Mateo, Alberto Nel R.

Balonso, John Justine A

O0B

1. Utilitarian
Right: Justine argues that Ms. Dylan is right in the context of Utilitarianism
because she had successfully pursued her happiness by gaining pleasure in sexuality
and having money to continue her studies.
Wrong: Nel argues that Ms. Dylan is wrong because she only pursued her
own tentative happiness but not the happiness of all which refers to the greater end of
Utilitarianism.

2. Kantian View (Categorical Imperative)

Right: Nel argues that Ms. Dylan is right in context to the Categorical
Imperative because her act can be a universal law because having sex to earn money
is already legal in some places and it is still done on other places even it is prohibited
by their law.
Wrong: Justine argues that Ms. Dylan is wrong because she didn't act in
treating human beings as an end in itself that she had a thought that all men would
accept her condition on the basis of money.

3. Nietzcheian (Master and Slave Morality)

Right: Justine argues that Ms. Dylan is right in context of Master and Slave
Morality because she considers herself as a noble who is the creator of her own
values. Thus, her bidding for her virginity is good because she is the one who
determines that her actions were right and good.
Wrong: Nel argues that Ms. Dylan is wrong because she became a slave of
power which is called money in our times. She despises those people who have
money but didn't use it in a right way like gambling. Thus, she was deceived by it
which makes her act to the point of even selling her virginity making her think that it
is the one that may free her to the chain power of money.

4. Aristotelian (Golden Mean)

Right: Nel argues that Ms. Dylan is right in context of the Golden Mean
because she used her intellectual virtue in order to figure out how she can have
enough money for her studies. Thus, her actions were good because it brings her
happiness which is to gain money and not the sexual pleasure itself.
Wrong: Justine argues that Ms. Dylan is wrong because she have forgotten to
include the concept of moral virtue. It's for the reason that she only acquire her perfect
intellectual virtue and forgotten to find the mean of the moral virtue. Thus, she didn’t
attain the greater happiness that is prescribed in the Golden mean. It would only cause
a little amount of it because intellectual virtue alone is not suited in the environment
of humanity.