Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 15

N

Lcl

0 1552.648
11.326
1456.5
20.663 1368.329

2.90

29.144 1293.714
36.888 1216.519
44.558 1137.569
52.348 1053.59
59.928 953.678
67.365 836.164
74.526 695.748
74.526 695.748
76.202 497.424
71.946 309.719
62.815 161.413
52.081
51.993
41.705
-36.36
31.886 -117.876
22.126
-199.73
11.731 -284.078
0
-369.36

ETABS
C45
C46
C47
C48
C49
C50
C54
C55
C57
C58

N
0 2294.858
25.954
47.171
66.265
83.698
100.078
117.394
134.972
152.711
170.79
170.79
175.305
159.444
139.853
118.468
95.675
73.073
50.557
26.782
0

2152.164
2018.384
1905.138
1790.124
1671.298
1546.831
1403.171
1233.758
1027.925
1027.925
739.85
486.693
274.902
100.958
-35.388
-152.556
-267.277
-388.776
-518.34

26.317
26.04
26.734
26.734
25.07
27.664
29.458
34.497
30.751
28.978

7.43
86.94
164.54
164.54
23.45
133.85
113.66
214.92
214.95
209.19

34.21
33.85
34.75
34.75
32.59
35.96
38.30
44.85
39.98
37.67

7.43
86.94
164.54
164.54
23.45
133.85
113.66
214.92
214.95
209.19

ETABS
C51
C52
C56
C59

M22

80.43
72.318
84.522
58.022

221.71
222.38
141.26
127.15

104.56
94.01
109.88
75.43

221.71
222.38
141.26
127.15

M
0
17.093
31.126
43.83
55.374
66.814
78.518
90.1

N
2294.858
2149.83
2016.812
1905.024
1789.644
1673.965
1548.848
1402.179

101.501 1229.646
112.824 1020.909
112.824 1020.909
115.1 734.952
107.614 470.254
93.31 263.055
77.421 107.036
62.202
-21.82
47.727 -142.054
33.225 -263.861
17.683 -389.809
0
-518.34

ETABS
M33
C51
C52
C56
C59

41.364
37.398
46.069
42.123

N
221.71
222.38
141.26
127.15

53.77
48.62
59.89
54.76

221.71
222.38
141.26
127.15

VEdu

46.85
55.51
63.01
65.30
48.73
60.11
58.13
66.11
66.11
65.76

32.31
38.28
43.45
45.03
33.61
41.46
40.09
45.59
45.59
45.35

1500
1000
Series1
500

Series2

0
20

40

91.94
93.10
85.12
84.72

60

80

100

30x45 - 10d14
2500
2000
1500
1000
N

133.31
134.99
123.42
122.85

2000

-500

VEdu

c2 =

30x30 - 8d14

Mcap

13.33

Mcap

fcd =

Series1
500

Series2

0
0

50

100

-500
-1000

150

200

45x30 - 10d14
2500
2000
1500

VEdu

89.10
89.17
81.46
79.80

61.45
61.49
56.18
55.03

1000
N

Mcap

500
0
0

50

100

-500
-1000

150

Series1
Series2

Series1
Series2

0
0.1
0.2

0
1.30
2.53

0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5

3.70
4.80
5.83
6.80
7.70
8.53
9.30
10.00
10.63
11.20
11.70
12.13
12.50
12.80
13.03
13.20
13.30
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33

2.6
2.7
2.8
2.9
3
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5

13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33

0.0000
0.0001

0.00
1.30

0.0002
0.0003
0.0004
0.0005
0.0006
0.0007
0.0008
0.0009
0.0010
0.0011
0.0012
0.0013
0.0014
0.0015
0.0016
0.0017
0.0018
0.0019
0.0020
0.0021
0.0022
0.0023
0.0024

2.53
3.70
4.80
5.83
6.80
7.70
8.53
9.30
10.00
10.63
11.20
11.70
12.13
12.50
12.80
13.03
13.20
13.30
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33

0.0025
0.0026
0.0027
0.0028
0.0029
0.0030
0.0031
0.0032
0.0033
0.0034
0.0035

13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.33

C20/25
14
12
10
Axis Title

8
6
4
2
0
0

2
Axis Title

Series1
Series2

C20/25

Series1

2
Axis Title

Story

Column

Load

Loc

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C51
C51
C51

NSXPSY
NSXNSY
PSYNSX

0
0
0

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51
C51

NSYNSX
PSXNSY
PSXPSY
GF
NSXPSY
NSXNSY
PSYNSX
NSYNSX
GF
PSYPSX
NSYPSX
PSYPSX
NSYPSX
NSYPSX
PSYPSX
PSXPSY
PSXNSY
GF
NSYNSX
PSYNSX
PSXPSY
PSXNSY
NSXNSY

0
2.75
2.75
0
1.375
1.375
1.375
1.375
1.375
0
0
1.375
1.375
2.75
2.75
1.375
1.375
2.75
2.75
2.75
0
0
2.75

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C51
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52

NSXPSY
GF
GF
GF
NSYNSX
NSYPSX
NSXNSY
NSYNSX
NSYPSX
NSXNSY
NSYNSX
NSXPSY
NSYPSX
PSXNSY
NSXNSY
NSXPSY
PSXNSY
PSXPSY
NSXPSY

2.75
0
1.375
2.75
0
0
0
1.375
1.375
1.375
2.75
0
2.75
0
2.75
1.375
1.375
0
2.75

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C52
C56
C56
C56

PSYNSX
PSXNSY
PSYPSX
PSXPSY
PSYNSX
PSYPSX
PSXPSY
PSYNSX
PSYPSX
GF
GF
GF

0
2.75
0
1.375
1.375
1.375
2.75
2.75
2.75
0
1.375
2.75

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C56
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59

NSYPSX
NSYNSX
NSYPSX
PSXNSY
NSYNSX
NSYPSX
PSXNSY
NSYNSX
PSXPSY
PSXNSY
PSXPSY
NSXNSY
PSXPSY
NSXNSY
NSXPSY
NSXNSY
PSYPSX
NSXPSY
PSYNSX
PSYPSX
NSXPSY
PSYNSX
PSYPSX
PSYNSX
NSYPSX
NSYNSX
PSXNSY
GF
NSXNSY
NSYPSX
PSXPSY
NSYNSX
PSXNSY
NSXNSY

0
0
1.375
0
1.375
2.75
1.375
2.75
0
2.75
1.375
0
2.75
1.375
0
2.75
0
1.375
0
1.375
2.75
1.375
2.75
2.75
0
0
0
0
0
1.375
0
1.375
1.375
1.375

STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1
STORY1

C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59
C59

NSXPSY
PSXPSY
GF
PSYNSX
NSXPSY
PSYPSX
NSXPSY
PSYPSX
PSYNSX
PSXPSY
PSYPSX
NSXNSY
PSYNSX
PSXNSY
GF
NSYNSX
NSYPSX

0
1.375
1.375
2.75
1.375
2.75
2.75
1.375
1.375
2.75
0
2.75
0
2.75
2.75
2.75
2.75

V2

V3

M2

M3

-234.9
-241.86
-230.99

-26.73
-26.61
-12.79

20.21
-1.97
47.35

-0.257
-0.682
0.569

29.61
-10.393
78.514

-41.364
-41.172
-17.576

-254.18
-244.58
-237.62
-383.8
-230.26
-237.22
-226.35
-249.54
-377.53
-234.59
-257.78
-229.95
-253.14
-248.5
-225.31
-242.27
-249.22
-371.27
-244.9
-221.71
-246.91
-253.86
-232.58

-12.39
13.62
13.5
-9.11
-26.73
-26.61
-12.79
-12.39
-9.11
-0.72
-0.32
-0.72
-0.32
-0.32
-0.72
13.5
13.62
-9.11
-12.39
-12.79
13.5
13.62
-26.61

-26.58
1.65
23.83
15.5
20.21
-1.97
47.35
-26.58
15.5
48.44
-25.49
48.44
-25.49
-25.49
48.44
23.83
1.65
15.5
-26.58
47.35
23.83
1.65
-1.97

-0.85
0.256
0.682
-0.001
-0.257
-0.682
0.569
-0.85
-0.001
0.85
-0.569
0.85
-0.569
-0.569
0.85
0.682
0.256
-0.001
-0.85
0.569
0.682
0.256
-0.682

-54.826
-8.541
-29.532
18.061
1.819
-7.686
13.403
-18.281
-3.247
80.43
-52.91
13.827
-17.857
17.197
-52.777
3.232
-6.273
-24.555
18.265
-51.708
35.997
-4.005
-4.979

-16.935
-10.022
-9.882
-9.644
-4.611
-4.584
0.01
0.098
2.876
3.006
3.646
3.997
4.085
4.524
4.989
8.68
8.706
15.396
17.131
17.596
27.242
27.434
32.003

-225.62
-369.15
-362.88
-356.62
-254.67
-252.06
-250.57
-250.03
-247.42
-245.93
-245.39
-244.46
-242.78
-241.88
-241.29
-239.81
-237.24
-235.76
-235.17

-26.73
3.92
3.92
3.92
-3.19
8.97
-17.47
-3.19
8.97
-17.47
-3.19
-17.55
8.97
23.08
-17.47
-17.55
23.08
23.01
-17.55

20.21
15.41
15.41
15.41
-21.37
-22.04
2.24
-21.37
-22.04
2.24
-21.37
21.81
-22.04
0.01
2.24
21.81
0.01
19.58
21.81

-0.257
-0.001
-0.001
-0.001
-0.85
-0.569
-0.682
-0.85
-0.569
-0.682
-0.85
-0.257
-0.569
0.256
-0.682
-0.257
0.256
0.682
-0.257

-25.971
17.973
-3.209
-24.392
-45.577
-46.753
-2.942
-16.195
-16.453
-6.023
13.186
32.427
13.847
-6.862
-9.103
2.44
-6.88
28.507
-27.547

32.142
4.07
-1.315
-6.701
-7.25
13.434
-31.549
-2.862
1.094
-7.525
1.527
-31.692
-11.245
37.398
16.499
-7.566
5.661
37.254
16.56

-234.27
-232.6
-231.67
-231.12
-229.63
-227.02
-226.48
-224.99
-222.38
-246.99
-240.72
-234.46

-3.44
23.08
8.73
23.01
-3.44
8.73
23.01
-3.44
8.73
14.5
14.5
14.5

43.86
0.01
43.19
19.58
43.86
43.19
19.58
43.86
43.19
-20.31
-20.31
-20.31

0.569
0.256
0.85
0.682
0.569
0.85
0.682
0.569
0.85
-0.001
-0.001
-0.001

72.318
-6.899
71.142
1.582
12.012
11.755
-25.342
-48.293
-47.631
-19.056
8.871
36.798

-7.728
-26.075
12.956
5.62
-2.999
0.957
-26.014
1.73
-11.042
15.216
-4.726
-24.669

-185.53
-181.09
-180.89
-180.02
-176.45
-176.25
-175.37
-171.81
-170.85
-170.73
-166.21
-165.23
-161.57
-160.59
-156.06
-155.94
-154.98
-151.42
-150.55
-150.34
-146.78
-145.9
-145.7
-141.26
-162.88
-169.95
-145.38
-222.94
-168.93
-158.24
-137.44
-165.31
-140.74
-164.29

13.67
2.7
13.67
28.12
2.7
13.67
28.12
2.7
29.54
28.12
29.54
-8.45
29.54
-8.45
-7.03
-8.45
18.39
-7.03
7.42
18.39
-7.03
7.42
18.39
7.42
-2.67
-14.18
12.71
-7.64
-25.67
-2.67
14.37
-14.18
12.71
-25.67

-46.11
-49.16
-46.11
-19.23
-49.16
-46.11
-19.23
-49.16
0.77
-19.23
0.77
-29.38
0.77
-29.38
-9.39
-29.38
20.55
-9.39
17.5
20.55
-9.39
17.5
20.55
17.5
-35.95
-33.75
-24.46
-20.93
-17.14
-35.95
-12.41
-33.75
-24.46
-17.14

-0.569
-0.85
-0.569
0.256
-0.85
-0.569
0.256
-0.85
0.682
0.256
0.682
-0.682
0.682
-0.682
-0.257
-0.682
0.85
-0.257
0.569
0.85
-0.257
0.569
0.85
0.569
-0.569
-0.85
0.256
-0.001
-0.682
-0.569
0.682
-0.85
0.256
-0.682

-78.488
-84.522
-15.083
-23.742
-16.927
48.322
2.697
50.668
17.15
29.135
16.092
-43.854
15.034
-3.45
-2.962
36.953
57.818
9.945
51.784
29.569
22.852
27.725
1.319
3.665
-58.022
-53.706
-33.638
-19.673
-19.251
-8.593
-8.421
-7.295
-0.012
4.318

16.762
-3.464
-2.034
43.434
-7.175
-20.83
4.769
-10.886
46.069
-33.896
5.458
-23.986
-35.152
-12.368
-21.351
-0.751
25.547
-11.679
5.321
0.265
-2.007
-4.876
-25.017
-15.073
-0.443
-21.24
27.201
-8.104
-42.123
3.224
30.098
-1.743
9.729
-6.826

-161
-132.8
-216.67
-134.21
-156.36
-127.15
-151.72
-131.79
-138.86
-128.16
-136.43
-159.65
-143.5
-136.1
-210.41
-160.67
-153.6

-24.01
14.37
-7.64
-8.63
-24.01
2.88
-24.01
2.88
-8.63
14.37
2.88
-25.67
-8.63
12.71
-7.64
-14.18
-2.67

-5.1
-12.41
-20.93
6.4
-5.1
4.2
-5.1
4.2
6.4
-12.41
4.2
-17.14
6.4
-24.46
-20.93
-33.75
-35.95

-0.257
0.682
-0.001
0.569
-0.257
0.85
-0.257
0.85
0.569
0.682
0.85
-0.682
0.569
0.256
-0.001
-0.85
-0.569

5.966
8.643
9.105
12.758
12.972
14.477
19.979
20.255
21.554
25.707
26.034
27.886
30.35
33.615
37.884
39.117
40.835

-39.226
10.339
2.4
12.162
-6.216
1.298
26.794
5.256
0.289
-9.42
9.214
28.472
-11.583
-7.742
12.903
17.755
6.891

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi