.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

.
/ ? . . . . . . . . . .

48

56

. ,
?
. . . . . . . . .

73

. . . . . . . . . . . .

93

.
. . . . . . . . . .

121

-.
XX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

156

.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

191

. . . . . . . . . . . . . .

217

08.02.1948 02.05.2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

229

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

231

. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

233

. . . :
. . . . . . . . . . . . .

235

237

. . . . . . .

 #,
-
.,


( ),
( ),
, , ,
,

. . (),
. . (), . . (), . . (),
. (), . (), . . (),
. . (), . . (), . (),
. . (), . ()
Adressed abroad:
Logos Editorial Staff
c/o Dr. Michail Maiatsky
Section de Langues et Civilisations Slaves
Universit de Lausanne, Anthropole
CH - 1015 Lausanne
Switzerland
michail.maiatsky@unil.ch

Logos Editorial Staff

c/o Dr. Nicolaj Plotnikov
Institut fr Philosophie
Ruhr-Universitt Bochum
D - 44780 Bochum
Germany
nicolaj.plotnikov@rub.de

,



E-mail : logos@orc. ru
http: 6 www. ruthenia. ru / logos

141406, ., . , . , . 11
1000 . 0000

V KWX Q YZ [ \Q ] X^

. ,
.
.
,
. , , ,
: ,
(modernity), , . ,
, , .

,
. , . ,
.

/ . . . , . . , . . . .: , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

, , ( ).
-: , () ,
,

.
, . ,
, - , ( - , -),
,
.
.
, ,
( ). ,
, ,
,
, , . ,
. ,
( !)
, ,

, , ,
, . Skocpol T. (with M. Somers), The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial
Inquiry, in Social Revolutions in the Modern World. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, . P. .
, . ,
, , , ,
. , , , , ,
.
,
. . Abrams P. Historical Sociology. Ithaca (NY ): Cornell
University Press, , . ; Sahlins M. The Return of the Event,

 . , ,
.

?
( , , ), , ,
, . ,
. , , .
, .
, , , , - , -
XVII XVIII

. ,
,

, , doxa, , . . -

Again, in Clio in Oceania: Toward a Historical Anthropology. Washington, DC : Smithsonian

Institution Press, ; Abbot A. From Causes to Events, Sociological Methods and
Research. . Vol. . No ; Grifn L. Temporality, Events, and Explanation in
Historical Sociology, in Sociological Methods and Research. . Vol. . No. ; Sewell
W. H., Jr. Historical Events as Transformations of Structures, in Theory and Society.
. Vol. . No. .
. , . ,
, . . Darnton R. What
Was Revolutionary about the French Revolution? in The French Revolution in Social and
Political Perspectives, ed. P. Jones. L.: Arnold, . P. .
. .
. . . .: ,
. C. .
- ,
( , . . ) . ,
, . . Bourdieu P. Pascalian Meditations, tr. R. Nice. Stanford (CA ): Stanford University
Press, . Pp. ff.

KOKQ 6, 2008


. ,
( ) , ( ) .

: , () .
.
. , . -
, . ,
,
.

. , . . ,
,
( , , , . .). .
( )

. , ,
.
, ,

, ,
suppositum ( ) - . . Descombes V . A propos
of the Critique of the Subject and of the Critique of this Critique, in Who Comes after
the Subject? Ed. E. Cadava, P. Connor and J.-L. Nancy. L.: Routledge, .

 , ,
. :

, , . -, .
, ,
, [], . , .
, ,
,
,

, . , , ,

!
. ,
. ,
, .

. . . . . . . . .: ,
. .
., . . : mobilis in mobile 6 ... . .
. . . .: - - -, , (. ) (. ), ., . . .
. .: , .
, ,
,
( . : 6 ... . ). ,
- (. (
, ) . 6
... . ).
. . . . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

 , . .
. . Subaltern, , - ( ) - . Selfnegating
, .
(F. Moshiri, Revolutionary Conict Theory), .
. ,
. , .
, -, .


. .
, (, - ), . , ,
. : - . ( , ),
, .
, -
! , , ,
.
,
. , ,

. ... . , .
. . . , .
. . Trimberger E. K. A Theory of Elite Revolutions, in Studies in Comparative International Development. . Vol. . No. .
. : , - XIX ,

 ?
? , , .
, . . ? ! , , , .
( ).
, ?
,
,
, . ? , ? , ,
, ( ?)
,
?
, , . , , ?
, [ ] .
, ,
, , , . , , , ,
, -

( . . 6 ... . ).
. . . . . .
. . :
6 ... . , .
Balandier G. Political Anthropology, tr. A. Sheridan Smith. NY : Random House, . P. .
. Debord G. The Society of the Spectacle. Detroit: Black & Red, . Para. . , , . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

 . .
, . , .
,
.

? .
, . . - .
. , .

, .
, , . , ,
, ,
.
. . ,
.
, ( )
, ( ,
. .), , . .
. . ... . , .

. . Dunn J. Capitalist Democracy: Elective Afnity or Beguiling Illusion,
Daedalus. . Vol. . No. . P. .
, . . Comaroff J. L. and J. Introduction, in Civil

10

 ,
- ,
.
- . ,
, . .
/ ,
:
, -, .

, .
, , .

, . ,
, , , , . , ,

Society and the Political Imagination in Africa: Critical Perspectives, ed. J. L. and J. Comaroff.
Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, . Pp. .
, ,
, (tacit knowledge) .
,
. . Polanyi M. Tacit Dimension. NY : Anchor Books, .
. Furet F. The French Revolution Is Over, in The French Revolution in Social and
Political Perspectives. Pp. .

. . Porter R. The Enlightenment. Basingstoke (UK ):
Macmillan, . P. ff.

KOKQ 6, 2008

11

 - , , , .
, , ,

.

,
, .
, .

?.
, , ?.
?. .

,
( ). .
. , , . ,
, . - ,
, . - ,
,
. , , . .,
. ,
,

. . . . . C. .

12


.
( , ), .
( ,
) , . , ,
,
.
,


.
: . ,
,
, (, , ,
, , ).
,
, ,
, . . ,

. Finley M. I . Revolution in Antiquity, in Revolution in History, ed. R. Porter and

M. Teich. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, , . , , .
. ,
. . Osborne R. When Was
the Athenian Revolution? in Rethinking Revolutions Through Ancient Greece. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, .
:
. . . Finley M. I . Op. cit.
P. . , , , . . Grote G. History of Greece. Vol. . L.: J. Murray, . Pp. , , ; Walker
E. M. The Periclean Democracy, in Cambridge Ancient History. Vol. , ed. J. B. Bury
et al. Cambridge: University Press, . Pp. ff; Forrest W. G. The Emergence of Greek
Democracy. L.: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, . Pp. , ; Davies J. K. Democracy
and Classical Greece. Cambridge (MA ): Harvard University Press, . Pp. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

13


, .
, ,
( , . . , ) . ,
.
, .
.
, ,
. ,
,
, ,
- .
- , , , ,
. ., ,
.
, , . , (
) . , .

. 6 . . . C. .
. 6 . . . C. .
, (. . . . ), ,
, , . , , , .
. , ,
, ,
( ). ,
, , , , . .
Ober J. The Athenian Revolution of / B. C.: Violence, Authority, and the Origins
of Democracy, in The Athenian Revolution: Essays on Ancient Greek Democracy and Political
Theory. Princeton (NJ ): Princeton University Press, . Pp. , .

14

, , ,
. , ,
- ,
, , . , ,

,
. , , , , (
). - ,
,
, , . , ,
,
. , , , - ,
, . . ,
, .
, , , , :
, , , , , ,
, .
, , ,
, . , .
.
,
( - ),
. , , . , , . . , , .

. Benjamin W. Theses on the Philosophy of History (A, VI XVI ), in

Illuminations, ed. H. Arendt. NY : Schocken Books, . Pp. , .
: (
) ,

KOKQ 6, 2008

15

 , , . , , ,
, .
. ( ,
), ,
. , , , , , ,
() , [] . , ,

. (
- ) ,
:
. . Moore B. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston: Beacon Press,
. P. . , ,
, , , , .
. . Rothman S. Barrington Moore and the Dialectic
of Revolution: An Essay Review, in The American Political Science Review. . Vol. .
No. . Pp. ff.
, ,
, . . -, . . Garton
Ash T. The Last Revolution, in The New York Review of Books, . November (Vol.
. No. ). ,
, . :
( ) ,
? : ,
,
, ,
( ).
. ? . . . 6 . . . . . . . .

16

 - , , :
, , , , .
, -
( ) , , , , ,
, . ( )
, ,
, ? .
. : , .
, , ,
. , , .
: ,
? , ,

. . . . . . .: , . . .
, , ,
- ,
. :
, , , (Levi M. J. Some Social Obstacles to Capital
Formation in Underdeveloped Areas, in Capital Formation and Economic Growth, ed.
M. Abramovitz. Princeton (NJ ): National Bureau of Economic Research, . P. ).
. . . . ,
. . . ,
. . (. Davidson N. How
Revolutionary Were the Bourgeois Revolutions? in Historical Materialism, . Vol. .
No. . Pp. ff).

KOKQ 6, 2008

17

 . ,
, [ ] . , .

. , ,
( ), . .

, ,
- .
? , , ,
. , ,
-
.
,

. , , ,
.
,
, , , , , . ,

Brenner R. Bourgeois Revolution and Transition to Capitalism, in The First Modern

Society: Essays in English History in Honour of Lawrence Stone, ed. A. L. Beier et al.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, . P. .
. Anderson P. Modernity and Revolution, in New Left Review,
. No. . Pp. ff.
. The ballot box is the cofn
of revolutionaries (. The Future of Revolutions, ed. J. Foran. L.: Zed Press, .
P. ). . Halliday F. Utopian Realism: The Challenge for Revolution in Our Times,
in ibid. P. ff.
,
-

18

 ,
, , . .
, , -, -.
, .
-. , - TINA (There Is No Alternative). TINA ,
, , .
,
?

. (
) .
! : -,
, , ,
. . , , ,
, .
,
.
,
.
.
- ,
. -

. Lindblom C. E. The Market as Prison, in The Journal of Politics, .

Vol. . No. , . , , , .
. Castoriadis C. The Idea of Revolution, in The Rising Tide of Insignicance. P. ff.
(http:6www.notbored.org / RTI . pdf).
, . . .
. Finlay C. J. Violence and Revolutionary Subjectivity, in
European Journal of Political Theory, . Vol. . No. . P. .
. . . . .: REFL -book, . C. , , , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

19

 , ,
,
(, ). ,
, . ,
- , - , ,
. (
)
, .
.
. ,
. , , , ,
modus operandi .
, ,
, / ( - )
, ,
. .

. Wang Hui.
Depoliticized Politics, from East to West, in New Left Review, . No. .
, , Olson M. Rise and Decline of Nations: Economic Growth, Stagation, and
Social Rigidities. New Haven, CT : Yale University Press, . . ,
, Olson M. Power and Prosperity: Outgrowing Communist and
Capitalist Dictatorships. NY : Basic Books, .
. Hayek F. A. Law, Legislation and Liberty. Vol. . Chicago: The University of Chicago
Press, . Pp. ff.
. . . .: -, .
( . .) -

20

 ,
, ,
. ,
, . (, ,
)
,
, .
,
, , .

. (
)? , , , . , , , ?
,
? , ,

, .
,
,
?
,
(
) - .

. , , ,
,
. . Balibar E. Citizen Subject, in Who Comes After the Subject? Pp. ff.
. , , , , . . Jameson F.
A Singular Modernity. Essays on the Ontology of the Present. L.-NY : Verso, . Pp. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

21

( ), :
.

. , -,
, . ,

. , ,
. ?

. , . , XVIII . .
, , . .
.
? , , . ,
. ,

, .
Sewell W. H. Jr. Op. cit. P. .
. . 6 . . . . : -, . C. .
. : 6 . . --, .
.
, . ,
, .

, , ,
. . ( ) , ( ).
-- , , , non-starter.

22

 , ?
( ), ( )? ( ) ,
(. . .) , , ,
.
, ,
, , ?
, -- , .
, . , ,
, . ,
, () .

,
, ,
, . .

. Hampson N. The Enlightenment: An Evaluation of Its Assumptions and Values.

Harmondsworth: Penguin, . P. . , , , .
. Gagliardo J. G. Enlightened Despotism. Arlington Heights (IL ): Harlan Davidson,
. P. VI ff.


( ) .
( , ) . , ( , ),
cahiers,
. ,
. . Doyle W. Revolution and Counter-Revolution in France, in Revolution
and Counter-Revolution, ed. E. E. Rice. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, . Pp. ..

KOKQ 6, 2008

23

 ,
, ( , ). ,
, ( ), , , .
, -
, republique des letters -
XIX , XX ? ,
, ,

?
, , ( ).
(-) , , , , , , , , -
,
, . , , .
,
, ,
,
, . . ,
.
? ?

. Hobsbawm E. The Making of a Bourgeois Revolution, in Social Research. .

Vol. . No. . Pp. .
. Voegelin E. From Enlightenment to Revolution, ed. J. H. Hallowell. Durham, NC : Duke
University Press, . P. , , .

, ,
, .

24

 , ,
?
,
,


. ,

, , ,

. -
. . , . , . , , , , . . ( )
,
.
-
- :
, , - ,
.
,
-, . : ,
, . .

(. . ).
(. . . . C. ).
Przeworski A. Democracy and the Market. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, . P. .
. Lipset S. M. and G. Bence. Anticipations of the Failure of Communism, in Theory
and Society. . vol. . No. . Pp. , . ,
, ,
, . , , . . Kuran T. Now Out of Never: The Element
of Surprise in the East European Revolution of , in World Politics. . Vol. .
No. , . . .
Sharman J. C. Culture, Strategy, and State-Centered Explanations of Revolution,
and , in Social Science History. . Vol. . No. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

25

 , , . . , ,
, , , , .
,
, , ,
.
, , , . .
, .
, ,
.

( ), ,
, , . ., .
. . , , . . , , ,
.
? , ,

. Wolin S. The Politics of the Study of Revolution, in Comparative Politics. . Vol. .

No. , . , . ,

,
,
,
- . , -
, ! .
Mouzelis N. Evolution and Democracy: Talcott Parsons and the Collapse of Eastern
European Regimes, in Theory, Culture and Society. . Vol. . No. , . .
. . : 6 C. . ,

. . . 6 . . . . . . . .: , .

26

 , , .
, - .
, - . ,
, , .
, , , ,
, ,
,
,
( ). ,
,
, , , , ,
, . , , . , .
- , - ,
. . , ,
( . , . . , . ). , ,
. ,
,
: , , ,
, , , ,
. ,

. Dunn J. Modern Revolutions: An Introduction to the Analysis of a Political Phenomenon.

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, . Pp. , .
. . . . . . .: , . C. .
. . / . . . .: , . C. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

27

 , ( ), .
, , :
(
),

- .
, ,
. . , . ? , ,
, , . , , -
,
, , , .

, ,
? ? ? ?
-
, .

Arendt H. What Is Freedom? in Between Past and Future. NY : Penguin, . P. .

. Calvert P. Revolution and Counter-Revolution. Milton Keynes (UK ): Open University
Press, . P. .
. : 6
C. .
, , , , (.
Calvert P. Op. cit. P. ). , () , .
. ,
, ,

. , , -

28

, , , ,
. , ,
[ . . .]
, .
, , , , ( ), , . . ,
.
, .
I.

. , ,
,
, . ,
, . . , . , XV ,
, .
, (
), , . , , ,
. ( )
, ,
, ( ), , .
: ,

. (. . . ., ). , .
Badiou A. In nite Thought. Truth and the Return to Philosophy, tr. O. Feltham and
J. Clemens. L-NY : Continuum, . P. .
. Benjamin W. Op. cit. P. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

29

( ), ,
. , , , , , . . ,
.
, ,


. ,
,
, , , , . .
.
( . ), ,
- , . ,
.
,
.
, , , , , , .
Les Rvolutions de Paris, , , .

. Badiou A. On a Finally Objectless Subject, in Who Comes After the Subject. P. .

. Bensaid D. Alain Badiou and the Miracle of Event, in Think Again: Alain Badiou and the
Future of Philosophy, ed. P. Hallward. L NY : Continuum, . Pp. . . Clemens J. and O. Feltham. The Thought of Stupefaction; Or, Event and Decision as NonOntological and Pre-Political Factors in the Work of Gilles Deleuze and Alain Badiou.
P. ff. http:6whiteheadresearch.org / event-and-decision / #papers
, . . Godechot J. The Taking
of the Bastille: July , , tr. J. Stewart. NY : Charles Scribners Sons, .

. Baker K. M. Inventing the French

30

 , , :

. . Palais Royal .
,
: Saint-Lazare, , , ,
, , Htel des Invalides. .
, .
, .
, ,
. . , , , ,
Htel des Invalides ,
.
.
,
. ,
. , , ,
, , . -

Revolution: Essays on the French Political Culture in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, . Pp. .
. Godechot J. Op. cit. Pp. . : , . !
,
. :
- . , , ,
. . . Lusebrink H-J. and R. Reihardt. The Bastille: A History of a Symbol of Despotism
and Freedom, tr. N. Schurer. Durham (NC ): Duke University Press, . P. , .
. Godechot J. Op. cit. P. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

31

 :
( ) . , ,
, ,
, . , .
, .
, .
. ,
: , , , , . .
.
, . .
, , . - , , , . .
,
. , . . . ,
. , ( ) , ,
,
(, , ) .

?

. Lefebvre G. The Coming of the French Revolution, tr. R. R. Palmer. Princeton (NJ ):
Princeton University Press, (. ).

32

 . , , , ,
, , . .
, . Htel des
Invalides -. .
,
, ,
Htel des Invalides ,
?

, . . ,
, . . , , ,
. ,
- ( ) ,
. , , , modus operandi .
, . . , , ,
. .
,
, . , : .
:
- ;
- ( ,
, ).
, ,
, , IV ,
, .

. Sewell W. H. Op. cit. P. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

33

II .

() .
, , ( ) ,
, ,
.
, , ,
, ( ), ,
, - , , , .
, ,
. , ,
, , ,
, . , , , . .
,
, . , ,
, . . ,
. ( ,
, ,
), . ,
. . , .
. ,

, , .
, XX (
XIX ) (. .., . ). ,
.

34

, , , ,
.
, . . , :
, , . .
, .
?
,
, ,
. , , , , , ( )
, , .
. :
, , . <>

. Zeitgeist [] . , , , , . ,
. ,
[ ].
, , . ( ),
(

Badiou A. Innite Thought... P. .

Schumpeter J. A. Imperialism and Social Classes, ed. P. M. Sweezy. NY : A. M. Kelley, .
Pp. ( . . .).

KOKQ 6, 2008

35

 ), / ( , , ).
,
( ),
. ,
, ,
.
, , ,
. , , ,
. ,
, modus operandi
.
(dislocation) , , .

. ,
( ), ,
. , , , ,
. ,

, ,
-
, .
. Laclau E. New Reections on the Revolution of Our Time. L-NY : Verso, . Pp. .

36

 Cahiers de dolances, . .
,
, ,
,
, . , , -

, .
, , ,
, ,
. ,
.
( ) : ,
, , . - ,
.
:
, .
, , (,
) .
, . . , , ,
, . ,
, . - ,
- , , . :
, ,

, ,

. . .: , . C. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

37

 ?. , , - -,
, . .

.
, ,
, . ,
, ,
,
- .
() ,
,
.

( ) .
, , , -
, , .
, , ,
. , , .
, , ( ,
. .), ,
.

, ,
.

. .

38

 , , . . , . , ,
, ,
, , , ,
. , .
( ) , - ,
. . ,
, , , . . ,
.
, , ,
.
, . . , - , .
,
. ,

. , . . , ,
, [ ] ,
( . 6 ... C. , ).

. Bobbio N. Gramsci and the Conception of Civil Society, in Gramsci and Marxist
Theory, ed. C. Mouffe. L.: Routledge and Kegan Paul, . Pp. ff.
. Gramsci A. Selections from the Prison Notebooks, tr. Q. Hoare and G. Nowell Smith. L.:
Lawrence and Wishart, . Pp. n, , .
,
,
( ) . . Balibar E.
Marx, the Joker in the Pack (or the Included Middle), in Economy and Society. .
Vol. . No. . Pp. ; Rosenthal J. Who Practices Hegemony? Class Division and the
Subject of Politics, in Cultural Critique. . No. . Pp. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

39


. , , . , Htel
des Invalides , ,
, , , .
,
, , . , ,
, . , ,
, ,
.
III .

, , -, ( ), -, .
-
,
. ( -)

, :
, , , . (,
) . ,
, ,
(. . / . . . . .: , . . , ).
( )
, .
, , :
.
,
,
, . , , ( ). ,
. . Foucault M. The Ethics of the Concern for Self as a Practice of Freedom:

40

 , , , . ., ,

, . ,
, , , . .
.
( ) , . .
, , ,
( ) . ,
, , . .
. -.
() .
,
.
, . ,
,
, -

An Interview with Michel Foucault, in Ethics: Subjectivity and Truth. Essential Works of
Michel Foucault, , ed. P. Rabinow. Vol. . L.: Penguin Books, . P. .
. Laclau E. Op. cit. P. .

.
.
,
, , , , , , . . Countryman E. The
American Revolution. NY : Hill & Wang, . P. .
,
. ,
, , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

41

 . ( ,
), , , ,
,
.

, . . ,
. ,
. , -

,
, , .
, ( ) , . ,
,
(. ).

, , , - , (! ! !), (. . .
6 . . . . . .: , . C. ). ,
. . , ( ), (. Trotsky L. The History of the
Russian Revolution. Vol. 6 Tr. M. Eastman. NY : Simon & Schuster, . P. ).
, - .
,
, ,
. (. . ), .
,
. , , (,
, ).

42


,
, .

. , ,
, . ,
(, , ,
).
, , . , .
( )
,
.
. , ,
( ) .
( , )
, ( ) , .
, ,
, . ,
, (
). , ,

. . 6 .
. . . .: , . C. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

43

 , ( )
, -
, . , ,
,
, , .
IV .

( ) , . :
,
, , .
, , .
( ) ,
. ,
. , ,
. , , ,
,
? ,

, (. ).
, ,
,
. , , ,

. Che Guevara E. Guerilla Warfare: A Method, in Venceremos! The Speeches and

Writings of Che Guevara, ed. J. Gerassi. NY : Macmillan, . Pp. , .
. . . . 6 . C. .
. Moore B. Op. cit. Pp. . , (Interregnum), (
. . . ). , , ?.
. . . . C. .

44

 ?
, ,
()
, ?
. ,
,
(

)?
. ,
, .
( ), . .
. ,
, .
,
, ,
, , .
, ontradictio in adjecto.
,

. Klima A. The Bourgeois Revolution of in Central

Europe, in Revolution in History Pp. . .

, - ? , : , ,
, ( / )? , , . Tassin E. sed victa Catoni: The
Defeated Cause of Revolutions, in Social Research, . Vol. . No. .
. . . . C. .
( ), .
, , , ( ) , . . Badiou A. On a Finally Objectless
Subject. P. .
. . . . C. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

45


differentia specica. , , , , ,
, ,
, .
, , -
. , ,
, , , , . , , , .
: (. ).

,
, ,
, .
, , , , . , , - , ,
. ,
.
, . , ( ,
)
, .
, . , , .

. (- , , ,
). - .
, : - ,

46

( , , ), . , Champs-lyses Place de la
Concorde, ,
,
. , , , , . ,
,
. , , ,
.

-
Lusebrink H-J. and R. Reichardt. Op. cit. Pp. vii-ix.

KOKQ 6, 2008

47

Z^ W ^ XYK

/
?

,
, , . : , , -, , ,
,
.

, , , , ( INTAS YSF
- -).
. Lepenies, W. Between Literature and Science: The Rise of Sociology. New York: Cambridge
UP , . Discourses on Society: The Shaping of the Social Science Disciplines. Sociology
of Sciences Yearbook. Eds. by Peter Wagner, Bjorn Wittrock, Richard P. Whitley.
Dordrecht: Kluwer, . Wagner P. After Justication: Repertoires of Evaluation and
the Sociology of Modernity 6 European Journal of Social Theory. () , .
Wagner P. Epistemology and Critique 6 European Journal of Social Theory. () ,
. Wagner P. Two Ways of Vindicating the Political 6 European Journal of Social
Theory. () , . Wagner P. A History and Theory of the Social Sciences. Not All That
Is Solid Melts Into Air. London: Sage, . Wagner, Peter. Social Theory and Political
Philosophy 6 Contemporary European Social Theory. Ed. G. Delanty. London, New York:
Routledge, ; . Wagner P. Modernity as Experience and Interpretation. A New
Sociology of Modernity. Cambridge: Polity, . .
, .

48



( ), , , , ( )
( ),

; , ,
. . e , . , , , :
, .
, , , . , , . ,
, ?

.
(
, , ),
,
.
, ,
, , e ,
.

, ,
: , ,
, , ;
,

. The Return of the Grand Theories in the Human Sciences. Ed. Quentin Skinner. Worcester:
Cambridge UP , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

49

, . ( ) - , , , ,
, ,
e
.
.
, , ,
,

. ( ), , ( ,
) ,
.
, : -, , , (
, ),
, - ( ,
), ,
- , , (); -,
,
, ,
( )
( ) (); , , e , ().

-, ,
(-

50

 ),
( , ). - ,
,
.
I .

-, ( )
, ,
, ( , , ),
, - . -
( , , ), - .
(, , ) ( , , , . . . .) e ,
,
.
II .

-,
,
. . : KOKQ 6, 2008

51


;

, , .
,
e ,
- ., ,

( )
. , , , , , .
, e ,
()
(policy
sciences),
, ,
.

: (administered
society), policy designer

. , ,
, ,
, , , . ( )
.
III .

-, -

52

 . ( ,
, ,
), , , ,
. e ,

-, - , . . , , .
IV .

-e, , - , ( - .
, , ), , ,
(,
)
(), () (
). ,
,
.

, , - ,
, , ,
,
.
, , : -, ; -, ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

53

 ; -, ; -e, ,
(
).
: ?

, , ,
. , , :
, - , , ,
, .
: ( , opinion makers, - , . .) ,
, e , . , , , ,
, ,

, .
, , e
- (, , , ) ( , ,
), (
,
,

. : Boltanski L.,
Thvenot L. On Justication, Economies of Worth. Tr. by C Porter. Princeton: Princeton
UP , . The Social Logic of Politics. Personal Networks as Contexts for political Behavior. Ed.
Alan S. Zuckerman. Philadelphia: Temple UP , .

54

 , ,
, , , ). , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

55

[X ] W Z O ^W

.
(; ) , ,
, ,
, . , () ,
, , ,
.
() . , , ,
...
, , , ().
, - , , ,
, ( ,
). - ,

56

 , , .
, ;
, , , ,
. . .

,
.
, ,
, . , , ,
.
, , , ?
,
, , , . , ,
.
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
. ,
, ,
, .
- . ,
.

, ( KOKQ 6, 2008

57

) ,
.
, . ,
, . , , ,
:

; , , . , ,

. , ; ,

.
.
. , ( : ). , , , ,
- . , , ,
, . .
, , , ,
. , ,
. ,
: ;
.
. , . . , . ,
, , ,

. .

58

 .
, , , .
.

,
.
, .
sui generis ( ) , ,
, .
, ( ).
, , , ,
, .
.
, ,
( ). , ,
, . , .
, .
; . ,
,

. ; . .
. ().

KOKQ 6, 2008

59

 .
, , ,
.

,
. , . (: ): ,
... , ,
,
,

. .
, ,

,
(), - . . , , ,
,
( : ). , .
;
, ,
( : ).

. , , , ,

(: ) - : .
. .

. .

60

 . , - ,
- - . .

,
, ( ).
, . ,
. ,
, , ,
.
; , , . ,
. , -. ( ) , -
, ; . ,
, , , . ., , ,
,
, ( , ,
).

, , , , , ,
, . , ,

.
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

61

 , . , , . . . ,
. , -,
, , , ,
.
, . -, , ,

, . ,
,
,
. , ,
,
, .

. (
[]: , ),
, , ( : ).

, , , ,
.
, , . , , ( []: ),
.
(, . . ), , , , ; , :
, .

62

 , ,
, : , , , ( ) (
), ;
,
. , , .
, , , ,
. . , ,
.
,
, , , ( : ). , ,
, , , .
,
.
, . . , . , , .
, ,
,
.
:
. ,

, ,
;
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

63

 . , , . ,
, , . , .
,
, ,
.
, , , .
, ( ).
, ,
,

. , . ,
( ) , , ,
,
, , .
. , :
,
. : ,
.
; ,
. ,
, ,

(),
.

64

, . ,
, .
, , , , , , ( ).
, .
, , , . -
, . . ,
, , ,
. ,
, - ,
.
- , , ,
, -
.
,
.
- ,
, . , ,
; . , , , (. .,
, ),
-- -, (. ., ; ). , , .

, -, ,

, ,
, .

KOKQ 6, 2008

65

 , , ,
.
-. -, ,
.
, ,
.
:
. :
. ,
, -
.

,
, . ,
, , . ,

, . ,
, ( ),
-
.
; , ,
, , .

66


, .
, , , , . ,
. ,
.

, , ,
. , . , ,
,
,
, , , .
,
.
. , ,
( ), ( ), , , , ,
.
, ,
.
,
( ) .
, . , , ,
. , , KOKQ 6, 2008

67

, , .
, ,
. ,
,
.
-,

. , , , . .
,
- . -, , ,
, , . , , ,
.
, , . -,

.
,
.
, ,
, ,
.
,
,
, ,
. ,
, . , , ,

68

 . ,
, ,
, . ,
, ,
,
, . , .

, ,

. ,
. ,
( ) .
-
, - . , -, - - ,
, ,
, , . -- ,
, ,
, .

, : , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

69

 . ,
. (constitution)
, ,
. , - -.
,
, . ,
, / . , . ,

(case), . (.
). (law),
, ,
. , , .

:

,
, ,
(. ; );
, ,
; () () , , (),
.

70


Arendt H. (1958) The Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Baker K. M. (1975) Condorcet: From Natural Philosophy to Social Mathematics. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press.
Boltanski L., Thvenot L. (1991) De la justication. Paris: Gallimard.
Burke E. (1993 [1790]) Reections on the Revolution in France. Oxford: Oxford University Press (ed.
L. G. Mitchell).
Desrosires A. (1993) La politique des grands nombres: Histoire de la raison statistique. Paris: La
dcouverte.
Donzelot J. (1984) Linvention du social: Essai sur le dclin des passions politiques. Paris: Fayard.
Esposito R. (1998) Communitas: Origine destino della communit. Turin: Einaudi.
Fourasti J., Cohen D. (2004) Les Trente Glorieuses ou la Rvolution invisible de 1946 1975. Paris:
Hachette Littratures.
Gander E. (1999) The Last Conceptual Revolution: A Critique of Richard Rortys Political Philosophy.
Albany: SUNY Press.
Hallberg P., Wittrock B. (2006) From koinonia politik to societas civilis, In P. Wagner (ed.) The
Languages of Civil Society. Oxford: Berghahn.
Heilbron J. (1995) The Rise of Social Theory. Cambridge: Polity.
Hirschman A. (1977) The Passions and Interests: Arguments for Capitalism before Its Triumph.
Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Honneth A. (1992) Kampf um Anerkennung. Frankfurt / M: Suhrkamp.
Joas H. (1992) Die Kreativitt des Handelns. Frankfurt / M: Suhrkamp.
Karagiannis N., Wagner P. (2005) Towards a Theory of Synagonism. In The Journal of Political
Philosophy 13 (1): 232 265.
Lamont M., Thvenot L. (eds.) (2000) Rethinking Comparative Cultural Sociology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Latour B. (1991) Nous navons jamais ts modernes. Paris: La dcouverte.
Lefort C. (1986) Rversibilit: Libert politique et libert de lindividu. In Essais sur le politique.
XIX XX sicles. Paris: Seuil: 197 216.
Manent P. (1994) La cit de lhomme. Paris: Fayard.
Nancy J-L. (1986) La communaut dsoeuvre. Paris: Bourgois.
Nancy J-L. (2001) La communaut affront. Paris: Galile.
Offe C. (1998) Demokratie und Wohlfahrtsstaat: Eine europische Regimeform unter dem
Stress der europischen Integration. In W. Streeck (ed.) Internationale Wirtschaft, nationale
Demokratie. Frankfurt / M: Campus: 99 136.
Pettit P. (1997) Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government. Oxford: Clarendon.
Rawls J. (1971) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.
Rorty R. (1989) Contingency, Irony, Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skinner Q. (1998) Liberty before Liberalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taylor C. (1975) Hegel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Therborn G. (1976) Science, Class and Society: On the Formation of Sociology and Historical Materialism.
London: New Left Books.
Van Gelderen M., Skinner Q. (eds.) (2002) Republicanism: A Shared European Heritage. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press (2 vol.).

KOKQ 6, 2008

71

Wagner P. (1998) Certainty and Order, Liberty and Contingency; the Birth of Social Science as
Empirical Political Philosophy. In J. Heilbron, L. Magnusson, B. Wittrock (eds.) The Rise of
the Social Sciences and the Formation of Modernity. Dordrecht: Kluwer: 241 263.
Wagner P. (1999) After Justication: Repertoires of Evaluation and the Sociology of Modernity.
In European Journal of Social Theory 2 (3): 341 357.
Wagner P. (2001) A History and Theory of Social Sciences. London: Sage.
Wagner P. (2004) Soziologie der kritischen Urteilskraft und der Rechtfertigung: Die Politik- und
Moralsoziologie um Luc Boltanski und Laurent Thvenot. In S. Moebius, L. Peter, Franzsische Soziologie heute. Konstanz: UVK / UTB : 417 448.
Wood G. S. (1998 [1969]) The Creation of the American Republic 1776 1787. Durham: University of
North Carolina Press.

72

OKWZ^ ]WVK W^

,
?

?
? ,
. , , . , ,
, ,
.
? ,
() () , , , , (),
(), (),

Gran Therborn. What Does The Ruling Class Do When It Rules? Some Reections on
Different Approaches to The Study of Power In Society, in: Rhonda F. Levine (ed.),
Enriching the Sociological Imagination: How Radical Sociology Changed the Discipline. Boulder,
CO : Paradigm, . P. .
., .: R. Dahl. A Critique of the Ruling Elite Model. American Political Science Review
(APSR) . . P. ; N. Polsby. How to Study Community Power: The Pluralist
Alternative. Journal of Politics. . . P. : P. Bachrach M. Baratz. The Two
Faces of Power. APSR. . . P. ; P. Bachrach M. Baratz. Decisions and
Nondecisions: An Analytical Framework. APSR. . . P. ; R. Merelman. On
the Neo-Elitist Critique of Community Power. APSR. . . P. ; APSR. .
. P. ; F. Frey. Comment: On Issues and Nonissues in the Study of Power.
APSR. . . P. ; R. Wolnger. Rejoinder to Freys Comment. APSR. . .
P. . : R. Bell, D. Edwards,
and H. Wagner, (eds.) Political Power. New York: Free Press, .

KOKQ 6, 2008

73

 ( , ) (, )
, ?
,

.
. , : ?,
: ?, , . . , ?, : - ?

,
, , , . , . ,
: ? , , ,
, , ,
? , .

-.
- , ,
. ,

, : A. Giddens. The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies.

London: Hutchinson, . P. . ,
, , , : R. Dahl. Pluralist Democracy in
the United States: Conict and Consent. Chicago: Rand McNally, .
R. Dahl. Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City. New Haven: Yale Univ.
Press, .
W. Domhoff. Who Rules America? Englewood Cliffs, N. J.: Prentice-Hall, .
W. G. Runciman. Towards a Theory of Social Stratication, in F. Parkin, ed. The Social
Analysis of Class Sructure. London: Tavistock, . P. .
Polsby. Op. cit. P. .

, , , ,
. , .: Bachrach and
Baratz. Power and Poverty. New York; Oxford University Press, .
: F. Hunter. Community
Power Structure. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press, ; . . . .: , ; W. Domhoff. Op. cit. Bachrach
and Baratz. Op. cit.; M. Parenti. Power and Pluralism: A View From the Bottom, in

74

 ,
, , . ,
, , .
, ,
,
.
, , , .
.
, , , .
. ,
, ,
. , .
. , , , ,
, ,

, .
. -

M. Surkin A. Wolfe, eds., An End to Political Science. New York: Basic Books, .
P. ; M. Creson. The Un-Politics of Air Pollution. Baltimore: The John Hopkins Press,
. .: S. D. Riesman, et al. The Lonely Crowd. New York:
Doubleday Anchor, ; R. Dahl. Who Governs?; E. Baneld. Political Inuence. New York:
Free Press, . . . .
: R. Miliband. The State in Capitalist Society. London:
Weidenfeld & Nicolson, . .: N. Poulantzas. Political Power and Social Class. London: NLB , . ,
, : E. Laclau. The Specicity of the Political:
The Poulantzas / Miliband Debate. Economy and Society (). P. . , . .
. 6
. . . .: , . . .
. . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

75

 , . ,
,
, , ,
.

, ,
, .
, ,
,
/ , , . ,
.
.
(
, ) ;
. . , .
,
, . , , , , , , , ,
. , .
,
.
-.
,
,

J. Buchanan G. Tullock. The Calculus of Consent. Ann Arbor: Univ. of Michigan Press,
. . .
, / , - . A. Downs. An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York:
Harper & Row, . P. .
S. Huntington. Political Order in Changing Societies. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, . P. l.
Ibid. P. .

76

 , , , -, , , .
, : ? : ,
?
, ,
, , ,
,
. , ,
() ,
. , ,
( )
.
II

, ,
. / , .
, ,
: , ?
?
,
, , . .
, , ,
, .
/ ,
. , .
, ,
,

. . . . .
. . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

77

 , ,
. , , , . . ,
,
. (, , . .) .
.
, , ,
.

, , , : ,
,
, , , , ().
(,
): [Gemeinwesen],
, . ,

,

.: G. Therborn. Klasser och okonomiska

system. Staffanstorp: Cavefors, . . : G. Therborn.
Classes in Sweden , in R. Scase, ed., Readings in the Swedish Class Structure.
Oxford: Pergammon, .
, , , ,
, , .
,
.
, , , , . ,
.

78

 , , , ,
, , .
,
, ? : ,
? ? , , , , .
,

-. ,
.
,
. , , , , ,
, , , , . , , , , :
, ?
, , ,
. - . , . , , ,
, .
, , . : , , . ,

., . . . . . II . . .
, , -
.
T. . .: , .
.: G. Therborn. Class, Science and Society. London: NLB , . Ch. ..

KOKQ 6, 2008

79

 . ,
, , , .
. , , ,
; ,
.
, , . , ,
. : , , ! : , , ! ,

, , ,
, ,
,
.
/ , , , . -
-? ,
,

?
,
, ,
. - .
: ,
,

, ,
. V . Pareto. Les
Systemes Socialistes. Paris, . . P. . . R. Michels.
Political Parties. Glencoe: Free Press, . P. .
: Bachrach Baratz. Op. cit.

80

 ?
?
, , . , ,
-, ,
- . ,
, ,
.
, ,

, , , .
, ? / ,
,
?

: . , . , , ,
, ,
. R. Dahl. A Preface to
Democratic Theory. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press, . P. . , - , , ?
(Miliband. Op. cit.).
,
.

(.: Ch. . Part IV ). , . , ,
. ,
,
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

81

 , ;

, . , . , -, .
,
, , .
.
. ,
, ,
.
! ,
, , ( ). , -,
/
( , ).
/ , , , , ,

Bachrach and Baratz. Op. cit. , , .

S. Lukes. Power: A Radical View. London: Macmillan, .
, , . Bachrach-Baratz. Op. cit. . P. .
Lukes. Op. cit. Chs. , . : Crenson. Op. cit.
Bachrach and Baratz. Op. cit. . Ch. .
Lukes. Op. cit. P. . .:
. ,
, . - ;
, , , , .
( ., . C. . . . ). , , , , ; , -,
. , , -. , ( ).

82

 .

. , , ,
,
. , .
, , , , , , , , .
XVIII XIX , , , XX : , ,
,
. , .
, ,
? ? : , ? ? ( ) ( )
, ? , ,
. . , () , /
.

.

. C. .
. C. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

83

III

,
, - ()
. , , . , , ,
, - ,
. , , ,
( , )
() () , .
, . . ,
,
,
, , ,
. ,
(, -), , , .
() ( ) ( ) . ,
, .
. : ( ) , . .

(,
, ,
. .) ,

84

 , ,
( , )
.

, , , ,
, , , . , , ,
. , ,
,
.
, , (
, () ). . . , , , .
,
, ( ),
. ,
.
, ,
. (

, ). , :

,
: Claus Offe. Klassenherrschaft und politisches System.
Zur Selektivitat politischer Institutionen, in his Strukturprobleme des kapitalistischen
Staates. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, . ,
, (P. ). ,
post festum, (P. ),
, .

KOKQ 6, 2008

85


( )

,
, , , . ., , . , , . ,
,
,
, , , .
, . , ,
,
,
.
.
() ( , ).

,
. , , ; - ,
;
, , ( , ).

86

 , ,
. ,
. ,

. . , , ,

,
(,
, , ). , , .
, ( , )
. , ,
(, , ,
, ).
( ), , , . ,
, , , (, , ),
.
, ,
. ,
, , .

, , -

KOKQ 6, 2008

87

 , , (
), , . .
, ,
, , . , ,
. .
( )
. , ,
, . , , .
,
, .
, .
, , ,
, . , ,
. ,
, , . - ,
. ,
, .
. ,
( ):
, . , , , . -

, . .: N. Poulantzas. Fascism and Dictatorship. London: NLB ,

.
N. Poulantzas. On Social Classes, New Left Review. . . P. .

88

 , ,
. , .

, . ; ,
, .
,

? , ,
. , , , .

, . , ;

, , . , , ,
,
,
.
, , , , .
-
,
.
, ,
(, , ). , ,
, . . . KOKQ 6, 2008

89

 (
) (
,
). .
, ,
.
, .

. , ,
.
. (
,
). , , , , .
, . . ,

. .: .
. .: , . . . , (Parkin. Op. cit. . Ch. ),
: , , , . ,
,
: H. F. Moorhouse.
The Political Incorporation of the British Working Class: An Interpretation. Sociology. .
. P. . . : R. Gray. The Political Incorporation of the Working Class.
Sociology. . . P. ; H. F. Moorhouse. On the Political Incorporation of the
Working Class: Reply to Gray. Ibid. P. .
, ,
, . . ,
, ,
.
, . -

90

 . , ,
: , , , ,
( ). , , . ,
( ) .
, ; . ,
. ,
:
,
. ,
. -

, ,
. , , , . . : Michael Mann. The Social Cohesion of Liberal Democracy. American Sociological
Review. . . P. .
,
, . ., .: J. Habermas. Legitimationsprobleme im Spatkapitallismus.
Frankfurt: Suhrkapm, . P. . . ,
, ,
, (Habermas. Op. cit. Ch. II .; Offe. Tauschverhaltnis und politische
Steuerung. Zur Aktualitat des Legitimationsproblems, in Offe, op. cit. P. ).

,

.
. : Louis Althusser. Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
(Notes towards an Investigation), in Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays. London:
NLB , . P. . , ,
.
., . C. . . . II . . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

91

, .
, , . , , , .


, .
.
( ) .
, , , .
.
.
, .

.
. , , . , ,
.
. , , , . XX
.

,
,
, .
, , . , , .

92

ZW ] XX

,
, , , ? ?
?
, ,

, , ,
. ,
, ,
( ) . ,
. ,
, .
.
,
,
, , ,
, , ,

Charles Tilly. Regimes and Contention, in Thomas Janoski, et. al (eds). The Handbook
of Political Sociology: States, Civil Societies, and Globalization. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, . P. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

93

 . , ,
.

. ,
,
, . : -,
, ;
-, .
,
. ,
, :
, ,



, : )
; ) ,

, ,
,
, . (Tilly, )
, . -,
, . .

94


, . ,
: , , , . , (McAdam,
Tarrow, and Tilly, ). , .
? : , , ,
, , , , , , , .
:

, () , , ;

, ,
,
, .
, , , . ( , , , ). ,
, , , ,
, . , , , . ,
, ,
.
,
, , , :
KOKQ 6, 2008

95

 , . , , . . , ,
, ; , , .
, , :
, , .

. , . , .
. ,
, :

, , , ,
, ,
, , ,
, : , ,
; ,
,
: , ;
. ,
, .

, .
, .
( , ), . ,
-
.
,

96

 .
,
,
. , , ,
( .:
Lichbach and Zuckerman, ).
, , ,
, . , : , ,
, . , , , , (., .: Stearns, ).

, .
, . .
(Dogan and Higley, ; Dogan and Pelassy,
; Held, ; Spruyt, ).
, , (Collier and Collier, ;
Mahoney, , ; Mahoney and Snyder, ).
. - , , ,
, ,

(., .: ; Anderson
). , . ,
, . KOKQ 6, 2008

97

 , ,
/ (Moore, ). ,
,
. , , , , , , .
, , .
.
, . , . ,
, :
(.: Przeworski, Alvarez, Cheibub, and Limongi, ).
,
: (Anderson,
Fish, Hanson, and Roeder, ; Arat, ; Bratton and van de Walle, ;
Burkhart and Lewis-Beck, ; Dawisha and Parrott, ; Lijphart, ;
Linz and Stepan, ; Vanhanen, ; Yashar, ).
. ,
(Marshall, ; . :
Barbalet, ; Turner, ), : ?
?
, ,
(Esping-Anderson, ; Goodin, Headey, Muffels, and Dirven, ; Hage,
Hannemann, and Gargan, ; Janoski and Hicks, ; Ruggie, ).

98

 , ,
- . ( , , , -). , ,
:
-
, , ,
. -, ,
, . ,
,
, . ,
, , .
,
. (Janoski, 1998: 222 223)

, , .
, , : , .
, . . .
. . , : ,
,
, , ,
.
, , ; .
,
, ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

99

(
)

( )
. 1.

, -,
.
: () , () , () , () , ()
, () , () ()
, .
,
,
, (Dahl, : ; . : , ). ,

, ,
. , ,
.
incognito, ( ) , ,
,
. ,
, , , . -

100

. 2.

() ,
, () ()
.
. , (, ),
, , , ,
, , , , . . , : ( ), ( ), ( )
(). .
. , -,
,
. , ,
, ; . , ,

. popolo

KOKQ 6, 2008

101

 . , , , , XIII : ,
(Finer, 1997: 954).

, , , . ,
, ,
.
, ,
A X , Y Z.
, : -, ,
; -, , , ,
, .
, .
,
.
( ) , , , , ,

. ,
. , : -,
, , , ,
,
; -, , , , , , ,
. .

102

, ,
,
. : , , , , ,
, ,
,
.
, : , ,
, - ; ;
; , ( , ) ; ,

.
, ,
. ,
, ,

, ,
,
.

.

. /
.
.
:
. (
): () ().
. : ()
().
KOKQ 6, 2008

103

. : ()
, , ().
. , , () , ()
, :
()
().
. : () ().
( ,
, , , ) , , .
( , ,
, , ) ,
. .
- ,
, - , , :
, , , , , , , , . ,
(Janoski, : ):

0,80

0,85

0,90

0,80

0,85

0,90

0,85

0,80

0,95

0,80

0,90

0,85

0,75

0,80

0,95

, , ,
, .

104

 ,
, , .
: ,
. (, , ) , .
, ,
. ,
. ,
, , ,
,
,
, . , ,
.
.
, . , , ,
. ,
.
: , ,
. , , , ,
. , .
: . , .
KOKQ 6, 2008

105

 : ,

, .

. ,
,
, ,
, , , , , -
,
, , . ,
,
XIX . .
, .
, .

XIX , , ,
/ , . , , , 0

W
]

. 3.

106


, , .
, ,
,
;
.

,
.
, , , ,
.
.
, ,
, , .
, , , , ;
, .
, , ,
, ; , , , ,
, ,
, , , .
, , , , ,
.
, , ,
, .
; , . ; , , ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

107

 . -, , , ( - )
. XIX
, , : ,
, , , . , . ,
; ,
.
XIX , ,
.

.
, , . , : , , , ,
. .
, ,
: , ,
. , , .

/ / .
: () ,
,
; () ,
; ()
.
: ,
, , . -

108

 , , , . , .
, . , .
,
? , ,
()
; () ,
, ,
, , ; ()
, ,
.
, ,
. , :
. ,
,
.
. ,
.
. , .
. , , , , .
. , , / , , , .
.
, ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

109

 , ( ), .
.
, ,
.
. ,
, ,
/ .
?
,
, .
.
, .
, () , (
), / , , , () ,
, ,
, .
:
.
.
.
,
.
. , / , , .
. , , ,
,
.
. , ,

110

, , .
. , ,
, :
.
. , .
, . , - .
?
, ,
. ,
. (, , , , , , ,
). ,
, , .

, , , / .

. ,
, , ,
. ( , , ).
, , , ,
.
( , , , ). :
KOKQ 6, 2008

111

. , ,
.
. ,
.
( ,
-

: ).
.
: ,
.
. (, , ) ,
(.: Tilly, : chapter ).
, , .
, ,
.
?
. . ,
() , , () , ()
, , () . / , , , ,
, , , , , . ,
.
,
.
,
, . , ,
,
() ,

112

(Scott ) , () ,
, ,
, . :
. (,
) ,
. , .
. ,
.
. , ( ) .
. , , ,
.
.
, , ,
, , .
. ,
, . , , , ,
, , .
. , .
.
: ,
, (, ,
).
.
( ), .
. ,
.
KOKQ 6, 2008

113

. ,
,
.
. , (
).
? : -, ,
, , -, , , , ,
, .
, , ,
. , , .
:
. ,
.
. , , .
. , / .
. ,
.
. , ,
.
. ,
,
.
. ,
.
, ,
,
-

114

 , , (
, )
.
, .
,
,
, . () , , ; () , ,
; () ,
; () , .


/ ,
: ,
.
. , ,
, , . ,
, , .
,
,
. , ,
( ),
:
, , , ;
,
;
,

KOKQ 6, 2008

115

, ,

. , , ,

.
? . .:
, , . ? -,

. 4.

116

 , ; ,
,
. ,


. , .
-,
,
; , , , . , ,

, , , , .
. , . , , : ()
,
, ,
; ()
; ()
, , .
,
- ; . , , , , , .
-,
. , ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

117

 , .
, , .
.
,
, ,
/ , .
, . :
, , . , ,
.
, , :
() ,
() ? :

? () , () , ()
, () , ()
() , () , () ,
? : ,
, , ? , , .
: () , ,
; () ; () .
, , : ,
.
, , , , , .

118

 , .
; . , ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,
.

. 2007. . .: .
. 2005. . - . .: .
Anderson Perry. 1974. Lineages of the Absolutist State. London: New Left Books.
Anderson, Richard D., Jr., M. Steven Fish, Stephen E. Hanson, and Philip G. Roeder. 2001. Postcommunism and the Theory of Democracy. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
Arat, Zehra F. 1991. Democracy and Human Rights in Developing Countries. Boulder, CO : Lynne Rienner.
Barbalet, J. M. 1988. Citizenship. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Bratton, Michael, and Nicholas van de Walle. 1997. Democratic Experiments in Africa. New York:
Cambridge University Press.
Burkhart, Ross E., and Michael S. Lewis-Beck. 1994. Comparative democracy: The economic
development thesis. American Political Science Review 88: 903 10.
Collier, Ruth Berins, and David Collier. 1991. Shaping the Political Arena. Critical Junctures,
the Labor Movement, and Regime Dynamics in Latin America. Princeton, NJ : Princeton
University Press.
Dahl, Robert A. 1975. Governments and political oppositions. In Fred I. Greenstein and Nelson
W. Polsby (eds.), Handbook of Political Science. Volume 3: Macropolitical Theory. Reading, MA :
Addison-Wesley.
Dawisha, Karen, and Bruce Parrott (eds.). 1997. The Consolidation of Democracy in East-Central
Europe. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
Dogan, Mattei, and John Higley. 1998. Elites, crises, and regimes in comparative analysis. In
Mattei Dogan and John Higley (eds.), Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes. Lanham, MD :
Rowman and Littleeld.
Dogan, Mattei, and Dominique Pelassy. 1984. How to Compare Nations. Strategies in Comparative
Politics. Chatham, NJ : Chatham House.
Esping-Andersen, Gsta. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge, UK : Polity.

KOKQ 6, 2008

119

Finer, S. E. 1997. The History of Government from the Earliest Times. Oxford, UK : Oxford University
Press.
Goodin, Robert E., Bruce Headey, Ruud Muffels, and Henk-Jan Dirven. 1999. The Real Worlds of
Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
Hage, Jerald, Robert Hanneman, and Edward T. Gargan. 1989. State Responsiveness and State
Activism: An Examination of the Social Forces that Explain the Rise in Social Expenditures
in Britain, France, Germany and Italy 1870 1968. London: Unwin Hyman.
Held, David. 1996. Models of Democracy (2nd Edition). Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press.
Janoski, Thomas. 1998. Citizenship and Civil Society: A Framework of Rights and Obligations in
Liberal, Traditional, and Social Democratic Regimes. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Janoski, Thomas and Alexander Hicks (eds.). 1994. Methodological Innovations in Comparative
Political Economy: An Introduction. Pp. 130 in Thomas Janoski and Alexander Hicks (eds.),
The Comparative Political Economy of the Welfare State. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Lichbach, Mark Irving, and Alan S. Zuckerman (eds.). 1997. Comparative Politics. Rationality, Culture, and Structure. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
Lijphart, Arend. 1999. Patterns of Democracy. Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six
Countries. New Haven, CT : Yale University Press.
Linz, Juan J., and Stepan, Alfred (eds.). 1978. The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes. Baltimore, London: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Mahoney, James. 2001. The Legacies of Liberalism. Path Dependence Dependence and Political
Regimes in Central America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Mahoney, James. 2002. Knowledge accumulation in comparative historical research: The case of
democracy and authoritarianism. In James Mahoney and Dietrich Rueschemeyer (eds.),
Comparative Historical Analysis in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University
Press.
Mahoney, James, and Richard Snyder. 1999. Rethinking agency and structure in the study of
regime change. Studies in Comparative International Development 34:3 32.
Marshall, T. H. 1992 [1950.] Citizenship and Social Class and Other Essays. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
McAdam, Doug, Sidney Tarrow, and Charles Tilly. 1996. To map contentious politics. Mobilization: An International Journal 1:17 34.
Moore, Barrington Jr. 1966. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston: Beacon.
Przeworski, Adam, Michael E. Alvarez, Jose Antonio Cheibub, and Fernando Limongi. 2000.
Democracy and Development: Political Institutions and Material Well-Being in the World, 1950 1990.
Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
Ruggie, John G. 1996.. 1996. Globalization and the embedded liberalism compromise: end of
an era? Working paper 97 / 1, Max Planck Institut fur Gesellschaftsforschung, Cologne.
Spruyt, Hendrik. 2002. The origins, development, and possible decline of the modern state.
Annual Review of Political Science 5:127 50.
Stearns, PeterN. (ed.). 2001. The Encyclopedia of World History, Ancient, Medieval, and Modern, Chronologically Arranged. Boston: Houghton Mifin.
Tilly, Charles. 2001. Mechanisms in political processes. Annual Review of Political Science 4:21 41.
Turner, Bryan. 1997. Citizenship studies: A general theory. Citizenship Studies 1:5 18.
Vanhanen, Tatu. 1997. Prospects of Democracy. A Study of 172 Countries. London: Routledge.
Yashar, Deborah J. 1997. Demanding Democracy. Reform and Reaction in Costa Rica and Guatemala, 1870s 1950s. Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press.

120

X ]Z X X Z ^K

, , , , , .
( )
( ). , , . ,
, . , , ,

,
.

. ( ) , ,
(, . .), (
), . . .

, , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

121

 , .
?
, , , .
, , . res publica, ,
--
.
, .,
, , . . ( ) . ,
, .
XVI . , : , , , , , . , ,

(, , , populaire). , , opus
magnum, republic . . .
: : , . ,
,
. , ,
: ,

Machiavelli N. Il Principe. Cap. I 6 Machiavelli N. Il Principe e Discorsi sopra la prima Deca

di Tito Livio. Firenze, . P. ; . . . I 6 . . . . .,
. . .
Bodin J. Les six livres de la Rpublique. Paris, . L. II . Ch. I . P. .
Harrington J. The Commonwealth of Oceana. London, . P .
XV . commonwealth. commonwealth. , res publica, ,
. commonwealth , . . Commonwealth of Nations, , .

122

 ; , , ;
.
, , ( , ), (
, ).
, XVIII . , ,
, , , , .
. . ,
, . .
. , , . ,
.
. (), . , , -.
. ( , , ) . ,
,
(, ). ,
.
(). , ,
,

Montesquieu. De L'Esprit des Lois. Paris, . T. I . L. II . Ch. . P. ; . .

. ., . . II . . I . . .
Rousseau J.-J. Contrat social: ou Principes du Droit Politique. Geneve, . L. II . Ch. VI .
P. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

123

 , . . . - .
. , .
, , , .
-, ,
,
, , . ,
. . .
. ,
. .
(), IV () ( ).
,
, ( - ),
( ). , ,
( , ) , , ,
.
-,
( ) , , , . , .
. ( - - .)
,
(
).
-, , (), , ,

, (. ).

124

( -), ,

.
-, . , ,
, .
:
.
,
.
. . , ,
.
-, ,
.
, , , , . . () -. -
, -,
,
- . () ( , ,
).
. ,
. , , , .
, ( ., .,
. . .).
,

,
, - , . , ( . . ., . . , ).

KOKQ 6, 2008

125

 , , . , , ,
, , .
, , , .
, .
, (, , ). - ( ),
, ( ) . .
, (-).
. ,
(,
, ). ?
. ,
. -
, . . , . ,
.

:
, ( , ).
(
.) , . . - ( )

The King [] shall be the Supreme Representative of the Nation . . (http:6www.al-bab.com / maroc / gov / con.htm).
, ,
, . , , . , ,
, III / II II .,
II (, , .) . . .

126

 . , , ,
? ? ,
/ , , .
, ( ) . .
, , .
, ,
,
.
. , , . , , .
. , ?
,
. ,
, , - . ,
, ? , ? ,
?
- , .
. ,
, , ,
. ,

. ,
, . , , , ,

, - .
.,
., . . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

127

, . - , . .
, ,
, .
.
, ( ),
( ) , . .
, ,
.
,
.
. , ( , ),
:
) ;
) ;
) -;
) ;
) ;
) -;
) ;
) ;
) ( ).

,
, .
,
. ,
, ,
,
, - . . ( . . . 6 . . . . ., . . . . , ).
. .
, . , , ,
, .

128

 , ,
. , , , .
(,
) ,
. ,
-,
-.
(). (. )
, , . , , , , .
() . .
, (
), . . . ,
.
(). ,
(. ) . , ,
. (, ),
( , ), , ( ), (
), (). , (, ) . , , ,
. ()
. , ()
( ) ,

, (
). , , .
. ( ).

KOKQ 6, 2008

129

, . ,
. . ,
( ,
). , .
.
(, , , , ),
( ), ,
. , , , ,
. ( . -

-, ,
, , ( !), , ,
. monarchia absoluta
XVI XVIII . ,
, ,
, , . .
,
, , ,
XVII .,
,
. (. :
. . . ., . . .).
, , .
, ,
, , , . , -,
, , : , .
, . ,
,
, . .

130

 -). ,
, .
- .
, . , , . (, ,
, , ), , (, , ),
( ,
, , ,
,
) (, ).
(), (). .
,
.
, . ,
, . , ,
.
.
.
( ).
.
, ,
.
. ( ). (

.
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

131

) ,
. , , ()-- ()--. ,
( ) , . . .
-. , , , .

- , ,
, . .
. national state .
,
, - .

. ( ).
( ), ( ) ,
. , .

.
.
. .
.
.
.

() , . , ,
( - ), -- . . .

.

132

 . , ( ). (
). ( ), (). . , ,
,
( ) /
. .
- . (), , ,
.
(, ),
(). , ,
; (). , , -
(). ,
().
(,
) (). ,
,
.
. () (, ). (
),
. , - () - () - .
- . -
KOKQ 6, 2008

133

 .
,
. - .
.
. ,
( ).
, (, , , )
(). , (, ).
, , (). ,
(
). , , (). ,

. .
,
, . ,
.
.
. . .
- ( ,

.
.
. (
)
. ( III
. . ).
, , ,
.

134

 -), , ,
. ()
( ), - .
,
. (
) , . -
( ), .
() ,
.
.
; , , .
( , ).
. .
(
) , . ,
. . () .
( ).
( ). , ,

, .,
, , , , .
.
, , (http:6www.wilayah.org / langs / ru / index.
php? p=leader_imam).
,
,
( ) . , , , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

135

 ( ).
( ). ( ),
, ,
.
( ),
.
,
. , , , .
.
,
( -),
, .
, ,
- .
. .
, ,
. ,
- . , , .
. , , .

. , , , . , . ,
. .

. ( ,
, ) , ,
, . .

136

 . ,
, . , , government of the
people, by the people, for the people. , (
). , ,
. / . ,
.
,
(, , ) , . , .
, ,
,
? ,
, ,
,
? , ,


.
. ,
(. . ).
, ,
, (, , .).
,
- - ( , ,
, ).
, . , ,
, ,
, , .
. , , .
KOKQ 6, 2008

137

 , . ,
V IV . . . , , ,
,
. , , , ,
, .
, . ,
. ,
,
( , .). , ,
. .
,
:
) ;
) , , ;
) , ,
;
) ( );
) ( , ,
).
, , . . ,
.
, . (
, , , , .).

. 6 . . . .
. . .
, ,
.

138

*
. , ,
,
.
,
., . . , , ., ( .). , , ,
,
, ( . . .), . , .,
.
,
.
Empire of Democracy,
. , , , , . ,
,
. , . ,
. ,
-?
,
. , ,
,
, , ,
(
).

. . ., . . .
6 . , . ., . . .
[] 6 . . .

KOKQ 6, 2008

139

 . ,
,
. . ,
, ,
.
. ( ) .
. ,
,
, .
,
, ( , .),
, , , . . ( , PR , ).


, , .
:
) ( ),
;
) , ,
, , , ,
();
) ;
) ,
;

( )
(, . . ):
, , ,
. (. : . / . . . . ., . . ).

140

)
(,
, , );
) ,
, ,
, ( , , .);
) ,
.
,
- ,
, , , . . , ,
. . . , , , . , , .
, ( ,
.) . , ( , , ),
, , , .
- ,
( ). .
.
. XVIII XIX . (-, , ), ,
, ,
, ,

KOKQ 6, 2008

141

 ,
, ,
, ,
.
Nation Building ,
, ,
().
. / , -,
.
-,
( , , ), -
, - . XX .
.
, . .
, , ,
.

. , , , .,
, ( , ) . ,
, . , . ,
, , .
,
. :
.

, .
- ,
, . ,
. .

.

142

 (. ).
, . . XX .
. ,
,
. . ,
.

. , . . ,
- , .
, ( , ).
.
, , ,
.
, .
, . , . . .
, ,
, , , . , .
, , .
,
.
, .
. ,
, (, , .) .
, , ,
/ .

, . ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

143


. .
, ,
, , , . ,
( , ),
, ,
.
,
. ,
. . .
, .
.
, ,
()
, ,
.
,
XVI XVIII . , , (, ,

(, , ) , ( )
.
,
. ,
.
III .,
( ) .;
II ( ) ., I ., , ( ) .
( , ).

144

 . .). , , .
.
-. .
. .
, . (), - , .
, . ( )
, ?
, .
, , -,
, , , , . , . . ,
. .
( , ,
.)
, -, , , , . , , . , ,
. - , , (

. .
( ), . . , ( .). .
( . ,
. ), . . .
,
, , , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

145

) ., .
. -.
, ( ). . , . , .
, .
.,
.
. , ,
- . ( ) -.
. .
, ,
, . . , , , ,
. , , .
.

, , , .
. , ,
, , ; ,
. .
,
. , .
, ,
. , , ,
( , , , ,

. . . III . a.
. b.
. . II . ab.

146

; ,
, , ,
). , , , .
,
, .
, , . -, . []
, , . -,
. , . . , ,
,
(
, ).
, ,
? ,
, , ?
. . , , , (, ). . .
! ,
, . ?
,
, ,

. b.
. b.
. . IV . b, a.
. . III . a.
. . . VI . b.
. . . III . b.

, ; ,
, , , ,
, , . -, - ,
, , (. . . VIII . ). , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

147


, , . , ,
. , ,
. , , . ., ,
, , . , ,
. , , .
. , , .
- . ?
? ,
? , , , .
.
., , eherne Gesetz der Oligarchie (Iron Law of
Oligarchy, ), , ,
, . , , . Wer Organisation sagt, sagt Tendenz zur
Oligarchie ( ). , ,
: Who says organization, says oligarchy
( ).

Hobbes T. Leviathan, or the Matter, Form, and Power of a Commonwealth, Ecclesiastical and
Civil. Oxford, . P. . Ch. XIX . P. ; . , ,
. . II . . XIX 6 . . ., . . . . .
. . . III . a.
Michels R. Zur Soziologie des Parteilebens in der modernen Demokratie.
Untersuchungen ber die oligarchischen Tendenzen des Gruppenlebens. Stuttgart,
. S. ; Michels R. Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical
Tendencies of Modern Democracy. New York, . P. .
Michels R. Zur Soziologie des Parteilebens S. .
Michels R. Political Parties P. .

148

 , , -, .
. C, -,
. [] die
Mehrheit der Menschen, durch eine grausame Fatalitt der Geschichte
dazu vorherbestimmt, gezwungen sehen, die Herrschaft einer kleinen
Minderheit aus ihrem Schoe ber sich ergehen zu lassen und nur als
Piedestal fr Groe der Oligarchie zu dienen.
, , , , .
(, .), , , , , .
. , , ,
, - -, ,
, , .

, ,
, . , ( , ,

Michels R. Zur Soziologie des Parteilebens S. .

: Die demokratischen Strmungen in der Geschichte gleichen
mithin dem steten Schlage der Wellen. Immer brechen sie an der Brandung. Aber auch
immer wieder werden sie erneut. Das Schauspiel, das sie bieten, enthlt zugleich Elemente der Ermutigung und der Verzweiung. Sobald die Demokratie ein gewisses Stadium ihrer Entwicklung erreicht hat, setzt ein Entartungsproze ein, sie nimmt damit
aristokratischen Geist, bisweilen auch aristokratische Formen an und wird dem hnlich, gegen das sie einst zu Feld zog. Dann entstehen ihr aus ihrem eigenen Scho
neue Anklger, die sie der Oligarchie zeihen. Aber nach einer Periode glorreicher
Kmpfe und einer Periode ruhmloser Teilnahme an der Herrschaft gehen auch sie zu
guter Letzt in der alten dominierenden Klasse auf. Jedoch, gegen sie erheben sich nun
namens der Demokratie wieder neue Freiheitskmpfer. Und dieses grausamen Spieles
zwischen dem unheilbaren Idealismus der Jungen und der unheilbaren Herrschsucht
der Alten ist kein Ende (Ibid. S. ).

, .
- , ,
, , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

149

 , ),
( ), , ,
,
. (
, ). .
.
, ,
( ) . ( ).
,
.
, ()
, ,
.
,
.
, () . , ,
/ (
- ., ,
, ,
, )
, , ,
( , , ) , , .
, .
, . .
, .
.

150

 , .
,
, ,
, , , ,
. , , , -, . ,
. .
. .
, , , .
,
.
. , , . ,
, .
, .
, , . , ( ). , .
, , .
, .
XX . .

.
, PR ,

, -. , , . : [] , ,
, . []
, (. . ., . . ).
, .

KOKQ 6, 2008

151

 . , . ,
.
, , - (
, ) . , ,
. . , , . , ,
, . , ,
. , ,
.
, , , ,
, . , , .
, - .
, , , ,
. .

- . . , :
,
, . , , ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
. ( . 6 http:6www.lenta.ru / a
rticles / / / / party / ).

152

 , ,
(, ), ,
, .
, , . ,
. , , , . , . ( ),
.
, , .
, , . .
( , - , ). .
, - ( ).
, . - , .
.
,
. , ,

,
. , . .
,
. ( ; .:
http:6www.gazeta.ru / politics / election_usa_ / / / _a_ .shtml)
, , , . , , -, (,
, ),
( .). -, - (, , ) .
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

153


, ., . (, , ), -
(), , .,
., , , XX . ().
, , .
,
. .
XX . - ( ) ( .,
., .)
(, , ) .
,
,
, . . . ,

. , , , , , . . , . . ,
. , , . , , . . , .
.
, .
, ,
.

. , . , ,

.

154

 - (-), ,
.
,
- , status quo,
,
.
-. .
XVII XIX . , ( , -). , , , -.

petrostates, .,
., .
.,
.
( , , - .
.).
, , .
, , , : ) , ) , , , )
, , , )
.

( .,
.), ( )
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

155

X X Z^ V WZ ] - Z WYQ

XX
Unser National Sozialismus ist die Zukunft
Deutschlands. Trotz diese Zukunft wirtschaftlich
rechts-orientiert wird, werden unsere Herzen
links orientiert bleiben. Aber vor allem werden
wir niemals vergessen, dass wir Deutschen sind.
, 1932 , -

Socialement je suis de gauche, conomiquement

je suis de droite, et nationalement je suis de
France!
, 2002 ,

,
, . , , ,
, , ,

Viviane Brachet-Marquez, Undemocratic Politics in the Twentieth Century and Beyond,

in Thomas Janoski, et. al (eds), The Handbook of Political Sociology: States, Civil Societies,
and Globalization. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, , p. .
- .
, . , .
, , .

156 -

, , .
,
, , , .
,
. .

, , , , , .
,
. , .
. .
,
,
. -
,
.
.
, , .

,

, . , , ,
. (
KOKQ 6, 2008

157

, ?) - , , . ,
, (Kershaw and Lewin,
) , ,
, .
,
(Linz ). ,
. : () ; () ,
; () , , .

, (Linz ), ,


. - (Mann ), , (Arendt ; Marcuse ; Burrin
) (Korchak ). , : () , ,
; () ,
, ; () , , .
(Friedrich and Brzezinski
; Burrin ), (Arendt ; Friedrich
and Brzezinski ) (Friedrich and

, .

158 -

Brzezinski ). , . , (Friedrich and

Brzezinski ). , , , .
, -, [ ] . ,
. () ? , , , .
(, , ,
)
. , , ,
. , (), ( ),
, (Fairbank : ).

(Bragger and Reglar ),
(OBrien : ).
, , ,
.
, (Grifn

, ! ,
. ,
, III IV . . (MacFarquhar, ).
, ,
. , . ,
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

159

) , , (Payne
: ; Gentile ). (Paxton
; Korchak ), -
(Ahrend ; Burrin ) (Linz ; Mann ).
(Remond ),
.
, .

, , (Milza ; Beetham ). ,
,
, .
, , , , ,
, (Gramsci ).
, , : ;
, ;
,
, . , .
,
, , , .

? , , ,
.
(Preston ) , , , , , , (

,
. , , .

160 -

 ,
). , -
Falange, ,
.
,
.
, ,
, .
, , (Payne ),
( ), ,
, .
, , ,
. , (Milza ; Burrin ).
,
.
, , (Eley ), , (Moore ;
Dahrendorf ; Gerschenkron ).
,
. ,
( %), ( %),
( %) ( %) , (Luebbert : ).
, ,
, .
, , , , KOKQ 6, 2008

161

 ,
, %- . , , , % (Luebbert :
). , ,
%, ,
.
(Milza, ; Collins, ; Linz, ;
Macherer, ) .
- ,
- , . , , , ,
, . , , , , (
), . (Hamilton )
.
(Moore ) (Stephens ;
Rueschemeyer, Stephens, and Stephens ).
, , , ,

, - , .
.
,
, .
: , , , , , , , avant la letter ,
(Pinto ).
(Stephens ) :
()
; ()
, , ; () , ; () , .

162 -

 . ,
,

,
, . , , (, [Blackbourne and Eley ]), ,
, , .
, ,
, (Rueschemeyer et al. )
,
, , ,
. ,
, (Luebbert
)
.
,
, ,
, , , , , ,
, , -
, ,
- . , (Luebbert :
). , , , , ( ,
, ), . , , , , ,

, , . (Gramsci ),
, .
, , , , , ,
, , , -, , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

163

 , ,

, ,
(Payne : ). ,
-
(Payne : ).
, : ,
, , .
, ,

. ,
.
, (Brustein ) ?, (
, % ),
. , , , , , .
,
,
.
,
, ,
, . ,
.

, : , ,
.
, , , .

164 -


(Eley ; Burrin ; Furet and Nolte ),
.
,
, , .
,
, , , .

, , XX ,
, , , , ,
,
, , (Linz : ).
, , ,
. ,
(
) , , , .
(ODonnell
),
(Stepan , ),
.

;
; -;
(),
(); , , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

165

 , ,
, - . ,
.

,
/
, ,
.

, , .
, , . , ,
: - ,
.
( , ) (Collier :
). , ,
: -
, , . , ,
.
,
,
,
, . ,
XIX ,
( ,
),

,
; .

166 -

 - .
,
( ). , ( , ) -
.
,
(Cardoso ), ;

-
(Hirshman ). ,
-
, ,
, .
, .
, ,
,
, . , (ODonnell, Schmitter, and

,
,
, .
, : ( ) -,
, - -. -, ,
. ,
( ).

KOKQ 6, 2008

167

Whitehead ), ,
, blandos () duros () .
sine die,
, -
(), () (). ( ) , ( : Loveman ; Aguero ; Mainwaring,
Brinks, and Perez-Linan ) , , .
.
,
, , . , ,

(Barahona de Brito : ), .
.
(Di Palma ).
(
).

( , ) .
( )
(.: ODonnell ; Mendez,
ODonnell, and Pinheiro ; Fox
; Fatton Jr. ).
, (Karl ; Schmitter ).
.:
Brachet-Marquez .

168 -

, , , ,
,
,
, , , ,
(Chehabi and Linz, a).
, status quo (Chehabi and Linz, a).
(Rouqui , ),
(Wickham-Crowley ), (Evans )
, . , , , ;

( ), . , , , ,
. , , - . , ,
( , , ) , .
: , .
, (Chehabi and Linz, b).
, , : , ,
, ( ). ,
- .
,
, KOKQ 6, 2008

169

 (Snyder ).
, , , ( ) (
). , ,
, , (Przeworski ), , . ,
( -).
,
,
. , , ,
, ,
( ). , ,
, . , , . .
- , ,
(, ,
, ) , , .

, , , (Parsa ).
, , ,
,
. , , , ,

, .

170 -

 -.

(Katouzian, ).
, , , . ,
, , , ,
. ,
, , .
, ?
, , , (Chehabi
and Linz b: ) -
, ,
,
. , , (
, ,
).
( ) (
). , , ( ), ( ) - (
).

,
, ,

,
. (Goodwin :).
.: Esposito .

KOKQ 6, 2008

171

 . ,
, .

(, ), .
()
, (Castaneda ; Wickham-Crowley ).
,
, ( ), , (Wickham-Crowley, ).
, . , , (
, ) ( - )

.
, . , , , , .
, ,
, , , , (,
, , ), , .
, %
, % %
. ,
( ), % , % , % % (Castaneda : ).
, , , . () .

172 -

 ( )
, . , : ,
.
,
(, , )
, . ,
, .
, ,
, . , ,
, ,
.
, ( ) .

.
,
, , , . ,

, ,
, .
, , ,
, ,
(Payne ).
( ), ,

(Payne ).

KOKQ 6, 2008

173

 , , ,
.
Sendero Luminoso, , (Degregori
), - (Degregori et al. ). , , , , , ,
- ,
, . (Goodwin : ).
, , ( ), . ,
( ) Ejercito Zapatista de Liberacion Nacional (EZLN ) .
, , , , , .
status quo
,

, La Violencia,
,
, .
. ( ) ,

(Castaneda : ).
, (, %)
(Degregori et al. : ). ,
(
Rondas Campesinas). Sendero Luminoso ( -).
, Sendero Luminoso .

174 -

 , (Stepan ). (),
,
.
,
.
,
(Goodwin : ).
- , - () - . , -, -
, -,
,
. , ,
, .
, (Goodwin : ).


; , (Goodwin : ).
,
, , ,
, , .
, (, ,
; Mudde ) (Mudde a).

, ,
(Goodwin : ).

KOKQ 6, 2008

175

, (Betz
; Hainsworth, b; Merkl and Weinberg ; Plotke : xxix), , ,
. , ,
. , , ; : (Ignazi
); ,
(Betz and Immerfall ; Mudde ); ;
( ) (Mudde b). , (Mudde : ),
,
, .

, () (), ,
,
, ,
. , (Mudde b), , .
, ,
,
, .
,
. ,
, ,

176 -

 ,
.

/ . , Union Nacional de Propietarios
(UNP ), ,
, (Payne, ).
, ,
, ,
, , ,
(Hainsworth a: ). , , Carapintadas, / , ,
, - , , / .

Union Nacional de Propietarios

()

Carapintadas ()

()
()

( )

()

(, )
(Mudde ) : ( ); ( ,

Carapintadas (: )
, , , ,
(), .

, , . , ,
( , . .).

KOKQ 6, 2008

177

); (
).
( )
( ).
, , ,
(, , ) ,
,
( ), .

, .

, , (Bell ) ( ) () ( ,
), .
, , , . , , ,
,
, (Macfarquhar and Resa Narr ).
. ,
,
, , , ,

. , ,

,
,
, ,
. .: Kopecky and Mudde . .: Camus ; Mudde
a, .

178 -

 , , , . ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, , , , (Payne : ); , , ,
, , .
,
, (
)
,
.
,
, ,
.

, . , (, ,
?, ) , .

.

, .
?

.
.
KOKQ 6, 2008

179

 . , ( ) , , , , ,
. ( ), . ,

, . , Sendero Luminoso
.
, ,
- . , , ,
.

, , .
, , ,
.
, ,
. , , XX , , , ,
.
?

, ,
- , .

180 -

 - , ,
, . , , . ,
, ( ,
).
,

.
, , ,

. , , , ,
,
, , .
,
,
. ,
(
),
, () (),
(,
, ) () ( ) (, ). , ,
,
.

,
KOKQ 6, 2008

181

 , , - .
, , ,
. , (
- ),
( ), , ,
, , . ,
.
, ,
,
, , ? , , .
( )
, ,
,
,
. ,
,
,
.

: ,
, , , . ,
, ? , ,
,

182 -

.


.
?

.
-, , , , , ,
, . , ()
() , ,

.
,
.
-, , ,
, ,
XX
, .
-, ,
(
),
, - , , .
,

( ) () ,
. , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

183

 . ,
, , .

.
, ,
, , , ,
, ( , , ),
.

?

,
.
,
. . ,
. , - , , ( ,
) ( ).

.
,
,
,
, , , , .



, ,
. , ,
-

184 -

, .
,
: () ; ()
.

. : ()
;
()
(,
, , ), , .
,
, .
, ,


.
, , ,
,
, ,
, . , , , ,
( , ).
,
, ,
, . ,
, ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

185

 ,

. ,
, , .

, , ,
,
,
. , . , .
.
, , ?
( , ,
, . .) . ,
, ,
: .
, , , ,
.

. , X , , Y, . (
), , Z, , . :
, , , .
. ,
, , , ,
. , ( )
, , , -

186 -

 , , ,

,
,
( ).

Aguero, Francisco. 1992. The armed forces, democracy and the limits to democratization in
South America. Pp. 153 98 in Scott Mainwaring et al. (eds.), Issues in Democratic Consolidation: TheNew South American Democracies in Comparative Perspective. Notre Dame: University of
Notre Dame Press.
Arendt, Hannah. [1951] 1968. Totalitarianism, Part III: The Origins of Totalitarianism. 4th ed. New
York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovitch.
Barbahona de Brito, Alejandra. 1997. Human Rights and Democratization in Latin America. New
York: Oxford University Press.
Beetham, David (ed). 1983. Marxists in Face of Fascism. Writings by Marxists from the Interwar
Period. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Bell, Daniel. 2000. The Radical Right. 3rd ed. New Brunswick, NJ : Transaction.
Betz, Hans Georg, and Stefan Immerfall (eds.). 1998. The New Politics of the Right: Neopopulist
Parties and Movements in Established Democracies. New York: St. Martins.
Blackbourne, David, and Geoff Eley. 1984. Introduction. Pp. 1 38 in David Blackbourne and
Geoff Eley (eds.), The Peculiarities of German History. Bourgeois Society and Politics in Nineteenth
Century Germany. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brachet-Marquez, Viviane. 1997. Democratic transition and consolidation in Latin America:
Steps toward a new theory of democratization. Current Sociology 45 (1):15 53.
Bragger, Bill, and Stephen Reglar. 1994. Politics, Economy and Society in Contemporary China. Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press.
Brustein, William. 1996. The Logic of Evil: The Social Origins of the Nazi Party, 1925 to 1933.
NewHaven, CT : Yale University Press.
Burrin, Philippe. 2000. Fascismo, Nazism, autoritarisme. Paris: Editions du Seuil.
Camus, Jean Yves. 1999. Extremism in Europe. 1998 Survey. Paris: Editions de lAube / CERA .
Cardoso, Fernando Henrique. 1979. On the characterization of authoritarian regimes in Latin
America. Pp. 33 60 in David Collier (ed.), The New Authoritarianism in Latin America. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
Castaneda, Jorge. 1993. Utopia Unarmed: The Latin American Left After the ColdWar. New York:
Alfred A. Knopf.
Chehabi, H. E., and Juan Linz. 1998a. A theory of sultanism 1. A type of nondemocratic rule.
Pp. 3 25 in H. E. Chehabi and Juan J. Linz (eds.), Sultanistic Regimes. Baltimore, MD : Johns
Hopkins University Press.
Chehabi, H. E., and Juan Linz. 1998b. Sultanistic Regimes. Baltimore, MD : Johns Hopkins University Press.

