Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 26

Mtaheuristiques

pour

loptimisation
difficile

Johann Dro - Alain Ptrowski


Patrick Siarry - ric Taillard
Ouvrage coordonn par Patrick Siarry

ditions Eyrolles, 2003,


ISBN : 2-212-11368-4

|M

!

OI

HO

HI

HO

n  ?QB n C;B


     I<V n  ? 
 ADZS`XO<I NPTFN*OPRS_! n N*\XZ^AWVWI*_MIP`aV `aVDIPAWopZSOPIY}ZSKLCFRMI<V `JfaNP`JCFIPADCmIY\-RS?JATFI*E@N*EWI*Z^?J
RaJCFTmI{EPn Ln AD?JIbKL? dNP`JN*ADZST~jI{O<TFIPAlO^n Xn hEWEW|]TFI*E RS?XTmCF`JI*ZS?L
B? CnBb
F



eu

2



!rv

4

"$#%'&)(+*-,/.0(/1243$5+(-16/7-,879*$76/:;.<&=6/:;.

]'*)

-+ ,(.0/214365879.;:<1=,
jI]AWN{ExI{Z^?c_MRSXCmTFI]KJI4VWADRSCyExCFP_MI4faNP`JN*ADZ^VWCFRS`#?>8@dn2Twi
`JCFQSIPAlEWZST RaJCFTmI 0IPu
TFI*OPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZVDCmRa`XE e|LEhVDIP_ n[\-I*AW_MI<VWVWAlZBKJI6oRa?JAD`JCmA{nkIP`\JTF?XE4KLI*E4 ExI*AWQeCyO<I{E(KLIQSRSCmnKLI
`JRa?JQSI*ZS?L8EWIPADQeCFOPI*EI<VdZ^\J\XTmCyOPZ^VWCFRS`XEb `aVWI*AW`XI<V*nXVDADZS`XExoIPAWVDE@KLIKLRa`J`JN*I*E*nJQeCyKLNPRa\JvJRa`JCmIanJI<VlO^
I*EEWIPADQHCyO<I{E[VDIP_M\XEADNPI*T2 <nLOSi I{EhVWu r^u KLCFADI}rKLNPXCtVfHZ^AlZ^`aVDCnSVDIPTyEGa?XIUTFZsQSRSCm4IPVTFId_=?XTtVDCtu
_MN*KJCFZbRS?]KLI*E9EWIPADQHCyO<I{Ek`XRS`(-VD IP_M\XE9AWN*IPT; 2VDIPTyE9GH?JI@TmI@VWNPTFN*OlvXZ^ADfSI*_MIP`aV9KLI{E[OlvJCFIPAlE[RS?
TyZ_MI*EDEWZSfSIPADCFIbN*TmI{OVWADRS`XCFGH?JI(ExI*AWRa`aVd\JADCFEUIP`cODvXZSAWfaIS-jIMKLN*\JTmRaCmI*_MIP`aVbKLI*EdAWN{ExI{Z^?L
I*`?JADRS\-I]AWI*\JADN*EWIP`aVDI4?J` CF`HQSI*ExVWCyEWEWIP_MIP`HVOPRSTFRaEDEWZST[\-RS?XA=TFI*E=Ra\-NPAlZVDIP?JAlEPn~TFCFNKji ?J`XI]\Z^AWV
ZS?8O<RSJVKLI*ECF`LoAlZSExVWAD?XOVD?JADI*E*nH_4Z^CyEZ^?EWEWC~Z^? D PXw l nL\XZ|SNYExRa?XEzoRSAD_MIYKLIdTFCFOPIP`XOPI*E*
;Z4_MCFEWIsI*`\JTyZSO<IKL?AWN{ExI{Z^?Kji ZaOPO<{E@AlZSKLCFR]AWI*\JAWN{ExI*`aVWIsIP`HQeCFAWRaB` AS4 C KL?VWRSVDZST2KLI*E}CF`HQSI*Exu
VDCFEDExI*_MIP`aVlEMI*`CF`LoAlZSExVWAD?XOVD?JADI*E* Z^`E4OPIO<Ra`aVWIPeVWISnTwi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`KLI{EMADN*EWI*ZS?LK~i ZSO*O<*E
AlZSKLCFRsKLIPQeCFIP`aV{nH\-RS?XA?X`]Ra\-NPAlZVDIP?JA{n^?J`IP`ghI*?4oRS`XKXZ^_MIP`aVlZ^T-\-IPAD_MI<VWVDZ^`HVzKji N{O<RS`XRS_MCFEWIPAzKLI{E
CF`HQSI*ExVWCyEWEWIP_MI*`aVDE*n;KLI4ADN*KJ?JCmADIMTmI]`JRa_=XAWI]KLIEWCtVDI*E=rKLNP\JTFR|SI*A*njIPVsKJI4fHZ^AlZ^`aVDCmAb?J`JI]-RS`J`XI
GH?XZSTmCmVWN=KLIbEWIPADQeCFOPIYZ^?L6?LVWCFTmCyEDZVWI*?JAlEP
x

t4

x

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


;Z8_4ZghRSADCtVDN]KLI*EbRa\-NPAlZVDIP?JAlEdRa`aVsAWI{O<RS?XADEbrTi RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`c_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFISn0XZSEWNPI]Ex?XAsKLI*E
_MN<VWvXRLKLI{E}I*_(\XCmADCFGH?JI{EUI<VY`JRa`EW|LEhVDNP_4ZVDCFGH?JI{EP@Ra?XEdZQ^Ra`XEdODvJI*ADOlvJN(r6Z^?LVDRS_4ZVDCFEWIPAdOPI<VWVWI
RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`jn*KLI_4Z^`JCFPADI[rVWI{EhVDIPA0?J`bN*Q^I*`aVDZSCmTaKLIzO<RS`JXfS?JAlZVDCmRa`XE-I*Z^?O<RS?X\d\XTm?XEjTyZ^ADfSIGa?XI
Ti NPQSI*`aVDZSCmTX\-I*AW_MCyE[\XZ^ATwi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`(_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFISnarbZ^_MNPTFCFRSADIPA[TFI*E[\-I*AxoRaAW_4ZS`XO<I{EkKLI@ADN*EWI*ZS?L
RS\LVDCm_MCyExN{E}_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFIP_MIP`aVYI<VYrN*OPRS`JRa_(CyEWIPA}TmIsVDIP_M\XEdKJI*EUIPe\IPAWVDE}AlZSKLCFRX-jI`JRa_=XAWIsVWAD*E
Cm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aVdKLI=\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*E@r4RS\JVWCF_(CyEWIPAUKji ?J`XI=\Z^AWV*nXIPVUTFZ]OPRS_M\JTFI<LCmVWNsKLIsTwi N*QZSTm?XZ^VWCFRS`KL?
AWN{ExI{Z^? K~i ZS?LVWADI\XZ^AWV*n;ADIP`KLIP`aV(CF_M\-NPAlZVDCmQSI?J`JI8Z^\J\XAWRJODvJIK~i RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`OPRS_sJCF`XZVDRSCFAWIa
jI@ODvJRaCtKJITi >@TFfSRaAWCmVWvJ_MI dNP`XN<VWCyGH?JI= @dkO<RS_M_MIVDI*OlvJ`JCyGa?XI@K~i Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`ME*i I{EhVZ{QSN*AWN
I<]OPZaO<I[I<V0\-I*AxoRaAW_4ZS`aV~\-Ra?JA0O<I\JAWRaJTFP_M I >@TmVW_4Z^` P n zI*E` DHZ^_4ZSZ < ^ wzI<VWVWI
RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`=KLI*E0ADN*EWI*ZS?LUI{EhV2O<Ra`J`H?JIzEWRS?XEjTFI9`JRS_ KJI wp6l<tL W ^L ^ ^G FPX
RS? UL wp [Pa ^XH n{IPV2Ti RS`KLN*EWCmfa`JI9\Z^A UL wp Pa -P 0 0Twi Ra?LVWCFT
KLIY\XTFZS`JCt-OPZVDCmRa`8ZS?LVWRa_4ZVWCyGH?JIS
zI}OlvXZ^\XCtVDAWI@I*ExV9RSADfaZS`JCyExNKLI@TyZYopZaq<RS`]Ex?XCmQ^Z^`aVDIbaTFZb\XAWI*_(CFPADI\XZSAxVDCmI@\JADN*EWIP`aVDI@KLI@opZaq<RS`
Ex?OPO<CF`XO<VWIMTmI(oRa`XOVDCmRa`J`JIP_MI*`aV=KLI{EYAWN{ExI{Z^?L
njZSCm`XEWCGH?JI(TFI*EYfaADZS`XKLIP?XADEUCm`HVWIPADQSIP`XZS`aV
KJZ^`E0Twi ZS`XZ^TF|LExIKLIExI{E0\-I*AxoRaAW_4ZS`XO<I{EP{0ZUKLI*?LLCm*_(Iz\Z^AWVWCFIKLN<X`XCtVkTFI\JAWRaJTFP_MIzK~i RS\JVWCF_(CyEDZu
VWCFRS`]KLI}TFZb\XTFZS`JCt-OPZVDCmRa`4KLI}AWN{ExI{Z^?L
Z^`E?J`JI@VWADRSCyExCFP_MI@\XZ^AWVWCFISnS`JRa?XE\JAWN{ExI*`aVWRa`XE
Ti Z^\X\JTmCyOPZ^VWCFRS`]KLI}Ti @ rbTyZb\JTyZ^`JCmOPZ^VWCFRS`]KLI}AWN{ExI{Z^?jn^IPVzI*`LX`jnHKJZS`XE?J`JIUGH?XZVDAWCFP_MI@\Z^AWVWCFISn
TmI{EAWN{Ex?XTtVlZVDERaLVWI*`H?XE@Ex?XA?J`AWN{ExI{Z^?6ADN*Z^TFCyEhVDIYExRa`aV@ZS`XZ^TF|LExN{EP
]'
+,.0/k1M38587.;:P1=, =5 / s5 / =38:<1 1 8:
9i RaeghI{OVWCmoK~i ?J`cADN*EWI*ZS?AlZSKJCmR8_MRSJCFTmIanJLNM\XZ^AYTFI*EYTFCFOPIP`XOPI*EYKji Ra\-NPAlZVDCmRa`jn-I*ExV=KLIM\-IPAWu
_MI<VxVDAWI=rM?X`fSAlZ^`K`JRa_sJAWI=Kji ?LVDCmTFCyEWZ^VWIP?XADE@K~i ZSOPOPN*KLI*A@r4O<IbADN*EWI*ZS?8rMTwi ZSCFKJI=K~i ?X`8VWI*AW_MCF`XZ^T
\-RSAWVDZ^VWCmoVWN*TmN*\JvJRa`JISnLRaADKLCF`XZ^VWIP?XA*nHIPVDOS <nJr\Z^AWVWCFAKJIY`ji Cm_M\-RaAxVDIYGH?JIPT~\-RSCF`aV}K~i ?X`VDIPADAWCmVWRaCmADI
N<VDIP`XKL?0`cfSN*`JNPAlZ^TwnTFI*EdTmCyO<I*`XO<I{E}XeI*`aVbKLI{EdRSLghI*OVDCtopEbKji ZaOPO<{EUZS?ADN*EWI*ZS?jnRa?BKLI l; 6<
nSIP`4\RS?JAlO<I*`aVDZSfSIKJI@\RS\J?JTyZVDCmRa`M\XZSA9ADZS\J\-RSAWVr=TFZb\-RS\X?JTFZ^VWCFRS`MVWR^VlZ^TFISnaI<VKLIVDIPADAWCmVWRaCmADI
\XLZ^DA ADZS\J\-RaAxVZS?VDIPADAWCmVWRaCmADIU`ZVWCFRS`Z^TwLjI{E?LVDCmTFCyEWZ^VWIP?XADEKLRaCmQSI*`aV\-Ra?JQSRSCFAExIbKLN*\JTFZaO<I*AEW?JA@OPI
VWI*AWADCtVDRSCFAWIYEDZ^`XEGa?XIYTyZMGH?XZ^TFCmVWNbKJIYTFIP?JA@OPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZVDCmRa`EWRSCmVIPJO<I*EDEWCmQSIP_MI*`aV@KLN*fSAlZSKLN*IS
8

B

b

u


g

:

`<?@BJ?A

`A

->^J?@

'.

Bz#z2

>@X`8KJId\-IPAD_MI<VWVWADIdZS?L]?LVWCFTFCFEDZVDIP?JAlEK~i PVWADId_MRSJCFTFI*E*nH?X`JIdTFCFZSCFEWRS`6ADZaKLCmRLNPTFI*O<VWADCFGH?JI}ADIPTFCmI
TmIVWI*AW_MCF`XZ^T@_MRSJCFTmIZ^?ADN*EWI*ZS?j[0IEWCmfa`XZ^TADZaKLCFReNPTFI*O<VWADCFGH?JI6I{EhVZ^VxVDNP`H?JNZS?OPRS?JAlEMKJIEWZ
\JADRS\XZSfaZVDCmRa`pZ^ZSCmJTFCyEWEWIP_MIP`HVsKLI\XZ^AlO<Ra?JADE*njKLCm-AlZSO<VWCFRS`XE*njADN XIPLCmRa`XEYIPVDOS <20Z\J?JCyEDEWZS`XO<I
GH?JCzZ^ADAWCFQSI4Z^?`JCFQ^I{Z^? KL?AWN{O<I*\LVWI*?JAsKLRaCtVs<VDAWIEx?J4EDZ^`HVWI]\-RS?JAGa?0i CFT9\J?XCFEDExI]ADI*O<Ra`XExVWCmVW?JI*A
O<RaAWADI*O<VWIP_MI*`aV(Ti CF`LoRSAD_4ZVWCFRS`GH?JCTm?JCI{EhV]KLI*ExVWCF`JNPIa[0I*E(\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<I*EMKLI*EMKLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEMN*_MI<Vxu
VWI*?JADEYKL?EW|eExVW*_MI(ADZaKLCFR^u _(RaJCFTmIN<VDZS`aVbTmCF_MCtVDNPI{EPn~\JTm?ExCFIP?JAlEd\RSCF`aVDEbK~i ZaOPOP*EdZS?BAWN{ExI{Z^?jn-TFI*E
EhVlZVDCmRa`XEKLI}XZaExIanSEWRS`HV9Cm`EhVlZ^TFTmN{EKXZ^`XETFIVDIPADAWCmVWRaCmADIbXfS?XAWI < `]_MRSJCFTFI}GH?JCEWI}KLN*\JTFZaO<I
Ex?XAY?J`cVWI*AWADCmVWRSCFADI(E*i Z^VxVlZSODvXIMr8TyZEhVlZVWCFRS`KLI4XZSEWIMGH?JCTm?JCoRS?JAD`JCmVYTFIM_MI*CmTFTmI*?JA=TmCFIP`cAlZSKJCmR
U`cKLN<`JCtV=TFZO<IPTFTF?JTmI4OPRS_M_MI(TyZ6*RS`JI(R B?J`c_MRSXCmTFI(I*ExV=ZVWVDZSOlvJNMr8?J`JI4ExVDZ^VWCFRS`cKLIMXZaExI
KLRS`X`JNPIajI(\XZSEDEDZ^fSIKL?B_MRSJCFTmIMK~i ?J`JIMOPIPTFTm?XTmIMr?X`JI(ZS?LVWADI8pGH?ji RS`cZ^\J\IPTFTmIMZ^?XEDEWC a
dKLRSCmVbEWIsopZSCmADI(KJI(_4Z^`JCFPADIsVWAlZ^`XEW\XZSAWI*`aVWI\-RS?JAYTi ?LVWCFTFCFEDZVDIP?JA{n~EDZ^`XEdCm`aVDIPADAW?X\LVWCFRS`cKLI(TyZ
O<6RaP_( _s?J`XCFO*ZVWCFRS`0n-`JC[KJNPfSAlZSKXZVWCFRS`I<JOPI*EDExCFQSI(KLITyZ8Ga?Z^TFCtVDN(KLI4ExI*AWQeCyO<IS>`cK~i N*OPRS`JRa_MCFEWIPA
TmI{EO<RaLVDE@K~i Cm`XExVDZSTmTyZVDCmRa`6IPV@KLIb_4ZSCm`aVDIP`XZS`XO<IbKLI{EEWCmVWI*E*nJTmI{ERa\-NPAlZVDIP?JAlEz\JADRLOP*KLI*`aV@rTyZVWADCtu
-)

gf

!.

u u
v

$ 9%^pyS^ d8bhWW8sy b! h

EWI*O<VWRSADCyEWZ^VWCFRS`pQ^RaCmAXfa?JADI SVWADRSCyE9EhVlZVWCFRS`EKJI@ZSEWI@EWRS`aVzCF`XExVDZ^TFTFNPI*E9EW?JA9?X`4_MP_MIUEWCtVDI
TFI*E@Z^`aVDIP`J`XI*E@KLI*EExVDZ^VWCFRS`XEKLIb XZSEWIbExRa`aV@KJCmADI*O<VWCFQ^I{EZ{QSI*OY?J`JIbRS?JQSIPAWVW?XAWIYKji I*`HQeCmADRS` JI /KJ

ts

 xp

eLlld bhxWY ;#ShkDp P9 {WLl@wpl^0W^ D 0 pl

 



!

8$

LNMPO$Q'RPSUT?R;RVT)W8X YZRV[]\V[]^GT)_`Sa[]X RVR;T?b]b]T)W

'$

LNcJOde[ SUT?WSU^U[ fWUT)_)SUX ^G[]T?b]W

Wl*p l O  1zSP 0WDy<*H* h~ Y W`[9 (b{ h 9{{^MD=hxkhhs^h0DU@D WblSPp}yl h[{{P (W(=xh


 





b 

^$

&g&@ B

`2

`

i ?LVWCFTmCyEDZVWCFRS`KLITFZ]TFCFZSCFEWRS`AlZSKLCFRKJZ^`XE}TFI*EUOPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZ^VWCFRS`XE}\-RHExIs?J`O<I*AxVlZ^CF``XRS_sJADI
LK IY\JADRSXTm*_(I{EPneTFCmN{ErTyZ`XZVD?JADId_MP_MIbKL?8_MN*KLCF?J_ KLIdVWAlZ^`Ex_MCyEWEWCmRa`jJzIY_MN*KLCF?J_I*ExV\XZ^A
`XZ^VW?JADI8KLCyEx\IPAlExCmohn2CFTI{EhV4O<Ra_M_=?X`rVWRa?XETFI*E(?LVDCmTFCFEDZVDIP?JAlE*n2I<V4ExRa`?XEWZSfSI6KLRaCtV4KLRS`O<VWADI
\XZSAxVlZ^faNSajIdEx\-I{OVDAWI@AlZSKJCmRnSI<V\Z^AzOPRS`XEWN*GH?JI*`aVzTyZsOPZS\XZSOPCtVDN}KJCFEW\-RS`XCmJTFI}\-RS?XAzTi ZSO*O<*E9ADZaKLCFRXn
I{EhVbfSN*`JNPAlZ^TFIP_MI*`aVdTFCF_(CmVWNM\XZSAYTyZ6ADNPfSTFIP_MI*`aVDZ^VWCFRS`TFCFOPIP`XOPI*El T[AWI*\JADN*EWIP`aVDI(KLRa`XO?J`XI(ADI*Exu
EWRS?JAlO<I9Ra`JNPADIP?XEWISn{GH?ji CFTHI*ExV2I{EWEWIP`HVWCFIPTeK~i N*OPRS`JRa_MCFEWIPA{{jIO*Z^`XZSTaADZaKLCmR}I{EhV[Ex?^ghI<V[rUKLIz_s?JTtVDCm\XTmI{E
u su

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


QZSAWCyZVDCmRa`XEKL?JI{EUrMTyZ4_MRSJCFTFCtVDNsKJI*E@?EWZSfSIPAlEI<VdZ^?LOlvXZ^`XfSIP_MI*`aVDEUKLI*EUOPZ^AlZSO<VWN*AWCyEhVDCFGH?JI{EKLI
Ti IP`eQHCFADRS`J`JI*_MIP`aV{nO<Ra_(_MITi I<I<VbKJI_MZaEWGH?JIRS?Twi NPQZS`JRS?XCFEDExI*_MIP`aVdADZS\JCFKJI eCFP?J` w~0I
OPZS`XZ^T9I*ExV\-IPAWVW?XAW-N\XZ^AsTFI*EsCF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EPn;I<VTFI*EEWCFfS`XZS?LcNP_MCyEExI]\XAWRa\XZ^faIP`aVExI*TmRa` KLI*E
VWAlZghI<VDE_s?JTmVWCF\JTFI*E*zI*E\JvJNP`XRS_MP`JI{EQZSAWCFIP`aV@KJZS`XETwi I{Ex\XZaO<IYI<V}KJZ^`ETFIdVDIP_M\XE*
UJ{{ -2# e^*HMa{;j2HzmXSSe
g  h~ h~
Z^`XE@TmI{E@EW|LEhVDP_MI*EAlZSKLCFRM_MRSXCmTFI*E*nJTyZMXZ^`XKJI=KLIboADN*GH?JIP`O<Ib?LVDCmTFCFEWNPI=\XZSATFI*E}O<Ra_M_=?X`JCtu
OPZ^VWCFRS`XE}I*ExVUTFCm_MCmVWNPIajzI<VWVWIXZS`XKLI(KLRSCmVdKLRa`XO=<VDAWI?LVWCFTmCyEWNPIKJIsTyZMopZaq<Ra`TyZ]\JTF?XE9gh?XKLCyO<CFIP?XEWI
\-RaEDEWCmJTFI9\RS?JA2N*OPRS?JTFIPA;TFIz_4Z^eCF_s?J_ KLIOPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZ^VWCFRS`XE**9TmTFII*ExVk\XZ^AWVDZSfSNPI9I*`OPZS`XZ^?JbGH?JC
ExRa`aV@Z^TFTmRa?JN*Er(TyZ(KLIP_4ZS`XKLIbKJI*E_MRSJCFTFI*ERa?8KJI*EExVDZVDCmRa`XEKJIYXZaExIaL0Z(`XZVD?JAWIbKLI{EOPZS`XZ^?L
KLIzVWAlZ^`XEW_MCFEDExCFRS`KLNP\-I*`XKsKJITFZ}_MNPVWvJRJKLIKji ZaOPO<{E;?LVDCmTFCFEWNPIa0I*E0VDAWRaCFE;\XAWCF`XO<CF\XZSTmI{EjVDI*ODvX`JCFGH?JI{E
K~i ZSOPOP*E_=?XTtVDCm\JTFISnOSi I{EhVWu r^u KLCFADIdKLIb\Z^AWVDZ^faIdKJIYTyZADI*EDEWRS?JAlO<IUAlZSKLCFRXnJExRa`aVTFI*E@EW?JCmQ^Z^`aVDI*E*
ikjVjVl$monqp'rs)tuvrwxuy{z}|~euy{z$s?t)s)t?{0w}'z;~V$p'w$jVw-m 8S
x!M- 'z;wV$p'w$j$xt)
;Zb_MN<VWvXRLKLIUK~i ZSO*O<*E9_s?JTtVDCm\XTmIdTFZ=\JTF?XEzZS`XO<CFIP`J`XI
t`mJt?np'rs)tuvrwikjVjVw-mJm}
I* ExV4TFZB_MNPVWvJRJKLI  >s90ZBZXKZ^`8 KLI\XZSEDEWZS`aVWI8I*ExV4\XZ^AWVDZSfSN*I6IP`XZ^`XKJI*E(NPVWADRSCmVWI{E(ZS?LVWRa?JA
K~i ?J`JIboAWN{Ga?XIP`XOPIb\-RSAWVWI*?XExI JKJZ^`XE@TmIsEx|LExVW*_(IbADZaKLCFR^u _(RaJCFTmIUoAlZ^`qPZ^CyE@KLIb\JADIP_MCm*AWIbfSN*`JNPAlZu
VWCFRS`jn@ZaKLCFRLO<Ra_ aSXnLODvZSGH?JI=OPZS`XZ^TjRLO*O<?J\Z^CmV - 9BX-zvXZaGH?JIb\-RSAWVWI*?XEWIMpRS?OPZ^`Z^TI*ExV
?LVWCFTFCFEWNPI4\-RS?JAbQSNPvJCyO<?JTFIPA=?J`ZS\J\-I*T[?J`JCyGa?XI4I<V=KXZ^`XEb?J`EWIP?JT9EWIP`XEbr8TyZ6oRSCyE4pKJI4TFZExVDZVDCmRa`
QSIPAlEkTmI_MRSXCmTFIRS?(CF`HQSIPAlEWIP_MIP`aVa0ZbOPZS\XZSOPCtVDNKJ?4EW|eExVW*_MII*ExV9KLRa`XOTFCm_MCmVWN*I\XZSA[TmI`XRS_sJADI
KLIY\RSAWVWIP?ExI{EKLCyEx\RS`JCFJTFI*E*
ikjVjVl$mnprs?tuvrwuy{z|~euyz4s)t)s?t?0ww$u'm 8S
}- t`wt t`mJt?{npr
0ZVWI{ODvJ`XCFGH?JI > I*ExV?LVWCFTmCyEWNPIbKXZ^`XETmI{EEx|LExVWP_MI{EAlZSKLCFR^u
_Ms)tuvRSJrwECFTmI{iEMjVKLj;Iw$mJEWmI*O< Ra`XKLMI68 faNP`JN*ADZ^VWCFRS`OPRS_M_MI6TFI n[R I*TmTFI8I*ExV4OPRS_sJCF`JNPIrBTyZ_MN<VDvJRLKJI
` Cm`aVDIPADQZSTmTFI*EzKLI@VWIP_M\XEd @Ra?
 >se0Z=\-RaAxVDIP?XEWIsoADN*GH?JIP`O<I}AlZSKJCmRe2I{EhV\XZ^AWVDZSfSNPII*
O<?J4TFCFIPA{ mU `IPZ(VdKJ\-RSIP`X?LOUVY\XKJTm?XRSEW`XCFO=IP?J<AlVDEAWI?LVD?LCmVWTFCyCFEWTFCFZ^EWVWNPIPI?X\XADEZSA \XZ^ AoVDAWIPN{ADGa_M?XCmIP`X`XZSOP?LIS~Jn-0OlZvXVWZSAlOPZ^?J`X`EW_M?LVDCFEDCmTFExCyCFEWRSZS``aVdI*` ?J` \X> Z^AWI*VWExCmVu
KLCyEWOPRS`aVDCm`H?XI6?J`B_MRSXCmTFI(GH?JCkNP_MI<VbEx?XAdTi @KLRSCmVYZ^VxVDIP`XKLADITwi \-Ra?JAdNP_MI<VWVWADI(r
`JRS?XQ^I{Z^?je0ZO*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNdKL?8Ex|LExVW*_(IUI{EhVTFCm_MCmVWNPIY\XZ^ATmId`JRa_=XAWIdKLId\-RaAxVDIP?XEWI*E9IPVTmIU`XRS_sJADI
K~i %\XZ^A\-RaAxVDIP?XEWIS
ikjVjVl$mxnprs?tuvrwuy{zE|~euy{z$s)t)s?t?{0w40w$m} 8S
N Y- 90wExt t`mJt?{npr
0I}\JADCF`XO<CF\-IUKJI}TyZb_MNPVWvJRJKLIUK~i ZSO*O<{E >%I{EhVKLI}_MRJKL?JTFIPA
s)tuvrwxikjVjVw$mJm} N
TmIUExCFfS`XZSTX?LVWCFTmIU\XZ^A9M?J`8 O<RJKLI@ `H?X_(N*AWCyGH?JI@\XEWIP?KLR^u Z^TFN*Z^VWRSCFADIKJRS`aVzTFI}KJNPJCmVzI{EhV9`XI<VxVDIP_MIP`HVEx?Lu
\-NPADCFIP?JA9r=Ti Cm`JoRSAD_MZ^VWCFRS`4?LVDCmTFISJzI<VWVWIU_(RJKL?JTyZVDCmRa`4Zb\-Ra?JAzO<Ra`XExN{GH?JIP`XOPI@Kji NPVDZ^TFIPA9TFIUEx\-I{OVDAWI
oAWN{GH?JIP`aVDCmI*TKJ?EWCFfS`XZST;`ADN*OPIP\LVDCmRa`jn;TmI8ExCFfS`Z^T9I{EhVMOPRSADAWN*TmN]ZQSI*O]?X`JIADNP\JTFCyGa?XIEW|e`XODvXAWRSu
`JCyExN*I4KL?O<RJKLI4Kji NPVDZ^TFIP_MI*`aV*n;O<I]GH?JC\-I*AW_MI<VsKJI4AWI{EhVDCtVD?JIPAbTwi CF`LoRaAW_4ZVDCmRa`cCF`JCtVDCFZSTmIa0i ZSO*O<{E
ExCF_s?JTmVDZ^`XN]EW?JA=?J`XI]_MP_MI4\RSAWVWIP?ExI4I*ExVsAWI*`XKL?\-RHEWEWCmXTmI4faA aO<I4rTi ZVWVWADCmX?LVWCFRS` rODvXZaGa?XI
?LVWCFTFCFEDZVDIP?JAYK~i ?J`BOPRLKLIs\XEWIP?XKJR6Z^TFN*Z^VWRaCmADI=CF`XKLNP\IP`XKJZS`aVMpOPRLKLI{E}RaAxVDvJRSfaRS`XZS?LX0Z]ADI*ExVWCmVW?Lu
VWCFRS`KL?EWCmfa`XZ^TjRaAWCFfSCF`XZST~\-Ra?JA@?J`?LVDCmTFCFEDZVDIP?JAdEPi I<I*O<VW?JIsIP`Z^\J\JTFCyGa?Z^`aV}TFIsOPRLKLIsEx\N*O<CmGH?JI
rOPI<V?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWI*?JA*nJO<IYGH?JCjZs\RS?JAOPRS`XEWN*GH?JI*`XO<IdKji ZS`J`H?JTFIPATmI{EEWCFfS`XZS?L]KLI{EhVDCm`XN*EZS?LZ^?JVWADI*E
?LVWCFTFCFEDZVDIP?JAlEPJzI<VWVWI}VDI*ODvX`JCFGH?JIYK~i N<VlZ^TFIP_MIP`aVKLIdEW\-I*O<VWADI}AWN*\XZ^AWVWCmVzTi NP`JI*AWfaCmI}AlZSKLCFRsNPTFI*O<VWADCFGH?JI
Ex?XA9?J`JIUXZ^`KLIUKLI@oADN*GH?JI*`XO<I@I*Z^?O<RS?X\4\JTm?E9TyZ^ADfSI@GH?JIdO<IPTFTFI@`XN*O<I{EWEDZ^CFADI@rbTyZYVDADZS`XEx_MCyEWEWCFRS`
u u
8

B

b

g

s

 g

uF&4

gf

`(

#

*

*

vrv

$ 9%^pyS^ d8bhWW8sy b! h

LK ?4ExCFfS`XZSTe?LVWCFTmIaS0ZYKLIP`XEWCmVWNEW\-I{OVWAlZ^TFIKLI\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI\XZSAk?LVDCmTFCFEDZVDIP?JA[I{EhVkopZSCmJTFISn^TFIEWCFfS`XZSTeI*ExV
GH?XZaExCF_MIP`aV0Cm`KLN*OPIPTyZ^JTFI[I<V0\-IP?=ExI*`XEWCmJTFIZ^?JUCF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EP U`Y\XZSAWTFI[KJICyKLIPZ^`XKeux >
Ra?E >sezI*EkEW|LEhVDP_MI*EkADZaKLCFR^u _(RaJCFTmI{E;EWRS`aVZS?XEWEWCLKLCmVDEKLIVWADRSCyExCFP_MIfaNP`JN*ADZ^VWCFRS`j0IP?JA
O*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNdI{EhV@TFCm_MCmVWN*Ib\XZ^ATmI{ECF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EIP`aVDAWIbTmI{EEWCFfS`XZS?L]IPV\XZSATmIb`JRS_sJADIbKJIbO<RJKLI*E*
jI*EVDAWRaCFE_MNPVWvJRJKLI*EK~i ZSO*O<{EExRa`aV\JADN*EWIP`HVWNPI{EEW?JATyZXfa?JAWI J
N

Amplitude

Amplitude

Amplitude

Temps

Temps

Temps

Frquence

Frquence

LNMPOX\VTQ

Frquence

LNcJOXe\;Tv'Q

LN_OXe\;T'Q

bp{Sh l h

 





 $

j j 8 ~2e(;2B kp4j -
jIYKL?X\JTmIPJZ^fSIdI*ExVTyZ_4Z^`JCFPADIYKLRS`aVTFI*EKLIP?L6EWIP`XEKLIdTFCFZSCFEWRS`6\XZ^AWVDZSfSIP`HVTFI*EAWI{EWEWRS?JAlO<I{E
AlZSKLCFRX U`#\XZ^ADTmIKLITFCmI*`_MRa`aVDZS`aV W]6P P Ra? -t n9`JRSVWN ;4GH?XZ^`XKCFT}E*i ZSfSCmV
KLITwi NP_MCFEDEWCmRa`KJ?_MRSJCFTFIQ^I*ADE}TyZ6ExVDZVDCmRa`KLI(XZSEWISjITFCFIP`BKJI*EDO<IP`KJZ^`aVM < ^  RS?
aJ [X` t nX`JRSVWN ;OPRSADAWI{Ex\RSRS`X? Kr(Ti NP_M Cy EWEWCFRS`KLIYTyZMExVDZ^VWCFRS`KLIYXZaExIYQSnHIPTyAlZEExTFVDIYZ_MVDCmRaRS`6JCFKLTFISIU ZSEWI
IPV(TFIVDIPAD_MCmm`X ZS T*a_(R RalJ =CFTmF<I8XP?LXVWwCFpTFCF<EW IP`aV]KLI*EoADN*GHW?J= IPF<`XO<PI*-EM] K~i sN*_M7 6*CFEDExpCFRS `sKLCm -NPmAD IP `aVDI*E(I<VMN*_MI<VxVDIP`aV]EWCtu
_s?JTmVDZS`JNP_MIP`HV*UzIc_MRLKJIBI*ExV8\XZSAxVDCFOP?JTFCm*AWI*_(I*`aVCm`aVDNPADI*EDEWZS`aVKJZS`XE6TFI*EEx|LExVW*_(I{E6_4ZSOPAWRSu
OPIPTFTm?JTyZ^CFADI*E*nLOPZSACFT~`XIb`JN*OPI*EDExCmVWIY\XZaEKLI=Ex|e`XOlvJADRS`JCyEWZ^VWCFRS`j
`
RS?

<nTFZ]ExVDZ^VWCFRS`KLIsXZaExIsI<VUTFI
VDIPAD_(CF`XZST2 _MmRS J*CFTmaI(M?L VD<CmTFCFEWJIP^`HWVYP TFZ6_MP_MI(\-RS0AWVWI*4?X ExIasn_47 6*ZSCFpEU^N*_M=I<VxVDIPm`a V=r6KLI{EdCm`XExVDZS`aVDEYKLCmNPADIP`aVlEP
zI{EKLIP?L8_MRLKLI{EKLI=KL?X\JTmIPJZ^fSIbExRa`aVADIP\JADN*EWIP`HVWN*EEx?XATFZXfa?JAWI
g h h h

8*

&3

53

53

`(

0

((

+*

+*

b 

53

2b^Yq

& 

jI*EYEx|LExVWP_MI{EUADZaKLCFR_MRSJCFTFI*EdKLIVWADRSCyEWCm*_(IfaNP`JN*ADZ^VWCFRS`RS`aVY\-Ra?JAdRSLghI*O<VWCmoKLI\XAWI*`XKLADI
I*`(ODvXZSAWfaIz?J`JIfSAlZ^`XKJI9QZSAWCFN<VDNKJIExI*AWQeCyO<I{EjVDIPTyE[Ga?XITFZdQ^RaCt~nTyZ}QeCyKLNPRn `aVDIPAD`JI<V{nTmIzVDADZS`XExoIPAWV
KLI4KLRS`J`XNPI*E*n~Z{QSI*OKJI*EYKJNPJCmVDEY\-RS?JQ^Z^`aVbZVWVWI*Cm`XKJAWI L ~ sIP`BTFCFZSCFEWRS`BKLI{EWOPIP`XKXZ^`aVDIS I*?L
_MRLKJI*E[K~i ZSO*O<*Ek\-RS?XA[Ti Cm`HVWIPAWopZSOPIAlZSKLCFRYKLITi sRa`aVN<VDNEW\-N*OPCtN*Ek\XZSA[TmI{EkRaAWfHZ^`JCyEx_MI{E2KLI
`JRaAW_4ZSTmCyEWZ^VWCFRS`6^TFI@\JAWI*_MCmI*A[I{EhV9ZaEWEWRLOPCmNrY?X`M_MRLKLI@KLI}KL?J\JTFI<JZ^faI    >U
IPV@TmI=ExI{O<RS`K6r(?J`_MRLKLI  >d }RSTF_MZ < a w




^pra

`((

((

((

u u
v

F



`((

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


8

B

b

Temps

Temps

DL
UL

DL
UL
Frquence

Frquence

LNMPOX\VTv

LNcJOXe\;Tv'

YS ^<H { H
Z^`XEkO<IODvXZS\JCtVDAWIan{`JRa?XE;`JRa?XE;CF`aVWN*AWI{EWEWIPADRS`XE;ZS?s_(RJKLI  >snSGH?JCLExI*ADZ@?LVDCmTFCFEWN
KJZ^`ETyZ\JADIP_MCm*AWIYQ^I*ADEWCFRS`6KJIdTwi 6KJNP\JTFR|SNPIYI*`6?XAWRa \-IS ?J\JTFI<LN*EoADN*GH?JI*`aVWCFIPTFTFIP_MIP`aV
<n2?J`ExCFfS`XZST_MRS`aVlZ^`aVIPVs?X` ExCFfS`XZSTzKLI*EDO<I*`XKJZ^`HVs`JI]\-I*?JQSIP`aV\XZaE=Cm`aVDIPAWoNPADIPA{02RS?JA
?J ` _(*_MI6EWIP`XEKLITFCFZSCFEWRS`0njTFI*Es?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWI*?JADEs\XZ^AWVDZSfSI*`aV=TyZ_MP_MI6XZ^`XKJIKJI4oADN*GH?JI*`XO<II<V
EPi CF`aVWI*Axo*AWI*`aV}_s?LVW?XIPTFTmI*_(I*`aV*n~O<IsGa?XC0TFCm_MCmVWIsTFZ]OPZS\XZSOPCtVDNSX0I*E@\-I*AxoRaAW_4Z^`O<I*EKJ?AWN{ExI{Z^?jnJIP`
VWI*AW_MI*EKLI6OPRS?JQSI*AxVD?JAWIan;OPZ^\ZSO<CmVWNI<V(GH?XZSTmCmVWN8KLI6ExI*AWQeCyO<Ian0I<VMExRa`RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`ExRa`aV(KLRS`O
N<VDAWRaCtVDIP_MIP`aVzTFCmN*I*Ezr=TyZbfaI*ExVWCFRS`]KLI*E9CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EPakRS?JAOPI<VxVDI}AlZ^CyExRa`jnS`JRS?E9KLN{O<ADCmADRS`XE9KJZ^`XE
O<I\XZ^AlZ^faADZS\JvJI;TFI*E0KLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEjV |e\-I{EjKji CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EjKJZS`XE~TFIEW|LEhVDP_MISnP\J?JCyEj`JRS?E~\XAWN{O<CyExI*AWRa`XE
TmI{E`JR^VDCmRa`XEKLI=O*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNSnJKLI=O<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADIdI<V}KLIb_MZaO<ADR^u KLCFQ^I*ADEWCmVWNS
ULXp2L*2eMp~*HJ He2Se
g  h~ j
zRa`XExCyKLN*AWRa`XEUTyZ8O<Ra_(_s?J`XCFO*ZVWCFRS`K~i ?J`c_MRSXCmTFI4r6?X`JI4ExVDZ^VWCFRS`cKLI4XZSEWIMKLRa`J`JNPIa;zI<VWVWI
O<Ra_(_s?J`XCFO*ZVWCFRS`4I{EhVzJADRS?XCmTFTmN*I@\XZSATFI*EzOPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZ^VWCFRS`XE9KLI{EzZ^?LVDAWI{E[_MRaJCmTFI*E* Z^`XEzODvXZaGa?XI
ExI*`XEKLIbTFCFZSCFEWRS`0neRS`KLCFExVWCF`Jfa?JIYTFI*ECm`HVWIPAWoNPADIP`O<I*EO*Z^?XEWNPI{E\XZSATmI{EOPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZ^VWCFRS`XEKJZS`XETyZ
_MP_MI4OPIPTFTm?JTFISn0GH?ji RS`ZS\J\-IPTFTFI(CF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E xCm`aVDADZOPIPTFTm?JTyZ^CFADI*E nI<V=TFI*EYCF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*EbOPZS?Lu
ExN*I*E\Z^A}TmI{E}OPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZVDCmRa`XE@KLI{E@_MRSXCmTFI*E@IP`KLI*vJRSAlE@KLI=TyZ]O<IPTFTF?JTmIanGH?ji RS`ZS\J\-IPTFTFIbCF`aVWI*Axu
oNPADIP`XOPI*E xCm`aVDIPA@OPIPTFTm?JTyZ^CFADI*E e>@X`KLIbOPRS_M\JADIP`XKLADIYO<I*EKLCm-N*AWI*`aVDE@EWOlvJNP_4ZaEKji CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EPn
?J`8IPeI*_M\JTmI=ExCF_M\JTFI=KLIbEW|LEhVDP_MIbrMKLI*?L8O<IPTFTF?JTmI{EI{EhV}KLN*OPAWCmV@KXZ^`XEOPIbGH?JC0Ex?JCmV*
0Z XfS?JADI CFTmTF?XExVWADI TFI*E CF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E
Cm<`H~VW*AlHZJu O<wHIPTFTFe?J;TFZSaCmADeI* EMGa?XI*EW?J JDaCmV4HTypZ2pO<JRap_(H_sa?J `XCFO*ZVWCFRS`#K~i ?J`_MRS XCmTFI Z^`EMTFIExI*`XE4KLI*EDO<I*`Lu
KJZ^`HV*nSTFI@_MRSXCmTFI 80ADI*qPRSCmV?J`]EWCmfa`XZ^TJ?JVWCFTmI}\JADRQSIP`Z^`aVzKLI@TFZ=EhVlZVDCmRa`4KLI@ZSEWISn^_4Z^CyECmTAWI{q<RaCtV
Z^?XEDEWCXTyZsEWRS_M_MI}KJI*EzEWCmfa`XZ^?L4KLI{EhVDCm`JN{EzZS?L4ZS?LVWADI*E9_MRSXCmTFI*EzKLIUTFZsOPIPTFTm?JTFIS+ TFIP?JANP_MCyEWEWCmRa`jn
O<I{E9KLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEzEWCFfS`XZS?L(EWRS`aVzRaAxVDvJRSfaRS`XZS?L6_s?JTmVWCF\JTFI<JZ^faI}EW|H`ODvJADRS`JI@\XZSA9KJI*EzO<RJKLI*ERSAWVWvJRSu
fSRa`XZ^?LX<`BAlZ^CyEWRS`KLI*E}VDADZghIPVDEd_s?JTtVDCm\XTmI{EYEW?JCmQeCyEd\XZ^AdTmI{EdEWCmfa`XZ^?L~n-Ti RSAWVWvXRSfSRa`XZ^TFCmVWN=`ji I*ExV
\XZSEk\Z^AWopZ^CmVWIrYTFZYAWN{O<I*\LVWCFRS`j U`4KLN<`JCtV9?J`(opZSO<VWI*?JA9K~i RSAWVWvJRafSRa`XZ^TFCtVDNGH?JCX_(I{Ex?XAWIO<I`XCmQSI*ZS?
K~i RSAWVWvJRafSRS`Z^TFCtVDNSa9i IPL\JAWI{EWEWCFRS`KLIdTwi CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<IdCF`aVWAlZu O<I*TmTF?JTyZ^CFAWI}ADI*q<?XIU\XZ^A?J`6_MRSJCFTFI
u u
 



W  '$

`(

4e

`((

M

v 6

$ 9%^pyS^ d8bhWW8sy b! h

ExI*`XEKJI*EDO<IP`KJZ^`aVzI{EhV@TFZ4Ex?JCFQZS`aVWIM
' =

'

9 a

=~
Z^`XE@O<IPVxVDIYN*GH?XZ^VWCFRS`c
I*ExV@TFIbopZSO<VWI*?JA}K~i RSAWVWvJRafSRa`XZ^TFCtVDNSnJOPRS_M\JADCFEIP`aVDAWIsMI<VSX2RS?XA
JnXTi RSAWu
' 
VWvJRafSRS`Z^TFCtVDN6I{EhV4\XZSAxopZSCtVDI [Z^?O<Ra`aVWAlZ^CFADISnkEWC  = SnkTwi RSAW'VWvJ =RafSRS`Z^TFCtVDNI*ExV
`H?JTFTmIa

I*ExVbTyZ6\X?JCFEDEDZ^`XOPIMKji N*_(CyEDExCFRS`KLIMTyZEhVlZVDCmRa`KLIMZSEWI(QSIPAlEYTmI4_(RaJCFTmI M8Z{QSI{O

'
S
I*ExVYTyZ6\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI(Kji N*_(CyEDExCFRS`cKLI{EYO*Z^`XZS?LOPRS_M_s?J`XE*;zI*EYOPZS`XZ^?LOPRS_M_s?J`XE*n


RS?XZSTmCyExI{EPnExI*AWQSIP`HVUr4KJCt?XEWIPA}TyZ]ExCFfS`XZSTmCyEDZVWCFRS`KJZ^`XE@TyZ]O<I*TmTF?JTFIS TFEUExRa`aV}NP_MCyE
r\X?JCFEDEDZ^`XOPIYOPRS`XExVDZS`aVWIa
I*ExV2TFZ}\J?XCFEDEWZS`XO<IzKL?(OPZS`XZ^TeKLIEW|H`ODvJADRS`JCyEDZVWCFRS`0nP?J`OPZS`XZ^TeO<Ra_M_=?X`s\XZSAxVDCFOP?JTmCFIPA{n


`JRS`8RaAxVDvJRSfaRS`XZST-ZS?L8Z^?LVDAWI{EO*Z^`XZS?L~

 ~ 6 6I{EhV@Ti Z~Z^CFJTFCFEDExI*_MIP`aV}KL?ExCFfS`XZSTI*`aVWADIYTyZMEhVlZVWCFRS`KLIYXZaExI ~}I<V@TFIY_MRSXCmTFI 8W


Z^`XETFIYEWIP`XE_MRS`aVlZ^`aV=p_(RaJCFTmI{EzQSI*ADEExVDZVDCmRa`XEKLIYXZSEWI{<nHTFIYEWCmfa`XZ^TNP_MCFE\XZ^ATmId_MRaJCmTFI
I{EhVCF`aVWI*AxoN*AWN]\Z^AsTmI{EsEWCmfa`XZ^?Jc\JAWRQSIP`XZS`aVsKJI4VDRS?XEsTmI{Es_MRSJCFTmI{EsKLITFZ_M*_(I6OPIPTFTm?JTFIS[zI{E
EWCmfa`XZ^?J`JIExRa`aV]\XZSEEx|e`XOlvJAWRa`JCyExN{EPn[I<V6KLI*EO<RJKLI*E4KJI dRaTFK pOPRLKLI{E4Kji I*_=XAWRa?JCmTFTyZ^fSIGH?JC
KLCmNPADIP`XOPCmI*`aV6TmI{E4?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWI*?JADEl4EWRS`aV?LVDCmTFCFEWN*E*jI{EExCFfS`XZS?LKLI*E6Z^?LVDAWI{E4?LVDCmTFCFEDZVDIP?JAlEExRa`aV
KLRa`XOd\-IPAlq<?EO<RS_M_MIbKL?JAD?JCtV@XTFZS`XO }RSTF_MZ < ^ a w

9N 4  y

+4 ~ -
Z^`XE@O<IPVxVDIYN*GH?XZ^VWCFRS`c

I*ExVTyZ(\J?JCyEDEWZS`XO<IYKji N*_(CyEDExCFRS`KJ?8_MRSJCFTmI=K~i Cm`XKJCFOPI Z{QSI{O l

~ / I{EhV@Ti Z~Z^CFJTFCFEDExI*_MIP`aV}KL?EWCmfa`XZ^T~I*`aVWADIYTyZMEhVlZVWCFRS`KLIbXZaExIYIPVTFIb_(RaJCFTmI
44

__

ts

__





__

__

mi

LNMPOdeT)RVW\VT)Wa_)T)RV\JM=RPS


mi

Lc/OdT?R;WYZX RSaM=RS

^pl mlll  ^y]wlD { hjD h2SP0 


u bu
%



v&

!

