Teaching Archetypes, Symbolism, and Allegory through Narrative Writing in a 12 th
Grade ELA Classroom Michael Martell Wake Forest Teacher Education Program Evidence #3: Unit Plan Dr. Alan Brown Spring 2014
1 Table of Contents: Introduction and Rationale Assessment Plan Overview of Pedagogical Strategies Lesson Plans References Appendix A: List of Additional Resources Appendix B Bridging English Resources & Activities Appendix C Original Planning Sheet Appendix E Individual Learner Profiles
2 INTRODUCTION AND RATIONALE Subject Area Content English IV Standard British Literature Unit Overview and Rationale This unit, Quests and Heroes: Teaching Archetypes, Symbolism, and Allegory through Narrative Writing in a 12 th Grade ELA Classroom, is designed to be taught as the second unit in the standard-level English IV curriculum. Though the unit can easily be adapted to include texts from various periods, it currently focuses on Arthurian romances of the middle ages because the symbolism, allegory, and quest hero archetypes are so prominent. Many of these Arthurian romance texts can be difficult to teach, even when the language is modernized and accompanied with explanative notes, because the distance between our cultural mindset and that of the middle ages can be enough to block contemporary readers from connecting the stories to their personal experience. After all, these archetypal heroes and villains often represent a single virtue or vice (e.g., patience, honor, humility) that a twenty-first century reader may find too one-dimensional. For this reason, the unit is designed to encourage students to consider, first and foremost, what it means to be human, then to explore how this humanity may be reflected in medieval literature through archetypes and symbolism, and finally to create their own expression of the human experience by writing an original quest narrative that follows the Heros Journey as outlined by Joseph Campbell in The Hero With a Thousand Faces. The two major texts for the unit are excerpts from Sir Thomas Malorys Le Morte dArthur and the alliterative poem Sir Gawain and the Green Knight (authors name unknown), but the major goal for the unit is not for students merely to demonstrate their S comprehension of these two narratives. Rather, the main objective for the unit is that students apply their understanding of the archetypes, symbolism, and allegory of these narratives to the task of creating their own narrative as a final project. Ideally, students engage with the essential questions in the text through personal triggers, enter the text on a personal level, and then draw on specific romance conventions and narrative techniques from their reading as they write their original quest narratives. By moving from the role of reader to writer, the student more actively engages with particular components of a narrative, such as point of view and characterization, which may serve as important building blocks for their future reading and writing. To ensure that the students view the writing process as meaningful, I have chosen to have students publish their brainstorms, rough drafts, peer-review comments, and final products on personal blog pages. This electronic forum not only lets students share their work with an audience larger than just the teacher, but it also allows them to view their own growth and development throughout the writing process. The comment feature of Google Blogger as well as the track changes and in-text comments of Microsoft Word enhance students experience sharing and editing their work with peers. For the second half of the unit, students work in quest writing groups of 3 or 4 students to collaborate on brainstorming, editing, and analysis. To encourage students to reflect on this collaboration, I have made the first of the three components of the summative assessment a group presentation on the peer-revision experience. Another advantage of the blog forum is that it enables students to continue building on their work, even after the unit has ended. In fact, the second and third components of the summative assessment extend beyond the final lesson of the unit. 4 After sharing their peer-edits and completing their group presentations, students revise their quest narrative independently, make a visual component to compliment this narrative, and publish both pieces together on a personal blog page. Then, for the final component of the summative assessment, students write a 1-paged analysis of their own quest narrative, focusing on the allegorical significance of their heros quest. This analysis assignment also serves as a formative assessment of the subsequent unit, which culminates in an analytical research paper. Enduring Understandings Given that neither major text of this unit features a single salient theme, I do not expect students to come away from the unit with a certain picture of what the Heros Journey represents. In fact, I do not even expect all students to remember specific plot points from these narratives even a year after reading them. I do hope, however, that the unit instills a strong understanding of how archetypal characters and situations, though not always memorable, represent fundamental patterns of human experience that play out on a day-to-day basis. I also hope that students finish the unit understanding that no textno quest, no symbol, no allegorycan be reduced to one single meaning because each reader, in the process of interpretation, creates meanings that reflect her own unique perspective. As such, the creative individual projects for the unit are published online so that students may share their work with peer readers and (just as importantly) learn from their readers comments. In the act of writing original narratives and interpretations of others narratives, students themselves become living proof that we as individuals create our own meaning. S Standards NCTE/IRA ELA: 3. Students apply a wide range of strategies to comprehend, interpret, evaluate, and appreciate texts. They draw on their prior experience, their interactions with other readers and writers, their knowledge of word meaning and of other texts, their word identification strategies, and their understanding of textual features (e.g., sound-letter correspondence, sentence structure, context, graphics). 5. Students employ a wide range of strategies as they write and use different writing process elements appropriately to communicate with different audiences for a variety of purposes. 11. Students participate as knowledgeable, reflective, creative, and critical members of a variety of literacy communities.
Common Core Standards, ELA/Literacy Grades 11-12: Reading Literature: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.1: Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text, including determining where the text leaves matters uncertain. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.3: Analyze the impact of the author's choices regarding how to develop and relate elements of a story or drama (e.g., where a story is set, how the action is ordered, how the characters are introduced and developed). Reading Informational Texts: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.11-12.1: Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to 6 support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text, including determining where the text leaves matters uncertain. Writing: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.3: Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events using effective technique, well-chosen details, and well-structured event sequences. A. Engage and orient the reader by setting out a problem, situation, or observation and its significance, establishing one or multiple point(s) of view, and introducing a narrator and/or characters; create a smooth progression of experiences or events. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.10: Write routinely over extended time frames (time for research, reflection, and revision) and shorter time frames (a single sitting or a day or two) for a range of tasks, purposes, and audiences. Speaking & Listening: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.1: Initiate and participate effectively in a range of collaborative discussions (one-on-one, in groups, and teacher-led) with diverse partners on grades 11-12 topics, texts, and issues, building on others' ideas and expressing their own clearly and persuasively.
21 st Century Student Outcomes: Creativity and Innovation: - Think Creatively: Use a wide range of idea creation techniques (such as brainstorming); Elaborate, refine, analyze and evaluate their own ideas in order to 7 improve and maximize creative efforts. - Work Creatively with Others: Be open and responsive to new and diverse perspectives; incorporate group input and feedback into the work. Communication and Collaboration: - Collaborate with Others: Demonstrate ability to work effectively and respectfully with diverse teams; Assume shared responsibility for collaborative work, and value the individual contributions made by each team member. Critical Thinking and Problem Solving: - Make Judgments and Decisions: Reflect critically on learning experiences and processes. Global Awareness: - Learning from and working collaboratively with individuals representing diverse cultures, religions and lifestyles in a spirit of mutual respect and open dialogue in personal, work and community contexts Class and Learner Profiles The English IV curriculum, centering on British literature, introduces students to a long history of linguistic and cultural development. The texts of these units, especially the pre-modern ones, may seem inaccessible or even irrelevant to us as Americans in the 21 st century. Thanks to the flexibility granted by the Common Core State Standards, teachers are not held to teaching specific texts and thus often deemphasize Old and Middle English texts in favor of more accessible, engaging works (from Shakespeare onward). This approach, though valid, may deprive students of the chance to explore essential questions such asHow do languages come into being? and How can 8 literature reflect the fundamental values of a culture?which can deepen their understanding of how any given literary text connects to us as readers. For this reason, my English IV curriculum begins with these essential questions and continually encourages students to connect textsranging from Beowulf to Philip Larkin, from scientific articles to literary criticismto their personal experience. This unit is designed for a standard-level class but can easily be adapted for an honors or AP class by increasing the number of core texts (both literary and informational) and holding students accountable for completing their readings outside of class. 1 Because a number of students in the class have difficulties reading, decoding, or synthesizing texts, the curriculum is designed for students to complete the majority of reading in class so that they may benefit from teacher and peer support. A number of research-based literacy strategies, such as Collaborative Strategic Reading (CSR) and drawing visual storyboards for a narrative, are used to promote comprehension, sequencing, and synthesis of these texts among students of multiple intelligences (Bremer). Students are expected to work in groups throughout their reading, brainstorming, editing, and reflecting so that students from diverse backgrounds and learning styles may benefit from collaboration. The final project also caters to multiple intelligences and ability levels. Because the task of writing an original quest narrative is
1 For an honors or AP class, students would be held accountable for reading the excerpts of Le Morte dArthur, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Canto I of Dantes Inferno, and the Bower of Bliss scene of Edmund Spensers Faerie Queene outside of class and preparing a list of questions for small-group discussions of these texts. Each of these texts would be supplemented by an informational text that offers a different perspective of the major themes. For example, students could explore the definition of archetype by reading excerpts of Joseph Campbells The Hero with a Thousand Faces, Carl Jungs Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, and another scientific article on the importance of dreams to human experience. 9 inherently creative and individual, no student is at a disadvantage for lacking prior knowledge. Furthermore, no student could deem the task as too easy because there is no limit to how much planning and revising can be done. In the end, each of the 33 students in the class benefits from the unique perspectives and insight that their peers bring to the table. Consideration of Group Differences This unit is designed for a particular group of students at a traditional public high school with over 2,000 students. The student body is predominantly white (65.5%), and few students apply for free and reduced meals (only 25.14% designated as needy). However, the standard-level English Language Arts classes tend to have a healthy amount of economic and racial diversity. Over 93% of students at this high school performed at or above grade level on their end-of-course testing, but the sub-populations of black, Hispanic, and economically disadvantaged students have lower percentages of students performing at or above grade level (84.1%, 82.3%, and 81.6 %, respectively). This particular group of 12 th graders has a wealth of diverse experiences to draw from. Two students were born and raised in foreign countries (Cuba and Panama), and several others are bilingual first-generation Americans. These 12 th graders also have diverse interests and future plans. Based on anecdotal information and student surveys, I estimate that about a third of the students hope to attend a 4-year college, about a third plan to attend the local 2-year community college, and about a third plan on working full- time after graduation. The personal quest narrative assignment allows for students to draw on these distinct outlooks and integrate them into their stories. For example, one may create a hero who strives to attend college, whereas another may make a quest 1u narrative in which a hero moves to live in a foreign country. The hope is that this creative assignment sparks small-group and whole-class discussions that promote a mutual appreciation of diverse experiences, perspectives and ideas. For students less inclined to share their views orally, there are multiple opportunities to express themselves (through visual art and writing, both in class and online). Consideration of Individual Differences The activities and assignments detailed in the lesson plans are designed to allow students of diverse learning styles and multiple intelligences to engage with the content in a variety of ways. Most reading tasks are accompanied by an activity that involves viewing or creating visual representations of the narrative. Graphic organizers and collaborative reading strategies are also in place to ensure that the instruction is differentiated to meet a wide range of needs. The class also contains three fictional students who either have individualized education plans (IEPs) or receive ESL services. Each lesson of the unit includes individualized accommodations or modifications for each student based on his needs. Marcus has an IEP to help raise his reading and writing proficiency. He earned 80% accuracy for reading comprehension at a 9 th grade level, but continues to struggle with sequencing events and finding inferential meanings in a text. He also struggles with the pre-writing and editing stages of writing, which causes his organization to suffer. For this unit, Marcus is given extra time on the quiz and written assignments, during which time he has the option of extra support from the teacher or the schools EC specialist. The unit also includes a variety of activities aimed at developing his ability to sequence and infer meanings from a text (e.g., making a visual storyboard for the major plot points and 11 symbols in Le Morte dArthur). The small-group collaborationfor reading, pre-writing, and editing activitiesallows him to rely on his peers as an added resource. David is an English Language Learner (ELL) who is proficient at speaking and listening, but struggles with reading and writing (3.1 and 3.6 WIDA proficiency levels, respectively). Though he is a fully proficient speaker, he rarely if ever partakes in class discussions because he is shy and lacks confidence speaking in front of peers. As such, he would benefit greatly from the Collaborative Strategic Reading activities because it would give him the chance to raise comprehension questions about the texts in an informal small group setting. He would also benefit from the activities centered on analyzing and creating visual representations of the plot and symbols of the given texts. He is given extra time to complete his writing assignments and his quiz on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and the option for extra help outside of class from either the teacher or the ESL specialist at the school. Christophe has difficulties with reading comprehension, decoding, and writing. Though he struggles with longer passages with more complex themes and vocabulary, he does better with material that he can relate to through his own past experiences. For this reason, the entire structure of the unitfrom the skits whose scenarios parallel plot points in Sir Gawain to the final quest narrative projectmay help Christophe to engage with the major texts and concepts. His writing suffers from poor pre-writing and editing skills, so the small group activities for brainstorming, editing, and peer-review can provide helpful models for useful strategies.
12 ASSESSMENT PLAN Overview of Assessments In this unit, students are assessed for a variety of skills through a variety of measures. Because the central skills targeted for this unit are not quantifiablesuch as the 21 st Century skills of Creativity and Innovation and Communication and Collaborationthe majority of assessments are qualitative and largely holistic. The group presentations for lessons 2 and 10, as well as the group skit activity of lesson 4, are assessed based on rubrics, each of which has a category for Collaboration with Peers. The majority of in-class formative assessments (e.g., Dream Cloud Worksheet, Plot Structure Worksheet) are graded for accuracy and completeness, but largely assessed based on students participation in class. Similarly, the during-reading activities are designed at once to aid students comprehension and allow the teacher to assess each individuals understanding informally. In lessons 1, 5, and 6, students synthesize a difficult text by writing short 1-sentence summaries of the most important points. In lesson 3, students take notes on important actions and symbols that they eventually use to make a visual representation of the reading. For writing, the teacher can assess both the students work (most of which is collected or posted on their blog pages) and the students ability to provide feedback and revisions on their peers work. Though many of these writing assignments are done in class and largely informal, they all build up to the final project, which includes a) a quest narrative and b) a 1-paged analysis of ones own narrative. As such, the majority of writing activities are geared toward developing specific narrative writing techniques (e.g., 1S establishing point of view, characterization) or analytical skills (e.g., analyzing symbolism, characters). Assessment Formative As seen below, this unit has a wide variety of formative assessments, ranging from informal group activities to a quiz on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Lesson # 1 2 3 4 Formative Assessments -1-paragraph analysis of Arthurs Dream -Dream Cloud Worksheet -Informal group presentations - Exit slip on Essential Question -Analysis of Characterization -Annotation Guide -8-frame Storyboard -Bell-ringer Free Write -Group Skits -Written Reflection on Essential Question
5 6 7 8 9 -Summary and Conflict notes on Gawain (continued in next lesson) -Written prediction of the climax and resolution for Sir Gawain -Movie Pitch outline of quest narrative (posted on blog page for homework) -Summary and Conflict notes on Gawain -Plot Structure Worksheet -1-paragraph analysis (on Plot Structure Worksheet)
-Quiz on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight -Warm-up Analysis on Plot Structure -Defining Vocabulary Words (in-class group activity) -Identifying symbols (in- class individual activity) -Allegory Team Interpretation Activity (in small groups) -Analysis of Manuscript Illumination -Illuminated Manuscript for Dantes Inferno
-Peer-feedback and editing (written with Microsoft Word track changes and in-text comments, emailed to teacher) -Exit-slip reflection on editing process
These assessments may be divided into three general categories: assessments of writing (narrative, analytical, and reflective), assessments of comprehension (through 14 summarizing, drawing, and other activities adapted from Bridging English 2 ), and assessments of communication and collaboration (through informal teacher observations and more formal rubrics). Of course, it would be impossible for a teacher to provide substantial descriptive feedback on all of these assessments in time for it to be useful for completing the final project. However, the activities are structured in such a way that students receive immediate feedback from peer collaboration on many of the projects. Moreover, the students have ample opportunities to raise questions and concerns to the teacher. Summative The summative assessment for the unit is comprised of three components. Each component assesses a different skill set (presentation skills, narrative writing, and analytical writing), but all three fall under the single theme of personal quest narratives. For the first assessment, students work with their quest writing group to prepare a 2- part presentation. During part one, each student presents the quest for which she or he provided peer feedback. During part two, all group members present on the experience of working in a group to brainstorm, edit, and review their quest narratives. The second component is the final draft of the quest narrative, which each student will publish on Google Blogger alongside original manuscript illuminations. The manuscript illuminations can be drawn illustrations, original photographs, or student-produced videos, so long as they represent at least 3 major plot points and 3 symbols from the quest narrative. The quest narrative must include a well-developed hero and quest (including each stage of the Heros Journey), at least three symbols, and a deeper allegorical
2 See Appendix C for the specific activities and insights from Bridging English that inspired some of my lesson planning. 1S meaning of what the quest represents. The final component of the summative assessment is a 300-word self-analysis essay in which students analyze the allegorical significance of their own quest, drawing on their own narrative for textual support for their claims. This final component is designed to be integrated into the subsequent unit on conducting analytical research. As such, the specific skills needed to organize an argumentative essay are not taught in this unit because they are central to the following unit. All three components are explained in greater detail in the instructions and rubric handout below (which also includes details for formative assessments, such as the Movie Pitch and the Rough Draft).
16 Make A Quest! (304 points) lor Lhls pro[ecL, you wlll wrlLe your own quesL narraLlve, revlse lL ln a peer-edlLlng group, and publlsh your work on a blog. ?ou may recounL an acLual evenL ln your llfe, draw on currenL evenLs, or lmaglne a hypoLheLlcal slLuaLlon, buL you musL follow Lhe Pero's !ourney" archeLypes ouLllned by !oseph Campbell:
8ecause all quesL narraLlves are dlfferenL, you do noL have Lo lnclude every sLage ouLllned by Campbell so long as Lhe quesL as a whole has a deeper mora| s|gn|f|cance. lor example, when Slr Cawaln breaks hls promlse Lo exchange glfLs wlLh hls hosL because he wanLs Lo keep hls glrdle for proLecLlon, he exhlblLs weakness (dlshonesLy, dlshonor, ungraLefulness). Powever, when he follows Lhrough wlLh hls promlse and apologlzes for hls mlsLake, he demonsLraLes greaL vlrLue (honesLy, honor, humlllLy). 1o make a quesL wlLh a deeper meanlng, you should lnclude aL leasL Lhese bulleL polnLs:
- Status uo: A brlef porLralL of every day llfe" before Lhe quesL beglns - Ca|| to Adventure: someLhlng (a call, a dream, an evenL) LhaL seLs Lhe hero on Lhe quesL - Departure: leavlng Lhe Crdlnary World" and enLerlng Lhe Speclal World." - 1r|a|s: challenges and LempLaLlons LhaL !"#"$% Lhe hero's characLer (sLrengLhs/shorLcomlngs, vlrLues/vlces) - Cr|s|s: Pero musL hlL a low-polnL before belng reborn." - kesu|ts]1reasures: WhaL are Lhe consequences of compleLlng Lhls quesL? Are Lhere any rewards LhaL represenL whaL Lhe hero has galned (morally, splrlLually) - keso|ut|on]Atonement]keturn: noL all heroes reLurn home afLer Lhelr quesLs, buL Lhey all end up somewhere. Clve deLalls Lo explaln how llfe wlll be for your hero afLer Lhe quesL.
1oday, each of you wlll make a blog accounL uslng Coogle 8logger (www.blogspoL.com), bralnsLorm wlLh your asslgned peer-edlLlng group, Lhen posL your Movle lLch" for homework. 1hls blog wlll be walled- ln," meanlng LhaL your blog wlll be lnvlslble Lo all excepL your classmaLes and me. lor Lhls pro[ecL, you wlll compleLe:
1A): Mov|e |tch (22 po|nts): lmaglne LhaL you have Lo plLch your quesL narraLlve Lo a busy movle producer. 1o sell your sLory, conclsely explaln: - Who ls Lhe nero(|ne)? - WhaL ls Lhe 'quest'? - WhaL's Lhe 'mora|' of Lhe sLory (whaL does Lhe quesL represenL on a deeper level)? - WhaL ls Lhe ord|nary wor|d? Modern-day uSA? Colonlal PalLl? WhaL's your seLLlng? - WhaL ls Lhe spec|a| wor|d? An advenLure wlLhln a dream? A vlrLual plaLform? - WhaL's Lhe 'Ca||' Lo advenLure? Could be a message, a dream, an evenL.. - Departure? &"'!" )*+ ,) -$).$. $)/0*!"1 2*3*4 - 1ra||s? WhaL klnds of challenges/LempLaLlons wlll LesL your hero(lne)? - ne|p along Lhe way? Who/whaL wlll supporL your characLer along Lhe way? - Cr|s|s? uoes your characLer go Lhrough any klnd of LransformaLlon (deaLh & reblrLh)? - 1reasures]keso|ut|on]keturn? noL all heroes reLurn, buL all should reach some sorL of resoluLlon. 17
18) eer-kesponses on Mov|e |tches (9 po|nts): lor "$56 of your group members, you musL posL a peer-response" commenL, ln whlch you. a) explaln whaL you llke mosL abouL hls/her Movle lLch b) ask one follow-up quesLlon (elLher for clarlflcaLlon or Lo geL more deLalls abouL Lhe sLory) c) suggesL one ldea for how Lhey can Lake Lhelr sLory furLher
2) kough Draft (40 po|nts): ?our rough drafL musL be posLed on your blog before class on Lhe day lL's due. ?our drafL should be aL leasL 400 words and should lnclude a Pero(lne), a clearly-deflned quesL, aL leasL half of Lhe sLages of Lhe Pero's !ourney," and aL leasL Lwo symbols.
3A) eer-Ld|t|ng (16 po|nts): ln class, you wlll carefully read, edlL, and make suggesLlons for one of your group member's rough drafL uslng MlcrosofL Word 1rack Changes and ln-LexL 8evlew CommenLs. AL Lhe end of class, you wlll emall Lhese revlslons Lo your parLner and Lo me. ?our revlslons musL address: 1) loL: uslng ln-LexL 8evlew CommenLs, you musL ldenLlfy Lhe hero, Lhe ob[ecL of Lhe quesL (boLh llLeral and symbollc), each sLage of Lhe Pero's !ourney," and aL leasL 3 symbols. As a flnal commenL, you musL llsL whaL ploL elemenLs musL be added Lo Lhe drafL and make aL leasL Lhree suggesLlons on how Lo lnLegraLe Lhem ln ways LhaL enhance Lhe bulld up Lo Lhe cllmax and Lhe progresslon Lowards Lhe resoluLlon. 2) SLyle: uslng Lhe 1rack Changes" and Lhe ln-LexL CommenLs" feaLures, you musL suggesL changes Lo lmprove Lhe sLyle and clarlLy of Lhe rough drafL, focuslng especlally on grammar (sub[ecL-verb agreemenL, Lense conslsLency.), convenLlons (paragraph breaks, quoLaLlon marks for dlalogue.), and LranslLlons (effecLlve LranslLlon words, clear flow of evenLs...). Make aL leasL 3 Lrack changes and posL aL leasL 3 commenLs).
38) Comments (24 po|nts): Pere, you wlll publlsh a 1-paragraph blog commenL on "$56 of your CuesL WrlLlng" group members' rough drafLs. ln Lhls commenL, you wlll ldenLlfy speclflc deLalls/aspecLs LhaL you especlally llked abouL Lhe drafL and why. ralse your peers for whaL Lhey dld well!
3C) "uest Wr|t|ng" Group resentat|on (40 po|nts): AfLer compleLlng your pro[ecL, you and your asslgned peer-edlLlng parLners wlll presenL as a group.
lor parL 1 of Lhe presenLaLlon, each of you wlll presenL your peer-feedback parLner's quesL narraLlve (noL your own). 1o do so, you musL: - uescrlbe Lhe seLLlng (ordlnary and speclal world) and Lhe hero (hls/her characLer LralLs, hls/her poslLlon ln Lhe world) - Summarlze Lhe Pero's CuesL (explaln Lhe goal of Lhe quesL, Lhe call Lo advenLure, Lhe crlsls, and Lhe resoluLlon) - 8eflecL on whaL you %"$!)"3 from Lhls group member's pro[ecL. ln your oplnlon, whaL ls Lhe moral of Lhls quesL? WhaL deLalls/aspecLs of Lhe sLory were mosL lnLeresLlng? Why?
lor parL 2 of your group presenLaLlon, all of you wlll reflecL on whaL you learned from Lhe edlLlng process. As a group, answer Lhe quesLlons: -uld you en[oy Lhe group peer-edlLlng process? Why or why noL? -WhaL klnd of feedback dld you flnd mosL helpful (suggesLlons for ldeas, grammar, sLyle, eLc.)? -Pow dld Lhe peer-edlLlng process lnfluence Lhe way you wroLe your own narraLlve?
4A) I|na| uest Narrat|ve (80 po|nts) ($+ %"$.+ 700 words): 8y 1 sL perlod of Lhe due daLe, you musL have your orlglnal 700+-word quesL narraLlve posLed on your blog (Labeled as llnal CuesL narraLlve"), and submlLLed Lo LurnlLln.com. See p. 1 for lnsLrucLlons and p. (4) for Lhe rubrlc on how your work wlll be evaluaLed.
18 48) Manuscr|pt I||um|nat|ons of I|na| uest Narrat|ve (20 po|nts): ln Lhe splrlL of medleval lllumlnaLed manuscrlpLs, you musL upload an orlglnal vlsual plece. 1hls plece can range from hand-drawn lllusLraLlons (dlglLlzed and uploaded for your blog) Lo a homemade vldeo, so long as lL deplcLs $+ %"$.+ 3 key ploL polnLs and $+ %"$.+ 3 symbols. AfLer posLlng your lllumlnaLlons wlLh your narraLlve (elLher ln Lhe marglns, aL Lhe Lop, or aL Lhe boLLom of Lhe posL), you musL posL a 1-paragraph explanaLlon of how your vlsual componenL represenLs 3+ key ploL polnLs and 3+ symbols.
S) Se|f-Ana|ys|s: AfLer posLlng Lhe flnal drafL of your CuesL narraLlve, you musL posL a 300-word analysls of your own quesL. 1hls ls !"# a self-reflecLlon on Lhe wrlLlng process. lnsLead, you are wrlLlng an argumenL LhaL answers Lhe quesLlon, WhaL does your quesL represenL on a deeper level?" ?our blog posL should lnclude: - An lnLroducLory paragraph endlng wlLh a clear Lhesls sLaLemenL (e.g., 8llly's quesL Lo change hls name represenLs hls deslre Lo leave behlnd Lhe experlences of hls horrlflc chlldhood."). -8ody paragraphs LhaL analyze speclflc passages/aspecLs of Lhe quesL LhaL supporL your Lhesls. -A concludlng paragraph LhaL answers Lhe quesLlon: Pow does Lhe moral of your sLory relaLe Lo human experlence?" or WhaL does Lhls deeper moral slgnlflcance Leach us abouL Lhe world we llve ln?"
CA1LCC8? 4 3 2 1 Stays on 1op|c Addresses all (100-90) of Lhe requlred prompLs. Addresses mosL (89- 60) of Lhe requlred prompLs. Addresses (39- 40) of Lhe requlred prompLs. Addresses less Lhan 40 Lhe requlred prompLs. Content Shows a full undersLandlng of Lhe Loplc. Shows a good undersLandlng of Lhe Loplc. Shows a good undersLandlng of parLs of Lhe Loplc. uoes noL seem Lo undersLand Lhe Loplc very well. Speaks C|ear|y Speaks clearly and dlsLlncLly all (100-93) Lhe Llme, and mlspronounces no words. Speaks clearly and dlsLlncLly all (100-93) Lhe Llme, buL mlspronounces one word. Speaks clearly and dlsLlncLly mosL (94- 83) of Lhe Llme. Mlspronounces no more Lhan one word. CfLen mumbles or can noL be undersLood C8 mlspronounces more Lhan one word. reparedness SLudenL ls compleLely prepared and has obvlously rehearsed. SLudenL seems preLLy prepared buL mlghL have needed a couple of more rehearsals. 1he sLudenL ls somewhaL prepared, buL lL ls clear LhaL rehearsal was lacklng. SLudenL does noL seem aL all prepared Lo presenL. Co||aborat|on w|th eers AlmosL always llsLens Lo, shares wlLh, and supporLs Lhe efforLs of oLhers ln Lhe group. 1rles Lo keep people worklng well LogeLher. usually llsLens Lo, shares wlLh, and supporLs Lhe efforLs of oLhers ln Lhe group. uoes noL cause \"waves\" ln Lhe group. CfLen llsLens Lo, shares wlLh, and supporLs Lhe efforLs of oLhers ln Lhe group buL someLlmes ls noL a good Leam member. 8arely llsLens Lo, shares wlLh, and supporLs Lhe efforLs of oLhers ln Lhe group. CfLen ls noL a good Leam member. 19 CuesL narraLlve llnal urafL - 8ubrlc nA88A1lvL 3 4 3 2 CuesL Cb[ecLlve and Meanlng 1he narraLlve clearly deplcLs Lhe ob[ecLlve of Lhe quesL and whaL lL represenLs on a deeper (moral/splrlLual) level. 1he narraLlve somewhaL clearly deplcLs Lhe ob[ecLlve of Lhe quesL and whaL lL represenLs on a deeper (moral/splrlLual) level. 1he narraLlve somewhaL descrlbes LhaL Lhere ls a quesL, buL Lhe ob[ecLlve and deeper slgnlflcance are noL clear. 1he narraLlve does noL appear Lo have a quesL. Symbollsm 1he narraLlve and vlsual componenL vlvldly deplcL aL leasL 3 symbols LhaL clearly add Lo Lhe deeper meanlng of Lhe quesL. 1he narraLlve and vlsual componenL deplcL aL leasL 3 recognlzable symbols. 1he narraLlve and vlsual componenL presenL aL leasL 1 symbol. no symbollsm can be ldenLlfled. Crammar/ Mechanlcs ConslsLenLly uses sLandard wrlLlng convenLlons ln grammar, puncLuaLlon, and usage. Cenerally uses sLandard wrlLlng convenLlons ln spelllng, and caplLallzaLlon. Mlnlmally uses sLandard wrlLlng convenLlons ln spelllng, and caplLallzaLlon. uoes noL use sLandard wrlLlng convenLlons ln spelllng, and caplLallzaLlon. lrom SLaLus Cuo Lo Call 1he narraLlve vlvldly deplcLs Lhe hero's "SLaLus Cuo", "Call Lo AcLlon", and reacLlon Lo Lhe call. 1he narraLlve somewhaL clearly deplcLs Lhe hero's sLaLus quo, call Lo acLlon, and reacLlon Lo Lhe call. 1he narraLlve ls mlsslng key deLalls abouL Lhe hero's sLaLus quo, call Lo acLlon and reacLlon Lo Lhe call. 1he narraLlve does noL even descrlbe Lhe hero's sLaLus quo or call Lo acLlon. Approachlng a Crlsls 1he narraLlve vlvldly deplcLs Lhe hero's approach Lowards Lhe goal of Lhe quesL and Lhe "Crlsls" LhaL ensues. 1he narraLlve somewhaL clearly deplcLs an approach Lowards Lhe goal of Lhe quesL and a "Crlsls" 1he narraLlve somewhaL deplcLs a flnal confllcL, buL Lhe approach and/or "Crlsls" of Lhe characLer ln unclear. 1he narraLlve has no approach Loward Lhe goal of Lhe quesL, and Lhe hero has no "Crlsls." 1reasures/ 8esulLs/ ALonemenL 1he narraLlve clearly deplcLs Lhe "1reasures" galned by compleLlng Lhe quesL as well as Lhe overall "8esulLs" of Lhe quesL. 1he narraLlve somewhaL clearly descrlbes Lhe "1reasures" galned by compleLlng Lhe quesL as well as Lhe overall "8esulLs" of Lhe quesL. 1he narraLlve somewhaL descrlbes Lhe "1reasures" and "8esulLs", buL lL ls noL clear how Lhey relaLe Lo Lhe quesL. 1he narraLlve does noL descrlbe any "1reasures" or "8esulLs" from Lhe quesL. 8esoluLlon 1he narraLlve clearly deplcLs Lhe "8esoluLlon" of Lhe quesL (boLh for Lhe hero and Lhe world(s) s/he lnhablLs) 1he narraLlve somewhaL clearly deplcLs Lhe "8esoluLlon" Lo Lhe quesL. 1he narraLlve brlngs Lhe quesL Lo an end, buL leaves many quesLlons unresolved. 1he narraLlve ends abrupLly wlLhouL marklng Lhe end of Lhe quesL. CreaLlvlLy 1he pro[ecL conLalns many creaLlve deLalls and/or descrlpLlons LhaL conLrlbuLe Lo Lhe reader's en[oymenL. 1ruly lmaglnaLlve. 1he pro[ecL conLalns a few creaLlve deLalls and/or descrlpLlons LhaL conLrlbuLe Lo Lhe reader's en[oymenL. 1he pro[ecL conLalns a few creaLlve deLalls and/or descrlpLlons, buL Lhey dlsLracL from Lhe sLory. 1here ls llLLle evldence of creaLlvlLy or lmaglnaLlon. 10 8 6 4 ManuscrlpL lllumlnaLlons Crlglnal lllusLraLlons are deLalled, creaLlve and deplcL 3+ ploL momenLs and 3+ symbols Crlglnal lllusLraLlons are somewhaL deLalled and deplcL 2 ploL momenLs / 2 symbols Crlglnal lllusLraLlons relaLe Lo Lhe quesL narraLlve, buL no ldenLlflable symbols Crlglnal lllusLraLlons are noL presenL C8 are noL orlglnal llnal lllumlnaLed CuesL (____ / 30 ) *2 = (____ / 100) Crade: ______ LeLLer LqulvalenL_____
CATEGORY 4 - Above Standards 3 - Meets Standards 2 - Approaching Standar ds 1 - Below Standards Focus or Thesis Statement The thesis statement names the topic of the essay and outlines the main points to be discussed. The thesis statement names the topic of the essay. The thesis statement outlines some or all of the main points to be discussed but does not name the topic. The thesis statement does not name the topic AND does not preview what will be discussed. Evidence and Examples All of the evidence and examples are specific, relevant and explanations are given that show how each piece of evidence supports the author\'s position. Most of the evidence and examples are specific, relevant and explanations are given that show how each piece of evidence supports the author\'s position. At least one of the pieces of evidence and examples is relevant and has an explanation that shows how that piece of evidence supports the author\'s position. Evidence and examples are NOT relevant AND/OR are not explained. Sentence Structure All sentences are well- constructed with varied structure. Most sentences are well- constructed and there is some varied sentence structure in the essay. Most sentences are well constructed, but there is no variation is structure. Most sentences are not well-constructed or varied. Grammar & Spelling Author makes no errors in grammar or spelling that distract the reader from the content. Author makes 1-2 errors in grammar or spelling that distract the reader from the content. Author makes 3-4 errors in grammar or spelling that distract the reader from the content. Author makes more than 4 errors in grammar or spelling that distract the reader from the content. Transitions A variety of thoughtful transitions are used. They clearly show how ideas are connected Transitions show how ideas are connected, but there is little variety Some transitions work well, but some connections between ideas are fuzzy. The transitions between ideas are unclear OR nonexistent. Closing paragraph The conclusion is strong and leaves the reader solidly understanding the writer\'s position. Effective restatement of the position statement begins the closing paragraph. The conclusion is recognizable. The author\'s position is restated within the first two sentences of the closing paragraph. The author\'s position is restated within the closing paragraph, but not near the beginning. There is no conclusion - the paper just ends. 21 Plan for Reporting Outcomes Students will demonstrate that they have mastered the objectives for the unit by applying their knowledge of archetypes, symbolism, and allegory to a variety of assessments. Most of these assessments take the form of creative projects, but students will also demonstrate their knowledge in written and oral communication of their ideas. The final three-component project alone, if done adequately, would demonstrate a mastery of the goals of the unit, but there are also a large number of formative assessments in place to scaffold these end-goals for the students and to provide feedback for the teacher. The in-class writing exercises, especially those that require students to analyze a text and provide examples for support, are an excellent barometer of whether the students have mastered the objectives of the lesson. The most difficult objective to measureand perhaps the most importantis collaboration and communication with other students. The unit is structured to promote collaboration in various forms, ranging from informal think-pair-shares to peer editing and feedback shared via email. The teacher can assess the more informal collaborative activities holistically by circulating among students. For the peer editing and feedback, the teacher instructs students to email their revisions not only to their partner but also to the teacher. A major advantage of the blog platform is that it allows students to communicate informally outside of class in an authentic setting while still allowing for the teacher to track each students participation and engagement with peers. On a day-to- day basis, the exit slip writing reflections and in-class work allow the teacher to assess individual students understanding of concepts in order to make adjustments to upcoming lessons. 22 OVERVIEW OF PEDAGOGICAL STRATEGIES Instructional Goals The baseline objective for the unit is that students apply their understanding of the archetypes, symbolism, and allegory to the model of Campbells Heros Journey through visual creations, narrative writing, analytical writing, and communication with peers. Even more important than this objective, though, are the skills that students develop in the various ways of meeting it. To produce an original quest narrative that develops a hero, a quest, symbolism and allegory, students must learn to develop characters, events and themes in the process. To write a 1-paged analysis of their own quest narrative, students must learn to organize their claims, support them with textual evidence, and arrive at an overall conclusion. The various opportunities for student communication and collaboration encourage students to exercise other valuable 21 st
century skills, such as self-directed learning, global awareness, and creativity and innovation. Thus, students will be provided many opportunities to answer different forms of the essential question for the unit: what are the fundamental patterns of human experience? In making creative projects and sharing them with their peers, students show rather than tell what these patterns may be and why they are important. 21 st Century Teaching Strategies - Connection to other disciplines: The unit connects to psychology and neurosciencemost saliently in the first lesson when students read a scientific article on the importance of dreams in relation to medieval perspectives on the subject. 2S - Variety of methods and materials: This unit plan utilizes a wide variety of methods, including whole-class, small-group, and partner discussions, collaborative and individual reading activities, in-class and outside writing assignments, and activities to create visual projects. Some of the materials used in this unit include texts (both literary and informational), works of visual art, art supplies, and technology (especially the blog platform). - Integration of technology: Students will utilize technology to collaborate and communicate with their Quest Writing group members throughout the unit. By using Microsoft Word track changes and in-text comments, students take advantage of tools frequently used in the workplace for giving receiving feedback on projects. The Google Blogger platform enhances students ability to communicate outside of class and share their work with peers. - Engagement with problem solving, inquiry, and critical thinking: The unit centers on the important question of what patterns are fundamental to human experience. However, each lesson has an essential question that is specifically geared toward the texts or activities of the day. Students will think critically about these questions and express themselves in a variety of activitiesranging from small-group to whole-class discussions, from individual written analysis to group creative projects (such as the make your own illuminated manuscript activity of lesson 8, in which students must visually represent the allegory of an excerpt of Dantes Inferno). In addition, the creative writing and peer-editing assignments a high level of critical thinking. 24 - Experiences in collaborative and team learning structures: The unit furnishes students with a number of collaborative and team learning structures (in fact, lessons 2 and 4-10 are heavily group-work oriented). For example, while reading Sir Gawain and the Green Knight in class, students intermittently share notes with their small group to resolve doubts about specific passages. In addition, students work in Quest Writing groups of 3-4 students throughout the brainstorming, editing, and feedback stages of writing their original quest narratives. - Opportunities for students to develop leadership and communication skills: Students can develop leadership skills throughout the unit by fulfilling specific functions within their group. For the presentations in lesson 2 and 4, the teacher assigns specific roles to each student so as to model the ways in which a group would communicate and collaborate to accomplish a shared task. In lessons 5 and 6, students rely on one another as a resource in comprehending and analyzing the text Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. In lessons 7 through 10 students work largely independently toward completing their individual quest narratives as well as the group presentation. This scaffolding is designed to promote students to grow in leadership and self-directed learning.
2S LESSON PLANS
Name: Michael Martell
Subject/Grade Level: British Literature (Standard-level English 4 12 th Grade)
!"#$% Quests and Heroes: Teaching Archetypes, Symbolism, and Allegory through Narrative Writing in a 12 th Grade ELA Classroom Lesson Title: Dream Visions
!"#$%&'(#)%"
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Students will analyze the importance of dreams in relation to personal experience, a scientific article on the subject, and Arthurs dream vision from Le Morte dArthur. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:RL 11-12.1: Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text, including determining where the text leaves matters uncertain.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:RL.5: Analyze how an authors choices concerning how to structure specific parts of a text (e.g., the choice of where to begin or end a story, the choice to provide a comedic or tragic resolution) contribute to its overall structure and meaning as well as its aesthetic impact.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:RI.1 = Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text, including determining where the text leaves matters uncertain.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:RI7: Integrate and evaluate multiple sources of information presented in different media or formats (e.g., visually, quantitatively) as well as in words in order to address a question or solve a problem.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:SL.1: Initiate and participate effectively in a range of collaborative discussions (one-on-one, in groups, and teacher-led) with diverse partners on grades 11-12 topics, texts, and issues, building on others ideas and expressing their own clearly and persuasively.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy:W.1: Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, 26 using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence.
Students will engage in a variety of discussions (whole class, one-on-one) centered on the essential question of the lesson Students will write a 1-paragraph analysis of Arthurs dream vision (citing the text for support). Stuuents will oiganize the iueas ieau fiom 2 uiveise texts (a scientific aiticle anu a liteiaiy naiiative) onto a venn uiagiam (analyzing ielationships between the two peispectives)
:--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
What iole uo uieams play in human expeiience. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- General scientific knowledge - Personal experience with dreams +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Critical Thinking and Problem Solving: Students are required to interpret diverse sources (a scientific article, the teachers PowerPoint, a literary text), evaluate the information presented in each, and synthesize all three to form their own viewpoint.
Communication and Collaboration: Students express their opinions orally (in pairs) and written (on the Dream Cloud Worksheet).
21 st Centuiy Stanuaius: Builus unueistanuing acioss anu among coie subjects as well as 21st centuiy inteiuisciplinaiy themes
- Wiitten Analysis: Aftei ieauing Pp. 176-178, stuuents will wiite a shoit analysis in iesponse to this piompt: What uoes Aithuis uieam vision iepiesent. Cite specific passages (in quotes) to suppoit youi claims. You may also use the teims: peisonification anu symbol. - Bieam Clouu Woiksheet: Stuuents will oiganize theii summaiies of 2 souices onto a venn uiagiam anu answei questions below 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
27 This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Marcus: The Post-it note summary activity will help Marcus to synthesize the information from the scientific article. The Venn diagram on the Dream Cloud Worksheet will help him organize and synthesize the important information.
Daniel: The video clip and images in the PowerPoint will aid Daniels understanding of the essential question. The Post- it notes and the Venn diagram will help him synthesize and organize longer texts into short bullet points.
Chiistophe: The Post-it note summaiy activity will help Chiistophe to unueistanu anu paiaphiase the moie uifficult technical vocabulaiy. The viueo clip anu images will help to engage with the mateiial in spite of his uecouing uifficulties. The venn Biagiam on the Bieam Clouu Woiksheet will help him oiganize his thoughts befoie iesponuing to the wiitten piompts. The bell-iingei will help him to engage with the mateiial by fiist connecting it to peisonal expeiience.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Post-it notes; Tv Nonitoi (foi PoweiPoint anu viueo clips); Scientific Ameiican Aiticle on Bieaming; Bieam Clouu Woiksheet; viueo clip of cafe scene in Nolans Inception (http:www.youtube.comwatch.v=_bsu00vTA84) ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
- Warm-up writing prompt (displayed on monitor): What is the most vivid dream youve ever had? Describe what you remembered when you woke up. - The teacher gives students 3 minutes to write. O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Discussion of Dreams (15 min):
1. The teacher asks 2-3 students to share their responses with class.
1. The teacher asks students follow-up questions: How did you wake up? When did you realize it was a dream? Show of hands for having a dream, but not remembering what it was - 1 student share; dream within dream?
2. The teacher plays the 2-minute video clip of the cafe scene in Inception (meanwhile, the teacher passes out copies of the Scientific American article)
1. The teacher asks: Is there a connection/separation between dreams and reality? Dreams and 28 memories?
2. Teacher raises essential question for students to respond to: What role do dreams play in human experience?
- Reading of The ScienceDreaming (20 min)
1. Transition question: What can science tell us about dreams?
1. Instructions for students: As you read, summarize the most important points (in your notes).
2. After reading the first paragraph, the teacher draws a timeline on the whiteboard, fills out the first (general) date mentioned in the article, and asks students to fill in the rest (by searching through the first paragraph).
1. Students read the rest of the article aloud (the teacher calls on individuals to read paragraphs).
3. After reading: The teacher shows students that there is a Post-it note on the back of the article and instructs them to take 1 minute to summarize 3 most important points on it. The teacher models a 1 st point for the whole class.
- Middle Ages: Dream Vision PowerPoint (13 min)
- Students take notes on the essential vocab word (motif) and examples of the dream vision motif: Caedmons hymn, Pearl, Dante, King Arthur and the quest for the Holy Grail. The teacher emphasizes that the dream vision can function as a warning, a connection to the supernatural, and way to set a plot in motion. - Think-pair-share: 1. The teacher instructs: On the 2 nd post-it, write 3-4 most important features of dream vision motif. What do all of these dream visions have in common? (share with a partner) - Analyze image (5 min): students analyze a medieval depiction of the Wheel of Fortune and respond (in their notes) to the prompt: What does this Wheel symbolize? Who are the people depicted? - Whole class discussion: share ideas (5 minutes) 1. The teacher calls on students to share their ideas. 2. The teacher gives Wheel of Fortune (TV show) hint. 3. Slides: teacher explains this symbol (the wheel) and personification (Fortune) in terms of Middle Ages. 1. Student take notes on vocabulary words. 2. The teacher displays definitions on PowerPoint: Motif A recurring feature of a literary work that is related to a theme. Symbol 29 Something that represents something else. Personification Giving humanlike qualities to something non-human. - In-class reading of Dream Vision (Pp. 176-78) (10 min) 1. Open to P. 176: read introductory paragraph 2. Paragraph 1: point to image, remind them of danger warning (adaptation to survive? Or divine prophecy?) 3. Draw small Character web (to give context for Gawain and Mordred) 4. Continue reading until Gawain vanishes. The teacher reminds students of Dream within a Dream (Inception clip). Emphasize the uiffeient LAYERS of ieality. The teachei asks stuuents: Bow uo these layeis inteiielate.
63%-'$,
- Analyzing Aithuis uieam vision (1u min): o In 1 paiagiaph, stuuents answei the question: What uoes Aithuis uieam vision iepiesent. Cite specific passages (in quotes) to suppoit youi claims. You may also use the teims: peisonification anu symbol. o The teachei collects stuuents 1-paiagiaph analyses at the enu of class - Bomewoik: use post-its to make a Bieam venn uiagiam. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
If the Bieam Clouu woiksheets anu 1-paiagiaph analyses inuicate that stuuents faileu to giasp the concept of the uieam motif, the teachei coulu ieintiouuce the uieam motif alongsiue examples of othei common motifs. The teachei coulu cieate a paitneismall gioup activity in which stuuents woik togethei to finu the iecuiiing pattein among S-4 specific examples fiom liteiatuie (foi example, S stoiies in which a chaiactei has a uieam anu takes action in iesponse to it). This appioach woulu allow stuuents to iuentify foi themselves that the uieam as a common pattein in liteiatuie (as opposeu to be being tolu by the teachei that it is a pattein). N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Krn, Emil, and Daniel Marx. "Dream of the Magi by GISLEBERTUS." Dream of the Magi by GISLEBERTUS. Web Gallery of Art, n.d. Web. 07 May 2014.
Milner, Joseph O'Beirne, and Lucy Floyd Morcock Milner. "Venn Diagramming" and Synergistic Texts Bridging English. 4th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill, 2008. 99- 101. Print.
Prentice Hall British Literature : Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2000. Print.
Su Slade, Benjamin. "Beowulf on Steorarume [Beowulf in Cyberspace]: Bede's Account of the Poet Caedmon & Caedmon's Hymn." Beowulf on Steorarume [Beowulf in Cyberspace]: Bede's Account of the Poet Caedmon & Caedmon's Hymn. Benjamin Slade, n.d. Web. 07 May 2014.
Van Der Linden, Sander. "The Science Behind Dreaming." Scientific American (2011): n. pag. Scientific American Online. Scientific American, 26 June 2011. Web.
NOTE: Attach or insert any materials used in this lesson.
PowerPoint, Dream Cloud Worksheet, The Science of Dreaming
S1 4(),"#)L)( H7,$)(2" !"# %&'#(&# )#"'(* +,#-.'(/ New ieseaich sheus light on how anu why we iemembei uieams--anu what puipose they aie likely to seive Jul 26, 2011 |By Sander van der Linden
Foi centuiies people have ponueieu the meaning of uieams. Eaily civilizations thought of uieams as a meuium between oui eaithly woilu anu that of the gous. In fact, the uieeks anu Romans weie convinceu that uieams hau ceitain piophetic poweis. While theie has always been a gieat inteiest in the inteipietation of human uieams, it wasnt until the enu of the nineteenth centuiy that Sigmunu Fieuu anu Cail }ung put foith some of the most wiuely-known mouein theoiies of uieaming. Fieuus theoiy centeieu aiounu the notion of iepiesseu longing -- the iuea that uieaming allows us to soit thiough uniesolveu, iepiesseu wishes. Cail }ung (who stuuieu unuei Fieuu) also believeu that uieams hau psychological impoitance, but pioposeu uiffeient theoiies about theii meaning. Since then, technological auvancements have alloweu foi the uevelopment of othei theoiies. 0ne piominent neuiobiological theoiy of uieaming is the activation- synthesis hypothesis, which states that uieams uont actually mean anything: they aie meiely electiical biain impulses that pull ianuom thoughts anu imageiy fiom oui memoiies. Bumans, the theoiy goes, constiuct uieam stoiies aftei they wake up, in a natuial attempt to make sense of it all. Yet, given the vast uocumentation of iealistic aspects to human uieaming as well as inuiiect expeiimental eviuence that othei mammals such as cats also uieam, evolutionaiy psychologists have theoiizeu that uieaming ieally uoes seive a puipose. In paiticulai, the thieat simulation theoiy suggests that uieaming shoulu be seen as an ancient biological uefense mechanism that pioviueu an evolutionaiy auvantage because of its capacity to iepeateuly simulate potential thieatening events enhancing the neuio-cognitive mechanisms iequiieu foi efficient thieat peiception anu avoiuance. So, ovei the yeais, numeious theoiies have been put foith in an attempt to illuminate the mysteiy behinu human uieams, but, until iecently, stiong tangible eviuence has iemaineu laigely elusive. Yet, new ieseaich publisheu in the }ouinal of Neuioscience pioviues compelling insights into the mechanisms that unueilie uieaming anu the stiong ielationship oui uieams have with oui memoiies. Ciistina Naizano anu hei colleagues at the 0niveisity of Rome have succeeueu, foi the fiist time, in explaining how humans iemembei theii uieams. The scientists pieuicteu the likelihoou of successful uieam iecall baseu on a signatuie pattein of biain waves. In oiuei to uo this, the Italian ieseaich team inviteu 6S stuuents to spenu two consecutive nights in theii ieseaich laboiatoiy. S2 Buiing the fiist night, the stuuents weie left to sleep, allowing them to get useu to the sounu-pioofeu anu tempeiatuie-contiolleu iooms. Buiing the seconu night the ieseaicheis measuieu the stuuents biain waves while they slept. 0ui biain expeiiences foui types of electiical biain waves: uelta, theta, alpha, anu beta. Each iepiesents a uiffeient speeu of oscillating electiical voltages anu togethei they foim the electioencephalogiaphy (EEu). The Italian ieseaich team useu this technology to measuie the paiticipants biain waves uuiing vaiious sleep- stages. (Theie aie five stages of sleep; most uieaming anu oui most intense uieams occui uuiing the REN stage.) The stuuents weie woken at vaiious times anu askeu to fill out a uiaiy uetailing whethei oi not they uieamt, how often they uieamt anu whethei they coulu iemembei the content of theii uieams. While pievious stuuies have alieauy inuicateu that people aie moie likely to iemembei theii uieams when woken uiiectly aftei REN sleep, the cuiient stuuy explains why. Those paiticipants who exhibiteu moie low fiequency theta waves in the fiontal lobes weie also moie likely to iemembei theii uieams. This finuing is inteiesting because the incieaseu fiontal theta activity the ieseaicheis obseiveu looks just like the successful encouing anu ietiieval of autobiogiaphical memoiies seen while we aie awake. That is, it is the same electiical oscillations in the fiontal coitex that make the iecollection of episouic memoiies (e.g., things that happeneu to you) possible. Thus, these finuings suggest that the neuiophysiological mechanisms that we employ while uieaming (anu iecalling uieams) aie the same as when we constiuct anu ietiieve memoiies while we aie awake. In anothei iecent stuuy conuucteu by the same ieseaich team, the authois useu the latest NRI techniques to investigate the ielation between uieaming anu the iole of ueep-biain stiuctuies. In theii stuuy, the ieseaicheis founu that viviu, bizaiie anu emotionally intense uieams (the uieams that people usually iemembei) aie linkeu to paits of the amyguala anu hippocampus. While the amyguala plays a piimaiy iole in the piocessing anu memoiy of emotional ieactions, the hippocampus has been implicateu in impoitant memoiy functions, such as the consoliuation of infoimation fiom shoit-teim to long-teim memoiy. The pioposeu link between oui uieams anu emotions is also highlighteu in anothei iecent stuuy publisheu by Natthew Walkei anu colleagues at the Sleep anu Neuioimaging Lab at 0C Beikeley, who founu that a ieuuction in REN sleep (oi less uieaming) influences oui ability to unueistanu complex emotions in uaily life an essential featuie of human social functioning. Scientists have also iecently iuentifieu wheie uieaming is likely to occui in the biain. A veiy iaie clinical conuition known as Chaicot-Wilbianu Synuiome has been known to cause SS (among othei neuiological symptoms) loss of the ability to uieam. Bowevei, it was not until a few yeais ago that a patient iepoiteu to have lost hei ability to uieam while having viitually no othei peimanent neuiological symptoms. The patient suffeieu a lesion in a pait of the biain known as the iight infeiioi lingual gyius (locateu in the visual coitex). Thus, we know that uieams aie geneiateu in, oi tiansmitteu thiough this paiticulai aiea of the biain, which is associateu with visual piocessing, emotion anu visual memoiies. Taken togethei, these iecent finuings tell an impoitant stoiy about the unueilying mechanism anu possible puipose of uieaming. Bieams seem to help us piocess emotions by encouing anu constiucting memoiies of them. QJ2# 0, -,, 2"& ,MK,$),"(, )" %'$ &$,27- 7)CJ# "%# ",(,--2$)3G =, $,23R ='# #J, ,7%#)%"- 2##2(J,& #% #J,-, ,MK,$),"(,- (,$#2)"3G 2$,S 0ui uieam stoiies essentially tiy to stiip the emotion out of a ceitain expeiience by cieating a memoiy of it. This way, the emotion itself is no longei active. This mechanism fulfills an impoitant iole because when we uont piocess oui emotions, especially negative ones, this incieases peisonal woiiy anu anxiety. In fact, seveie REN sleep- uepiivation is incieasingly coiielateu to the uevelopment of mental uisoiueis. In shoit, uieams help iegulate tiaffic on that fiagile biiuge which connects oui expeiiences with oui emotions anu memoiies. H?.TU UV: HTUV.N54; 42"&,$ /2" &,$ +)"&," is a uoctoial ieseaichei in social expeiimental psychology at the Lonuon School of Economics anu Political Science. Bis ieseaich is conceineu with the piocess of behavioial change anu funueu by the uiantham Reseaich Institute on Climate Change anu the Enviionment.
S4 +,--%" A32" W E
Lesson Title: Investigating Aithui: fiom spoken woiu to wiitten accounts.
Name: Nichael Naitell
!"#$%&'(#)%"
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Stuuents will ieflect on how an oially spieau legenu becomes a wiitten account, leain anu contextualize Aithuiian Romance (anu key figuies) alongsiue Beowulf, anu synthesize infoimation fiom vaiious texts to be piesenteu infoimally in gioups of 4-S. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.4: Piesent infoimation, finuings, anu suppoiting eviuence, conveying a cleai anu uistinct peispective, such that listeneis can follow the line of ieasoning, alteinative oi opposing peispectives aie auuiesseu, anu the oiganization, uevelopment, substance, anu style aie appiopiiate to puipose, auuience, anu a iange of foimal anu infoimal tasks. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.1 Initiate anu paiticipate effectively in a iange of collaboiative uiscussions (one-on-one, in gioups, anu teachei-leu) with uiveise paitneis on giaues 11-12 topics, texts, anu issues, builuing on otheis' iueas anu expiessing theii own cleaily anu peisuasively. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.1.B Woik with peeis to piomote civil, uemociatic uiscussions anu uecision-making, set cleai goals anu ueaulines, anu establish inuiviuual ioles as neeueu. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.2.F Pioviue a concluuing statement oi section that follows fiom anu suppoits the infoimation oi explanation piesenteu (e.g., aiticulating implications oi the significance of the topic). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents collaboiate in small gioups to synthesize, oiganize anu piesent infoimation fiom two oi moie souices on a topic. - 0n a wiitten exit slip, stuuent answei the essential question on the implications of the tiansfoimation fiom oial legenu to wiitten account, citing examples piesenteu by othei gioups. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
What happens when an oial legenu becomes a wiitten account. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
In the pievious unit, stuuents weie taught anu assesseu on the uevelopment of the English Language, oial tiauition, the heio cycle, anu Beowulf. SS +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents woik togethei in small gioups to synthesize infoimation fiom two oi moie texts anu oiganize the ciucial points into a piesentation.
Ciitical Thinking anu Pioblem Solving Stuuents synthesize infoimation fiom two oi moie texts anu oiganize them into a shoit gioup piesentation (meant to teach theii peeis).
- Infoimal gioup piesentations: Stuuents woik togethei to synthesize, oiganize anu piesent infoimation fiom 2 oi moie souices. Stuuents piesentation skills aie assesseu baseu on a iubiic (attacheu) anu the accuiacy of theii iesponses aie assesseu by evaluating theii iesponses to theii assigneu questions (wiitten uown anu tuineu in). - Exit slip: stuuents answei the essential question on a notecaiu then shaie theii iesponses in paiis. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus: The Chaiactei Web woiksheet auuiesses Naicus neeu of giaphic oiganizeis. Woiking with peeis who aie moie focuseu will help Naicus stay on task uuiing the Aithuiian Investigation pioject.
Baviu: The teacheis multimeuia piesentation (alteinating between PoweiPoint sliues anu shoit clips of an euucational viueo) will aiu Bavius compiehension. Woiking in small gioups will allow him to piactice speaking in a lowei-stakes setting.
Chiistophe: The guiueu ieauing questions (foi his gioups assigneu souices in the Aithuiian Investigation) will help Chiistophe to ieau thiough the infoimation while actively seaiching foi the impoitant infoimation. Woiking S6 in a small gioup will help Chiistophe to gain a ueepei unueistanuing of the texts thiough collaboiation.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
PoweiPoint; BvB: King Aithui : Bis Life anu Legenus (also maue available on youtube http:www.youtube.comwatch.v=cZLub_FNTNY); sciatch papei; laige notecaius; small sheets of papei with numbeis wiitten on them; chaiactei web; Rubiic anu Instiuctions foi Aithuiian Investigation; Inuiviuual Souices anu Roles foi each gioup ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
-0pon enteiing the classioom, each stuuent takes a sheet of papei anu a numbei fiom a bucket (1-8). The papei will be useu foi the waim-up activity, anu the numbei will ueteimine what gioup the stuuent will be in foi the Aithuiian Investigation
Waim-up activity: embellishing otheis stoiies (S min) Instiuctions to stuuents: -Wiite uown a 1-sentences stoiy (keep it simple), then pass it to the peison behinu you (if theie is no one behinu you, pass it to the fiont. -Now, embellish the stoiy you have been given (auu uetails to make it seem moie fantasticattiactive) anu pass it back again -Auu uetails to this S iu stoiy. Then, give it back to the peison who oiiginally wiote it. O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Biscussion of activity (S min) o The teachei asks foi 1-2 volunteeis to ieau, tiace back to what the stoiy oiiginally was o The teachei asks: What happeneu theie. anu ieminus them of the oial tiauition telephone activity fiom the pievious unit. The teachei asks what makes this game uiffeient fiom the typical telephone. - PoweiPointviueo: 0ial to Wiitten (S min) o Teachei asks: who is the authoi of Beowulf. (Stuuents shoulu know that theie is no known single authoi). Baseu on stuuent iesponses, teachei asks But if we have it on papei, who wiote it uown. o Stuuents iesponu to the essential question (in notes): What happens when stoiies fiom oial tiauition get wiitten uown. What changes. What stays the same. o Stuuents shaie iesponses foi essential question. - Intiouucing Aithui anu Legenu (PoweiPoint) S7 (1u min) o U$2"-)#)%" to Aithui: wiite eveiything you know about Aithui (2 min) o Was King Aithui a man, oi is he just a legenu. (Show of hanus who wiote man anu who wiote legenu) o Bis stoiy came fiom oial tiauition, but was latei wiitten uown. o Teachei uefinesX Legenu: a stoiy oi gioup of stoiies tolu about a peison oi a place (as if its histoiy) ! Teachei asks: Coulu Aithui be both histoiy anu legenu. o Watch fiist S minutes of viueo clip (Aithui: Bis Life) ! Point out embellishment piocess - PoweiPointviueo: Embellishing Aithui (1S min) o Fiom Celtic stoiies to Nonmouth ! Nonmouths auuience. Notive. o The teachei plays the viueo clip on Chietien chivaliy (S min) (Aithui: Bis Life) ! Bave stuuents answei questions uuiing clip (uisplayeu on PoweiPoint sliues). o Chitiens single heio auventuie mouel o Chivaliy: teachei uefines geneially anu gives specific chaiacteiistics o Romance: teachei uefines geneial anu gives chaiacteiistics o Featuies of Quest o Puipose = teach ieaueis viitues - Tiansition: The teachei asks, Bow uoes liteiatuie ieflect the values of the peoplecultuie of the eia. - Aithuiian Investigation (uioup investigation task) (The teachei sets a classioom timei foi 2u minutes.) o Stuuents aie uiviueu into gioups of 4-S baseu on the numbei they uiew at the beginning of the class. Each gioup # will ieseaich a uiffeient chaiacteitopic fiom Aithuiian legenu (by ieauing anu answei questions foi texts pioviueu) anu piepaie an infoimal piesentation on the topic. o Stuuents will woik in gioups of 4-S to ieseaich anu compile an infoimal piesentation on a topic S8 o Each gioup will get a set of questions to answei anu the instiuctions: The piesentation must auuiess these questions, but not in any paiticulai oiuei. o Each membei will be assigneu a iole (speak, wiite, ieau aiticle #1, ieau aiticle #2, ieau aiticle #S) Infoimal Piesentations (2 min each, 1 min foi Qs) (2S min) - 0n the scieen, the teachei uisplays the essential questions that each gioup will be answeiing. All othei stuuents aie instiucteu to take notes foi answeis. - Aftei piesentations: the teachei asks foi stuuent iesponses on the effects of embellishment. 63%-'$,
Befoie piesentations aie uone, the teachei passes out laige blank notecaius to all stuuents. Exit slip: Answei Essential Q (1u minutes) -Each stuuent inuiviuually answeis the essential question: What happens when an oial legenu becomes a wiitten account. What uoes this piocess imply about the funuamental natuie of liteiatuie. Cite examples fiom othei gioups piesentations to suppoit youi claims on the fiont of a notecaiu (1u min) BW: fill in chaiactei web using notes, textbook, anu the Rochestei 0niveisity uatabase of Aithuiian Chaiacteis (http:u.lib.iochestei.euuthemeCamelot%2uPioject). H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
If stuuents fail to fill out the chaiactei web using notes, textbook, anu the Rochestei 0niveisity uatabase (http:u.lib.iochestei.euuthemeCamelot%2uPioject), the teachei can point out specific chaiactei ielationships uuiing the ieauing of Noite uAithui anu Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight (instiucting stuuents to fill in theii web little-by-little thioughout the unit). N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Bailey, Chailene. "Naking the Niuule Ages Fun foi Teacheis anu Stuuents." '()#"* $+, '#--., /*,0 12" 345 6,(7+,50 ("- 8$2-,"$0. Louisiana Enuowment foi the Bumanities, 2uuu. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
Caimichael, Ashley. "Aithuiian Legenu." 9"*.#0+ : ;472<,"$0 => !"#$. Winston Salem Foisyth County Public Schools, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
Cuiiin, Nathan. "King Aithui & The Knights of the Rounu Table | Bistoiy, Legenu anu Eveiything in Between." ?#"* /5$+25 @ 6+, ?"#*+$0 43 $+, A42"- 6(=., B C#0$45>D E,*,"- ("- 9F,5>$+#"* #" G,$H,,". Live Peison, 2uu1. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
?#"* /5$+25% C#0 E#3, ("- E,*,"-0. A & E, 2uuS. BvB. S9
N0TE: Attach oi inseit any mateiials useu in this lesson.
PoweiPoint; uocuments foi each gioups Aithuiian Investigation; Aithuiian Investigation RubiicInstiuctions; uesciiption of inuiviuual ioles; Assigneu Questions foi each gioup; Chaiactei Web
4u
Character Web Aftei viewing youi peeis' mini piesentations, use youi notes to fill in this web of chaiactei ielations. If you cannot finu the answei in youi notes oi in the textbook, seaich foi the answeis in the "Camelot Pioject" uatabase (0niveisity of Rochestei: http:u.lib.iochestei.euucamelot-pioject). (Answei questions baseu on Naloiy's account of the chaiactei ielations).
Reflection Reflect on how Aithuiian legenu evolveu as vaiious authois auueu uetails ovei time. Bow uoes this piocess of embellishment affect the ielationships among chaiacteis.
41
Arthurian Investigation: Mini Group Presentations (16 points)
In youi foluei you will finu youi gioup topic anu ioles (note-takei, ieauei, wiitei, oi piesentation leauei). Beciue amongst youi gioup who will peifoim which iole.
Woik with youi gioup to ieau the text, answei the assigneu questions, anu piepaie a 2-minute piesentation on the topic. In youi piesentation, you shoulu.
1) Intiouuce the topic 2) Biiectly answei the assigneu questions S) Ask the iest of the class if they have any questions
Each of you has a specific iole, but you will be given a C$%'K C$2&, (incluuing collaboiation). That means you must woik togethei anu help each othei. uoou luck!
CATEGORY 4 3 2 1 Content Shows a full understanding of the topic. Shows a good understanding of the topic. Shows a good understanding of parts of the topic. Does not seem to understand the topic very well. Answer the Questions Students accurately answer almost all of the assigned questions. Students accurately answer most of the assigned questions. Students answer a few of the assigned questions. Students do not accurately answer the assigned questions. Listens to Other Presentations Listens intently. Does not make distracting noises or movements. Listens intently but has one distracting noise or movement. Sometimes does not appear to be listening but is not distracting. Sometimes does not appear to be listening and has distracting noises or movements. Collaboration with Peers Almost always listens to, shares with, and supports the efforts of others in the group. Tries to keep people working well together. Usually listens to, shares with, and supports the efforts of others in the group. Does not cause \"waves\" in the group. Often listens to, shares with, and supports the efforts of others in the group but sometimes is not a good team member. Rarely listens to, shares with, and supports the efforts of others in the group. Often is not a good team member. Y$%'K <,7=,$-: Total Points (____ 16) Piesentation Leauei: ________________________ uiaue: ____% Reauei: ____________________________ Lettei Equivalent: _____ Note-takei:_________________________ Wiitei: ____________________________
42
H$#J'$)2" !"/,-#)C2#)%" Z N%3,- 2"& Y$%'K U%K)(-
Each stuuent will be given a sheet of papei uesciibing the gioup (coloi), topic, anu iole that she has been assigneu. The gioups will have 1S minutes to ieau thiough 2-S uocuments on an assigneu topic, answei the assigneu questions, anu piepaie an infoimal piesentation (teaching the iest of the class). The gioup ioles aie as follows:
N,2&,$: You aie the ieauei of youi gioup. Reau the uocument(s) out-louu to the iest of youi gioup. Then, woik with youi team's "wiitei" to answei the assigneu questions anu come up with a piesentation
9%#,P#2D,$: You aie in chaige of taking notes as the ieauei ieaus the uocuments. Keep the assigneu questions in minu, but youi job is "4$ to wiite out the answeis. Insteau, wiite uown any impoitant uetails that may auu to the claiity anu uepth of youi piesentation.
Q$)#,$: You aie in chaige of wiiting the iesponses to the assigneu questions. Woik with youi gioup to come up with cleai, uetaileu answeis that can be useu in the piesentation.
A$,-,"#2#)%" +,2&,$: You aie in chaige of oiganizing the 2-minute piesentation. All membeis can speak, but make suie you have a cleai plan so that theie is no confusion. You aie also iesponsible foi keeping eveiyone on task.
The gioups aie as follows: uioup 1: Aithui: Fiom Legenu to 'Bistoiy' uioup 2: Aithui in Romances uioup S: Neilin uioup 4: Lancelot anu uuineveie uioup S: Sii uawain uioup 6: Noiuieu anu Noiguase uioup 7: The Lauy of the Lake anu Excalibui uioup 8: Epic vs. Romance 4S
Arthurian Investigation Group 1: Arthur From Legend to History Woik togethei to ieau the text, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
1) In what yeai uiu King Aithui fiist appeai in a text.
2) Who was the authoi.
S) Was the account moie of a legenu oi a histoiy.
4) What majoi event in Biitian spaikeu a floweiing in Celtic liteiatuie (give uate). Why.
S) What wiitei gave the fiist full account of Aithui's life.
6) What is the name of the hugely influential book he wiote.
7) What souice uiu ueoffiey claim that he useu to finu infoimation about Aithui.
8) Accoiuing to the authoi, how uiu ueoffiey ueal with myth anu fact (legenu anu 'histoiy').
44 Arthurian Investigation Group 1: Arthur From Legend to History First layer of the legend 3
The King Arthur that we know of today is a composite of layers of different legends, written by different authors at different times. He appears in his first incarnation in the 'History of the Britons', written in 830 and attributed to a writer called Nennius. Here Arthur appears as a heroic British general and a Christian warrior, during the tumultuous late fifth century, when Anglo-Saxon tribes were attacking Britain. In one of the most pregnant passages in British history, Nennius says: Then in those days Arthur fought against them with the kings of the Britons, but he was commander [dux bellorum] in those battles. Nennius then gives a list of 12 battles fought by Arthur, a list that belongs in an old tradition of battle-list poems in Welsh poetry. Some of the names appear in other early poems and annals, stretched over a wide period of time and place, and the list represents the kind of eclectic plundering that was the bards stock-in-trade. So the 12 battles of Arthur are not history. One man could not possibly have fought in all of them. The 12 battles are in fact the first signs of a legend. Historic Arthur In the turmoil of the period following the Norman invasion in 1066, Celtic literature experienced a flowering. Much of it concerned stories of the Welsh and the other Celtic Britons in glorious triumph against their new masters. A shower of
S Exceipt taken fiom Nichael Woou's aiticle, "'King A4ithui,' 0nce anu Futuie King (BBC.co.uk) 4S new histories also sprung forth, introducing the Normans to the culture and the past of the Celts. All such stories need a main protagonist, a hero to lead the troops, and this is where Arthur fitted in. Much of it concerned stories of the Welsh and the other Celtic Britons in glorious triumph against their new masters. Already known in Welsh poetry and in Nennius's history, he was an obvious contender. And with that background it is perhaps unsurprising that it was another Welsh writer who propelled Arthur from being just a Celtic warrior to being a mythical super-star. The writer was Geoffrey of Monmouth, who spent his working life in Oxford and here produced his momentous work 'The History of the Kings of Britain'. Geoffrey claimed the work was based on a secret lost Celtic manuscript that only he was able to examine. But it's really a myth masquerading as history, a fantastical tale of the history of the British Isles, which concentrates its key pages on King Arthur and his wondrous deeds. In this work, for the first time, Arthur's whole life is told - from his birth at Tintagel to his eventual betrayal and death. Theres Guinevere and Merlin, theres the legendary sword Caliburn (later known as Excalibur), and even the kings final resting place at Avalon - though it's not yet identified with Glastonbury. At the time it was written Geoffreys book had a tremendous influence, and over 200 manuscripts still remain in existence. Its impact was as great in Europe as it was in Britain. Geoffrey had an expert way of mixing myth with fact, thus blurring reality - and this blend attracted a mass audience, perhaps in the same way that works such as The Da Vinci Code do today. 46 Arthurian Investigation Group 2: Arthur in Romances Woik togethei to ieau the text, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) What key event biought the legenu of King Aithui to Fiance.
2) What political maiiiage encouiageu an inteimingling of Fiench anu English liteiatuie.
S) Which Fiench wiitei of chivaliic iomances tuineu the Aithuiian Legenu into a spiiitual quest. Bow uiu he uo so.
4) Accoiuing to the authoi, what uiu the uiail come to symbolize.
S) Which Aithuiian iomance was one of the fiist books to be piinteu in Englanu. When was it publisheu.
6) Accoiuing to the aiticle, which Biitish monaichs accepteu Aithui as a histoiical anu political figuie.
7) Why uo you think Beniy vIII painteu himself in the position of Aithui on a Rounu Table.
47 Arthurian Investigation Group 2: Arthur in Romances
The Holy Grail At the same time of Geoffrey of Monmouth, the stories of Arthur began to bloom in the Celtic lands of northern France. This French connection began soon after the Norman Conquest, when Henry II of England married the vivacious and beautiful Eleanor of Aquitaine. In their court the two worlds of French and English literature intermingled, and poets and troubadours transformed the Arthur legend from a political fable to a tale of chivalric romance. Perhaps the most important among the court writers was Chrtien de Troyes, who worked for Eleanors daughter Marie de Champagne. Chrtien is probably the greatest medieval writer of Arthurian romances, and it was he who turned the legend from courtly romance into spiritual quest. The mysterious Holy Grail, one of the most captivating motifs in all literature, first appears as part of the Arthurian legend in Chrtien's unfinished poem 'Perceval, or the Story of the Grail' (1181-90): A girl came in, fair and comely and beautifully adorned, and between her hands she held a grail. And when she carried the grail in, the hall was suffused by a light so brilliant that the candles lost their brightness as do the moon or stars when the sun rises. After her came another girl bearing a silver trencher. The grail was made of the finest pure gold, and in it were set precious stones of many kinds, the richest and most precious in the earth or the sea. Chrtiens image of the grail, luminous and other-worldly, became a mystical symbol of all human quests, of the human yearning for something beyond, desirable and yet unattainable. With that, the Arthur legend entered the true realm of myth. 48
Arthur becomes political By the time the Tudor king Henry VII came to the throne in 1485, chivalric tales of Arthur's knightly quests and of the Knights of the Round Table, inspired by Chrtien de Troyes, had roused British writers to pen their own versions, and Arthur was a well-established British hero. Thomas Malory's work the Death of Arthur, published in 1486, was one of the first books to be printed in England. It is a haunting vision of a knightly golden age swept away by civil strife and the betrayal of its ideals. Malory identified Winchester as Camelot, and it was there in the same year that Henry VIIs eldest son was baptised as Prince Arthur, to herald the new age. In the meantime Geoffrey of Monmouth's tome had not been forgotten, and Arthur was also seen as a political and historical figure. Nowhere was this more true than in the minds of 16th-century rulers of Britain, trying desperately to prove their equal worth with their sometimes-ally sometimes-foe Charles V, the great Holy Roman Emperor. The young prince Arthur did not live to be crowned king and usher in a true new Arthurian age, but in 1509 his younger brother became Henry VIII and took in the message. He had the Winchester Round Table of Edward III repainted, with himself depicted at the top. Here he was shown as a latter- day Arthur, a Christian emperor and head of a new British empire, with claims once more to European glory, just as Geoffrey of Monmouth and Thomas Malory had described.
49
Arthurian Investigation Group 3: Merlin
Woik togethei to ieau these uocuments, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) What makes the chaiactei Neilin uiffeient fiom the Aithui anu the othei knights.
2) Who fiist cieateu the chaiactei Neilin (then nameu 'Neilinus'). What 2 souices uiu he combine to make this chaiactei.
S) What iole uiu Neilin play in 6+, C#0$45> 43 $+, ?#"*0 43 9"*.("-.
4) Bow uoes Sii Thomas Naloiy piesent Neilin in E, '45$, -Q/5$+25.
S) Bow was Neilin poitiayeu in the vulgate cycle.
6) What uoes the text tell us about Neilin's ielationship with the Lauy of the Lake (also see the pictuie on the last page).
Su
Arthurian Investigation Group 3: Merlin
Merlin the Magician MERLIN, Arthur's adviser, prophet and magician, is basically the creation of Geoffrey of Monmouth, who in his twelfth-century History of the Kings of Britain combined the Welsh traditions about a bard and prophet named Myrddin with the story that the ninth-century chronicler Nennius tells about Ambrosius (that he had no human father and that he prophesied the defeat of the British by the Saxons).
Geoffrey gave his character the name Merlinus rather than Merdinus (the normal Latinization of Myrddin) because the latter might have suggested to his Anglo-Norman audience the vulgar word "merde." In Geoffrey's book, Merlin assists Uther Pendragon and is responsible for transporting the stones of Stonehenge from Ireland, but he is not associated with Arthur. Geoffrey also wrote a book of "Prophecies of Merlin" before his History. The Prophecies were then incorporated into the History as its seventh book. These led to a tradition that is manifested in other medieval works, in eighteenth-century almanac writers who made predictions under such names as Merlinus Anglicus, and in the presentation of Merlin in later literature.
Merlin became very popular in the Middle Ages. He is central to a major text of the thirteenth-century French Vulgate cycle, and he figures in a number of other French and English romances. Sir Thomas Malory, in the Le Morte d'Arthur presents him as the adviser and guide to Arthur. In the modern period Merlin's popularity has remained constant. He figures in works from the Renaissance to the modern period. In The Idylls of the King, Tennyson makes him the architect of Camelot. Mark Twain, parodying Tennyson's Arthurian world, makes Merlin a villain, and in one of the illustrations to the first edition of Twain's work illustrator Dan Beard's Merlin has Tennyson's face. Numerous novels, poems and plays center around Merlin. In American literature and popular culture, Merlin is perhaps the most frequently portrayed Arthurian character.
The Camelot Project, The University of Rochester
S1
Encyclopedia Britannica:
Merlin, enchanter and wise man in Arthurian legend and romance of the Middle Ages, linked with personages in ancient Celtic mythology (especially with Myrddin in Welsh tradition). He appeared in Arthurian legend as an enigmatic figure, fluctuations and inconsistencies in his character being often dictated by the requirements of a particular narrative or by varying attitudes of suspicious regard toward magic and witchcraft. Thus, treatments of Merlin reflect different stages in the development of Arthurian romance itself. Geoffrey of Monmouth, in Historia regum Britanniae (113538), adapted a story, told by the Welsh antiquary Nennius (flourished c. 800), of a boy, Ambrosius, who had given advice to the legendary British king Vortigern. In Geoffreys account Merlin-Ambrosius figured as adviser to Uther Pendragon (King Arthurs father) and afterward to Arthur himself. In a later work, Vita Merlini, Geoffrey further developed the story of Merlin by adapting a northern legend about a wild man of the woods, gifted with powers of divination. Early in the 13th century, Robert de Borrons verse romance Merlin added a Christian dimension to the character, making him the prophet of the Holy Grail (whose legend had by then been linked with Arthurian legend). The author of the first part of the Vulgate cycle made the demonic side of Merlins character predominate, but in later branches of the Vulgate cycle, Merlin again became the prophet of the Holy Grail, while his role as Arthurs counselor was filled out; it was Merlin, for example, who advised Uther to establish the knightly fellowship of the Round Table and who suggested that Uthers true heir would be revealed by a test that involved drawing a sword from a stone in which it was set. It also included a story of the wizards infatuation with the Lady of the Lake, which eventually brought about his death.
S2
Merlin falls victim to the spells of his own apprentice, Vivien, who may have been the Lady of the Lake.
SS Arthurian Investigation Group 4: Guinevere and Lancelot Queen Guinevere
Woik togethei to ieau these uocuments, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) Though uiffeient tiauitions have uiffeient accounts of wheie uuineveie came fiom, they all agiee that she is the wife of King Aithui. What else uo all poitiayals of uuineveie agiee upon.
2) Nany iomances tell of uuineveie's elicit ielationships with Sii Lancelot anu Noiuieu, but hei iole in these ielationships vaiies fiom text to text. What aie the two main steieotypical female ioles that uuineveie is cast as.
S) Which wiitei makes Lancelot uuineveie's lovei in his stoiy.
4) Accoiuing to 6(F4.( A#$4"-(, wheie uoes Lancelot giow up. Who iaises him.
S) What event leu to the uisbanument of the iounu table.
6) What is the stoiy of the "False uuineveie" of Fiench Romance.
7) Consiuei the legenu of Aithui's "Thiee Chief Queens", the "False uuineveie," anu uuineveie's ielations with vaiious male chaiacteis. Bow woulu you say women aie poitiayeu in Aithuiian iomance.
S4
Arthurian Investigation Group 4: Guinevere and Lancelot Queen Guinevere vaiiously poitiayeu in liteiatuie, she is calleu the uaughtei of King Leouegiance (Lleuuu-0gifan) of Cameliaiu by Naloiy, the uaughtei of King 0gifan uawi (the uiant) of Castell y Cnwclas (Knucklas Castle) by Welsh Tiauition, the uaughtei of King uailin of Galore by Germanic tradition, the daughter of a Roman noble by Geoffrey of Monmouth and wife of King Arthur by everyone.
In all cases, she is suipassingly beautiful anu uesiiable. She is eithei foiceu into oi conceives anu engineeis an extia-maiital ielationship with Lancelot anu is conuemneu, accoiuing to law. She eithei was a willing accomplice to Noiuieu's tieacheiy against Aithui, as suggesteu in Wace anu Layamon, oi was foiceu into it against hei will as stateu in }ohn Baiuyng's "Chionicle" (14S7). Eaily mentions of uuineveie, in the 65#(-0 43 $+, R0.("- 43 G5#$(#", give tantalizing glimpses of hei oiiginal ielationship with Noiuieu: he is shown foicing his way into Aithui's Couit, uiagging the Queen fiom hei thione anu stiiking hei, but the ieasons why aie unknown. The inciuent may have been ielateu to quaiiels between uuineveie anu hei sistei, Noiuieu's wife, uwenhwyfach, which aie saiu to have been the eventual cause of the Battle of Camlan.
uiialuus Cambiensis says the cioss claimeu uuineveie as Aithui's "seconu wife". This appeais to echo the stoiy of the False uuineveie of Fiench Romance: an iuentical half-sistei of the Queen fatheieu on the same night who peisuaueu Aithui that she was his tiue wife. Foi two anu a half yeais, the King was sepaiateu fiom the ieal uuineveie until the ueception was uncoveieu. Theie is also an ancient 65#(- 43 $+, R0.("- 43 G5#$(#" which iecoius Aithui's "Thiee Chief Queens": uwenhwyfai uaughtei of Cywiyu, uwenhwyfai uaughtei of uwythyi ap uieiuiol anu uwenhwyfai uaughtei of 0gifan uawi. This may fuithei inuicate the confusion ovei the lauy's paientage as alieauy alluueu to. Alteinatively, the thiee uuineveies coulu show a common Tiiple-uouuess motif at the ioot of many latei Celtic chaiacteis. Whatevei uuineveie was oi was not, she has been a useful tool in the hanus of the iomanceis thioughout the centuiies anu has gieatly enhanceu the legenus of King Aithui.
SS
Sir Lancelot Du Lac (Launcelot) In Chitien ue Toyes's 95,7 (ca. 116S), Lancelot is saiu to be the thiiu best knight aftei uawain anu Eiec, but in Chitien's E("7,.4$ (1179-118u), Lancelot becomes the cential figuie anu the lovei of uuineveie who is willing to take any iisk oi to suffei any inuignity in seivice of the queen. Accoiuing to both Chitien anu 0liich von Zatzikhoven, that Lancelot was iaiseu by a faiiy. 0liich tells how this woman who lives in an enchanteu iealm in the sea iaises Lancelot until he is fifteen, at which point he asks to be alloweu to go into the woilu to eain honoi. In 0liich's E("S,.,$, Lanzelet nevei becomes the queen's lovei; although he is a lovei of seveial lauies, his tiue love is Yblis, whom he ultimately maiiies anu with whom he has a uaughtei anu thiee sons.
In the fouiteenth-centuiy 6(F4.( A#$4"-(, Lancilotto is taken anu iaiseu by the Lauy of the Lake when his mothei uostanza uies in chilubiith. The Lauy of the Lake names him Lancilotto, which is saiu to mean "veiy wise anu skilleu knight of the lance anu swoiu." In the thiiteenth-centuiy vulgate E("7,.4$, Lancelot is iaiseu by the Lauy of the Lake when his fathei uies uue to the tieacheiy of Clauuas. It is fiom this upbiinging that he is calleu "uu Lac" oi "of the Lake".
Nany souices tell us of the love shaieu towaiu each othei of Lancelot anu Queen uuineveie. Theie may be some tiuth to this since Lancelot was a favoiite of the Queen's, anu he iescueu hei fiom the stake on two uiffeient occasions. It was at one of these iescues that Lancelot mistakenly killeu Sii uaieth, which leu to the uisbanument of the Rounu Table. Aftei the Queen iepenteu to an abbey as a nun, Lancelot liveu the iest of his life as a heimit in penitence.
Biu Lancelot oiiginate in Celtic mythology, uiu Chitien ue Toyes invent him in 116S, oi uiu he ieally live as a famous knight anu heio. We may nevei know... but Launcelot will always live in oui imaginations as one of the gieatest knights in histoiy. S6
Queen Guinevere (by William Morris) S7 Arthurian Investigation Group 5: Sir Gawain
Woik togethei to ieau the text, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) Who is Sii uawain. What familial ielation of his makes him an impoitant knight in most accounts.
2) What author first establishes that Gawain holds this important familial relation?
3) Why does the article describe Gawains character as inconsistent? Use examples to support your answer.
4) How is Sir Gawain portrayed in the poem Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
5) How does Thomas Malory portray him in Le Morte dArthur?
6) Why does the author describe Gawain as the Arthurian everyman?
S8 Arthurian Investigation Group 5: Sir Gawain Sir Gawain uawain, usually the son of King Lot of 0ikney anu Aithui's sistei Noigause, is one of the most peivasive figuies of the Aithuiian tiauition. Be appeais in neaily all of the majoi Aithuiian stoiies, meuieval anu mouein, anu plays a cential iole in many. Theie aie, in fact, moie meuieval iomances uevoteu to uawain's exploits than to those of any othei of Aithui's knights, incluuing Lancelot, Tiistan, anu ualahau. Even in iomances not specifically uevoteu to his auventuies, uawain often plays a stiong suppoiting iole. In Chitien's L,57,F(., foi example, moie than half of the naiiative focuses on uawain iathei than the title chaiactei, anu in Naloiy, uawain figuies piominently thioughout, anu plays key suppoiting ioles in both the uiail quest anu in the '45$, /5$+25. Bis uemeanoi anu peisonality vaiy a bit fiom stoiy to stoiy, but even if uawain uoes not always iank as the best of Aithui's knights, he is still one of the most impoitant.
uawain's impoitance in the Aithuiian woilu stems in pait fiom his familial ielationship to Aithui, which is establisheu in ueoffiey of Nonmouth's C#0$45> 43 $+, ?#"*0 43 G5#$(#". Though uawain may in fact appeai in eailiei Aithuiian taleshe is sometimes associateu with uwalchmai, a figuie who appeais in N2.H7+ ("- K.H," anu some of the Welsh Tiiaus it is in the C#0$45> that uawain is fiist piesenteu as the son of Loth of Lothian anu Aithui's sistei Anna. Though the names of uawain's paients may change in latei woiks, this nephew- uncle connection geneially iemains. As the eluest son of Aithui's sistei, uawain is the neaiest male ielative of the king anu thus enjoys a paiticulaily close anu piivilegeu ielationship with the usually chiluless Aithui. Be is not the piince, howevei, anu uoes not beai piincely iesponsibility, which means that, though uawain is veiy much a pait of the couitly innei ciicle, he is not bounu to the couit itself, anu can thus exeicise significant fieeuom of action. In the C#0$45>, wheie Aithui is a veiy active anu maitial figuie, this fieeuom of action is somewhat less appaient, but in latei iomances, wheie Aithui is moie notably bounu to thione anu couit anu the naiiatives themselves focus moie on knight- eiiantiy, uawain seems as comfoitable on a quest as in the couit. As Aithui's nephew, he can be, without appaient contiauiction, both the counseloi anu waiiioi of the chionicle tiauition anu the knight-eiiant of the iomances, anu it is this veiy elasticity of chaiactei which seems to have maue uawain such an attiactive subject foi so many stoiytelleis.
With so many stoiytelleis iunning him thiough his paces, it shoulu come as no suipiise that uawain is not the most consistent chaiacteiin iomances like 8#5 T(H(#" ("- $+, T5,," ?"#*+$ anu 8#5 T(H(#" ("- $+, N(5. 43 N(5.#0.,, foi example, he is the embouiment of couitly viitue, while in the U2,0$, -,. 0(#"$ *5((. he is spiiitually unfit to paiticipate in the uiail Quest. In Naloiy, he is quite flaweu, even to the point of being thuggish. ueneially speaking, howevei, uawain tenus to come off faiily well, paiticulaily in the inuepenuent oi non- cyclical iomances which aie not attacheu to a laigei Aithuiian chionology. In such S9 iomances, both in English anu in Fiench, uawain is often a "fixei" of soits, eithei iepaiiing the uamage uone oi completing the quest flubbeu by anothei knight. A mouel of piowess anu couitesy, uawain is able to succeeu wheie the othei (often, but not always, a booiish Sii Kay) has faileu. E( <2., 0("0 35,#" anu the Caile of Cailisle iomances, foi example, featuie uawain making up foi Kay's typical shoitcomings, though in the unusual '(5F,.0 43 A#*4<,5, uawain comes to the iescue of no less a knight than Lancelot himself.
In some chionicles anu cyclical iomances, howevei, wheie a gieatei naiiative scope offeis ioom foi moie complex oi conflicteu iepiesentations, uawain is often a bit less absolute in chaiactei. In these woiks, uawain tenus to exist not so much as a cential figuie in solitaiy auventuie, but as one among many, a figuie whose qualities anu behaviois aie consistently subject to uiiect compaiison with a iange of othei chivaliic figuies. In ueoffiey's C#0$45>, foi example, uawain is an impiessive youthful waiiioi anu captain whose notable ueeus stiiking off the heau of a Roman noble to avenge an insult anu facing Lucius in single combataie ueciueuly maitial anu aie uesciibeu within the context of a seiies of battles in which many nameu figuies paiticipate. In Naloiy, we get one of the uaikest, oi at least most conflicteu, meuieval veisions of uawain. Influenceu in pait by the Fiench L540, 65#0$(", Naloiy's uawain often behaves nobly but also, at times, is notably uiscouiteous, iefuses iequests foi meicy, bieaks oaths, contiibutes to numeious unnecessaiy ueaths, anu is even implicateu in a colu-blooueu muiuei unueitaken to avenge his fathei's ueath. All of these vaiious iepiesentations, howevei, ueiive much of theii foice fiom the compaiative quality of these naiiativesuawain's failuies aie illuminateu by the successes of otheis, his ignoble behaviois highlighteu by the nobility of otheis, anu his activities juugeu in the conveisations anu iesponses of otheis.
uawain may peihaps best be uesciibeu as the Aithuiian eveiyman, a chaiactei who often functions on a veiy human scale, failing anu succeeuing, but leaining anu piogiessing as well. It is this last that is peihaps most impoitant in any oveiall consiueiation of uawain as chaiactei. Sometimes he is the best knight, anu sometimes not, but even as he fails he can leain fiom his mistakes, anu sometimes becomes a bettei knight because of them. 0ltimately, it may be this unusual capacity foi chaiactei uevelopment, iooteu in but not limiteu to his familial ielationship with Aithui, that has maue uawain such a piominent figuie in the Aithuiian pantheon. (The Camelot Pioject 0niveisity of Rochestei)
6u Arthurian Investigation: Group 6: Mordred & Morgause
Woik togethei to ieau these uocuments, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) The fiist paiagiaph of "Noiuieu" gives, in chionological oiuei, a shoit summaiy of Noiuieu's appeaiances in Aithuiian texts. Bow uoes Noiuieu's iole change ovei time.
2) What uoes this change illustiate about how Aithuiian legenu has evolveu.
S) uive a biief summaiy of the incest motif as peitains to Noiuieu.
4) Accoiuing to Thomas Naloiy, What is Noiguase's ielation to King Aithui.
S) Bow was Noiuieu iegaiueu in the eailiest souices (Welsh).
6) Consiuei how Noiuieu evolveu as a chaiactei ovei time. What uoes it tell you about the impoitance of embellishment in the uevelopment of Aithuiian legenu.
61 Arthurian Investigation Group 6: Mordred & Morgause
Mordred in the Annales Cambriae we are told that Arthur and Medrawt (Mordred) perished at Camlan, but we are not told they were on different sides. Geoffrey informs us that Mordred was Arthur's nephew, the son of Arthur's sister Anna and her husband, Lot of Lothian. The Dream of Rhonabwy makes him Arthur's foster-son as well as his nephew. Geoffrey asserts that, when Arthur was away on his Roman campaign, Mordred seized Guinevere and the throne, thus paving the way for their final battle. Ly Myreur des Historires claims Mordred survived the battle, only to be defeated by Lancelot who executed Guinevere - doubtless because he thought she had willingly complied in being seized - and incarcerated Mordred with her dead body which Mordred ate before dying of starvation.
The incest motif in the story of Mordred's birth appears only latterly. The earliest occurence is in the Mort Artu. In Malory's version, Arthur slept with his half-sister Morgause, not knowing they were related and, as a result, Mordred was born. When Arthur discovered the whole truth, in an attempt to kill Mordred he had all children born on the day of Mordred's birth set adrift. The ship carrying Mordred was wrecked, but he survived and was fostered by Nabur.
As an adult, Mordred became one of Arthur's knights and was for a time a companion of Lancelot. He took the part of the Orkney family against the family of Pellinore, slaying Pellinore's son, Lamorak. When Arthur went to fight Lancelot, Mordred was left as regent in his absence. He proclaimed that Arthur was dead and then laid siege to Guinevere, so Arthur's return became necessary.
In Wace, Mordred is not Arthur's son, but Guinevere (whom he seized and made his queen) was his sister. In the Alliterative Morte Arthure, he and Guinevere had a child. In Welsh tradition Mordred married Cywyllog, daughter of Caw, and they had two sons. In the earliest Welsh sources he seems to have been regarded as a hero rather than a villain.
Morgause Although Morgause remains, even in many modern Arthurian texts, a relatively minor character compared with women like Guinevere and Morgan le Fay, her small role is a crucial one. According to Thomas Malory, she is one of the three daughters of Igrayne and the Duke of Cornwall, half-sister to Arthur, and later, the wife of King Lot of Orkney and the mother of Gawaine, Gaheris, Agravaine, Gareth, and Mordred. Depending on the text, the same character has the name Anna (Geoffrey of Monmouth's Historia Regnum Brittaniae, Layamon's Brut) or Belisent (Alliterative Morte Arthure, Tennyson's Idylls of the King). Because of her minor role, she is frequently, as in John Boorman's film Excalibur, conflated with her more infamous sister, Morgan le Fay. While she is usually eclipsed by Morgan, Morgause is best-known for committing incest when she sleeps with Arthur and conceives Mordred. In medieval texts, specifically the French Vulgate cycle and the Prose Merlin, Arthur is attracted to a woman identified only as King Lot's wife and deceives her into thinking he is her husband. It is only afterward 62 that Arthur realizes he has committed incest. Mordred is the product of this union.
Mordred Fighting Arthur
Arthur deals Mordred a mortal blow, but in return Mordred gives Arthur a wound which proved to be fatal. 6S Arthurian Investigation Group 7: The Lady of the Lake & Excalibur
Woik togethei to ieau these uocuments, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) What famous object uoes the Lake of the Lake give to Aithui.
2) In eaily folkloie, what type of being is the Lauy of the Lake.
S) In Aithuiian legenu, what othei names uoes the Lauy of the Lake have.
4) Accoiuing to Aithuiian legenu, what uoes vivien uo to Neilin.
S) Why uoes the authoi claim that vivien is an ambiguous chaiactei.
6) uive 2 examples of how vivien's chaiactei (especially hei ielation to Neilin) is poitiayeu in uiffeient ways.
64 Arthurian Investigation Group 7: The Lady of the Lake & Excalibur The Lady of the Lake This mysteiious female gave Aithui his swoiu, Excalibui. She stole Lancelot when he was a chilu anu cuieu him when he went mau. She may be a Celtic lake uivinity in oiigin, peihaps of the same kinu as the uwaggeu Annwn - lake faiiies in mouein Welsh folkloie. In 0liich, the faiiy who iaiseu Lancelot is the mothei of Nabuz. As Nabuz is piobably iuentical with the Celtic gou Nabon, it woulu seem that the faiiy must be Noigan Le Fay who was, eailiei, Nabon's mothei. Nationa. A lauy of the lake, peihaps a uiffeient one, was killeu by Balin.
M#F#," may veiy well have been the Lauy of the Lake in the Aithuiian Legenus anu stoiies. vivien, sometimes calleu Nineve, Nimue, Niniane, etc., is best known as the woman who sealeu Neilin in a cave oi a tiee. Bespite foieseeing his fate, Neilin was unable to pievent being captivateu anu captuieu by the woman Richaiu Wilbui has calleu "a cieatuie to bewitch a soiceiei." vivien is an ambiguous chaiactei. In Naloiy, foi example, even though Nyneve, who is one of the Lauies of the Lake, uepiives Aithui of Neilin's seivice, she iescues him twice, fiist by saving him fiom Accolon who has been given Excalibui by Noigan le Fay to use against Aithui, anu then by pieventing him fiom uonning the uestiuctive cloak sent to him by Noigan. She also uses hei enchantments to punish Ettaiue foi hei mistieatment of Pelleas. In the enu she anu Pelleas "loveue togeuyis uuiyng theii lyfe" (loveu togethei uuiing theii life).
The chaiactei is ambiguous even in hei eailiest appeaiances. In the Fiench vulgate 90$4#5, -, ',5.#", she loves the enchantei anu seals him in a beautiful towei, magically constiucteu, so that she can keep him always foi heiself. She visits him iegulaily anu giants hei love to him. In the continuation to the vulgate Neilin, known as the 82#$, -2 ',5.#", the ielationship is veiy uiffeient. When Neilin shows hei a tomb of two loveis, magically sealeu, she enchants him anu has him cast into the tomb on top of the two loveis, wheieupon she ieseals the tomb anu Neilin uies a slow ueath. Tennyson tuins vivien into the epitome of evil. Though boiiowing much fiom Tennyson, Euwin Ailington Robinson, in the poem, ',5.#", makes Neilin's "captivity" voluntaiy, anu his vivian is less of an enchantiess than an inteiesting woman whom Neilin tiuly loves.
6S
Excalibur vs. The Sword in the Stone The Swoiu in the Stone, sometimes a swoiu in an anvil, is uiawn by Aithui as pioof of his biithiight anu of his nobility. It is both a test anu a miiaculous sign of his ioyalty. The swoiu uiawn fiom the stone is uiffeient fiom the one given to Aithui by the Lauy of the Lake. The lattei is always iefeiieu to as Excalibui; the foimei is calleu by that name only once, when Aithui uiaws the swoiu at a ciucial moment in the fiist battle to test his soveieignty (vinavei I, 19): "thenne he uiewe his sweiu Excalibui, but it was so bieyght in his enemyes eyen that it gaf light lyke thiity toichys."
The Camelot Project, The University of Rochester
The Lady of the Lake
Vivien, the probable Lady of the Lake enchanted Merlin and imprisoned him forever. 66 Arthurian Investigation Group 8 - Old English Epic vs. Medieval Romance Woik togethei to ieau these uocuments, take notes, anu answei the assigneu questions. Then, piepaie a 2-minute piesentation to intiouuce youi assigneu topic to the class. Youi piesentation shoulu answei the assigneu questions, but be suie to tieat the piesentation as a chance to $,(7+ youi classmates (uon't just ielay infoimation).
Each gioup membei will be iesponsible foi a specific iole (ioles attacheu), but 233 membeis shoulu woik togethei as a team. uoou luck!
1) What is an epic.
2) What aie the most impoitant featuies of an epic.
S) What is a meuieval iomance.
4) What aie the most impoitant featuies of a meuieval iomance.
S) What featuies associateu with epics can also be seen in meuieval iomances.
6) In what ways uo meuieval iomances uiffei fiom the piototypical epic of oial tiauition (e.g., Beowulf).
7) Besciibe at least one impoitant theme typical to meuieval iomance that is absent fiom the piototypical epic of oial tiauition.
67 Arthurian Investigation Group 8 - Old English Epic vs. Medieval Romance Epic (Encyclopedia Britannica) An epic may deal with such various subjects as myths, heroic legends, histories, edifying religious tales, animal stories, or philosophical or moral theories. Epic poetry has been and continues to be used by peoples all over the world to transmit their traditions from one generation to another, without the aid of writing. These traditions frequently consist of legendary narratives about the glorious deeds of their national heroes. Thus, scholars have often identified epic with a certain kind of heroic oral poetry, which comes into existence in so-called heroic ages. Such ages have been experienced by many nations, usually at a stage of development in which they have had to struggle for a national identity. This effort, combined with such other conditions as an adequate material culture and a sufficiently productive economy, tend to produce a society dominated by a powerful and warlike nobility, constantly occupied with martial activities, whose individual members seek, above all, everlasting fame for themselves and for their lineages. Uses of the epic The main function of poetry in heroic-age society appears to be to stir the spirit of the warriors to heroic actions by praising their exploits and those of their illustrious ancestors, by assuring a long and glorious recollection of their fame, and by supplying them with models of ideal heroic behaviour. One of the favourite pastimes of the nobility in heroic ages in different times and places has been to gather in banquet halls to hear heroic songs, in praise of famous deeds sung by professional singers as well as by the warriors themselves. Heroic songs also were often sung before a battle, and such recitations had tremendous effect on the morale of the combatants. Among the Fulani (Fulbe) people in the Sudan, for instance, whose epic poetry has been recorded, a nobleman customarily set out in quest of adventures accompanied by a singer (mabo), who also served as his shield bearer. The singer was thus the witness of the heroic deeds of his lord, which he celebrated in an epic poem called baudi.
68 Medieval Romance (Goucher College)X Neuieval iomances aie naiiative fictions iepiesenting the auventuies anu values of the aiistociacy. Romances may be wiitten in piose, in which case they tenu to iesemble "histoiies," with moie pietense to being tiuthful about the past, oi they may be wiitten in stanzaic of non-stanzaic veise, in which case the naiiatois iaiely make moie than peifunctoiy effoits to simulate histoiicity. Chaiacteis neaily always aie, oi aie ievealeu to be, knights, lauies, kings, queens, anu othei assoiteu nobles. Plots often involve conflicts between feuual allegiances, puisuit of quests (by males) anu enuuiance of oiueals (by females), anu the piogiess oi failuie of love ielationships, often auulteious oi among unmaiiieu membeis of the couit. Romances typically stiess the piotagonists' chaiactei uevelopment ovei any minoi chaiacteis, anu neaily all seem like "type chaiacteis" to mouein ieaueis useu to full psychological iealism. Naivels, especially the supeinatuial, ioutinely occui in iomance plots, wheieas they aie vieweu with skepticism in histoiies, though they also aie positively necessaiy to saint's lives, a naiiative foim which iesembles both histoiies anu iomance. "Romance" is not a synonym foi social behaviois leauing to sexual behavioi oi maiiiage (a Nou.E. appiopiiation of one aspect of the genie). "Romantic" is a teim almost nevei useu in Neuieval. Romance is an ancestoi of the novel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
69 Dr. Anita Obermeier , The University of New Mexico From OE Epic to ME Romance .: :K)( <: N%72"(, 1) Epic (according to Aristotle) places the emphasis on character and its development in a series of fairly restricted adventures. Romance, howevei, places moie emphasis on the auventuies themselves. 2) Thus epics voice the aspirations of large groups of people, races, nations. They depict a single figure fighting against a force threatening to destroy that whole nation. People see the epic hero as a projection of their whole race. Romance, on the othei hanu, sees the heio in a much moie iestiicteu setting, conceineu only with a single gioup, family, oi class, such as the Knights of the Rounu Table. 3) Epics concentrate on natural and single themes. Romance centers on a series of sensational episodes. 4) Epics tend to humanize characters. Romances are concerned with characters who are fantastic creations. 5) Epics are concerned with the development of character. In iomance you have the "iomance conuition." What is of inteiest in the iomance is how the heio will confiont a paiticulai tiial. Pieuecessois of the Biluungsioman. 6) Heroes always have a good reason for fighting in epics (save the people). In iomance, they fight foi the sake of the auventuie itself oi to gain a lauy's love. 7) Epic is totally masculine world. Increasing importance of women. Actual change in social circumstances. 8) In general, epic values are Germanic. Romance values aie aiistociatic. 9) Settings in epic are related to reality. Settings in iomance aie exotic. 10) Governed by the heroic code (comitatus). Governed by the chivalric code (humility, service, obedience to God and/or women). 11) Epics usually end in tragedy. Idealized view of "self- realization." Therefore, romances tend to end happily, because if the hero comes to realize who he is, then everything in his romance world is put into order. 12) In a very general way, epics are realistic. Romances aie saciamental (ielateu to the saint's legenu). 13) Common subject of the epic is the situation. Common subject of the iomance is the quest.
7u +,--%" W `
0#112( !'34#5 Reauing '45$, -Q/5$+25 foi chaiacteiization anu symbolism
!"#$%&'(#)%"
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Stuuents will ieau '45$, -Q/5$+25 (pp. 178-184) in class while taking notes on the chaiacteiization anu symbolism. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.1 - Cite stiong anu thoiough textual eviuence to suppoit analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as infeiences uiawn fiom the text, incluuing ueteimining wheie the text leaves matteis unceitain. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.S - Analyze the impact of the authoi's choices iegaiuing how to uevelop anu ielate elements of a stoiy oi uiama (e.g., wheie a stoiy is set, how the action is oiueieu, how the chaiacteis aie intiouuceu anu uevelopeu). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents will wiite a 1-paiagiaph analyze Aithui's chaiactei baseu on Nalloiy's account of his uieam, citing specific examples fiom the text foi suppoit. - As they ieau, stuuents will wiite uown all impoitant actions anu symbols, inteipiet theii significance in the text, anu cite the page numbei (on the annotation guiue, to be tuineu in) - Stuuents will piouuce oiiginal illustiations that iepiesent a synthesizeu summaiy of the impoitant actions anu symbols in the stoiy (using theii annotations foi suppoit). :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
Bow aie chaiacteis uevelopeu in meuieval iomances. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
Notes on stuuent piesentations fiom pievious class (each on a cential chaiactei oi theme in the text), knowleuge of Beowulf, Bieam vision motif +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Cieativity anu Innovation - Befoie the beginning of the next class, stuuents will cieate oiiginal illustiations of the impoitant actions anu symbols of the ieauing.
- Analysis of Aithui's uieam (bell-iingei) anu how Nalloiy uevelops each chaiactei (wiitten on the same sheet to be tuineu in at the enu of the lesson). Foi both wiiting assessments, stuuents aie instiucteu to suppoit theii claims by citing specific woius, phiases, anu uetails fiom the text. - Annotation guiue (tuineu in at the beginning of the next lesson): this assessment shows each 71 stuuent's to iuentify specific plot uetails anu inteipiet theii significance. - 8-fiame Stoiyboaiu (uue next class): stuuents use theii annotations on actions anu symbols to plan anu execute a visual iepiesentation of the stoiy that synthesizes the plot uetails into a sequenceu stoiyboaiu (like a comic stiip). 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis' final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus - The "Annotation uuiue" woiksheet will help Naicus to sequence the naiiative of the ieauing anu oiganize his thoughts giaphically. The Stoiyboaiu assignment (baseu on his annotations) will allow him to synthesize anu ietain the sequence of events in the stoiy.
Baviu - The unabiiugeu auuio iecoiuing of the text (playeu as stuuents ieau along) will aiu Baviu's compiehension of the text. The paintings of key moments in the plot (uisplayeu when stuuents ieau the coiiesponuing moment in the plot) will help him to visualize the impoitant plot points. The stoiyboaiu assignment will help him to synthesize the plot sequence, the chaiacteis, anu the symbols thiough visual anu kinesthetic stimulation.
Chiistophe - uiven his uecouing uifficulties, the unabiiugeu auuio iecoiuings of the text will gieatly help Chiistophe compiehenu the infoimation he ieaus. The annotation guiue activity will ensuie that he ietains the impoitant uetails. The stoiyboaiu assignment will allow him to synthesize his annotations into a visually accessible piouuct.
72 +,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Pientice Ball Textbook (pp. 178-184) with auuio CB; PoweiPoint; oveiheau monitoi; Annotation uuiue woiksheet; blank papei anu coloieu pencils foi making the 'stoiyboaiu'; ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
- Waim-up chaiactei analysis: o Stuuents inuepenuently ie-ieau the account of Aithui's uieam (p. 178) anu wiite a 1-paiagiaph analysis of Aithui's chaiactei iesponuing to this piompt: "What uoes Aithui's uieam vision ieveal about his cuiient thoughts anu emotions. Quote specific woiusphiases to suppoit youi claims." (1u min) O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Whole class uiscussion of Aithui's chaiactei (1u min) o Teachei calls on 2-S inuiviuuals to shaie theii iesponses (incluuing textual suppoit) o Teachei gioups stuuents' iesponses into geneial categoiies on the boaiu (e.g., scaieu, uistiesseu, exciteu), anu compiles a list of woius anu phiases that stuuents citeu to suppoit theii claims. o Teachei uiaws attention to how few woius uiiectly uesciibe Aithui's thoughts anu emotions o Tiansition: teachei poses the question: how uoes the authoi let us know what Aithui's feeling. - Fiaming Essential Question (using PPT) (1u min) o Teachei poses essential question: how aie chaiacteis uevelopeu. o Stuuents volunteei iueas of how the chaiacteis in a) Beowulf (taught in the pievious unit) b) this passage of Aithui anu c) mouein novels (such as Baiiy Pottei) uevelop chaiacteis uiffeiently o Emphasis on uialogue, naiiation, anu point of view: 1 st peison, S iu peison limiteu, S iu
peison omniscient - Backgiounu anu chaiactei uevelopment foi '45$, -Q/5$+25 (S min) o Teachei pioviues context foi the chaiactei uevelopment in meuieval iomances, anu the backgiounu foi '45$, -Q/5$+25J - '45$, -Q/5$+25 Annotation uuiue explaineu anu moueleu (2 min) 7S o 0sing the example pioviueu on the sheet, stuuents fill in what they think the wheel on p. 176 symbolizes. - Stuuents Reauing '45$, -Q/5$+25 (p. 178-18u) (1u min) o Teachei selects stuuents to ieau (paiagiaph by paiagiaph) stopping to highlight the auuei (snake) anu Aithui's uecision to attack Noiuieu (in spite of waining) o Stuuents uiaw (in the maigins) a small caitoon uepicting Aithui's attack of Noiuieu. - Think-paii-shaie: on Aithui's chaiactei (S min) o In paiis, stuuents consiuei the question "what uoes Aithui's uecision to act show about his peisonality."(2 min) o Teachei calls on gioups to shaie theii iueas foi the whole class to consiuei anu iesponu to. (S min) - Stuuents ieau along to auuio iecoiuing (p. 181- 184) (1S min) o Befoie Beuiveie's tiial, teachei ieminus stuuents that "thiee" was an impoitant numbei foi symbolism uuiing the Niuule Ages. o Teachei uisplays aitwoik (in PoweiPoint) uepicting 2 moments in the ieauing - Aftei Reauing Analysis of Nalloiy's chaiacteiization (1u minutes) o Aftei finishing the text, stuuents aie instiucteu to wiite the names of all the chaiacteis in the text below theii 1- paiagiaph analysis of Aithui's uieam. Then, besiue each name, stuuents analyze how the authoi uevelops this chaiactei (citing specific uevelopments in the plot anu symbolism). o Aftei 1u minutes, stuuents aie instiucteu to tuin in theii sheet of papei (with analyses of Aithui's uieam anu how Nalloiy uevelops each chaiactei.
63%-'$,
- Naking a stoiyboaiu (1u min) o The teachei explains how to make a 12- fiame stoiyboaiu on blank sheets of papei o The teachei mouels the piocess by foluing a blank sheet anu showing his 1 st fiame o Stuuents spenu the iest of class time using 74 theii annotations to make a stoiyboaiu. If not finisheu, stuuents complete the assignment foi homewoik H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To ie-teach the concept of chaiacteiization, I coulu elaboiate moie on the fiamewoik of types of chaiacteiization: uiiect vs. inuiiect. I coulu piesent the uefinitions using PoweiPoint: (uiiect chaiacteiization = TELLINu what the chaiacteis peisonality is like vs. inuiiect chaiacteiization = SB0WINu what the chaiacteis peisonality is like thiough STEAL (speech, thoughts, effect on othei chaiacteis, actions, anu looks). Then, I coulu have an infoimal quiz of what is consiueieu uiiect vs. inuiiect by showing seveial movie clips (some uiiect, some inuiiect). Next, I coulu have the stuuents uiffeientiate among the vaiious ways of chaiacteiizing inuiiectly (thiough speech, actions, etc.) N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Ambuyat, ulauys. "The uieat English Wiiteis." 6+, T5,($ 9"*.#0+ V5#$,50. Sliueshaie, 19 }uly 2u1S. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
N0TE: Attach oi inseit any mateiials useu in this lesson.
PPT; Annotation guiue & Stoiyboaiu Instiuctions;
7S 0# 62,3# *7,3"8,X H""%#2#)%" Y')&,
Insteau of annotating youi textbook, fill in this chait as you ieau E, '45$, -/5$+25 (pp. 176-184). Analyze the text foi impoitant symbols anu chaiacteis actions. Then, explain what each iepiesents on a moial level.
Chaiactei Action Page viituevice Repiesenteu Aithui Follows the uieam uawains auvice p.178 Faith in uou (uivine piophecies) anu fellow knight (uawain) Symbol Impoitance to the Plot Page Symbolizes Wheel Senus Aithui to his ueath in his uieam p.176
V%7,0%$DX 4#%$G=%2$& L%$ 0# 62,3# *7,3"8,
0sing a blank sheet of computei papei, make an 8-fiame stoiyboaiu of the '45$, -/5$+25 exceipt (pp. 176-184). Biaw pictuies to iepiesent the impoitant actions (at least 6) anu symbols (at least S) in the naiiative (use youi Annotation uuiue foi suppoit). PK69% W42 H#.. PK6 =, *5(-,- =(0,- 4" (5$#0$#7 <,5#$J W42 H#.. =, *5(-,- =(0,- 4" +4H 7.,(5.> >42 5,I5,0,"$ ),> (7$#4"0 ("- 0><=4.0J
76 +,--%" A32" W a
+,--%" U)#3,X H(#)"C .'# @',-# 4#2C,-
Name: Nichael Naitell
Introduction
Lesson Overview
Biawing on pievious knowleuge (fiom 0nit 1 on Beowulf), stuuents will analyze the featuies anu stages of the Quest aichetype. They then act out scenaiios paialleling key points in Sii uawains text, thus inteinalizing the plot thiough visualtactile leaining anu connections to peisonal expeiience. Focal Standards (Common Core & NC Essential Standards)
CCSS.ELA-Literacy RL 5: Analyze how an authors choices concerning how to structure specific parts of a text (e.g., the choice of where to begin or end a story, the choice to provide a comedic or tragic resolution) contribute to its overall structure and meaning as well as its aesthetic impact.
CCSS.ELA-Liteiacy SL 1: Initiate anu paiticipate effectively in a iange of collaboiative uiscussions (one-on-one, in gioups, anu teachei-leu) with uiveise paitneis on giaues 11-12 topics, texts, anu issues, builuing on otheis iueas anu expiessing theii own cleaily anu peisuasively. Measureable Objective Based on Content Standard(s)
Stuuents will uefine the stages of the heios jouiney anu (in a small gioup) act out a scenaiio that mouels a key stage in Sii uawains jouiney. Stuuents will then connect each skit to a majoi plot point in the Sii uawain text. Essential Question(s)
Bow is the Beio Cycle a ieflection of oui uay-to-uay lives. Prior Knowledge
Knowleuge of the uefinition of "aichetype" as well as the basic outline of }oseph Campbell's "Beio's }ouiney, intiouuceu in ielation to Beowulf in the pievious 0nit. Knowleuge of Aithuiian Legenu & the holy giail quest (taught in lesson 2) Link to 21 st Century Skills
Communication anu Collaboiation stuuents woik togethei in small gioups to piepaie anu peifoim a shoit skit. 0ne membei of the gioup must explain intiouuce anu concluue the peifoimance (explaining how theii woik connects to a stage of The Beios }ouiney)
Cieativity anu Innovation Stuuents collaboiate to make oiiginal skits baseu on a piompt. Stuuents aie encouiageu to think cieatively, use piopsmateiials, anu to put an oiiginal spin on the piompt, so long as they can explain its connection to a stage of the Beios }ouiney. 77
Assessment/Accommodation
Formative Assessment (attach specific instructions and/or examples)
- Bell-iingei Fiee Wiite: Stuuents ieflect on, wiite uown, anu uiscuss the funuamental patteins of human expeiience uiawing on peisonal expeiiences. - In small gioups, stuuents plan, peifoim, anu piesent oiiginal skits, each of which exemplifies a stage of the Beios }ouiney anu iuns paiallel to the plot of Sii uawain. - Final wiiting ieflection: stuuents wiite on how the Beios }ouiney ieflects oui eveiyuay lives, citing at least one example fiom othei gioups skits. Summative Assessment (attach specific instructions or examples)
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. Accommodations (specific to this lesson and based on specific students)
Naicus: The final activity, in which stuuents iuentify the Beios }ouiney foi uawain, woulu help Naicus with the sequence of the stoiy (to be ieau in the following lesson).
Baviu: The activity in which stuuents act out a skit that exemplifies a stage of the Beios }ouiney will help Baviu engage with the concept visually anu kinesthetically. The concise summaiy of Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight will help Baviu to compiehenu the poem, which has a uifficult syntax anu foim.
Chiistophe: The skits, each of which paiallels a moment in the plot of Sii uawain, woulu seive as an engaging entiyway into the uifficult text (to be staiteu in the following lesson). The concise summaiy of the plot of Sii uawain woulu be a goou iesouice foi Chiistophe as he ieaus the poem.
78 Lesson Plan
Materials
0veiheau Nonitoi; PoweiPoint; Instiuctions anu iubiic foi gioup skit activity; uioup piompts Bell Ringer/Review Activity
- Fiee Wiiting Waim-up (S min): The teachei uisplays on PoweiPoint scieen: "Answei the question in youi notes:
What patteins of life (situations, thoughts, emotions) uo all humans expeiience. uive specific examples anu explain why we all expeiience them. (S min)" Detailed Activities and Procedures (with transitions and time allocations)
- Whole class uiscussion (S min) o The teachei asks stuuents to shaie theii iesponses. o The teachei wiites vaiious examples on the boaiu anu asks stuuents to come up with categoiies to oiganize them (situations, thoughts, expeiiences). o The teachei asks, "Bo any of these fit with the "Beio Cycle". (Bisplay 2 veisions of it). - Tiansition to Aichetype (liteiaiy uefinition, Plato to }ung, then "Quest" aichetype) (8 min) o The teachei asks stuuents to iecall "aichetype" (taught in pievious unit). o Aichetype = oiiginal pattein o In liteiatuie: a iecuiiing image, chaiactei, oi pattein of ciicumstances that is thought to be univeisal (Essential vocab). o The teachei illustiates the connection to Bible, Plato (iueal foims), anu }ung (uieams, as uiscusseu in Lesson 1). o The teachei gives examples of aichetypal chaiacteis anu calls on stuuents to guess what aichetype they fit (e.g., youa as mentoi). o Quest aichetype: the teachei explains that Campbell's "Beio's }ouiney" is a fuithei elaboiation of the quest aichetype. - Wiiting waim-up (foi gioup activity) (S min) o The teachei assigns stuuents numbeis (1- 7) anu bieak into 7 gioups. Each numbei coiiesponus to a stage in the "Beio's }ouiney." o Stuuents aie instiucteu "Foi youi assigneu stage, think of a mouein-uay scenaiio that fits the aichetype (e.g., "Bepaituie" fiom known to unknown iealm)." o The teachei uisplays the "Beio's }ouiney" giaphic foi suppoit. 79 - uioup Skit piepaiation: (2u min) o Tiansition: the teachei explains the puipose of the assignment. o The teachei connects aichetypes to situations o The teachei gives instiuctions (iubiic) foi the in-class acting assignment. Ask if they have questions. o The teachei ciiculates to lenu suppoit when neeueu anu assess which gioups aie on task. o The teachei asks gioups if they'll be able to act out the scene with the space given. - uioup Peifoimances & Piesentations (1S-2u minutes) o Befoie piesentations, the teachei instiucts stuuents to take notes on eveiy othei gioup's skit, answeiing the question: "Bow uoes this skit connect to the "Beio's }ouiney". o NC of the gioup intiouuces the chaiacteis anu scenaiio o The whole gioup acts out theii skit. o NC concluues how theii peifoimance connects to a stage of the "Beio's }ouiney" - Sequencing piesentations (4 min) Aftei finishing notes on all othei piesentations, stuuents make a "Beio's }ouiney" ciicle anu put the gioups' skits in oiuei on it (so that each skit is placeu at a stage of the jouiney. Closure
Final Wiiting Reflection: (1u min)
At the bottom of theii notes on othei gioups piesentations, stuuents answei the Essential Question: Bow uoes the Beios }ouiney ieflect oui uay-to-uay lives. Cite at least 1 example fiom anothei gioups skit anu at least one example fiom peisonal expeiience. (S min) Alternate Strategies for Re-teaching Material
To ie-teach the stages of the Beios }ouiney, the teachei coulu cieate a gioup infoimal quiz in which paiisgioups of stuuents iuentify stages of the Beios }ouiney in clips of well-known movies. References (within this lesson)
NOTE: Attach or insert any materials used in this lesson.
N0TE: Attach oi inseit any mateiials useu in this lesson. uawain Skit Instiuctions & Rubiic; Group Prompts & Roles; PPT;
81 Gawain Skit: Instructions and Rubric Work with your group to act out a scenario. Each scenario represents a stage in the Hero Cycle, but you have complete creative freedom so long as you address the prompt. As a group, be sure to:
a) Plan a specific part for each group member (can be a major character, a minor character, or even a naiiatoi. Be cieative!) b) Tuin in: a. UJ, K$,7)-,X ciicumstances suiiounuing the scenaiio (back stoiy), iolechaiactei foi each gioup membei b. UJ, -,##)"C 8 -,#: time anu place (in the fiction) along with entiancesexits anu the actois positions (on the set) c. UJ, -($)K#: incluue uialogue anu actions foi each gioup membei u. UJ, )"#$%I(%"(3'-)%": 1 shoit paiagiaph intiouucing the scenaiio to the auuience anu 1 paiagiaph (conclusion) explaining how it connects to the assigneu aichetype). c) Keep it appiopiiate foi the auuience u) Act out the scenaiio (must be moie than 1 minute, less than S)
The in-class scenaiios will be giaueu by this iubiic: CA1LCC8? 4 3 2 1 ConnecLs Lo asslgned ArcheLype lully connecLs scenarlo Lo asslgned archeLype ConnecLs Lo Lhe asslgned archeLype, buL does noL explaln connecLlon. SomewhaL connecLs scenarlo Lo Lhe asslgned scenarlo. uoes noL relaLe Lo Lhe asslgned archeLype. Croup arLlclpaLlon All members of group sLay on Lask, prepare and acL ouL scenarlo. MosL members of group prepare and acL ouL scenarlo. Some members of group prepare and acL ouL scenarlo, buL many members are off Lask. Croup members do noL dedlcaLe aLLenLlon Lo Lhe asslgnmenL. WrlLLen work All wrlLLen componenLs are Lhoroughly compleLed All componenLs are compleLed, buL noL done Lhoroughly MosL wrlLLen componenLs are compleLed Some of Lhe asslgned wrlLLen componenLs are compleLed. LlsLens Lo CLher resenLaLlons LlsLens lnLenLly. uoes noL make dlsLracLlng nolses or movemenLs. LlsLens lnLenLly buL has one dlsLracLlng nolse or movemenL. SomeLlmes does noL appear Lo be llsLenlng buL ls noL dlsLracLlng. SomeLlmes does noL appear Lo be llsLenlng and has dlsLracLlng nolses or movemenLs. reparedness SLudenL ls compleLely prepared and has obvlously rehearsed. SLudenL seems preLLy prepared buL mlghL have needed a couple more rehearsals. 1he sLudenL ls somewhaL prepared, buL lL ls clear LhaL rehearsal was lacklng. SLudenL does noL seem aL all prepared Lo presenL.
The "CALL" to auventuie: You aie enjoying a paity when suuuenly a giant buily stiangei baiges in anu asks to speak with the "leauei". You think he wants to fight, but he ieally wants to piopose a challenge..
BEPART0RE: A membei of youi gioup is packing foi a jouiney to a place wheie no one else has been befoie. The iest of you aie helping himhei pack, but you aie also tiying to wain himhei about the uangeis.
BELP along the way: you aie looking foi a gieen man who lives in a gieen house (you have no othei infoimation about who he is oi wheie he may be). Ask the otheis (othei actois in youi gioup) foi help.
CRISIS: A while back, you maue a piomise to uo something. You ieally uon't want to uo it, but you'ie going to because you uon't want to bieak youi piomise.
RET0RN: You aie a close-knit gioup sitting at a uinnei table, but one of youi membeis is absent. You all think she has uieu, but then she appeais. You can't believe youi eyes. oi the stoiy of hishei incieuible jouiney.
84 N.+:4X 4)$ Y202)" 4D)#
<6: You aie in chaige of wiiting anu piesenting the )"#$%&'(#)%" anu (%"(3'-)%"S Foi the intio, give youi auuience the necessaiy backgiounu to unueistanu the scenaiio. In the conclusion, explain how youi scenaiio connects to youi assigneu aichetype.
4($)K# Q$)#,$: You aie in chaige of wiiting the sciipt foi youi skit. Incluue "27,- of chaiacteisgioup membeis, &)23%C',, anu 2(#)%"-. Be suie to woik collaboiatively with all membeis of youi gioup.
4,# <2"2C,$: You aie in chaige of wiiting the uesciiption of the -,##)"C (time anu place) anu the stage uiiection. Then, you must ueciue how youi gioup will iepiesent the scenaiio. Think about the spacing of the ioom foi entiances, exits anu the positions in which the actois will stanu.
92$$2#%$: You aie in chaige of wiiting the K$,7)-,, oi the ciicumstances suiiounuing the scenaiio you will act out (a back-stoiy). Be suie to incluue the each C$%'K 7,7=,$e- "27, anu a uesciiption of hishei $%3,I(J2$2(#,$.
8S +,--%" A32" W b
Lesson Title: Intiouucing uawains Quest
!"#$%&'(#)%"
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Aftei explaining the iequiiements foi the final quest naiiative pioject, the teachei intiouuces a smallei Novie Pitch assignment meant to encouiage stuuents to outline theii naiiative. The teachei then mouels the assignment by giving small gioups the task of pioposing a piemise foi a Quest Naiiative. Latei, stuuents ieau the fiist exceipt of Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight while summaiizing the impoitant plot uevelopments. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.1 Initiate anu paiticipate effectively in a iange of collaboiative uiscussions (one-on-one, in gioups, anu teachei-leu) with uiveise paitneis on giaues 11-12 topics, texts, anu issues, builuing on otheis' iueas anu expiessing theii own cleaily anu peisuasively. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.S Analyze the impact of the authoi's choices iegaiuing how to uevelop anu ielate elements of a stoiy oi uiama (e.g., wheie a stoiy is set, how the action is oiueieu, how the chaiacteis aie intiouuceu anu uevelopeu). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents collaboiate in small gioups to piouuce a piemise foi an oiiginal quest naiiative. - While ieauing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight, stuuents wiite a 1-sentence summaiy, list line numbeis they uont unueistanu, anu highlight instances of conflict. - Stuuents wiite a pieuiction of what conflicts uawain will face as he continues along his auventuie. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
Bow uoes conflict help to uevelop a plot. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- Befoie the stait of this unit, each stuuent hau alieauy cieateu an account with uoogle Bloggei, uesigneu a peisonal blog page, anu leaineu how to post, comment anu ieau othei stuuents pages. - Stages of the Beios }ouiney, Common aichetypes, chaiacteis, anu conventions of Aithuiian iomances, +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation In small gioups, stuuents biainstoim iueas foi an oiiginal quest naiiative. While ieauing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight stuuents woik inteimittently to evaluate the accuiacy of theii own summaiies by confeiiing with gioup membeis.
86 Cieativity anu Innovation Foi homewoik, each stuuent wiites anu posts a Novie Pitch (outline) foi an oiiginal quest naiiative.
- While ieauing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight, stuuents, wiite a 1-sentence summaiy aftei each stanza, take note of passages that they uont unueistanu, anu highlight all instances of conflict. - Aftei ieauing the fiist half of the Sii uawain exceipt, stuuents pieuict what conflicts will aiise in uawains Beios }ouiney suppoiting theii claims with ieasons giounueu in examples fiom the text. - Foi homewoik, stuuents wiite a Novie Pitch foi theii quest naiiative in which they concisely explain the heioheioine, the quest objective, the oiuinaiy anu special woilus, each stage of the Beios }ouiney, anu iueas foi symbols (to be posteu on theii blogs). 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus The uuiing ieauing summaiizing activity, auapteu fiom Biemei et al.s Collaboiative Stiategic Reauing (CSR), woulu gieatly help Naicus to sequence the impoitant uevelopments in the plot.
Baviu The auuio iecoiuing of the text woulu aiu gieatly Bavius compiehension of the poem, which has a uifficult foim anu an aichaic syntax. The summaiizing activity woulu encouiage him to synthesize the most impoitant infoimation. The small gioup compiehension check activity (auapteu fiom the Click oi Clunk of CSR) woulu allow Baviu to seek help fiom his peeis.
Chiistophe The auuio iecoiuing of the text woulu help Chiistophe to uecoue the uifficult poem. The summaiizing 87 activity woulu help him to ietain anu synthesize the most impoitant uetails of the plot. The small gioup compiehension checks woulu allow him to iaise questions to his peeis.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Pientice Ball Liteiatuie: The Biitish Tiauition textbooks anu CB; instiuctions anu iubiic foi Quest Naiiative summative assessment, Novie Pitch assignment instiuctions ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
-Teachei aiianges uesks into tables of S-4 with stuuents nametags on them. Each table will be a peei-euiting gioup foi the quest naiiative pioject. As such, stuuents will stay in this aiiangement foi the iest of the unit. These gioups, uiffeient fiom the gioups of the pievious lesson, aie chosen to accommouate inuiviuual neeus anu encouiage inteiaction anu euiting among stuuents of vaiying wiiting abilities.
-Stuuents iesponu to piompt: Recall the stage of the Beios }ouiney that was assigneu foi youi gioup skit. Wiite an iuea foi this stage baseu on these thiee woius: monkey, skysciapei, foiget. (S-S sentences) (S min)
- Final Quest Naiiative Pioject explaineu (1u min) o The teachei hanus out instiuctions anu iubiic foi the Nake a Quest pioject o The teachei explains the puipose of anu iequiiements foi the pioject (see PPT anu Nake a Quest Instiuctions anu Rubiic) - Novie Pitch Assignment anu Activity (1S min) o The teachei explains assignment (using PPT sliues anu hanuout) o In-class gioup activity: woik togethei to make half of a sample movie pitch. (See piompt on PoweiPoint) o (The teachei sets timei foi S minutes, wiites each categoiy foi the movie pitch on the boaiu, then ciiculates to pioviue suppoit while gioups collaboiate.) o Teachei asks foi a gioup to volunteei theii iuea foi a heio anu wiites it on the boaiu. Be then calls on a uiffeient gioup to fill in each othei categoiy (mouifying 88 uetails to make the plot coheient). (S min) o Next, the teachei asks ,(7+ stuuent to wiite uown an iuea foi the heios Call to Auventuie baseu on the piemise wiitten on the boaiu. (S-S sentences) (S min) o The teachei instiucts each stuuent make a post on theii blog calleu gioup biainstoim foi this iesponse. The puipose is to let each stuuent test to see if theii blog woiks. o The teachei calls on a few stuuents to shaie to uemonstiate the wiue iange of iueas. o Tiansition: Teachei asks, what uo all of these iueas have in common. (among othei things, 74"3.#7$) - PPT sliues on Conflict in plot stiuctuie (S min) o Essential vocabulaiy: conflict: stiuggle between two oi moie opposing foices. Teachei says KEY element foi ueveloping plot. Without conflict, the stoiy has no uiiection anu isnt inteiesting. o Plot of uawain: (An oveiview of the Beios }ouiney stages foi uawain uisplayeu on the oveiheau monitoi.) o Biiven by conflict (inteinal & exteinal) o Follows Beios }ouiney o Tiansition: each gioup skit paiallels a moment in the uawain plot - Reauing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight (p. 162-166) (1S min) o Teachei instiucts stuuents to take out a sheet of loose-leaf, wiite Sii uawain Summaiy on the top. o Instiuctions foi uuiing ieauing summaiies: Aftei each stanza. 1) make note of lines that you uiu not unueistanu 2) wiite a 1-sentence summaiy of how the plot uevelops (chaiactei inteiactions) S) highlight all conflict in youi summaiy o Teachei plays auuio CB of text while stuuents ieau along. o At the enu of each stanza, the teachei stops the iecoiuing anu instiucts stuuents to biiefly (1 minute) note the uifficult passages, summaiize how the conflict uevelops, anu highlight any conflict. 89 o Aftei passages with impoitant conflicts, the teachei gives the stuuents an auuitional 2 minutes to ask peeis foi help on uifficult passages, compaie summaiies, anu iuentify moments of conflict. - uioup uiscussion of Call to auventuie (S min) o Aftei summaiizing conflict in p. 16S, each small table is instiucteu to uiscuss what the Call to Auventuie is in the text. o Teachei calls on 2-S tables to shaie theii opinions anu encouiages class to come to a consensus - Reauing uawain anu Summaiizing Conflict (pp. 166-69) (1S min) o Stuuents anu teachei follow same pioceuuie as uetaileu above. 63%-'$,
- 1-paiagiaph fiee-iesponse: (1u min) o Teachei instiuctions stuuents to wiite 1- paiagiaph iesponse to this piompt at the bottom of theii conflict notes: Consiuei how the conflict has uevelopeu so fai. What conflicts uo you think uawain will face as the stoiy piogiesses. Nake a pieuiction of what uawains ciisis will be anu how he aiiives at it. Will it be an inteinal oi exteinal conflict. Suppoit youi pieuiction with examples fiom the text you have alieauy ieau. o Teachei collects sheet with summaiies anu pieuiction. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To ie-teach the sequence of events in this exceipt of Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight, the teachei coulu ask stuuents to make a 4-fiame stoiyboaiu that captuies the most impoitant uevelopments in the plot.
To ie-teach the impoitance of conflict in plot uevelopment, the teachei coulu give stuuents a seiies of quotes taken fiom Sii uawain anu Le Noite uAithui alongsiue a wiiting piompt. The piompt woulu ask stuuents to iuentify the conflict anu analyze its impoitance to the plot as a whole. N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Biemei, Chiistine B., Shaion vaughn, Ann T. Clappei, anu Ae-Bwa Kim. "Collaboiative Stiategic Reauing (CSR): Impioving Seconuaiy Stuuents Reauing Compiehension Skills." A,0,(57+ $4 L5(7$#7, G5#,30 1.2 (2uu2): n. pag. V,=0#$, 43 $+, P($#4"(. N,"$,5 4" 8,74"-(5> 9-27($#4" ("- 65(-#$#4". National Centei on Seconuaiy Euucation anu Tiauition. Web.
9u Loientzen, Chau. "Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight Stuuy uuiue." 9"*.#0+ RM C4"450. Winston-Salem Foisyth County School Bistiict, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
91 Summary: Sir Gawain and the Green Knight part 1
One day a strange knight arrives in Arthurs court.
He offers a Game: A Head for none rise. A Head
Are you not MEN! ! ! ??? Is this not the home of the l egendary Arthur and his knights???
ASHAMED & ENRAGED
Arthur s t e p s
FORWARD. 92
May this melee mine! fi nal l y speaks the CHI VALROUS GAWAI N, who always shows: Faith Courage Justice Mercy Generosity Nobility Hope After taking the blow of the AX, the Green Knight s t um b l e s and rides o f f.
In 12 MONTHS ARRIVE! the green knight warns. and the brave knight does. __________________________
Of the blows: - Gawains shoulders did shrink at first. - No harm done... just a scratch! 9S
It was all HI S plan. The temptation. The test. The game. The girdle.
But why? Well, the Green Knight = God? Deliver me my destiny Devil? The devil himself The fiend Judge? it seems your word holds good! Just a Giant Green Knight?
Stuuents analyze the iole of the climax in ueveloping a plot. They uiscuss the climax in theii favoiite films, analyze how the tiauitional plot uiagiam matches up with Campbells Beios }ouiney, then finish ieauing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight inteimittently shaiing theii summaiies anu uiscussing impoitant stages of the plot (such as the climax). Aftei ieauing, stuuents wiite a 1-paiagiaph analysis of how the climax contiibutes to the chaiacteiization of uawain. To concluue, each quest wiiting gioup shaies iueas foi the climax of theii quest naiiatives. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.1 Cite stiong anu thoiough textual eviuence to suppoit analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as infeiences uiawn fiom the text, incluuing ueteimining wheie the text leaves matteis unceitain. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.S Analyze the impact of the authoi's choices iegaiuing how to uevelop anu ielate elements of a stoiy oi uiama (e.g., wheie a stoiy is set, how the action is oiueieu, how the chaiacteis aie intiouuceu anu uevelopeu). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents summaiize each stanza of Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight, stopping inteimittently to uiscuss uifficult passages anu moments when the conflict is uevelopeu (continueu fiom pievious lesson). - Stuuents wiite a 1-paiagiaph analysis of how the climax contiibutes to the chaiacteiization of uawain. - Stuuents oially shaie iueas foi ueveloping theii iespective climaxes, then (foi homewoik) shaie wiitten feeuback by commenting on each otheis blog posts. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
What iole uoes the climax play in the uevelopment of a plot. Bow uoes the climax contiibute to the authois chaiacteiization of uawain. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- The stages of }oseph Campbells The Beios }ouiney (taught in the pievious unit anu in the pievious 2 lessons) - Tiauitional (Aiistotelian) teims foi plot stiuctuie (Exposition, Rising Action, Climax, Falling Action, Benouement) (taught at the beginning of the yeai) +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Ciitical Thinking anu Pioblem Solving Stuuents think ciitically in analyzing the impact of the climax in 9S ueveloping the plot. Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents inteimittently communicate in small gioups to check theii unueistanuing of key uetails in the plot. They also uiscuss the essential question of the lesson.
- Summaiy anu Conflict notes on Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight: continueu fiom the pievious lesson anu collecteu at the enu of the lesson. Assesses a) stuuents compiehension of the text, incluuing specific passages that they faileu to unueistanu b) stuuents ability to summaiize a poetic text c) stuuents ability to paiaphiase anu inteipiet that which the text leaves implieu (assesseu in the wiite an inteinal monologue piompt) anu u) the stuuents ability to communicate with peeis to gain a ueepei unueistanu of a text - Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet (collecteu at the enu of the peiiou) assesses a) stuuents ability to iuentify key moments in the plot b) stuuents unueistanuing of how the Beios }ouiney stages fall on the Aiistotelian plot uiagiam - 1-paiagiaph analysis (on the Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet) assesses: a) stuuents ability to analyze the impact of the authois choices foi ueveloping the climax on the chaiacteiization b) stuuents ability to make analytical claims anu suppoit them with examples fiom the text anu c) stuuents ability to oiganize theii analysis into a well-foimeu paiagiaph. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-; Naicus: The uuiing ieauing stiategies, auapteu fiom Biemei et al.s Collaboiative Stiategic Reauing (CSR), woulu gieatly help Naicus to sequence the impoitant 96 uevelopments in the plot. The Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet woulu also aiu Naicus as he sequences the plot uevelopment.
Baviu: The small gioup compiehension check uiscussions woulu gieatly aiu Bavius compiehension as woulu the summaiizing anu plot uiagiamming activities. The visual aiu (the photo of uawain enteiing the cave) woulu also benefit Baviu.
Chiistophe: The summaiizing, plot uiagiamming, anu gioup uiscussion activities woulu gieatly aiu Chiistophe as he stiuggles with uecouing Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight. The connection to peisonal expeiience (foi the bell iingei anu closuie of the lesson) woulu also ueepen his unueistanuing of plot stiuctuie anu plot uevelopment.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Papei (useu foi the uawain Summaiy notes); Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet; PoweiPoint Piesentation; 0veiheau monitoi; whiteblackboaiu ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
- Writing prompt: Think of the climax of your favorite movie. How does it contribute to the movie? What specific techniques does the director use to make the film more interesting? (5 min) O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Small gioup uiscussion (1u min) o Students share answers with their quest writing group o As a table, write down the 3 most common techniques o Each table shares with group as a group. o Teacher poses the Essential Question: What role does the climax play? - Transition to Gawain: The teacher says: we will be reading the climax of Sir Gawain & the Green Knight. Pay attention to the strategies that the author uses before during and after it. and hands back the students summary notes on Part 1 along with the Plot structure worksheet - Slides on Plot Structure (5 min) o The teacher explains that the climax is both 1) the point of highest tension and 2) the major turning point in the story (for the hero) 97 o Teacher draws parallel between the Heros Journey circle and more general plot diagram (exposition, rising action, climax). o Students are instructed to fill in Gawains Heros Journey as far as they can (using their notes for support); then, transfer those events onto the traditional plot structure. o Transition: The teacher instructs students to open their textbooks up to p. 169 and says as we approach the climax / crisis, pay attention to the build up of tension. - Reading Sir Gawain Part II (40 min) o The teacher instructs the students to read the italicized paragraph on p. 169 (which summarizes a large portion of the original Sir Gawain text) (5 min) o After they read, the teacher instructs On your Plot structure worksheet, fill in more stages of the Heros Journey and the plot diagram. o Reading lines 259-352 (15 min) ! Teacher tells students: Make a mental picture of everything you read to make it like a movie and displays a depiction of p. 171 (Gawains approach towards the underground chapel) ! Teacher instructs students to continue their Summary notes: a) write down lines that you dont understand b) write a 1-sentence summary and c) highlight any conflict. ! After reading to line 308, each small group shares their notes and works together to explain difficult passages. Then, students are instructed to paraphrase Gawains words into a text message (summary of his emotions) on their summary notes. ! After reading line 352, students are given time to discuss their notes and resolve doubts. Then, 98 they are instructed to write an internal monologue of what Gawain may be thinking at that moment. o Reading lines 353-end (20 min) ! Students are instructed to take a moment to fill in their 2 plot diagrams. ! Then the teacher asks, what do you predict the Gawains crisis (the climax) will be? and calls on a few students to share. Some may say, when Gawain gets his head cut off, to which the teacher could respond, then how will Gawain complete the Heros Journey? ! After reading and summarizing up to 421, the teacher instructs students to share notes with their small groups and discuss the question what is the climax of the story? as they fill out their plot diagrams. o After Reading writing prompt (on Plot Structure worksheet) (15 min) ! Students write a 1-paragraph essay on the conflict in the plot, citing their notes on the text for support (10 min) ! Students share responses with their small groups, citing specific examples from the text. (5 min) o Whole class discussion of climax and characterization (5 min) ! The teacher makes a conflict T- chart with the categories internal and external ! The teacher calls on small groups to share responses, compiling 2 columns of examples (line numbers) based on student responses. ! The teacher poses the question: can the conflict be both internal and external? Why or why not? 99 63%-'$,
- Small group work: Explain your movie pitch to your group. (10 min) o Guiding questions: o What is the climax (crisis/ death and rebirth) of your quest? o How will you build up to it? o How will you resolve the story after the climax? - Homework: Peer-Feedback: Post a comment on each of your group members pitches. Write 3+ ideas to help develop the climax of his or her story. Focus on trials and rising action. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To ie-teach plot stiuctuie, the teachei coulu give a synopsis of a well-known plot (fiom a Bisney movie, foi example) anu ask stuuents to label each pait of the plot uiagiam (exposition, iising action, climax) with appiopiiate moments in the well-known plot. N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Biemei, Chiistine B., Shaion vaughn, Ann T. Clappei, anu Ae-Bwa Kim. "Collaboiative Stiategic Reauing (CSR): Impioving Seconuaiy Stuuents Reauing Compiehension Skills." A,0,(57+ $4 L5(7$#7, G5#,30 1.2 (2uu2): n. pag. V,=0#$, 43 $+, P($#4"(. N,"$,5 4" 8,74"-(5> 9-27($#4" ("- 65(-#$#4". National Centei on Seconuaiy Euucation anu Tiauition. Web.
N,(233X Wiite in the key plot point foi each stage along uawain's jouiney (incluue page # of when the stage appeais in the text). Then, tiansfei these same events onto the tiauitional "plot uiagiam."
H- G%' $,2& %": Continue to fill in key events on both uiagiams. Aftei Reauing: In youi opinion, what viituesvices uoes uawain uisplay by facing his "Ciisis" ("ueath" anu "iebiith"). Suppoit youi answei with examples fiom the text.
What ieasons uoes the uieen Knight give uawain foi feigning twice befoie finally bieaking skin. If you weie uawain, woulu you be satisfieu with those ieasons.
Bow uoes the climax contiibute to the authoi's chaiacteiization of uawain.
Is the plot uiiven by inteinal conflict, exteinal conflict, oi both. Wiite a 1-paiagiaph analysis citing specific passages to suppoit youi aigument.
1u1 0#112( FM5 7,&"#3=D#1 2H 0'H#
!"#$%&'(#)%"
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Stuuents take a 2u-minute quiz on Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight, take notes on the key teims foi the unit, anu piactice naiiative wiiting fiom 1 st peison anu S iu
peison point of view. Foi homewoik, they ieau anu comment on theii quest wiiting gioup membeis fiee wiiting posts, analyzing the uiffeiences in how 1 st anu S iu
peison point of view chaiacteiizes the heio of the stoiy. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.S Analyze the impact of the authoi's choices iegaiuing how to uevelop anu ielate elements of a stoiy oi uiama (e.g., wheie a stoiy is set, how the action is oiueieu, how the chaiacteis aie intiouuceu anu uevelopeu). CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.3.A Engage and orient the reader by setting out a problem, situation, or observation and its significance, establishing one or multiple point(s) of view, and introducing a narrator and/or characters; create a smooth progression of experiences or events. <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents analyze how inteinal anu exteinal conflict impact the uevelopment of plot, citing specific examples foi suppoit (question #24 on quiz) - Stuuents answei questions uesigneu to assess theii unueistanuing of plot uetails fiom Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight anu theii ability to inteipiet theii significance. - Stuuents uefine key teims fiom eailiei in the unit anu take notes on chaiacteiization anu point of view. - Stuuents complete two 1u-minute fiee wiiting exeicises to uevelop the movement fiom Status Quo to the Call to Auventuie foi theii naiiative: one fiom a 1 st peison point of view, one fiom a S iu peison point of view. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
Bow uo you connect with an aichetypal chaiacteisituation. Bow uoes point of view affect the way you iuentify with chaiacteis in a stoiy. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- Knowleuge of motif, aichetype, chaiacteiization, anu climax (uefinitions anu how they aie applieu) - Knowleuge of }oseph Campbells The Beios }ouiney +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents communicate, both in peison anu via blog comments, to shaie peispectives on the effectiveness of theii naiiative wiiting techniques. 1u2
Cieativity anu Innovation In two fiee wiiting activities, stuuents uevelop a stage of theii quest naiiative (fiist in 1 st peison, then in S iu ).
- Quiz on Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight: Stuuents answei 2u multiple-choice questions uesigneu to assess stuuents compiehension of the text. Next, they answei 4 shoit answei questions uesigneu to test stuuents ability to infei implicit meanings, foim peisonal inteipietations, anu (foi question # 24) analyze the plot stiuctuie anu conflict while citing the text foi suppoit. - Waim-up analysis on plot stiuctuie: stuuents wiite S-S sentences analyzing the similaiities anu uiffeiences between theii own quest anu that of uawain, iefeiencing specific stages of the Beios }ouiney. - Befining vocabulaiy woius (fiist inuiviuually, then in a gioup): This S-minute exeicise allows the teachei to infoimally assess each inuiviuual stuuents ability to uefine the key vocabulaiy teims fiom the unit. This infoimation coulu infoim the teachei about which concepts neeu to be ie-taught. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus: The homewoik assignment, to wiite a 1- paiagiaph analysis of how uiffeient naiiative techniques uevelop the same heio, will help Naicus to unueistanu how naiiative techniques contiibute to chaiacteiization.
Baviu: The small gioup activity of collaboiating to uefine the ieview teims fiom the unit will ieinfoice Bavius unueistanuing of the majoi concepts coveieu in the unit. 1uS
Chiistophe: The wiiting waim up allows Chiistophe to connect the plot of uawain to his peisonal quest naiiative. The pie-wiiting activities (in 1 st anu S iu peison) will help Chiistophe to oiganize his naiiative at a latei time.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Libiaiy (meuia centei with tables anu inuiviuual computeis foi stuuents); PoweiPoint Piesentation Chaiacteiization anu Point of view; oveiheau monitoi; uawain Plot Stiuctuie woiksheet (giaueu anu ietuineu to stuuents at the beginning of lesson); loose-leaf papei; pencils ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
Stuuents meet in the meuia lab, which has small tables, an oveiheau monitoi, anu computeis foi each stuuent. Befoie the lesson, the teachei places stuuents nametags on the computeis so that all membeis of the quest wiiting gioup aie sitting in close pioximity.
- Quiz on Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight (2u min) O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Chaiactei compaiison wiiting waim-up (S min) - While stuuents aie finishing the quiz, the teachei passes back theii uawain Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet anu uisplays the instiuctions: o When you finish the quiz take youi notes anu youi uawain Plot Stiuctuie Woiksheet to the computei with youi nametag on it, log in anu open youi blog page, anu computei youi heios quest to that of uawain. o In youi notes, analyze the similaiitiesuiffeiences between youi heios quest anu that of uawain. Refei to specific stages of the Beios }ouiney (S- S sentences). - Small uioup Biscussion (S min) o The teachei instiucts each quest wiiting gioup to uiscuss how theii heio quest compaies to that of uawain. o The stuuents aie encouiageu - Whole Class Biscussion: (S min) o The teachei calls on 2-S stuuents (each fiom a uiffeient gioup) to synthesize how theii iespective quests compaie to that of uawain. o Teachei emphasizes: No quest is exactly alike, but all follow a similai pattein. o Tiansition to vocabulaiy ieview: The 1u4 teachei asks: Which vocab woiu uoes this ieminu you of. (Answei: aichetype) - Biief Review of Key Teims (1u min) o Below theii wiiting waim-up iesponse, stuuents attempt to wiite the uefinitions of aichetype, motif, conflict, climax, anu chaiacteiization without confeiiing with theii peeis (4 min) ! Neanwhile, the teachei ciiculates to assess inuiviuual stuuents unueistanuing of the teims. o Aftei S minutes, the teachei instiucts stuuents to collaboiate with theii quest wiiting gioups to finu the coiiect answeis. (S min) o Teachei calls on inuiviuuals to uefine the teims, anu then ieveals the answei with PoweiPoint animation. - Sliues on Chaiacteiization (S min) o 0n the same sheet, stuuents take notes on uiiect vs. inuiiect o Tiansition to STEAL methous of chaiacteiization: The teachei asks: What techniques uoes the authoi use to chaiacteiize uawain. Aftei stuuent iesponses, the teachei ieveals STEAL o STEAL methous: foi each (Speech, thought,) the teachei asks the class as a whole to volunteei an example (fiom the Sii uawain, '45$, -/5$+25, oi any othei textfilm). o Tiansition: Bow uo you connect with an aichetypal chaiacteisituation. - Point of view (S minutes) - Essential vocab: Point of view: the vantage point oi peispective fiom which a stoiy is tolu. (1 st
peison, S iu limiteu, S iu omniscient) - Teachei iaises the Essential Question: Bow uoes point of view affect the way you iuentify with chaiacteis in a stoiy. -Fiee Wiiting Activity: 1 st anu S iu Point of view (2u min) Wiiting piompt: 1 st peison Fiee Wiite: Put youiself in the position of youi heioheioine. Imagine the movement fiom status quo to call to auventuie. What uo you see. What happens. Besciibe the scene fiom that chaiacteis peispective (1 st
peison). (1u min)
63%-'$,
S iu Peison Fiee Wiite: The teachei instiucts the stuuents: Now, Wiite the scene 1uS fiom a S iu peison peispective (give moie uesciiptive uetails about the heio). (1u min)
Bomewoik: Comment on each gioup membeis Fiee Wiiting Wiite 1 paiagiaph analyzing the uiffeiences in how the 1 st peison anu S iu peison naiiation uevelops the heio (thiough actions, thiough uesciiptions). Concluue with a shoit evaluation of what appioach woiks bettei foi the wiitei. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
- To ie-teach point of view, the teachei coulu uesign a quiz game in which stuuents iuentify the naiiative point of view foi seveial passages. To make the quiz uiuactic, stuuents woulu highlight specific woius that inuicate the point of view foi the naiiation. When the teachei goes ovei the answeis, the stuuents coulu cleaily note the uiffeiences in subject anu veib tense. N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
"Chaiacteiization." A,(- V5#$, 6+#"). National Council of Teacheis of English, 2uu4. Web.
1. Why does the Green Knight come seeking King Arthur? a. to give him a present b. to fight him c. to challenge him 2. What is the challenge that he offers them? a. you chop my head off and Ill chop your head off later b. you eat my soup and Ill eat your soup later c. fight me in hand to hand combat 3. Why does the Green Knight mock them? a. because no one accepts the challenge b. because he wants to make them mad c. because he is a mean person 4. Who accepts the challenge first? a. Arthur b. Gawain c. Guinevere 5. What reason does Gawain give for being the better candidate? a. he is the strongest and will do the King honor b. he is the weakest and the challenge is beneath that of the king c. he is not scared 6. How is Gawain related to King Arthur? a. son b. uncle c. nephew 7. What happens when Gawain swings the ax at the Green Knights neck? a. the knight is saved by a goddess b. the knight lifts his arm to protect himself and his arm is chopped off c. the knights head rolls off and sits on the floor 8. How does the Green Knight leave? a. he runs away while the members of the court, who have turned into an angry mob, chase him. b. he doesnt c. he picks his head up off the floor and carries it to his horse, mounts, and rides away 9. What is Gawain supposed to do in 12 months? a. duel Arthur for Guineveres hand b. bury the Green Knight at the Green Chapel c. allow the Green Knight to take a swing at his own head 10. What do Gawain and Arthur do after the Green Knight rides away? a. try to clear the air and then party on b. lock all the doors and make everyone vow not to let the Green Knight in again c. put the Green Knight in the dungeon so he can never hurt anyone again. 11. What is Gawain supposed to do in 12 months? a. duel Arthur for Guineveres hand b. bury the Green Knight at the Green Chapel c. allow the Green Knight to take a swing at his own head
12. Where does Gawain stop on Christmas Eve? a. The Green Chapel b. a wondrous castle c. Sir Arthurs personal residence
1u7 13. What deal does Gawain and the lord of the castle make? a. To trade places on New Years day, so the lord will fight the Green Knight b. To exchange gifts the next morning c. To exchange whatever the receive during the next three days
14. Why does Gawain keep the Green Girdle? a. because it was supposed to protect him b. because it was pretty c. because the Green Knight made him promise to bring it to him
15.Where is Gawain supposed to meet the Green Knight? a. The Green Castle b. The Green Chapel c. The Green Meadow
16. What happens the first time the Green Knight swings the ax at Gawains neck? a. Gawain flinches, and the Green Knight mocks him b. Gawain cries, and the Green Knight mocks him c. Gawain begs for mercy, and the Green Knight mocks him
17. What happens the second time the Green Knight swings the ax at Gawains neck? a. Gawains head rolls off b. Gawain cries again c. The knight withdraws at the last second and mocks Gawain
18. What happens the third time the Green Knight swings the ax at Gawains neck? a. Gawain is dead, so he doesnt swing it a third time b. the ax only nicks Gawain, who swiftly rises to his feet to defend himself c. Gawain passes out
18. Why is Gawain ashamed? a. because he dishonored himself by sleeping with the lords wife b. because he dishonored himself by going back on his word c. because he dishonored himself by crying
19. Who does the Green Knight reveal himself to be? a. the lord of the castle b. the devil c. King Arthur
20. At the end Gawain is a. proud b. humbled c. enraged
1u8 Short Answer:
21. In your opinion, what virtues/vices does Gawain represent in his quest? Why? Support your answer with examples from the text.
22. In your opinion, what virtues/vices does Gawain display by facing his Crisis (death and rebirth)? Support your answer with examples from the text.
23. What reasons does the Green Knight give Gawain for feigning twice before finally breaking skin? If you were Gawain, would you be satisfied with those reasons?
24. Is the plot driven by internal conflict, external conflict, or both? Cite examples from the text to support your argument.
1u9 +,--%" fX O)CC)"C O,,K,$X 4G7=%3)-7R H33,C%$GR 8 !33'7)"2#,& <2"'-($)K#-
Intiouuction
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Stuuents inteipiet the meanings of symbols in a seiies of images, uiscuss the essential question of how a single textimage can have seveial meanings, anu take notes on common meuieval symbols. Then, the teachei intiouuces the concept of allegoiy (its uefinition anu examples) anu ielates it to the essential question. In small gioups, stuuents come to a consensus about the allegoiy of Platos Allegoiy of the Cave, Aesops The Two Tiavelleis anu the Beai, anu a shoit exceipt fiom Canto I of Bantes R"3,5"4. To concluue, each gioup uiaws oiiginal illuminations (maiginal illustiations) foi theii exceipt of the Infeino anu infoimally piesent theii woik 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.1 Cite stiong anu thoiough textual eviuence to suppoit analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as infeiences uiawn fiom the text, incluuing ueteimining wheie the text leaves matteis unceitain. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.4 Beteimine the meaning of woius anu phiases as they aie useu in the text, incluuing figuiative anu connotative meanings; analyze the impact of specific woiu choices on meaning anu tone, incluuing woius with multiple meanings oi language that is paiticulaily fiesh, engaging, oi beautiful. (Incluue Shakespeaie as well as othei authois.) CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.1 Initiate anu paiticipate effectively in a iange of collaboiative uiscussions (one-on-one, in gioups, anu teachei-leu) with uiveise paitneis on giaues 11-12 topics, texts, anu issues, builuing on otheis' iueas anu expiessing theii own cleaily anu peisuasively. <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- In small gioups, stuuents analyze the significance of a seiies of symbols. - In small gioups, stuuents inteipiet the allegoiical anu liteial meaning of shoit exceipts of Canto I of Bantes R"3,5"4, Aesops The Two Nen anu the Beai, Platos The Allegoiy of the Cave (stuuents aie askeu to iecall the geneial plot fiom lesson 4), anu uiottos painting of St. Fiancis of Assisi maiiying poveit. - In small gioups, stuuents piouuce oiiginal manusciipt illuminations foi an assigneu exceipt of Canto I of Bantes R"3,5"4 anu explain how theii illustiations iepiesent the allegoiy of the text. 11u :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
Bow can a single text oi image have moie than one meaning. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- ueneial knowleuge of symbolism (its uefinition anu examples taught in lessons 1 anu S) +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents woik in small gioups to analyze the symbolism anu allegoiy in a vaiiety of texts anu images. They also piouuce oiiginal illustiations that iepiesent the allegoiical meaning of an exceipt of the R"3,5"4.
Cieativity anu Innovation Stuuents woik in small gioups to cieate oiiginal illustiations that iepiesent the allegoiical meaning of a paiticulai passage of Bantes R"3,5"4.
Ciitical Thinking anu Pioblem Solving Stuuents analyze seveial paintings anu texts to inteipiet symbolism anu allegoiical meaning.
- Iuentifying symbols: As an infoimal assessment, stuuents wiite uown any symbols that they can iuentify in a seiies of images. Foi each symbol, they must iuentify the tangible icon anu the intangible quality that is iepiesenteu. - Allegoiy team inteipietation activity: In small gioups, stuuents aiticulate the liteial meaning anu allegoiical meaning of vaiious textsimages. - Analysis of a manusciipt illumination foi Canto I: Stuuents wiite a S-S sentence analysis of the appaient symbols in a blown-up image of an illuminateu manusciipt (R"3,5"4 Canto I). - Illuminateu Nanusciipt foi Bantes Infeino: In small gioups, stuuents make S+ illustiations in the maigins of the R"3,5"4 exceipt that in some way connect to the allegoiical meaning of theii assigneu poition of the exceipt. 0n the back, each gioup explains what they inteipieteu the allegoiy to be, how they chose to iepiesent it visually, anu why. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols. 111
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus: As stuuents ieau the exceipt fiom Bantes R"3,5"4, the teachei pioviues a simple paiaphiase of the text in seveial PoweiPoint sliues, each of which incluues an image to aiu with compiehension. This piesentation stiategy will help Naicus with his uifficulties sequencing events.
Baviu: The numeious activities centeieu on inteipieting an image will help Baviu to unueistanu the concept anu examples of symbolism anu allegoiy thiough a visual meuium, which ciicumvents his uifficulties with English. 0nce he has piacticeu iuentifying symbolism anu allegoiy in images, he will have highei confiuence anu gieatei facility with a textual example.
Chiistophe: The activities in which stuuents analyze images will help Chiistophe to piactice iuentifying examples of symbolism anu allegoiy visually befoie facing the challenge of uecouing a text (the exceipts fiom Bantes R"3,5"4). The final gioup activity in which stuuents make theii own illustiations that iepiesent the allegoiy will allow Chiistophe to ueepen his unueistanuing of the text thiough a cieative, visually- stimulating pioject.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
PoweiPoint Piesentation Bigging Beepei; Banuout of shoit exceipts foi Bantes R"3,5"4 (Nanuelbaum tianslation) to be given to each gioup; Banuout of all gioups R"3,5"4 exceipts compileu; coloieu pencilsmaikeisciayons; Aesops Fable The Two Nen anu the Beai (with inteinet link to the auuio file); ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
Besks aie aiiangeu into small tables of S oi 4. Stuuents aie sitting with theii quest wiiting gioups.
- Wiiting Response to Swastika (S min) o The teachei uisplays an image of a Binuu Swastika alongsiue the piompt: What uoes this icon mean to you. What emotionsthoughts uoes it stii up in you. O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J - Whole class uiscussion of Swastika (S min) o The teachei calls on inuiviuuals to shaie theii 112 #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
iesponses to the icon anu oiganizes stuuent iesponses into categoiies on the whiteboaiu (e.g., angei feai Nazis, peace, etc.) o Tiansition: The teachei asks stuuents Bow can a single icon mean moie than one thing. o The teachei biiefly explains the histoiy of the Swastika symbol (its uiffeient associations ovei time) - Whole Class Biscussion of Essential Question (S min) o The teachei poses the essential question: Bow can a single text have moie than one meaning. o The teachei uiges stuuents to leau the uiscussion, but (if neeueu) pushes stuuents to elaboiate moie. o If neeu be, the teachei asks: how uo these uiffeient meanings come into being. - Symbolism team inteipietation activity (S min) o The teachei ieviews vocab: symbol: has a meaning beyonu the liteial. o The teachei instiuctions each gioup to wiite theii names on a single sheet (to be collecteu). As stuuents aie shown images, they must iuentify as many symbols as they can. Foi each symbol, they must inuicate the tangible icon anu the intangible quality that it iepiesents, suppoiting theii claims with uetails fiom the image. o S paintings shown: aftei each small gioup uiscussion, the teachei calls on seveial gioups to shaie theii iueas. - Nini-lectuie on meuieval symbols (S min) o Stuuents aie instiucteu to take notes on these common meuieval symbols: unicoin (shown in final painting), symbolic numbeis, pentangle (featuieu in Sii uawain anu the uieen Knight) o Tiansition: Teachei elaboiates the numeious meanings of the pentangle in ielation to uawain: shows that 1 symbol often has NANY meanings (anu it is the peiceivei who cieates the meaning). - Allegoiy team inteipietation activity: (1S min) o Teachei intiouuces the essential vocab (foi stuuents notes) allegoiy: naiiative with a uouble meaning: a liteial (suiface meaning, anu a symbolic (ueepei) meaning. o Biffeience between symbol anu allegoiy: an allegoiy is a NARRATIvE. It uses symbols again anu again in a consistent way as the stoiy 11S uevelops. Bowevei, the ueepei meaning is nevei explicitly stateu. o Activity instiuctions: Stuuents aie instiucteu to woik with theii small gioups to agiee on a wiitten iesponse foi each image. Bowevei, this time they aie inteipieting allegoiies. Not just symbols. Foi EACB: wiite the LITERAL anu the ALLEu0RICAL meaning of the stoiy. o The teachei shows Allegoiy of the Cave photo (ieview fiom lesson 4). ! The teachei calls on 1-2 gioups to shaie theii explanation. The class comes to a consensus. o Teachei shows painting: St. Fiancis weus Poveity (possible answei: liteial meaning = St. Fiancis maiiies a woman nameu Poveity. Allegoiical meaning = St. Fiancis takes a vow to live in poveity foi his whole life.) ! The teachei calls on 1-2 gioups to shaie. Class comes to a consensus. o Stuuents ieau Aesops fable The Two Nen anu the Beai (while teachei plays the auuio iecoiuing). Stuuents aie instiucteu to wiite what the moial of the stoiy is. o The teachei asks S-4 gioups to shaie theii moials anu wiites them on the boaiu. Then, he ieveals the moial that the stoiy gives. o Tiansition: The teachei poses the question: Can theie be moie than one valiu answei. Is it okay foi us to uisagiee about what the moial of the stoiy is. - Inuiviuual wiiting S-S-sentence analysis of an image: (S min) o A blown-up illuminateu manusciipt illustiation uepicting Canto I of Bantes R"3,5"4 is shown on the scieen. o The stuuents iesponu to piompt: What uo you think this image iepiesent. Wiite 2-S sentences citing specific figuiesimages. - Small gioup uiscussion (S min) o The teachei instiucts stuuents to shaie theii iueas with theii small gioup o While small gioups shaie, the teachei ciiculates encouiaging stuuents to suppoit theii inteipietations with specific featuies fiom the image. o Tiansition: the teachei ieveals the context of the image: fiom an illuminateu manusciipt of Bantes R"3,5"4 (the veiy beginning) o Neanwhile, the teachei hanus out copies of the 114 oiiginal text (Nanuelbaum tianslation) that goes with the illustiation (fiist half of Canto I). Each gioup ieceives copies with a uiffeient poition of the poem highlighteu. - Reauing Bantes R"3,5"4 (1u min) o Sliue on Illuminateu manusciipts: illustiateu book uuiing the miuule ages. o 0ne stuuent fiom each gioup is chosen to ieau theii highlighteu passage. At 4 points uuiing the ieauing, the teachei stops to show an image anu a summaiy of the text ieau (see PoweiPoint). - Small uioup Analysis of Allegoiy (1u min) o Each small gioup iesponus to piompts A anu B anu wiites theii answeis on the back of the R"3,5"4 hanuout. a) Iuentify impoitant figuies anu actions in highlighteu passage b) What coulu this passage iepiesent on a ueepei level. 63%-'$,
- Illuminate youi Nanusciipt activity (1u min) c) With youi gioup, make S+ illustiations that iepiesent the allegoiical meaning of youi passage. 0se -#33,5,"$ figuiesimages than what Bante uses. Biaw them in the maigins of the poem (in the style of meuieval illuminateu manusciipts) u) 0n the back, explain what youi gioup inteipieteu the allegoiy to be, how you chose to iepiesent it visually, anu why. o The teachei announces that the stuuents will be iequiieu to make oiiginal illuminations foi theii final quest naiiative, except that they must be publisheu in an electionic foimat (scanneu, uploaueu, uesigneu, etc.). o Pioceuuie: Buiing this activity, the teachei ciiculates to assess inuiviuual stuuents unueistanuing anu the gioup uynamics. o At the enu of class, the teachei collects the illuminateu manusciipt foi each gioup. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P#,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To ie-teach the concept of allegoiy, the teachei coulu wiite a shoit tale (S sentences) anu ask stuuents to inteipiet the liteial anu allegoiical meaning of the text. This exeicise woulu allow stuuents to compaie vaiious stuuent-piouuceu inteipietations, thus illustiating that theie is no single iight answei foi iuentifying the allegoiy.
0nce stuuents have finisheu theii quests, stuuents coulu inteipiet the allegoiy of each otheis naiiatives. N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Alighieii, Bante, Baiiy Nosei, anu Allen Nanuelbaum. R"3,5"4% / M,50, 65("0.($#4" H#$+ R"$54-27$#4" => /..," '("-,.=(2<. Camp Bill, PA: Quality Papeiback Book Club, 198u. Piint.
11S "The Beai anu the Two Tiaveleis - ueneial Fable Collection." T,",5(. 1(=., N4..,7$#4". AesopFables.com, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
From Canto I of Dantes Inferno (Allen Mandelbaum translation)
(Group 1) When I had journeyed half of our life's way, I found myself within a shadowed forest, for I had lost the path that does not stray.
Ah, it is hard to speak of what it was, that savage forest, dense and difficult, which even in recall renews my fear:
so bitter-death is hardly more severe! But to retell the good discovered there, I'll also tell the other things I saw.
(Group 2) I cannot clearly say how I had entered the wood; I was so full of sleep just at the point where I abandoned the true path.
But when I'd reached the bottom of a hill- it rose along the boundary of the valley that had harassed my heart with so much fear-
(Group 3) I looked on high and saw its shoulders clothed already by the rays of that same planet which serves to lead men straight along all roads.
At this my fear was somewhat quieted; for through the night of sorrow I had spent, the lake within my heart felt terror present.
(Group 4) And just as he who, with exhausted breath, having escaped from sea to shore, turns back to watch the dangerous waters he has quit,
117 so did my spirit, still a fugitive, turn back to look intently at the pass that never has let any man survive.
(Group 5) I let my tired body rest awhile. Moving again, I tried the lonely slope- my firm foot always was the one below.
And almost where the hillside starts to rise- look there!-a leopard, very quick and lithe, a leopard covered with a spotted hide.
He did not disappear from sight, but stayed; indeed, he so impeded my ascent that I had often to turn back again.
(Group 6) The time was the beginning of the morning; the sun was rising now in fellowship with the same stars that had escorted it
when Divine Love first moved those things of beauty; so that the hour and the gentle season gave me good cause for hopefulness on seeing
(Group 7) that beast before me with his speckled skin; but hope was hardly able to prevent the fear I felt when I beheld a lion.
His head held high and ravenous with hunger- even the air around him seemed to shudder- this lion seemed to make his way against me.
(Group 8) And then a she-wolf showed herself; she seemed to carry every craving in her leanness; she had already brought despair to many.
The very sight of her so weighted me with fearfulness that I abandoned hope 118 of ever climbing up that mountain slope.
(Group 9) Even as he who glories while he gains will, when the time has come to tally loss, lament with every thought and turn despondent,
so was I when I faced that restless beast which, even as she stalked me, step by step had thrust me back to where the sun is speechless.
119 +,--%" gX A,,$P1,,&=2(D %" N%'CJ O$2L#-
Intiouuction
+,--%" ./,$/),0
Stuuents woik in paitneis to ieview, euit, anu comment on each otheis iough uiafts of the quest naiiative using uoogle Bloggei anu Niciosoft Woiu comments anu tiack changes. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.6 0se technology, incluuing the Inteinet, to piouuce, publish, anu upuate inuiviuual oi shaieu wiiting piouucts in iesponse to ongoing feeuback, incluuing new aiguments oi infoimation. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.3 Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events using effective technique, well-chosen details, and well-structured event sequences. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.3.C Use a variety of techniques to sequence events so that they build on one another to create a coherent whole and build toward a particular tone and outcome (e.g., a sense of mystery, suspense, growth, or resolution). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
- Stuuents euit a paitneis iough uiaft foi style anu claiity using Niciosoft Woiu tiack changes anu in- text comments. - Stuuents wiite in-text comments to iuentify the sequence of stages of the Beios }ouiney in the plot as well as symbols anu the quest objective. - In a final in-text comment on theii paitneis iough uiaft, stuuents wiite at least thiee suggestions on how to impiove the builu up to the climax anu the piogiession towaius the iesolution. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
Bow can we impiove oui own wiiting anu thinking by ievising the woik of otheis. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
- Knowleuge of uoogle Bloggei (how to log into theii accounts, post mateiial, anu comment on othei stuuents posts) - Familiaiity with Niciosoft Woiu (incluuing how to Post in-text Comments anu tiack changes) - ueneial knowleuge of how to coiiect foi English mechanics anu conventions, incluuing subject- veib agieement, tense consistency, punctuation (comma vs. peiiou vs. semicolon vs. colon), capitalization, speech quotations, paiagiaph bieaks, anu syntax (Bowevei, the stuuents masteiy of these skills vaiies gieatly.) +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents woik in paiis to pioviue feeuback, both wiitten anu oial, on the iough uiaft. At the enu of the lesson, stuuents woik togethei to piepaie foi a gioup piesentation. 12u
Ciitical Thinking anu Pioblem Solving Stuuents aie encouiageu to piopose specific euits to impiove the claiity, style, anu content of a paitneis uiaft. The piocess of euiting is inheiently ciitical, anu often piesents pioblems to be solveu.
Cieativity anu Innovation Stuuents aie encouiageu to suggest cieative iueas to fuithei uevelop the plot of theii paitneis uiaft (specifically focusing on the builu up to the climax anu the piogiession towaius a final iesolution).
ulobal Awaieness: Stuuents leain fiom anu woik collaboiatively with theii peeis in the piocess of peei- ievision anu peei-feeuback. Stuuents also shaie iueas about the uiveise peispectives anu expeiiences ieflecteu in theii peisonal naiiatives.
Initiative anu Self-Biiection The lesson iequiies stuuents to woik inuepenuently on peei ievisions both in anu outsiue of class.
- Peei-feeuback on Plot: Each stuuent iuentifies the heio, each stage of the Beios }ouiney, the quest objective anu its allegoiical significance, anu as many symbols as can be founu in a paitneis iough uiaft. As a final in-text comment, each stuuent makes at least thiee suggestions on how to enhance the builu-up to the climax anu the piogiession towaius a final iesolution anu (if necessaiy) integiate the missing elements of the Beios }ouiney. - Peei-euiting foi style anu content: each stuuent euits a paitneis iough uiaft foi style anu content, focusing specifically on giammai, punctuation, anu tiansitions. - Exit slip ieflection on euiting piocess: At the enu of the lesson, each stuuent wiites a shoit ieflection on what they have leaineu fiom the peei-ievision piocess. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 121 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus The tiack-changes anu in-text comment technology woulu help Naicus to oiganize his thoughts as he makes ievisions. Noie geneially, the peei-ievision piocess will help him to isolate specific aspects of his wiiting that neeu impiovement.
Baviu The peei-euiting anu peei feeuback activities will help Baviu, who woulu gieatly benefit fiom specific uesciiptive feeuback fiom a native speakei.
Chiistophe The peei-feeuback anu peei-euiting activities will help mouel goou euiting techniques foi Chiistophe, who stiuggles with the pie-wiiting anu euiting stages of his wiiting.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
The lesson takes place in the libiaiy, which has computeis foi the stuuents, a computei foi the teachei, anu a monitoi to uisplay the teacheis PoweiPoint. Befoie class, the teachei places stuuents nametags at computei uesks so that each stuuent is sitting next to his oi hei Peei- Feeuback paitnei, anu each Quest Wiiting gioup is in close pioximity. Computeis with Niciosoft Woiu anu inteinet access; oveiheau monitoi; PoweiPoint piesentation; ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
- Waim-up Activity Elevatoi talks (8 minutes) o Inuiviuual wiiting (2 min): Stuuents aie instiucteu: In youi notes, explain the objective of youi heios quest (what is youi heio tiying to accomplish.). In auuition, explain the ueepei, allegoiical meaning foi this liteial objective. o Elevatoi talk #1 (2.S min): Stuuents aie instiucteu to stanu up anu silently ciiculate aiounu the ioom until the teachei calls stop. Then, they aie instiucteu to shake hanus with a peison who is not in theii Quest Wiiting gioup. In these paiis, stuuents explain the objectives of theii iespective quests (anu theii allegoiical significance) in 2 minutes time. 122 o Elevatoi talk #2 (2.S min): Stuuents aie instiucteu to ciiculate again, to stop, anu shake hanus with a uiffeient peison, who will be theii new paitnei. This time, stuuent must explain the objective of $+,#5 I5,F#420 I(5$",50 quest (in 2 minutes) o Tiansition (1 min): The teachei instiucts stuuents to ietuin to theii seats (to the computei with theii nametag on it) anu asks, Bow many of you weie able to iemembei the uetails of youi 1 st paitneis stoiy. stuuents shaie iesponses with the whole class. O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Puipose anu 0bjectives of Peei-Revision (S min) o The teachei explains the take-away point of waim-up: the wiitei makes the stoiy, but the ieauei may unueistanu it uiffeiently than how the wiitei intenueu. Thats why its impoitant to consiuei the meaning that anothei peison takes away fiom youi stoiy. o 0bjectives of the lesson: 1) pioviue constiuctive feeuback foi youi peeis 2) leain fiom youi peei so that you can make impiovements to youi uiaft o The teachei explains the agenua foi the lesson: Paitnei peei-feeuback on plot; Paitnei peei-euiting Peei feeuback foi style anu claiity; Blog Comments (on each membei of youi Quest Wiiting gioup); anu Piepaiing foi Piesentations. o The teachei asks stuuents if they have any questions. o Tiansition: The teachei explains: The name wiitten in pencil on youi nametag will be youi peei-feeuback paitnei. Right now, go to this peisons blog anu open his oi hei iough uiaft. - Peei-feeuback on plot (2u min): o Stuuents aie instiucteu to open a blank Niciosoft Woiu uocument, copy theii paitneis iough uiaft fiom theii blog post, anu then paste the uiaft onto the blank Woiu uocument. The teachei explains the thiee steps in inciements: o Step 1 (1u min): As you ieau thiough youi paitneis uiaft ciitically, wiite in-text comments to iuentify a) the heio, b) each stage of the Beios }ouiney, c) as many symbols as you can finu, anu u) the 12S objective of the quest anu its allegoiical significance. Foi each in-text comment, wiite a 1-S sentences explaining youi choice (e.g. The Call to Auventuie is when Sallys fathei gets kiunappeu because it foices hei to take action) o Step 2 (S min): When you finish step 1, post a final comment at the bottom of the uocument in which you a) list all the plot elements that neeu to be auueu to youi paitneis quest anu b) at least thiee suggestions on how to enhance the builu up to the climax anu the piogiession towaius the iesolution anu (if the quest is missing iequiieu elements) how to integiate them into the plot. o Step S (S min): Talk to youi paitnei about youi thiee suggestions on how to enhance theii builu up, climax, anu iesolution. o Thioughout the thiee steps, the teachei ciiculates to lenu suppoit, claiify uoubts, anu gauge stuuents level of paiticipation. - Peei-Euiting foi Style anu Claiity (2u min) o The teachei explains that stuuents will use both tiack changes anu in-text comments to pioviue suggestions to impiove the style, claiity, anu oiganization of the same paitneis uiaft. Stuuents aie instiucteu to euit foi o uiammai: Euit youi paitneis uiaft so that the naiiative follows consistent iules foi giammai. Watch out foi subject-veib agieement, tense consistency, anu incoiiect spelling, aiticles, anu pionouns. If a chaiacteinaiiatoi uoes not follow the conventions of Stanuaiu Ameiican English (like Buck Finn), then make suie that the uialect is useu consistently. o Punctuation: Euit youi paitneis uiaft to make suie that punctuation is useu consistently anu cleaily. Nake suie that commas, colons, semi-colons, anu peiious aie useu appiopiiately anu coiiectly. Also make suie that all uialogue is intiouuceu with a comma oi colon anu put in uouble quotes (e.g., }im saiu, I uont know about that, Buck.). o Tiansitions: Euit anu comment on youi paitneis uiaft with an eye to impiove the claiity anu flow of the stoiy. Suggest 124 tiansition woius when appiopiiate. If you see a jump in the logic oi sequence of events, make a comment explaining youi confusion. Suggest uiffeient paiagiaph bieaks if you feel it is necessaiy. o Buiing the peei-euiting stage, the teachei ciiculates to lenu suppoit anu assess stuuents paiticipation anu quality of feeuback. o Aftei 18 minutes, stuuents aie instiucteu to email the Woiu uocument to 2 iecipients: the authoi of the uiaft anu the teachei. - Blog Comments (1S min) o The teachei instiucts stuuents to post a 1- paiagiaph blog comment on theii paitneis iough uiaft with the piompt: Iuentify specific uetailsaspects that you especially likeu about the uiaft anu why. Piaise youi peeis foi what they uiu well! (1u min) o Stuuents aie instiucteu to ieau the comments on theii blogs, anu then uiscuss them with theii paitnei. (S min) o Tiansition: The teachei explains that the homewoik foi this evening is to ieau all othei gioup membeis uiafts anu post a 1- paiagiaph comment foi each auuiessing the same piompt. - Explaining Quest Wiiting uioup Piesentations (S min) o The teachei instiucts stuuents to take out the Instiuctions anu Rubiic foi the Nake a Quest pioject, anu then explains the Quest Wiiting uioup Piesentation. o The teachei says: Foi pait 1 of the piesentation, you will intiouuce youi peei-feeuback paitneis quest. Foi pait 2, all membeis will ieflect on the expeiience of woiking as a gioup foi biainstoiming, feeuback, anu ievisions. o The teachei uiiects stuuents attention to the iubiic on the Nake a Quest hanuout anu asks stuuents if they have any questions. o The teachei explains that they will be given the next 1u minutes to piepaie pait 1 of theii piesentation, anu that they can piepaie pait 2 at the beginning of the next lesson (iight befoie piesenting). 12S - Piepaiing pait 1 of uioup Piesentations (1u min) o Stuuents aie instiucteu to wiite an outline foi piesenting theii paitneis quest foi pait 1 of the piesentation, consulting himhei when neeueu. o The teachei ciiculates to lenu suppoit, iesolve uoubts, anu answei questions iegaiuing the piesentation guiuelines. 63%-'$,
Stuuents inuiviuually answei essential question (S min): What have you leaineu fiom the piocess of ievising youi paitneis quest naiiative. wiiting it on a notecaiu to be tuineu in at the enu of class.
B0NEW0RK: - Reau anu comment on ALL gioup membeis quests. - Caiefully ieau youi peei-feeuback anu make necessaiy ievisions (fiist to giammaistyle, then plotcontent). H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To bettei mouel peei-ievision stiategies, the teachei coulu uisplay scieenshots of stuuent peei-feeuback (tiack changes anu in-text comments). The teachei coulu show S anonymous examples: one that is exemplaiy, one that is pooily uone, anu one that is miuule-of-the-ioau. Stuuents coulu woik togethei in paitneis oi small gioups to iank which feeuback is most helpful anu why. N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
Kawahata, Cinuy. "Running Beau: Peei Euiting thiough Technology in K-12 Classiooms." Thesis. Califoinia State 0niveisity, Saciamento, 2u12. Web.
Each Quest Wiiting uioup piesents theii quests (each gioup membei piesenting theii Peei-Feeuback paitneis quest) anu the oveiall expeiience of woiking in a gioup foi biainstoiming, feeuback, anu ievisions. Buiing the piesentations, each stuuent fills out an infoimal evaluation of all othei gioups piesentations. 1%(23 4#2"&2$&- 56%77%" 6%$, 8 96 :--,"#)23 4#2"&2$&-;
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.11-12.4 Present information, findings, and supporting evidence, conveying a clear and distinct perspective, such that listeners can follow the line of reasoning, alternative or opposing perspectives are addressed, and the organization, development, substance, and style are appropriate to purpose, audience, and a range of formal and informal tasks. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.3 Analyze the impact of the author's choices regarding how to develop and relate elements of a story or drama (e.g., where a story is set, how the action is ordered, how the characters are introduced and developed). <,2-'$,2=3, .=>,(#)/, ?2-,& %" 6%"#,"# 4#2"&2$&5-;
-Each stuuent piesents a paitneis quest naiiative to the whole class, explaining the setting, the heios chaiacteiistics, the quest objective, anu the key plot points. -As a gioup, stuuents piesent on what they leaineu thioughout the gioup ievision piocess. :--,"#)23 @',-#)%"5-;
What can we as wiiteis leain fiom oui ieaueis. A$)%$ B"%03,&C,
-The stuuents have been exposeu to eveiything taught in the pievious lessons foi this unit. +)"D #% EF -# 6,"#'$G 4D)33-
Communication anu Collaboiation Stuuents woik togethei to piesent on theii expeiience of collaboiating thioughout the unit.
-uioup Piesentation: Foi pait 1 of the piesentation, each stuuent is chaigeu with the task of piesenting the quest naiiative of his oi hei Peei-Feeuback paitnei, explaining the heios chaiacteiistics, the setting, the quest objective anu the key plot points. Foi pait 2 of the piesentation, each gioup of stuuents must ieflect on what they leaineu thioughout the peei-ievision piocess. -Peei-Evaluations of othei uioup Piesentations: Buiing the gioup piesentations, each stuuent wiites notes, questions, anu an oveiall assessment of each othei gioups piesentation. 127 -1-paiagiaph Reflection on othei Authois Choices: stuuents wiite a 1-paiagiaph ieflection on the most inteiesting choices maue by theii classmates in ueveloping the plot anu chaiacteis of theii quest naiiatives. 4'772#)/, H--,--7,"# 52##2(J -K,()L)( )"-#$'(#)%"- %$ ,M27K3,-;
Students write an original quest narrative (at least 700 words) featuring a hero, an object or goal, and each of the stages of the Heros Journey. In addition, the story must develop at least 3 symbols and a deeper moral significance for the quest.
After peer-editing rough drafts in small groups, students post their final drafts on their blog page. This post must include manuscript illuminations: illustrations that depict at least 3 key plot points and at least 3 symbols.
This summative assessment will not be uue until aftei the unit is finisheu. Thanks to the blog foium, stuuents can view each otheis final piouucts even if they aie not shaieu in class. H((%77%&2#)%"- 5-K,()L)( #% #J)- 3,--%" 2"& =2-,& %" -K,()L)( -#'&,"#-;
Naicus The labeleu boxes in the peei-evaluation foim will help Naicus to oiganize his thoughts befoie tiansfeiiing them to papei.
Baviu The 1u minutes of piepaiation befoie the gioup piesentations will allow Baviu to consult his peeis on the pionunciation anu emphasis of ceitain woius in his poition of the piesentation.
Chiistophe The gioup piesentationswhich incluue summaiies of inuiviuual stuuents quest naiiatives as well as gioup ieflections on the euiting piocesswill ieinfoice Chiistophes unueistanuing of the quest aichetype because he benefits fiom lessons that allow him to connect the mateiial to his peisonal expeiiences.
+,--%" A32"
<2#,$)23-
Peei-Evaluation Foims foi uioup Piesentations; PoweiPoint Piesentation entitleu Quest Wiiting uioup Piesentations; Nake a Quest Instiuctions anu Rubiic (hanueu out in lesson S); oveiheau monitoi; Besk cameia whose feeu can be uisplayeu on the oveiheau monitoi ?,33 N)"C,$IN,/),0 H(#)/)#G
- Waim-up wiiting piompt (S minutes) o The teachei uisplays on a monitoi: Think of all the peei-feeuback youve ieceiveu so fai. Wiite uown the S most helpful suggestions youve been given anu how you plan to use them as you continue with youi naiiative. o Buiing this waim-up, the teachei 128 ciiculates to assess which stuuents can cite specific suggestions fiom memoiy. O,#2)3,& H(#)/)#),- 2"& A$%(,&'$,- 50)#J #$2"-)#)%"- 2"& #)7, 233%(2#)%"-;
- Small-gioup anu whole-class uiscussions of piompt (1u min) o Each Quest Wiiting gioup uiscusses the specific suggestions that they founu most helpful anu how they plan to use them as they continue woiking on the pioject. o Whole class: The teachei calls on 2-S stuuents to shaie specific examples of feeuback, why it has been helpful, anu how they plan to use it as they move foiwaiu. o Tiansition: the teachei says: By now, you all shoulu have ieau anu commenteu on each of youi Quest Wiiting gioup membeis iough uiafts. - Piepaiing foi Pait 2 of the uioup Piesentation: (1u min) o The teachei instiuctions each gioup: Wiite an outline foi Pait 2 of youi piesentation. Nake suie that all question on the piompt aie auuiesseu anu that each gioup membei speaks. Then, piactice pacing, ueliveiy, anu bouy language foi the piesentation. o The teachei ieminus stuuents to check the iubiic to make suie that they aie meeting all iequiiements. o As gioups piepaie foi theii piesentations, the teachei ciiculates to lenu suppoit, answei questions, anu assess whethei stuuents aie collaboiating to oiganize theii piesentation. o Aftei 9 minutes, the teachei passes out the peei-evaluation sheets. - Instiuctions foi Peei-Evaluations (S min) o The teachei explains that each stuuent must evaluate all othei gioups using this peei-evaluation sheet. o To mouel feeuback, the teachei fills out each column foi a sample gioup (uisplaying the comments on the oveiheau monitoi). - Quest Wiiting uioup Piesentations. (Su min) o Each gioup piesents (both pait 1 anu pait 2 of theii piesentations). o Aftei each piesentation, the teachei gives stuuents a minute to fill out theii peei- evaluation sheet. 63%-'$, Reflection on othei quest naiiatives (1u minutes): 129 Review youi piesentation notes on othei stuuents quest naiiatives. 0f these quest naiiatives piesenteu, which authois choices aie most inteiesting to you. Bow uo these choices affect the uevelopment of plot. Incluue examples fiom at least S uiffeient stoiies in youi 1- paiagiaph ieflection. H3#,$"2#, 4#$2#,C),- L%$ N,P #,2(J)"C <2#,$)23
To ie-teach piesentation skills, the teachei coulu highlight specific aspects of piesenting (e.g., bouy postuie, eye contact, pacing, etc.) anu mouel goou anu bau examples foi each. To fuithei heighten stuuents sensitivity to these aspects of a piesentation, the teachei coulu cieate an in- class gioup exeicise in which each table takes notes on positive anu negative aspects of S piesentations (taken fiom a goveinment website oi even youtube.com). N,L,$,"(,- 50)#J)" #J)- 3,--%";
"Assessing Leaining: Peei anu Self Assessment." L,,5 ("- 8,.3 /00,00<,"$. The National Capital Language Resouice Centei, n.u. Web. u9 Nay 2u14.
Alighieri, Dante, Barry Moser, and Allen Mandelbaum. Inferno: A Verse Translation with Introduction by Allen Mandelbaum. Camp Hill, PA: Quality Paperback Book Club, 1980. Print.
Ambuyat, Gladys. "The Great English Writers." The Great English Writers. Slideshare, 19 July 2013. Web. 07 May 2014.
"Archetype." Encyclopaedia Britannica. Encyclopaedia Britannica Online Academic Edition. Encyclopdia Britannica Inc., 2014. Web. 07 May. 2014.
Campbell, Joseph. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton, NJ: Princeton UP, 1968. Print.
"Collective unconscious." Encyclopaedia Britannica. Encyclopaedia Britannica Online Academic Edition. Encyclopdia Britannica Inc., 2014. Web. 07 May. 2014.
Bailey, Charlene. "Naking the Niuule Ages Fun foi Teacheis anu Stuuents." '()#"* $+, '#--., /*,0 12" 345 6,(7+,50 ("- 8$2-,"$0. Louisiana Enuowment foi the Bumanities, 2uuu. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
Biemei, Chiistine B., Shaion vaughn, Ann T. Clappei, anu Ae-Bwa Kim. "Collaboiative Stiategic Reauing (CSR): Impioving Seconuaiy Stuuents Reauing Compiehension Skills." A,0,(57+ $4 L5(7$#7, G5#,30 1.2 (2uu2): n. pag. V,=0#$, 43 $+, P($#4"(. N,"$,5 4" 8,74"-(5> 9-27($#4" ("- 65(-#$#4". National Centei on Seconuaiy Euucation anu Tiauition. Web.
Biennan, Kiisten. "Stai Wais 0iigins - }oseph Campbell anu the Beio's }ouiney." 8$(5 V(50 K5#*#"0 X Y40,I+ N(<I=,.. ("- $+, C,54Z0 Y425",>. }itteibug Fantasia, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
"The Beai anu the Two Tiaveleis - ueneial Fable Collection." T,",5(. 1(=., N4..,7$#4". AesopFables.com, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
6+, N(<,.4$ L54O,7$. The 0niveisity of Rochestei, n.u. Web.
Caimichael, Ashley. "Aithuiian Legenu." 9"*.#0+ : ;472<,"$0 => !"#$. Winston Salem Foisyth County Public Schools, n.u. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
"Chaiacteiization." A,(- V5#$, 6+#"). National Council of Teacheis of English, 2uu4. Web.
Cohen, S. Naic. "Allegoiy of the Cave." /..,*45> 43 $+, N(F,. Washington 0niveisity in St. Louis, 2uu6. Web. u4 Nay 2u14.
Cuiiin, Nathan. "King Aithui & The Knights of the Rounu Table | Bistoiy, Legenu anu Eveiything in Between." ?#"* /5$+25 @ 6+, ?"#*+$0 43 $+, A42"- 6(=., B C#0$45>D E,*,"- ("- 9F,5>$+#"* #" G,$H,,". Live Peison, 2uu1. Web. u7 Nay 2u14.
Slade, Benjamin. "Beowulf on Steorarume [Beowulf in Cyberspace]: Bede's Account of the Poet Caedmon & Caedmon's Hymn." Beowulf on Steorarume [Beowulf in Cyberspace]: Bede's Account of the Poet Caedmon & Caedmon's Hymn. Benjamin Slade, n.d. Web. 07 May 2014.
van Bei Linuen, Sanuei. "The Science Behinu Bieaming." 87#,"$#3#7 /<,5#7(" (2u11): n. pag. 87#,"$#3#7 /<,5#7(" K".#",. Scientific Ameiican, 26 }une 2u11. Web.
1S6 APPENDIX A: ADDITIONAL RESOURCES The Power of Myth: a 6-part PBS documentary featuring Joseph Campbell, the author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces What Makes a Hero?: a Ted-Ed Video explaining the Heros Journey (http://ed.ted.com/lessons/what-makes-a-hero-matthew-winkler) The Heros Quest: In this essay on Tolkien, W. H. Auden proposes his own model for the Heros Quest, which varies slightly from that of Joseph Campbell. I chose to use Campbells The Heros Journey because it is by far the most widely used, but there are many variants of the same general structure. o Auden, W. H. "The Hero's Quest." Tolkien and the Critics: Essays on J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. By Neil David Isaacs and Rose A. Zimbardo. Notre Dame: U of Notre Dame, 1968. N. pag. Print. Jung, C. G. The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. New York: Pantheon, 1959. Print.
1S7 APPENDIX B BRIDGING ENGLISH RESOURCES/ACTIVITES Archetypal (p. 167): Here, Milner and Milner provide a concise and accurate overview of Archetypal criticism, from its roots in Platonic thought to its place in Jungian theory. Collaborative Authors (pp. 131-133): I adapted several of the strategies and insights of this section to my activities for reading Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. I have students write an internal monologue of Gawains thoughts approaching the climax. I also have students act out moments that parallel the text, but use this activity before we begin reading the text, as opposed to after, so that students are familiar with the general plot structure beforehand. Synergistic Texts (p. 130): I adapted this strategy for lesson 1, in which students are instructed to write the three most important points from a scientific article and a PowerPoint presentation on the importance of dreams. As in Bridging English, the students use a Venn diagram to organize how these two perspectives interrelate. Venn Diagramming (pp. 148-9): The insights on how Venn Diagramming can be used to encourage analysis and synthesis were helpful for my planning of lesson 1. Trio Tales (pp. 99-101) The group brainstorm activity of lesson 5 draws its inspiration from Trio Tales, but is quite different. Instead of providing multiple options for characters, settings, and resolutions, the teacher merely writes 3 seemingly unrelated words and instructs each small group to brainstorm a character, a setting, and a premise for a quest. Personal Triggers (p. 128): Throughout the unit, students are prompted to reflect on personal experiences before engaging with a text (see, for example, the bell-ringers of lessons 1, 4, and 6). 1S8 Free Writing (p. 123): Several free writing prompts are interspersed throughout the unit so that students can formulate their thoughts on paper informally before engaging in partner, small-group, or whole-class discussion (see, for example, the bell-ringer of lesson 6). Students Write (pp. 157-158): The structure of my unit as a whole is organized around the premise that after students have written their own stories, they are positioned to consider what they did and, in turn, to more consciously understand the choices authors make as well (p 157-158) Enactment (pp. 248-249): The concept of having students enact a text before analyzing it formally is central to my activities in Lesson 4. Story Drama (p. 254): The insights of this section, especially students need of visualizing the action in a story, are highly relevant to my approaches to teaching both major texts in this unit. After reading Le Morte dArthur, students make a visual storyboard of key actions and symbols. Before beginning Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, students act out original skits that parallel major plot points in the story.
1S9 APPENDIX C ORIGINAL PLANNING SHEET Backward Mapping Unit Plan 94-(('(/ %"##3
0nit Title: Neuieval Quests Subject Aiea Content: Biitish Liteiatuie - emphasis on the meuieval iomance tiauition. uiaue Level: English 4
Final Piouuct
Bow will you know if stuuents have cieateu a quality piouuct. In othei woius, "what" will you assess anu how.
St udent s wi l l creat e a narrat i ve fol l owi ng medi eval romance conve St udent s wi l l creat e a narrat i ve fol l owi ng medi eval romance convent i ons nt i ons (i ncl udi ng at l east 3 sust ai ned symbol s) al ong wi t h a 1 (i ncl udi ng at l east 3 sust ai ned symbol s) al ong wi t h a 1- - paged anal ysi s of i t s paged anal ysi s of i t s symbol i sm. The narrat i ve shoul d i ncl ude a vi sual component and a pl ot i n symbol i sm. The narrat i ve shoul d i ncl ude a vi sual component and a pl ot i n keepi ng wi t h t he medi eval quest convent i ons. keepi ng wi t h t he medi eval quest convent i ons. The final summative assessment shoulu incluue: 1) a 2-pageu naiiative with a well-uevelopeu plot (exposition, conflict, iising action, climax, uenouement) with a "heio" (piotagonist chaiacteiizeu with paiticulai viituesvices), a "quest" (a challengeconflicttest that biings out the heioes qualities), anu a system of symbols (at least thiee) that come togethei to foim an allegoiical meaning foi the text. 2) a visual component piesenteu alongsiue the naiiative. This coulu be an illuminateu manusciipt (uigitally oi by hanu) oi a posteiPoweiPointviueo supplement (othei iueas must be appioveu by the teachei). These illustiations shoulu iepiesent the symbols of the stuuent's allegoiy. anu S) a 1-pageu analysis of the naiiative's allegoiy. The analysis must incluue a) a thesis statement pioposing a cential allegoiical meaning foi the "quest" (aigue foi a specific inteipietation of what the quest symbolizes) b) a ieauing of at least S symbols in the text (explain how they suppoit youi inteipietation of the allegoiy).
The illustiateu naiiative anu the analysis will be evaluateu sepaiately, but the scoies will be auueu togethei to ueteimine the stuuent's final giaue. By ieauing the stuuents' naiiatives anu analyses, I will be able to ueteimine 1) the stuuents' masteiy of the naiiative wiiting moue 2) the stuuents' unueistanuing of the meuieval "quest" naiiative conventions anu S) the stuuents' unueistanuing of allegoiy (sustaineu symbolism). 14u What seiies of lessonsactivities will you neeu to covei in oiuei to suppoit stuuents' piogiess.
Instructional Unit Plan
For st udent s t o gai n t he ski l l s t o compl et e t hi s proj ect , t hey must fi rst gai n a deep underst andi ng of For st udent s t o gai n t he ski l l s t o compl et e t hi s proj ect , t hey must fi rst gai n a deep underst andi ng of medi eval t ext s (bot h medi eval t ext s (bot h t he l i t eral and i nferent i al meani ng). The t wo cent ral t ext s wi l l be 1) excerpt s t he l i t eral and i nferent i al meani ng). The t wo cent ral t ext s wi l l be 1) excerpt s from Si r Gawai n and t he Green Kni ght and t he Mort e dArt hur (bot h i ncl uded i n modern Engl i sh from Si r Gawai n and t he Green Kni ght and t he Mort e dArt hur (bot h i ncl uded i n modern Engl i sh i n t he Prent i ce Hal l t ext book). Before begi nni ng t hese t wo t ext s, t he st udent i n t he Prent i ce Hal l t ext book). Before begi nni ng t hese t wo t ext s, t he st udent s must fi rst 1) s must fi rst 1) demonst rat e knowl edge of Art huri an Legend (hi st ory, charact ers, l egends) Thi s can be accompl i shed demonst rat e knowl edge of Art huri an Legend (hi st ory, charact ers, l egends) Thi s can be accompl i shed by format i ve assessment s (wri t i ng warm by format i ve assessment s (wri t i ng warm- - ups/ cl osers, organi zat i onal chart s, qui zzes) admi ni st ered ups/ cl osers, organi zat i onal chart s, qui zzes) admi ni st ered aft er l ect ures and duri ng act i vi t i es. In bet w aft er l ect ures and duri ng act i vi t i es. In bet ween readi ng sessi ons, st udent s must demonst rat e een readi ng sessi ons, st udent s must demonst rat e underst andi ng of romance quest convent i ons (dream vi si on, quest / chal l enge, moral symbol i sm, underst andi ng of romance quest convent i ons (dream vi si on, quest / chal l enge, moral symbol i sm, i mport ance of set t i ng) i n format i ve assessment s (warm i mport ance of set t i ng) i n format i ve assessment s (warm- - ups/ cl osers, organi zat i onal chart s, i n ups/ cl osers, organi zat i onal chart s, i n- - cl ass cl ass group act i vi t i es) group act i vi t i es) . .
St udent s must al so demonst rat e t he abi l i t y t o wri t e a narrat i ve (W 3, W4, and W5), anal yze a l i t erary St udent s must al so demonst rat e t he abi l i t y t o wri t e a narrat i ve (W 3, W4, and W5), anal yze a l i t erary t ext (RL 1, RL4, RI1, RI4, RI9, SL1), wri t e a 5 paragraph essay organi zi ng t hi s anal ysi s (RL 5, RI 5, t ext (RL 1, RL4, RI1, RI4, RI9, SL1), wri t e a 5 paragraph essay organi zi ng t hi s anal ysi s (RL 5, RI 5, SL6). Lucki l y, t he st udent s have al ready submi t t e SL6). Lucki l y, t he st udent s have al ready submi t t e d a narrat i ve wri t i ng pi ece at t he begi nni ng of t he d a narrat i ve wri t i ng pi ece at t he begi nni ng of t he semest er and recei ved descri pt i ve feedback. They wi l l have al so fi ni shed a research paper, compl et e semest er and recei ved descri pt i ve feedback. They wi l l have al so fi ni shed a research paper, compl et e wi t h a t hesi s st at ement and support i ng evi dence. Thi s uni t wi l l bui l d on t hese t wo ski l l wi t h a t hesi s st at ement and support i ng evi dence. Thi s uni t wi l l bui l d on t hese t wo ski l l - - set s and appl y set s and appl y t hem t o l i t erary anal ysi s. Therefore, mai n ski l l t hat must be model ed for t he st udent s i s l i t erary t hem t o l i t erary anal ysi s. Therefore, mai n ski l l t hat must be model ed for t he st udent s i s l i t erary anal ysi s. As such, near t he begi nni ng of t he uni t t he t eacher wi l l present 2 anal ysi s. As such, near t he begi nni ng of t he uni t t he t eacher wi l l present 2- - 3 exampl e st udent anal yses 3 exampl e st udent anal yses of l i t erary t ext s. Then, st udent s wi l l spl i t i nt o sma of l i t erary t ext s. Then, st udent s wi l l spl i t i nt o sma l l groups t o provi de descri pt i ve feedback for t hese l l groups t o provi de descri pt i ve feedback for t hese t hree sampl e st udent s (poi nt i ng out t he st rong and weak poi nt s). The next l esson, t he st udent s wi l l t hree sampl e st udent s (poi nt i ng out t he st rong and weak poi nt s). The next l esson, t he st udent s wi l l compl et e an i n compl et e an i n- - cl ass anal ysi s of an excerpt (from Si r Gawai n). In t hi s anal ysi s, t hey wi l l i dent i fy t he cl ass anal ysi s of an excerpt (from Si r Gawai n). In t hi s anal ysi s, t hey wi l l i dent i fy t he l i t eral and symbol i c meani ng and support t hei r cl ai ms wi t h t ext ual evi dence. The next day, st udent s l i t eral and symbol i c meani ng and support t hei r cl ai ms wi t h t ext ual evi dence. The next day, st udent s wi l l exchange anal yses and engage i n peer edi t i ng, hi ghl i ght i ng t he a) ID of l i t eral meani ng i n 1 col or wi l l exchange anal yses and engage i n peer edi t i ng, hi ghl i ght i ng t he a) ID of l i t eral meani ng i n 1 col or b) t he symbol i c i n anot her and c) t he t ext ual evi den b) t he symbol i c i n anot her and c) t he t ext ual evi dence i n anot her. st udent s wi l l t hen poi nt out ce i n anot her. st udent s wi l l t hen poi nt out st rengt hs and short comi ngs of t he anal ysi s. st rengt hs and short comi ngs of t he anal ysi s.
To encourage creat i vi t y and brai nst ormi ng for t he fi nal proj ect , st udent s wi l l compl et e a t el ephone To encourage creat i vi t y and brai nst ormi ng for t he fi nal proj ect , st udent s wi l l compl et e a t el ephone composi t i on act i vi t y. The st udent s wi l l be gi ven a prompt for a n composi t i on act i vi t y. The st udent s wi l l be gi ven a prompt for a narrat i ve begi nni ng t hat i s arrat i ve begi nni ng t hat i s commensurat e wi t h t he romance quest convent i ons. Each st udent wi l l have 5 mi nut es t o wri t e a commensurat e wi t h t he romance quest convent i ons. Each st udent wi l l have 5 mi nut es t o wri t e a paragraph. Then, st udent s wi l l pass t hei r unfi ni shed quest t o t he person behi nd t hem (repeat 4 more paragraph. Then, st udent s wi l l pass t hei r unfi ni shed quest t o t he person behi nd t hem (repeat 4 more t i mes). By t he end, each group of t i mes). By t he end, each group of 5 st udent s wi l l have a 5 co 5 st udent s wi l l have a 5 co- - aut hored 5 aut hored 5- - paragraph quest s. Then, each paragraph quest s. Then, each st udent wi l l have 5 mi nut es t o i l l ust rat e t hei r manuscri pt (i n t he st yl e of an i l l umi nat ed manuscri pt , st udent wi l l have 5 mi nut es t o i l l ust rat e t hei r manuscri pt (i n t he st yl e of an i l l umi nat ed manuscri pt , whi ch wi l l be i nt roduced at t he begi nni ng of t he cl ass). Then, for 5 mi nut es each gro whi ch wi l l be i nt roduced at t he begi nni ng of t he cl ass). Then, for 5 mi nut es each gro up wi l l share t he up wi l l share t he common t hemes and symbol s used i n t hei r respect i ve st ori es. Then, for t he l ast 10 mi nut es, each common t hemes and symbol s used i n t hei r respect i ve st ori es. Then, for t he l ast 10 mi nut es, each group wi l l t ake t urns shari ng (i nformal present at i ons). group wi l l t ake t urns shari ng (i nformal present at i ons).
Lat er format i ve assessment : have each st udent creat e a st oryboard for t hei r quest . Lat er format i ve assessment : have each st udent creat e a st oryboard for t hei r quest . Each st udent Each st udent must i ncl ude 1 frame for each of Audens 6 el ement s of a quest . Thi s cl ass can move from group work must i ncl ude 1 frame for each of Audens 6 el ement s of a quest . Thi s cl ass can move from group work (pl anni ng 6 el ement s), t o i ndi vi dual (worki ng on st ory board) t o group (shari ng, refl ect i ng, peer (pl anni ng 6 el ement s), t o i ndi vi dual (worki ng on st ory board) t o group (shari ng, refl ect i ng, peer - - edi t i ng). edi t i ng).
141 APPENDIX D INDIVIDUAL LEARNER PROFILES - Naicus: IEP o ieauing compiehension: Naicus eaineu 8u% accuiacy in ieauing compiehension on a 9th giaue level. Be continues to have tiouble sequencing events when they have not sequenceu them in the text. Be also stiuggles to finu the infeiential meaning of a text. uiaphic oiganizeis aie helpful. Be also stiuggles to stay focuseu on the task at hanu anu often misses notes o wiiting: Naicus has impioveu his wiiting. Bowevei, he continues to stiuggle with the pie-wiiting anu euiting stages of wiiting. Focuseu uesciiptive feeuback on his uiafts is helpful. o accommouations: extenueu time (Time anu a half foi classioom, uistiict, state, ACT testing), testing in sepaiate setting, ieau alouu upon iequest, computei ieau alouu when available. o mouifications: Abbieviateu assignments when seveial uays aie misseu fiom school baseu on meuical issues. - Baniel: LEP o Language: Spanish; English pioficiency: Reauing - S.1, Wiiting - S.6; o accommouations: extenueu time (time anu a half foi classioom, uistiict, state, ACT testing); use of uictionaiy anu tianslatoi, ESL seivices o mouifications: none - Chiistophe: o Reauing Becouing: Baseu on the Biigance, past testing, anu woik samples, Chiistophe is able to ieau many simplei mateiials wiitten on giaue level. Be uoes neeu extia time to mastei long lists of moie complex vocabulaiy. Bis functional skills aie age appiopiiate. Be is able to leain many teims by using memoiy techniques. Bis ieauing skills uo hinuei him to a uegiee because of his pooi uecouing skills anu these weaknesses may hinuei him at the post seconuaiy level. o Reauing Compiehension: Chiis is able to ieau shoit simple ieauing passages on giaue level. Be continues to have moie pioblems with longei passages with highei level vocabulaiy oi technical teims. Bis functional ieauing skills aie age appiopiiate. Bis weaknesses in the aiea of ieauing compiehension with moie complex ieauing 142 mateiial uoes hinuei his classioom peifoimance anu may hinuei him at the post seconuaiy level. Chiis continues to uo best with mateiial that he can ielate to thiough his own past expeiiences. i. Annual uoal: Chiistophe will ieau longei ieauing passages in his novel anu liteiatuie books, given assistance as neeueu, anu he will answei highei level compiehension questions with 8S% accuiacy ii. shoit-teim goals: Chiistophe will pieuict logical outcome oi uiaw conclusions thiough familiai expeiiences, fiom given facts oi infeiences, anu fiom cause-anu-effect ielationships with 8S% accuiacy. iii. Chiistophe will answei liteial, evaluative, anu infeiential questions at 1uth giaue level with 8S% accuiacy o Wiiting: Chiistophe has impioveu in the aiea of wiiting, howevei, baseu on wiiting samples anu piogiess iepoits fiom his coie classes he continues to uisplay weaknesses in the aiea of euiting. Bis spelling skills aie still weak anu he neeus to use spell check to euit his woik. Be also is still weak in his piewiiting techniques causing his wiiting to lack goou oiganization. Chiistophe's functional skills aie age appiopiiate. Bis weak euiting skills uo have a negative impact on his classioom wiiting peifoimance anu may hinuei him at the post seconuaiy level. o accommouations: Extenueu time, Testing in Sepaiate Room, Reau alouu, Stuuent Naiks in Book, Teacheiclass notes.