, ,
. .: Le Nouvel Observateur, July , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

187

Collier, David. 1979. Overviewof the bureaucratic-authoritarian model. Pp. 1932 in David Collier (ed.), The New Authoritarianism in Latin America. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
Dahrendorf, Ralf. 1959. Class and Class Conict in Industrial Society. Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press.
Degregori, Carlos Ivan. 1990. Ayacucho 1969 1979. El surgimiento de Sendero Luminoso. Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos.
Degregori, Carlos Ivan, Jose Coronel, Ponciano del Pino, and Orin Starn, 1996. Las rondas
campesinas y la derrota del Sendero Luminoso. Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos / Universidad Nacional de San Cristobal de Huamanga.
Di Palma, Giuseppe. 1990. To Craft Democracies. An Essay on Democratic Transitions. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Eley, Geoff. 1995. The social construction of democracy in Germany, 1871 1933. Pp. 90 117
in Reid Andrews George and Herrick Chapman (eds.), The Social Construction of Democracy
1870 1990. New York: New York University Press.
Esposito, John L., and R. K. Ramazaniu (eds.). 2001. Iran at the Crossroads. New York: Palgrave.
Evans, Peter B. 1995. Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
Fairbank, John K. 1992. China. A New History. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.
Fox, Jonathan. 1994. The difcult transition from clientelism to citizenship. Lessons from Mexico. World Politics 46 (January):51 84.
Friedrich, Carl J., and Zbigniew Brzezinski. 1965. Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy. New York:
Praeger.
Furet, Francois, and Ernst Nolte. 1998. Fascisme et communisme. Paris: Librairie Plon.
Gentile, Emilio. 1975. Le origini dellideologa fascista. Rome: Ta Terza.
Gershenkron, Alxander. [1943] 1989. Bread and Democracy in Germany. Ithaca, NY : Cornell University Press.
Grifn, Roger. 1995. Fascism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Goodwin, Jeff. 2001. No Other Way Out: States and Revolutionary Movements, 1945 1991. Cambridge,
UK : Cambridge University Press.
Gramsci, Antonio. [1924] 1983. Democracy and fascism. Pp. 121 4 in Beetham Davis (ed.),
Marxists in Face of Fascism. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Hainsworth, Paul. 2000a. Introduction: The extreme Right. Pp. 1 17 in Paul Hainsworth (ed.),
The Politics of the Extreme Right. From the Margins to the Mainstream. London: Pinter.
Hainsworth, Paul. (ed.). 2000b. The Politics of the Extreme Right. From the Margins to the
Mainstream. London: Pinter.
Hamilton, Richard F. 1995. Some difculties with cultural explanations of national socialism.
Pp. 197 216 in Houchan Chehabi and Alfred Stepan (eds.), Politics, Society and Democracy.
Boulder, CO : Westview.
Hirschman, Albert O. 1979. The turn to authoritarianism in Latin America and the search for
its economic determinants. Pp. 61 98 in David Collier (ed.), The New Authoritarianism in
Latin America. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
Ignazi, Piero. 1997. The extreme Right in Europe: A survey. Pp. 300 19 in P. H. Merkl and
L. Weinberg (eds.), The Revival of Right Wing Extremism in the 90s. London: Frank Cass.
Karl, Terry Lynn. 1990. Dilemmas of democratization in Latin America. Comparative Politics 23
(1):1 21.
Kopecky, Petr, and Cas Mudde (eds.). 2003. Uncivil Society? Contentious Politics in Post-Communist
Europe. London: Routledge.
Korchak, Alexander. 1994. Contemporary Totalitarianism. A Systems Approach. East European Monographs. New York: Columbia University Press.

188 -

Linz, Juan J. 1970. An authoritarian regime: The case of Spain. Pp. xxx in Erik Allard and Stein
Rokkan (eds.), Mass Politics. Studies in Political Sociology. New York: Free Press.
Linz, Juan J. 2000. Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes. Boulder, CO and London: Lynne Rienner.
Loveman, Brian. 1994. Protected democracies and military guardianship: Political transition in
Latin America, 1978 1993. Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 36 (2):105 89.
Luebbert, Gregory M. 1987. Social foundations of political order in interwar Europe. World
Politics 39:449 78.
Luebbert, Gregory M. 1991. Liberalism, Fascism, or Social Democracy: Social Classes and the
Political Origins of Regimes in Interwar Europe. Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press.
Macfarquhar, Roderick, and Seyyed Vali Resa Narr. 2001. Islamic Leviathan. Islam and the Making
of State Power. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mainwaring, Scott, Daniel Brinks, and Anibal Perez-Linan. 2000. Classifying political regimes
in Latin America, 1945 1999.Working Paper #280, September 2000, Kellogg Institute of
Political Studies.
Mann, Michael. 1970. The social cohesion of liberal democracy. American Sociological Review
35:423 40.
Marcuse, Herbert. 1967. Faschismus und Kapitalismus. Frankfurt am Main: Europaische Verlagsanstalt, 1967).
Mendez, Juan E., Guillermo ODonnell, and Paulo Sergio Pinheiro. (eds.), 1999. The (Un) rule
of Law and the Underprivileged in Latin America. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.
Merkl, P. H., and L. Weinberg (eds.). 1997. The Revival of Right Wing Extremism in the 90s. London:
Frank Cass.
Milza, Pierre. [1985] 2001. Les Fascismes. Paris: Editions du Seuil.
Moore, Barrington Jr. 1966. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston: Beacon.
Mudde, Cas. 2000a. Extreme Right parties in Eastern Europe. Patterns of Prejudice 34 (1):5 27.
Mudde, Cas. 2000b. The Ideology of the Extreme Right. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Mudde, Cas. 2001. In the name of the peasantry, the proletariat, and the people: Populism in
Eastern Europe. East European Politics and Societies 15 (1): 35 53.
Mudde, Cas. 2002. Extreme Movements. Pp. 135 48 in Paul Heywood, Erik Jones, and Martin
Rhodes (eds.), Developments in West European Politics. 2nd ed. Houndsmills: Macmillan.
OBrien, Kevin. 1990. Reform without Liberalization. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press.
ODonnell, Guillermo. 1973. Modernization and Bureaucratic Authoritarianism: Studies in
South American Politics. Berkeley: University of California Press.
ODonnell, Guillermo. 1993. On the state, democratization and some conceptual problems: A
Latin Americian view with glances at some postcommunist countries. World Development 21
(8):1355 69.
ODonnell, Guillermo, Philippe Schmitter, and Laurence Whitehead (eds.). 1986. Transitions
from Authoritarian Rule. Baltimore, MD : Johns Hopkins University Press.
Paxton, Robert. 1998. The ve stages of fascism. Journal of Modern History, March: 1 23.
Payne, Leigh A. 2000. Uncivil Movements. The Armed Right Wing and Democracy in Latin America. Baltimore, MD : Johns Hopkins University Press.
Payne, Stanley G. 1995. A History of Fascism 1914 1945. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Pinto, Antonio Costa. 1995. Salazars Dictatorship and European Fascism Problems of Interpretation.
Boulder, CO : Social Science Monographs.
Plotke, David. 2002. The success and anger of the modern American Right. Pp. xxx in Daniel
Bell (ed.), The Radical Right. 3rd ed. New Brunswick, NJ : Transaction.
Preston, Paul. 1990. The Politics of Revenge. Fascism and the Military in 20th Centuary Spain.
London: Unwin Hyman.

KOKQ 6, 2008

189

Przeworski, Adam. 1986. Some problems in the study of transitions to democracy. Pp. 47 63
in G. ODonnell, P. C. Schmitter, and L. Whitehead (eds.), Transitions from Authoritarian Rule:
Comparative Perspectives. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Remond, Rene. 1982. Les Droites en France. Paris: Aubier.
Rouquie, Alain. 1984. O Estado Militar na America Latina. Sao Paulo: Alpha-Omega.
Rueschemeyer, Dietrich, Evelyne Huber Stephens, and John D. Stephens. 1992. Capitalist Development and Democracy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Schmitter, Philippe C. 1991. Cinco reexiones sobre la cuarta onda de democratizacion.
Pp. 101 40 in Carlos Barbas Solano, J. L. Barros Horcasitas, and Javier Hurtado (eds.), Transiciones hacia.
Snyder, Richard. 1998. Paths out of sultanistic regimes: Combining structural and voluntarist
perspectives. Pp. 49 81 in Houchang E. Chehabi and Juan J. Linz (eds.), Sultanistic Regimes.
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Stepan, Alfred. 1986. Paths toward Redemocratization: Theoretical and Comparative Considerations. Pp. 64 84 in Guillermo ODonnell, Philippe C. Schmitter, and Laurence Whitehead
(eds.), Transitions from Authoritarian Rule. Prospects for Democracy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins
University Press.
Stephens, John D. 1989. Democratic transition and breakdown in Western Europe, 1870 1939:
A test of the Moore thesis. American Journal of Sociology 94:1019 77.
Wickham-Crowley, Timothy P. 1992. Guerrillas and Revolution in Latin America: A Comparative
Study of Insurgents and Regimes since 1956. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.

190 -

^ X YKZ Q WK\

, . , , ,
, ,
, . , , , , ,
, / , / , / .
,
.
, , , , ,
,
. ,

, , , , .

Nikolas Rose, Governing Advanced Liberal Democracies, in A. Barry, T. Osborne and

N. Rose (eds.), Foucault and Political Reason: Liberalism, Neo-liberalism and Rationalities of
Government. London: University College London Press, , p. .

KOKQ 6, 2008

191

 , ,
, ,
, , , , .
, ,
, ,
, , , , , , ,
, , , , (. : Gordin ). , ,
,
, .
, ; . , . , ,
, , , ,
. , , , , . ,
, , , , , , , ,
, ?
,
, ? ? , , ,
, , , ?

192

, ? , ,
, ?

,
, ?
.
XIX , , , , , , .
, , , . , , ,
.
- , , , , . , , .
XIX , , , , , , .
, , :
,
, (Osborne ).
XIX XX , , ,
, . ,
. ,
,
KOKQ 6, 2008

193

 ( , , , ) . , , , ,
, .
, , ,
, , , . ,
. , ,
, .
: ; ,

,
. :
, XIX , , , , ,
.
, , . ,
, , , . ,
,


, .
,
, , .

194

 , .
, ,
, , . , ,
.
,
,
,
.
/

, / (Gordon ; .: , Gordon
). -, ( ), ,
, , ,
. , ,
- , ,
, ,
. ,
, , ,
, .
, - , . ,
, ,
, , , , . / KOKQ 6, 2008

195

, , .
, ,

.
, ,
,
, (Rose and Miller ; .: Miller
and Rose ). , , , ,
, .
, , , , , , ,
, , , . :
,

,
.
,
, , ,
.

, (, , , , , ), (, , , , ),
( , , ),
,
(.: Rose
and Miller : ).
, , , . , ,
, , , ,
-

196

. , . , ,
, , , . ,
. ,
, ,
.
:

,
(.: Latour ). ,
, : .

XVIII ,
, (Foucault , ; .:
Pasquino ).
, ,
, (.: Oestreich ).
, , . , , ,
, . , raison detat ,
(Burchell ). , , ,
. , , - , . ,
, KOKQ 6, 2008

197

 , ,
.
, ,
, , ( ). ,
, , ,
, , , . , ,
,
: ,
, ,
(Foucault ). , , , , , (
, )
( , ) ,
,
.
.
/ .
/ ,
, ,
, . ( : Hacking
): ( , ), ( , ),
( , ), , (, , , ). , ,
, , : , , , -

198

 ; know-how
,
, .
. , , .
, , , , , ,
, , . ,
, ( , , , ), ,
, , , . ,
XIX . ,
, :
- , ,
, , .
,
. ,
. , , , ,

.
.
XIX ,
,
,
KOKQ 6, 2008

199

 . (.: Foucault ). , , ,
, , ,
. , , ,
, ,
, ,
. , , , , , , , .

, ,
,
, , . ,
, . ,
.
. ,
(Giddens ; Lash and Urry ). , ,
;
.
? , ,
, ,
. , , ? ,

200

 ?
, ?
-
,
,
. , ,
, , ,
.

XIX XX
. , ,
, , , -, (Donzelot ; . : Rabinow : Chs ; Ewald ).
, XIX ,
,
,
, , . , , ,
,
.
, ,
,
,
, .
, , , .
,
.
KOKQ 6, 2008

201

 . ,
, , .
, : (.: Procacci ).

, . (OMalley ; Rose ).

,
, . ,

. , XX
. , , ,
,

, .
, , ,

(Donzelot ; Rose ; Parton ).
, , . , , ,
, , , , .
, ,
,
,
. ( -

202

 ),

.
, , ,
.
,
, ,
(Rose : ).
, ,
,
(Rose ). ,
. , XIX , ,
, . , , , ,

, , . , ,
.
, . , , ,
, , .

, , . , ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

203


, . , , , ,
, , ,
, ( ; .: Gordon , ; : Rose ). , (
), :
; ,
, ,
,
(Hayek : ).
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
,
. , ,
, , (OConnor ;
Bacon and Eltis ).
, ,
, .

: ; ; , , ; ,
. , , -

204

, ;
,
, . ,
- , .
,
; , ; ,
; , (Murray ,
Adler and Asquith ; Friedman ; .: Reich ,
: Hirschman ).
: , ,
, , , -, , , .
:
. -.
. , , ,
, ,
, , ,
, , . , ,
, .
KOKQ 6, 2008

205

 . ,
, : ,
; (Reich
; Adler and Asquith ).
, , ,

. , ( ): ,
, , , .

