Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
http://petrotimes.vn/news/vn/anh-clips/ve-dep-the-gioi-nhin-tu-tren-ca o.html
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 2
CONTENT
Guiding Principles
& Objectives
Case Review
that
being
development,
to
for
name a few.
that
seek
support
and
public
and
maintain
sustainability
of
engagement,
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 4
FUNCTION
Regardless of income
level open space
provides public
recreation opportunities
that are both accessible
and of low cost to the
city as a whole. Often,
many issues of childhood
illnesses and obesity are
linked to fewer acres
of open space. Open
space can help areas of
high levels of density, poverty, youth and seniors overcome issues of social
equity. Particularly, when examining Tucsons current urban heat island
issues, due in large to masses of unshaded impermeable surfaces, we must
begin to look at the benefits of open space and urban tree canopy that
have a multitude of benefits.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 5
ECOLOGY
Ecology is the interaction and relationship between living
and non-living organisms in the physical environment.
Ecology can benefit open space by preserving natural
elements such as native plants, habitat, wetland, riparian
areas, hydrology and patch/corridor connectivity .By
maintaining biodiversity ecology will aid in creating a
multi -functional open space design.
ECONOMY
Open spaces such as parks and
recreation areas can have a positive
effect on nearby residential property
values, and can lead to proportionately
higher property tax revenues for local
governments.
The
level
of
economic
impact
recreational areas have on home prices
depends on how far the home is located
from a park, the size of the recreational
area and the characteristics of the
surrounding neighborhood.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 6
NATIONAL PARKS
NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS
Size: 5 to 20 acres
Population Served: 3,000 to
10,000
Definition: The neighborhood
park is the basic unit of the park
system and should be within
walking distance of the
neighborhood homes. Serving
as the recreational focus of the
neighborhood, the park should
achieve a balance between
informal active and passive park
uses.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 8
PLAY GROUNDS
Size: less than 5 acres
Population Served: 500-3,000
Definition: Mini parks are small pieces of parkland
meant to serve a residential or business area within a
one-quarter mile radius. Due to their limited service
potential and maintenance inefficiencies their
acquisition and development should be limited.
Location and Access: One potential area of
importance for the development of mini-parks is to
create pockets of park development along trails and
greenbelt corridors. In general, these parks serve a
passive need and normally do not require vehicular
parking.
Appropriate Use: Passive recreation.
POCKET PARKS
Size: less than 5 acres
Population Served: 5003,000
Definition: Mini parks are small pieces
of parkland meant to serve a residential
or business area within a onequarter
mile radius. Due to their limited service
potential and maintenance
inefficiencies their acquisition and
development should be limited.
Location and Access: One potential
area of importance for the development
of miniparks is to
create pockets of park development
along trails and greenbelt corridors. In
general, these parks serve a passive
need and normally do not require
vehicular parking.
Appropriate Use: Passive recreation.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 9
PLAZAS
PETAR ZORANI
SQUARE AND IME
BUDINI PLAZA
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 10
ECOLOGY
CORRIDORS
Corridors
are
generally
linear landscape elements
that are defined on the basis
of structure and function.
Corridors are sometimes
isolated narrow strips which
are usually attached to a
patch of similar vegetation
type.
PATCHES
Patches are
relatively discrete
areas in shape,
spatial expanse
and period areas
of relatively
homogeneous
environmental
conditions. In
the landscape
perspective, patches create patterns in which smaller elements are
composed of habitat, agriculture fields, forest stands, highways just to name
a few.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 11
NETWORKS
TRAILS
SIDEWALKS
Sidewalks are one of the most important elements to
establish an open space network. When a city is lack of
sidewalks, people is not going to walk from place A to
place B even when the distances are shorter. Tucsonans
say that they would be willing to walk more if there
were more shaded sidewalks. This plan encourages
the increase of canopy in our neighborhoods and the
major roadways.
BIKE BATHS
GREENWAYS
Definition: Greenspaces are small
parcels of preserved open space
including street medians and
streetscapes that increase the
perception.
Location and Access: The location of
the greenspace would be opportunity
based with access from interconnecting
trails, sidewalks, or low-volume
residential streets.
Appropriate Uses: If passive recreation
facilities exist, appropriate
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 12
UNDERUSED
PARKING LOTS
Tucson has a great number of parking lots.
