BUSINESS NEEDS MONEY TO MAKE MORE MONEY FINANCIAL SERVICES IS CONCERNED WITH THE DESIGN AND DELIVERY OF ADVICE AND FINANCIAL PRODUCTS TO INDIVIDUALS ,BUSINESS AND GOVT. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT IS CONCERNED WITH DUTIES OF FINANCIAL MANAGERS IN THE BUSINESS FIRM. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT MEANS THE ENTIRE GAMUT OF MANAGERIAL EFFORTS DEVOTED TO THE MANAGEMENT OF FINANCE BOTH ITS SOURCES AND USES. TRADITIONAL PHASE OF FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT LASTED FOR FOUR DECADES AND TALKED ABOUT : FORMATION ,ISSUANCE OF CAPITAL , MAJOR EXPANSION , MERGERS , REORGANISATIONS AND LIQUIDATION. APPROACH WAS DESCRIPTIVE AND INSTITUTIONAL OUTSIDERS VIEW WAS MORE DOMINANT SPECIFICALLY INVESTMENT BANKERS AND LENDERS. MODERN PHASE STARTED IN MID FIFTIES AND STRESS WAS LAID ON ECONOMIC THEORY AND APPLICATION OF QUANTITATIVE METHODS.
CONCERNS WITH RATIONAL MATCHING OF FUNDS TO THEIR USES SO AS TO MAXIMISE SHAREHOLDERS WEALTH.
APPROACH HAS BECOME MORE ANALYTICAL AND QUANTITATIVE.
MODERN PHASE EMPHASISES ON CAPITAL BUDGETING ,CAPITAL STRUCTURE THEORIES , EFFICIENT MARKET THEORY , OPTION PRICING THEORY , AGENCY THEORY , ARBITRAGE THEORY , VALUATION MODELS , DIVIDEND POLICY , WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT , FINANCIAL MODELLING. OBJECTIVES OF FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT TRADITIONALLY IT WAS MAINTENANCE OF LIQUID ASSETS AND MAXIMISATION OF PROFITABILITY OF THE FIRM. OBJECTIVE IS A SENSE OF GOAL OR DECISION CRITERION FOR THREE DECISIONS INVOLVED IN FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT VIZ. INVESTMENT , FINANCING AND DIVIDEND POLICY. ENSURING FAIR RETURNS TO SHAREHOLDERS, BUILDING RESERVES FOR GROWTH AND EXPANSION , MAXIMUM OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY BY EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT UTILISATION OF FINANCES AND ENSURING FINANCIAL DISCIPLINE. MICROECONOMIC FACTORS : NATURE AND SIZE OF ENTERPRISE/ LEVEL OF RISK AND STABILITY IN EARNINGS / LIQUIDITY POSITION/ ASSET STRUCTURE AND PATTERN OF OWNERSHIP/ATTITUDE OF MANAGEMENT MACROECONOMIC FACTORS : STATE OF ECONOMY / GOVERNMENT POLICY TWO APPROACHES ARE PROFIT / EPS MAXIMISATION AND WEALTH MAXIMISATION APPROACH.
WHEN FUNDS ARE INVOLVED ,SOUND FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT IS NECESSARY.
COLLINS BROOKS REMARKED BAD PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT AND BAD SALES MANAGEMENT HAVE SLAIN IN HUNDREDS ,BUT FAULTY FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT HAS SLAIN IN THOUSANDS .
FM HELPS IN ASCERTAINING HOW THE COMPANY WOULD PERFORM IN FUTURE.WHETHER THE FIRM WILL GENERATE ENOUGH FUNDS TO MEET ITS FUTURE OBLIGATIONS. PROFIT / EPS MAXIMISATION ACTIONS WHICH INCREASE EPS / PROFIT SHOULD BE UNDERTAKEN AND WHICH DECREASE THEM SHOULD BE AVOIDED. IT IS DESCRIBED AS PROFITABILITY AND SIGNIFIES ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY AND PERFORMANCE . IMPLYING THEREBY SELECT THOSE ASSETS , PROJECTS AND DECISIONS THAT INCREASE PROFITABILITY. HAS CERTAIN AMBIGUITY SHOULD PROFIT BE SHORT TERM OR LONG TERM , IS IT TOTAL RATE OF PROFIT , IS IT BEFORE TAX OR AFTER TAX, IS IT RETURN ON TOTAL CAPITAL EMPLOYED OR TOTAL ASSETS OR SHAREHOLDERS EQUITY ETC. TIME PATTERN OF BENEFITS : PROFITS IN THE EARLIER YEARS ARE BETTER OR GROWTH IS MORE BENEFICIAL. UNCERTAINITY OF BENEFITS : DEGREE OF CERTAINITY WITH WHICH BENEFITS ARE EXPECTED. IT IGNORES THE RISK FACTOR AND TIME VALUE OF MONEY. THE CONCEPT IS ANALOGOUS TO RATIONAL BEHAVIOUR OF THE FIRM. ENSURES THAT ULTIMATE SURVIVOR IN THE CORPORATE WORLD IS THE PROFIT MAXIMISER. HELPS IN ACQUIRING OF MONOPOLY POWERS IN THE IMPERFECT PRODUCT MARKET. WEALTH MAXIMISATION REFINED DECISION OVER EPS/ PROFIT MAXIMISATION CRITERION. FINANCIAL DECISIONS SHOULD BE THE MAXIMISATION OF THE VALUE OF THE FIRM OR THE CORPORATE WEALTH. ACCEPTABLE TO SHAREHOLDERS , CREDITORS , EMPLOYEES , MANAGEMENT , SOCIETY DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY. SHAREHOLDERS HIGHER VALUE OF SHARES , CREDITORS PROTECTION IN RESPECT TO REPAYMENT OF INTEREST AND PRINCIPLE, EMPLOYEES HIGHER PAY PACKAGES, MANAGEMENT EXISTENCE OF THE MANAGEMENT DEPENDS ON THE PROSPERITY OF THE FIRM. VALUE OF THE ASSET IN TERMS OF BENEFITS WHICH IT PROVIDES. BASED ON THE CONCEPT OF CASH FLOWS GENERATED BY THE DECISION RATHER ACCOUNTING PROFIT ON WHICH PROFIT MAXIMISATON IS BASED. IT CONSIDERS BOTH QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE DIMENSIONS OF BENEFITS AND INCORPORATE THE TIME VALUE OF MONEY. TIME VALUE OF MONEY MONEY HAS TIME VALUE . A RUPEE TODAY IS MORE VALUABLE THAN A RUPEE AFTER ONE YEAR. VALUE OF A UNIT OF MONEY IS DIFFERENT AT DIFFERENT TIME PERIODS.FUTURE IS UNCERTAIN PREFERENCE IS FOR REINVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR FUNDS RECEIVED EARLIER. GENERALLY REFERRED IN TERMS OF RATE OF RETURN OR DISCOUNT RATE. INDIVIDUALS PREFER CURRENT CONSUMPTION TO FUTURE CONSUMPTION CAPITAL CAN BE ENJOYED PRODUCTIVELY TO GENERATE POSITIVE RETURNS. DUE TO INFLATION A RUPEE TODAY REPRESENTS GREATER PURCHASING POWER THAN RUPEE TOMORROW. COMPOUNDING RATE : A=P(1+r)n PRESENT VALUE OR DISCOUNTING TECHNIQUE : OPPOSITE OF COMPOUNDING RATE . INTEREST IS ADDED BACK TO THE PRINCIPLE AND THEN INTEREST IS CHARGED IN COMPOUNDING METHOD , WHEREAS IN PV THE MONEY RECEIVED IN SOME FUTURE DATE IS DISCOUNTED TO GET ITS PRESENT WORTH AS THE INTEREST IS LOST P=A(1/1+i)n LEVERAGE LEVERAGE IS AN ADVANTAGE GAINED FROM THE OPERATIONS OF A LEVER. IN FINANCIAL TERM IT RELATES TO ACCELERATION OF PROFITS THROUGH CHANGES IN CERTAIN FINANCIAL VARIABLES MEANING THEREBY THAT LEVERAGE IS A TOOL OF PROFIT PLANNING. RETURN ON INVESTMENT LEVERAGE / MARGINAL ANALYSIS LEVERAGE / FINANCIAL LEVERAGE. RETURN ON INVESTMENT LEVERAGE : POINTS OUT THE FIRMS EFFICIENCY IN EARNING PROFITS WITH REGARDS TO OPERATING PROFIT , SALES AND ASSET TURNOVER. MARGINAL ANALYSIS LEVERAGE :RELATES TO PROFIT MEASURES TO CERTAIN OTHER ASPECTS OF FIRMS OPERATIONS OR FINANCIAL SITUATIONS-OPERATING LEVERAGE ,FIXED CHARGES LEVERAGE AND COMBINED LEVERAGE. OPERATING LEVERAGE :CHANGE IN SALES PRODUCE GREATER CHANGES IN THE OPERATING PROFIT.INTEREST ON DEBT IS NOT INCLUDED SINCE IT IS A FIXED FINANCIAL COST.ONCE BEP IS REACHED THE ENTIRE MARGINAL CONTRIBUTION TAKES THE FORM OF OPERATING PROFIT. DOL= % CHANGE IN EBIT / % CHANGE IN THE UNITS SOLD/OUTPUT.
LEVERAGE OPERATING LEVERAGE IS DEFINED AS THE TENDENCY OF THE OPERATING PROFIT TO VARY DISPROPORTIONATELY WITH SALES. IT IS SAID TO EXIST WHEN THE FIRM HAS TO PAY FIXED COST REGARDLESS OF VOLUME OF OUTPUT OR SALES. FIRM IS SAID TO HAVE HIGH DEGREE OF OPERATING LEVERAGE IF IT EMPLOYS GREATER AMOUNT OF FIXED COST AND SMALL AMOUNT OF VARIABLE COST AND VICE VERSA.