(.: Cooley ). , , , ,

. ,
.
, ,
-,
, ;
,
. , , , , .
, . , ,
,
,
. , , , -

206

 , a priori,
, : ,
,
(.: Rose and Miller
: ). :
,
, .
?
. ,
.
,
,
,
. , ,
, ,
. .
. . : , ,
. , , ,
. , . ,
, .
; , . ,
, , : , - , , , ,
, .
KOKQ 6, 2008

207

 , , :
.
,
, .
, , , , , , .
, /
, , , ,
, ,
, .

.
, , ,
,
.
,
. , ,
. , , .

.
, , , (Power , ).
,
.
, , , ,

208

 . : , , , .
,
,
. , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , .
. . ,

,
,
, XIX ,
.
(.: Rose b).
, XX
,
: , , , , . , , ,
, , ,
. ,
.
, , : ,
.
, ,
, , , , , , , , ,
, -, -, , ,
KOKQ 6, 2008

209

 . , ,
, (.: Hood ). , , , ,
, .
, , , , .

: , ,
.
. . , ,
- :
, ,
, ,
,
(Rose , a).
, ,
.
,
,
, , , . ,
,
, , , , (Rose b).
,

, .

210

 , , , ,
. , , ,
;
, ;
, ;
(Rose ). ,
.
, , , , .
, . ,
, . ,
. , ,
. ,
,
, . , -
, (OMalley ).
, ,

(Rose ).
,
,
, .
,
,
, . KOKQ 6, 2008

211

 ,
, , , . ,
, .
, , . , , (empowerment) ,
.

, , , .
, . , , ,
, ,
. ,
, , , .
, . ,
,
:
, , ,
.
, ,
,

.
, , , -
: -
(Rose a, b; .: Hacking ).
a priori -

212

, , , , , ,
,
, .
, ,
, , , ,
, , , , .
,
,
, .
, ,
. ,
, ? , , , .

, ,
, . ,
,
, , , , , .
,

KOKQ 6, 2008

213

.
,

.
, , , , ,
. , , , , ,
, . . , ,

, , , , ,
.
, , . ,
. ,
, . , ,

.

: 1996. : , .
. ., .
. 1999. . . .: Ad Marginem.
. 2005. 6 . . .
. 2. .: .
. 2005. Omnes et singulatim: 6 . . . . 2. .: .
. . 2005. . .: .
Adler M. and S. Asquith (eds.). 1981. Discretion and welfare. London: Heinemann.
Bacon R. and S. Eltis. 1976. Britains economic problems: too few producers? London: Macmillan.
Burchell G. 1991. Peculiar interests: civil society and governing the system of natural liberty. In:
Burchell et al. (1991), 119 150.
Cooley M. 1980. Architect or bee: the human / technology relationship. Slough, England: Langley Technical Services.

214

Donzelot J. 1979. The policing of families [with a foreword by G. Deleuze]. London: Hutchinson.
Donzelot J. 1991. The mobilization of society. In: Butchell et. al. (1991), 169 180.
Ewald E. 1991. Insurance and risk. In: Burchell et al. (1991), 197 210.
Foucault M. 1980. The politics of health in the eighteenth century. In: Power / knowledge. C. Gordon (ed.). 166 182. Brighton: Harvester.
Foucault M. 1989. Resumes des cours. College de France, Paris.
Friedman M. 1982. Capitalism and freedom. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Giddens A. 1990. Consequences of modernity. Cambridge: Polity.
Gordin C. 1980. Afterword. In: Michel Foucault: Power / Knowledge. C. Gorgon (ed.), 229 260.
Brighot: Harvester.
Gordon C. 1986. Question, ethos, event. Foucault on Kant and Enlightenment. Economy and
Society. 15 (1), 71 87.
Gordon C. 1987. The soul of the citizen: Max Weber and Michel Foucault on rationality and government. In: Max Weber: rationality and modernity. S. Lash and S. Whimster (eds.), 293 316.
London: Allen and Unwin.
Gordon C. 1991. Governmental rationality: an introduction. In: Burchell et al. (1991), 1 52.
Hacking I . 1986. Making up people. In: Reconstructing individualism. T. C. Heller et al. (eds),
222 236. Paolo Alto, CA : Stanford University Press.
Hacking I . 1991. The timing of chance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hayek F. A. 1979. The Constitution of Liberty. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Hirchman A. 1991. The rhetoric of reaction. Cambridge, MA : Belkanp Harvard.
Hood C. 1991. A public management for all seasons. Public Administration. 69 (1), 3 19.
Lasch S. and J. Urry. 1994. Economies of signs and spaces. Cambridge: Polity.
Miller P. and N. Rose. 1989. Political rationalities and technologies of government. In: Texts, contexts, concepts. S. Hanninen and K. Palonen (eds), 171 183. Helsinki: Finnish Political Science Association.
Miller P. and N. Rose. 1990. Governing economic life. Economy and Society. 19 (1). 1 31.
OConnor J. 1972. The scal crisis of the state. New York: St. Martins Press.
Oestreich G. 1982. Neostoicism and the modern state. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
OMalley P. 1992. Risk, power and crime prevention. Economy and Society. 21 (2). 283 299.
Osborne T. 1994. Bureaucracy as a vocation: governmentality and administration in nineteenth
century Britain. Journal of Historical Sociology. 7 (3). 289 313.
Parton N. 1991. Governing the family: child care, child protection and the State. London: Macmillan.
Pasquino P. 1991. Theatrum Politicum: the genealogy of capital police and the state of prosperity. In: Burchell et al. (1991). 105 118.
Power M. 1992. The audit society. Paper delivered to London History of the Present Research
Network, 4 November 1992.
Power M. 1994. The audit society. London: Demos.
Procacci, G. 1989. Sociology and its poor. Politics and Society. 17. 163 187.
Rabinow P. 1989. French modern: norms and forms of the social environment. Cambridge, MA :
MIT Press.
Reich C. 1964. Individual rights and social welfare. Yale Law Jurnal. 74. 1245.
Rose N. 1985. The psychological complex: psychology, politics and society in England, 1869 1939.
London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Rose N. 1987. Beyond the public / private division: law, power and the family. Journal of Law and
Society. 14 (1). 61 76.

KOKQ 6, 2008

215

Rose N. 1990. Governing the soul: the shaping of the private self. London: Routledge.
Rose N. 1992. Governing the enterprising self. In: The values of the enterprise culture: the moral debate.
P. Heelas and P. Morris (eds). 141 164. London: Routledge.
Rose N. 1993. Towards a critical sociology of freedom. Inaugural Lecture delivered on 5 May 1992 at
Goldsmiths College, University of London: Goldsmiths College Occasional Paper.
Rose N. 1994. Eriavoisuus ja valta hyvinvointivaition jaikeen. Janus. 1. 44 68.
Rose N. 1995a. Authority and the genealogy of subjectivity. In: De-traditionalization: authority and
self in an age of cultural change. P. Heelas, P. Morris, S. Lash (eds). Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Rose N. 1995b. Identity, genealogy, history. In: Questions of cultural identity. S. Hall and P. du Gay
(eds). London: Sage.
Rose N. 1996a. Inventing our selves: psychology, power and personhood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rose N. 1996b. The death of the social? Reguring the territory of government. Economy and
Society. 25 (3). 327 346
Rose N. and P. Miller. 1992. Political power beyond the state: problematics of government. British
Journal of Sociology. 43 (2). 172 205.

216

X ZX W X K

, , .
.
,
.
,

,
.


-, , . ,
.
. , ,
,

.
, . - KOKQ 6, 2008

217

 , . ,
. , , , ,
, : . .

,
. .
,
, .
, ,
. , , , .

: ,
, ,
.
,
.
,
.
, , , , ,
, -
.
,
, , , .
,
. , ( ,

, ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, . ,
. , ,
.

218


), , .
, .
, .


. , .
, , , . ,
,
( )
.

(
), , , , .
,
, . , , ,
, :
.
( ), , . ,
, ( , ),
. , .

.
,
. ,
, , , . , .

KOKQ 6, 2008

219


.
, ,
. ,
: . ,
, .
, .
, , ,
. ,
, , , .

, , , . ,
, , :
? , , , ?
.

, ( )
: .
. ,
, , . , , ,
.
, ,
: . , , , , , , .
, , .
, , , ,
. . , , . ,
-, , , ,

220

 , (. . ) ( ).
, ,
. , ,
, . . , , .
, .
, ,

, . .
. ,
.
,
?

. , , . -, , . ( ) ,
.

, .
, ,
() , , .

( , ) .
, , , ,
.
, () ( ) ,

. : http:6www.archipelag.ru / geoeconomics / kapital / statute / spirit.

KOKQ 6, 2008

221

 . , . , ,
,
.
. , , ,
. , . ,
. : ,

.
, , (
), . , , .
, , , , , .
.
, . ? , ? , ,
, ,
, (
) . ,
, :

.
. , ,
,
, . ,
.
-
, ,
, .
, -
XVIII , . , , ,

222

 . ( ) , () , .
, , ,
, , . , .
- ,
. , ,
( , ) .

, , ,

,
, . , , ,
( , , . .); , . (. . ()).

(
). ,
. ( ,
) , , , () . ,
(
) .
, , . , , ,
, .
. . ,
, .

KOKQ 6, 2008

223

 .
,
. ,
() ()
(). ,
, , , , . .
.
( ,
, ) . , , , , . , ,
,
.
.

, , . , ,
- ? , , . . , .
, .
, .
. , - .
, ,
.

,
, .
. . . ., .

224

 :
, -, , -, , , -,
.

. ,
,
, , ( , ), (
).
, , , .
,
, , , , ,
. . , , .
, (
- ), ,
( )
( ). ,
,
.
, ,
,

, , , ,
, , . . , . ,
,
,
.

KOKQ 6, 2008

225

 ,
la la .
, , ,
.
, , , . , ,
. , , , ,
, .
, , ,
, , , , . , , .
.
. ,
, , , , , . . ,
.
, , ? .
. , . , ,
, . . . ,
,
.
,
, : , ,

., ., http:6www.journalapologia.ru / rnews. html? id=&id_issue=

, ,
.

226

 , .
:
, , .

. , , ,

: , , , ,
. -
.
, , , , , , .
,
. ( )
, ,
.
,
,
,
.
,
, , ,
, , .
,
, , ,
.
, . .
,
, , ( ). , .
, , ,
. ?
KOKQ 6, 2008

227

, . , , . -. .
, (- -) ( - -),
.
. , . ,
.
,

?
, . ,
, - ,
(, , ) , .
. .
, ,
, ,
.
, .
.
. , .
,
,
.

, . ,

.
. .

228

.. ..

.
, ,
: .
( ( , ) , .
.
. , , .
: . , .
, ; . , , , , . , .
. , .
, , . . , ,
.
, . . , , ,
, . , , :
,
.
, , KOKQ 6, 2008

229

. .
, , - .
. . . : , , , .
, (
) . .
. . .
, , !
. , ,
. .

230 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008

Q WO [KK X^YX^

- - .
, .
. ,
.
. , . : .
,
, .
. . :
, ,
, , , ?
- , :
, . .
,
.
.
- , . . .
. , , , - ,
. . . , , . , .
? , , .
. ,
. .
KOKQ 6, 2008

231

 , .
.
, . ,
, . .
, .
, . ,
. , ,
. . ,
. .
.
. - -
, :
, , !
.
: ,
. ,
, . ( ).
, . .
, .
. , . . ,
. . ,
, : , ,
. . . , . , , .

232 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008

Z YQZ^ W [ ] XOK WQ YX

: , , . , ,
. , ,
. , . - ,
, , , ,
, , -, . ,

.
, ,
, , , , . -
, .
, . , , , ( , ).

,
. , XXI , , , : ,
. : . ,
.
KOKQ 6, 2008

233

, , ,
, ,
. , , .
, , , . ,
. .
. ,
, , . .

234 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008

^. . K]WK XK Z

: , , , .
, , . - ,
, , , ,
, . . , , , .
,
:
, .
, ,
, ,
. ,
, , . . . ,
, , - XX , . , , .
. ( , , . ,
,
KOKQ 6, 2008

235

 , ,
)
( , , ) , , , ,
. , .
, , ,
, , .
, , .
, ,
.
- .
( )
I , , .
, ,
.
, , ,
. , . ,

, , , , .

236 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008

^ X YKZ [K] ^XYK

.
, , , ,
, .
, .
.
.


,
, ,
. , , , .
, - .
. ,
, , .
,
. , , ,
, , . ,
,
.
KOKQ 6, 2008

237

 . , , , ,
.
, , ,
, . ,
, .

, ,
. , , , , ,
. , , , ,
, . ,
, .
, .
,
,
,

- . ,
.

238 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008

* * *

. .
. . . . ( . . ). , (
), ,
. . .
, - .
. ,
- ,
.
.
.
. .
6 . .: , 1984.
6 - . .: , 1984.
6
. .: , 1987 ( .).
6
. : , 1988.
6
. 1988. 12.
. 6 . 1988. 4
( .).
: ? 6 . .: - , 1991.
: 6 . 1992. 2.
6 . 1994. 6.
6 , ( ). .: , 1994.
6 .
. .: -, 1994.

KOKQ 6, 2008

239

 . . 6 . .: Ad Marginem, 1996.
? 6
. 1996. 3.
. . 1- 6 . 1997. 10.
6
: . .: , 1998.
6 . 1999. 6.
6 . 1998. 2.
6 . . .: ,
2002.
. . . [
] 6 . . .: , 2004.
: 6
. : ,
2004.
. . 6 . . . 2003 2004 . .: , 2004.
. . 6 . .: . . .-, 2004.
: 6 . .: . . .-, 2006.
6 . 2007. 6.

240 . 08.02.1948 02.05.2008