Sadly this means that the impervious surface
in the region area is significant. Impervious
surfaces represent a threat to our environment,
especially to our water resources. Impervious
surfaces increase water runoff. We must
reduce the number of parking lots in our metro
area. This open space plan envisions parking
lots as vegetated areas, shaded areas where
people can take advantage of a micro
climate setting. The benefits of transforming
parking lots into one of the many types of
open spaces could reduce negative impacts
to our environment, like climate change and
water quality.
VACANT LAND
GOLF COURSES
GOLF COURSES a large open
space design specifically for
golfing, may include water
feature , trails for the golf carts,
structures (club house) .
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 13
Currently Tucsons existing open space is 50% lower than the national average.
With 12.2 acres per capita, Tucson trails behind with 6.2 acres per capita.
Although we have an abundance of beautiful national parks and state parks,
literally in our backyard, Tucson has a major surplus of vacant and underutilized
land. The purpose of this open space plan is to develop a network of greenways,
trails, and washes that connect Tucsonans to existing nodes of park space and
future park nodes created from the vacant lots. (kaboom.org/bestpractices)
Currently Tucsons existing open space is 50% lower than the national
average. With 12.2 acres per capita, Tucson trails behind with 6.2 acres per
capita. Although we have an abundance of beautiful national parks and
state parks, literally in our backyard, Tucson has a major surplus of vacant
and underutilized land. The purpose of this open space plan is to develop a
network of greenways, trails, and washes that connect Tucsonans to existing
nodes of park space and future park nodes created from the vacant lots.
(kaboom.org/bestpractices)
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 14
2. SENSE OF PLACE
4. CONNECTIVITY
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 15
7. SUSTAINING STEWARDSHIP
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 16
Encourage the dynamic and flexible use of existing open spaces and
promote a variety of open space uses, where appropriate.
Prioritize renovation in highly-utilized open spaces and in high needs
areas.
Preserve existing open space by restricting its conversion to other uses
and limiting encroachment from other uses, assuring no loss of quantity or
quality of open space.
Maintain and repair open spaces to modern maintenance standards.
Support public art as an essential component of open space design.
Support urban agriculture and local food security through
development of policies and programs that encourage food production
throughout Tucson.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 18
Local biodiversity protect, preserve and restore ecological communities such as freshwater, wetland, riparian
area, grasslands and landscaped design. The purpose of this project is to restore and enhance the remainder of
the existing natural areas of the site, as well as developing an integral plan for the community. When open space
and parks are being revitalized, the developers have to come up with a new vacant space which is categorized
as environmentally sustainable. Therefore, new building and recreational features should protect and restore local
biodiversity. Depending on the open space, suitable criteria should be applied in the sensitivity of habitat (wildlife),
proposed function of the space, and the new addition of the renovated space. Some of the requirements that have
to be applied to the new addition and renovated space includes:
Water conservation, recycling/ reuse and storm water mitigation.
Soil conservation - being able to use local soil by a balanced cut and fill system in order to minimize the cost
of transporting soil into or away from the site.
Energy production and efficiency -new or revitalized open space can be used as energy efficient source
(solar panels).
Native and drought tolerant plant. Planting native species to natural areas.
Lighting. - Recreational lighting should be environmentally efficient to provide safety and security to the park
users and protect wildlife in natural areas.
Habitat and wildlife. Design spaces that provide habitat for local and migrating wildlife.
Construction and siting- using local materials, services and supplies.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 19
CASE REVIEW
FRONT YARD
WASHINGTON, DC
Owner: District of
Columbia
Designer|Architect:
M. Paul Friedberg &
Partners
Rick Parisi, Managing
Principal
Size: 5.7 acres
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 20
THE BUFFER
A 5 mile buffer was clipped around
the Tucson city limits. This was to
insure that some of the existing links
to other cities such as Marana and
Sahuarita are considered in this
plan. The following image shows
Tucson, the southern tip of Marana
and the northern tip of Sahuarita,
all of which are located in Pima
County.
Legend
cities_buff_clip
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 21
CIRCULATION
The following maps illustrate the current
circulation of vehicles, people and water
throughout Tucson. Tucson boast and extensive
network of streets, bike paths, trails and washes.
The system functions very much in a gridded
fashion, with the trail, wash and bike systems
running in some cases diagonally. These
paths usually follow the existing topography
and natural systems. There is a great level of
connectivity around the city. However, the
streets of Tucson are large extensive paved
surface that lack street trees, the bike paths
simply run along these major roads and place
bikers in extreme circumstances both in regards
to the weather and safety.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 22
STREETS
Legend
st_maj
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 23
BIKE ROUTES
Legend
bike_rte
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 24
BUS ROUTES
Legend
busstops
st_maj
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 25
TRAILS
Legend
trails_buff_clip
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 26
WASHES
Legend
wash_buff_clip
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 27
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 28
PARKS
Legend
park_rec_buff_clip
PARK_TYPE
COUNTY
FEDERAL
MUNICIPAL
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
STATE
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 29
HABITAT
Legend
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
habitat_buff_clip
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 30
POTENTIAL
Vacant lots are the most underutilized
areas of open space. Consisting of
parcels on which there are no permanent
structures, vacant lots can be repurposed
into functional spaces for public
engagement.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 31
VACANT LAND
Legend
2.5
7.5
vac_land_dissolve
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 32
Miles
10
IN SEARCH OF A SOLUTION
SUITABILITY
MODEL
PROCEDURE
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 34
MODEL
The following suitability model was developed. After analyzing the created model, the next step
in this process was to ground truth. Specific areas were selected to examine at a closer scale,
in an effort to understand specific design decision that may or may not be made based on the
suitability model.
Legend
suitability
<VALUE>
50 - 70
70 - 90
90 - 105
105 - 125
125 - 140
140 - 150
150 - 170
170- 180
180 - 195
195 - 215
215 - 250
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
The two specific areas chosen from the suitability model were based on large nodes of were
suitable areas were identified and larger network extensions where suitability was identified. These
two areas included downtown Tucson and the Rillito River.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 35
Legend
suitability
<VALUE>
suitability
<VALUE>
50 - 70
50 - 70
70 - 90
70 - 90
90 - 105
90 - 105
105 - 125
105 - 125
125 - 140
125 - 140
140 - 150
140 - 150
150 - 170
150 - 170
170- 180
170- 180
180 - 195
195 - 215
180 - 195
215 - 250
195 - 215
215 - 250
2.5
7.5
0.05
0.1
Miles
0.2
0.15
Miles
10
tucson_buff
0.05
0.1
0.15
Miles
0.2
For downtown, an increase in urban tree canopy was suggested. This will provide for greater
human thermal comfort will walking along the streets of downtown, reduce urban heat island
and enhance habitat for bird and other desert urban wildlife.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 36
Legend
suitability
suitability
<VALUE>
<VALUE>
50 - 70
50 - 70
70 - 90
70 - 90
90 - 105
105 - 125
90 - 105
125 - 140
105 - 125
140 - 150
125 - 140
150 - 170
170- 180
140 - 150
180 - 195
150 - 170
195 - 215
170- 180
215 - 250
0.1
0.2
0.3
Miles
0.4
180 - 195
195 - 215
215 - 250
2.5
7.5
Miles
10
tucson_buff
vacant_land_dissolve
park_rec_buff_clip
PARK_TYPE
COUNTY
FEDERAL
MUNICIPAL
STATE
vacant_land
washes
tucson_buff
0.1
0.2
0.3
Miles
0.4
The Rillito River area was retro fitted with a few pocket parks to add amenities along exiting
trails.
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 37
CONCLUSION
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 38
a career in the built environment field. Edlin earned her Bachelors degree in
Architecture from the Sonoran-Desert city of Hermosillo, Sonora, Mexico. The
Masters Planning Program at University of Arizona, College of Architecture,
Planning, and Landscape Architecture allows her to expand her knowledge in
her field of interests, such as urban planning, urban design, and architecture.
Edlin is passionate about enhancing the spatial character of places of the
communities, by achieving a balance between art and the environment with
its available resources.
KENDRA HYSON
ESTEFANIA VASQUEZ
YANG YANG
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 39
REFERENCES
PAGE 2
Images :
Petro Times, (2013), Cnh ng hoa tulip, H Lan. [ONLINE]. Available at: http://
petrotimes.vn/news/vn/anh-clips/ve-dep-the-gioi-nhin-tu-tren-cao.html
[Accessed 07 April 14]
PAGE 6
Images:
Turenscape, (2013), Qunli Stormwater Wetland Park [ONLINE]. Available at: http://www.
archdaily.com/446025/qunli-stormwater-wetland-park-turenscape/ [Accessed 07 April 14]
Nipic.com, (2014), - [ONLINE]. Available at: http://pic4.nipic.com/20090821/2155056_
205450005_2.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Text:
AmericanTrails.org. 2010. Economic Benefits of Trails. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.
americantrails.org/resources/economics/Economic-Benefits-Trails-Open-Space-WalkableCommunity.html. [Accessed 07 April 14]
PAGE 7
Images:
Wikipedia, (2014), National Park Service Logo [ONLINE]. Available at: http://
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US-NationalParkService-ShadedLogo.svg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Cabin Fever Chronicles, (2010), - [ONLINE]. Available at: http://cabinfeverchronicles.
files.wordpress.com/2010/06/img_1825.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Text:
Wenku.baidu.com. 2014. Play Okc. [ONLINE] Available at: http://wenku.baidu.com/
view/e8454e9184868762caaed553.html. [Accessed 07 April 14]
PAGE 8
Image:
Farm6, (2014), Static [ONLINE]. Available at: http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5540/126921
87533_983330a795_o.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
PAGE 9
Image:
Rome.info 2003. St Peters Square (Piazza San Pietro) [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.
rome.info/squares/st-peters-square/ [Accessed 07 April 14]
Fabijani, Damir. (2014) [ONLINE]. Available at: http://www.archdaily.com/?p=478606
[Accessed 07 April 14]
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 40
Text:
Morris, N. Openspace: the research centre for inclusive access to outdoor environments.
(2003) [ONLINE]. Available at: http://www.openspace.eca.ac.uk/pdf/healthwellbeing.pdf
The Trust for Public Land. (2014). Economic & health benefits. [ONLINE]. Available at: http://
www.tpl.org/economic-health-benefits
PAGE 10
IMAGES
Lab Russells(2012), Lte Aerial view [ONLINE]. Available at: http://lab.russells.wisc.edu/
cullenlab/files/2012/03/lte_aerialview
PAGE 11
IMAGES :
Redwoods.info, (2014), JamesIrvineTrail [ONLINE]. Available at: http://redwoods.info/
richard/01.JamesIrvineTrail.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Blogspot.com, (2010), Copacabana Calcadao [ONLINE]. Available at: http://3.
bp.blogspot.com/_GsSO59irGfQ/TKGEZ99srPI/AAAAAAAAADA/dVmbM9iZ52A/s1600/
Copacabana+Calcadao+9-27-10.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Blogspot.com, (2014), Cycle Track Render [ONLINE]. Available at: http://4.bp.blogspot.
com/-_i8Evff644E/T-PKxo2wq0I/AAAAAAAAAPY/prjhPk_2bn8/s1600/grt2ndst_cycle_track_
render.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
TEXT:
Wenku.baidu.com. 2014. Play Okc. [ONLINE] Available at: http://wenku.baidu.com/view/
e8454e9184868762caaed553.html [Accessed 07 April 14]
PAGE 12
IMAGES
Robert McHamltd (2013), Parking Lot [ONLINE] Available at: http://robertmchamltd.com/
wp-content/uploads/2013/04/parkinglot.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Willcox Real Estate (2014), Land [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.willcoxrealestate.
com/images/land/ [Accessed 07 April 14]
Imavex.vo. .llnwd.net (2014), Silverbell 16 [ONLINE] Available at: http://imavex.vo.llnwd.
net/o18/clients/tucsongolf/images/course_images/silverbell16.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 41
PAGE 14 & 15
IMAGES
Insana Collins, (2014), Yards Park Bridge [ONLINE]. Available at: http://4.bp.blogspot.
com/-IRQAWGKwo8w/Th7rg9-w3nI/AAAAAAAAGWU/CisDBSJA97w/s1600/YardsParkBridge.jpg
[Accessed 07 April 14]
Charlesallen, DC, (2013), Yards Park Cora [ONLINE]. Available at: http://charlesallendc.
files.wordpress.com/2013/09/yards-park-cora.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
(2014), Land Value [ONLINE]. Available at: http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-wryygPrSoQI/
UQGMW79ZieI/AAAAAAAAAQk/ou9H28B884s/s1600/Land+Value.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
Parks.ca.gov, (2005), Taylor Yard General Plan [ONLINE]. Available at: http://www.parks.
ca.gov/pages/21299/files/tayloryardprefaltgeneralplan.jpg [Accessed 07 April 14]
TEXT:
(2014), Hudson Yards NYC Arts and Parks-public [ONLINE]. Available at: http://content.
related.com/HYHeroShotLibrary/hudson-yards-nyc-arts-and-parks-public-sq-011514.jpg
[Accessed 07 April 14]
Greatergreater.com, (2013), - [ONLINE]. Available at: http://greatergreater.com/
images/201009/300100.jpg[Accessed 07 April 14]
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 42
THANK YOU
LAR 623 | OPEN SPACE PLAN | SPR 2014 | GROUP C - HERNANDEZ, HYSON, VASQUEZ, YANG | S. KILBANE | PAGE 43