Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ESH310
Signed
Date
*By submitting this assignment and cover sheet electronically, in whatever form, you are deemed to have made the declaration
set out above.
Assessors feedback:
You have developed a useful unit of work that I am sure you will adapt and use one day. The lessons
were well designed and ordered to build understanding about literature. Your characterisation lessons
both written and visual, were mostly accurate although I would like to have seen more about your
explicit teacher talk. With your lesson on Critical Literacy, I felt you could have focussed more
explicitly on who had the power and who was othered.
Your assessment tasks with their detailed rubrics would certainly demonstrate the students level of
understanding but it is so much easier to assess them accurately when your wording directly aligns to
the curriculum achievement standard.
Well done on a very good assignment!
Assessment: DN
Assessors Signature (optional) : Prue Sturgess
Dated: 09/11/2014
Unit Overview
A critical and comparative study of the novel and film adaptation of
The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe
Focus group: year 5
ACARA outcomes included in lesson sequence:
Identify aspects of literary texts that convey details or information about particular
social, cultural and historical contexts (ACELT1608)
Identify and explain characteristic text structures and language features used in
imaginative, informative and persuasive texts to meet the purpose of the text
(ACELY1701)
Understand how adverb groups/phrases and prepositional phrases work in different
ways to provide circumstantial details about an activity (ACELA1495)
Plan, rehearse and deliver presentations for defined audiences and purposes
incorporating accurate and sequenced content and multimodal elements
(ACELY1700)
Navigate and read texts for specific purposes applying appropriate text processing
strategies, for example predicting and confirming, monitoring meaning, skimming
and scanning (ACELY1702)
Create literary texts that experiment with structures, ideas and stylistic features of
selected authors (ACELT1798)
Compare texts including media texts that represent ideas and events in different
ways, explaining the effects of the different approaches (ACELY1708)
Participate in and contribute to discussions, clarifying and interrogating ideas,
developing and supporting arguments, sharing and evaluating information,
experiences and opinions (ACELY1709)
Plan, draft and publish imaginative, informative and persuasive texts, choosing and
experimenting with text structures, language features, images and digital resources
appropriate to purpose and audience (ACELY1714)
Identify and explain how analytical images like figures, tables, diagrams, maps and
graphs contribute to our understanding of verbal information in factual and
persuasive texts (ACELA1524)
Page 2 of 36
Lesso
n
1
Outcomes
Lesson Details
(ACELT1608)
(ACELY1701)
(ACELY1709)
Lesso
n
2
Outcomes
(ACELY1701)
(ACELY1709)
Outcomes
Notes /
Resources
A copy of the
novel for each
student.
Paper and pens.
Dictionaries for
each group.
Lesson Details
(ACELA1495)
Lesso
Notes /
Resources
Literacy work
Teacher will re-introduce the
concept of literature circles and will books.
remind students of the requirements
Pencils/pens.
of each role within the group:
passage picker, word wizard, artful White-board.
artist, summarizer, connector and
discussion director.
Students will focus on the first two
chapters of the text, and are to
concentrate on the actions of the
characters when undertaking their
roles.
The group will share their findings
amongst themselves, with the
summarizer taking notes so as to
share with the rest of the class.
Whole class discussion about
descriptive language, followed by
teacher explanation of adverbials.
Lesson Details
Page 3 of 36
Notes /
n
3
(ACELY1700)
(ACELY1702)
Lesso
n
4
Outcomes
(ACELA1495)
(ACELY1709)
Lesson
Outcomes
Resources
Students will be divided into groups of
Writing
four, with each group member materials.
allocated the role of one of the four
siblings (from the novel).
Students will be given time to list
character traits presented by their
allocated character in the novel.
Students will then rehearse a scene of
their choice from the novel.
Groups will take turns performing
their selected scene, with the teacherin-role as an additional character when
required (e.g. professor, faun etc.)
Students will list the character traits of
their character in the respective
column which will be drawn on the
white board (if the same character trait
is listed more than once for the same
character, a tally system will be
introduced).
Space
to
rehearse
and
perform drama
activity.
White-board
and markers.
Lesson Details
(ACELY1701)
(ACELT1798)
Notes /
Resources
Whole class discussion regarding the White-board
main characters in the novel. Students and markers.
will offer suggestions of adverbials
and adverbial groups which could be
used to describe respective characters.
Students will highlight adverbial
groups found within the provided
passages (see Appendix A).
Whole class discussion regarding how
the adverbials served to describe the
character/s and his/her actions.
Assessment Task 1: Students will
work individually to select a passage
from the novel. Students will then
highlight the adverbials present in the
passage and complete an illustration
informed by these (See Appendix B for
assessment rubric).
Lesson Details
Copy of the
novel for each
student.
Students
literacy
work
books.
Notes
Page 4 of 36
5
(ACELY1702)
(ACELY1708)
(ACELY1709)
(ACELA1524)
Lesson Outcomes
Lesson Details
6*
Lesson Outcomes
Lesson Details
7*
Page 5 of 36
Resources
Students
will
have
watched
the film version
of the story
prior to this
lesson.
White A3 paper,
crayons
and
food-dye.
Writing paper
and pens.
Notes /
Resources
Notes /
Resources
Lesson Outcomes
8
(ACELY1709)
Lesson Details
(ACELY1714)
Lesson Outcomes
9
(ACELY1709)
Lesson Details
(ACELT1798)
Page 6 of 36
Notes /
Resources
Example
completed comic
strip.
Screenshots
from the movie.
Comic
strip
templates
for
each student.
Drawing
writing
materials.
and
Notes /
Resources
Short story from
Paul Jennings
book Uncanny
Literacy
books
work
Lesson Outcomes
10
(ACELY1709)
Lesson Details
(ACELT1798)
(ACELY1714)
Notes /
Resources
Students
will
require
additional time
to complete the
final assessment
task.
A selection of
picture books.
White A4 paper.
Art supplies.
Staplers.
Access
cameras,
computers,
printers.
Page 7 of 36
to
(making explicit
the semiotic /
characterisation
focus, getting to
know the film
excerpts,
viewing for
comprehension
and response)
Deconstruction
(Teacher-led
analysis of visual
semiotic features
- explicit
teaching /
practice of target
elements and
Resources
needed
Print-outs of
the
screenshots
to display.
Page 8 of 36
how they
construct
characterisation
Joint
Construction
(teacher-and
Page 9 of 36
student
construction of a
character
practising the
visual semiotic
features taught)
Independent
construction
(student-led
construction of
character using
target semiotics)
Paper.
Drawing/
writing
materials.
Camera/s.
Teachers
laptop.
Camera
connection
cord.
Smart-board.
Detailed Lesson Critical Literacy Lesson using novel and film excerpts
English outcome(s):
Page 10 of 36
Identify aspects of literary texts that convey details or information about particular
social, cultural and historical contexts (ACELT1608)
Compare texts including media texts that represent ideas and events in different ways,
explaining the effects of the different approaches (ACELY1708)
Participate in and contribute to discussions, clarifying and interrogating ideas,
developing and supporting arguments, sharing and evaluating information, experiences
and opinions (ACELY1709)
Setting the
context /
building the
field
(activating
prior
knowledge
about either
gender or race
issues; the film
and novel
excerpts to be
used in the
lesson)
Deconstructio
n: novel
(Teacher led
critical
questions and
discussion on
novel excerpts)
Deconstructio
n: film
(Teacher led
critical
questions and
discussion on
film excerpts)
Resources
needed
Print-outs
of
the
required
excerpts
from
the
novel.
Copies of
the
screenshots
from
the
film.
Page 11 of 36
Whiteboard and
markers to
list
key
ideas.
(joint activity
to compare
texts)
Lined
paper.
Pen/pencil.
(activity to
consolidate
knowledge
about either
Page 12 of 36
White
paper.
A4
Drawing
materials.
gender or race)
References
Australian Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Authority [ACARA]. (2014). The
Australian
Curriculum:
English.
Retrieved
from
http://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/english/curriculum/f-10?layout=1#level5
Australian Government Australian Research Council. (2010). Visual literacy: How do I make
meaning.
Retrieved
Page 13 of 36
from
http://portals.studentnet.edu.au/literacy/Minisites/SCEGGSDarlinghurstrevised/vliter
acy/meaning.htm
Aylmey, H. (2012). Having some fun. English In Aotearoa, (77), 15-18.
Farmer, D. (2014). Drama resource. Retrieved from http://dramaresource.com/strategies
Fraraccio, V. (2008). When is a hula hoop not a hula hoop? When it's a Venn diagram.
Teacher, (194).
Graham, J. E. (2004). Women, sex, and power: Circe and Lilith in Narnia. Childrens
Literature Association Quarterly, 29(1-2), 32-44.
Humphrey, S., Droga, S. & Feez, S. (2012). Grammar and meaning. Sydney: Primary
English Teaching Association of Australia.
Jennings, P. (1994). Uncanny. Melbourne, Victoria: Penguin Books Limited.
Johnson, M., & Adamson, A. (Producers), & Adamson, A. (Director). (2005). The Lion the
witch and the wardrobe [Motion picture]. [With W. Moseley, A. Popplwell, S. Keynes
& G. Henley]. United States: Walt Disney Pictures & Walden Media.
Lewis, C. S. (1970). The lion, the witch & the wardrobe. Victoria, Australia: Penguin Books
Australia. (Original work published 1950).
Literacy Solutions. (2014). Literature circle role cards. Retrieved from
http://www.literacysolutions.com.au/resources/literature-role-cards.php
MacNaughton, G., & Williams, G. (2009). Techniques for teaching young children. (3rd ed.).
Frenchs Forest, NSW: Pearson Education Australia.
Marsh, C. (2010). Becoming a teacher: Knowledge, skills and issues. (5th ed.). Frenchs
Forest, NSW: Pearson Australia.
Page 14 of 36
Nixon, R. (2012). Teaching narrative writing using comics: Delainey and Rasmussen, the
creators of Betty, share their composing strategies as rich literacy resources for
elementary teachers. Literacy, 46(2), 81-93.
Rimmon-Kenan, S. (1983) Narrative fiction: contemporary poetics. London: Methuen.
Russell-Bowie, D. (2012). Drama in education. In MADD about the Arts: an Introduction to
Primary Arts Education (3rd ed.). Sydney, Australia: Pearson Education Australia.
Starko, A, J. (2014). Creativity in the Classroom: Schools of Curious Delight. (5th ed.). Third
Avenue, New York: Routledge.
State of NSW Department of Education and Training. (2003). Quality teaching in public
schools. Retrieved from
https://www.det.nsw.edu.au/proflearn/docs/pdf/qt_EPSColor.pdf
The College Board. (2010). Literature circles. Retrieved from http://www.gcisdk12.org/cms/lib/TX01000829/Centricity/Domain/61/Literature_Circles.pdf
Winch, G., Ross Johnston, R., March, P., Ljungdall, L., Holliday, M. (2010). Literacy (4th
ed.). South Melbourne, VIC: Oxford University Press
Appendix A
Passages from the novel containing adverbials (lesson 4)
Lewis, C. S. (1970). The lion, the witch & the wardrobe. Victoria, Australia: Penguin Books
Australia. (Original work published 1950).
Edmund was already feeling uncomfortable from having eaten too many sweets, and
when he heard that the lady he had made friends with was a dangerous witch he felt even
more uncomfortable. But he still wanted to taste that Turkish Delight again more than
anything else. (p.42).
Page 15 of 36
Edmund, who was becoming a nastier person every minute, thought that he had
scored a great success, and went on at once to say, There she goes again. Whats the matter
with her? Thats the worst of young kids, they always- Look here, said Peter, turning on
him savagely, shut up! Youve been perfectly beastly to Lu ever since she started this
nonsense about the wardrobe, and now you go playing games with her about it and setting
her off again. I believe you did it simply out of spite. (p.45).
So they went and knocked at the study door, and the Professor said Come in and got
up and found chairs for them and said he was quite at their disposal. The he sat listening to
them with the tips of his fingers pressed together and never interrupting, till they had finished
the whole story. After that he said nothing for quite a long time. Then he cleared his throat
and said the last thing either of them had expected: How do you know that your sisters
story is not true? (p.46).
Appendix B
Rubric for Assessment task 1 (lesson 4)
Working Towards
Satisfactory
Page 16 of 36
High Achievement
Excellent Achievement
Ability to
identify
adverbials in
text
Student is
beginning to
develop an
understanding of
adverbials.
Student has
demonstrated the
ability to identify
some adverbials.
Student competently
identifies most
adverbials in a given
text.
Student correctly
identifies adverbials,
including adverbial
groups in texts.
Understanding
of the role of
adverbials in
written text.
Student is working
towards an
understanding of
the contribution of
adverbials to a
passage of writing.
Student demonstrates
some understandings
of the impact of
adverbials on a
passage of writing.
Student is able to
accurately describe
how adverbials
influence a passage
of writing.
Student demonstrates a
high level of
understanding
regarding the
contribution of
adverbials to a passage
of writing.
Application of
understanding
Student has
completed a piece of
artwork to an
acceptable standard.
The written
explanation
demonstrates a basic
understanding of the
role of adverbials in
a passage of writing.
Student has
successfully
completed a piece of
artwork, along with
an explanation
demonstrating a
succinct
understanding of the
role of adverbials in
informing their
finished work.
Appendix C
Screenshots for Comic Strips (lesson 8)
Johnson, M., & Adamson, A. (Producers), & Adamson, A. (Director). (2005). The Lion the
witch and the wardrobe [Motion picture]. [With W. Moseley, A. Popplwell, S. Keynes
& G. Henley]. United States: Walt Disney Pictures & Walden Media.
Page 17 of 36
Page 18 of 36
Page 19 of 36
Appendix D
Rubric for Assessment Task 2 (lesson 10)
Working Towards
Satisfactory
High Achievement
Excellent Achievement
Description of
character
Student is
beginning to build
an understanding
of character.
Student has
demonstrated the
ability to identify
relevant character
traits and has
attempted to include
these in the text.
Student competently
identifies elements
of character and has
included these in
completed text.
Student effectively
relates elements of
character to the
reader through
thoughtful selection
of descriptive
language.
Plot Structure/
Planning
Plot follows a
somewhat logical
sequence of
development.
Plot advances
thoughtfully and
effectively.
No planning
evident.
Little evidence of
planning
Some evidence of
planning
Evident thoughtful
planning process.
Language
Language included
in the text was
inappropriate for
this format.
Spelling mistakes
and grammatical
errors common
throughout the
text.
Appropriate
language has been
implemented
throughout the text.
There are few
spelling mistakes
and grammatical
errors.
Language included in
the text is of an
advanced level. There
are no apparent
spelling mistakes or
grammatical errors.
Use of
imagery/multimedi
a
The imagery/
multimedia does
not support the
written text or task
requirements.
Student has
completed a
multimodal text.
The imagery/
multimedia
included in the
finished product is
somewhat
appropriate.
Student has
successfully
completed a
multimodal text. The
imagery/multimedia
supports the written
text effectively.
Student has
effectively conveyed
understanding of the
requirements of the
task. Text is
complimented by the
usage of appropriate
imagery/ multimedia.
Appendix E
Page 20 of 36
Finished product is of
a high standard.
Screenshots from the film, utilised in Detailed Lesson 1: Characterisation lesson using
the film
Johnson, M., & Adamson, A. (Producers), & Adamson, A. (Director). (2005). The Lion the
witch and the wardrobe [Motion picture]. [With W. Moseley, A. Popplwell, S. Keynes
& G. Henley]. United States: Walt Disney Pictures & Walden Media.
First Selection of screenshots, depicting Edmunds character at the beginning of the film:
Page 21 of 36
Page 22 of 36
The second selection of screenshots depicting Edmunds character towards the end of
the film:
Page 23 of 36
Page 24 of 36
Page 25 of 36
Appendix F
Page 26 of 36
Novel excerpts and film screenshots utilised in Detailed Lesson 2: critical literacy
lesson using novel and film
Lewis, C. S. (1970). The lion, the witch & the wardrobe. Victoria, Australia: Penguin Books
Australia. (Original work published 1950).
Page 27 of 36
Novel Excerpts describing the physical appearance and character of The White Witch.
But behind him, on a much higher seat in the middle of the sledge sat a very different
person a great lady, taller than any woman that Edmund had ever seen. She also was
covered in white fur up to her throat and held a long straight golden wand in her right hand
and wore a golden crown on her head. Her face was white not merely pale, but white like
snow or paper or icing-sugar, except for her very red mouth. It was a beautiful face in other
respects, but proud and cold and stern And what, pray, are you? said the Lady, looking
hard at Edmund.
Im Im my names Edmund, said Edmund rather awkwardly. He did not like the
way she looked at him.
The lady frowned, Is that how you address a Queen? she asked, looking sterner than
ever.
I beg your pardon, your majesty, I didnt know, said Edmund.
Not know the Queen of Narnia? cried she. Ha! You shall know us better hereafter.
But I repeat what are you? (pp.33-34).
But what are you? said the Queen again. Are you a great overgrown dwarf that has
cut off its beard?
No, your majesty, said Edmund, I never had a beard, Im a boy.
A boy! said she. Do you mean you are a Son of Adam?
Edmund stood still, saying nothing. He was too confused by this time to understand
what the question meant.
I see you are an idiot, whatever else you may be, said the Queen. Answer me, once
and for all, or I shall lose my patience. Are you human?
Yes, your majesty, said Edmund. (p.35).
Page 28 of 36
Thats what I dont understand, Mr Beaver, said Peter, I mean isnt the Witch
herself human?
Shed like us to believe it, said Mr Beaver, and its on that that she bases her claim
to be Queen. But shes no Daughter of Eve. She comes of your father Adams (here Mr
Beaver bowed) your father Adams first wife, her they called Lilith. And she was one of the
Jinn. Thats what she comes from on one side. And on the other she comes of the giants. No,
no, there isnt a drop of real human blood in the Witch.
Thats why shes bad all through, Mr Beaver, said Mrs Beaver. (p. 76).
Novel excerpts depicting Aslan.
Who is Aslan? asked Susan.
Aslan? said Mr Beaver. Why dont you know? Hes the King. Hes the Lord of the
whole wood, but not often here, you understand. Never in my time or my fathers time. But
the word has reached us that he has come back. He is in Narnia at this moment. Hell settle
the White Queen all right. It is he, not you that will save Mr Tumnus. (p.74).
We have come Aslan.
Welcome, Peter, Son of Adam, said Aslan. Welcome, Susan and Lucy, Daughters of
Eve. Welcome He-Beaver and She-Beaver.
His voice was deep and rich and somehow took the fidgets out of them. They now
felt glad and quiet and it didnt seem awkward to them to stand and say nothing.
But where is the fourth? asked Aslan.
He has tried to betray them and joined the White Witch, O Aslan, said Mr Beaver.
And then something made Peter say, That was partly my fault Aslan. I was angry with him
and I think that helped him to go wrong.
And Aslan said nothing either to excuse Peter or to blame him but merely stood
looking at him with his great unchanging eyes. And it seemed to all of them that there was
nothing to be said. (pp. 117-118).
Page 29 of 36
We have a long journey to go. You must ride on me. And he crouched down and the
children climbed on to his warm, golden back, and Susan sat first, holding on tightly to his
mane and Lucy sat behind holding on tightly to Susan. And with a great heave he rose
underneath them and then shot off, faster than any horse could go, down hill and into the
thick of the forest. (p.149).
Now for the inside of this house! said Aslan. Look alive, everyone. Up stairs and
down stairs and in my ladys chamber! Leave no corner unsearched. You never know where
some poor prisoner may be concealed. (p.155).
Page 30 of 36
Page 31 of 36
Page 32 of 36
Page 33 of 36
Page 34 of 36
Assessment Guide
Criterion 1: Design lessons which: (a) are sequenced to teach students cumulative knowledge about
literature; (b) teach critical and comparative approaches to literature; (c) teach students how to
interpret meanings of words and images (80%)
1(a) Sequenced
lessons to teach
cumulative
knowledge about
literature (30%)
HD
DN
CR
PP
NN
There is a logical
sequence based on a
pedagogical model
to all lessons in the
unit, providing
opportunities for
cumulative learning
about literature.
A significant
number of elements
from the quality
teaching framework
are evident and
applied thoughtfully
and critically.
There is a logical
sequence to all
lessons in the unit,
providing
opportunities for
cumulative
learning about
literature.
A significant
number of
elements from the
quality teaching
framework are
evident.
There is a logical
sequence to most
lessons in the unit,
providing
opportunities for
cumulative learning
about literature.
There is a logical
sequence to some
lessons in the unit,
providing
opportunities for
cumulative learning
about literature.
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
Some elements
from the quality
teaching framework
are evident.
A few elements
from the quality
teaching framework
are evident.
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
Deep knowledge
Deep understanding
Problematic knowledge
Higher-order thinking
Metalanguage
Substantive communication
Engagement
High expectations
Social support
Students self-regulation
Student direction
DN
HD
CR
Significance
Background knowledge
Cultural knowledge
Knowledge integration
Inclusivity
Connectedness
Narrative
PP
The detailed critical literacy lesson clearly focuses on either an aspect of the
construction of gender or race. The lesson compares the novel and film. An activity
that compares the construction of power in both text forms is included. An
opportunity is provided to students to create their own critical response to the
texts.
Deconstructions
Deconstructions
Deconstruction
Deconstruction
strategies are
strategies are
strategies are
strategies are
included for both
included for both
included for both
included for both
novel and film
novel and film
novel and film
novel and film
excerpts,
excerpts,
excerpts,
excerpts.
demonstrating an
demonstrating a
demonstrating a
exceptional
thorough
reasonable
understanding of
understanding of
understanding of
critical literacy.
critical literacy.
critical literacy.
HD
DN
CR
PP
Characterisation (through the novel) is taught drawing from any one of the
following grammatical elements: participants, processes, circumstances. Any
excerpt used for this minor lesson is included as an appendix.
The lesson
The lesson
The lesson
Some accurate
accurately includes
accurately
accurately includes
probe questions are
deconstruction,
includes a
a deconstruction
included in the
joint constriction,
deconstruction
teaching strategy.
lesson.
and independent
and independent
construction
construction
teaching strategies.
teaching strategy.
Page 35 of 36
NN
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NN
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
HD
DN
CR
PP
NN
Characterisation (through the film) is taught using any three of the following visual
semiotic elements: contact, social distance, power, ambience, salience, narrative
processes, with relevant excerpt(s) from the film. Approximately 10 screenshots are
included with an attempt at analysis of each.
Evidence of critical
Evidence of
Relevant selection
Mostly relevant
and thoughtful
thoughtful sorting
of film excerpts
selection of film
sorting and
and selection of
and related
excerpts and
selection of
relevant film
screenshots to
related screenshots
relevant film
excerpts and
teach
to teach
excerpts and
related
characterisation.
characterisation.
related screenshots
screenshots to
to teach
teach
characterisation.
characterisation.
All three visual
All three visual
At least two visual
At least half of the
semiotic elements
semiotic elements
semiotic elements
visual semiotic
are analysed
are mostly
are mostly analysed elements are
accurately in the
analysed
accurately in the
analysed accurately
screenshot
accurately in the
screenshot
in the screenshot
selection.
screenshot
selection.
selection.
selection.
The lesson
accurately includes
deconstruction,
joint &
independent
constriction.
The lesson
accurately
includes
deconstruction
and independent
construction.
The lesson
accurately includes
deconstruction.
Some accurate
probe questions are
included in the
lesson.
PP
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
NN
NI / Some aspects
need developing
(NI= not included)
Technical aspects
Powerful,
confident and
precise use of
language; mastery
of style and tone
suited to audience.
Spelling,
punctuation,
grammar and
referencing
accurate.
Language use
demonstrates
precision and
clarity.
Language is
generally sound and
clear throughout.
Page 36 of 36
NN
Clear enough to be
understood; some
confused or unclear
expression.
Does not
meet
requirements
for academic
writing.
Spelling, punctuation,
grammar and
referencing generally
satisfactory but likely
to need attention.
Does not
meet
requirements
for academic
writing.