1. Producing no useful results 2. Pointless To learn how a poet creates a sense of misery To learn and explain how and why Owen used structure to create the tone of Futility Written in May 1918 Famously echoes Tennysons In Memoriam Tennysons poem questions the nature of death itself (regarded as one of the greatest poems of the 19 th century)
Futilitys title is taken from Tennysons line: O life as futile, then, as frail. Futility depicts a dead soldier, a country man whom the sun is unable to wake up, as it awakens seeds in the ground. Owen asks, Was man created for dying? And if so, what was the purpose of the creation? Owens message these deaths are utterly futile and no meaningful result arises from them.
It is, therefore, a philosophical poem.
The sun in Romantic Poetry is a symbol of life and a moral or creative force sometimes in opposition to God. The kind old sun is faithful because it always shines, but the line: Was it for this that the clay grew tall? (clay is the human body as opposed to the spirit) suggests a sense of religious questioning.
What is the purpose of life? Owen structures his poem into two stanzas. In the first, he shows us the dead soldier who cant be woken, personifies the sun as a kindly old man Then, in the second verse he takes a step back and questions life and the universe. Why is the sun bothering at all? Passive in stanza one tender in feeling for the dead soldier Rising anger in the second stanza as it moves to question the meaning and purpose of life.
Owen builds up a central point in this poem. How does he do this? LYRIC: a short poem, song-like and full of thought and emotional intensity Two regular stanzas seven lines each [sestet] The metrical pattern Iambic lines, first and last of each stanza with three feet (6 syllables), intervening ones with 4 feet (8 syllables)
is the effect of the authors words and tone on the reader. It is the feeling that an author sets or creates for the reader using carefully chosen words and phrases, as well as other devices such as repetition, rhyme, and hyperbole: the readers mood.
So, whats the mood in Futility and how does Owen create it?
Personification of the sun Whispering of sun speaks to him like a person Kind old sun - makes the sun a fatherly, almost grandfatherly, figure Fatuous (foolish, silly) sun beams Questioning the purpose of the life giving force
There is a simplicity of diction many monosyllables Move him into the sun The kind old sun will know Was it for this the clay grew tall Creates a sense of child-like questioning about the meaning and purpose of life
Annotate the poem, making sure you note: - what the poem is about; - The different techniques Owen uses and WHY he uses them - Speculate about WHY he might have written the poem - Note down your PERSONAL responses, your thoughts and feelings
What did you learn today?
On an exit-slip, write down:
1. 3 different ways Owen used techniques to create a sense of misery 2. Write one sentence about the tone of the poem Put these explanations in the right order (structure) Owen asks what makes pointless sun wake up the earth Owen says the dead soldier should be moved into the sun Owen considers how the universe created human beings who feel and have limbs Owen thinks if anything could wake the soldier it must be the sun What does futility mean? Why does this poem have this title? What once woke up the soldier in this poem? Owen personifies the sun. Why? What are the clays of a cold star in stanza 2? What is hard to stir? How would you describe the tone of this poem? Extension activities Write a critical essay on the poem, explaining why it is effective