#$

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


jI{EdfS?JADI*E I<V ]CFTFTm?XExVWADIP`HV=TFI*EbCF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E
Cm<`H~VW*IPHAWJu O<wIPHTFTF?JeTF;ZSaCmADeI*E4pGH~?J*C}HJDADaRSH?XCmpTF2TmI*p`aJVpTFHZa OPRS_M_s?J`JCyOPZVDCmRa`KL?_MRSJCFTmI KXZ^`XE4?X`EW|eExVW*_MIr
KLIP?JBO<I*TmTF?JTFI*E* ZS`XEYTFI4OPZaEdfSN*`JNPAlZ^T[K~i ?J`cADN*EWI*ZS?BEr EhVlZVWCFRS`EPn~TmIM_MRSJCFTFI 8@ZVxVlZSOlvJN4r
?J`JIExVDZ^VWCFRS`K~i CF`XKLCyO<I I{EhV4Cm`aVDIPAWoNPADN6\Z^A(TFI*E4ExCFfS`XZS?L\JADRQSIP`XZS`aV4KLI6VWRa?LVWI{E(TFI*EMZ^?JVWADI*E
EhVlZVDCmRa`XEKLIbZSEWIYKJ?8AWN{ExI{Z^?8KJZS`XETFIbEWIP`XE@ KLI*EDO<I*`XKJZS`aVb
}
4 $
}  ~ 6
ZS `X E@O<I<VWVWIbN*GH?XZVDCmRa`B
I{EhV@TFZM\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPIUVWRSVDZSTmI=K~i N*_MCFEDExCFRS`KLIbTFZMExVDZVDCmRa`KLIbXZSEWIbK~i CF`XKLCyO<PI ~
}

 ~ 6I*ExV4Twi Z^ZSCmXTmCyEWEWIP_MI*`aV]KL?EWCmfa`XZ^TI*`aVWADITyZExVDZ^VWCFRS`#KJIXZaExIK~i Cm`KLCFOP


I ~6I<V]TFI
_MRSXCmTFI 8W
ZS`XE=TFI6ExI*`XE=_MRa`aVDZS`aV*n2Ti CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I]CF`aVDIPAWu OPIPTFTm?JTyZ^CFADI4I*ExVKJ?JI6rTi NP_MCyEWEWCFRS` KLI]VWRa?XE=TFI*E
_MRSJCFTmI{E}KJZS`XE@TFI*EUZ^?LVDAWI{E}O<IPTFTF?JTmI{EP-;ZMVWAlZ^`Ex_MCyEWEWCmRa`K~i ?X`_MRSXCmTFIZVxVlZSOlvJNsr4TyZ]ExVDZVDCmRa`KLI
XZSEWIYK~i ^pl ~@I{EhV@\IPAWVW?JAD-NPIY\XZ^ATmI=EWCmfa`XZ^TjEx?XCmQ^Z^`aV=

 $ 

+9 ] 4-
ZS`XE@O<I<VWVWIbN*GH?XZVDCmRa`B

I{EhVdTyZ\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<IKji N*_(CyEDExCFRS`Kji ?J`B_MRaJCmTFI(K~i Cm`KLCFOPIYnZ^VxVlZSODvXN(r?J`JI(ExVDZVDCmRa`

KLIbXZSEWIbZ^?LVDAWIbGH?JI ]

~ 4/ BI{EhV6Twi Z^ZSCmJTFCyEWEWIP_MIP`HV6KJ?%ExCFfS`Z^T}IP`aVDAWITyZ ExVDZVDCmRa` KJIZSEWI ~8I<V8TmI_MRSJCFTFI


K~i CF`XKLCyO<I}

B

b

__

__

__

__

mi

 

mi

^pl mllD@ ^pl  Dl { hWlD{^p


6

l%

'$

mj

^D tlll ^l wll { 9^{^


u u

  

%

'$

$ 9%^pyS^ d8bhWW8sy b! h

j 0 N -0-H*;HMSn 2Ja{
0ZADIP`aVlZ^JCFTmCmVWN6KL? ADN*EWI*Z^?I*ExVsNPVWADRSCmVWI*_(I*`aVsTFCmN*I6rEDZO*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNan0OSi I{EhVWu r^u KJCmADI
N
rM;TyZ4 kGHJ?XSZSp*`a-VWCmVWNK~i CF`LoRaAW_4ZVDCmRa`\-RS?JQ^Z^`aV@PVWADIbN{ODvXZS`JfSN*I=ExCF_s?JTmVDZ^`XNP_MIP`aV{ ZS`XE@?J`O<Ra`aVWIPeVWI
_MRS`XR^u ExI*AWQeCyO<ISnSTFIU`JRS_sJADIUKji ?LVDCmTFCyEWZ^VWIP?XADEKLN<`JCtVTyZsOPZS\XZSOPCtVDNS ZS`XEzTmIdEW|LEhVDP_MI neR
\JTF?XEWCmI*?JAlE[ExI*AWQeCyO<I*E[ExI*AWRa`aV[R^IPAWVDE[I<VR (TFZbO<Ra`XExRa_M_MZ^VWCFRS`I*`(AWI{EWEWRS?XADOPI*E;AlZSKLCFRYKLCmPADI@K~i ?X`
EWIPADQeCFOPI[rTi Z^?LVDAWIan<\JTF?LVWSV2Ga?XIKLIAlZ^CyExRa`J`JIPAjEW?JAjTFI`JRa_sJAWIKJI_MRSJCFTmI{EPnPTyZO*Z^\XZaO<CmVWN[\-IP?LV;<VWADI
KLNPX`JCFIYO<Ra_M_(IUTFIYKLN*JCmVfSTFRSXZSTN{O<Ra?JTmNdKXZ^`XEzTFIdAWN{ExI{Z^?]\XZSAI<LI*_(\XTmIae0IU`XRS_sJADIU_MZ^LCm_4Z^T
KLIO<Ra_M_=?X`JCFO*ZVDCmRa`XEM`XIKLNP\-I*`XK\ZSE4?J`XCFGH?JI*_(I*`aV6KLI{E4ADI*EDExRa?JADOPI*E WKL?JADI*E nrEWZQ^RaCmA]KJ?
`JRa_sJAWI=KLIsO<RLKJI*EKLCyEx\RS`JCFJTFI*E*nL_4Z^CyE@Z^?XEDExC0KLI{ECm`HVWIPAWoNPADIP`O<I*E*nXKLRS`XObKLI=TFZ4KL CFExVWADCFJ?LVWCFRS`KLI
VDADZ^OYKJZ^`XETFIYADN*EWI*ZS?6I<V}KLI=ExI{EOPZSADZaOVWN*AWCyExVWCyGa?XI*E* U`6\Z^ADTmIbZ^TFRSAlEKLI P! l a<
`_MRSJCFTFI(I{EhV=OPRS?JQSIPAWVY\XZSAYTFIMAWN{ExI{Z^?BEWC[TFI*EdVWADRSCyEYOPRS`XKJCtVDCmRa`XEYEW?JCFQZ^`HVWI*E
N
EWRS-`aV@0-QSHNPADCt*X;N*I*EY
T~\-IP?LV@KLN{O<RJKLIPATmI{ECF`LoRSAD_4ZVDCmRa`XEEW?JATFIdADN*EWI*ZS?jejId_MRSXCmTFIdKJRSCmVAWI{O<I*Q^RaCmAZ^?6_MRSCF`XE
?J`EWCmfa`XZ^T~\JCFTmRSVWIbZQSI*Od?J`JI=GH?XZSTmCmVWN=Ex?L]EDZ^`aVDIS TjE*i Z^fSCmV@KLIYTyZMO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADI x\JCmTFR^VDI
;ZM\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPIbAWI{GH?JCFEWIb\-Ra?JATyZMVWAlZ^`XEW_MCFEDExCFRS`KLI=TyZ]EhVlZVWCFRS`QSIPAlE@OPIb_MRSXCmTFIbI{EhV}CF`LoN<u
ADCmI*?JADIbr4TFZ4\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<Ib_4ZLCF_MZSTmI=Kji ?J`O*Z^`XZST0KLIbVWAlZOS U`KLCmVUZ^TFRSAlEGH?JI=TFIb_MRaJCmTFI
I{EhV}O<RS?XQ^I*AxV@KJZS`XETFIbEWIP`XE@KLI*EDO<I*`XKJZS`aV*
;Z4\X?JCFEDEDZ^`XOPI=ADI*GH?JCyEWI=\RS?JAUTyZ4VDADZS`XEx_MCyEWEWCFRS`KLI(O<I_MRSJCFTFIsQSIPAlE}TFZ6EhVlZVDCmRa`KLIZSEWI
I{EhVzCF`LoNPADCmI*?JADI}rbTyZb\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<I@_MZ^LCm_4Z^TFI}K~i NP_MCyEWEWCFRS`]KL?]_MRSJCFTmIaHjI@_MRaJCmTFI}I*ExVZ^TFRSAlE
OPRS?JQSIPAWV@KJZ^`ETmI=ExI*`XE_MRS`aVlZ^`aV{
Z^`XE[TFI*EkVDAWRaCFE[O*ZSE*nTFZbO<RS?XQ^I*AxVD?JADIKji ?J`M_MRSXCmTFI@KLNP\IP`XKoRSAWVWI*_MIP`aV9KLI{E[CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EPn^KLRa`XO
KLITFZUKLCyExVWADCmJ?JVWCFRS`(KL?sVDADZ^OzKXZ^`XE;TFIADN*EWI*ZS?j{>}Cm`ExCwn?J`JIExVDZ^VWCFRS`KLIZSEWIGa?XCLEWIPAWV2-I{Z^?XOPRS?J\
KLI_MRaJCmTFI*EUQSRSCmVdEDZ]*RS`JIKLI(OPRS?JQSIPAWVW?XAWIsEWIsADN*KJ?JCmADIS-kZSAUIPeI*_M\JTmIan-KXZ^`XEUTFZ]XfS?XAWI nTyZ
ExVDZ^VWCFRS:` ~@I{EhV-I{Z^?XOPRS?J\6\JTF?XE@ODvXZSAWfaNPIdGH?JI=EWZQSRaCFEWCm`XI (VDADZSCtV@\JTFIPCF`zIPV@EDZ(OPRS?JQSI*AxVD?JAWIdI*ExV
KLRa`XOCF`LoNPADCmI*?JADIS U`\XZ^ADTmI8ZSTmRaADEKJI6ADI*EW\JCFADZ^VWCFRS`KLI*EMO<I*TmTF?JTFI*E* eCTFI6ADI*OPRS?JQeADIP_MIP`HV(Z{QSI{O
TFI*EbQSRaCFEWCm`XI*EbI{EhVsCm`Ex?L]EDZ^`aV{n;KLI*EbVWADRS?EbKLI6O<RS?XQ^I*AxVD?JADIMZS\J\XZSADZSCFEDExI*`aV*n~IPVKLI{E=Z^\J\IPTyE=ExRa`aV
ADIhghIPVWN*E*L>X`8Kji N*QHCmVWI*AO<I{E\JvJNP`XRS_MP`JI{EKLIUVDAWRa?XEKLIYO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADI}TFCFN*ErsTi Z^?XfS_MIP`aVlZVDCmRa`KJ?
VDADZ^O^nKJI*EYZ^TFfSRaAWCmVWvJ_MI{EUKLIMO<Ra`aVWADSTFIKji ZaKL_MCFEDExCFRS`BEWRS`aVY_MCFEdI*` b?JQeAWIa-;Z6O<RS?XQ^I*AxVD?JADIsI<V
TyZMOPZ^\ZSO<CmVWNbEWRS`aV}KLRS`OdKJIP?L8fSAlZ^`XKLI*?JAlE9oRSAWVWI*_(I*`aV@TFCmN*I*EKJZS`XETmI{EADN*EWI*ZS?L{  >=
g h N h

4e

rf

gf

FM

2N

M *


802

?M

N

axW< bH <9hl {HP Hl ^h= @lWl h b Lp{H l ; (xw* {{P= {^l b (D 8 D

 


$

'$

`6_(RaJCFTmIdEPi ZVWVDZSOlvJIUrsTFZEhVlZVDCmRa`GH?JCTF?JCR^ADI@TyZ=_MI*CmTFTmI*?JADIUGH?XZ^TFCmVWN
KL?bXTFCF^IP`bn AllZS;KLp-CFRHEW?J{Aj{TF-I9 OPZS`X Z^TS\JCmTFR^VDISJU?XZ^`XKd?J`b_MRaJCmTFI\XZSEDExIKji ?J`XI9O<I*TmTF?JTFI9r?X`JI9Z^?JVWADISn<CFTSQSRSCmV
u su
8

v

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


TmI\JCFTmRSVWIKLITyZ\JAWI*_MCm*AWIEhVlZVWCFRS`bE*i Z^ZSCmXTmCFA*n<I<V2O<IPTF?JCaKLITFZEWI*OPRS`XKJI[O<ADRyVWADIk\JADRSfSADI*EDEWCmQSIP_MI*`aV*
jRaADEDGH?JIsTi Cm`HVWIP`ExCmVWN]KLI*EYKLI*?L\XCmTFR^VDI*EdI*ExVbZSEDEWIPs\XAWRJODvJI8U K$ K~i N{OPZSAxVY\XZ^AYI<LIP_M\JTFI{<n?J`
TmCFIP`AlZSKLCFRI{EhV(NPVDZ^XTmCZQSI*OODvXZaO<?J`XI8KLI*E(KLIP?J O<I*TmTF?JTFI*E8QSRSCFAXfS?JADI a<20I_MRSJCFTFI6I*ExV
Z^TFRSAlEZVWVDZaODvJNYZS?L6KLIP?L8EhVlZVWCFRS`EKLIYXZaExIdI*`6_M*_(IdVDIP_M\XE*nJOPIYGH?JC~\IPAD_(IPV@KLIbO<RS_sXZ^VxVDAWI
TmI{EI<I<VlE@K~i NPQZS`JRS?XCFEDExI*_MIP`aVI<V}KLIb_4ZSEDGH?XZ^faIU\XZSAIPeI*_M\JTmI ?JADAWI*`HXZaODv P nJI<V}KLI
faZSADZS`aVWCFA?J`JIb-RS`X`JIbOPRS`aVDCm`H?XCtVDN=KLIbEWIPADQeCFOPISL0IY_MRSXCmTFIYAWI{O<RS_sJCF`JIYTFI*E@KLIP?L8ExCFfS`XZS?L6Ga?0i CFT
AWI{q<RaCtV=Z`Kji I*`I<eVDADZSCmADI(TFI4_MZ^LCm_s?J_ K~i CF`LoRSAD_4ZVWCFRS`pZ^TFfSRaAWCmVWvX_(I4KLI eS(L wp
ZS`XEdTmIMExI*`XEU_MRS`HVDZ^`HV*nTFI(_(RaJCFTmI(I*ExVdADI*qP?\XZSAUTFI*EYKLI*?LExVDZVDCmRa`XEdKLI(XZaExI
I<V}Tm4I=<ADN*EWI*HZ^ ?AWI{O<RS`EhVDCtVD?JIYTFIsEWCmfa`XZ^Tj?LVWCFTFI=IP`NPQZSTm?Z^`aV}r4OlvXZSGH?JIbCF`XExVDZ^`HV}TmI=_MIPCFTmTFIP?XA}ExCFfS`Z^T
AWI{q<?MEx?XA[TFI*EKLIP?JTFCmI*`XEZ^TFfSRaAWCmVWvJ_MIKLI@EWNPTFI*O<VWCFRS`< Z^`XE[TFI@OPZSEk\Z^AWVWCyO<?JTFCmI*A[R (TFI*EExVDZVDCmRa`XE
KLI(XZSEWI(Z^\J\Z^AWVWCFIP`J`JI*`aVYZ^?B_MP_MI(EWCmVWISn~TmI{EdZ^TFfSRaAWCmVWvX_(I{EUKLI(AWI{O<RS_sJCF`XZSCFEWRS`\-IP?XQ^I*`aVYPVWADI
?LVWCFTFCFEWN*EIP`
8

B

b

 (


r

rf

Preue
3 dB



]'zy

J Wl@l^jl = DPzy{ e={lyw DlmW






'$

,8:l.;:<1=, 365 6/k1


3+*x1 6.;: : Y.;:<1=,
Z^`XE4OPI<VWVWIEWI*OVDCmRa`jn[`JRa?XEM\JADN*EWIP`aVDRS`XEMTi RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`#KL?\XZSADZS_MN<VWAlZ^faI6KLI{EMADN*EWI*ZS?L
OPZ^VWCFRS`6~EW RS`HZ^V`XAWEYI*\J?XAD`BCFEWI*\JE*ADnHIPIP_M`6CFIP\XAbAWN{\XO<Z^CyEWAlZSZ^`afaVADZSTF\JIdvJAWISanTmIYTFI*K~Ebi ?JKL`8Cm-RSN*?LAWI*VD`aCmTjVWI{KLEYIY\J\JvTFZSZS`JEWI*CmEYOPKLZ^?cVWCFRS\J`6ADRLZSOP?LI*VWEDRaEx_4?EUZVWKLCyIMGH?J\JIYTyZ^KJ`XZ^Ct`XJEu
O<IPVxVWIsODvZ`JIS Z^`ETFI=KLI*?LLCm*_(I=\XZSADZSfSAlZ^\JvJIanHTFIb\JADRSXTm*_(I=K~i RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`I*ExV}KJN<X`JCwnXIP`
\JADN*O<CyEDZ^`aVTFI*E\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*EI<V@TmI{ERaeghI{OVDCtopE*

<

DC

FEG>-HIKJ

FC

^I

-@xA

4e

)22 

#

2xgB`

0I6\JADRLOPI*EDEx?EKLI8\JTyZ^`JCmO*ZVWCFRS`ADZaKLCFRBKLI{EADN*EWI*ZS?L \-I*?LVM<VDAWIKLCFQeCFEWN8IP`\XTm?Lu
xE CFIP?XADEsN<VDZS\-I*Es\XAWN{ExI*`aVWN*I*EEW?JATFZXfS?XAWI X i Z^-RaADKjn; TmI8KLCm_MI*`XExCFRS`X`JIP_MIP`HVMOPRS`XEWCFExVWI6r
I*ExVWCF_MIPATyZKLIP`ExCmVWNYKJIdEWCtVDI*E`JN{O<I*EDEDZ^CFAWIUrsTyZO<RS?XQ^I*AxVD?JADIUKL?VDIPADAWCmVWRaCmADI}I<VrOlvJRSCyExCFATmI{EEWCmVWI*E
u a su

4e

$ 1^ Y^@^y! l@ <e @ h

\XZSAW_MC?J`I*`XEWIP_sJTFIK~i IP_M\JTyZSOPIP_MIP`aVlEM\-RaEDEWCmJTFI*E*9zIODvJRaCtI*ExV]O<RS`HVWAlZ^CF`aV4\XZ^AMTFI*E4O<RaLVDE
K~i CF`LoADZaEhVDAW?OVW?XAWIYI<V@TFI*E@Z^?JVWRSADCyEWZ^VWCFRS`XEKji CF`XExVDZ^TFTyZVWCFRS`KLI*E@Z^`aVDIP`J`XI*E*L2Ra?JA@TFI*EAWN{ExI{Z^?L (n
TFI*ERS\-N*ADZ^VWI*?JADEODvJI*ADOlvJIP`aV}KLRS`OYr(AWN*?LVWCFTFCFEWIPA@ZS?6_4ZLCF_s?J_TFI*E@ExCmVWI{E IPLCFExVDZS`aVDE*
u

uF24

Dimensionnement
Choix de site & ngociation
Design manuel ou automatique
Paramtres antennaires : types, azimuts, tilts
Puissances des canaux communs

