Balloon debate

Draw a balloon over water, or just tell the class that they are in a hot air balloon
that is in trouble and will crash into the sea before they reach the desert island,
unless someone jumps into the sea to lighten the load, and save the others.
Each student chooses a job - imaginary. They must then prepare notes as to
why they are important for the community of survivors on the island.
After the students have had time to make notes, each one should present their
case for remaining on the balloon. After everyone had spoken, the group(s)
must discuss the usefulness of each person. Then a vote is made to decide
who must jump. The person chosen is then 'out' of the balloon. Unfortunately,
the balloon is still too heavy and someone else must jump. More discussion is
needed, followed by another vote. This ESL discussion activity can be
continued in the same way, or can be stopped after a certain number of people
have 'jumped.' Those who have jumped, are, of course, still able to take part in
the discussion to decide on the next one who needs to jump.