LOCAL GOVERNMENTS

Law 15J r SY 2013-201+

hol. Ddtr! aonutun

Sections 3-B and

I-D

cndssshall becompulcd usingrhc lDllo$ii! b$es:

R..ndion s0% lri'ml Erm,i'mion 50%

Pld

l. I'Inxlrti.r: lliioD rid

Airid! X. l9lll ConiirIidr

Adn,i',GrdircCddc of 198t. Tirle
RITUblic cr )io il60 (199:)
Rcpublic Act N.
R.puhli! Acr No

69ii (1000).
sijl(19u8)

tll $

Bosic Cotr.cDts

'ctrdcd

\{ l ll

Rcpubli! Acl No 916l (1001)

lulintnnt\ R&xli'!t: t)vnie\'. kiu\', itgeeat

. Aqtrilir' Q. Pime{cl. r, lhc l.Ltrl Oorcnnr. (ndc of I99l: X.} ro NatioDl

Dc\clL,pn l L: ( ltrS)
. fhc \r.frd lri D...r/?/,1tr'1: Ruril'kr1* c,,dr,r!,r, ,, worLd DevclopNnt
'1. litrrcii,,c the I " C.ntui-a l0r l:l ( 1999)
ItqDn 199912000
. Al.ct\ 1,. I'atiuo. /t/r//.l.iht l\rlrloyt nt D\I'ldidr. i &.p.n- J!tu -a 2007.1
I'dt F'r.ury { r'$ Nhhls Jnd.Illn'lu\'in dc\uhrinr
|

t.. 1!o\\trn
D[ I-lioN

v.

r. llcan^li:nlion, unr,teh.t

lSCl:trtJ{,\.

li]

scR,\ 601(lr)3?l

sAN JUAN r.ClVlL SIR\'lLLCollr\llsSlON, l96scRA69(1991)

c^NZoN \ CA.100 sCl l?l (199l)
Br\S(O\ l'Accol{.197 S(RA 5l ( 91)l)
ivlicl,^JISI PRYcI I'ROPIilt ] ILs cORl'ORA I ION, l\.'f . :ll SCR 155(1991)

1.. 1 !,tdlr,s^ qlDitr^b.i,.r rrtidt:, ddotb\ow tgn a

See

Republic AclNo.712? (1992), !S l2 (L), l l

ABBAS v. COMEI-liC, lr9 SCRA:37 (l93tl

cIIIoNGBIAN !. ORBOS, 215 SCRl2j3 (1995)
CORDII-LLR.{ BROAD COAt-lllON v. COA- l3l SCR 195 (1990)
oltDlLLO! CONIELEC. l9lSCR^ i00(1990)

BACABUYov COMMlssloN oN ELllCllONs jTr SCld{190(l00lr)

TI IE IROVINCE Oll NORTH CO TABATO v. I l lE GOVERNMDN] Of_ l flll RIPU Bl.lC Ol'
TITE PHII-IPPINI]S PIACE P NELON ANCES TRAI- DOMAIN.563 SCRA 1i]: (]OO3)
5(d),5r6

Eafediviryofilrc code,
"*$

EVARDONF !. CoMELEC,lo.t SCRA 16,1(1991)

SECRETARYOFITE LTHv COLIRTOFAPPIj/\LS,ITI SClrA633(199t

frd

Rd.kl: cfl,e'alP.\isions

li(eOno l]3s.PiLr.iplcs

CREATER BiLANGA DEvELoPvENT CORPORATION

'fANO v. SOCRATES,173 SCRA

B 6c -d

P,

$e'

ctrdtioh tt L..dt

r'd

ahr btrtr\,

BALANG . lll9 scRA

154 (1991)

!t6.la

Govlrnat ltm^

conniloliof,
x, $$ r, r. 10, rl, ri. 16, le
^nr85 136,411-112,lc9110,.160 16l
I-CC 5!l 6 10,
RepublhActNo 7373(lee5)
Rqiubl,c Ac!No.3i7l {lee7), \ l3
Rqitrbl c dNo.9009 (200r)
Roptrb icAcrNo 9054(?00 ). rnLcelv, ! 19
See

ReNb ic Act No. 10170 (?012)

I)ADILLA v. CoMELEC, l l l SCl| 715 (1991)

TORR-{LBA v slBACAl, 1.17 SCRA 190 (193r)
CA\VAI-|NG v. COMELEC.163 SCRA 413 (20011
PELAEZ v AUDTTOR CENTR-^L, 15 SCtdr. 569 (196t
strMA v coMrl[c. 55 e scRA 700 (1003)
LAT^S v COMELEC. 4l? SCRA 601 (1001)
NAVARRO V. LX ECU I IVE SECRETARY ERMITA,

C R

No l30050,scpbn,cr

l.l0ll

li6

NIALAIIANU

BDNITO,l? SCRA

CANDII Y \. C
.JlNl[NEZr RAz.265

ill ( 969)

, 251 SCRA i:10 (1995)

SC

RA ll|:(1996)

rolrlAs !. ABALos, 2r9 scl{ 106 (199.1)

fASLC v COMLII-Ec. ill sCR^ rr911999)
Nl nl Nov colllllEc-24zsCL lll (l9ss)
MTl| ND,{ v AclrlRRh, rlr scR 601(1999)
sAl\1soNv CjLrlltRl. i l5 ScRA 5l (1999)

SULTAN USNIAN SAI]"\NCANl v. COi\lNllssioN ON ELECIIONS,lll SCI{A 379 (2000)

S LVA M KALIN fAL, I10 SCIIA 506(:000)

