Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Wikipedia Critique -
Wikipedia has become the default starting place for many students in their
research. It is important for students to know that the site can be helpful, but that there are
often many errors in the articles. In order to develop a keen eye to evaluate Wikipedia articles
students will both critique and supplement a Wikipedia article. Students will first select an article
on Wikipedia that is relevant to a research project in their course of study. They will then
evaluate the article by evaluating the sources used in the article. This will begin with an
evaluation of the resources used as sources. Students will then evaluate whether or not the
author of the Wikipedia article has properly interpreted the sources used and if the author has
omitted important sources relevant to the topic. Students will then offer corrections and
amendments to the Wikipedia article.
Evaluating Websites -
One of the most important tasks for students working on research
projects is evaluating websites. Using the
UC Berkley Evaluating Web Sites checklist
students
will evaluate three websites related to their research. They will assess the websites
trustworthiness and accuracy. Students will provide specific reasons why a website is trustworthy
and accurate and add their evaluation to a class Wiki page for reference by future students.
Periodically, teachers can ask students to evaluate the evaluation made by previous students in
order to determine if deficiencies in websites have been fixed or if once reputable websites have
now become untrustworthy. This activity will remind students of the dynamic nature of the
information on the internet.
make concept maps. This is a brainstorming/webbing site that allows students to type in a
concept and from that, different categories are generated like a concept map. When you click
on something, it adds more info including links to the internet, it is google based, so it will give
the best four options (but you may have to monitor the links).