FINANCIAL LEVERAGE IS DEFINED AS THE TENDENCY OF THE RESIDUAL NET INCOME TO VARY DISPROPORTIONATELY WITH OPERATING PROFIT. CHANGES IN TAXABLE INCOME AS A RESULT OF CHANGES IN OPERATING INCOME. SIGNIFIES THE EXISTENCE OF FIXED INTEREST /FIXED DIVIDEND BEARING SECURITIES IN THE TOTAL CAPITAL STRUCTURE OF THE COMPANY. FINANCIAL LEVERAGE
FINANCIAL LEVERAGE IS ALSO REFERRED AS FIXED CHARGE LEVERAGE BUT COST THERE IS A SLIGHT DIFFERENCE AND FINANCIAL LEVERAGE EXISTS WHEN THE CAPITAL STRUCTURE COMPRISES OF DEBT OR OTHER FIXED COST CAPITAL AND ROI IS NOT EQUAL TO THE PERCENTAGE OF INTEREST OR OTHER FIXED CHARGES .THE ROI MUST BE GREATER THAN THE FIXED CHARGES . TO RAISE THE EPS AND ATTRACT INVESTORS A FIRM WILL APPLY HIGHER DEGREE OF FINANCIAL LEVERAGE. DFL=% CHANGE IN EPS / % CHANGE IN EBIT DCL=DOL*DFL CAPITAL BUDGETING DEALS WITH THE SELECTION OF PROPOSALS / PROJECTS FOR MAKING LONG TERM INVESTMENTS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION.
PURPOSE IS TO YIELD POSITIVE CASH INFLOWS THAT CAN ADD TO CORPORATE WEALTH.
INVOLVES LONG TERM INVESTMENTS IN FIXED ASSETS AS THEY ARE SIZEABLE PROPORTION OF TOTAL ASSETS AND THEIR LIFE IS LONG,ALSO THESE ASSETS ARE SPECIALLY DESIGNED FOR SPECIFIC ACTIVITY.
LONG TERM INVESTMENTS ARE REQUIRED FOR EXPANSION / REPLACEMENT / DIVERSIFICATION / R & D.
STEPS IN CAPITAL BUDGETING PROCESS : IDENTIFICATION OF LONG TERM GOALS / SCREENING PROPOSALS / PROJECT EVALUATION / PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION / PROJECT AUDIT. PROJECT EVALUATION CRITERION 1. AN APPRAISAL METHOD SHOULD PROVIDE FOR : BASIS OF DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN ACCEPTABLE AND NON ACCEPTABLE PROJECTS. RANKING OF PROJECTS IN ORDER OF DESIRABILITY. CHOOSING AMONG SEVERAL ALTERNATIVES. RECOGNISES , BIGGER BENEFITS ARE PREFERABLE TO SMALLER BENEFITS AND EARLIER BENEFITS ARE PREFERABLE TO LATER ONES.
2. DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW TECHNIQUE : NET PRESENT VALUE METHOD INTERNAL RATE FO RETURN METHOD
3. CASH FLOW NON DISCOUNTING TECHNIQUE : PAY BACK PERIOD METHOD ACCOUNTING RATE OF RETURN NET PRESENT VALUE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TOTAL PRESENT VALUES OF FUTURE CASH INFLOWS AND TOTAL PRESENT VALUE OF FUTURE CASH OUTFLOWS. NPV = PRESENT VALUE INITIAL INVESTMENT PRESENT VALUE = CASH INFLOW * DISCOUNTING RATE. CASH INFLOWS AND OUTFLOWS ASSOCIATED WITH EACH PROJECT ARE WORKED OUT. THE PRESENT VALUE OF CASH INFLOWS AND OUTFLOWS ARE CALCULATED AS PER THE RETURN ACCEPTABLE TO MANAGEMENT. NPV GREATER THAN ZERO ACCEPT THE PROJECT . INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN THE RATE OF RETURN AT WHICH SUM OF DISCOUNTED CASH INFLOWS EQUALS THE SUM OF DISCOUNTED CASH OUTFLOWS.CASH INFLOWS AND OUTFLOWS ARE KNOWN , DISCOUNTED RATE HAS TO BE FOUND OUT. CASH INFLOWS ARE UNIFORM , IRR = I/C , WHERE I IS INITIAL INVESTMENT AND C IS CASH INFLOWS EVERY YEAR. CASH INFLOWS ARE UNEVEN , IRR=r- ( PVCO- PVCI )/ DELTA PV * DELTA R. PV=PRESENT VALUE OF CASH OUTLAY PVCI=PRESENT VALUE OF CASH INFLOWS OF FIRST INTEREST RATE r= EITHER OF TWO INTERESR RATES USED IN FORMULA DELTA r = DIFF.BETWEEN TWO RATES DELTA PV = DIFF. IN CALCULATED PRESENT VALUS OF TWO RATES.
PAY BACK PERIOD REFERS TO THE EXPECTED NUMBER OF YEARS DURING WHICH THE ORIGINAL INVESTMENT SHOULD BE RECOVERED. MANAGEMENT SETS A TARGET PAY BACK PERIOD ON THE BASIS OF NATURE OF PROJECT AND INDUSTRY NORM. ACTUAL PAY BACK PERIOD LESS THAN TARGET NORM , PROJECT IS ACCEPTED. PB PERIOD = INITIAL INVESTMENT / ANNUAL CASH INFLOW. ACCOUNTING RATE OF RETURN ARR = AVERAGE NET INCOME / AVERAGE INVESTMENT *100. AVERAGE INVESTMENT = NET WC + SALVAGE VALUE +1/2(COST SALVAGE VALUE). AVERAGE DEP. = INITIAL INVESTMENT SCRAP VALUE / LIFE OF PROJECT.
RISK ANALYSIS IN CAPITAL BUDGETING THE VARIABILITY THAT IS LIKELY TO OCCUR IN FUTURE BETWEEN ESTIMATED AND ACTUAL RETURNS. RISK IS LINKED TO BUSINESS DECISIONS AND VARIES FROM ONE INVESTMENT TO ANOTHER INVESTMENT PROPOSAL. TWO WAYS OF INCORPORATING RISK FACTOR - ONE BEING CERTAINITY EQUIVALENT APPROACH AND OTHER BEING RISK ADJUSTED DISCOUNT RATE. CASH FLOW UNCERTAIN ,CERTAINITY FACTOR INTRODUCED IN CASH FLOW MAKING IT CERTAIN , REDUCED TO PRESENT VALUE THROUGH USE OF RISK FREE DISCOUNT RATE. CAPITAL RATIONING THE FIRM MAY ACCEPT ALL THOSE PROJECTS WHICH HAVE A POSITIVE NPV OR WHICH GIVE HIGHER RATE OF RETURN THAN THE COST OF CAPITAL.
WHEN A FIRM HAS MORE INVESTMENT PROPOSALS THAN IT CAN FINANCE IT PLACES A CONSTRAINT WITH REGARD TO TOTAL SIZE OF CAPITAL INVESTMENT. IN SUCH AN EVENT THE FIRM HAS TO SELECT A COMBINATION OF INVESTMENT PROPOSALS THAT PROVIDES HIGHEST NPV AND HIGHER RETURNS.
RANKING IS BASED ON THE PROFITABILITY INDEX OR IRR. CAPITAL STRUCTURE REPRESENTS THE RATIO BETWEEN DIFFERENT FORMS OF CAPITAL. CATEGORISED AS OWNERS FUND / SHARE CAPITAL AND BORROWED FUNDS. COMPANIES CAPITAL STRUCTURE SHOULD HAVE ONLY EQUITY CAPITAL OR IT SHOULD REPRESENT MIXTURE OF EQUITY AND BORROWED FUNDS ?. SEARCH FOR OPTIMAL STRUCTURE ENDS WHEN WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL (WACC) IS MINIMUM AND VALUE OF FIRM IS MAXIMUM. IRRELEVANCE APPROACH STATES THAT CHANGE IN CAPITAL STRUCTURE HAS NO INFLUENCE ON CORPORATE WEALTH---- FINANCIAL LEVERAGE HAS NO INFLUENCE ON TOTAL CASH FLOWS AND FINANCIAL LEVERAGE DOES NOT CHANGE COST OF CAPITAL HENCE VALUE OF FIRM REMAINS SAME. ARBITRAGE PROCESS( M M HYPOTHESIS): ASSUMES THAT FIRM PAYS NO TAXES / NO TRANSACTION COST / INVESTORS HAVE SAME EXPECTATION AS TO FIRMS FUTURE EARNINGS AND RISK / FUTURE FINANCING DECISIONS DO NOT AFFECT FIRMS INVESTMENT IN ASSETS. FEATURES OF SOUND CAPITAL STRUCTURE PERFECT TRADE OFF BETWEEN RISK AND RETURN --- SOUND CAPITAL STRUCTURE PERMITS LEVERAGE ONLY TO THE EXTENT OF PERFECT TRADE OFF BETWEEN RISK AND RETURN.
MINIMUM COST OF CAPITAL.
SUFFICIENCY OF CASH FLOW TO SERVICE DEBT--- LEVERAGE SHOULD BE USED TO THE EXTENT THAT THE CASH FLOWS ARE AVAILABLE TO SERVICE THE DEBT.
MAINTAINANCE OF INDUSTRY NORM---DEBT EQUITY RATIO SHOULD BE IN CONCURRENCE WITH INDUSTRY NORMS.
FLEXIBILITY--- IN RAISING FUNDS AND REDEEMING DEBTS. GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS FIRM EMPLOYS TWO TYPES OF CAPITAL i.e DEBT AND EQUITY.
THERE ARE NO CORPORATE TAXES.
FIRM PAYS 100% OF ITS EARNINGS AS DIVIDENDS.
INVESTMENT DECISIONS ARE ASSUMED TO BE CONSTANT.
FIRMS TOTAL FINANCING REMAINS CONSTANT.
EBIT REMAINS CONSTANT.
BUSINESS RISK REMAINS CONSTANT AND IS INDEPENDENT OF CAPITAL STRUCTURE AND FINANCIAL RISK.
INVESTORS HAVE SAME SUBJECTIVE DISTRIBUTION OF FUTURE EXPECTED OPERATING PROFIT. FIRM HAS PERPETUAL LIFE. TRADITIONAL POSITION COST OF DEBT rD MORE OR LESS REMAINS CONSTANT UPTO A CERTAIN DEGREE OF LEVERAGE BUT RISES THEREAFTER AT AN INCREASING RATE.
COST OF EQUITY rE REMAINS MORE OR LESS CONSTANT OR RISES ONLY GRADUALLY UPTO A CERTAIN DEGREE OF LEVERAGE AND RISES SHARPLY THEREAFTER.
THE AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL rA DECREASES UPTO A CERTAIN POINT , REMAINS MORE OR LESS UNCHANGED FOR MODERATE INCREASE IN LEVERAGE AND RISES BEYOND A CERTAIN POINT DUE TO THE BEHAVIOUR OF rD AND rE.
COST OF DEBT (ki) = I/B AND VALUE OF DEBT(B) = I/ki WHERE I IS TOTAL INTEREST PAYMENTS , B IS TOTAL MARKET VALUE OF DEBT . COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL (ke) = Di /Po + g , WHERE Di IS NET DIVIDENDS , Po IS CURRENT MARKET PRICE OF SHARES AND g IS GROWTH RATE . NET INCOME APPROACH PROPOSED BY DURAND CHANGE IN CAPITAL STRUCTURE CAUSES CORRESPONDING CHANGE IN THE OVERALL COST OF CAPITAL AS WELL AS VALUE OF THE FIRM. HIGHER DEBT IN CAPITAL STRUCTURE RESULTS IN DECLINE IN WACC.THIS CAUSES INCREASE IN VALUE OF THE FIRM AND DECREASE IN THE EQUITY SHARES OF THE COMPANY AND VICE VERSA. ASSUMPTIONS : THERE ARE NO CORPORATE TAXES . COST OF DEBT IS LESS THAN COST OF EQUITY. DEBT CONTENT DOES NOT CHANGE RISK PERCEPTION OF INVESTOR. VALUE OF FIRM : V=S+B ,WHERE V = VALUE OF FIRM , S=MARKET VALUE OF EQUITY AND B= MARKET VALUE OF DEBT. VALUE OF S = NI/Ke , NI= EARNING AVAILABLE TO EQUITY SHAREHOLDERS AND Ke = EQUITY CAPITALIZATION RATE. WACC = EBIT / V*100 WHERE V = VALUE OF FIRM. A COMPANYS EBIT IS RS 50,000/- , DEBT OF RS 2,00,000/- AT 10% AND ke IS 12.5 % . FIND WACC WHEN DEBT IS RS 2,00,000 , INCREASED BY 1,00,000 AND DECREASED BY 1,00,000 ?. NET OPERATING INCOME APPROACH FORMULATED BY DURAND MARKET VALUE OF THE FIRM IS ASCERTAINED BY CAPITALIZING THE NET OPERATING INCOME AT WHICH IS WACC IS CONSIDERED TO BE CONSTANT. OVERALL COST OF CAPITAL/ CAPITILISATION RATE Ko IS CONSTANT. ASSUMPTIONS : WACC IS CONSTANT FOR ALL DEGREES OF DEBT EQUITY MIX. MARKET CAPITALIZES THE VALUE OF THE FIRM AS A WHOLE AND THEREFORE THE SPLIT BETWEEN DEBT AND EQUITY IS NOT RELEVANT. USE OF DEBT INCREASES RISK TO EQUITY SHAREHOLDERS AND HENCE INCREASES Ke. NO CORPORATE TAXES. V= EBIT / Ko , S= V-B AND Ke= NI/S *100 OPERATING INCOME IS RS 50,000 , COST OF DEBT IS 10% on outstanding debt of rs 2,00,000 . Overall capitalisation rate is 12.5% . FIND VALUS OF FIRM AND EQUITY CAPITALISATION RATE WHEN DEBT IS REDUCED BY 1,00,000 AND INCREASED BY 1,00,000 ?. MODIGLIANI MILLER APPROACH SIMILAR TO NOI APPROACH SUPPORTS THE NOI APPROACH PROVIDING THE BEHAVIORAL JUSTIFICATION FOR INDEPENDENCE OF THE TOTAL VALUATION AND COST OF CAPITAL OF THE FIRM. PROPOSITIONS : WACC AND VALUE OF FIRM ARE INDEPENDENT OF CAPITAL STRUCTURE. COST OF EQUITY = CAPITALIZATION RATE OF A PURE EQUITY STREAM +PREMIUM FOR FINANCIAL RISK . THE FINANCIAL RISK INCREASES WITH MORE DEBT CONTAINED IN CAPITAL STRUCTURE. CUT OF RATE FOR INVESTMENT PURPOSE IS COMPLETELY INDEPENDENT OF THE WAY THE INVESTMENT IS FINANCED.
TWO FIRMS IDENTICAL EXCEPT FIRM L HAS 5,00,000 AT 10 % , EBIT IS RS 1,00,000 FOR BOTH AND ke OF FIRM L IS 16% AND FIRM U IS 12.5% . FIND ko. ASSUMPTIONS :
PERFECT CAPITAL MARKETS : INFORMATION IS FREELY AVAILABLE ,TRANSACTIONS ARE COSTLESS , NO BANKRUPTCY COSTS , SECURITIES ARE INFINITELY DIVISIBLE. RATIONAL INVESTORS AND MANAGERS : INVESTORS RATIONALLY CHOOSE COMBINATION OF RISK AND RETURN THAT IS MOST ADVANTAGEOUS.MANAGERS ACT IN THE INTEREST OF SHAREHOLDERS. HOMOGENEOUS EXPECTATIONS : INVESTORS HOLD IDENTICAL EXPECTATIONS ABOUT FUTURE OPERATING EARNINGS. EQUIVALENT RISK CLASS : FIRMS CAN BE GROUPED IN EQUIVALENT RISK CLASSES ON THE BASIS OF THEIR BUSINESS RISK. NO TAXES EXIST. M M APPROACH V=D+E OR O/R WHERE V= VALUE OF FIRM D= MARKET VALUE OF DEBT E= MARKET VALUE OF EQUITY O= EXPECTED OPERATING INCOME R= DISCOUNT RATE APPLICABLE TO THE RICH CLASS TO WHICH THE FIRM BELONGS . CRITICISMS OF M M APPROACH : FIRMS ARE LIABLE TO PAY TAXES ON THEIR INCOMES AND INVESTORS ALSO HAVE TO PAY TAXES ON THEIR PERSONAL INCOME. BANKRUPTCY COSTS ARE VERY HIGH. AGENCY COSTS EXIST CONFLICT OF INTEREST BETWEEN MANAGERS AND SHAREHOLDERS. MANAGERS HAVE PREFERENCE FOR CERTAIN SEQUENCE OF FINANCING. INVESTORS ARE EQUALLY INFORMED AS MANAGERS AND ASYMMETRY EXISTS. CAPITAL STRUCTURE Company X and Y are in the same risk class and are identical in every respect except that company X uses debt while company Y does not. The levered firm has Rs 9,00,000 debentures carrying 10% rate of interest .Both firms earn 20% operating profit on their total assets of Rs 15 lacs. Tax rate is 35% and equity capitilisation rate is 15%: 1. Compute the value of firms X and Y using NI Approach 2. Compute the value of each firm using NOI Approach 3. Using the NOI Approach calculate overall cost of capital (k0) for firms X and Y.
Solution : Valuation under NI Approach __________________________________________________________ Particulars Firm X Firm Y EBIT 300000 300000 Less Interest 90000 Nil Taxable Income 210000 300000 Less Taxes 73500 105000 Earnings for equity holders 136500 195000 Equity Capitilisation rate (ke) .15 .15 Market value of the firm 910000 1300000 Market value of debt 900000 Nil _____________________________________________________________ Total value of firm 1800000 1300000 CAPITAL STRUCTURE Valuation under NOI Approach: Vy = EBIT(1-tax rate )/ ko 300000(1-0.35)/.15 Rs 1300000 Vx = Rs 1300000 + Rs 900000(.35) = Rs 1615000
Working note : EBIT 300000 Less Interest 90000 Taxable Income 210000 Less tax 35% 73500 Net Income 136500 Value of firm (V) 1615000 Value of Debt (B) 900000 Value of Equity (S) 715000 Ke = NI/S 136500/715000 i.e 19.1% Kd = 10(1-.35) i.e 6.5 % COST OF CAPITAL Understanding general concept of opportunity cost of capital. Distinguish between the project cost of capital and the firms cost of capital. Learn about the methods of calculating component cost of capital and the weighted average cost of capital. Understand the concept and calculation of the marginal cost of capital. Recognise the need for calculating cost of capital for divisions. Illustrate the cost of capital calculation for a real company.
Cost of capital The projects cost of capital is the minimum required rate of return on funds committed to the project, which depends on the riskiness of its cash flows. The firms cost of capital will be the overall, or average, required rate of return on the aggregate of investment projects. Significance of the Cost of Capital Evaluating investment decisions, Designing a firms debt policy, and Appraising the financial performance of top management.
COST OF CAPITAL M.J.GORDON THE COST OF CAPITAL IS THE RATE OF RETURN A COMPANY MUST EARN ON AN INVESTMENT TO MAINTAIN THE VALUE OF THE COMPANY . SOLOMAN EZRA THE COST OF CAPITAL IS THE MINIMUM REQUIRED RATE OF EARNINGS OR THE CUT OFF RATE FOR CAPITAL EXPENDITURE . FEATURES : 1. ITS NOT A COST 2. ITS MINIMUM RATE OF RETURN 3. ITS A REWARD FOR RISK. SIGNIFICANCE : 1. DESIGNING THE CAPITAL STRUCTURE 2. CAPITAL BUDGETING DECISIONS 3. COMPARATIVE STUDY OF SOURCES OF FINANCING 4. EVALUATION OF FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE OF TOP MANAGEMENT 5. KNOWLEDGE OF FIRMS EXPECTED INCOME AND INHERENT RISK 6. FINANCING AND DIVIDEND DECISIONS. HISTORICAL VS FUTURE COST HISTORICAL COST REPRESENTS THE COST WHICH HAS ALREADY BEEN INCURRED FOR FINANCING A PROJECT . IT IS CALCULATED ON THE BASIS OF PAST DATA. FUTURE COST REFERS TO THE EXPECTED COST OF FUNDS TO BE RAISED FOR FINANCING A PROJECT . SPECIFIC COST REFERS TO THE COST OF A SPECIFIC SOURCE OF CAPITAL SUCH AS EQUITY CAPITAL / PREFERENCE CAPITAL / DEBENTURE CAPITAL / RETAINED EARNINGS. COMPOSITE COST REFERS TO THE COMBINED COST OF VARIOUS SOURCES OF FINANCE . IT IS THE WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL . AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL REFERS TO THE WACC CALCULATED ON THE BASIS OF COST OF EACH SOURCE OF CAPITAL AND WEIGHTS ARE ASSIGNED IN THE RATIO OF THEIR SHARE TO THE TOTAL CAPITAL FUNDS. MARGINAL COST OF CAPITAL IS DEFINED AS THE COST OF OBTAINING ANOTHER RUPEE OF NEW CAPITAL. EXPLICIT COST REFERS TO THE DISCOUNT RATE WHICH EQUATES THE PRESENT VALUE OF CASH INFLOWS WITH THE PRESENT VALUE OF CASH OUTFLOWS OR VALUE OF INVESTMENT.ITS THE INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN WHICH A FIRM PAYS FOR PROCURING FINANCES. IMPLICIT COST REPRESENTS THE RATE OF RETURN WHICH CAN BE EARNED BY INVESTING THE FUNDS IN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS . OPPORTUNITY COST OF FUNDS IS THE IMPLICIT COST. ASSUMPTIONS THE COST CAN BE EITHER EXPLICIT OR IMPLICIT.
FINANCIAL AND BUSINESS RISKS ARE NOT AFFECTED BY INVESTING IN NEW INVESTMENT PROPOSALS.
THE FIRMS CAPITAL STRUCTURE REMAINS UNCHANGED.
COST OF EACH SOURCE OF CAPITAL IS DETERMINED AS AN AFTER TAX BASIS.
COST OF PREVIOUSLY OBTAINED CAPITAL ARE NOT RELEVANT FOR COMPUTING THE COST FOR CAPITAL TO BE RAISED FROM A SPECIFIC SOURCE. MEASUREMENT OF COST OF CAPITAL IT INVOLVES : COST OF DEBT / COST OF PREFERENCE CAPITAL / COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL / COST OF RETAINED EARNINGS.
COST OF DEBT : THE COST OF FUNDS RAISED THROUGH DEBT IN THE FORM OF DEBENTURES OR LOAN FROM FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS .DEBT COULD BE PERPETUAL / IRREDEMABLE OR REEDEMABLE. COST OF PERPETUAL DEBT : IT IS THE IRREDEMABLE DEBT AND IS THE RATE OF RETURN WHICH THE LENDERS EXPECT.PRINCIPLE IS NOT REEDEMED. Kd = I/NP WHERE Kd = COST OF DEBT , I= ANNUAL INTEREST PAYMENT AND NP= NET PROCEEDS OF DEBT . AFTER TAX Kd=I/NP (1-t) WHERE t = TAX RATE. COST OF REEDEMABLE DEBT : THE PRINCIPLE HAS TO BE REEDEMED AFTER A SPECIFIC PERIOD FROM THE PAYMENT OF INTEREST. Kd = I+(P-NP)/n WHERE I= INTEREST RATE , P=PAR VALUE OF DEBT , (P+NP)/2 NP= NET PROCEEDS OF DEBT , n= NO. OF YEARS OF MATURITY. AFTER TAX Kd = ( 1-t) (I+(P-NP)/n) (P+NP)/2 SOLVED PROBLEM ISSUE OF 1000 9% DEBENTURES OF RS.500/- EACH AT PAR REEDEMABLE AFTER 8 YEARS . THE COST OF ISSUE OF DEBENTURE INCLUDES 1.5% UNDERWRITING COMM. , .5% BROKERAGE AND 2% AS PRINTING AND OTHER EXPENSES. CALCULATE AFTER TAX COST OF DEBT WHEN TAX RATE IS 50 %. SOLUTION NP= 500-(500*1.5% + 500 * .5% + 500*2% ) = 480 /- Kd = (1-.5) ( 45+500 480 )/8 ( 500+480) /2 .5 * 47.5/490 4.85 %
COST OF PREFERENCE CAPITAL PREFERENCE DIVIDEND IS NOT LEGALLY BINDING ON THE FIRM AS COMPARED TO DEBT. DIVIDEND IS PAID TO THE SHAREHOLDERS AFTER CHARGING FOR TAXES AND HENCE THERE IS NO TAX DEDUCTION IN CASE OF COST OF PREFERENCE SHARES. COST OF PREFERENCE IS GENERALLY HIGHER THAN COST OF DEBT. Kp = DP/P * 100 WHERE P= PAR VALUE OF PREFERENCE SHARES ON PER SHARE BASIS AND DP=EXPECTED DIVIDEND ON PER SHARE BASIS. SOLVED PROBLEM : PREFERENCE SHARE CAPITAL OF RS.100000 BY ISSUE OF PREFERENCE SHARES OF RS.10 EACH. CALCULATE COST OF PREFERENCE CAPITAL WHEN THEY ARE ISSUED AT 10% PREMIUM AND DISCOUNT ?. ISSUED AT PREMIUM Kp = DP/P , 10000/110000* 100 =9.09% ISSUED AT DISCOUNT Kp=dp/p , 10000/90000*100 =11.11%. COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL Ke IS DEFINED AS THE MINIMUM RATE OF RETURN THAT A FIRM MUST EARN ON THE EQUITY FINANCED PORTION OF AN INVESTMENT PROJECT IN ORDER TO LEAVE UNCHANGED THE MARKET PRICES OF THE SHARES . THE FOLLOWING ARE THE APPROACHES ACCORDING TO WHICH THE COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL CAN BE WORKED OUT : 1. DIVIDEND PRICE APPROACH 2. DIVIDEND PRICE ALONGWITH GROWTH APPROACH 3. EARNING PRICE APPROACH 4. REALISED YIELD APPROACH. DIVIDEND PRICE APPROACH : THE COST OF EQUITY WILL BE THAT RATE OF EXPECTED DIVIDENDS WHICH WILL MAINTAIN THE PRESENT MARKET PRICE OF EQUITY CAPITAL. Ke= DPS/MP*100 WHERE DPS = DIVIDEND PER SHARE , MP=MARKET PRICE OF SHARE. SOLVED PROBLEM : ISSUE OF 300000 EQUITY SHARES AT RS 10 PER SHARE MARKET VALUE BEING RS 15 PER SHARE . CO. PAYS 1.2 AS DIVIDEND PER SHARE .CALCULATE COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL. SOLUTION : Ke = DPS/MP*100 = 1.2/15*100= 8%. DIVIDEND PRICE ALONGWITH GROWTH APPROACH THE COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL IS DETERMINED ON THE BASIS OF THE EXPECTED DIVIDEND RATE ALONGWITH THE RATE FOR GROWTH RATE IN DIVIDEND.RATE OF GROWTH IN DIVIDEND IS DETERMINED ON THE BASIS OF THE AMOUNT OF DIVIDEND PAID IN LAST YEARS. Ke= DPS/MP+g , WHERE g= GROWTH.
EARNING PRICE APPROACH ITS THE EARNING PER SHARE WHICH DETERMINES THE MARKET PRICE OF THE SHARE.IT IS BASED ON THE ASSUMPTION THAT THE SHAREHOLDERS CAPITALISE A STREAM OF FUTURE EARNINGS IN ORDER TO EVALUATE THEIR SHAREHOLDINGS.HENCE THE COST OF CAPITAL SHOULD BE RELATED TO THE EARNINGS % WHICH COULD KEEP THE MARKET PRICE OF EQUITY SHAREHOLDERS CONSTANT. Ke = EPS / NP , FOR EXISTING EQUITY SHAREHOLDERS WE USE MP INSTEAD OF NP. REALISED YIELD APPROACH THE COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL SHOULD BE DETERMINED ON THE BASIS OF RETURN ACTUALLY REALISED BY THE INVESTOR IN A COMPANY ON THEIR EQUITY SHARES.THE PAST RECORDS IN A GIVEN PERIOD REGARDING DIVIDENDS AND THE ACTUAL CAPITAL APPRECIATION IN THE VALUE OF EQUITY SHARES SHOULD BE TAKEN TO COMPUTE THE COST OF EQUITY CAPITAL.
COST OF RETAINED EARNINGS COST OF RETAINED EARNINGS REPRESENT AN OPPORTUNITY COST IN TERMS OF THE RETURNS ON THEIR INVESTMENT IN ANOTHER ENETRPRISE BY THE FIRM WHOSE COST OF RETAINED EARNINGS HAS TO BE CONSIDERED. SUPPOSE THE EARNINGS ARE NOT RETAINED BY THE COMPANY AND PASSED TO THE SHAREHOLDERS AND THEY ARE INVESTED BY THE SHAREHOLDERS IN THE NEW EQUITY SHARES OF THE SAME COMPANY , THE EXPECTATIONS OF THE SHAREHOLDERS FROM THE NEW EQUITY SHARES WOULD BE TAKEN AS THE OPPORTUNITY COST OF THE RETAINED EARNINGS. ADJUSTMENTS
INCOME TAX ADJUSTMENT :THE DIVIDEND RECEIVED BY THE SHAREHOLDERS ARE SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX IN THEIR HANDS.
BROKERAGE ADJUSTMENTS : THE SHAREHOLDERS HAVE TO INCUR SOME BROKERAGE COST ON INVESTMENT OF DIVIDEND RECEIVED , THUS THE FUND AVAILABLE FOR REINVESTMENT IS REDUCED BY THIS AMOUNT.
Kr = EPS(1-Tp) (1-B)/MP*100 Kr = COST OF RETAINED EARNINGS Tp= INCOME TAX RATE OF INDIVIDUAL SHAREHOLDER B= BROKERAGE.