Teaching Active Listening Skills at Lily Corporation: Learning Design In the context analysis already submitted, Lily Corporation has asked their employees to improve their listening skills to increase the collective intelligence, spirit, and harmony of the company (Keyser, 2013). The content analysis proposed the development of an online, asynchronous course that uses discussion boards, multimedia, and other engaging technology to teach active listening skills. The purpose of this document is to present the instructional design for the proposed course entitled Active Listening. This course is designed to employ real world, relevant scenarios that engage the students and challenge them to not only understand what it means to listen actively, but to become active listeners. Course Overview The Active Listening course is an eight hour, online learning course that teaches students how to be engaging and efficacious listeners. The course description is as follows: Have you ever been told that you dont listen? Most people have, but dont know why. Thats because most people think they are inherently good listeners, when in fact, listening is a skill that must be learned. In this course you will learn how to be an effective listener when communicating with work colleagues and customers. You will also learn the benefits to be derived by both you and Lily Corporation when using this skill. This course emphasizes how to employ active listening skills when communicating with coworkers and customers face-to-face, over the phone, and via written discourse. You will explore and practice listening skills through class readings, written assignments, Gail Wingate 2 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
online discussion boards, simulated video clips, audio recordings, and web-based conferencing tools. By successfully completing this course, you will achieve greater concentration, comprehension, sensitivity, objectivity, and responsiveness when communicating with your work colleagues and customers. Measurable Learning Objectives The following learning objectives explain how students will use the skills they acquire upon successfully completing this course and returning to work. Students will use the objectives to understand what they will learn, the benefits to them and Lily Corporation, and expectations for their performance. This course design expresses the objectives through observable, external events. Upon successful completion of this course, students will be able to: Recognize the difference between active and passive listening when engaging in conversation with coworkers. o The instructor will measure this objective by grading a written essay according to a rubric. Students are expected to receive a grade of at least 70% to demonstrate competency. The instructor will also measure this objective by evaluating the students participation in the online discussion forum related to this topic. Exercise active listening skills in different types of conversations, such as one-on-one and in group meetings, over the phone, and via written discourse. Gail Wingate 3 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
o Students will participate in the different types of conversations with their classmates. Each participant in the conversation will grade their classmates performance according to a rubric. The instructor will oversee the conversations and also grade each students performance according to a rubric. The instructors grade will count for 75% of the overall grade, and the students grades for 25%. Each student is expected to receive an overall grade of at least 70% to demonstrate competency. Students will also produce a written essay practicing communication via written discourse. Each student is expected to receive at least 70% to demonstrate competency. Communicate with colleagues and customers, online and face to face, in an emotionally neutral manner, using verbal and nonverbal behaviors that engage the person with whom you are speaking. o The instructor will measure this objective by evaluating the students participation in the online discussion forum related to this topic. Summarize the key points of the conversation and ask questions when communicating with coworkers. o The instructor will measure this objective by grading a written essay according to a rubric. Students are expected to receive a grade of at least 70% to demonstrate competency. The instructor will also measure this objective by evaluating the students participation in the online discussion forum related to this topic.
Theoretical Background This online course will follow a Constructivist learning theory. The Constructivist learning theory promotes active learning that encourages students to participate in activities on their own and through collaboration with their peers (Harasim, 2012). In accordance with the Constructivist learning theory, students will learn how to actively listen by testing the theories presented, drawing their own conclusions, and sharing their conclusions with their peers, thus constructing their own knowledge. Specifically, the activities designed for this course require students to discuss, debate, practice, and identify solutions in a collaborative environment that simulates real world experiences (Ruey, 2010). The instructor provides the topics for discussion, and then guides and mediates the discussion between the students. Moreover, by offering this course online, students have the flexibility to study and learn at a time and place of their choosing. For example: Karagiorgi and Symeou (2005) say that students are more apt to learn and retain knowledge if situations posed by the instructor are relevant and meaningful in the real world. Thus, students will engage in different types of conversations to practice active listening in a variety of authentic situations. These activities enable students to engage in collaborative, contextualized learning by simulating and assuming an authentic role that is real in the authentic society (Ruey, 2010, p. 708). Karagiorgi and Symeou (2005) suggest that designers of Constructivist-based courses develop questions and problems that allow students to develop answers and resolutions based on their prior and new knowledge, thus promoting constructive Gail Wingate 5 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
learning and higher order thinking. Therefore, students will research topics, formulate ideas and opinions, and respond to questions or solve problems posed by the instructor. Students will discuss and debate their ideas and opinions with their classmates on a discussion board. Karagiorgi and Symeou (2005) explain that when students must explain, justify, debate, and negotiate their ideas and opinions, then learning is dynamic, engaging, realistic, and universal. Through collaborative learning, students will, as a matter of course, self-reflect on what they have learned. Karagiorgi and Symeou (2005) say self-reflection through collaborative learning is an important element of evaluation and is related to the development of metacognitive skills and self-reflexive processes (p. 21). Ruey (2010) says that the instructors role in facilitating learning is critical to fostering motivation, socialization, information exchange, knowledge construction, and goal achievement. In this course, the instructor will facilitate learning by stating objectives and assessment specifications, providing feedback to activities, summarizing discussions, and promoting participation and timeliness. Subject Matter Content This course design presents examples of subject matter content throughout. For example, students will view a video clip of a one on one conversation and discuss the listening skills they observe. In general, students will use course materials presented in the form of the course syllabus, suggested readings, discussion questions, audio and video clips and other sources. Gail Wingate 6 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
Students will create their own course content via discussion boards, written assignments, and activities. The learning management system will organize and present the content into four modules. In general, the course content will consist of explanations, examples, tips, and scenarios of using active listening skills in the workplace. Motivation Studies have shown that while online learning has proved to be as effective, if not more, than face to face learning, student completion rates in online courses are still lower (Boston, Diaz, Gibson, Ice, Richardson, & Swan, 2010). Keller and Lichtfield (2002) explain that a key to the successful completion of an online course is the students motivation to learn. Both external and internal forces motivate students; however, only external forces are within the scope of this course design. Further, in a learner centered, e-learning environment, students are externally motivated when they interact with the social, cognitive, and teaching elements of the course, the intersection of which provides a complete educational experience (Garrison, Anderson, & Archer, 2010). Table 1 presents the plan to motivate students based on the ARCS model of motivation. In the ARCS model, the course design defines a motivation plan for each category of student behavior (Gagn, Wager, Golas, & Keller, 2005). In its entirety, the motivation plan promotes a comprehensive learning experience by addressing one or more of the elements of social, cognitive, and teaching.
Table 1 Motivation Plan for Categories of Behavior Based on the ARCS Model. Category Subcategory Motivation Plan Attention Perceptual Arousal To start, this course will capture the students interest by asking them to reflect on their listening skills. Then, students will view and comment on a video clip illustrating passive listening and common listening mistakes. This activity is also intended to allow the students to become acquainted with one another. Inquiry Arousal Students will be given discussion questions that will require them to seek out information in addition to what is provided in the course, and ask the learner to formulate their own opinion in response. Variability The activities of the course will use a variety of media, such as online discussion boards, text, audio, and video, to address different learning styles and reinforce content. Relevance Goal Orientation This course will clearly define goals and objectives, and the relevance of the content to their existing listening skills and to the students work environment. In addition, this course will present real world scenarios for the students to assess and discuss that represent situations relevant to their own work experience. Motive Matching Students will discuss their communication experiences, and how they hope their relationships at work will change as a result of the successful completion of this course. Familiarity All activities in this course will present real world scenarios that reflect what the students experience at work, such as group meetings and customer phone conversations. Confidence Learning Requirements This course will state goals, objectives, requirements, and performance expectations tied to activities and evaluation criteria. Success Opportunities With clear guidelines and the presence of the instructor as moderator, students will discuss their ideas and opinions with their peers in a discussion forum that is positive and friendly, and fosters feelings of success and competency. Personal Control This course encourages students to research resources in addition to those provided. Also, when practicing active Gail Wingate 8 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
listening skills with their classmates, students will choose their own topic for discussion. Satisfaction Natural Consequences Students will participate in meaningful application opportunities by practicing active listening skills in conversations with their peers on a topic of their choice. Positive Consequences Student will receive feedback on their ideas and opinions presented on the discussion board, and on their participation and performance on tasks and activities. This course will provide guidelines to the students on how to respond to their classmates in a positive and thoughtful manner. Equity This course provides assessment specification and evaluation criteria for all activities that is consistent and equitable. Note: Adapted from Motivation Categories of the ARCS Model, by R. M. Gagn, W. W. Wager, K. C. Golas, and J. M. Keller, 2005, Principles of instructional design (5th ed.), p. 115. Copyright 2005 by Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, Inc. Assessment Strategies The purpose of assessments is to facilitate students construction of knowledge (Koohang, Riley, Smith, & Schreurs, 2009). All assessments in this course are formative, thus aligned to course and module objectives and content (Wang & Gearhart, 2006). Formative assessments allow both the student and instructor to monitor the students performance throughout the duration of the course (Wang & Gearhart, 2006). In this course design there are three types of assessments: individual, team, and instructor. As part of individual assessment, learners will formulate their own ideas and opinions, and present and justify them to their peers. Students are also asked to utilize media, such as video clips, and identify positive and negative listening behaviors based on their learning. This form of self-assessment will allow the students to assume responsibility for their learning (Koohang et al., 2009). Students will work with their classmates to practice active listening skills. At the conclusion of these team activities, students Gail Wingate 9 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
will assess their teammates performance based on a given set of criteria. The instructor will assess all activities giving value and perspective to students responses through deliberate and purposeful feedback. Feedback The strategies outlined in this course design, such as Constructivist learning, assessment, motivation, and learning objectives, cannot fully address how to promote engagement and learning without also addressing the concept of feedback. In fact, effective and timely feedback is vital in an online, asynchronous learning environment to minimize the feeling of isolation students may feel (Lewis & Hamid, 2006). Wang and Gearhart (2006) advise instructors to provide prompt feedback to help alleviate learner sense of alienation, correct misconceptions, and adjust learning progress in a timely manner (p. 72). While this course design cannot address the specific content of the feedback provided by the instructor, it does propose strategies for feedback that sets a standard for the instructor to follow. Specifically, the instructor will provide feedback to the students as follows: To promote critical thinking skills and knowledge construction, and foster a sense of community; In a timely manner and during conventional and unconventional work hours, such as in the evenings and on weekends; To assess individual items of work and overall performance, notating strengths and weaknesses; To highlight exemplary work; Gail Wingate 10 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
To encourage participation and provide deadline reminders; and To answer questions and concerns. At its start, this course will provide guidelines on qualitative feedback and netiquette to the students. Instructors will provide feedback that exemplifies the quality of feedback expected by the students. Instructors are expected to provide feedback to discussion board posts, questions, and concerns within twenty-four hours, and to written assignments within three days. Students can use the statistical reporting features of the learning management system to assess their participation on the discussion board, and their progress on tasks and activities. Course Outline The course outline that follows provides a sequence and duration of the learning objectives, individual and group activities, and assessments. The resources required to complete the activities are also included. Students perform all activities and assessments within the learning management system, except activities taking place over the phone which is naturally beyond the scope of any such system. There are four modules in total, each estimated to require two hours of each students time to complete.
Table 2 Course Module Outline with Description and Sequence Module Title Listening 101 Duration 2 hours Objective(s) Define active and passive listening. Describe why it is important to be a good a listener personally, and for the company. Identify what kind of listener you are. Resources Online Discussion Board Individual Activities Students will take a quiz that determines the type of listener they are. Students will write a 700 word essay describing their perception of their listening skills versus the results of the quiz. Students will complete the class readings and respond to the discussion questions. Assessment The instructor will assess the students based on their participation in the online discussion topics and whether they address the topics completely. Students are also expected to respond to at least one other classmates posting. Discussion Topics Describe the type of listener you are? Based on your understanding of the modules readings and the definitions of active and passive listening, do you need to improve your skills? Please explain.
Module Title Barriers to Listening Duration 2 hours Objective(s) Define your role as a listener in a conversation or meeting. Explain how your emotions affect your listening skills. Discuss the verbal and nonverbal cues that help or hinder communication. Resources Video clip illustrating communication between two persons, one of which is very emotional. Video clip of two persons communicating that illustrates verbal and nonverbal cues. Online Discussion Board Individual Activities Students will view the video clips, complete the class readings, and respond to the discussion questions. Assessment The instructor will assess the students based on their participation in the online discussion topics and whether they address the topics completely. Students are also expected to respond to at least one other classmates posting. Discussion Topics Discuss the emotions displayed in the video clip that helped or Gail Wingate 12 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
hindered the conversation. Discuss the verbal and nonverbal cues displayed in the video clip that helped or hindered the conversation. Discuss methods you can personally use to stay emotionally neutral during conversations.
Module Title Active Listening Techniques Duration 2 hours Objective(s) Explain what is meant by hearing the speaker. Interpret what the speaker is saying. Evaluate what the speaker is saying. Respond to the speaker. Illustrate online active listening skills by responding via written discourse. Resources Video clip of a hostage negotiator communicating with the hostage taker. Video clip of a group meeting. Video clip of a one on one conversation in an office setting. Audio clip of a conversation between two persons. Email question/answer samples between consultant and customer. Online Discussion Board. Individual Activities Students will write a response to a customer question and post their response to the discussion board for peer review. Students will view the video clips, complete the class readings, and respond to the discussion questions. Assessment The instructor will assess the students based on their participation in the online discussion topics and whether they address the topics completely. Students are also expected to respond to at least one other classmates posting. Discussion Topics Explain how the hostage negotiator interpreted, evaluated, and responded to the speaker. Assess what went wrong in the group meeting and what the manager could have done to improve the communication. Interpret what you heard on the audio clip. Choose one customer question and provide a response.
Module Title Lets Listen Duration 2 hours Objective(s) Demonstrate active listening skills in a one on one conversation. Show active listening skills in a group meeting. Apply active listening skills during a phone conversation. Resources Online Discussion Board. Phone. Web-based conferencing tool. Gail Wingate 13 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
Group Activities Students will work in pairs to perform the one on one conversation and the phone conversation. The one on one conversation will take place using a web-based conferencing tool. Each conversation will last no more than 10 minutes. Students will work in teams of four to perform the group meeting. The group meeting will last no more than 20 minutes. The group meeting will take place using a web-based conferencing tool. Assessment Students will assess their own and their partners performance in the one on one and phone conversation. Students will assess their teammates performance in the group meeting. Students will use a rubric to complete the assessments. The instructor will assess students participation and performance in all group activities. Discussion Topics Reflect on your performance in the conversations, what you did right and wrong, and how you could have improved your performance. Discuss how your listening skills have changed since the start of this course. Conclusion This document outlines the instructional design for the Active Listening course. The design documents the course description, learning objectives, subject matter content, motivation plan, assessment strategies, and feedback strategies. This design includes an outline that defines components, such as the course modules, their sequence and duration, resources, activities, and assessments. The context analysis proposed that the course be based on the Constructivist learning theory. This document explains how the Constructivist theory has been applied to the instructional strategies included in this course design. The next step will be to prototype and develop this course. As a result of the detail in this document, course developers can deploy and iteratively modify the course while still maintaining the instructional design integrity of the course. A project plan for these next steps is forthcoming.
References Boston, W., Daz, S. R., Gibson, A. M., Ice, P., Richardson, J., & Swan, K. (2010). An exploration of the relationship between indicators of the community of inquiry framework and retention in online programs. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 14(1), 3-19. Retrieved from http://www.sloanconsortium.org/publications/jaln_main Gagn, R. M., Wager, W. W., Golas, K. C., & Keller, J. M. (2005). Principles of instructional design (5th ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning. Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2010). The first decade of the community of inquiry framework: A retrospective. Internet and Higher Education, 13, 5-9. doi:10.1016/j.iheduc.2009.10.003 Harasim, L. (2012). Learning theory and online technologies. New York, NY: Routledge. Karagiorgi, Y., & Symeou, L. (2005). Translating constructivism into instructional design: Potential and limitations. Educational Technology & Society, 8 (1), 17-27. Retrieved from http://www.ifets.info/ Keller J.M., & Litchfield B.C. (2002). Motivation and performance. In R.A. Reiser & J.V. Dempsey (Eds.), Trends and issues in Instructional Design and technology, (pp. 83-98). Columbus: Merrill Prentice Hall. Gail Wingate 15 June 13, 2014 DETT 607 Section 9020 Assignment 2: Learning Design
Keyser, J. (2013). Active listening leads to business success: Learning to be an active listener will increase your leadership capabilities--and guide you on a path toward personal and professional success. T+D, 67(7), 26-28. Retrieved from http://www.astd.org Koohang, A., Riley, L. & Smith, T. (2009). Elearning and constructivism: From theory to application. Interdisciplinary Journal of E-learning and Learning Objects, 5. Retrieved from http://www.informingscience.us/icarus/journals/ijello Lewis, C. C., & Abdul-Hamid, H. (2006). Implementing effective online teaching practices: Voices of exemplary faculty. Innovative Higher Education, 31(2), 83-98. doi: 10.1007/s10755-006-9010-z Ruey, S. (2010). A Case Study of Constructivist Instructional Strategies for Adult Online Learning. British Journal Of Educational Technology, 41(5), 706-720. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8535.2009.00965.x Wang, H., & Gearhart, D. L. (2006). Designing and Developing Web-Based Instruction. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.