Implmentation de la
solution sur le terrain

JJhz H {oW d bhWWb{ Y


>@\JAD*E8OPI<VWVWIc\JADIP_MCFPADI\JvZSEWISnTFIBADN*EWI*ZS?I{EhV\XZSADZS_(NPVWADN\-RS?JAEWIPADQHCFAZ^?%_MCmI*?L TmI{E
?LVDCmTFCyEWZ^VWIP?XADE* U`6?LVWCFTmCyEWIYEWRS?XQ^I*`aVTFIUVWI*AW_MI a tS \-Ra?JAO<I<VWVWIYN<VlZ^\-Iae`8Qe?JIYKLIYADNP\-Ra`XKLADI
r6?X`JI4KLI*_4Z^`XKLI4Cm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aVDIMKLIMVWAlZOSn~Z{QSI{O?X`JIM-RS`J`XIMGH?XZSTmCmVWN4KLI]ExI*AWQeCyO<Ian-Twi RS\-N*ADZ^VWIP?XA
KLRaCtVb\XZ^AlZ^_MN<VDAWI*AUTmIMADN*EWI*ZS?KLI(opZSqPRS`Br6_MCm`XCm_MCyExI*AYTFI*EdCF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E*jzIPVxVDI(Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`
I{EhV=?J`\JADRSXTm*_(I]KLCm4OPCmTFI4I<Vs_MI<V=I*`6ghI*?KLI{E=O<I*`aVDZSCm`XI*E=KLI4\XZ^AlZ^_MPVWADI*E ~KJZS`XE=O<I]OPZaKLADISn
Twi ?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWCFRS`Kji ?J`Ra?LVWCFTjKJIb\JTFZS`JCmOPZ^VWCFRS`Z^?LVDRS_4ZVDCFGH?JIdI{EhV@\IPAWVWCF`JIP`aVDIS
i RS?LVDCmTKLI\JTFZS`JCmOPZ^VWCFRS`ZS?LVWRa_4ZVWCyGH?JIp>}zzsAWI{ODvJI*ADOlvJI4?J`ghIP?KLI]\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*EbRS\Lu
VDCm_4Z^T\-RS?XA(TFI8ADN*EWI*ZS? IPV4\-IPAD_MI<V4rBTi RS\NPAlZVWI*?JAMKLIE*i ZaKJZ^\LVDIPAMZS?_MCmI*?LrBTyZcKLIP_4ZS`XKLI
KLI=VWAlZOSX0I*E}NPQSRSTF?LVWCFRS`E@KJ?ADN*EWI*ZS?6VWI*TmTFI*EUGH?JI=Twi Cm`aVDAWRJKL?XO<VWCFRS`Kji ?J``JRa?JQSI*Z^?ExI*AWQeCyO<IanJRS?
Twi ZS\J\XZSAWCmVWCFRS`KLI*EUPRa`JI*EUKLI=oRaAxV}VWAlZ-O] X X <n\-I*?JQSIP`aVdADIP`KLAWIsTmI\XZ^AlZ^_MN<VDADZSfSIYI<LCyEhu
VlZ^`aV@`JRS`8RS\LVDCm_4ZST TjI*ExV@KLRa`XOU`JN{O<I{EWEDZ^CFAWIYK~i ZSKJZS\LVWI*ATmIb\XZ^AlZ^_MN<VDADZSfSI}IP`?LVWCFTmCyEDZ^`aV@Ti >@zk
kZSA=Z^CFTmTFIP?XADE*nCFT[I{EhVb\-RHEWEWCFJTmI4Ga?XIMTFI(\XAWRaJTm*_MIMKji Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`B`ji Z^CmVb\XZSEbKJI4EWRSTF?LVWCFRS`BfHZu
AlZ^`aVDCFEDEDZ^`aVU?J`JI(GH?XZ^TFCtVDNZaOPO<I*\LVDZSJTFI]CFT2I{EhVYZ^TFRSAlECF`XKLCyEW\-IP`XEDZ^XTmIsKJIADZghRS?JVWIPAUKLI{EUExVDZ^VWCFRS`XE
KLIbZSEWIY\-Ra?JA\-RS?XQ^RaCmA@ZSEDEx?XAWI*ATyZMO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADISnJOPIbGH?ji RS`Z^\X\-IPTFTmI=KLIP`ExCmOPZ^VWCFRS`KJ?8ADN*EWI*ZS?j
Z^`XE9TmIUO*ZSER 4Twi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`]KL?]\XZ^AlZ^_MN<VDADZSfSIZb?J`OPZSADZaOVDPADI\XTm?XE9TFRLO*Z^T0p_MRLKLCmOPZ^VWCFRS`XE
OPIP`aVDAWN*I*EMZS?LVWRa?JA4K~i ?J`EWCmVWI\XZ^AWVWCyO<?XTmCFIPAn[RS`\-I*?LV]Z^?XEDExC?LVWCFTFCFEWIPA4Ti RS?LVDCmT@KJI8\XTFZS`JCt-OPZVDCmRa`
ZS?LVWRa_MZ^VWCyGH?JISH>@CF`XExCwnHO<Ra_M_(I}TFI}_(Ra`aVWADI}TFZbXfS?JADI nSTwi >}zAWI{q<RSCmV9I*`4I*`aVWADNPI}?J`JIUOPRS`LJu
fa?JADZ^VWCFRS`Cm`JCmVWCyZ^TFI(KL?ADN*EWI*ZS?I<VdN*TFZS-RSADIb?J`AWN{ExI{Z^?RaS\L VWCF_MCFEWNSjIAWN{ExI{Z^?CF`JCmVWCyZ^T2\IP?LVd<VWADI
CyEWEW?K~i ?J`KLN*\JTFRSCFIP_MIP`aVCm`JCmVWCyZ^T9Ra? WL njRS?JCFIP`AWN{Ex?XTtVDIPAsK~i ?X`\JADRLOPI*EDEx?XEbKLIKLCm_MI*`Lu
EWCmRa`J`JI*_(I*`aV_MZS`H?JI*TRS?6IP`XOPRSADIUK~i ?J`JIbZSOVDCmRa`6KLIYKLI*`XExCmO*ZVWCFRS`0e0ZEWRSTF?LVWCFRS`6\JADRS\-RHExN*I@\XZ^A
Twi >}z#I{EhV@IP`XEW?JCmVWIbNPQ^Z^TF?JNPIanLZQZ^`HV@K~i <VDAWIYCF_(\XTmN*_(I*`aVWN*I=EW?JATFIdVDIPADADZSCm`j
 





'$

'*

?*0

*

&

rf

u SJ u

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


8

Dploiement
initial

B

b

Rseau optimis
manuellement

Densification de
rseau existant

Rseau initial

ACP

Rseau optimis

Analyse des
performances

Implmentation
de la solution

hx H S eJll{P <z h U U^ HH {oW @ ^z{{Pz [SySl D<

 





$

u aS u

$ 1^ Y^@^y! l@ <e @ h


H

b 

#2 

[t#Bl2x2b

jI@\JAWRaJTFP_MI@K~i RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`MI*ExV9KJN<X`JC-KJZ^`EO<I}GH?JCEW?JCmV\XZSATFI*E\XZ^AlZ^_MPVWADI*Ekr=Zgh?XExVWIPA
IPV@\XZ^ATmI{ERaeghI{OVWCmopE@r(RS\JVWCF_(CyEWIPA{
UJX HPe(2hm 2*pp{L*
g N 0 hj
U`BKLCyEhVDCm`XfS?JIMKLIP?JVh|H\I*EYKLI(\XZ^AlZ^_M<VDAWI{EsTFI*Ed\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*EUZS`aVWI*`J`XZ^CFADI*EUI<VYTFI*Ed\XZSADZ^u
_M<VDAWI{EEx|LExVW*_(Ia
UEWI*LO<VWRSJADCFIPTka*JTFHIdV |eJ\-~I=*eKj;i ZS2`aJVWI*p`Je`JaIS nExRa;`AWRaVDCFCmEdTmV@\XIPZSV@ADEWZSRS_M`<VWZ^AD*I*Cm_sEYOP?LZ^V{Al ZSO<VWN*AWCyExI*`aVYTi Z^`aVDIP`J`XI4K~i ?J`ExCmVWIMVWADCtu
jIV |e\-I}K~i ZS`aVWI*`J`JI@Cm` X?JI}Ex?JA9Ti N<VDIP`XKL?XIIPVTyZdoRSAD_MI@KLITyZYPRa`JIOPRS?Lu
? 99FJ~*e;2
QSIPAWVWI9\XZSA;TFZ} ExVD Z^VWCFRS`sKLI9XZaExIa TeZ@NPfHZ^TFIP_MIP`aV;?J`sIP-IPVkEx?JA;TFI*E0CF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E;O<ADNPN*I*E;Ex?JA
TFI*E[O<IPTFTF?JTmI{E2QSRSCyEWCm`JI{EP2Ra?JA[KJI*E[EWCtVDI*EkEWI*O<VWRaAWCFIPTyE0\Z^AkI<LIP_M\JTFISnRa`?LVWCFTFCFEWIKLI*E[Z^`aVDIP`J`JI{E
rsADN XI{OVDIP?JA{neGH?JC~ExRa`aVOPZ^AlZSO<VWN*AWCyExN*I*E\XZSATFZsTyZ^ADfSI*?JAKL?6TFRS-I(opZ^CyEWOPI*ZS?\JADCm`XOPCm\Z^T~KLI
TFIP?JA4KLCyZ^faADZS_M_(I8KLI8AlZ{|SRS`X`JIP_MIP`HVMKJZS`XEMKLIP?J \JTyZ^`E\IPAD\-IP`XKJCFOP?JTFZSCmADI*E* `JI8ZSEWI
KLI4GH?JI*TFGH?JI{EUV |e\-I{EbK~i Z^`aVDIP`J`JI{EbOPZS`XKLCyKJZVlEdI*ExV=KLN<`JCmI4\XZ^AD_MCkTmI{EWGH?JI*TFEYTi Z^TFfSRaAWCmVWvJ_MI
faNP`JNPVWCyGa?XIYOlvJRSCyEWCtV@TmI{EZS`aVWI*`J`JI*E*
=
VDCFjO*Z^I(TwVWCFTtV=` K~i VD?JCmTm`JVDI4ZS`aZ^V `HVWIPTi`XZ^`J`aI4VDIPO<`JRS`XADIsADI*QSEWIP\-AlRSE@`XTmKIXr8ZSExERa`BpO<IZ^`XGHfS?JTFC2I(OPK~RSi ADCF`XAWI{O<ExTF\-Cm`RaZ^`XCyExK8Ra`Br]?JKJ`JZSI`XEdZS?J?JfS`B_M\XIPTF`HZSVD`BZVDQ^CmI*RaAx` u
KLITwi ZS`JfSTFIKL?VWCFTmVl nkTFZ*RS`JI6O<RS?XQ^I*AxVDI4\Z^AsTi Z^`HVWIP`X`JI6KLCm_MCF`H?JI6IPVsTwi Cm`aVDIP`XEWCmVWN6KJI]TyZ
\J?XCFEDEWZS`XO<I_MR|SI*`J`JIADI*qP?JIKJZ^`EMTyZOPIPTFTm?JTFIZS?JfS_MI*`aVWIa9i CF` X?JI*`XO<IKJ?VDCmTmV6Ex?JA4TyZ
EW?JAWopZSO<IMO<Ra?JQSIPAWVWI(\XZ^AbTi Z^`HVWIP`X`JIMI*ExVYCFTFTm?XExVWADNPI4EW?JAYTyZXfa?JADI ~jIVDCmTmV=\-I*?LVb<VWADI
_MRLKJCtXNKLIbopZSqPRS`_(N{OPZS`JCFGH?JI6Twi ZS`JfSTFI=KJI=Ti Z^`HVWIP`X`JIODvXZS`JfSI=\JvH|L EWCFGH?JI*_(I*`aVl<nRa?KLI
opZaq<RS`6N*TmI{OVDAWCyGH?JISnLI*`6_MRLKJCtZS`aVTmI=KLCyZ^fSAlZ^_M_MIdKLIYAlZ{|SRS`J`XIP_MIP`aV@KLIYTwi ZS`aVWI*`J`JIanJEDZ^`XE
VDRS?XOlvJIPA=rEWRS`BCF`XO<TFCm`Z^CyExRa`B\JvH|LExCyGH?JIS CFTtVDIPAb?J`JI]Z^`aVDIP`J`XIM`JN{O<I*EDEWCtVDI(?X`JIMCF`aVWI*AWQSI*`Lu
VDCmRa`cve?J_4Z^CF`JI]EW?JAsExCmVWIan0O<I]GH?JC9Cm`aVDAWRJKL?JCmV=?J`OPRSLV=TFCFN]Z^?\XZ^AlZ^_MNPVWAlZ^fSI(KL?ADN*EWI*ZS?j
Z^`XE@?J`o?LVW?XA}\JADRLOlvJISnJTFZM_MRJKLCt-OPZVDCmRa`KL?8VDCmTmVUNPTFI*OVDAWCyGH?JIb\-Ra?JAWAlZPVWADIbI<I*OVD?JNPIr
KLCyExVDZ^`O<IS
i Z^`JfaTmIUK~i Z^*Cm_s?LV@O<RSADADI*EW\-RS`XK4rsTi RSADCFIP`aVlZVWCFRS`KL?6TFRS-IU\JADCm`XOPCm\Z^TKLIUTwi Z^`aVDIP`J`JI
x p0x
KJZS `XE} TFIs\JTyZ^`vXRSADCm*RS`aVlZ^Tw hKLN{Z^TFIP_MIP`aV{n-KXZ^`XE}?J`BEWCtVDI=VDAWCmu EWI*O<VWRaAWCFIPTwnXTi RSADCmI*`aVDZ^VWCFRS`KLI{E
ZS`aVWI*`J`JI*E=I{EhVExN*\XZ^ADNPI4KLI JI /KJ `JI_(RJKLCmOPZ^VWCFRS`KLI]Twi ZS`JfSTFI]K~i Z^PCF_s?LVs\-I*?LVs<VWADI
?LVDCmTFI=EW?JCtVDIbr(?J`8IP-IPV}KLIY_4ZaEWGH?JIY TFCmN=Z^?8\XZ{|LEDZ^fSIURa?rMKLI*E VWCF_MIP`aVlEPnGa?XC~\-I*?JQSIP`aV
O*Z^?XEWIPA@KLI*EADN XIPLCmRa`XEIPV}KLI*ECF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{ECm`KLN*EWCmAlZ^XTmI{EP
ULJa*HMe jP{e -
b2p{*OPXRS;`XaEWCFKJNP2ADeN(E KJ kZSp`XEdX{Twei RSx \LVD Cm_M;ZYCyEWZ^\XVW?JCFRSCFED`jEDjZ^`X0OPZ6I}\JKL?X?CFEDOPEWZ^ZS``XZ^O<TXIM\J\JCFTmCmRSTFR^VWI}VDIMI*ExCm`XVzKJTmIUCFGHEW?JIPI4?JTZ^\X?cZS_MADZSRS_MJ<CFTFVWI(ADI@TFZEW|eOPExIPVWTF*Tm?J_MTFII
r4TyZSGH?JI*TmTFI=CmT2KLRaCtVdEWI=AlZVxVlZSOlvJIPA{nJIPTFTFIsKJN<X`JCmVdKJIsOPI<VWVWI=opZSqPRS`Twi N<VWI*`XKL?JI(KLIsTFZO<IPTFTF?JTmIa
`oRa`XOVDCmRa`KLI{E(\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI*E(KLI*E(\JCFTFR^VWI{EADI*q<?XI*E*n;TFI6_MRaJCmTFIKLN*OPCFKLIrcO<RS_sJCFIP`KLI
ExVDZ^VWCFRS`XEYCFT9EWIPAlZ6ADZ^VxVlZSODvXNSnjO<I]GH?JCADIP`XKB\RaEDExCFJTFI(TFZ_MRSJCFTmCmVWN]KXZ^`XEbTmI4AWN{ExI{Z^?cK~i ?J`JI
\XZSAxV{nLI<V@TFIYADIP`LoRaADOPIP_MIP`HVKJ?8TFCFIP`8AlZSKLCFRMK~i Z^?JVWADId\Z^AWV*
Y

2)

-)

