0 évaluation0% ont trouvé ce document utile (0 vote)
22 vues14 pages
This document discusses key differences between Homer's epics the Iliad and the Odyssey. It notes that the Iliad focuses on glory in war and the sublime, while the Odyssey emphasizes survival, migration, and the relationship between humans and the divine. It also contrasts the characters Achilles and Odysseus, with Achilles seeking glory and Odysseus prioritizing survival. The document then analyzes Odysseus' traits like cunning and resilience, before discussing how themes of the Iliad like war continue in the Odyssey on an individual level. It questions whether Odysseus' world is real or a product of memory and the mind.
This document discusses key differences between Homer's epics the Iliad and the Odyssey. It notes that the Iliad focuses on glory in war and the sublime, while the Odyssey emphasizes survival, migration, and the relationship between humans and the divine. It also contrasts the characters Achilles and Odysseus, with Achilles seeking glory and Odysseus prioritizing survival. The document then analyzes Odysseus' traits like cunning and resilience, before discussing how themes of the Iliad like war continue in the Odyssey on an individual level. It questions whether Odysseus' world is real or a product of memory and the mind.
This document discusses key differences between Homer's epics the Iliad and the Odyssey. It notes that the Iliad focuses on glory in war and the sublime, while the Odyssey emphasizes survival, migration, and the relationship between humans and the divine. It also contrasts the characters Achilles and Odysseus, with Achilles seeking glory and Odysseus prioritizing survival. The document then analyzes Odysseus' traits like cunning and resilience, before discussing how themes of the Iliad like war continue in the Odyssey on an individual level. It questions whether Odysseus' world is real or a product of memory and the mind.
Both epic poems are Olympian in perspective They reflect different stages of the Hellenic Dark Ages Iliad = the warrior; invasion; the sublime; human-as-Divine; immanence Odyssey = the seafarer; migration; the monstrous; human versus the Divine; transcendence
Odysseus versus Achilles
Achilles: glory defies death
Odysseus: survival finds place Two different versions of immortality In the Iliad place is not enough; in the Odyssey place is all that matters! place dislocation place: nostos and belonging
Odysseus traits
Resourceful Cunning Resilient Self-centered Self-aware Questi(oni)ng The Hellenic individual par excellence!
War is never over!
The Iliad goes on in the Odyssey: the collective becomes individual; the external becomes internal Ilium or Troy expands and becomes the whole Mediterranean War turns into adventure; adventure into journey; journey into quest; quest into yearning Loss and repossession
Is Odysseus world real?
The Ancients could and did identify all places in the Odyssey with known place within the Mediterranean Something fuzzy about all those places; all of them are remembered, recalled, related; never presented in hic and nunc experience They are memories, which means they are experientially related to; places that regardless of their reality stand out as places of the mind
Odysseus: one more shaman!
Nekyia: the Underworld The most important rhapsody in the Odyssey The old immortality is not enough; a new immortality is needed The journey is spiritual and hierophanic
Odysseus and Poseidon
Friends or enemies? Teiresias prophecy: the people that dont know the oar The monstrosity of the Divine the monstrosity of the human But all this for what? For going back or for going forward?
Ithaca isnt out there!
The day of returning The place of returning is different but the same! You always have to belong; you always need your place; you cannot escape it! But you can live it out; make it into something make yourself into something Ithaca will always be there even if it not out there!