Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
[Type text]
Curriculum Guide
Biology 1 & 2
Biology 1 & 2 Honors
ESL Biology 1 & 2
Bilingual (Spanish) Biology 1 & 2
GOVERNING BOARD
David Lujan, President
GOVERNING BOARD
David Lujan, President
Table
of Contents
Copyright
2000 Phoenix Union High School District. All rights reserved. No part of this
document may be reproduced without the express prior written permission of the Phoenix
Union High School District.
1
[Type text]
[Type text]
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction to the Curriculum Guide .......................................................................................................................................... 4
History ...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Implications for PUHSD ................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Curriculum Coherency ..................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Unburdening the Curriculum ....................................................................................................................................................... 6
Inquiry-Based Teaching and Learning .................................................................................................................................... 7
Course Descriptions ............................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Biology 1-2 ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 9
Biology 1-2 Honors ............................................................................................................................................................................ 9
Background ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Development Team....................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Primer units ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
The Nature of Science and scientific inquiry ..................................................................................................................... 10
Characteristics of Life .................................................................................................................................................................... 11
Evolution By Natural Selection ................................................................................................................................................. 12
Biology Power Standards at a Glance ......................................................................................................................................... 13
Semester 1 ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 13
Energy and Living Systems.................................................................................................................................................... 13
Cells .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 14
Semester 2 ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
Heredity ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
Evolution ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 16
Energy and Living Systems .............................................................................................................................................................. 19
Background Information ............................................................................................................................................................. 19
Concepts and Student Pre/Misconceptions ....................................................................................................................... 20
Enduring Understanding/Topical Understanding ......................................................................................................... 22
Concepts to Uncover: ..................................................................................................................................................................... 23
Suggested Activities........................................................................................................................................................................ 23
Resources ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 23
Standards Crosswalk ..................................................................................................................................................................... 24
Topical Understandings .......................................................................................................................................................... 24
Suggested Performance Assessments ................................................................................................................................... 27
Cells Unit.................................................................................................................................................................................................... 29
2
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
Instructions for opening the Document Map for easy navigation of the Curriculum Guide
1) Select the View Tab from the Ribbon
S
2) Check the Document Map box
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
CURRICULUM COHERENCY
According to the American Association for the Advancement of Science (2001) a coherent curriculum is
one that focuses on the relatedness of particular knowledge and skills needed for science literacy, takes
developmental considerations into account in deciding on the grade placement of specific learning goals in
science, mathematics, and technology, and provides occasions for exploring thematic connections between
science-related subjects and other fields (p. 237). Improving curriculum coherence meant that we had to
develop curriculum intended to strengthen students grasp of concepts and skills by requiring that they
exercise them repeatedly in new contexts, at progressively higher levels of sophistication, and in relation to
other concepts.
Curriculum coherence was enhanced both through the refinement and re-sequencing of science courses
and was based on the following rationale (see Appendix A for the Science Course Sequence Flow Chart):
Students who have a strong foundation in physical science concepts (such as the structure of matter,
energy transformations, motion, etc.) will be better prepared for modern biology and higher-level sciences.
Biology is no longer merely the study of the physical characteristics of organisms; it probes more deeply
into how the chemistry of DNA, for example, determines the functions of a cell. Its study also includes the
flow of energy and matter. Learning can be enhanced if students of modern biology first have an
understanding of how atoms work (including energy and momentum concepts, and energy states).
If science is to be taught with an inquiry approach, then a physical science course preceding biology makes
the best sense. Experiments in physical science are the easiest to do as students manipulate physical
phenomena that they can touch. Further, physical science lends itself better to a modeling approach,
where mathematical and conceptual models to represent real-world phenomena are developed by
students. Biology experiments have many variables to control and often generate results that require the
use of sophisticated statistical analysis, making it a more difficult high school experimental science course
than physical science.
Earth science has the advantage of making use of all three core disciplines (biology, chemistry, and physics).
As a highly rigorous course, earth science can teach the student the power of the combination of disciplines
and earn the positive image it deserves.
[Type text]
[Type text]
Project team members utilized a backward design approach to curriculum revision and development a
planning sequence for curriculum (McTighe and Wiggins,1998). The planning sequence includes three
stages: identify desired results (enduring understandings), determine acceptable evidence (performancebased assessments), then plan learning experiences and instruction.
In the first stage, goals and content standards were considered. Because there was typically more content
than could reasonably be addressed, choices had to be made. Project team members used a framework for
establishing curricular priorities that included identification of understandings that are enduring beyond the
classroom. These, then, became the power standards for each course. Ideas that were identified as being
important to know or worth being familiar with were not included in the curriculum as being mandatory to
teach.
With inquiry-based teaching and learning as a goal, the first stage also required team members to take the
enduring understandings and shape them to engage and focus student inquiry. Thus, curriculum was built
around the questions that gave rise to the content knowledge in the first place. These became the
essential questions. Essential questions have no one obvious right answer, they are deliberately framed to
provoke and sustain student interest, and they promote uncoverage of foundational concepts important to
the discipline rather than coverage of everything known about a topic.
Determining acceptable evidence of student proficiency and understanding was the goal for stage two.
Example performance-based assessments (performance tasks) were generated for each of the enduring
understandings. Because student understanding develops as a result of ongoing inquiry and rethinking, the
assessment of understanding should be thought of in terms of a collection of evidence over time instead of
a single event.
Assessment methods should include informal checks for understanding, observations and dialogue, quizzes
and tests, and academic prompts as well as performance tasks. Units should be anchored in performance
tasks or projects as these provide evidence that students are able to use their knowledge in context. More
traditional assessments should be used to round out the picture by assessing essential knowledge and skills
that contribute to the culminating performances.
Stage three involves deciding what activities students will do during the unit in order to prepare for
demonstrating their understanding through performance tasks. This part of the planning is left to individual
teachers. Teachers should plan learning experiences that include inductive methods (inquiry-based labs
and investigations), guided reading activities, and cooperative learning group work, as well as direct
instruction. Direct instruction should also include Socratic method and frequent discussion.
[Type text]
[Type text]
constant. This ability is not limited to science, but also provides a powerful general strategy for solving
many problems encountered in the workplace and in everyday life.
The term scientific inquiry refers to the abilities students should develop to be able to design and conduct
scientific investigations and the understandings they should gain about the nature of scientific inquiry. It
also refers to the teaching and learning strategies that enable scientific concepts to be mastered through
investigations drawing connections between learning science, learning to do science and learning about
science.
Essential features of classroom inquiry include: 1) learners who are engaged by scientifically oriented
questions, 2) learners who give priority to evidence, which allows them to develop and evaluate
explanations that address scientifically oriented questions, 3) learners who formulate explanations from
evidence to address scientifically oriented questions, 4) learners who evaluate their explanations in light of
alternative explanations, particularly those reflecting scientific understanding, and 5) learners who
communicate and justify their proposed explanations (NSES, 1996).
Inquiry exists on several levels and may include many variations depending on the amount of learner selfdirection and amount of direction from the teacher or learning experiences. Inquiry may be structured,
guided by the teacher, or open-ended discovery. Teaching students through inquiry should be a scaffolded
journey to a level of mastery. This can be accomplished through engaging students in a research team
approach, student inquiry projects, scientific journaling, and by creating opportunities for students to
question, and answer their own testable questions.
Using inquiry-based instruction presents science teachers with several classroom implications. An inquirybased teacher: 1) concentrates on collection and use of evidence, 2) acts as a facilitator or guide for student
learning, 3) helps students benefit from mistakes, 4) models inquiry behaviors and skills, 5) uses
appropriate process vocabulary, 6) encourages dialogue among students and with the teacher, 7) poses
thoughtful, open-ended questions and helps students do the same, 8) provides a rich variety of materials
and resources for investigation, 9) uses raw data and primary sources of scientific information, 10) assists
students with clear oral and written communication, and 11) allows students to expand upon previous
inquiry activities (NSES, 1996).
[Type text]
[Type text]
COURSE DESCRIPTIONS
BIOLOGY 1-2
Course Description: Biology 1-2 is a laboratory science course designed to meet the Arizona and national
standards for the life sciences. It focuses on the life sciences and the manner in which science critical thinking
skills are used to study living organisms. Enduring understandings and essential questions center on Heredity,
The Cell, Evolution, and Energy and Living Systems.
BACKGROUND
There was a need in PUHSD to strengthen the science program for all students in the district. Traditionally,
Biology 1-2 and 1-2 Honors were survey courses developed around descriptive biology. With the national
reform movement in science (NSES and AAAS) promoting a molecular approach to biology, and the revision of
the state science standard for life sciences reflecting the same, PUHSD revised the biology curriculum to have a
more narrowed and concentrated focus of conceptual systems related to biology. Simultaneously, a new
course, Physical Science 1-2, was developed to support the biology curriculum. The new Physical Science
course was designed to equip freshmen science students with the fundamental skills of science inquiry, lab
procedures, measurement, and reporting as well as the basic concepts related to the properties of matter.
Biology 1-2, as the second science course in PUHSDs sequence, centers on the molecular basis of heredity,
cellular processes, the scientific principles and processes involved in biological evolution, and the
interdependence of organisms (particularly in relation to energy and living systems). It is a sophomore level
course and requires that students have a grasp of Physical Science concepts necessary for understanding the
difficult molecular biology (proteins, sugars, starches, lipids, DNA and nucleic acids) and biological processes
(cellular respiration, photosynthesis, and energy flow). Students who have successfully completed both
Physical Science and Biology will be well prepared for higher-level sciences, such as Chemistry, Physics, Earth
and Space Science, and Anatomy & Physiology.
DEVELOPMENT TEAM
Johnna Baca (Camelback), Jennifer Costello (North), Shoshanna Kroeger (South), and Bart James (Cesar Chavez)
worked in the Fall and Winter of 2004-2005 to evaluate the Biology course and modify it to meet the new state
science standard and the needs of our students district wide. Deedee Falls assisted by adding background
information on concepts and misconceptions for each unit and the data tables labeled Standards Crosswalk.
[Type text]
[Type text]
Primer Units
PRIMER UNITS
Primer units are intended to engage students more deeply in the scientific process than they experienced in
prerequisite science courses, while reviewing concepts related to the characteristics of living organisms. A
third primer in the series provides the bridge for understanding living organisms, and how they go about life,
through an introduction into one of the unifying and foundational themes of biology; evolution by natural
selection. Each unit following the Primers will add to student understanding of scientific inquiry, will take
students more deeply into each of the characteristics common to living organisms, and will help students
understand evolution in terms of reproductive success and change in populations.
FOR STUDENTS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
10
[Type text]
[Type text]
Primer Units
CHARACTERISTICS OF LIFE
FOR TEACHERS
FOR STUDENTS
CHARACTERISTICS OF LIFE
CHARACTERISTICS OF LIFE
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
What is life?
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
11
[Type text]
[Type text]
Primer Units
FOR STUDENTS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
A structure or behavior in an organism is an inherited
adaptation, and these adaptations can acclimate to
variations in environmental conditions to a limited
degree.
Foundational Questions:
Why do so many organisms share common
structures?
12
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
FOR STUDENTS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
13
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
CELLS
FOR TEACHERS
FOR STUDENTS
CELLS
CELLS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
What are the various ways that materials get into and
out of a cells?
14
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
SEMESTER 2
HEREDITY
FOR TEACHERS
FOR STUDENTS
HEREDITY
HEREDITY
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
15
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
EVOLUTION
FOR TEACHERS
FOR STUDENTS
EVOLUTION
EVOLUTION
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
16
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
Systems
Energy and Living Systems
Chemistry
Populations
Energy Flow
Pro- vs.
Eukaryotic
Cells
Membranes
Growth, Develop. and
Repro.
Proteins
Energy
Organ
Systems
17
[Type text]
[Type text]
Power Standards
Heredity
Genes & DNA
Genetic Engineering
Chromosomes
Evolution
Variation
Species change
Classification
18
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
[Type text]
Student Preconceptions
Some students may believe that organisms can change their food at will
according to the availability of particular sources.
Many students think that some populations of organisms are numerous in
order to fulfill a demand for food by another population.
Students meanings for energy both before and after traditional instruction are
considerable different from its scientific meaning.
Students believe energy is associated only with humans or movement, is a
fuel-like quantity with is used up, or is something that makes things happen
and is expended in the process.
Students have difficulty in identifying the sources of energy for plants and also
20
[Type text]
[Type text]
Student Preconceptions
Organs and organ systems are composed of cells and help to provide
all cells with basic needs.
for animals.
For the body to use food for energy and building materials, the food
must first be digested into molecules that are absorbed and
transported to cells.
To burn food for the release of energy stored in it, oxygen must be
supplied to cells, and carbon dioxide removed. Lungs take in oxygen
for the combustion of food and they eliminate the carbon dioxide
produced. The skin and lungs rid the body of heat energy. The
circulatory system moves all these substances to or from cells where
they are needed or produced, responding to changing demands.
The nervous system works by electrochemical signals in the nerves
and from one nerve to the next. The hormonal system exerts its
influences by chemicals that circulate in the blood. These two
systems also affect each other in coordinating body systems.
Communication between cells is required to coordinate their diverse
activities. Some cells secrete substances that spread only to nearby
cells. Other secrete3 hormones, molecules that are carried in the
bloodstream to widely distributed cells that have special receptor
sites to which they attach. Along nerve cells, electrical impulses carry
information much more rapidly than is possible by diffusion or blood
flow. Some drugs mimic or block the molecules involved in
transmitting nerve or hormone signals and therefore disturb normal
operations of the brain and body.
The immune system is designed to protect against microscopic
organisms and foreign substances that enter from outside the body
and against some cancer cells that arise within.
Students confuse energy and other concepts such as food, force, and
temperature.
Students may not appreciate the uniqueness and importance of energy
conversion processes like respiration and photosynthesis.
Students meanings for energy both before and after traditional instruction are
considerable different from its scientific meaning.
Students believe energy is associated only with humans or movement, is a
fuel-like quantity with is used up, or is something that makes things happen
and is expended in the process.
Students have difficulty in identifying the sources of energy for plants and also
for animals.
Students confuse energy and other concepts such as food, force, and
temperature.
Students may not appreciate the uniqueness and importance of energy
conversion processes like respiration and photosynthesis.
Students often believe that communication within the body occurs solely
through the nervous system.
Students relate hormone action to sexual maturation and functioning and to
21
[Type text]
[Type text]
Student Preconceptions
physical development, but do not understand them to be an important system
of communication and control for all systems.
Students think of hormones as unique to humans and they do not recognize
their action in plants and other animals (such as during metamorphosis).
FOR STUDENTS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
The sun is the source of energy that flows through interdependent living
systems.
Topical Understandings:
How are matter and energy stored and recycled in living systems?
22
[Type text]
[Type text]
CONCEPTS TO UNCOVER:
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
SUGGESTED ACTIVITIES
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
RESOURCES
SharePoint (https://sharepoint.ces)
23
[Type text]
[Type text]
STANDARDS CROSSWALK
TOPICAL UNDERSTANDINGS
1) MATTER AND ENERGY FLOWS THROUGH DIFFERENT LEVELS OF ORGANIZATION IN LIVING SYSTEMS AND THEIR
ENVIRONMENT
UNIT: ENERGY AND LIVING SYSTEMS
State Science Standard: Concepts and
Performance Objectives
Learning Objectives
Chemistry of Life:
Explain that energy is stored in the chemical bonds of food molecules.
Describe how cells use the chemical constituents of food molecules to synthesize carbohydrates, lipids,
proteins and nucleic acids.
The student will show the difference between covalent bonds that form by absorbing light energy
(photosynthesis) and covalent bonds that break down and release energy in the form of ATP
(respiration).
Create a flow-chart showing the connection between the sun and the energy needs of living things.
Compare and contrast photosynthesis and respiration by describing the reactants and products of
each.
ECOLOGY
Discuss interactions between organisms (i.e.: predator-prey, parasitism, mutualism, competition,
symbiosis, etc.).
Interpret diagrams of food chains and food webs to identify the producers, primary consumers
(herbivores), secondary consumers (carnivores), scavengers and decomposers.
[Type text]
ecosystem through a food chain.
[Type text]
environment, noting the recombination of chemical elements and the dissipation of energy as heat.
Interpret diagrams illustrating cycles, such as the water, the carbon and the nitrogen cycle.
Describe the processes involved in the water cycle as water moves between the biosphere and
atmosphere.
Relate the availability of matter and energy to changes in population by interpreting J- and S-shaped
population growth curves.
Apply the concepts of feedback, equilibria, and unpredictability to an ecological system.
2) CHEMICAL ELEMENTS ARE COMBINED IN DIFFERENT WAYS RESULTING IN CONSERVATION OF MATTER AND ENERGY IN
ECOSYSTEMS
UNIT: ENERGY AND LIVING SYSTEMS
State Science Standard: Concepts and Performance
Objectives
Learning Objectives
Ecology:
Interpret diagrams illustrating cycles, such as the water, the carbon and the nitrogen cycle.
Predict the chemical and physical changes that occur in organisms after death.
Describe the processes involved in the water cycle as water moves between the biosphere
and atmosphere.
Describe factors that influence the reuse, recycling and conservation of water.
Apply the concepts of feedback, equilibria, and unpredictability to an ecological system.
25
[Type text]
[Type text]
Learning Objectives
Ecology:
Use an energy pyramid to trace the flow of matter and energy through organisms
and the environment, noting the recombination of chemical elements and the
dissipation of energy as heat.
Explain how relationships between organisms have created ecosystems which
have remained relatively stable for extended periods of time.
Relate the availability of matter and energy to changes in population by
interpreting J- and S-shaped population growth curves.
26
[Type text]
[Type text]
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Propose a model
community
Architect
City council
27
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Determine the impact of
introducing a population
of organisms to a specific
environment.
Biologist
State
Legislature
Display, Report,
Expert Panel,
Debate
Biologist
State
Legislature
Display, Report,
Expert Panel,
Debate
28
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
CELLS UNIT
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Cells are complex and exemplify living systems. As the basic units of life, cells have needs and functions that
are very similar to those of whole organisms. Students at the elementary and middle school levels should
focus on idea that organisms are made up of cells and on the basic functions and needs of organisms for
sustaining life. Following ninth grade physical science once students have gained a basic understanding
about the structure of matter students will be able to understand the synthesis of protein molecules and the
interactions of molecules within and between cells.
In tenth grade biology, basic literacy related to cells should focus on the types of activities that cells engage in,
rather than on detailed processes or the names of the parts. Acquiring a general picture of cellular function
and an understanding of the idea that the cell has specialized parts to perform these functions is sufficient for
students at this level. This understanding can be accomplished without the study of large numbers of technical
terms. Emphasizing vocabulary over conceptual understanding can impede learning and take the fun out of
science. Discussion of what jobs need to be accomplished in the cell is much more important than identifying
or naming the parts that do it. For example, students should recognize that cells have specific components for
oxidizing sugar to release energy and components that link together protein chains according to instructions.
ON the other hand, students dont need to remember that one component is a mitochondrion and the other a
ribosome, or even which is which.
Students at this level should also be asked to consider how needed substances and information enter and
leave cells and the variety of tasks cells perform in organisms. Understanding how protein molecules are
assembled by cells and the idea that they conduct the work that goes on inside and outside the cells in an
organism, can be accomplished without going into the biochemical details. For tenth grade biology students,
knowing that the molecules involved in cellular processes are different configurations of a relatively few kinds
of amino acids, and that the different shapes of the molecules influence what they do, is sufficient. In
addition, thinking of cells as a community, with each cell having common tasks as well as specialized functions,
may help students to understand the interdependency of cells.
Finally, the individual cell can be considered as a system itself as well as a part of larger systems sometimes
as part of a multicellular organism, and always a part of an ecosystem. Thus, an understanding of how systems
work is of particular importance for students (for more information refer to the systems maps in the Atlas of
Science Literacy). Like all systems, cells can be viewed as having inputs, outputs, and boundaries. For example,
the cell membrane serves as a boundary between the cell and its environment and it allows the cell to contain
for its own use the proteins it makes, the equipment it uses to make them, and stored fuel for future use.
This unit has an important connection to the unit on Heredity through the idea that DNA provides the
instructions for the functions common to all cells and the specialized tasks of cells in different organs.
(Adapted from: Benchmarks for Science Literacy; National Science Education Standards; and Atlas for Science
Literacy)
29
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Student Preconceptions
A membrane that controls what enters and leaves covers every cell. Proteins form a complex
network, in all but primitive cells, providing organization and shape, and for animals cells,
movement.
Cells contain specialized parts for engaging in various tasks that are common to all cells:
transportation of materials, capture and release of energy, constructing proteins, disposing of waste
products, information feedback, and movement. In multicellular organisms, most cells perform
some special function(s) that others do not.
The cell assembles proteins, which carry out the work of the cell. Protein molecules are long chains,
that are usually folded, made from 20 different amino-acid molecules. The specific sequence of
amino acids and the shape of the protein molecule determine its function. The shape of the protein
molecule is determined by the attractions between the amino-acids.
DNA, the genetic information, provides assembly instructions for protein molecules. All life forms
use virtually the same code.
Cycles of activities, such as growth and division, are produced by complex interactions among
different kinds of molecules in the cell. Molecules from other parts of the organism or other
organisms can have an effect on cellular behavior.
Cellular gene mutation can cause cancer, uncontrolled cell division. Cellular exposure to certain
chemicals and radiation may increase the number of cellular mutations and thus increases the
chance of an organism developing cancer.
A narrow range of temperature and acidity is important for cellular efficient cellular function: low
temperatures reduce reaction rates, and high temperatures and/or extremes of acidity can
irreversibly change the structure of most protein molecules. Even small changes in acidity can alter
the molecules and how they interact. All organisms, both single celled and multicellular, contain
molecules that help to keep their cells acidity within a narrow range.
30
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
A small number of chemical elements, mainly carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus, and
sulfur, make up living cells. Carbon has the ability to form large, complex molecules. Its small size
and four available bonding electrons allows it to join to other carbon atoms in chains and rings.
Organs and organ systems are composed of cells and help to provide all cells with basic needs.
For the body to use food for energy and building materials, the food must first be digested into
molecules that are absorbed and transported to cells.
To burn food for the release of energy stored in it, oxygen must be supplied to cells, and carbon
dioxide removed. Lungs take in oxygen for the combustion of food and they eliminate the carbon
dioxide produced. The skin and lungs rid the body of heat energy. The circulatory system moves all
these substances to or from cells where they are needed or produced, responding to changing
demands.
The nervous system works by electrochemical signals in the nerves and from one nerve to the next.
The hormonal system exerts its influences by chemicals that circulate in the blood. These two
systems also affect each other in coordinating body systems.
Communication between cells is required to coordinate their diverse activities. Some cells secrete
substances that spread only to nearby cells. Other secrete3 hormones, molecules that are carried in
the bloodstream to widely distributed cells that have special receptor sites to which they attach.
Along nerve cells, electrical impulses carry information much more rapidly than is possible by
diffusion or blood flow. Some drugs mimic or block the molecules involved in transmitting nerve or
hormone signals and therefore disturb normal operations of the brain and body.
The immune system is designed to protect against microscopic organisms and foreign substances
that enter from outside the body and against some cancer cells that arise within.
31
[Type text]
[Type text]
FOR STUDENTS
CELLS
CELLS
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
The cell is the basic unit of structure and function in all living systems.
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
Why do antibiotics affect bacteria and not the cells of your body?
The structure of the cell membrane allows it to regulate what enters and
leaves the cell.
What are the various ways that materials get into and out of cells?
Why and how do cells divide (Why arent humans one giant cell)?
32
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
CONCEPTS TO UNCOVER
1)
2)
3)
4)
SUGGESTED ACTIVITIES
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
RESOURCES
SharePoint (https://sharepoint.ces)
33
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
STANDARDS CROSSWALK
TOPICAL UNDERSTANDINGS
1) THERE ARE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PROKARYOTIC AND EUKARYOTIC CELLULAR PROCESSES, SUCH AS REPRODUCTIVE
STRATEGIES
UNIT: CELL
State Science Standard: Concepts and Performance Objectives
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Relate the structure of cell parts and organelles to their functions.
Evolution:
Describe current theories and experiments relating to the first forms of life on
earth (e.g.: changing from an oxygen-poor atmosphere to an oxygen-rich
atmosphere).
34
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
2) THE STRUCTURE OF THE CELL MEMBRANE ALLOWS IT TO REGULATE WHAT ENTERS AND LEAVES THE CELL
UNIT: CELL
State Science Standard: Concepts and Performance Objectives
Learning Objectives
Cell:
35
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Identify the components of the cell theory and the contributions made by
various scientists.
Identify the purposes of mitotic cell division as:
a way to maintain cell size small enough for diffusion to be effective
a method of growth, repair and regeneration in multicellular organisms
a method of asexual reproduction in unicellular organisms
Relate the process of meiosis to the production of gametes (e.g.: eggs and
sperm).
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Physiology and Behavior:
Describe these processes in living organisms:
Egg production
Sperm formation
Fertilization
Embryo development
36
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Given a series of diagrams depicting the stages of mitosis, SWBAT arrange the diagrams in proper sequence and describe what
is happening to the chromosomes.
Identify the purposes of mitotic cell division as:
a way to maintain cell size small enough for diffusion to be effective
a method of growth, repair and regeneration in multicellular organisms
passive transport
Chemistry of Life:
active transport
Recognize the basic molecular structure of organic molecules (carbohydrates, proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids) and describe
their major functions.
Describe the synthesis and breakdown of organic molecules and the role of enzymes in these processes.
Explain that energy is stored in the chemical bonds of food molecules.
Describe how cells use the chemical constituents of food molecules to synthesize carbohydrates, lipids, proteins and nucleic
acids.
Create a flow-chart showing the connection between the sun and the energy needs of living things.
Show the difference between covalent bonds that form by absorbing light energy (photosynthesis) and covalent bonds that
break down and release energy in the form of ATP (respiration).
Given a description or a diagram of cell transport, SWBAT identify it as an example of diffusion, osmosis, passive transport or
active transport.
37
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Learning Objectives
Cell:
passive transport
Recognize the basic molecular structure of organic molecules (carbohydrates, proteins, lipids, and nucleic
acids) and describe their major functions.
active transport
Describe the synthesis and breakdown of organic molecules and the role of enzymes in these processes.
Describe how cells use the chemical constituents of food molecules to synthesize carbohydrates, lipids,
proteins and nucleic acids.
Design and conduct an experiment that tests the factors that affect enzyme activity.
Genetics:
Explain how genetic information is stored in DNA & directs protein synthesis, which regulates cell functions.
Differentiate between genetic mutations which are expressed (affect the production of amino acids) and
those which are not expressed (do not affect amino acid production).
38
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution:
Support the theory of evolution using the following independent lines of evidence: fossil record,
homologous structures, embryonic development, vestigial organs, radioactive dating of fossils, and
biochemistry (e.g.: DNA hybridization and amino acid sequencing).
Explain how mutations lead to genetic variability, which allows organisms to change over time.
Physiology and Behavior:
Relate the process of digestion in organisms to nutritional needs of cells & selective nature of cell
membranes.
39
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
Learning Objectives
40
Cells
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Convince doctors that a
new drug will be
effective without
causing harm to your
cells.
Marketing
Representative for
a Pharmaceutical
company
Doctors
41
Information Bulletin
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
Essential Question
What plan could you develop to decrease
your susceptibility to disease?
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Create an analogy to
account for the way in
which different substances
are transported across cell
membranes.
Peer tutor
Fellow
student
Picture, diagram,
model
Game developer
High school
biology
students
Game
42
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Tell the story of how you
came to be, from a single
cell to the multicelled
adolescent you are.
Yourself
Medical
Information
Specialist
You are a
journalist
Younger
sibling
Childrens book,
comic book
General
public
Informational
brochure
Newspaper
readers
Article,
PowerPoint,
Interview script
43
PowerPoint
STANDARDS
FOR SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Design a healthy vegan
diet.
Cytologist
A friend
44
Nutrition plan as
Letter, PowerPoint,
Script for role-play
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Cells
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Describe the interations of
body systems
Blood cell
New blood
cell
45
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
HEREDITY UNIT
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
There are some basic ideas that are important for students to understand as they pursue the study of heredity,
which is an enormously complex subject. First, early on, students understand that organisms produce
offspring that are in some ways alike and in some ways different from both their parents and their siblings.
Second, students recognize that these similarities and differences are produced through the transmission of
DNA from one generation to the next. At an early age, students also learn that similar animals have similar
offspring dogs have puppies, rabbits have bunnies and that there exists a wide variety among living things
on earth.
As students move to high school, the focus for instruction about heredity should move to the origin of
variation (i.e., the recombination of parents genes or genetic mutations in reproductive cells are what
produce differences between individuals within the same species and within the same family). High school
level biology should present students with opportunities to understand how variation arises in the process of
passing genetic information from one generation to the next. Further, understanding that recombination and
mutation over many generations can eventually lead to very different descendants, has a direct relationship to
understanding the principles that underlie the mechanisms for evolution.
The unit on heredity is grounded in student understanding of sexual reproduction and the mechanism of
inheritance that should be developed through elementary and middle school (see the Arizona Science
Standard articulated by grade level for more information about concepts addressed at the middle school level).
Basic literacy does not include the ability to explain the structure and function of DNA beyond its being a
molecular string of genetic code that directs the assembly of proteins. Advanced students, such as high school
students, however, are expected to learn more about the details once the literacy base is established. This
literacy base should be developed through the elementary and middle school levels, and through an
understanding of the basic concepts taught in ninth-grade physical science (such as the structure of matter).
With an appropriate literacy base, students should be ready to understand an explanation of genes and DNA,
what characteristics are heritable, and the mechanism by which heritable characteristics are passed from
parent to offspring.
Further, high school students should understand that both the continuity of traits, from generation to
generation, and the variation that leads to differences within species and to entirely new species, are possible
because of DNA. A high level of understanding about DNA promotes complex thinking and makes possible an
explanation of such phenomena as the similarities and differences between parents and offspring, hereditary
diseases, and the evolution of new species. Gene manipulation for the creation of new combinations of traits
and new varieties of organisms is also possible because of the scientific understanding about the structure,
function, and nature of DNA, and the principles of heredity.
(Adapted from: Benchmarks for Science Literacy; National Science Education Standards; and Atlas for Science
Literacy)
46
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Student Preconceptions
Some organisms have sexes so that half of their genes come from each of their parents, whereas all
of the genes come from a single parent in other kinds of organisms.
Sexual reproduction is the process by which one specialized cell from each parent (a male parent
and a female parent) merges to produce a new individual. This fertilized egg carries genetic
information from each parent and, as it multiplies to form a complete organism, the same genetic
information is copied in each new cell. In humans this produces an individual with approximately
one trillion cells.
Selective breeding for specific traits has produced new varieties of cultivated plants and domestic
animals.
New gene combinations may produce organisms with enhanced capabilities, with deleterious
genotypes, or with genotypes that have no effect.
In offspring with two parents (sexual reproduction), sorting and recombination of genes results in a
wide variety of possible gene combinations and traits.
Some segments of DNA molecules are genes. Thus, genes may be altered when segments of DNA
are inserted, deleted, or substituted during synthesis, recombination, and translation. Altered
genes may be passed on to every cell that develops from it. The offsprings success in its
environment may be improved, reduced, or unaffected by its altered genes.
Radiation and chemicals are sources of gene mutation. Mutations that occur in sex cells can be
passed on to offspring. Mutations occurring in other cells can only be passed on to descendant
cells. Only experiences that change the genetic makeup of an organisms sex cells can affect its
offspring.
Even though an individuals many body cells are descended from a single cell and have essentially
identical genetic instructions, they be very different from one another. This is because different
47
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
regions of the DNA are used in different types of cells as they are influenced by the cells
environment and past history.
FOR STUDENTS
HEREDITY
HEREDITY
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Heredity is the mechanism by which traits are passed from one generation
to another.
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
What are genes and how do they determine traits?
Transmission of DNA from one generation to the next accounts for both
similarities and differences in living things.
Genes are segments of DNA that provide instructions for protein synthesis.
Mutations are changes in DNA that result in altered proteins, providing
variability.
48
[Type text]
[Type text]
CONCEPTS TO UNCOVER
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
DNA Replication
DNA Transmission
DNA Translation
Meiosis
Protein synthesis
Genetic engineering
Mutation
Relationship between DNA, genes and chromosomes
SUGGESTED ACTIVITIES
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
DNA Replication
Design a Pet (CATTACA)
Flower Dissection
Meiosis Activity
DNA Electrophoresis
Fast Plant Activity
Build a Species
RESOURCES
SharePoint (https://sharepoint.ces)
49
Heredity
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
STANDARDS CROSSWALK
TOPICAL UNDERSTANDINGS
1) TRANSMISSION OF DNA FROM ONE GENERATION TO THE NEXT ACCOUNTS FOR BOTH SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES IN
LIVING THINGS
UNIT: HEREDITY
State Science Standard: Concepts and Performance
Objectives
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Identify the components of the cell theory and the contributions made by various
scientists.
Identify the purposes of mitotic cell division as:
a way to maintain cell size small enough for diffusion to be effective
a method of growth, repair and regeneration in multicellular organisms
a method of asexual reproduction in unicellular organisms
Relate the process of meiosis to the production of gametes (e.g.: eggs and sperm).
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Use the following terms to discuss and solve genetic problems: phenotype, genotype,
homozygous, heterozygous, dominant, recessive, codominant alleles, sex-linked traits,
multiple alleles.
Given the genotypes of the parents, SWBAT predict the genotypic and phenotypic ratios
50
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
51
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
2) GENES ARE SEGMENTS OF DNA THAT PROVIDE INSTRUCTIONS FOR PROTEIN SYNTHESIS
UNIT: HEREDITY
State Science Standard:
Concepts and Performance
Objectives
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Describe relationship between DNA, genes, and chromosomes.
Explain how genetic information is stored in DNA and directs synthesis of proteins, which regulates functions of cell.
Given a model of a DNA molecule, SWBAT identify the following: nucleotide, sugar (deoxyribose), phosphate group, and
the four bases: adenine (A), cytosine (C), thymine (T), and guanine (G).
Demonstrate the replication of DNA, transcription of mRNA from DNA, and translation of mRNA.