=M

&)

 xp

-)

u S su

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


8

B

LNMPO

b

Lc/O

L_ O

bW^ {D D hUW^ DDpSP@{^l} pl E { Ys={ 1 dD<JDFHPx (h


g  j h~ h 4 {e^*U M2xm ;{p *L{p-
0I*ERSLghI*O<VWCmopE@KLIbTi RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`EWRS`HVTFI*EEW?JCmQ^Z^`aVlEY
EWZ^VWCyEhopZSCmADIYTmI{E@RSLghI*OVDCtopE}KLIsO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADIY\RS?JA@TmI{E@KLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEUExI*AWQeCyO<I{EI<V}TFI*E@KJCtNPADIP`aVlE
O<Ra`aVWIPHVDI*Eb
n n *PD
_ 4ZLCm_MCyExI*ATyZMLOPSZ^{\ZS O<CmVWcNbKL ? ADN*EW I*SZS{?
KLCF_(I*`XEWCmRa`J`JIPA9TmI{E[*RS`JI{EKLI@_4ZaO<ADR^u KLCmQSI*ADEWCtVDNSn^KLI}_MZS`JCFPADI@rbZSEDEx?JADIPA[TyZ=O<RS`HVWCF`H?JCmVWNUKLI
ExI*AWQeCyO<I
Z^_MNPTFCFRSADIPATyZMGH?XZSTmCmVWNbKLI=EWIPADQeCFOPIMa UR J
_MCm`JCF_MCFEWIPATmIdOPRSLVTFCmNYrsTwi CF_M\JTmN*_MIP`aVlZVWCFRS`8KLIdTFZExRaTm?LVDCmRa`j `6O<RaLVN*OPRS`JRa_MCFGH?JIUI*ExV
ZSEDExRJO<CFNdrMOlvXZSGH?JIdV |e\-I=KJIY_MRLKLCmO*ZVWCFRS`8KJIb\XZ^AlZ^_M<VDAWIa
KLI*`JE=I]O<oADRaCmVW`XPOADVDI*CmEYRa` I<V=OPRSTyZ6LV(opZSZ^q<faRaAW`N*fSKLI{I4Z^`aTmI{VbEbTFI*ZSEsfSADRSNPLfSghI*I*AdO<VWKJCmNPopE6\-I*`XO<ADKLCtIPVD`HPADVsI*ElKLdI4\TFZIPAWEhVWVDCF`JADZ^IPVW`aN*VlfSEsCFI(I*Ex_MVCF?LEWVWIMCFTmI*CyEW`cNPISRLkIP?JjQeI6ADIODvJ\RaZ^Ct A
Ti RS\NPAlZVWI*?JA{0kZSA(I<LIP_M\JTFISnk\-RS?JA(TFI8O<ADCtVDPADI6KLI8OPRS?JQSIPAWVW?XAWIan;TmI{E\JADCmRaAWCmVWN{EZSOPOPRSAlKLNPI{EsZS?L
KLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEEWIPADQeCFOPI*EbCF` X?JI*`aVMEW?JAsTFI6ODvJRaCtKJI*EsEWIPADQeCFOPI*E=rRa\LVWCF_MCFEWIPA{ I]opZSq<Ra` ExCF_MCmTyZ^CFADISn
TmIO<RS_M\JADRS_MCyE@EWRS?JvXZSCtVDNbIP`aVDAWIsTyZ4OPRS?JQSI*AxVD?JAWIbIPVUTFZ]OPZS\XZSOPCtVDNbCF`aVWI*AWQeCFIP`aVdKJZS`XE@TmIODvJRaCtKLI*E
O<ADCtVDPADI*EI<VTFIP?XADE\-Ra`XKLN*ADZ^VWCFRS`XE*
]' )
<:P7 Y.2:<1=,
3 g* =1=/2:l.
, .;r: qM5 3
=,8 :
7 b.;:<1=, =5.;1
b.;r: qM5
0I\JADCF`XO<CF\-IfSNP`XNPAlZ^T}KLITwi Ra?LVWCFTUKLI\JTFZS`JCmOPZ^VWCFRS`Z^?LVDRS_4ZVDCFGH?JII{EhV8KLN*OPAWCmVEW?JATyZcJu
fS?JADI X `Z^TFfSRaAWCmVWvX_(IfSN*`JN<VDCFGH?JI@fa?JCyKLI?X`JI}fSNP`XNPAlZVWCFRS`4KLI@ADN*EWI*Z^?JQSIPAlE[?J`JIUEWRSTF?LVWCFRS`
fSTFRSXZSTmI]O<RaAWADI*EW\-RS`KJZ^`aV=r?J` RS\LVDCm_s?J_ faTmRaXZ^T9RS? r?J`RS`Ra\LVWCF_s?J_ TmRJOPZST ODvXZaGa?XI
CtVDNPAlZVDCmRa`jnH?J`6NPQZSTm?ZVWI*?JAADZS\JCFKJIdKLIUADN*EWI*ZS? OPZ^TyO<?XTmIUTFI*EKLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEO<ADCtVDPADI*EKLIYGa?Zu
TmCmVWNMGH?JCk\-IPAD_MI<VWVWIP`HVYKLI x`JR^VDIPA TFI*EU\XZSADZS_MN<VWAlZ^faI*E@KLI*EdADN*EWI*ZS?L8\XAWRa\-RaEWN*E*X`Ex?JCmVWIanTwi >
?LVWCFTFCFEWIbOPI*E h`JRSVWI{E I<V@\JADRS\-RHExId?J``JRS?XQ^I{Z^?ghIP?KLIb\XZ^AlZ^_M<VDAWI{Ez\-Ra?JATmIbAWN{ExI{Z^?j
 
8

 -

^$

s

Fs

ts

5 s

&)

C=C=>

lIKA

> zA>-

|=IKJ

<

=<

=J

>^A

CG>-A

FM

u

M

u a u
v

$ &i;H W dW ^*p @al ^Y @H {oW @ ^


Algorithme
Gntique

Nouveaux jeux
de paramtres

Evaluation des
critres de qualit
Evaluateur
rapide

 

eJDlYS l Jz ^p a9H oW @ ^

W

8$

Chromosome BS1 BS2 BS3 BS4

4HS{ a@hzoell^FkSPy{@y Hh^YhWx


v

 

G

BSN

Rglage=(type d'antenne, tilt,


azimut, puissance pilote)

Gne

!$

?

z

2RS?JAb_MI<VxVDAWIMIP` b?JQeADITi > (njTmI4O<RLKXZ^fSIKLIMTwi CF`LoRaAW_4ZVDCmRa`I*ExVYAWN{Z^TFCFEWN(KLI(TyZ6_MZS`JCFPADI


WE ?JCFQZ^`HVWI8-?X`cOlvJAWRa_MRaEWRS_MIO<RSADADI*EW\-RS`XKr?X`ghIP?c\XZ^AWVWCyO<?JTFCFIPAYKLI(\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*EUKL?BADN*EWI*ZS?j
zvXZaGH?JIOlvJAWRa_MRaEWRS_MIzI{EhV9OPRS`XExVWCmVW?XN@KLI\JTF?XExCFIP?XADE[fS*`JI*E* `4fSP`XIO<RaAWADI*EW\-Ra`XKsZS?(\XZ^AlZ^_MNPu
VDADZSfSIsK~i ?X`JIExVDZ^VWCFRS`KLIXZSEWI=\XZSAxVDCFOP?JTmCFPADI O^i I*ExVdKLRS`Ob?X`GH?XZSKLAD?J\JTFI<VdO<RS`HVWIP`Z^`aVdTmI=V |e\-I
K~i Z^`HVWIP`X`JIb?LVWCFTFCFEWNPIanJEWRS`6VWCFTtV{nExRa`8ZSPCF_=?JV@I<V@TyZ\X?JCFEDEDZ^`XOPIYKJ?OPZS`XZ^T~\JCFTFR^VWI]Xfa?JADI H<
?u

ts

G

F2&Bqtx2!@ B



; j 0epe^{p-
i RS\-N*ADZ^VWIP?XAYKLI]EWNPTFI*OVDCmRa`cOPTFZaEWEWCyGa?XIMKLI
I*ExVb?JVWCFTmCyExNanjfaZSADZS`aVWCyEDEWZS`aV
Twi ZaOPOPAWRaCFEDExI*_MIP`aVKL?`JRS_sJADIbKLI*ECF`XKLCFQHCyKL?XE@\-wIP AW*oaRSAD_45 Z^`a VlEW^KJLIbmPfSNP `X NPAlZVWCFRS`6IP`8faNP`JN*ADZ^VWCFRS`j
g ; hj h N -p{HH~
jIbOPAWRaCFEWIP_MI*`aVO<TyZSEDEWCFGH?JIYOPRS`XEWCyEhVDIYrMOlvJRSCyExCFAZSTmN{ZVDRSCFAWI*_(I*`aV?J`Cm`XKJCFOPIbKLI=ExVDZ^VWCFRS`KJZ^`XE
TFI]ADN*EWI*Z^?0n~IPVrN{ODvXZS`JfSI*A=TFI*E=\XZ^AlZ^_MPVWADI*EbKLI{EsExVDZVDCmRa`XE=KLI\XZ^AWV=IPVK~i Z^?LVDAWIKLIOPI4\RSCF`aV*n
OPRS_M_MIdTFIb_MRS`aVDAWIYTyZXfa?JADI {
zI<VxVDIRS\-N*ADZ^VWCFRS`KLI(OPAWRaCFEWIP_MIP`HV}\-IP?JVd<VWADIsAWN{Z^TFCFEWNPI=IP`BKLI*?L\-RSCF`aVlEUKL?BODvJADRS_MRaEWRS_MIan
OPIGH?JCLOPRS`XEWCFExVWIrUN*ODvZ^`JfaIPA2TFI*E2ADNPfSTyZ^faI*E;KLI{EkExVDZ^VWCFRS`XE2OPRS_M\JADCFEWI*E2IP`aVDAWIKJIP?LsCm`KLCFOPI*E[ODvJRaCFEWCFE
ZSTmN{ZVWRaCmADIP_MI*`aVbfS?JADI <
g h

76

u Sa u

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


8

B

b

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

{ 4Jy xl@l^;ls}H ^

 

$

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

BS 1 BS 2 BS 3 BS 4

BS N

4Jy Wl@l^;lb }e ^y
zI{E(KJIP?L IPeI*_M\JTmI{EMKLIO<ADRSCyEWIP_MIP`aVlEs`XI8\JADIP`J`JI*`aV4ZS?XO<?J`XI6CF`LoRSAD_4ZVDCmRa` I*`OPRS`XEWCFKJN<u
ADZ^VWCFRS`Ex?XAUTFZ\JADR{LCF_MCtVDNsfSN*RSfaADZS\JvJCyGa?XI=KLI*EdKLCm-N*AWI*`aVWI{EdEhVlZVDCmRa`XEPn-\J?JCyEDGa?XITmI{E}CF`XKLCyO<I{EdKLI*E
EhVlZVDCmRa`XE}KJZ^`XE@TFI WODvJADRS_MRaEWRS_MI `JI=ADNPQS*TmI*`aV}\XZaE@TFIP?JAlE@\-RaEWCtVDCmRa`XEADIPTyZVDCmQSI*E* T2EWIPAlZ^CmV@\JTF?XE
gh?XKLCyO<CFIP?L~n\-Ra?JA;`XR^VWADI9\XAWRaJTm*_MIS nK~i N*OlvXZ^`XfSIPA;TFI*EkO<RS`JXfS?JAlZVDCmRa`XEjI*`aVWADIKLI*?LsODvJADRS_MRHExRa_(I{E
\-RS?XAz?J`XId_MP_MIdPRa`JIdKL?6ADN*EWI*ZS?j `JId_MN<VDvJRLKJIdKLIbO<ADRSCyExI*_(I*`aVfSN*RSfaADZS\JvJCyGa?XI@I*ExV\XAWRa\-R^u
ExN*I=KJZ^`E I*?J`JCFIPA w T;E*i ZSfSCmV}KLIsODvXRSCyExCFA}K~i Z^-RaADK8?J`ExCmVWIKLI=_4Z^`JCFPADI=Z^TFN*Z^VWRaCmADISn
I<VUKji N{ODvXZS`JfSI*A@TmI{E@AWN*<fS TyZ^^fS I{E KLIbVDRS?LVDI*E@TFI*E}ExVDZ^VWCFRS`XE}O<Ra`aVWI*`H?JI{E}KJZS`XE@?J`O<I*ADOPTmIsZ{|aZ^`HV@\-Ra?JA
O<I*`aVWADIbO<IbEWCmVWI=ODvXRSCyExCwnLI<V}KLIbADZ|SRS`8KLRa`J`JNSnXGH?JCj\-IP?LV@TF?JC0Z^?XEDEWC~<VWADIY_MRLKLCmXNbKJIdopZSqPRS`Z^TFN*Z^u
VWRaCmADIMfS?JADI ^
 

76

F 4

 /

Chromosome 1

Chromosome 2

Zones d'change



MJy WD}D^ aW ay<H ^




u a u
6

'

8$

$ "hDF
Choix de la
station
BS1 BS2 BS3 BS4

BSN

Ensemble de rglages
possibles
Rglage 1
Rglage 2

Choix du
rglage

Rglage k


P# PLly0} U H0l= =lz

B

$

; j 8 0{L*
i RS\-N*ADZ^VWIP?XA=KLI6_s?LVDZ^VWCFRS`Z^fSCmVsI*`KLIP?J\JvXZaExI{E]XfS?XAWI < TODvXRSCyExCmV(K~i ZS-RSAlKcTFI
faP`JIYrs_MRJKLCtIPA{neOSi I{EhVWu r^u KJCmADI}TFZ(ExVDZ^VWCFRS`8KLIdXZaExIanH\X?JCFE?J`8\XZ^AlZ^_M <VDAWIdKLIYOPI<VxVDIYExVDZVDCmRa`8KLI
XZaExIa
g h N

G



``2

xz

 ?

i NPQZSTm?ZVWCFRS`BKLI{EdCF`XKLCFQeCFKL?EdI*ExVbAWN{Z^TFCFEWNPI\XZ^AY?J`c_MRLKL?XTmIMKji
KLI
TyZGa?Z^TFCtVDNKLI{E}AWN{ExI{Z^?L8AlZSKLCFR jzI_(RJKL?JTFIs\-IPAD_MI<VdKJIsADN*]Z^6 TF^CyEx I*A@w?Jp` fSAl Z^`XwKlw`XGFPRSX_s JADI
KLI6EWCm_s?JTyZVDCmRa`XE=IP` \-IP? KJI4VDIP_M\XE*n2O<I6GH?JC9\IPAD_(IPVKLI6O<Ra_M\XZ^ADIPA=TFZGH?XZ^TFCmVWN6KLI*EsAWN{ExI{Z^?L
\-Ra?JA?X`8faADZS`XK`JRa_=XAWIbKLI=O<RS`JXfS?JAlZVDCmRa`XEKLCm-N*AWI*`aVWI{EP
jRSAlEbKLI]Ti NPQ^Z^TF?XZVDCmRa`jnjTmI{Eb\JADCm`XOPCm\Z^TFI*EbfSAlZ^`XKLI*?JAlEYK~i ?J`ADN*EWI*ZS? n0VWIPTFTFI*EsGH?JI4TmI{E
\J?XCFEDEWZS`XO<I{E \XjCF` ;I<V R `XjCF` ;(KLI{E_MRSJCFTFI*E*n2TmI{EMOD vXZSAWfaI*E=IPV(TFI*E(CF`aVWI*AxoNPu
ADIP`XOPI*E*neEWRS`aVOPZSTFOP?JTmN*I*EzI*`VWI*`XZ^`aV@O<RS_M\LVDIYKLIdTyZ(KLCFExVWADCFJ?LVWCFRS`8KL?6VWAlZOUKJZS`XETmIdADN*EWI*Z^?0neKLI
TyZb_4ZSOPAWRSu KLCFQSIPAlExCmVWNanSKL?OPRS`aVDAWaTmI}KLIUODvZ^ADfSISnSIPVDO^JzI*EzKLCm-N*AWI*`aVWI{E9faADZS`XKLIP?XADE[CF`aVDIPADQHCFIP`X`JIP`aV
KJZS`XETFIbOPZSTFOP?JT0KLIYTyZoRS`XO<VWCFRS`KLI=OPRSLV{
]1' 0 ;5 l. Y.
@RS?E;KLN{O<ADCmQSRa`XE0KJZS`XE;O<IPVxVDIz\XZ^AWVWCFI9?J`sI<LIP_M\JTFIK~i Z^\J\JTFCyOPZVDCmRa`=KJI9Twi > r@Twi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`
K~i ?J`ADN*EWI*ZS? ;0I4AWN{ExI{Z^?cN<VD?XKLCFN]I*ExVsOPRS`XExVWCmVW?XN]KLIJ EhVlZVWCFRS`EbKLI]XZaExIanjEW?JAsKLI{E
EWCtVDI*EbVWADCmu EWI*O<VWRSADCFIPTyEMfS?JADI H TI{EhV(OPZ^AlZSO<VWN*AWCyExN(\XZSA=?J`I*`HQeCmADRS`X`JIP_MIP`HV=vJNPVWN*AWRafSP`XISn
u S bu


4e

4e

<?@ > A

x@

u

4e



q* [

+*

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


?JADXZ^CF`IPV WKLI*`XExI6?JADXZ^CF` n;I<V(?J`VWAlZO]CF`JvJRS_MRafSP`XISn2GH?JCI{EhV(\JTF?XE(KJIP`XEWI8KJZ^`EsTFZ*RS`JI
KLIoRSAWVWIMKLIP`XEWCmVWNMKLIMEWI*OVDIP?JAlE(pPRS`XI(r8KLADRSCmVWI(EW?JAdTyZ]Xfa?JADI{ `BAWN{ExI{Z^?CF`JCmVWCyZ^TwnRS\JVWCF_(CyEWN
_4Z^`H?JI*TmTFIP_MI*`aV*nHI{EhVCm`HVWADRLKL?JCmVzIP`]I*`aVWADNPIdKLI}Twi >@zkL0ZYVDRS\-RafSAlZ^\JvJCFIQZSTmTFRS`X`JNPIan^QeCyExCFJTFIUEW?JA
TFZXfa?JADISnLADIP`XK6TFZ(V aODvJI=KLIYTwi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`8_4Z^`H?XIPTFTmIb\XZ^AWVWCyO<?JTFCFPADIP_MIP`aV@KLCm]O<CFTmIa
2Ra?JA}OlvXZSGH?JI=ExVDZ^VWCFRS`KLI=XZaExIaneVDAWRaCFE\XZ^AlZ^_MPVWADI*EEWRS`HV@Ra\LVWCF_MCFEWN*EbXTmIbV |e\-IsK~i Z^`aVDIP`J`JIan
ODvJRaCFEWCj\XZ^AD_MC0ExCm8ZS`aVWI*`J`JI{E@OPZS`XKLCyKJZVDI*E*nLTFIYVWCFTtVUI<V}TmI{E\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<I*E@KLI{E@OPZS`XZ^?L6\JCmTFR^VDI*E*nXEWRSCmV
L; c\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*E]Z^?#VWR^VlZ^TU\-RS?JQ^Z^`aV<VDAWI_MRLKLCmXN{E]\XZSA]Ti > ( Z^`XE6O<I<V6I<LIP_M\JTFISnz`JRS?XE
Ex?X\J\-RaEWRS`E4Ga?XITmI{EZ^PCF_s?LVDEKLI{EZ^`aVDIP`J`JI{EEWRS`aV]JLN*E*n9TmI{E]QZ^TFIP?XADE4N<VlZ^`aVCF_M\-RaEWNPI{EM\Z^A
KLI*EsO<RS`HVWAlZ^CF`aVWI{E=KLIO<RSvZ^JCmVDZ^VWCFRS`ZQ^I{OMTFI]AWN{ExI{Z^? I<LCyEhVlZ^`aV{jkRS?JAs?J`\JADRSXTm*_(I]KLI
O<IPVxVWIVlZ^CFTmTFISnSTi > OPRS`HQSI*AWfaIIP` K YvJIP?XAWI{EkIP`HQeCFAWRa`MEx?XA[?J`JI}EhVlZVWCFRS`4KLIVWAlZ{Q^Z^CFT sLzI
VWI*_(\E[K~i Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`OPRS?JAWV2I{EhV[RSLVDIP`H?jn^Kji ?J`XI\XZSAxVkfS1A SOPIzZ^?JsZ^TFfSRSADCmVWvJ_MI*E;?JTmVWAl Zu ADZS\JCyKLI*E
K~i NPQZSTm?ZVWCFRS`KL?ADN*EWI*ZS?jnXGa?XCjoRS`HVUGH?JIsTmIbVDIP_M\XEUK~i N*QZSTm?XZ^VWCFRS`KLI=TyZMoRS`XO<VWCFRS`KLIsOPRSLVUI*ExV
\XZ^AWVWCyO<?XTmCFPADIP_MIP`HVYO<RS?XAxV{nIPVbK~i Z^?LVDAWI\XZ^AWVdfS1A SOPIsZS?\XZ{|LEDZ^fSI6 ^ P X YKJITwi I{Ex\ZSO<I(KLI*E
ExRaTm?JVWCFRS`XE*
8

B

b

FM

?u

uF&4

?u

[


* 8
0

;lkDP}W@ W p{ hCWx#} Hc <6SP eb0D lR Waph [hD^[ pPp2xl {*W l[ Q{wpPk[}DD pD yPl @{l^Wz p^l2y PDD{ eDh 2{D{


 



#9

t

'

$

Y

?

^$

9i > _MRJKLCtIUTFI*E\XZSADZS_(PVWADI*EzKLIdTyZs\JTF?J\XZSAxVKLI{EExVDZ^VWCFRS`XEKLIUZSEWISLi Cm_M\XZaOVKLIdTwi Ra\Lu


VWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`Ex?XATmI{EVDCmTmVDE}KL?ADN*EWI*Z^?6I{EhV@\JADN*EWIP`aVDNbEW?JATFZ(XfS?XAWI Xe2Ra?JA@TmIbAWN{ExI{Z^?6CF`JCtVDCFZST
I*`]`XRSCFAl<nHTmI{EVDCmTmVDEK~i IP`eQHCFADRS`]TyZs_MRSCmVWCFNdKLI*EZ^`aVDIP`J`XI*EzRa`aV?X`JIUQZSTmI*?JAzCFKJIP`aVDCFGH?JIaneOPIdGH?JCEWI
VWAlZSKL?XCtV\Z^A?J`8\JCFOdCF_M\-RSAWVDZS`aVZ^?8OPIP`aVDAWIbKLIYTi vJCyEhVDRSfSAlZ^_M_MIS I{EVWCFTtVlEN*TmI*Q^N{E\-I*AW_MIPVxVWI*`aV
K~i ZSEDEx?JADIPA9TyZO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADIUKJZ^`XEzTFIUAWN{ExI{Z^?jH0I*EzADN*EW?JTmVDZVlEzKL?ADN*EWI*ZS?4Ra\LVWCF_MCFEWNU_MRS`aVDAWI*`aVGa?XI
TmI{E}VWCFTmVDEYKJITyZ\JTF?J\XZ^AWVYKLI{EdZ^`aVDIP`J`XI*EdRS`aVYN<VDN(Zgh?XExVWN{EP`BI<I<V{nTyZ6O<RS_sJCF`XZ^VWRSCFADIsCF_(\RSAWu
u a u
u

$ "hDF

VlZ^`aVDIKLI*E]OPRS`LfS?JAlZVDCmRa`XEVWI*ExVWN*I*E4\XZ^A4Twi > KLRa`J`JITFCmI*?rc?J`#vJCyEhVDRSfaADZS_(_MI8NPVDZSTmNa I{E


ADN*EW?JTmVDZVlE9ExCF_MCmTyZ^CFAWI{EEWRS`aV9RaLVWI*`H?XE9\-RS?JA9TFI*E9\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI*EKJI*E9O*Z^`XZS?L\XCmTFR^VDI*E@aNPVDZSTmI*_(I*`aVKLI
Twi vXCFExVWRafSAlZ^_M_MIUIPV@AWN{KL?XOVDCmRa`8KJIbTFZ(\JTF?J\XZSAxV}KLI*E\J?XCFEDEWZS`XO<I{EKLI*EO*Z^`XZS?L\JCFTFR^VWI{EP
?u

90

Nombre de stations

80
70
Rseau initial
Rseau optimis

60
50
40
30
20
10
0

Tilt ()

E2 D Hy@@@  F9^YhWxb p {D={ t@l2^YhxWd<e @ WQl a G


i Zgh?EhVDIP_MIP`aV=KLI{EUVDCmTmVDE*njKLI*EY\J?JCyEWEDZ^`O<I*EYKLI*EYOPZS`XZ^?J\JCFTmRSVWI{EdI<VbTmIMOlvJRSCmRS\LVDCm_4Z^T[KLI{E
ZS`aVWI*`J`JI*E4OPRS`XKJ?JCFEWIP`HV]rc?J`JIAWN{KL?XOVDCmRa`KJI*EMCF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{E(I<Vrc?J`JIRa\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`KJI8TyZ
ADNP\XZSAxVDCtVDCmRa`KJ?VWAlZOsIP`aVDAWI(TmI{EdExVDZVDCmRa`XEdKLIZSEWI(KL?ADN*EWI*ZS?j~zI<VWVWI(_MIPCFTFTmI*?JAWI?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWCFRS`
KLI{EsADI*EDEWRS?JAlO<I{EbADZaKLCFRExIVDADZaKL?JCmV\XZSA?J`fHZ^CF`CF_M\-RSAWVDZS`aV(KJI8OPZ^\ZSO<CmVWNIPVMKLI8GH?XZ^TFCtVDN8KLI
EWIPADQeCFOPI=RS-I*AxV{ Z^`XEdOPI(GH?JCkEW?JCtV{nTFZ6GH?XZSTmCmVWN(KL?BAWN{ExI{Z^?RS\LVDCm_MCyExNI{EhVdN*QZSTm?JN*IsIPVdTwi ZS\J\-RaAxV
KLIbTi RS\JVWCF_(CyEDZVWCFRS`8I*ExV}Z^`Z^TF|eEWNS


^$

<

2x2bz

[&

0ZsOPZS\XZSOPCtVDN@I*ExVz?J`CF`XKLCyOPZ^VWIP?XAO<IP`HVWAlZ^T-KLIUTyZ=AWI*`aVDZSJCmTFCmVWNUKji ?J`ADN*EWI*ZS?jnSIPVzIPTFTFIUKLRaCtV<VWADI
N*QZ^TF?JN*IbZ{QSI{ObEWRSCF`jJ2Ra?JA}?J`EWIPADQHCyO<Ib?J`JCyGH?JISnXTyZ4O*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNYI{EhVU\JAWRa\-RSAWVWCFRS`X`JIPTFTmIbZ^?`XRS_sJADI
KLI]_MRSJCFTFI*E=EWIPADQeCFE*~2RS?XA=?X`cVWAlZ-OM_=?XTtVDCtu ExI*AWQeCyO<Ian~Ra`\-I*?LV=?JVWCFTmCyExI*AsEWRSCmV=TmIKLNPXCtVsfaTmRaXZ^Twn
EWRSCmV4TFI8VlZ^?LKLIVDADZS`XEx_MCyEWEWCFRS`XE(ADNP?XEDExCFI*E*[2Ra?JA4TFI_MRLKLI\XZaGH?JI<V{n9KLI*E4JCmVDE4I*AWADRS`XN*EMExRa`aV
ADI<VDADZS`XEx_MCyEP
jI*EzXfS?JADI*E I<V \JADN*EWIP`HVWIP`HVKLIUopZSqPRS`6EW|H`HVWvJNPVWCyGa?XIUTwi N*QSRSTF?LVWCFRS`6KLIUTyZKLIP_4ZS`XKLI
I*`VWAlZ-O\-RS?JQ^Z^`aJV] <VDAWIEWSIP ADQeCmIIP`oRa`XOVDCmRa`KL?#VDZS?L#KLIEWZ^VWCyEhopZaOVWCFRS`#\-RS?JA]TFI*EExI*AWQeCyO<I{E
g ;~ dI<V@QSRSCmAWI{Ex\I*OVDCmQSI*_(I*`aV*
jI=\JAWRJKL?JCmV}KJIbTyZ4KJIP_4Z^`XKJIbI*`VWAlZOYIPVUKL?VDZS?LKLIsEWZ^VWCyEhopZaOVDCmRa`8CF`XKLCyGH?JI=TyZ4OPZS\XZSOPCtVDN
KL?ADN*EWI*ZS?j2Ra?JA=?J`cVDZ^?JBKJI]EWZ^VWCyEhopZaOVWCFRS`KLRa`J`JNSnjTyZOPZS\XZSOPCtVDN4KL?AWN{ExI{Z^?BRS\JVWCF_(CyEWN4Z^?Xf^u
_MIP`HVWI}KLZI Ka C IP`eQHCFADRS`(\XZ^A[AlZ^\J\RSAWVkZS?(AWN{ExI{Z^?CF`JCmVWCyZ^TJ\-Ra?JA[TFIEWIPADQHCyO<ZI g ;~ anI<V9KLIb* C
\-Ra?JAUTFI(ExI*AWQeCyO<IsQSRSCmi RS\JVWCF_(CyEDZVWCFRS`BZ]N<VDNI<I*O<VW?JN*I\-Ra?JAU?J`cExI*AWQeCyO<IsOPCmJTFIvXZS?LVYKJNPJCmV*n
OPIYGH?JCIPe\XTmCyGH?JIdTFIdfaZSCm`6\JTm?ECm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aVRSLVDIP`H?8\-Ra?JATFIYEWIPADQeCFOPI  n~ SejIYAWN{ExI{Z^?]Ra\LVWCmu
_MCyExNO<Ra`XKL?JCmVdrKLI{E}faZSCm`XE@ADIPTyZVDCtopEUOPRS_M\XZ^AlZ^XTmI{EI*`OPZS\XZSOPCtVDN=\-RS?XAUKLCm-N*AWI*`aVDEU`JCFQSI*Z^?JKLI
u S su

7pa

7pa

^pra

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


KLIP_4ZS`XKLIIP`MVDADZ^O^HzI@AWN{Ex?JTmVDZ^VI*ExVCF_M\-RSAWVDZS`aV9OPZSA[CFTX_MRS`aVDAWI@TFZYADRSX?XEhVDI*EDExIKLI@TyZbEWRSTF?LVWCFRS`
RSLVDIP`H?XIY\XZSATi > QeCFExu r^uwQeCyEKL?8VWAlZOS
8

B

b

?u

700

Rseau optimis

500

Demande en trafic

600

Rseau initial

400
300
200
100
0
100

98

96

94

92

90

Taux de satisfaction (% mobiles servis)



J D{@pyjl p b^b bh l }e; [Wl D lQs& =^


l

7

$

2500

Demande en trafic

2000
Rseau initial
Rseau optimis
1500

1000

500

0
100

98

96

94

92

90

Taux de satisfaction (% mobiles servis)

a D{yl p b^b bh l }e; [Wl D l x



=<

2x2bB

$

`2tB

0IUAWN{ExI{Z^?4RS\JVWCF_(CyEWNU\-IPAD_MI<VKLIU_MCFIP?L]?LVWCFTmCyEWIPATFI*EzADI*EDEWRS?JAlO<I{E[ADZaKLCFRsKJCFEW\-RS`XCmJTFI*E*H2RS?JA
?J` _MP_MIVWAlZOSnO<I<VWVWIB_MIPCFTFTmI*?JAWI?LVDCmTFCyEWZ^VWCFRS`%ExIVWAlZSKL?JCmV6\XZ^A6?X`JIXZSCFEDEWIKLITyZODvXZSAWfaI
_MR|SIP`J`XIKJI*E6ExVDZVDCmRa`XE6KL? ADN*EWI*ZS?#Ra\LVWCF_MCFEWNS `HQSI*ADEWIP_MIP`HV*n\-RS?JA6?J` `JCFQSI*ZS? KLIcODvXZSAWfaI
KLRS`X`JNSnJTmIbAWN{ExI{Z^?6Ra\LVWCF_MCFEWNY\-I*?LV@N*OPRS?JTFIPA\JTF?XEKJIYVWAlZOSJ0Z(QZSAWCyZVDCmRa`6KLIYVWAlZOdN*OPRS?JTFNYIP`
oRS`XO<VWCFRS`KLI6TyZOlvXZ^ADfSI]_MR|^I*`J`JI8KL?AWN{ExI{Z^? I*ExV(\JADN*EWIP`aVDNPI6EW?JA(TmI{E=fS?JADI*E IPV
u su

r6

$ "hDF

9i ZS_(N*TmCFRSAlZVDCmRa`8KXZ^`XE@TFIsExI*`XE I{EhV}\Z^AWVWCyO<?JTFCm*AWI*_MIP`aV}Cm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aVDISnX`JRSVDZ^_M_MIP`HV}faA aO<I=r


Twi Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`8KJI*E\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI*EKLI*E@OPZS`XZ^?L\JCFTmRSVWI{EP
(

350
300

Trafic servi

250
200
150
100
Rseau initial
Rseau optimis

50
0

10

20

30

40

50

Charge DL (%)

 

8y^9Wl DJD l = dl{P H D<#

r$

350
300

Trafic servi

250
200
150

Rseau initial

100

Rseau optimis

50
0
0

10

15

20

25

30

35

Charge UL (%)

 

8yzWl DLl = Yl{P a {lc?#


v

u X u
6

g$

40

J{Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


8

=<

B

b

2x2bB&B2Bx

&& Bzz#2B

9i Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`8KL?AWN{ExI{Z^?6I<V@TFI*EfHZ^CF`XEI*`OPZ^\ZSO<CmVWNbExRa`aVNPVWADRSCmVWIP_MI*`aV@TmCFN*ErMTFZ(ADN*KL?Ou
VWCFRS`BKLI{E}CF`aVWI*AxoN*AWI*`XO<I{EP T2I{EhVYKLRa`XOs\XZSAxVDCFOP?JTmCFPADIP_MI*`aVUCF`aVWN*AWI{EWEDZ^`HVdK~i RSXEWIPADQSIPAUTmI{EUO*Z^TyGa?XI*E
K~i Cm`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*EdKXZ^`XEdTFIADN*EWI*ZS?j-0I*E}fS?JADI*E Z4IPV \JADN*EWIP`aVDIP`aVbTmI{EUCF`aVDIPAWoNPADIP`XOPI*E
Cm`HVWIPAWu O<IPTFTF?JTFZSCmADI*EMKLI*EMAWN{ExI{Z^?L Cm`JCmVWCyZ^TIPV4Ra\LVWCF_MaCFEW N8ADI*EW\-I*SO<VW CFQ^I*_MIP`aV{jI*EM`JCFQ^I{Z^?LKLIfSADCyE
O<RaAWADI*EW\-RS`KLIP`aV9ZS?LM\J?JCyEWEDZ^`XOPI*E9K~i Cm`HVWIPAWoNPADIP`O<I}AWI{q<?JI{E}XfS?JADI a O*<a0I}O*Z^TyGH?JI@\JTF?XEzO<TyZ^CFA
KL?BADN*EWI*Z^?Ra\LVWCF_MCFEWN_MIPVYI*`BNPQeCyKLIP`XOPI(TyZADN*KL?OVWCFRS`BCm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aVDI(KJI*EdCm`HVWIPAWoNPADIP`O<I*EdCF`aVWI*Axu
O<I*TmTF?JTyZ^CFAWI{EP-;Z]XfS?JADI K_MRS`aVDAWI(GH?JITyZ\JADRS\-RaAxVDCmRa`KLI(Ex?XAxopZaO<IsvZ^?LVDIP_MIP`aVbJAWRa?JCFTmTFNPI
I*ExVADN*KL?XCtVDIbKLIYopZSq<Ra`8OPRS`XaEW CyKLNPAlZ^JTFIYKJZ^`XETFIYADN*EWI*Z^?6RS\LVDCm_MCyExNa

LNMPO

Lc/O

Iinter < -75 dBm


-75dBm <= Iinter < -60 dBm

-60dBm <= Iinter

10

% Surface
Iinter>-60dBm

20

Lgende :

Rseau initial

L_O

Rseau optimis

L\/O

H;lN M ahD  ^h<^Wl l^ ptlDlsllDl1h ^D dwlD W {z hSUP^{ hp WWl^4 h Y{B D 4{llh@M^{6hpWlx@l^P e{py @^ W dlh b1 lD#l
 
b

=< G

 ^$





^$

2x2b#O2&2

;ZO<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADIKL?ADN*EWI*ZS?I{EhVYEDZVDCFExopZ^CmVWI\-RS?XAUTFIAWN{ExI{Z^?Cm`XCtVDCFZST2IPVdTFIADN*EWI*Z^?RS\JVWCF_(CyEWN
\-RS?XAUTFI*EdKJIP?LExI*`XEdKLI(TmCyZ^CyEWRS`IPVd\-Ra?JAdTmI{E}VWADRSCyEUEWIPADQeCFOPI*E}NPVW?XKLCFN*E(QSRSCm~ngI<VM] n~ a
u a u
^pa

r6

$ "hDF

9i ZS`XZ^TF|LExIKJI*EAWN{Ex?XTtVlZVDEk_MRa`aVWADI@GH?JITmI@ADN*EWI*Z^?(I*ExVTFCm_MCmVWN}KJZS`XE[TmI}ExI*`XEKLI*EDO<I*`XKJZ^`HV} S/[
\-RS?JA6TmI{GH?JIPTd?J`JIB\XZ^AWVWCFIKLIBTFZEW?JAxopZaO<II{EhV8IP` TFCF_(CmVWIcKLIBOPRS?JQSI*AxVD?JAWIaz;Z
OPRS ?JQSIPAW(VW?XAW I \-Ra?JA]TFIExI*AWQeCyO<I] g ;~ KLI{E4ADN*EWI*ZS?LCm`XCtVDCFZST}I<V6RS\LVDCm_MCyExNI{EhV6\JAWN{ExI*`Lu
VDNPIEW?JA]TmI{E(XfS?XAWI{E ZIPV AWI{Ex\-I{OVDCmQSIP_MI*`aV*9jI{EM`JCmQSI{Z^?LKLIfSADCFEMAWI*\JAWN{ExI*`aVWI*`aV
TFI*Eb\X?JCFEDEDZ^`XOPI*EbKLI{E=OPZS`XZ^?LcKLIMVWAlZOM`JN*OPI*EDEWZSCmADI*Ed\-Ra?JAsZVxVDIPCF`XKLADIM?J`_MRSJCFTmI4TFRLO*Z^TFCFEWNMIP`
?J`\RSCF`aVXfS?XAWI O*<j0I]KJN*OPZSTFZSfSIMQSIPAlEbKJI*EbVWI*Cm`aVDI*EO<TyZ^CFAWI{EY\-Ra?JA=TmI]AWN{ExI{Z^?cRa\LVWCF_MCFEWN
CFTmTF?XExVWADI}Twi ?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWCFRS`6Z^_MN*TmCFRSADNPI}KLI*EAWI{EWEWRS?JAlO<I{EkAlZSKJCmRH0Z=\JADRS\-RaAxVDCmRa`4KLIdEW?JAWopZSO<I}I*`]TFCF_(CmVWI
KLI(OPRS?JQSI*AxVD?JAWIsI{EhVd\JADN*EWIP`HVWNPI(Ex?XAUTyZ4Xfa?JADI K~;ZEW?JAWopZSO<IsI*`TFCm_MCmVWIMKLI(O<Ra?JQSIPAWVW?JADIZ
\JAlZVDCFGH?JI*_MIP`aV}KLCFEW\XZSAW?Ex?XATmIbAWN{ExI{Z^?6RS\JVWCF_(CyEWNS

&3

^pra

6

6

r6

6

LNMPO

Lc/O

% Surface en limite
de couverture

Lgende :
PDL < 28dBm
28dBm <= PDL < 31 dBm
31dBm <= PDL

9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0

Rseau initial

LN_O

Rseau optimis

L\/O

@D lWO1  1 #} eH^DDDzhDhS hW#6l^plh[dWW{({ 0= }yW ^z}SePy h dbhhx;WD] {lhpz{?ld  @[ bzhWW^WDMDPe 


 

6

 ^$

^$

< =<

2x2bz[`

z[&

Y x

0Z@\JADRSXZSJCmTFCmVWN9K~i ZSO*O<{E0Z^?sAWN{ExI{Z^?YI{EhV2?J`=CF`XKLCyOPZ^VWIP?XA;Cm_M\-RaAxVlZ^`aV2K~i Z^`XZSTm|LEWI9KLIzTFZ}GH?XZ^TFCmVWN


KLIExI*AWQeCyO<IYRS-I*AxVDIS `_MRSJCFTFI=\-IP?JVUZSO*O<N*KJIPA}Z^?ADN*EWI*ZS?EPi CmT0I{EhVUOPRS?JQSI*AxV}IP` I<V}I*`
u su
(

6

J {Hpp[}daje @ p UhWW hc e Y { h S*@h alp ^h


\XZ^A?J`OPZ^`Z^T-VDADZ^OUIPV\Z^ATFI*EO*Z^`XZS?LO<Ra_M_=?X`XEPJ;ZXfS?JADI =\JAWN{ExI*`aVWIYTyZ\JADRSXZSJCFTmCmVWN
K~i ZSOPOP*Ek\-Ra?JA[TFIEWIPADQHCyO<IQSRSCmZQ^I{O?J`XI_MZSAWfaIKLI\-N*`JN<VDADZ^VWCFRS`MKLIb;$ ZghRS?LVDNPI@Z^?L(Z~Z^Cmu
JTFCFEDExI*_MIP`aVlEUKL?BEWCmfa`XZ^Tw~zI<VWVWI_4Z^ADfSI=\-I*AW_MI<VYKLI\JADIP`XKJAWI=I*`BO<RS_M\LVDIs?J`BZ^ZSCmJTFCyEWEWIP_MIP`HV
Ex?X\J\JTFNP_MIP`aVlZ^CFAWIbO<RSADADI*EW\-RS`XKXZ^`aVrTyZ\-N*`JN<VDADZ^VWCFRS`8rTwi Cm`aVDNPADCmI*?JA@KLI{EC VDCm_MIP`HVDE*J0Id`XCmQSI*ZS?
KLI=fSADCFE@KLI*E@_4Z^CFTFTmI{EAWI*\JADN*EWIP`aVDIbTFZM\JADRSZ^JCFTmCmVWNYfS?JAlZ^`aV}EW?JA@TyZMTFNPfSI*`XKLIXfa?JADI O{X0Z
\JADRS\-RaAxVDCmRa`KLI(VWI*AWADCtVDRSCFAWI(Z|aZ^`aVY?X`JIM\JAWRaXZ^XCmTFCtVDNMK~i ZSO*O<*EdCF`LoNPADCFIP?JADI(r -ACZ8OPRS `XEWCyKLNPAlZu
JTFIP_MIP`aVKLCF_MCm`H?XNSL;ZsOPRS_M\XZ^AlZ^CyEWRS`4KLI*EEx?JAWopZSOPI*EzZ{QSI*O}?J`JId\JAWRaXZ^XCmTFCtVDNUK~i ZaOPOP*EzCm`LoN*AWCFIP?XAWI
r -AC I*ExV@\JADN*EWIP`aVDNPIbEx?XATFZXfa?JAWI K~
8

B

b

LNMPO

Lc/O

Lgende :
5

0,9

<= Paccs < 0,98

<= Paccs < 0,9

% Surface
Paccs<0,98

0,98 <= Paccs < 1

4
3
2
1
0

Rseau initial

L_O

Rseau optimis

L\/O

Q H l ;D h DleSW1 hD-WDy ^{l jW hU[{l h@eell ^=hHW W2]~ D {? l2 Dll[ej^y b{p W W p40 Pel }h2 WE m l1 (#
9i NPVW?XKLI4KLI(OPI<VYIPLIP_M\JTFI(Z6\-IPAD_MCFEYKLI(_MI<VWVWADII*`BNPQeCFKJIP`XOPITwi ZS\J\-RaAxVUoRS`XKJZS_MIP`aVlZ^T[KLI
Ti RS\JVWCF_(CyEDZVWCFRS`6\-RS?XATwi Z^_MNPTFCmRaADZ^VWCFRS`6KLI{E\-I*AxoRaAW_4Z^`O<I*EK~i ?J`8ADN*EWI*ZS?je0Z\JTyZ^`JCmO*ZVWCFRS`8ZS?Lu
VWRa_MZ^VWCyGH?JI4\-IPAD_MI<VKLI]_MCFIP?Lc?LVDCmTFCyExI*A=TFI*E=ADI*EDExRa?JAlO<I*EdAlZSKLCFRKJCFEW\-RS`XCmJTFI*E*n0KLI6KLCm_MCF`H?JI*AsTFI
`JCFQ^I{Z^?K~i Cm`HVWIPAWoNPADIP`O<I*EkKJZ^`XE2TmIAWN{ExI{Z^?jnK~i Z^?Jfa_MIP`aVDIPAkEDZ}O*Z^\XZaO<CmVWNzI<V[K~i Z^_MNPTFCFRSADIPA;TyZUGa?Z^TFCtVDN
KLIbEWIPADQeCFOPIS
u u
 

! 



8

 ^$

^$

r6 v

! 





$tssel <W

]'p

=1 ,67 <5 0:<1s,


zIUODvZ^\JCmVWADIUZKLN*OPAWCmVzTwi ?JVWCFTmCyEWZ^VWCFRS`KJIUTi Z^TFfSRaAWCmVWvJ_MI@faNP`JNPVWCyGH?JI}\-Ra?JA9Twi RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`KLI{E
ADN*EWI*ZS?L L9i ZSTmfaRSADCtVDvJ_MI}fSN*`JN<VDCFGH?JIdZgh?XExVWIdTFI*E\XZ^AlZ^_MPVWADI*EzZ^`HVWIP`X`XZ^CFAWI{E9IPVTFI*E\J?XCFExu
EDZ^`XOPI*EdKJI*EYO*Z^`XZS?L\XCmTFR^VDI*EYKJI*EYExVDZ^VWCFRS`XEYKLIMXZaExIMKL?BADN*EWI*ZS?jjIM`JRS_sJADIMKLI(\Z^AlZ^_M<VDAWI{E
rRS\LVDCm_MCyExI*AQZ^ADCFI}V |e\JCyGa?XIP_MIP`aV@IP`aVDAWIbGa?XIPTyGa?XI*EKLCF*Z^CF`JI{EzIPV\JTm?ExCFIP?JAlEO<I*`aVDZSCm`JI{EP `8NPQ^Zu
TF?XZVDIP?JAIP]OPZSOPIYZ(N<VDNbKLN*Q^I*TmRa\J\-NYZ^X`KLIb\-IPAD_MI<VWVWADIdTmI=OPZSTFOP?JTVWAD*EAlZ^\JCyKLIYKJI*EO<ADCmVW PADI*EKLI
GH?XZSTmCmVWNKL?sAWN{ExI{Z^?=r@\XZ^AWVWCFA2KLI{EWGH?JI*TFE0TyZoRa`XOVDCmRa`sKLIO<RaLV;I{EhVkOPZSTFOP?JTmN*ISjIzfSAlZ^`XKY`JRa_sJAWIKLI
\XZSADZS_M<VWADI*E[rYRa\LVWCF_MCFEWIPAzK~i ?X`JI@\XZSAxV9I<V9TmI*?JA9Cm`HVWIPAlKLN*\-IP`XKXZ^`XOPI@K~i ZS?LVWADI@\XZ^AWVAWI*`XKLI*`aV9TFI@KLNPu
QSIPTFRS\X\-IP_MIP`HV@KLI{EExRaTm?LVDCmRa`XEZSEWNPI*EEx?XAKLI{EvJI*?JADCFExVWCyGH?JI*EKLN<VDIPAD_(CF`JCyEhVDI*E\XZ^AWVWCyO<?XTmCFPADIP_MIP`HV
KLCm]O<CFTmIbIPVoRa`aV}KJIYTwi ZSTmfaRSADCtVDvJ_MIdfSN*`JN<VDCFGH?JIY?J`RS?JVWCFT~JCFIP`ZaKJZ^\LVDNbr(OPIY\JADRSXTm*_(Ia
i RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`KL?AWN{ExI{Z^?B\-I*AW_MI<VsK~i Z^_MNPTFCmRaAWI*AbO<RS`ExCyKLNPAlZ^XTmI*_(I*`aVbEWI*Eb\-IPAWoRSAD_4Z^`XOPI*E
I*`BVWI*AW_MI*EbKJI4OPZS\XZSOPCtVDNSnjKLI4OPRS?JQSIPAWVW?XAWI(I<VsKLI]GH?XZ^TFCtVDN4KLI4EWIPADQeCFOPIS2RS?XAb?J`AWN{ExI{Z^?BCF`JvJR^u
_MRSfaP`JIank?J`XI8Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFI8I{EhV]I<eVWADP_MI*_(I*`aV]KLCm4OPCmTFIrc_MIP`XIPA{n[I<V4TFI*EMfHZ^CF`XE
ZS\J\-RSAWVWN{E[\XZSA9?J`JIURS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`Z^?LVDRS_4ZVDCFGH?JIUExI*AWRa`aV9\JTF?XEzNPQeCFKJIP`aVlEPH`\XZ^AWVWCyO<?XTmCFIPA{nS\-Ra?JA
KLI{E@ADN*EWI*ZS?L8ZQ^I{Ob?J`VWAlZO=Cm`JvXRS_MRSfaP`JIanXKLI*E}I*`HQeCmADRS`X`JIP_MIP`HVDE@vXN<VWN*AWRafS*`JI*ERS?Z{QSI*Ob?J`JI
VDRS\-RafSAlZ^\JvJCFIQZSTmTFRS`X`JNPIan~Ti RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`c_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFI4I*ExVb\XZSAxVDCFOP?JTmCFPADIP_MI*`aV=KLCm]O<CFTmIa;jI*E=EWR^u
TF?LVWCFRS`ERa\LVWCF_4Z^TFI*E@EPi NPTFRSCFfS`XIP`aV}K~i ?J`\XZSADZS_MN<VWAlZ^faIUvXRS_MRSfaP`JIbI<V}TmI{EfHZ^CF`XE@K~i Ra\LVWCF_MCFEDZVDCmRa`
RaLVWI*`H?XE\XZ^ATwi ZSTmfaRSADCtVDvJ_MIUfaNP`JNPVWCyGH?JIbEWRS`aV@\XZ^AWVWCyO<?XTmCFPADIP_MIP`HVCF_M\-RSAWVDZS`aVDE*
CF`XZSTmI*_(I*`aV*nLTwi RS\LVDCm_MCyEWZ^VWCFRS`8KL?6ADN*EWI*ZS?]\Z^ATi Z^TFfSRaAWCmVWvX_(IUfSN*`JN<VDCFGH?JId\IPAD_(IPVK~i Z^_MNPTFCFR^u
ADIPATyZ(GH?XZ^TFCtVDNYKLI{EADN*EWI*Z^?J4RS\JVWCF_(CyEWN*E_4ZS`H?JIPTFTFIP_MIP`aV@I<V@KLIYADN*KL?JCFADIUTFIdVWIP_M\XE`XN*O<I{EWEDZ^CFADIdr
OPI<VxVDId1V SODvXIYADNP\-NPVWCmVWCFQ^IY\-Ra?JATFI*EIPL\-IPAWVDEADZaKLCmRL0IdfHZ^CF`6IP`8\IPAWoRSAD_MZS`XO<IYEWIUVDADZaKL?JCmV@Z^?XEDExC
\XZSATyZ(ADN*KL?OVWCFRS`8\-Ra?JATi RS\NPAlZVWI*?JAKLI{ECF`HQSI*ExVWCyEDExI*_(I*`aVDE@IP`8CF`LoAlZSExVWAD?XOVD?JAWI{EP
{

> =@

u H u
6

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi