Abykxj‡Y i‡evU n‡q _vKvi LZ& w`‡q AZtci mb`& cÖvß n‡q‡Qb| †ek
fv‡jv K_v! [Kvgivb wgR©vi ewY©Z ag©xq i‡ev‡Ui K_v ¯§iYxq|]

wKš‘ ag© MÖ‡š’ weÁvb LyR‡Z cvi‡eb bv ev Dnv‡Z weÁvb _vK‡jI Zv mg_©b Ki‡Z cvi‡eb bv ev ag© MÖš’ weÁvb wfwËK
M‡elYvB Ki‡Z cv‡eb bv A_ev weÁv‡bi Mv‡elwbK dj †Kviv‡bi mv‡_ wg‡j †M‡jI ¯^xKvi Ki‡eb bv A_ev weÁv‡bi
dj ag© RM‡Z idZvwb Ki‡Z cvi‡eb bv! Ggb †Kvb LZ& w`‡q‡Qb e‡j eveyi †jLvq G·‡cwi‡g›Uvj Z_¨ ev ZË¡ Av‡Q e‡j
g‡b nq bv| myZivs a‡g©i Dc‡i weÁvbg~Lx cÖwZ‡e`b wj‡L eveyi wQwbqi ÁvwZ fvB‡hiv wKfv‡e LZ& j•Nb K‡i †gvbv‡dK
n‡jb ? `qv K‡i cybt G¨·‡cwi‡g›U K‡i WvUv †eR eY©bv Ki“Y| e¨_© n‡j Zvi ¯^ †NvwlZ Ô`ye©j cÖwk¶b Z_v G¨·‡cwi‡g›UÕ
wenxY D™¢U cÖjv‡ci Rb¨ Av‡gwiKvb BDwbfviwmwU evey‡K A‡hvM¨ cÖgvb †nZz Zvi mb` cÎ evwZj Ki‡e wK bv?

L. GKRb mb`avix weÁvbx wnmv‡e †kl jvBbwU Agb bv wj‡L Ggb wjL‡j wK fv‡jv n‡Zv bv? Atheists must push this
issue scientifically---? GB push kãwU dzm, dvqvi, ‡U‡ivwió BZ¨vw`i G¨·‡cwi‡g›Uvj WvUv †e‡Ri ‡gŠwjK wfZ& wK
bv? n‡j BbUjv‡i›U †gŠjev`x †_‡K W: eveyiv KZ`~j `~‡i?

M. GKB LZ&avix be¨ i‡evU ÁvwZ fvB‡`i m‡½ hLb gZwe‡iva N‡U ZLb Zv‡`i d‡Zvqv: Ô†Kvb BDwbfviwmwU †_‡K W±‡iU
mb` cÖvß n‡q‡Qb! †Kvb ¸i“i wkl¨ BZ¨vw`!Õ hw`I Zv‡`i Rvbv Av‡Q †h ¸i“ ˆeÁvwb‡`i AwaKvs‡kiB BDwbfviwmwU †Zv
`~‡ii K_v ¯‹zj-K‡j‡Ri mb` ch©š— wQj bv| Avi Zviv Kv‡iv Kv‡Q i‡evwUq LZ&I †`b wb! AZGe GUv be¨ weÁvbx‡`i
G¨v·‡cwi‡g›U wei“× fvev‡eM bq wK?

N. mb‡` †Pnvov-QyiZ ev Avw` PwiÎ ev Avw` i‡mi cÖavbZt †Zgb GKUv cwieZ©b NUvq bv ev N‡Uw&b| IUvi ¸i“Z¡ Kv‡iv Aax‡b
i‡evwUq †Mvjvgx Kivi †hvM¨Zvi cÖv_wgK G¨·‡cwi‡g›Uvj WvUv †eR gvÎ| †Kvb& ¸i“i wkl¨, †Kvb& ev‡ci cyÎ, KZUzKz Ávb-
MyYavwi! cvj, Kzgvi wK cj! Zvi BwZevPK G¨·‡cwi‡g›Uvj cwiPq Zvi Pjgvb Kg© I ¯^fve PwiÎB cÖavb| myZivs mb`,
ms¯’v ev ¸i“ wk‡l¨i †`vnvB weÁv‡bi Av‡jv‡Z wKQyUv cÖZviYv g~jK Z_v GZÏ„wó‡Z eveyi e³e¨ AvswkK ¯^-we‡ivax e‡jB
g‡b nq|
 O. me‡P‡q eo K_v H A_&wU eveyi ev Av‡gwiKvb BDwbfviwmwUi byZb Avwe¯‹vi bq| 14 kZ ermi c~‡e©B g~L© †gvnv¤§` (mv) H
A_&wUiI cÖeZ©K [`ª: 17:36] DnvB wZj cwigvY ‡mÝi (hš¿cvwZi ms‡hvRb) K‡iB W±‡iUMY bKj K‡i New findings
e‡j Ghver Pvwj‡q hv‡”Qb| wek¦vm bv nq Progressive Gi †nvg †c‡Ri dzUcv‡Z jUKv‡bv ¯’vqx ˆeÁvwbK mvBb‡evW©wU
Dj½ †Pv‡LI `k©b Ki‡Z cv‡ib| G¶‡Y A_& bvgvwU mivmwi †Kvivb †_‡K bKj K‡i‡Qb ej&‡jB †Zv W¨vwms-cywls, Gd we
AvB, gvgjv gK`©gvi ‡_ªW w`‡q Ujv‡i›U Gi ¯^v¶i ivL‡eb!

evey e‡jb:
-- Typically when we start doing research as a graduate student, we all had a tendency to speak about
our new findings-however as we get seasoned, supervisors would mould us into the domain of science-
where experimental data is presented first and when we talk about our `discoveries’ as much as
experimental data would allow us to speak-not a single discovery we can present without backing-up
with repeatable results.

K. evey‡K wj‡L wQjvg †h wZwb weÁvbx bb, weÁvbx‡`i D¤§Z ev Abymvix| G‡Z wZwb weeªZ †eva K‡iB m¤¢eZ cÖwZ‡e`bwU
wj‡Lb| weÁv‡bi cÖPwjZ, cÖwZwôZ I Avwe®K…Z welqe¯—i †ZvZv c¶xq wk¶v Ges Dnv‡`i `vjvjx Qvov eveyi wbR¯^ †Kvb
Avwe¯‹vi Av‡Q wK bv? hvi e‡`Šj‡Z wZwb wbR‡K GKRb cÖwZwôZ weÁvbx e‡j `vwe Ki‡Z cv‡ib? wKQy Avwe¯‹vi bv K‡iB
Avwe¯‹…Z welqe¯‘ Avwe¯‹vi K‡iB hw` wbR‡K ˆeÁvwbK `vwe K‡ib Z‡e Zv‡K gvbwlK fvimvg¨ wenxY ˆeÁvwbK ev wkw¶Z
W±i wWwMÖavix MÛ-- ejvi AwaKvi Av‡Q wK bv?

L. ïi“‡ZB D‡j−L Kiv n‡q‡Q †h, evmv‡ii gZ fvimvg¨nxY I g~L©‡K Zvi Rvbv weÁv‡bi A‡bK Z_¨ Rvbv‡eb bv| evmvi GKRb
g~L© Zv wb‡RB ¯^xKvi K‡i Ges K‡qKevi wewfbœ cÖwZ‡e`‡b Zv ¯^xKvi Kiv n‡q‡Q| Z‡e evevRx! Avcwb †h Z_¨¸wj Rv‡bb
Zv wK Avcbvi wbR¯^ Avwe¯‹vi? New findings? bv avi, gyL¯— Kiv? Avcwb Qvov A‡b¨i KvQ †_‡K Zv cvIqv m¤¢e wK bv?
hw` m¤¢e nq Z‡e †Zv Bwj−Uv‡iU n‡jI evmvi‡K ÔBwj−Uv‡iUÕ ejv AMv‡elYxK !

evey e‡jb:
Interesting to note, some of such nut-heads bring the name of famous scientists who were admirer of
religion. For examples, Openheimmer or DCG Sudarshan was fascinated Gita, Abdus Salam was a
devoted Koran follower in his old age, But they liked religious texts because of its philosophy of life
and certainly not for `science in religion.’ I can not think of any leading scientist who claimed he
found scientific laws in religious texts! Mostly some second rated mentally imbalanced people with
PhD degree in Science wrote several books to prove traces of modern science in religious books.---.

K. I‡cbnvB¤§vi I my`k©YI H GKB e„× e‡q‡m MxZv f³ n‡q‡Qb wK bv Zv e‡jbwb| c¶vš—‡i AvãyQ Qvjvg eva¨K¨ †nZz †Kvivb
f³ n‡q‡Qb ! AweKj hyw³ w`‡q †Kv_vI wj‡LwQ‡jb †h, RvwZi cÖwZóvZv †kL mv‡ne msm` fe‡b †Kvb GK Kv‡j ¯úxKvi
mv‡n` Avjx‡K †Pqvi w`‡q AvNvZ K‡ib| gyû‡Z© i³ e‡q hvq Ges i³ eÜ Ki‡Z bv cvivq 3w`b c‡i ¯úxKvi gviv hvb|
eªv‡K‡U wj‡LwQ‡jb ¯úxKv‡ii Wvq‡ewUK wQj| A_©vr wZwb G¨v·‡cwi‡g›Uvj WvUv w`‡q eySv‡Z Pv‡”Qb †h, †kL mv‡ne ¸Ûv,
LyYw wQ‡jb bv! Zvi †Pqv‡ii AvNv‡Z bq eis Zvi Wvq‡ewUKB Zvi gyZzi cÖavb AvjvgZ wQj! Z`ª“c AvãyQ Qvjv‡gi e„×
eqmwUB ag©vbyiv‡Mi cÖavb KviY ej‡Z Pv‡”Qb! evK¨wU weÁv‡bi Av‡jv‡K KvUv wQiv Ki‡j Ggb evK¨I Avwe¯‹vi Kiv m¤¢e
†h: e„× eq‡m Zvi ¯§„wZåg ev gwZåg n‡q‡Q|
AweKj GKwU d‡Zvqv gv.Avãyi iwng I mvqL AvRxRyj nKI Mfxi I m~´ wePv‡i e‡jb †h, ÔnhiZ AveyeK‡ii nvw`Q
†cvov‡bvi cÖavb Ab¨Zg KviY Ôwe‡kl gb¯—vwZ¡K I gvbwlK Ae¯’vi cwiYvg|Õ A_©vr Zv‡`i wek¦vm †h, AveyeK‡ii gv_v
Lvivc n‡qwQj e‡jB nvw`Q cywo‡q wQ‡jb! mvjvg mv‡n‡ei gZ GUg ˆeÁvwbK hLb H e‡q‡m jvB‡di wd‡jvmwd wnmv‡e
†kl ch©š— ag©weÁvb‡K MÖnY K‡i‡Qb! ZLb cv‡jiI H eq‡m Ggb nIqvi AvjvgZ weÁvb m¤§Z wK bv?
L. Philosophy of life bv wj‡L eis Philosophy of religion wjL‡j Avcbvi a„óZv aiv co‡Zv bv| Qvjvg‡`i m‡½
mivmwi †hvMv‡hvM ev G¨·‡cwi‡g›U K‡iB wK Zv‡`i m¤^‡Ü e³e¨wU wj‡L‡Qb? bv Avwgbx, QvBw`‡`i gZ Mv‡q‡e wek¦vm
K‡i ev ¯^‡cœ †c‡q gš—e¨wU K‡i‡Qb? Giƒc n‡j Avcbvi mb` cÎwU evwZj †hvM¨ wK bv?

M. ag©MÖ‡š’ e−vW-myMvi, Pvc, Zvc BZ¨vw` gvcvi hš¿, K¨v‡giv, nvZzix-evUvjx, †KPx-¶z‡ii Qwe †bB mZ¨ Ges Dnvi cÖ‡qvM
cÏZx †bB, ZvI mZ¨| wKš‘ cix¶v-wbiw¶v wenxb g~L© bex wK K‡i! †Kvb& weÁv‡bi wfwˇZ AvR‡Ki mZ¨wU 14 kZ ermi
c~‡e©B e‡j †M‡Qb! ZeyI †gvnv¤§` Ges Zvi †jLvi cÖwZ wnsmv ‰e wZj cwigvY AvMÖn-‡KŠZznj ev‡owb| ‡gvnv¤§` ev bexMY
hš¿ wenxb †Kgb ‰eÁvwbK wQ‡jb Zv cÖgvb Kivi hš¿cvwZ GLbI Avwe¯‹vi Ki‡Z m¶g nb wb, Z‡e n‡eb ˆe wK| myZivs
Av‡iv hv Av‡Q Zv Avwe¯‹vi I ¯^xKvi Ki‡Z Av‡iv KZ nvRvi 14 kZ ermi jvM‡e! Avi hw` fv‡eb †h wbR¯^ eqm KvjwUB
†kl Kvj! wWwMÖxwUB †kl wWwMÖ Z‡e †m Avjv`v K_v e‡U!

N. ivmv` Ljxdv KZ„©K †Kviv‡bi ˆeÁvwbK Kw¤úDUvi M‡elYvi dj m¤^‡Ü KLbI wKQy wj‡L‡Qb e‡j Avgvi Rvbv †bB; m¤¢eZ
Zv †Pv‡L c‡o bv Ges co‡eI bv|

O. fvlv m„wó GKwU weÁvb; cÖwZwU eY©B gnv ‰eÁvwbK Avwe¯‹vi! †mB weÁv‡bi fvlvqB ag©MÖš’vw` †jLv; Dnvi cÖ‡Z¨KwU eY©-kãB
†Zv weÁvb| eywS bv e‡j Dnv‡Z wKQy †bB ejv wkï myjf ev weK…Z gM‡Ri ewntcÖKvk Qvov Avi wK ejv hvq!

†Kvivb m¤^‡Ü hZ gš—e¨ K‡ib Zvi meB †gvj−v B›Uvi‡cÖUvi‡`i Dci WUv‡eR M‡elYv wenxY AÜ wek¦vm ¯’vcb K‡iB! ZvB
bv? Ges ZvivI AvR ch©š— ms‡¶c kã¸wji B›Uvi‡cÖU Ki‡ZB m¶gB nb wb| hvi Kvi‡Y Dnv‡`i av‡i Kv‡QI †Nul‡Z
cvi‡Qb bv! MÖ‡Üi fvlvB Rv‡bb bv! myZivs †gvj−v‡`i Dci Bgvb G‡b ‡h gš—e¨ K‡ib Zv †gvj−v‡`i †gvj−v ev Zv‡`i †Q‡j-
wkl¨‡`i gZ nIqvB †Zv weÁvb m¤§Z| AZGe djvdj Ô‡gŠjev‡`i GwcV-IwcV| m¤cÖwZ Ôc„w_ex weQvbvi gZ j¤^v P¨vcUvÕ
Abyev`wU wb‡q AK¬vš— wimvm© cwikªg K‡i K¬vš— n‡q‡Qb! g‡b c‡o? co‡e bv! KviY evmv‡ii GKwU gvÎ cÖwZ‡e`b wc wW Gd
digv‡U †c‡q co‡Z †c‡i‡Qb! A_©vr ej‡Z Pv‡”Qb †h, evwK¸wj c‡obwb ev co‡Z cv‡ib wb! hw`I Avcbvi Avg‡ji mKj
cÖwZ‡e`bB wc wW Gd digv‡UB cvVv‡bv n‡qwQj Ges Zv wbqwgZ †cvó K‡i‡Qb hv AvgivI co‡Z †c‡iwQ|

P. Ôwd‡jvmwd Ae mv‡qÝÕ e‡j wKQy ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb| welqwU wK M‡elYv wfwËK? AZGe Ômv‡qÝ Ae wd‡jvmwdÕ ej‡Z wKQy
_vKv ¯^vfvweK e‡U! Ges †mLv‡b Rvqv›U K¨v‡givi `iKvi Av‡Q e‡j g‡b nq bv| Zvi ciI Av‡Q: BKbwgK mv‡qÝ,
‡mvmvj mv‡qÝ, wnwl&ª mv‡qÝ, cwjwUK¨vj mv‡qÝ, wRIMÖvwd mv‡qÝ, RyIjwR mv‡qÝ, cvwievwiK mv‡qÝ, †hŠY mv‡qÝ,
KzKzi, weovj mv‡qÝ, AvU© Kjv-gyjv mv‡qÝ BZ¨vw` hvi me¸wjB †Kviv‡b eZ©gvb| A_©vr †h AvqvZwUB co‡eb †mLv‡bB
mv‡qÝ; mv‡qÝB mv‡qÝ| Ggb Ae¯’vq wiwjwRqvm mv‡qÝ ev mv‡qÝ Ae wiwjwRqb ¯^xKvi Ki‡Z cvj‡`i `g eÜ n‡q
Avmvi KviY AÁvZ! nq‡Zv ev i‡evwUq LZ& †`qv mb` nvivevi f‡q? bv Ab¨ wKQy?

Ô‡hLv‡b †`wL‡e QvB

LuywRqv †`wL‡e ZvB
‡c‡jI †c‡Z cvi
Ag~j¨ iZb|Õ
Abyi“c AvqvZ †Kviv‡b K‡qK nvRvi weبgvb| D‡j−wLZ AvqvZwU c‡o hw` †Kn e‡j †h, QvB wK! †Kv_vq! Pzwj−i QvB wK wPZvi
QvB ! KZ wWMªx Zv‡c QvB nq! QvBi BbwMÖwW‡q›Um& wK wK! BZ¨vw`i G¨v·‡cwi‡g›Uvj †KvbB WvUv †eR AvqvZwU‡Z †bB! QvB Ly‡R
wKQy cvBwb! myZivs ILv‡b weÁv‡bi ÔeÕI †bB| wWMÖxavix Ggb weÁvbx‡`i g~L© ejv wK Bwj−Uv‡iU‡`i `vwqZ¡ bq?
Avi n¨v! P›`ª-m~h©, MÖn-Zviv, AvKvk-cvZvj, MvQcvjv-cï-cw¶, w`b-ivZ, Rb¥-gyZz¨, m„wó-Am„wó; AZxZ, eZ©gvb, fyZ-
fwel¨r; Ggb †Kvb welq weÁvb †bB hv †Kviv‡b D‡j−L, Bw½Z †bB!
Z‡e AZxe ¯§iYxq †h †Kvivb cÖavbZ: PZzi, wkw¶Z,wjwg‡UW wkw¶Z, †ZvZvcvLx wkw¶Z Ges wbqZ Lvivcx, e`y‡`¨k¨avix ayi›`i,
`vjvj‡`i Rb¨ bq! ‡Kvivb Zv evi evi kZK© K‡i w`‡q‡Q| eis bgª, f`ª, webqx; mnR-mij, wbt¯^v_©, Z¨Mx, gvbeZvev`x †QvU-
eo Ávbx‡`i Rb¨|

Q. Ôag©Õ weÁvb‡K Pigfv‡eB mg_©b K‡i|evjy KYv, †hŠY KYv e‡jb, †QvU-eo e¨vOM e‡jb! meB †Zv weÁv‡b Wyeš—! Avi
weÁvb Wyeš— Áv‡b; Ávb Wyeš— ARvbv, A`„k¨ a¨v‡b (Avj−vn,†Lv`v, MW, Ck¦i,fMev‡b)| m„wói mK‡jiB ag© Av‡Q| wccov-
 ‡gŠgvwQwUI gnv ˆeÁvwbK! Ki“Y bv AweKj Abyi“c GK‡dvUv gay ‰Zix! ag© weÁvb-weÁvbB ag©; Zv Pigfv‡eB ¯^xKvh¨©| wKš‘ wg:
cv‡ji weÁvb myÎ cÖavbZ: kvwjK,†ZvZvcvLxq Ges we‡eK ewR©Z `vjvjx e¨emv myÎ gvÎ! PZzi KzU-eyw× Qvov mnR mij
mvaviY-AmvaviY Áv‡bi m‡½ Zvi †Kvb m¤úK© †bB; eis we‡iva| A`„k¨ Áv‡bi cwiõzUb ev Áv‡bi ev¯—e iƒc ev djB
weÁvb; hv‡Z Rxe mgv‡Ri Kj¨vY Qvov AKj¨vY †Kvbfv‡eB cÖgvb Kiv hvq bv| mb` bv _vK‡jI weÁ-AwfÁRbB ¯^ ¯^ †¶‡Î
ˆeÁvwbK| c¶vš—‡i 9wU wWMÖxavox MYgvby‡li Kb¨v WvUv e¨vwmR we‡k¦i †kªóZg ˆeÁvwbK! AZtci wg: cvj! ZvB bv?

wg: cvj cix¶v wbix¶v Qvov †Kvb wKQyB ¯^xKvi mg_©b K‡ib wb! K‡ib bv, Ki‡eb bv! KviY wZwb A_&-LZ& cÖhy³ wkKwjZ, xjwg‡UW
ˆeÁvwbK! ZvB wZwb ‡Kv_vI wj‡LwQ‡jb †h, jvj‡bi `k©bI ˆeÁvwbK cix¶v wbwi¶v Qvov ¯^xKvi Ki‡eb bv Ges K‡ibwb| G‡nb
ˆeÁvwbK hyw³ w`‡q Zvi ¸i“-`v`v mgZzj¨ KwZcq cÖwZwóZ weÁvbx‡`iI eûZ †S‡o‡Qb! `xN© w`b hver ag© I †Kviv‡bi wei“‡×
wb‡ew`Z n‡q Av‡Qb; Aa© wkw¶Z evmvi‡K ÔBwj−Uv‡iU †gvj−vÕ e‡j d‡Zvqv w`‡q‡Qb! Zv‡Z evmvi wKQyB g‡b K‡iwb ev Zv‡Z W:
cv‡ji [wc GBP wW, (weÁvb,Av‡gwiKv)] Dci fv‡jvevmv fw³ kª×viI †Kvb KgwZ nqwb ev n‡e bv| AZGe cybt cybt M‡elYvjã H
GKB hyw³i LvwZ‡i wbæ ewY©Z WvUv‡eR cÖkœ Kivi AwaKvi weÁvb m¤§Z e‡jB g‡b nq| DËi †`qv bv †`qv Zvi Awfi“wP:

1. hš¿cvwZ wbf©ikxj weÁvb-M‡elYvq cÖgvb K‡i‡Qb †h, KzKzi-ïI‡ii exR I gvby‡li ex‡R †KvbB cv_©K¨ †bB eis
AweKj I mgv‡b mgvb [†kl cix¶vi djvdj Rvbv †bB|] m¤cÖwZ cix¶v-wbix¶v K‡i ÔAvwg †KÕ m¤^‡Ü eûevi
g~j¨evb Ava¨vwZ¡K ‰eÁvwbK cÖwZ‡e`b Qvwc‡q‡Qb; ZvB bv? n¨uv!-Gevi ej~b:

K. Ghver hv‡K evev †W‡K Avm‡Qb wZwbB wK ‰`Z¨ K¨v‡givq ¯^ n¯—-‡Pv‡L weÁvb cixw¶Z Rb¥`vZv?

L. ‡Kvb& exRwU †_‡K Avcbvi Drcbœ ! Zvi ˆeÁvwbK M‡elYv-wimvm© K‡i wbwðr n‡q‡Qb wK bv?

M. nZ¨v; Pzix, WvKvZx, wQbZvB, AZ¨vPvi; wg_¨v, An¼vi, †jvf, Nyl, ejrKvi, UvDU-evUcvix, `vjvjx; A_©vr my-Kz,
mZ¨-wg_¨v, b¨vq-Ab¨v‡qi BZ¨vw`i Rvqv›U K¨v‡giv ev j¨ve‡iUix M‡elYvi DcvË, ¯^i“c I djvdj wK?

N. cvwievwiK †m· m¤^Üxq Avi GKwU cÖkœ Av‡Q! cybe©vi Zv wjL‡Z PvB bv| KviY Zv 2/3 evi cÖKvk Kiv n‡q‡Q|`qv
K‡i †mwUI GZ`m‡½ hy³ K‡i DËi w`b?

D‡j−wLZ WvUv‡e‡Ri Aš—Z Ges Kg‡Q Kg †h †Kvb GKwUi ˆeÁvwbK Mv‡elYxK wfwË hw` Avcbvi bv _v‡K! Z‡e Av‡gwiKvb
BDwbfviwmwU †Kb †gvbv‡dK †NvNbv KiZt Avcbvi wc GBP wW mb` A‰ea e‡j ev‡Rqvß Ki‡e bv?

weÁv‡bi K_v e‡j e‡j A‡b‡Ki Rxe‡Yi 12 AvbvB wg_¨v cÖgvb Kivi e¨_© †Póvq wjß Av‡Qb| wKš‘ mvZvi bv Rvb‡j ‡h 16 AvbvB
wg_¨v cÖwZcbœ nq Zv So ev DËvj †XD‡q bv cov ch©š— Avcbv‡`i ¯^xKvi Kiv‡bv hv‡e bv! KviY Avcbviv A_&-¶Z& †`qv ‰eÁvwbK
wjwg‡UW †gvj−v A_ev Kvgivb wgR©vi i‡evU! gnv gvb¨ nwKsmMY 14k ermi Av‡MB hw` weZK©xZ AvqvZwUi Av‡jv‡K M‡elYv KvR
Pvjv‡Zb Z‡e AvR‡Ki w`bwU 14k ermi mvg‡b GwM‡q _vK‡Zv|

W: cvj!
gy`ªv †`vl ej‡Z GKUv gy`ªv weÁvb Av‡Q; gv‡bb †Zv! ewikv‡ji `w¶b A‡j wbKU Avw`‡Z wKQy gM emevm Ki‡Zb| Zviv kZ †Póv
K‡iI Ô†MvjvjyÕ ej‡ZB cvi‡Zb bv| c~e©v‡ji iwmK PZziMY Zv‡`i †`L‡jB dvb K‡i ej‡Zb †h, Ô†n! Ô†MvjvjyÕ ej‡Z cvi‡j 5
†mi im‡Mvj−v cvwe|Õ Iiv AvcÖvY †Póv Ki‡Zv wKš‘ ej‡Z cvi‡Zv bv| evi eviB g~L †_‡K †ei n‡Zv Ô‡Mvivjy;Õ im‡Mvj−vi †jv‡f
gM wb‡Ri gb‡K evi evi KgvÛ Ki‡Zv †h, gb! †`vnvB †Zvi! wVK K‡i ej! 5 †mi im‡Mvj−v cvwe! †Mv- †Mv-‡Mvivjy | welqwU
cvVK‡`i mvgwqK Avb›` w`‡jI nZvm Ki‡e GB †R‡b †h, Wt cv‡jiI †mB gy`ªv‡`vlwU M‡elYvq WvUv‡eRmn aiv c‡o‡Q; ïay g~LB
bq eis Zvi †Pv‡L GgbwK nv‡ZI H †`vlwU weØgvb|
A‡b‡KiB G¨v·‡cwi‡g›Uvj cÖgvb: hvi †jLvB Zvi wei“× ev gbc~Z bv nq! Zvi bvgwUB wZwb weK…Z K‡i wj‡Lb! GKB Awf‡hvM
c~‡e©I `yÕevi K‡iwQ, ci ci D‡j−L‡hvM¨ †ek K‡qKRb †jLKI K‡i‡Qb| wKš‘ W±‡ii Ô†MvivjyÕ AvRI ms‡kvab nqwb! Zvi nvZ,
†PvL I g~‡Li †Kvb Aby‡kvPbv †bB, Ggb wK Av¶wiK ev mvwnZ¨-JcbœvwmK jvR j¾¨viI ¯^v¶i ivL‡Z cv‡ib wb| myZivs †Kvb
iwmK †jLK B”Qv K‡iB ÔcvjÕ Gi ÔcvÕi ¯’‡j hw` ÔevÕ wj‡Lb! Zv‡Z Zvi ˆeÁvwbK wimvm©, GUg ev Rvq¨v›U K¨v‡giv w`‡q †VKv‡bvi
†Kvb c_ †bB| AvkvKwi gy`ªv‡`vlwU Gev‡i im‡Mvj−v QvovB ms‡kvab n‡e|
50 ermi eq‡mva© evsjv‡`kx‡`i MÖvg-M‡Äi evRv‡i wj‡gv‡b‡Wi †evZ‡ji cwiPq Av‡Q; †QvU †ejvq Avgiv ejZvg Ô‡j‡e‡bW,Õ
hvi Mjvq GKwU gv‡e©j _v‡K †mwU Ggbfv‡e AvUKv‡bv ‡h, ‡evZjwU bv fv½v ch©š— ‡evZ‡ji Zj‡`‡k wK¤^v evwni Kiv hvq bv|Avgiv
my‡Zv I km¨vi †Zj w`‡q weÁvb PP©v K‡i †ei Kivi †Póv KiZvg| †evZjwUi Zdmxi Kivi KviY eûw`b c~‡e©B Dnv Aejyß †nZz
A‡b‡KB wP‡bb bv e‡j GB cÖev`wU eyS‡Z cvi‡Zb bv: ÔAvKv‡k D‡ovRvnvR †Kg‡b P‡j Zv eywS! cvZv‡j Wy‡ev RvnvR †Kg‡b P‡j
ZvI eywS! wKš‘ †j‡e‡bW †evZ‡ji Mjvq wK K‡i gv‡e©jwU XyKv‡jv! Avi wK K‡iB ev †evZj bv †f‡½ †ei Kiv hvq! Zv AvR ch©š—
ey‡S DV‡Z cvijvg bv!

Abyiƒc eû eû w`b hver evevRxi GK‡PwUqv weÁvb-wimvm© ïb‡Z ïb‡Z Kvb Svjv-cvjv n‡q †Mj! wi³ n‡¯— eûZ wk¶v DRvo K‡i
w`‡jb, wb‡jb bv wKQyB| Ghver Kvj A‡bK wKQyB ïbjvg, me wKQyB eySjvg! wKš‘ eyS‡Z cvijvg bv Zvi gZ GKRb weÁvb wc GBm
wW avox ˆeÁvwbK evDov e¨emvq ‡Kb AvZ¥wb‡qvM Ki‡jb! eqmUvB nq‡Zv ev `vqx! [cywj‡ki `vjvj‡`i ÔBbdigvi,Õ we‡qi
`vjvj‡`i ÔNUKÕ Avi †ek¨v‡`i `vjvj‡`i AvÂwjK ‰eÁvwbK fvlvq ÔevDovÕ e‡j|]

hZ`~i Rvwb wfbœ gZ GKRb evsjv‡`kxi m„wó| wek¦vm Kivi hyw³ Av‡Q †h, wZwb wb‡R c~‡e©i gZB mvBU Acv‡iU Ki‡j †Kvb g‡ZB
Ôcwðg evsjvÕ ‡nvg †c‡Ri Pzovq emv‡Zb bv! hv wbZvš— ¯^vfvweK; Avi Rvb©vjwUi AwaKvsk cvVKB evsjv‡`kx| A_P fvov‡U
Amv¤cÖ`vwqK (?) evey e‡mB cwðg evsjv‡K Pzovq emv‡jb! Kwe bRi“j‡K emv‡Z wimv‡m© j¤^v mgq †¶cY K‡i‡Qb| jvBd †_ªW, Gd
we AvBÕi ao-cvKo, gvgjv gK`©gv, RySz eyoxi ARynv‡Z ag©weÁvb †¶ÎwU we‡jvc K‡i evDov e¨emvi †hŠY weÁvb ewm‡q w`‡jb!
m`vjv‡ci wei“‡×I gvgjv gK`©gvi ûgwK w`‡q eZ©gv‡b K¬vš—|
wfbœ gZ& ev¯—weKB wbw`©ó fvov‡Ui ZvÛ‡e AZx‡Zi HwZn¨ nvwi‡q †d‡j‡Qb! fvov‡Uiv me Kv‡jB mv¤cÖ`vwqK I Mnxb mv¤cÖ`vwqK
D‡Ïk¨ wfwËK! KviY Zv‡`i g~‡L nwi, Mjvq †`eZvi ‡`‡ni Pvgovi †Xvj! Avi GK`j fvov‡U m¤cÖwZ mviv we‡k¦ kvwš—i bv‡g ¯^-
Áv‡b, ‡m”Qvq AKvZ‡i gymjgvb nZ¨v K‡i gymjgvb‡`i mvnvh¨ Ki‡Qb![`ª: W: Avjx wmbv] eveyi G¨·‡cwi‡g‡›U wZwb gnv Ávbx!

mv¤cÖ`vwqKZv Z¨v‡Mi †Nvlbv w`‡jB wK 84 j¶ †Rvbx †f`Kvix †`nwUi i‡³ Mov gb-gM‡Ri AvPgKv cwieZ©b m¤¢e? Av‡iv
`yÕPviwU †RvYx †f` Qvov? weÁv‡b Av‡Q Ggb †Kvb WvUv‡eR Z_¨-myÎ? m‡›`n nq cÖwZ‡ebwU †cvó Ki‡eb wK bv! KviY cvVv‡bv `y-
`yÕwU †jLv GLb ch©š— †cvó K‡ibwb|
gqjv ay‡j Kqjv hvq;
Kqjv ay‡j wK gqjv hvq? (weÁvb cix¶v cÖv_©bxq)
`v`v evey
†cŠËwjK ag© †Q‡o wb‡Ri Dc‡i bvw¯—K d‡Zvqv w`‡q‡Qb Ges Dnvi mZ¨vq‡Yi Rb¨ Mi“ †`eZvi †Mv¯— ch©š— †L‡q‡Qb Ges Zvi
weÁvcbI w`‡q‡Qb| wKš‘ Ôgvó c~lÕ Ki‡Z Ki‡Z hLb GKw`b AvZ¥NvZx gyRvwn` n‡q, ‡W_& Avmvgx n‡q aiv co‡eb (wbwðZ bq)! ZLb
¯^-ivóª cÖwZ gš¿x A_ev wW wm, `v‡ivMv Avw` cwiPq Rvbvi Rb¨ Avcbvi †`n †gvevi‡Ki welyweq AÂj `k©b K‡i myiZ nvj WvUv
wi‡cv‡U© Aek¨B Ôbvw¯—KÕ wjL‡eb bv| wn›`y, †cŠËwjK, †eŠ×, wkL, Bûw` L„óvb I gymjgvbMY H A‡ji GKB cZvKvi `yÕwU wfbœ
wQ¤^j `Lj K‡i Av‡Qb| `iKvi gZ Dnv `k©Y K‡i Avcbv‡K Aš—Z evsjv-cwðg evsjvq Avw¯—K ev †cŠËwjK e‡jB mbv³ Ki‡eb,
bvw¯—K wnmv‡e bq! ZLb ¯^ †NvwlZ I ¯^xK…Z d‡ZvqvwU A‰eÁvwbK cÖgvb emZ: KvR Ki‡e bv| myZivs bvw¯—K‡`i H †gi“‡ZB weÁvb
m¤§Z GKwU wbkvbvi Ri“ix `iKvi Av‡Q e‡j AvRI ¸i“Z¡ †`b wb| wKQy g‡b Ki‡eb bv Dnvi e¨wZµg c_I †Lvjv Av‡Q! Z‡e Dnv‡Z
cybt cybt cixw¶Z ¯’vqx dj †`‡e bv|

W±‡iU evey !
weÁvb-weÁvb, M‡elYv, cix¶v-wbwi¶xq IqvR-bwQnZ& Ki‡Z Ki‡Z g~‡L d¨vbv Zz‡j †d‡j‡Qb! wKš‘ ÔAvwgÕ ‡K? †Zv `~‡ii K_v!
Avcwb Kvi! †Kvb& ex‡Ri DrcwË! Zvi Mv‡qex Bgvb Qvov GLb ch©š— cixw¶Z `wjj WvUv‡eR Avcbvi nv‡Z †bB e‡jB wek¦vm| Avi
GKRb W±‡iU! 14 kZ erm‡ii †miv 100 R‡bi cÖavb †miv A_ev bv-B ev †miv, wewjqbm †jv‡Ki mb¥vwbZ I wek¦vm fvRb bex
†gvnv¤§‡`i (mv) wimvm© Ki‡Z Ki‡Z GKwU gvÎ ¸YI Rvqv›U K¨v‡givq aiv c‡owb! Kzrmv MvB‡Z MvB‡Z Z…Zxq wek¦ hy‡×i wn‡iv nIqvi
cixw¶Z WvUv‡eR ¯^cœ †`L‡Qb ! Z…Zxq Avi GKRb W±‡iU, Kzrmv MvB‡Z wM‡q bv‡gi weo¤^bv †iv‡M AK¬vš—! ev‡ci †`qv bvg D”Pvi‡Y
fq cvb! Dnv‡Z bvwK †gŠjev` weasmx evi“‡`i MÜ Av‡Q! ïb‡jB bvwK †gŠjev`xiv Svwc‡q co‡e! ZvB evi evi bvg cwieZ©b Ki‡Qb!
ˆeÁvwbK bvg GLb ch©š— Ly‡R cvbwb|
G‡nb ˆeÁvwbK W±‡iUm& wWMÖxavox D¤§Z/Db¥v`‡`i wb‡q ¸i“i ¸i“ wgwjqb-wewjqb gvbyl, cï Ggb wK c„w_ex Ly‡Yi AMÖ-bvqK! Avcb
mr Kb¨vmn 12 Kb¨vi ¯^vgx-evÜe! [`ª: B‡ËdvK, 12-07-06] [cyi“‡liI ¯^vgx wQ‡jb wK bv Zv GLbI †Lvjvmv nqwb|] LyYx †bv‡ej
weRqx nhiZ AvjevU© AvBbóvBb (wc GBP wW wWwMÖnxY) wK Ki‡Zb †K Rv‡b!! gvd Ki‡eb! WvKvZ, LyYx e‡jwQ GRb¨ †h c„w_exï×
Dwo‡q w`‡j gvbe Kj¨v‡Y gnvg~j¨evb Ôw_Dix Ae wi‡jwUwfwUÕI D‡o hv‡e! †hLvb †_‡K AvmwQj wVK †mLv‡bB cybt †dir hv‡e|

Áv‡bi AbykxjYB weÁvb|

ÁvbnxY weÁvbB kqZvb|

weÁvbnxY Ávb A`„k¨|

A`„‡k¨B Kvgbv, evmbv|
DnvB a¨vb Dcvmbv|
DcvmbvB weÁv‡bi myPYv||

Abyi~c Ma©e LvUzbx Avi †hb Ki‡Z bv nq| ZvB mwebq wb‡e`b:

eûw`b c~‡e© Av‡¶c K‡i wj‡LwQ‡jb: †Kn Acœv‡K Avw¯—K e‡j, †Kn e‡j bvw¯—K; Avevi †Kn e‡j ˆeÁvwbK, `vk©wbK, cwjwUK,
Ab¨iv e‡j ivRbxwZwe`, A_© ˆbwZK,mvwnwZ¨K, wn›`y we‡ivax, gymjgvb we‡ivax, ag© we‡ivax, †mKzjvi BZ¨vw`| nimrdzj− ev nZvm n‡q
civgk© †P‡qwQ‡jb ÔGLb Avcwb wK Ki‡eb! †Kv_vq hv‡eb!Õ
Mv‡q c‡o civgk© w`‡qwQjvg: wPiKzU -46 (m¤¢eZ) †evW© evuavB K‡i, eMj`vev KiZt †`‡k wd‡i Avw` e¨emvq AvZ¥wb‡qvM Ki“Y|
evsMvjx †nZz webv cqmvi civgk© nvivg Ávb K‡i cvËv †`bwb| AveviI GKUz ‡‡mÝi, mnR K‡i ewj: †`‡k †divi `iKvi †bB|
GLv‡bB Avw` e¨emvwU Pvjy Ki“Y| Avkv Kwi cY© e−vK gv‡K©wUs e¨emvi †P‡q fv‡jv dj cv‡eb| e¨emvwU fy‡j †M‡j †mZviv nv‡m‡gi
¯§iYvcbœ †nvb! wZwb Avcbv‡K mvnvh¨ Ki‡Z cv‡ib! weÁvb e‡j, †Kvivb e‡j, nvw`Q e‡j, Avwg ewj, Avcwb e‡jb: Ávb-weÁvb
PP©vq `~tL Kó ev kiwg›`vi evjvB †bB|

¯§iYxq †h, e¨w³MZ ‡cÖwóR cvÂvi hv‡Z bv nq †m w`‡K Zx¶è `„wó ‡i‡L Ges Avcbvi c~e©vci AwaKvsk cÖwZ‡e`‡bi welqe¯‘i
cixw¶Z WvUv‡eR Abymi‡YB hvici †bB †jLv n‡q‡Q| Z`ycwi AwMÖg ¶gv †P‡q ivLjvg|
webxZ