Describe a mutation as a change in the genetic code that occurs spontaneously at a slow rate and more frequently under
certain conditions (i.e.: exposure to radiation, carcinogens, UV)
Differentiate between mutations which will not affect offspring (mutations in somatic cells) and mutations which create
new variations in the offspring (mutations in sex cells).
Describe examples of genetic engineering and discuss ethical issues related to their use (i.e.: production of drugs by
bacteria, treatments for genetic disorders, information on fetal genetics, and improvements in crops and livestock
through gene transfers).
Evolution:
Support the theory of evolution using the following independent lines of evidence: fossil record, homologous structures,
embryonic development, vestigial organs, radioactive dating of fossils, and biochemistry (e.g.: DNA hybridization and
amino acid sequencing).
Explain how mutations lead to genetic variability, which allows organisms to change over time.
52
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
3) MUTATIONS ARE CHANGES IN DNA THAT RESULT IN ALTERED PROTEINS, PROVIDING VARIABILITY
UNIT: HEREDITY
State Science Standard: Concepts and
Performance Objectives
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Describe relationship between DNA, genes, and chromosomes.
Explain how genetic information is stored in DNA and directs synthesis of proteins, which regulates
functions of cell.
Given a model of a DNA molecule, SWBAT identify the following: nucleotide, sugar (deoxyribose),
phosphate group, and the four bases: adenine (A), cytosine (C), thymine (T), and guanine (G).
Demonstrate the replication of DNA, transcription of mRNA from DNA, and translation of mRNA.
Describe a mutation as a change in the genetic code that occurs spontaneously at a slow rate and more
frequently under certain conditions (i.e.: exposure to radiation, carcinogens, UV)
Differentiate between mutations which will not affect offspring (mutations in somatic cells) and mutations
which create new variations in the offspring (mutations in sex cells).
Describe examples of genetic engineering and discuss ethical issues related to their use (i.e.: production of
drugs by bacteria, treatments for genetic disorders, information on fetal genetics, and improvements in
crops and livestock through gene transfers).
Evolution:
Support the theory of evolution using the following independent lines of evidence: fossil record,
homologous structures, embryonic development, vestigial organs, radioactive dating of fossils, and
biochemistry (e.g.: DNA hybridization and amino acid sequencing).
Explain how mutations lead to genetic variability, which allows organisms to change over time.
53
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Relate the process of meiosis to the production of gametes (e.g.: eggs and sperm).
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Use the following terms to discuss and solve genetic problems: phenotype, genotype, homozygous,
heterozygous, dominant, recessive, codominant alleles, sex-linked traits, multiple alleles.
Given the genotypes of the parents, SWBAT predict the genotypic and phenotypic ratios of the
offspring (as ratios or percentages), using a Punnett square or an algebraic equation.
Explain how genetic information is stored in DNA and directs synthesis of proteins, which regulates
functions of cell.
54
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Learning Objectives
Cell:
Given a series of diagrams depicting the stages of mitosis, SWBAT arrange the diagrams in proper
sequence and describe what is happening to the chromosomes.
Identify the purposes of mitotic cell division as:
Relate the process of meiosis to the production of gametes (e.g.: eggs and sperm).
Compare and contrast the processes and products of mitosis and meiosis.
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Describe the relationship between DNA, genes, and chromosomes.
Explain how genetic information is stored in DNA and directs synthesis of proteins, which regulates
functions of cell.
Given a karyotype, the student will be able to identify the sex of an individual and any
chromosomal disorders (e.g.: trisomy 21).
Describe examples of genetic engineering and discuss ethical issues related to their use (i.e.:
production of drugs by bacteria, treatments for genetic disorders, information on fetal genetics,
and improvements in crops and livestock through gene transfers).
55
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Learning Objectives
Genetics:
Describe examples of genetic engineering and discuss ethical issues related to their use (i.e.:
production of drugs by bacteria, treatments for genetic disorders, information on fetal genetics,
and improvements in crops and livestock through gene transfers).
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
56
[Type text]
GOAL
[Type text]
ROLE
AUDIENCE
SITUATION
Heredity
Product/
PERFORMANCE
Explain protein
synthesis.
Student/peer mentor
Previously
absent
student
Expert witness
Judge and
Jury
Identify the
political and social
consequences of
using the various
applications for
DNA
fingerprinting.
Concerned citizen
Newspaper
readers
Editorial promoting or
disputing the reliability of
DNA fingerprinting.
57
STANDARDS
FOR SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
GOAL
ROLE
AUDIENCE
SITUATION
Product/
PERFORMANCE
You are a
parent
Your child
An album or family
pictures, a pedigree of
family inheritance, and a
written explanation.
You are a
breeder
(select
animal/plan
t)
Prospective
buyer
Differentiate between
mutations which will not
affect offspring (mutations in
somatic cells) and mutations,
You are a
Talk Show
host that is
Guests of
the show
58
STANDARDS
FOR SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
a Doctor
Heredity
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Explain likely
consequences of the
inheritance of a lethal
trait.
Genetic counselor
Prospective
parents
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity
Foundational Questions
AUDIENCE
Product/
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Yourself
Friend
60
Persuasive paper,
role-play, debate
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
EVOLUTION UNIT
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The living world around us is most striking in its diversity and complexity. Yet the deeper scientists have
probed, the greater the similarities that have emerged. Evolution is a scientific principle drawing on
observable evidence and facts about life on earth, which provide an explanation for similarities within the
diversity of life and support the idea of decent from common ancestors.
Two kinds of observations provide evidence for biological evolution: patterns of similarity and variety
among living organisms, and corresponding patterns of similarity and variety among living organisms that
are now extinct.
Isotopic dating techniques, used to determine the actual age of fossils, contribute to the evidence
supporting evolutionary change. Understanding of radioactivity makes it possible for students to
comprehend these techniques and hence to appreciate that sufficient time may have elapsed for successive
changes to have accumulated. Also contributing to evidence for evolutionary change is DNA, which
supports the notion that life evolved from common ancestors and provides a plausible mechanism for the
origin of new traits.
Evolutionary history and fossil evidence for change over time are two ideas that should be addressed in
middle school. High school instruction related to evolution should focus on the mechanism by which
organisms change over time. Students at this level need to shift their thinking from individuals to
populations. Rather than thinking in terms of selection of individuals with a trait students should be
introduced to the idea of changing proportions of a trait in populations. Familiarizing students with
artificial selection, coming from studies of pedigrees and their own experiments, can then be applied to
natural systems, in which selection is directed by environmental conditions.
The theory of natural selection explains how the diversity of species we see today and in the fossil records
could all descend from common ancestors. For students to understand the idea of natural selection, they
must have a fairly complex sense of both similarities and differences evident in diverse organisms. They
must also be knowledgeable of the advantages or disadvantages of those differences, relative to particular
environments.
An understanding of artificial selection (breeding), how characteristics are inherited, variation and
advantage, and changes in the environment, is critical for students understanding about the mechanism of
natural selection. An often-missed subtlety in this story is that other organisms, too, are part of the
environment. Meaning that organisms adapt in part to one another all life evolves together.
Consequently, enduring understandings related to the interdependence of life relate closely to the unit on
evolution.
When learning about evolution, history should not be overlooked. What led Darwin and Wallace to the
concept of evolution by natural selection illuminates the interacting roles of evidence and theory in
scientific inquiry. Moreover, organizing new as well as old biological knowledge into a coherent picture
of life forms can be accomplished using evolution as a framework.
61
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Finally, the matter of public response should be considered. Opposition continues to come from people
whose interpretation of religious writings may conflict with the story of evolution. Unfortunately, people
have misconceptions about evolution. Often these are simple misunderstandings originating in the course
of learning about evolution, possibly from school experiences or the media.
One of our roles as teachers is to treat all student questions with respect and initially to accept each
question as the reflection of a legitimate desire to learn. Further, as teachers of biology it is our obligation
to teach to the state science standard, of which evolution is a major conceptual system.
Many misconceptions about the history of life and how it came about are very common. Most of these
misunderstandings have to do with assumptions that evolution proceeds in a particular direction or that
individual living things can choose to adapt (see the section on student preconceptions below). These
misconceptions or common misunderstandings are not unique to our students and therefore will be
addressed here in this introduction.
Misconception One: Evolution is a theory about the origin of life. Clarification: Evolution is a scientific
principle which deals mainly with how life changed after its origin. Scientists do investigate how life started
(e.g., whether or not it happened near a deep-sea vent, which organic molecules came first, etc.), but these
considerations are not the central focus of study for evolutionary biologists. According to the principle of
evolution life branched and diversified, regardless of how it started. Whether or not we understand how
life began, does not change what we know about what happened during the history of life.
Misconception Two: Evolution means that organisms are always getting better. Reality: Although natural
selection weeds out individuals that are unfit in a particular situation, no organism has to be perfect. In
reality, many taxa (like some mosses, protests, fungi, sharks, opossums, and crayfish) have changed little
over great expanses of time. They are not climbing up a ladder of progress. If they are fit enough to survive
long enough to reproduce, then that is all that is necessary to ensure their existence as a population. On
the other hand, many taxa have changed and diversified a great deal. This doesnt mean that they got
better. With changing climates, rivers shifting courses, and new competitors invading, what was better
a million years ago, may not be better today. Better is relative to time and place. What works better
in one location might not work so well in another as fitness is linked to environment, not to progress.
Misconception Three: When organisms evolve it means that they changed by chance. Clarification: Chance
is certainly a factory in evolution, but there are also non-random evolutionary mechanisms. Random
mutation is the ultimate source of genetic variation, however natural selection, the process by which some
variants survive and others do not, is not random. For example, aquatic animals are more likely to survive
and reproduce if they can move quickly through the water. Speed helps them to capture prey, escape
danger, and thus to survive and reproduce. Individuals that survive and reproduce better in their
environment will have more offspring (displaying the same traits) in the next generation. Thats not
random selection. To say that evolution happens by chance ignores half of the picture.
Misconception Four: Natural selection involves organisms trying to adapt. Clarification: Natural selection
leads to adaptation, but the process doesnt involve trying. Natural selection involves genetic variation
and selection among variants present in a population. Either an individual has genes that are good enough
to survive and reproduce, or it does not but it cant get the right genes by trying.
Misconception Five: Natural selection gives organisms what they need. Clarification: Natural selection
has no intentions or senses; it cannot sense what a species needs. If a population happens to have the
genetic variation that allows some individuals to survive a particular challenge better than others, then
62
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
those individuals will have more offspring in the next generation, and the population will evolve. If that
genetic variation is not in the population, the population may still survive (but not evolve much) or it may
die out. But, it will not be granted what it needs by natural selection.
There are also many misconceptions about the evidence supporting evolution. Following are several of the
most prominent misconceptions related to support for evolution.
Misconception One: Evolution is just a theory. Clarification: Scientific theories are explanations that are
based on lines of evidence, enable valid predictions, and have been tested in many ways. In contrast, there
is also a popular definition of theory a guess or conjecture. These conflicting definitions often cause
unnecessary confusion about evolution.
Misconception Two: Evolution is a theory in crisis and is collapsing as scientists lose confidence in it.
Clarification: Scientists do not debate whether evolution (decent with modification) took place, but they do
argue about how it took place. Details of the processes and mechanisms are vigorously debated. Evolution
is sound science and is treated accordingly by scientists and scholars worldwide.
Misconception Three: Gaps in the fossil record disprove evolution. Clarification: The fact that some
transitional fossils are not preserved does not disprove evolution. Evolutionary biologists do not expect
that all transitional forms will be found and realize that many species leave no fossils at all. Lots of
organisms do not fossilize well and the environmental conditions for forming good fossils are not that
common. So, science actually predicts that for many evolutionary changes there will be gaps in the record.
Also as predicted, scientists have found many fossils that show the presence of new, complex structures.
For example, there are fossils of transitional organisms between modern birds and their theropod dinosaur
ancestors, and between whales and their terrestrial mammal ancestors.
Misconception Four: Evolutionary theory is incomplete and is currently unable to give a total explanation of
life. Clarification: evolutionary science is a work in progress. New discoveries are made and explanations
adjusted when necessary. And, in this respect, evolution is just like all other sciences. Research continues
to add to our knowledge. While we dont know everything about evolution (or any scientific discipline, for
that matter), we do know a great deal about the history of life, the pattern of lineage-splitting through
time, and the mechanisms that have caused these changes. And more will be learned in the future. To
date, evolution is the only well-supported explanation for lifes diversity.
Misconception Five: Evolution is not science because it is not observable or testable. Clarification:
Evolution is observable and testable. The misconception here is that science is limited to controlled
experiments that are conducted in laboratories by people in white lab coats. Actually, much of science is
accomplished by gathering evidence from the real world and inferring how things work. Astronomers
cannot hold stars in their hands and geologists cannot go back in time, but in both cases scientists can learn
a great deal by using multiple lines of evidence to make valid and useful inferences about their objects of
study. The same is true of the study of the evolutionary history of life on Earth, and as a matter of fact,
many mechanisms of evolution are studied through direct experimentation as in more familiar sciences.
Misconception Six: Most biologists have rejected Darwinism (i.e., no longer really agree with the ideas
put forth by Darwin and Wallace). Clarification: Darwins idea that evolution generally proceeds at a slow,
deliberate pace has been modified to include the idea that evolution can proceed at a relatively rapid pace
under some circumstances. In this sense, Darwinism is continually being modified. Modification of
theories to make them more representative of how things work is the role of scientists and of science itself.
Thus far, however, there have been no credible challenges to the basic Darwinian principles that evolution
63
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
proceeds primarily by the mechanism of natural selection acting upon variation in populations and that
different species share common ancestors. Scientists have not rejected Darwins natural selection, but
have improved and expanded it as more information has become available. For example, we now know
(although Darwin did not) that genetic mutations are the source of variation acted on by natural selection,
but we havent rejected Darwins idea of natural selection weve just added to it.
Misconception Seven: Evolution supports the idea that might makes right and rationalizes the oppression
of some people by others. Clarification: In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a philosophy
called Social Darwinism arose from a misguided effort to apply lessons from biological evolution to
society. According to this view, society should allow the weak and less fit to fail and die, and that this is not
only good policy, but morally right. Supposedly, evolution by natural selection provided support for these
ideas. Pre-existing prejudices were rationalized by the notion that colonized nations, poor people, or
disadvantaged minorities must have deserved their situations because the were less fit than those who
were better off. This misapplication of science was used to promote social and political agendas. The
science of Social Darwinism was refuted. Biological evolution has stood the test of time, but Social
Darwinism has not.
Misconception Eight: Evolution and religion are incompatible. Clarification: Religion and science
(evolution) are very different things. In science (as in science class), only natural causes are used to explain
natural phenomena, while religion deals with beliefs that are beyond the natural world. The misconception
that one has to choose between science and religion is divisive. Most Christian and Jewish religious groups
have no conflict with evolution or other scientific findings. In fact, many religious people, including
theologians, fell that a deeper understanding of nature actually enriches their faith. Moreover, in the
scientific community there are thousands of scientists who are devoutly religious and also accept evolution.
(Adapted from: Benchmarks for Science Literacy; National Science Education Standards; and Atlas for
Science Literacy)
64
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Student Preconceptions
The premise that earths present-day species developed from earlier, distinctly
different species is the basic idea of biological evolution.
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
these misunderstandings.
For sexually reproducing organisms, a species comprises all organisms that can
mate with one another to produce fertile offspring.
All organisms, including the human species, are part of and depend on two main
66
[Type text]
[Type text]
interconnected global food webs. One includes microscopic ocean plants, the
animals that feed on them, and finally the animals that feed on those animals.
The other web includes land plants, the animals that feed on them, and so forth.
The cycles continue indefinitely because organisms decompose after death to
return food material to the environment.
The variation of organisms within a species increases the likelihood that at least
some members of the species will survive under changed environmental
conditions, and a great diversity of species increases the chance that at least
some living things will survive in the face of large changes in the environment.
The degree of kinship between organisms or species can be estimated from the
similarity of their DNA sequences, which often closely matches their
classification based on anatomical similarities.
67
Evolution
viewing jellyfish as fish because of the term fish, and penguins as
amphibians because they live on land and in water.
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
FOR STUDENTS
EVOLUTION
EVOLUTION
Enduring Understanding:
Essential Question:
Topical Understandings:
Foundational Questions:
What evidence supports the idea that species change over time?
68
[Type text]
[Type text]
CONCEPTS TO UNCOVER
1)
2)
3)
4)
Natural selection
Common decent models
Cladistics & Taxonomy
Evidence for evolution
SUGGESTED ACTIVITIES
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
RESOURCES
Teaching about Evolution and the Nature of Science: National Academy Press.
69
Evolution
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
STANDARDS CROSSWALK
TOPICAL UNDERSTANDINGS
1) VARIATION IN TRAITS DETERMINES THE SUCCESS OF A SPECIES IN AN ENVIRONMENT
UNIT: EVOLUTION
STATE SCIENCE STANDARD: CONCEPTS
AND PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES
Learning Objectives
Evolution:
Explain how mutations lead to genetic variability, which allows organisms to change over time.
Predict how a change in an environmental factor can affect the number of organisms in a population and
the biodiversity in an ecosystem.
Compare the evolution of behavior by natural selection to the evolution of physical characteristics
(adaptations) and describe the adaptive value of each.
Summarize how natural selection results in the diversity of species as well as the extinction of other
species.
Describe how organisms evolved from common ancestors and diverged to fill niches.
70
[Type text]
populations ability to adapt to changes in
the environment and leads to biodiversity
and the origin of new species.
4.2.3 Explain how genotypic variation
occurs and results in phenotypic diversity.
4.3.2 Describe how organisms are
influenced by a particular combination of
biotic (living) and abiotic (nonliving)
factors in a n environment.
[Type text]
Evolution
The Cell:
Explain how genetic variability is increased during the events of meiosis.
Genetics:
Differentiate between mutations which will not affect offspring (mutations in somatic cells) and mutations
which create new variations in the offspring (mutations in sex cells).
Differentiate between genetic mutations which are expressed (affect the production of amino acids) and
those which are not expressed (do not affect amino acid production).
ECOLOGY
Relate the availability of matter and energy to changes in population by interpreting J- and S-shaped
population growth curves.
The Cell:
Compare and contrast eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells.
CLASSIFICATION:
Describe modern methods used for classification such as comparative anatomy,
amino acid sequencing, DNA studies, and evolutionary relationships.
Evolution:
Support the theory of evolution using the following independent lines of
evidence: fossil record, homologous structures, embryonic development,
71
[Type text]
and recombination of genes
finite supply of resources required for life
selection by the environment of those offspring better able to
survive and produce offspring
[Type text]
Evolution
72
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Learning Objectives
Classification:
Use binomial nomenclature to name organisms.
Describe an organism using the following levels of classification; kingdom phylum (division), class, order,
family, genus, and species.
Given an organism, correctly place it in the kingdom system of classification based upon:
Mode of nutrition (heterotroph/autotrophy)
Presence and composition of cell wall
Number of cells (unicellular/multicellular)
Describe modern methods used for classification such as comparative anatomy, amino acid sequencing,
DNA studies, and evolutionary relationships.
Compare and contrast viruses and bacteria according to structure, reproduction and the characteristics
of life.
Discuss the major characteristics of protests, including algae and protozoa.
Discuss the major characteristics of fungi, including molds, yeasts, mildews, and mushrooms.
Discuss the major characteristics of plants, including mosses, ferns, gymnosperms, and angiosperms.
Identify the characteristics used to place animals into the various phyla: symmetry, tissue layers, body
cavities, segmentation, cephalization, and appendages.
73
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
Essential Question
Is change necessary to sustain life?
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Argue the points
completing a full cycle of
antibiotics.
Doctor
Patient
Written paper,
debate, role play
Childrens story
writer
Elementary
age students
74
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Demonstrate a line of
evidence supporting a
hypothesis that an extinct
organism is the ancestor
of a currently living
organism.
Scientist
Scientific
Community
Graphic organizer or
Display and
Presentation.
Demonstrate a line of
evidence supporting a
hypothesis that an extinct
organism is the ancestor
of a currently living
organism.
Museum
Curator
General public
75
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Evolution
Topical Understandings
Foundational Questions
ENDURING UNDERSTANDING
AUDIENCE
Product/
Essential Question
Is change necessary to sustain life?
GOAL
ROLE
SITUATION
PERFORMANCE
Design an arrangement of
species in a zoo
Zoo curator
Zoo visitors
76
Diagram, illustration
or model of the zoo,
with written
justification for the
arrangement
STANDARDS FOR
SUCCESS
[Type text]
[Type text]
Heredity Cells
X
77
[Type text]
[Type text]
78
[Type text]
[Type text]
79