LVARLZv OUINCoNA, ?52 SCRA 69i (1996)

LEAcUr ot ClTllls Oli rHEPrrlLIPI'NESv coNlELEC CR 1769s1,.,uN23.2011

AQUINOI L!.CONlELEc.C.lt.No L397r,APrilr.20l0

ALDAITA r. COMELEC. C R. No. 133073, Janull} 25,:010

Cotrsiirurion,A,r

XvllI. \

cRliJoI cor!1tl.Ec,2llscR/\612(1991)
Sclcdion ard
S^NISON

li.,rltrofLo.ilCororrmcrr

sire, S Ll

ACU]RRE,3l5 SCIL4 5l (1999)

Polni.!lrM co.p.nreNrtr ol l-ocrLaover

LIDASANv cONlELEC,ll

ncnr Uins. S! 5 (d)

& l5

scl{

'196(1s67)
FONTANIL-1.,{.35 SC R/\ i99 (19r3)
CllYOf NIANILAv lAC, l79SCllA423(1939)
MACASIANo r. DlOKNo. ll2 SCRA 161 (1992)
TORIO

Cenmlwcll,rc ciNse, ! 16.391.ll7.'1jl..rd

463

AdNo. &169(199?), is 3 md rr
Rcpublc dNo.3125 (1997), $ r1
Rcp!blicAcrNo.31rs (1997),liS r0, ee. l0l
R+trbrtrAdNo 35j0 (ree3), !! r6 r5
RcpubllcAdNo 3S75 (2000), ri$r. rl. rl
Rep rrrcAdNo 9275 (2004), ! ?0
ReplblicAcrNo 101?l (1009). l Ll l2
Repub ic

U.S r SAL VERIA,S9PrI l0l(1913)

VIRAY v CALoocAN.20 SCR,{ 191(1967)
BALACLnT v. CFt, r6:t SCRA t3l (t933)
BINAY v. DOIVIINCO 201 scRA i03 (1991)
CllY COVERNMjTNI Of QUEZON CITY v. lltlc
PATALINCHUo v cA.ll9 SCRA i5J(1991)

lll

SCR^ ?i9 (193i)

RUMLBANKOFMAKATI,Th-C r.M(JNTCIPALITYOFllt\KATl,131SCR^16l(3004)
TAYABANv fEoFLEOI' lllEPllll,IPPINEs. sl7SctrA.l33(100r)
BAYAN I ERMITA.ls3sCl{ 226 (2006)

Repubric

AclNo

9165 (r002).

!S'

5l

'lA lljL v vlR^C,207 SCRA ll7 (l99ll

ESTATE oF Ft{Nclsco v C,\.l99 SCRA595(199 )
TECTINOLOOY DEVELoPERS,INC. v. C^, l9l SCRA

.^OtO,iv

ASILO v. PEOPLEOF THE

117 (1991)

li90lr,Mrd,9,l0rl

PHll-

RdptrbrLcAdN. 3?49,q{ ? lr, 16,20,24,16,17,19

Reptrblic crNo.9001(2001), S$ l0 13, l6 2:.,11 11
Repubric Ad No. 3is0. slj r 6 ?s
Basc Senices

lfd

FaciLiies,

l7

PLAZA ll v. CASSION,,ll5 ScIlA29.](1004)

FFECTED HOMEOWNLRS OI'

\i
COMLISSION v Y!. C R No. 139011. J"ly il. l0ll

CIVIL SERVICE
PIMENTEL I ]t. !. EX ECU'IIVE SECRETARY, C R NO
LEACUD OF PROVINCI:S OF T
ANDNATURII-REsOlJRcEs.cR No l?5163.ApnL ll,20ll

TANO v. SOClrAl ES. 173 SCI|A Iii (199?)

LACUN LAKI] DEVI]I,OPMEN'I AUTHORIlY
LAND TRANSPORTATTON OFFICE

COURT OF APPE LS,

]5I

CjTY Ot AUTUAN,12 SCRA 805 (1000)

SCRA

]]

l'$\e
lo

be

1o

C0r.rxle Lttrutru.

iLiu*sft s

R! ! 6r. L9rr

pxn

lri

oft'M

l{L.rol a,\, Pn,Jidue

BIRA\Cr\\'SAN l{(JQLrllr llnRSo|i|ASTOR lllSCRA l17(:000)

!lral ll AN \ aL I \ Ol' [lANDAI-(]YoNC. ll3 SCRA ili (1000)
CllY()l C:ll{l\ CLrLlRTOli,\r'FALS lj3 SCRA 175 (lt96l
lLlLrclLY 0r rLUU r DIDAN1o. ]3i !CRA 7tl (100:l
fLr-s l RliA\l l\lnRNA l lo-!IL lNa v f0Lll{l of PPI,^LS l3r stR \ rl6 (1993)
sERR^No. it s(R \ lrl (r001)
\ ,\CUlL.\R.:150s(rRA.r8r(r001)
MA\LrlL-rl\rJNC
CITY Of_
SARDLl-l-ON v Nt\Slll..l0l Sal{t lJ0(1001)
fltANCl^ \ Nlt Nlrll'r\l lTl'ol'lllLYc]\lI\'4N.519 SCld\ 5i (1003)
Jr.,iL:s Ls r()RDclrRrsrlN scriooL FoLND^TloN. L\c ! N1!NlClPALllYOr
P.\SLc. N,rL t() [],\NrLA.166 SCRA ll5 (:00j)
Illt lRr\NSPORl^l()NOFFlCli\ COPllCO l6lSClt/\5llil00j)
RerLrs ficx'iD

l\d

oji! "l\ l:0

I rn! dn. (J'd{ No.l6l (199i)

[!t l!\!

,..i.,.

Nv3rr(llrri q1

rjr REIL

Lr\r\firFR

sLcRrll^RYol

LSf,\'lLl /\ND |UIIDERS ASSOCIATION. INC

ail{AltLlNitEl'oltu.CR ^_D l3lllr'r..lur! 13.:010

CIL\urc xrd

oNrtr! !r R.x,ls.l:iL

DAc/\N'\Y

Tllll

r9i sc R \:rll (le9li

ASlsllo,:08 saRA 101 (l9er)

arTYor \rn:!rl,\ r ric. L,'9 5aRA l:l (1939)

l,RO\rlr E ( )1, z,^l\18( t\Nc,\ \ C fYOLj/,\Nllro,\NCA.llSCRr\
r: 5L Ri 6j611971)
AdliDiLr

hN.S.rirk

SedLrcCrtr6. \

li

l(1961)

ll

rhlllJ tulhmgt\, ! lr
Nq\ cnilcod.. l\dicls:11.:l30. r rJ:139
3?19, \ lj
l{.puL,l!
L

^d\!
Nrr.NDor^ \ DL LLON. I l'1,

:0ll (1916)

(l!r9l)
FlRi\lr: lei sarr^
'ier
R/\
rrr(
L9e:)
fr.RN^NDO\ a/\.:0$ !a
(itrlll-ll{(:r,\ir \ (;^NZO\. I s{ Rd:5i (1966)
Pll.Al{\ S^NCCUN \ANC tsAYAN NC D^SOL, t'A-\C/\Sl\AN. ll3 SCR^ li:l

(19311

'fuzoN v couRr oF APPIALS,2l] scRA 7re ( eel)

BALUYOT v COIIRT OF APPEALS,lll SCRA19(1999)
QUEZON CITY v. DACAIL\. 160 SCRA ?11 (100t
THE MLNICIPALITY OF SAN ]UAN, NIFTRO NIANII.A V. COUR'
OSM

DN

No

v. COA, C.R.

133313. N1.'

ll,20ll

Chrpts r, lnrrgoremmerrd RoLalions-NdnJnaL Cov*rtridr

con$nutlor An. x, iS

$d

.1,

connirurion. An xl, !

n|

2j

HEBRoN REYES, l0l Pl,il lri (lt53l

CANZON v. C4.200 SCRA 271 (1991)
DRTLoN v LIM.2r5 scfta ll5 (leeal

Memdmdsncn rrrNo 5r(reer)

RepubLic

Ad No.

3975 (2000), S 7

BANGTTSFRYFISHERFoLKv LANZANAS.ioiscRAn0(1001)
PROVNCLOT RIZALv EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, 4r7 SCRA 136(200j)
AIIARDZv PICOPRISOURCESINc,(l.R No. l6z14r,Decemberi,1009
BoRACAY
lt No. l96370..ILre 16.

FOLNDATION,INC

Rel io's\i.hPl)ilipptieN*oMlP.lice,l23
RepubLicAc'No.6e75(1eeo),NaNodedbrRepubrn^c1No.3s5
Rep bLic ad No. 3j5l

(lee8)

(1993), S! 6r-65

.'epExectrtivcOlnqNo ?91(1937).Rooklv,cl'aFr?,!i3(i)
CARPIOv ExEcUTlvE sEcREIARY.206 SCRA r90 (1992)
ANDAYA V. REGIONAL TRIAL COL]RT- ] I9 SCRA 69]{I999)
CANONIZADO v. AGUIRRE,l?3 SCI{A ll2 (2000);i5l sctu\ 6j9 (1001)
RODRICUEZv COURl OF APPEALS, 136 SCld,\ lql 12002)
pEoPl-E v. vEL,{l{DE. i3.r scRA 616 (200?)

htcrlocal Goren'nem

ReldioDs. ${ :l G), 19

:rl

Relaiioisrynli Pconlct and Nor.sovcmmcnraL Or3m zd ons,

\! i.t l6

LocalPre-qualincdioi,Bidsand *rrdsC.nn,itcc.{$l?.13

lll]eleo: I cqivc officirt5,

$$ r9.75

Qulificalior

ftrd ELccrioN.5 r9

.11

\Lrtbes if t tP satatrD itu

neNh n A!' Nu I 60 r ll
rtePulrl q AdNo.6616 (r937)
Republrc dNo 7r66 (r99i)

Rt!Lln \r N! _337 (rc4i)

Ikp! n clNo 3i53 (19931
Rqrr,ri! AclNo r9156 (201r)
Hl:RRLRA

COr\rEI_EC.

L3

SCtrA

i.
No.016.1(100t), ts 6
^(
RcpubLicAdNd
3r71 (reet
Reptrb

(1999)

COI\1DLDC. 312 SCRA 417 (1999)

v. cor,r ELr:c, tB6 sctu{15 (200r)

SALCEDO II

cn'Rr^No

ri6

:rauTlsrAy

cor\1Nfl ssloNo\ rlL_r:cTIoNs_41.1scRA299(2001)

rUCAS COr!TVTSSTONON ELEC]]ON,420 SCRAr65 (1001)
(200r)
IAPZON v. COMELEC.576 SCRA
coRDoR^ v CoMDLDC. C.R. No I 7694r, Fet,ruary r9. 2003
MARUIIOM y. Cor\lf,Lijc,59.r SCRA r03 (1009)

l_,^3()!

lll

COMTTLLC AND Orar'rjcA,

SCRA 297 (199r)

LOSIOS! COMIjLrjC.6.ra No l9]237.Ocbbtr9,10r1

11t]vALDo v. coMELEc. ?5r scRA 27 (ree6)
Nr^aLrlrNc v coMtrLrc. c.R
N ELEcrroNS.44r scR^655 (2004)

r.oR DrsauALI,rcarroN
NNCHEL,ENA.C R NOS

CONlliL.lic. ilr SCIt 574 (2000)

CoQUILLA v COr\1LLLC.i35 SCl{^ 607 (200t)
I,^LOSIOS \. CONIFI.EC, c R No lslq70, Anril2l,l0l?
J,\LOSJOSv CON'LLT,C,C lt No. l9lll4,f.bn'a'r26,:0ll

lOltAlNO

R.prbli.,{c1 No 3:95 (1997). Si(,1.5

RqDliliNlsrNo.9 65(1001)-isi ll, 1j,27'28,i6(e)
Rlpnblic d No q:?5 (2003)

\. CONIELEC, C.R. r*o l63550,ArgLj 10.2006

MACI_O !. COtlEl-EC.l90 SCRA 195(2002)
K^RE ! co11irL.ric,4zs scRAr6.r (r00r)
NIORFNO

NIALINAOv RFYaS,255 SCRA 616 (1996)

RIYLSv CONIIjLEC,2i4 SClrA i14 (1996)

rN(; v. coMLLtr. ier sa R,\ 619 (r00r)

CON{NllSslON ON ELECTJONS. I j,l \CR \.131 (19')rl
llloRENo !.coi\ll]r.rc. 19r scR^ jli(:0061

r-rNc

CRLCO

IIFRUADo

| \llNrAN(),r07

DL cUZMlN

lCR,\ 610(

v co]llllll,a.590Scnj lr9(rore)

RODRI(;Ua7! cOMELEC.lj'r s(rR{

Reptrblic
RePtrb c

/\d\o
\o

196 (lr)96i

6679 (19331
tj5ll (r9931
9006. S
ll00L)

^d
ReptrblicAdNo
ll
RcpsbLiu dN0.'r16.1(1001).
tsOR]A

999)

v COTLLLC.

195

r!

SaRI I j7 (lr)93)

l'|]c lo\s.1lr s( L{^ 60] 1]t]0)

Ila{lL,\v.aONlELEr,CR No 9i:l9 aidobs'J.10 l
'IAI,AC r CONILlac, c lt No.196301. on.l,q9.l0ll
iBUNLTO\R. v a0Nfi:l-Ec, c
DAVIo \. CONIEL[C.

:il

SCRd 90 I L9tr]

CONIMISSIOT_ O\ rlJrc lllJ\S \. CRUZ, C R \. l366l6 Norcnlrsl0.l0l)t)

\loNIt[AL v CO]\1illlSSIoN oN fl.liC I lONS. C R. )!. l S lq.li. lre.anb{ 1 . 1009
\roNRoy! aolrRr r)rr^)r)r;\r s l0scrr'\610(L16r)

vrcmcic\ Ind sucsslod.ll

li rl

at\NlBa)A r. l\GLr RR[. :]10 saR

LTOCLNA

s6r 11999)

\ sI\CCLNlr\NC TANLILA\lcAri

OF

lr/\l{INAS r BARBA.li6 \uitA i96(1996)

DAMASEN ! IUNl NlO,GR NO lr:lL6j. Febn'x,jVlCTOirlA 1 CoNllll-Lc,:19 sclti\ 169( t9l)

N vAI{ltO !. COLJRT or APf[ALs. jji SCRA

MlR/\ND]\ r C^ltltl:O\. r0L 5CltA i0l ll00r) 'i7]
1...r l.cgna'i$i,

\!rt

fl,\\"llRN SANl^R.

l7,l0l0
(1001)

5e.133,511

SlNo v. c,\.l0a SCR.\.Ll9 ( L9tll

I1ALONZO \ ZANIORA.:ll L SCRA lrl. lll rr1 ( 909)
ZAIvIORAv CABAl.l,FRlJ.,l 9 s{ lt:\j3l1l1r0l)
DL LOS RLYLS ! SAIITGANRtYT\N. 13l SCR]\ 6l (i991)
VENDOR AS\OCL^1'I'TN
BULAC,{N, i 76 SCRA 176(2oor)
CIIYO|vtNll A f l lCLlO, JR. l5i SCRA l0ll(100i)
vHllELl.jllTColtl'olt,{lLON\ CITYOf-Nl^NLl j.r6saR,\ lL6(l00rj

^.
\,:63sfR^i36(reqii
L3ro6C.

i,r):.r0rl

lll \c{]\ rql

RrPtrb

ic,\dN.

oFFla L

or r rI

r,rj0 (r9ntr)
o\rBLiDsNl^i.r

aJui, n'd r! rlL1.r N. rr r9irrl

Admirstri \! o !o No 66 (reeel
1

FSfrRrLj

BT.RCL:S

aUTNCO\

x!,{

lrcd trJ

111

N.

t7:r00. Jd)

I imt \c o

ti, t0r0

dc. No Lr9

(t!q4l.l

\lll1.(iAR. ]r6 scR^:J6 (t99tl

OO\\ LAC5A.CRN.

or\Nzo\

R|)DRt(,utz, c R

r,|

\RY reo\( t^ rre Ie9o

SCR/\ ile(199i)

c^. r0l sarL\ ae, (reerl

ALLiJANDRO V. Ofl

lct

O]]

lfRLALr.C.rr.No

Ac!iNALrro

llrl

O\ITUDS\,1AN

r s/\\ ros.:r:r s.r.\ rn

f,\ai

:r scn]\273

(1001)

frNDri\ic AND rNTEr I,TCENCE

(re!r)

\ \l() rr'\.ir]scR^riilL 9re)

\ \rRo. 197 saR\1r (r00j)
PLOPr u\ fO.r'r)^\o. lrj s|R^rr0(r000)
cr\Rcrr\
c.\Rcr/\

!^L_[Nar^ ] s^Nr)ra,^Nlr^f^N. il:r saR\ 8$(r00r)

I lll: SINGLi\I^]_C B,\lllr.'O^Y Of A]\R,\NaiAY DON iUIRIiNO N'\RCOS r.

fi^a \r)

arol0.D.\Lro r_.rjLsaR^

rlr(

991)

ll]\RBLRS. r90 SCR.\ iLr (r99S)

\PlDv COURIOFl\PPF\ls.lllsaR,\llll(1000)
|lim irr.'\

.DLr

c.'brbs. 5re scRA r.r5 c00i)

rL\) L \

Lsr,\ltL]\L. llo5ari^ :rll (ltr9i)

rtLOs\ rLrisraoNDDrvlsroNoIllrLsr\liD1cAi.]ll1Y.\\.li9scRl\i3 (
sLjrjo\rA \ sa\Dr(j1\rA\',\N. l3s sald\:ll3 (r99q)
f,l|RrNr)^ \ \^Nr)kr \lr^\
16r s(x^ r6j (r00i)
JLt,\\

! fLlifLLol lf[Pt

^N.

r_rPr,rNF!. ]rr scRr |]j1]0001

s,\N Dtc,\Nu,\Y^N. :ll: scRl\ ltt(1000)
r)MsuDsNrair. rs9 saRr\ r rr tr00r)

LLortL\rL.Jrt. v
asQurrrrr.

\ )Nlir

r scRA l0r (r00i)

^N..]l Sf R'{r8$(1m.r)
lHr: Nl)\ORADT riSANDr(iA\RAYAN.,r].r
,\N r:1 sr'ra,\rj6(:00r)

s,\NrrciNR,\\

991)

S NTOS. zL2 SCRA ?63 (1991)

PABI-ICO v. VILLPAN DO, 135 SCRA 601(1{102)
AGUINALDOv

pllNoNc

Rcptrblic

RANC^Y SnVERTNO MARTINT:2.5.1r SCRA 416 (100n)

AdNo.

9214 (2001)

EVARDONE v. CoMLiLEC,l0,l SCRA '161(l9sl)

PARAS v. CONInLEC, 261 SCRA 49 (1996)
ANCoBUNC !. COMELDC,269 SCRA ll5 (1997)
CLAUDIO v coivlFlr-FC, lrd PREPAMTORY REclLI. AssEi\1BLY

'oiuELl:C

llL

aIADO v COMELtrc. r10 SCRA 60012000)

Hd.d

Resources Dcvelopmenr,

RepublicAcrNo 67ll(1939)

il76 el

MAcALINCAG v. CHANO.203 scRr\ al3 (1992)

DEBULCADO v. CMI- SERVICE Colvl M ISS lON, ll7 SCRA I Ir4 ( 1994)
CML SERVICE COMNIISSION v l lN/\Yl\,15L SCR i60 (1005)
DIMAANDAI, v. COA,291 SCRA l2l (1993)

|LORIS v. LrRrLoN.2ll SCRA

563 (1991)

SANCGLINIANG SAYAN OF SAN

NDRES, CNTANDUANIiS V

Y v CIvrL SERVICE COMMlsslo\, il? SCRA 9l (19t9)

MATHAY v COURT OF APPEALS,120 SCRA 701(1999)
DERAMA COURT or Al'PE\Ls,ljl SCRA 9l (2001)
LAMEYRAv PANGILIN AN, 122 SCRA I l7 (1000)
crfY GOVERNNIENT oF MAKAfT CITY v clvlL SERV CFr coMNIlSSIoN. 176 SCRI

MAIi:l

rAsToR v clTY Of' lASlC. r32 scRA 212 (2002)

CARCIA v PAJARo,ssa SCRA l2l(2002)

TEVTS v. SANDICANRAYAN. 111 SCRA 309{1001)

?ndlce ofProfcsioD,

!! ll,

e0

.JAVELLANA !. DII-G,2r2 SCRA 175 (1991)

soclAl JUSIlCE SOCIETY v LINA,574 SCR^ 162(1003)
cAl U v. RILLOSA, A.C. No 5713, Fobitml 19,1003
REPUBLTCv.RAMBUYONC.CR No r673r0,Osober4.l0l0

Loc.l SclFol Rods, !9 93

lll

COMI\'IlSS|ON ON AUDII

oF lH! l'ROVlNc[ oF c[BU

PROVlNcll ol'CEBU. ]7

osEA r. r\{/\r_,^Y]\. 375 SCR ?3j (1002)

l-dcil lllakh Bo Js, \\ 102.105

Loc.lDcvc op ncrr Coutrcil\. {!l 106
Rcptrb c
No. ri63 (lee2), \ 6
^d
LosrPocc sd ardscoorciL. s I l6

! ll7
!.ororj! zorsacior

Aur0runor sDccirlll!ofo i! zoncsj

tee5 (1995). S 14
R.0ublic acr No.7903, Thc z.Drtroarga ciry spe.irlE.!iodri. zonc Ad of t995 (199t

orl'$

Po;

ons

Aprricxbr. rd LocrLcdlenmefr uni6

sd cDEr olBotr1d.!-

Disrtrlcs, -({

]|3

v CONTLLEC,:rl SaR^ 179(1999)

CAM R|NES NORIL v. PROVTNCE OF QUEZON, 167 SCtuA 9t p00t)
ivr uNrcrPALl r y ori KANANA Y rvr,^ rrRoNA,
'102 scRA :]] 0 (?001)
NIUICTPALrTYOF PATEROS v COUR',L OT:APPEALS,539 SCRA 1r012009)
PASIC

PROVTNCe OF

Locrllritia. !crid Itctuq nn.! l?0.127.i93

,^dNo 6?lj (1939)

sr? Reptrblc

cARCr^ v aarNrLLLc.2rT scRA sTe (re91)

SIJNT v COr\1EL[C. 162 SCRA !92 (r9t6)

Local covernnfl

cotrm!ioi. An x,ls r(d),5,6.rtrd

r992), $

r Ta\diotr

Nd o$. hnern lteycn,e Code. S{ l17,231 i, 237 s Anerdcd b} Repub ic Acr No.
I re Inr R.tonn Ac' ol lee? llee7)
RepubhcacrNo 3rasllee6)
R.p!bri.
?e,r2lreej). { 1r2
Rcprbli! ^.1N.
AclNo 7916, ! 2a. rsrrudcd by Rlf!Lrl! AclNo.3,121(1t99)

RqN ir ArlNo 8915,(l(r00)S

Rq,ubli. ArlNo el65 (200r1. !

ll

\. PACCOR. lt7 SCRA 52 (1991)

rsTANrsr.^o \ cos rArrs_ r96 scRA 3n (1q9r)
ril.oRo cLNr!N r v. conosPL, 200 scrr4,r30 (r99r)
FICUERRI:S !. CoURl 0F ,\pPl:,^l.S, 105 SCR^ 206 (1S99)
'iIlriCIlYOrOLONCAPoI l l lri S I ALLIIOLITIjRS Ol; IllhllASTBAJAC BAJAC
BASCO

3421,

of olo\c,\Po ul l.) . !i scRA roj

r\1.\SC RllilAS, i:6 SaR^ i9: r1007)

fuBr.rc M]\n
BtiRDrN

KL r

ol-lv^Rts r NIIRQUEZ .Jl3 SCRA679(100{)

c/\ClYAN FLECllrlc Po\!lllt lNu Lla lltc0
No l9l76l. r*o\embe, 11,l0ll
Co'nmon

(10001

ltY ol c]\c1Y'\N

l-iDifuln{N rlE la\ri-i Po\rebolL!.r]C.\.r nntr lri

COTIRL Ol']r\PlLr\1.S,:99SCRr\'lll(l9ed)
RS]' PHII,'PPINE IN DUSTRIAL COR POR A1 l(JN T COL:RTOI

BUI,ACA\\
FI

PALNIA DI]VI]I-OP\1LNT

CORP

Lrrr

oRo ('

rr

API['\IS.rln\f1\

(JI NI]\L'ANC \S.

II]

ll.\!^N!,\\alrY J\
coRPoR,\fo\,113 scR,\ rj0
(i (
Lti L\c |ONIPANI \
LEPAN fO CONS{JLIDATED
'\Nlr^\ Or.
RATANCT\S PONERCORP{JI{]\T|ON\

(:001J

N{

I it i iTarer Sl L]7.l9l. jll

I\IERALCOv. PROVINaLOf l.A(iuN^.106 !rRr\ 1j0( 999)
PLDTv CllY of DA\'^O. il6i saR]\ jll (:001)
NA ONAL tO\\uR c{Jl{rOR]\ llON \ cllY OF C.\u{N1LLl\\.lnl s(

DlClllil-v l'l(OvlNCrof-P,\NC^SIN,!N il6SctI1l (1001)

SIllRl ! cllYol D VAO cR \o
\ c^\l\RI\ES SLrR lll ELIClRlf cr)l)l'l.R^f

Ref ,\.r

N.

r160.

R.\li9 (l|lrJl)

(1991)\l Ll0. l1l. lt0

Rer.^dNo Sr61(200r)

l!

rr r:

fH LIPPNe BASKFTBALL i\soalATluN

F|LM r,rrrvrr .or,\rr:NT aol;\c
c.lt. No l9;9r7, pi l.20Ll
TEL 7I.OY REA T.TY COIU)OTa TjON

r'

arlURT

oli

^rPrlLs.

PROVjNCTj OT'RFNCITET.

l:11 SaRA

(jR No lN:rjSr.^P'il

Re Pfupclr lr$r s,. \! Lei:3r

LOPIZ r. CllY OIjNlANlL.^,l0l !CRA llli (1999)
YANIANIi! BA l.FI' NTOCONDONILIlL\l CORloli]\llON..lrl S(

cIl,l A\l,{v orFlctOl'fllEO\la!DsNlArl.:SiSCRl6llt( Itli)

lY!

llt,\NlPL,:50

SCRA 500

( 99jl

NAPlrcoR v PRoV lNch OF QLTETON.

R+

ilrl saRAlr

153

R'\ljS (:00i1

1100q)

Ad\. r0rr. ! r(m). ( r, 1ot& (pr

\tctAA I M^lrcos, 26r scRA 667 (1996)

\,lANll"A INTERNAfIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORTN
NAPOCOR
]-ICI

II R

T.ANAO

II- 1RANSI

v CrlY

DtL SUR,161SCR \ 271 (t996)

I AI] I HORITY Y. ClN I RAL- ROARD

PTILREC,\ \.

SECt{t] Ry.40r

PI{OVlNcl/\l-

,^SS IISSOR

Oli

Oti PASAY.

OIJ ,\SSESSM

CR

ENl

t6i072,

APPEALS

SCRA 55S (2003)

RIN DUQUL

v cOURT

OF APl,uALS. C.R. No. I 55491,

LUNCCENTDROFlHEPlllllrl,lNEsv QUEZONCITY,43SSCRA lt9(?004)

P]L]I-]PPlNL f]SHhI{IES DEVEI-OPMENT AUTHORfIY \. COUR
COVERN MLN

I SIRVIC

E INSURANCU SYS'I'EIVI V. CITY

TREAUItEIt. C I{ NO, 116242.

NATTONIL HOUSINC AUTHORItY r. rLOrLO. C R No L?2267,^u8trs20,2003

RTPUBLTCy P]lll.rpptN ri RIC LAMATION AUT OR|TY, C R No ]9 l09,JutJ 13,n,2012

violr'iorsorla odi'nnes,

ll

516 519

lin.'Ml RcroL

]i!

?31 233

^lLorngDr.

ALVARFZ v CUINCONA,252 SCI{A'j9i (1996)

lrrllrlNTllL y. AculRRE, lr6 scRAz0l (2000)
ACORO

!.

ZANTORA, 459

s|[eofLocrlc.ve, nnBr

crdn Fimr.i"e.

S!

SCR

573

ROMULO,429SClr 7t,j (2004)

(200i)

rJrits in Nrriomrwcrhh, s{ 23s-294

2el'r0l

Loc,l l;is.1r ,^Jtrri,riskalior.

\\

r0l-3s1

Nl r_On*ZO \. ZANIORA. Sl| SCRA 2r.r (2000)

AfruNzA 1 vrLLAROSA.r5S SCrrAlS5 (2005)
auLSUNrrrNc L artii, c R No
PllOPLll,CR No5 ?0lls,l?0193 403,Mrtuh 9,2010
SIsON

'

IteDllil.AcrNo
l,ropen!

313511996)

i'd strprl!

NlDrsflnetrl

itrllELmrLad

men units.r!! r55 r33

COVERIINI|NT SERVICE INSUtu\NCE SYSTENI v. TIIE IROVINCE OF TARLAC. 417

Pan

Rcprblic^cr No saal (lee7) !

lll

LocaLCover ed Ur $

rr73 (2001)
Republic AdNo.9235 (2001), q
Republ o AciNo.

5l

PEoPLET RECIO.167 SCR 3!r0 (2001)

DAVID v. COMFLEC, 2?l sClt^ 90 (199r)
ALQUIZOLA r OCOL,
SCRA 271 11999)

lll

ili

KaiarufgaDgP.rnbmargay, {g l9'l J2l,

Suprcme Coun Adnininrariv! CirrlirNo.
R.pLblicAcr No 9235(2001). !

ll

MORA1A

ll9l

CO. 125 SCITA 44,1 (1931)

UY v. CONTRERAS, 217 SCkA 167( 991)

zAMoRA v HEIRS oF lzaU IERDO, 413 sCRA2.l(:004)
BOLEYLEY v. VILIANUEVA,ll4 scLA I'i4 (1999)

MENDOVA r. A FAB LE, l9l SCM 390 (2001)

VERCIDEv TDGEPRISCjLLA IIERN NDEZ,:l30SCRA.l9(1000)
lDoLoR v. coul{l OF PPEAI.s, r5L scnA rt9 (1001)
AQUINo v. ALTRE, 5a6 SCR 7l (2003)
l,AN6-lil v T,IANACNES D CIAS. C R N. 167:61 Ma,al,1.1007
ACRAYANIv COURToF APTEALS, G R No l3l62l.l',ncl5.:0ll

.t ,!g,,jr,g &irdrz,'. \rj

421 .1j9

Republic

AciNo

RenulJlic

A.tNo 3041(1995), { l0

Republic

AcrNo 916412002)
elro{2001)

R.nublh

7303 (199 r)

^dN.

ALUNAN

lll

v. MIRASOL, z76 SCRA

l0r (199r)

ASSOCIATED L BOR UNIONS r LL I R{)NDO, l:17 SC RA 6l I

MIGUELT COTIRT OF APPEAI.S.lr0 scRA lr9 (1991)
MARQUEZ v. corvlEl-trC, rll SCRA r0r (1999)

l99.ll

CARVIDA v SALES.17l SCR 767(1997)

ZARATEv CONIELEC,ll3 SCRA 603 (1999)
BAYTAN v. cuMDl-ric,3!16 scR^ ?03 (200i)lLrird isnLe)
MoNTEScLAROS v. COVELEC. 3 3.1 SCRA 26t (1001)
SAMBARANI v CoMELEC. 1l3 SCR/\ :r l9 (2004)

S.eCoNnissioi or

hLecrions

l.sohiion No

00-0046.

hirmr

lq.1000

rhe Mm ciprrL'), s! ai0 aa7, s aar (b)(3)

oL|\,

REZ

v SANDTC

BAYAN, ?43 SCRA r00 { t99i )

15

$$443,43r

MMos v CA, 108 SCRA 723 ( l93l )

fILlLl-A v. CA.233 SCR{ 134 (1991)

scRA l(1007)

R,\j\lOS ( A.169 SCI{A lL ( ttr)

(1991)
,\LINSUC llLajlO\AL lltLAL. ( otrRl.2:lj SCRA
J1911000)
A[PlAls
]l0
SCF-\
COL:RToF
N1^f,_CrrilDo\
N.\flvlDr\D r;ril.r\. rl! sflt,\ 630 (l,r9.l)
i\lONTUIlt llJ 1 l\'.(i.ft No l7rii6.Odobtf6.:00S

jjj

RqNlni. Acl No r0u9 rl00L)

Dl chNl.r:0 sali,\ 133(:00.11

ScRn ei (1999)
,\aL:LRRL \. r)r, (^s
ll.
l6l
scltA (1t33)
aORDoN lljltDiANO
col]r"\NY CTIURT oF APPLALS.

cANLil

fRo.Il

I \lv coLrl{ r)r,\l'l'li,\L.s.

s7

il

scRA lrq

ll9

SCRA

\ ILLl FOoDs.lNc. jLMRA6i3( 'rs'r)

\Eoiros ORIINT^l ll l:l.l:cLRlr COOPr:R,\TIvt INC \
lrNcsOD \c DLrll/\cl Ifl] li5 scRA llr (r937)
"\Nd
ru!rr. rer scRA r6r {r00r)
cr\ or.c.\Loarc,\N \ colR oF '\Pl'llls. l39 scr.A1511006)
\l,\Tll.\I.JR

s0r'1.\r

L.r

(1000)

(1U01)

SAN(itillNlA\G

JljslrcllsoalLl\'\ ,\lrl,Nr\,511sctu\657(100r)

l'^R/\NI\ coNll,l.l]C.::li !( l{.\ rr L(lt9r)

LllL:'l{O\'li.lcliOljNF(ntosOCClDrirlAl v ZIlCO.CR No L3?5rl Scllonb.'
/\rpodn. L.i.l()llicirlsrof f,ntiALlNhtr,iciPr 1i(.aitss. Nd rru\ itc\. \1

r69

R,^l,lsoL{,\ r alvLLsLR\ CFCo[1i\1lSsn)N 1:3 SCR^ 6]l(19'ri)

DlrNl\ Ll,(Ji.]llS.C R Nn 1697:6 NI:r.,13.1010

IACARLOT\C Iv rojo. aj lt r.'! l3l167.Ap.illr'l0ll

JACA V Pl:aiPl I oli l llh Pfl ] rPl'lNrs C lt No. l66961. l

uxi-a

l3. l0L:t

Lei-!r!snaLo!L'la,r\.,fr,!r!rLtr!idiikdneOfli.LxLr !S 19 5i0
\r(nrLrL.

vo|^\

.\. ]j0 saR/\ rr9 (1r91)

ir(nrRr o,
]r7 scR.\r091l9.r')
4LUN^N ]rr. ^r,rIr\

\ lL]RN/\\Dl7.rjo sfrlA 7ll(r

'lHliN/\ll{)N\LLlcA\c\luA
IlLlO ONON

I'r1l\

rl)

lllnc. LarcDrrr

li9scR^ l0(:004)
'rll'rorLnn's

Ptu\ s.tr\ ii)i L"idrncnn,r \\ jlL -ili

r'rr!D P

islotrr. \ir

il6 jll

10l,li.d.r.llh!CoLL.trLotrlCo\urn. lj'rn\i"rlrc1tr10unoL!Rceotrs.!i16

190

13.

hMrs imMDdanao
co'si1trriotr,Aniclc1,$l r, 15, 16, 13.10.itrd2l
The Autrna,mous Rcgion

RepubLicActNo.67i4 i1939)
ReNbLicAdNo. 3116(r999)
RepubLic AcrNo. 9012 (:000)
RepubLic Acr No.9054 (100 L)
ABBAS v. CONIELEC, l?9 SCRA 231 (1939)
Lll\4llONAv lvl NCELlN, l?0SCRA736(1939)
PANDIv.COURI OFAPFEALS,330SCRA.116(l0lrl)
DISOMANCCOP v THE StiC RETARY OF TllE D|iPAI{TNIFNT
HrcHwAYS,.l14 SCR^ :01 (2004)

ol'

PU

RLIC \\ ORKS /\ND

Co:dl Lc,r Administdive Rcsioi

S'. Republi. A.tNos.6766 afd

31lN

ORDILLO v. CO]\1ELEC.l9? SCRA 100(1990)

COITDILLEM BROAD COALITION v. CO,{, | 3 | SCRA 495 ( 1990)
BADUAv COIiDILLDRABODoNcASSoCIATIoN, l9JSCRA l0l (199 )

ATlTIwv.ZAlrlOltA,c.R.No l43l71.septe'nbtrl0,:00i
The Metopolit.n

lvlaii

Conniturion, Ad. X, S

a DevcLopmefr

AtrrlDnq

ll,An.xvlll,Ss

RepubLicAcrNo 7914(1995)

MMDA v.

RLN,456 SCRA 176 (1005)

MMD^v. BEL Alla

MMDA

123 SCRA 316 (1000)

ILLACE

^SsoclATlON,
TIACK$'ORKS
RAIL TRANSIT ADVERTISINC. vENDlNc. AND

PROMOTTONS rNC 47.r SCRA

rlr (r00t

I n 006)
SI'ORTATIoN co , 5r0 Scl{/\ r1|(200i)
MMD v. CONCERN ED RESIDENTS oF MANILA BAY,574 SCR 661(1003)

TI.ANCTSCO

FERNAN DO, 507 SCRA

MMDA v vlRoN TR

IG