Common Problems of Chinese Exchange Students to the University of Kentucky
Denisha Burton CIS 110-058
Common Problems of Chinese 2
Chinese exchange students are common in many universities. However, they are a group that gets a lot of stereotypical behavior directed at them. Some of the major problems that the Chinese exchange students face are related to food, religious stereotyping, acceptance by others, manners, and general classroom differences. Based off polls taken of fifty college students, many people could quickly come up with stereotypes about their Chinese friends, although when the same group was asked about stereotypes about other races or exchange students from countries other than China, their results were fewer, slower, and often more positive than the results given for the Chinese students. This is a very real problem. The cultures of all countries, geographic regions, religions, races, et cetera are different and sometimes have trouble blending. However, no matter how common, it needs to be addressed. Through intensive study on Chinese culture, stereotyping, polling, and interviews, this research proves the need for something to change in some way. Based solely on Chinese exchange students, with age commonly from eighteen to twenty two, in a university setting, this research shows some of the main problems that the Chinese exchange students face when choosing to come to America for an education. Two interviews were conducted on Linda and Samantha, both Chinese exchange students, and both nineteen. Linda shares: There are five legal religions in China: Taoism, Buddhism, Islam, Protestantism, and Chinese Catholicism. I have had people assume I am atheist because I am Chinese. I am Protestant. Also, People think all we eat is rice and fish. Samantha adds about her interactions with her classmates, They dont talk to me much, and I see them talking to other people. Also, they say that we cant drive a lot. Or that we are all smart. We arent all super smart. Just because the words are not said aloud does not mean that the students are not affected. These problems are real, and they need to be addressed.
Common Problems of Chinese 3
Some of the major problems that the Chinese exchange students face are related to food, religious stereotyping, acceptance by others, manners, and general classroom differences. Some of the main stereotypes that were responded during the researchers poll were those of Chinese people cant drive, Chinese people think they are better than us, Chinese people are only good at math or science, Chinese people only eat rice, or All Chinese people are Atheists. One poll voter even said, I never talk to them because they never seem to talk to me. Another said, If they would take the time to learn English I might take the time to talk to them. This is a very sad thing that this is an epidemic on college campuses today. The social structure of Chinese exchange students communities seems exclusive to nonmembers, but the group is often very welcoming once one takes the time to speak with them. During research, hours upon hours of time was spent with the Chinese community on the University of Kentucky campus. At first, the group seemed to keep up the stereotypical behavior that was above outlined. However, the longer time went on the more the members of the community opened up and were inclusive. Two members in particular showed more about their system. Samantha and Linda, the two members who helped the most with the research, shared that the most important thing in the Chinese, or Chinese-American, culture was respect. The things that they never do is make another person loose face, or disrespect an elder member of the community. The University puts on many functions for each demographic group on campus (exchange students, ethnicities and races, religions, genders, et cetera). These, as well as small private gatherings within the community itself, make up a large proportion of what the social activities of the Chinese exchange student community does. They also engage in class, and service opportunities. Much of the research information within this paper comes from interviews.
Common Problems of Chinese 4
The interviews done were conducted for an hour, and spent time exploring the problems that are common to Chinese exchange students. The questions mainly covered food, religious stereotyping, acceptance from others, manners and general classroom differences. Outside of the questions asked during the interview, the research included spending a week with the interviewees, and learning from them. They become more social and trusting towards the researcher as one gets to know them. They showed more about the topic than did the articles, as they are Chinese exchange students to the University of Kentucky, and live the life that this research explores. This research is not the only reference that supports the need to investigate the food and nutritional information provided to Chinese exchange students. Universities and colleges are potentially important targets for the promotion of healthy lifestyles of the adult population. However, little is known concerning the body mass index (BMI) distribution and nutritional and health related behavior of Chinese university students (Sakamaki, R., Toyama, K., Amamoto, R., Chuan-Jun, L., & Shinfuku, N, 2005, p. 45). According to Linda, The portion size is too much here. Common Chinese diet does revolve around rice, rice noodles, egg or wheat noodles, Chinese tea, bean curd or tofu, spring roll wrappers, Chinese sausages, bamboo shoots, dried Chinese mushrooms, white radish, snow peas, soy bean sprouts, Gai Lan, Chinese eggplant, bok choy, and various seasonings. This diet is, on average, healthy and nutritionally balanced. A sudden change to American foods, where meats, starches, and sugary sodas are served in very large amounts with few, if any, vegetables can cause rapid weight gain and also illnesses. Both of the interviewees commented that it was quite difficult to adjust to American foods, and both mentioned at some point in our time together that the portion size was very large for the type of
Common Problems of Chinese 5
food that was eaten. Samantha shared that she usually prefers to cook her own food than to eat the food served here, although that in itself is problematic. It is sometimes difficult for her to find her favorite ingredients here on campus. Many of the polled students commented that, having lived in the United States all their lives, they knew how much of the prepackaged or fast food that they could eat without consuming an exponentially too-large amount of calories. Says one, I know that I cannot eat as much food when I eat out as I do if I cook for myself or get food from home. There are a lot more calories and fat in fast food, so you have to eat less. This is a fact that new exchange students may not know. No one who is used to it ever really comments about it. They would never know unless someone told them this. Many become ill or get unhealthy suddenly because they never knew. Religious stereotyping is another common occurrence in the Chinese exchange student community. As stated above, there are five legal religions in China: Taoism, Buddhism, Islam, Protestantism, and Chinese Catholicism. Taoism is a traditional Chinese religion that has existed for centuries, as is Buddhism. Islam is another huge world religion. Protestantism and Chinese Catholicism are perhaps the most surprising of the religions in China to people in the outside word. Chinese Catholicism is distinct and independent of the Roman Catholic Church. A common stereotype among students that were polled showed that they believed that the majority, if not all, Chinese exchange students are atheists. Although there are naturally some Chinese exchange students who are atheist, this is a totally ungrounded assumption. I was raised a protestant, and I go to a protestant church nearby now that I am here in America. People think I hate God, but I am just as Christian as any other person. Kyle, a member of the Chinese community that was researched, shared.
Common Problems of Chinese 6
There is a common theme among the Chinese students reviewed and interviewed about the level of acceptance felt from the general community at large. Lydia shares, You are the first person to ever ask me to do anything with you. It makes me very happy that you want to spend time with me. I have never had a classmate talk to me unless they had to for a project. No one asks me to come to anything so I dont go to very many things. Nearly every community member that was researched showed an interest in becoming friends with American students. It was found that the American students that were interviewed said that they too wanted to be friends with the Chinese exchange students, but did not know how. One poll answer was I feel like they cant understand what I am saying, and I cant always understand them. So I dont talk to them. The language barrier is a large problem in the area of relationships forming among the American student population and the Chinese exchange student community. Although the Chinese students know Basic English, they are often not familiar with slang terms or activities that American students participate in outside of classes. Americans often seem to forget this, or to lose patience with the Chinese exchange students. Dong, X., Leong, F. L., & Shoudong, F (2008) mention that the cultural differences between Chinese students and their American counterparts is a leading cause for anxiety for said students. It has been described by one of the polled students as thus: When I see a Chinese exchange student, I get really nervous because I think that I cant talk to them or that they wont understand me. I avoid them because I dont want it to be awkward. I dont want to make them uncomfortable by them not understanding me or me not understanding them. It must be the same, if not worse for the students being actively avoided.
Common Problems of Chinese 7
Manners are another large area of differences between Chinese culture and that of the American culture. People here put business cards away really quickly and even throw them away. This is really bad. [It brings] dishonor to the person [who gave the card]. Provides Linda. Being on time [is considered rude]. Being at a party or dinner or meeting on time or early is bad in China. It is good to be just a little late. Also, Here it is rude to allow someone else to buy your food. In China it is rude not to let someone pay if they want to. As she stated, much of Chinese cultural taboos are considered mainstream and normal, even expected in America. Here people do not like if you slurp your soup or belch while eating. In China, it means the food is good and is a way to thank the person providing the food. Samantha shares. my roommate got me a yellow watch as a present when we moved in. It was embarrassing. Yellow in China has sexual meanings and watches are like counting the time until you die. It was uncomfortable, but here that is no problem. I understand now. Many things that would never be thought of twice in American culture are uncomfortable or rude to Chinese exchange students. That said, some things that Chinese exchange students are accustomed to would be social taboo here. According to Huang, J., & Brown, K (2009); students from the Peoples Republic of China revealed feeling uncomfortable in social and classroom interactions in American schools. Also stated in the research by Huang, J., & Brown, K. (2009), some areas that cause problems for Chinese exchange students include student behavior, too much group work, lack of lecture summaries, lack of general organization, the professors not teaching by referring to the textbook, the common use of classroom discussion as opposed to lecturing, and that they share few, if any, common interests with their American classmates.
Common Problems of Chinese 8
In American classrooms you talk to the professors in class and interrupt him with questions. This is disrespectful in China. Samantha adds. The professors speak to fast for me to understand and my classmates dont interact with me very much at all. Some of this is the language barrier, but some of it is a combination of, in large lecture classes of hundreds of students, the professor has no way of knowing that there are exchange students in the class. In all classes, the professor has multiple students with multiple learning styles that he/she must instruct and cannot alter his entire lesson plan for one student. In addition, the language classes must start at a fairly low level. The Chinese exchange students must have a crash course in English all during their college adjustment period, and be taking classes taught in advanced English at the same time as the introductory courses. During the past two decades there has been a significant growth in the number of nonnative speakers (NNS) of English pursuing academic studies in North American universities. Statistics shows that students from the Peoples Republic of China are the largest single group, and approximately 80% of them are graduate students (Canadian Bureau for International Education, 2002; Institute of International Education, 2001). Generally, they have completed their undergraduate education in China prior to commencing graduate studies in North American universities. Chinese graduate students are from a very different cultural background. Their learning experience in North American classrooms has important educational implications for both university administrators and educators (Huang & Klinger, 2006). Academic learning, as argued by Tweed and Lehman (2002), varies depending on the cultural context (Jinyan, H., 2009, p. 335-336). Chinese exchange students face many problems in the world today when they come to America to continue their education. They face problems concerning food, acceptance from
Common Problems of Chinese 9
peers, religious stereotypes, manners, and classroom differences. Throughout the study, evidence pointed over and over again to the role of peers to attempt camaraderie with their Chinese counterparts. Although various barriers may be present, not exclusive to the language, but also including manners, religious beliefs, stereotypes, food choices and under-education about nutrition in the American university setting, classroom disturbances, and the ever-present problem of understanding professors teaching styles and students learning styles that all students, Chinese or not, have to face. The main solution that seems to present itself falls to peer inclusiveness. The social and classroom activities should be more inclusive, and yet we could all learn something from each other. The structure and respect shown in the Chinese education system could be added to nearly all education systems for the better. A blend of the two cultures may create the perfect balance of harmonious coexisting of two people groups that become one on a college campus in central Kentucky.
Common Problems of Chinese 10
References Sakamaki, R., Toyama, K., Amamoto, R., Chuan-Jun, L., & Shinfuku, N. (2005). Nutritional knowledge, food habits and health attitude of Chinese university students --a cross sectional study. Nutrition Journal, 44-5. Yuming, L., & Yussen, S. (2005). A comparison of perceived control beliefs between Chinese and American students. International Journal Of Behavioral Development, 29(1), 14-23. Rienties, B., Hliot, Y., & Jindal-Snape, D. (2013). Understanding social learning relations of international students in a large classroom using social network analysis. Higher Education, 66(4), 489-504. Dong, X., Leong, F. L., & Shoudong, F. (2008). Culture-specific personality correlates of anxiety among Chinese and Caucasian college students. Asian Journal Of Social Psychology, 11(2), 163-174. Jinyan, H. (2009). What Happens When Two Cultures Meet in the Classroom?. Journal Of Instructional Psychology, 36(4), 335-342. Huang, J., & Brown, K. (2009). Cultural Factors Affecting Chinese ESL Students' Academic Learning. Education, 129(4), 643-653.