Opinion Editorial - Peer Review

Prep Sheet
Your name:
Peer Review Partner:
Instructions:
Please fill out this worksheet and bring it with you to your peer review
conference.
First, read through the entire paper, ignoring local issues (punctuation,
grammar, MLA) and focusing on the global issues (kairos, audience, thesis
statement, well-supported claims, counter-arguments, etc.). Then answer
the following questions.
1. What is the main claim?

2. Who is the audience?

3. Were any parts confusing or not sufficiently supported by

evidence?

4. Are there any counterarguments that are missing?

5. Does the writer make use of pathos, logos and ethos? Is it

particularly effective or ineffective in places?

Your partner should have written three questions for you to consider when
reviewing their paper. Write your answer to these questions here so that
you can discuss them during the peer review:

Any last comments on MLA, punctuation, grammar, or spelling can be made

here: