\WEADYSLAW TATARKREWICZ ART AND POETRY ‘A Contribution to the History of Ancient Aesthetics Anetent sod modern Conceptions of Ark ‘Posry smoot caattetre, the plate asa — att tows are wards of Gk ain. Mee poles aye napa ‘om om the Ora fn oar odeigane te are The Ant Gronks sud thao exproviny ba Sor the moe pat uote sete. Tiles wana mach beer andor clog ssi, ot abvaye runt farsi mathre Griinly “pote guid predation egos (ne-— te make; to pods) ad aly Iter aumelt'mach taro ‘unig by Hs application totaal oo type ef podeson tof ats sey, “pout fran whith Seater oat Pe ‘atday “poe, ovghslly guid any typo of producer? “ates mona every aati patronized by the Mave, nd sot only the at of scan “mou, se re ar fp ey ine —" Oop. Pg nae ‘ii mae Hap 5 eye ne ea ie ‘Bont as soe het iene le segs eon [pimeatrn Onc Mga Stem wc8 open tae eB) cekaed, wh under floc! careiaone senstdiecer if poodle ekdeltenie™ Thoin bad the mere oneal sgnicance af ‘Wis the arm of tie, Grok expresons ving rk general aplication sprain, cattcly iodo fotturof mort" soqutel auarower sad more rece, od tir une war aviied to cro divas of ar the cant and the thie) en “ashi. Sisty productions gun to mand for posty, sartae traning” for oy and ‘de spree at er sell ‘Beton eis came pase. the Grea had 0 opal terns to signify thos arts which ftw all wero the glory of thie Cre. They did't ave seh tomes sinply ee yal ot nod th forthe dno operate with ach oneepions i joey, mi welilecnce andthe plains Thin ag ‘pone Intille Wo un so vary nvurtomed are we to thew ‘ecepnurs we cousasly ue them fo sich sa sit that they seem a2 ik were tobe conyptions imposed by Natare aig "forme emestat to expan the peuouens of et Yet inary tear ue that ay toe noe Saomnmry the Creek trie had tone so sn fr te ein dino ve then oe ‘pte ath tine when their seativences eae Soarhing ne Shever dit tare or ebare Even dating the aporh sf tho fount stadia, ofthe Frchnoa, of Pie and Pras Ae a a pe yom iy iF Rene ee heer nereceen tied ig ai cy ee re ses etl fl 2 Se Sc a Sta ale ys ran ace ‘Mepis hs wi om af 8 ofc ok ititet Serna eta by tunes Ce 2 pine mono te oc of pe cnt st pe a ew ee te TOR eA A nae Sa a isi at ata s) 4 nd Poy ow fly sso eas woe lo fn evianng and inthe szotore Of tele coneepiony they were ay fat fem paying sae Filet tay. This dow aot ean tht th coerce {fthe Ancins Gree were aaderloped Te men tense tnt ‘hey wer ter than on Aiough one is ecended fiom tha of tho Greeks wwe obo ein ero ware we tn ate that thi wy sts ‘lations an aethete views wee tia wih aur Paso tl, thi teams of he aris wan dee, Soma othe oss ff ar whieh re t>lay most wes spre ere abate le ‘el she ‘The Greske had a hoppy ey had oly Soke, arate sang, poetry. Albnap hey Sted ua a ‘ramen, their wane wer faintly ral ny had wo purely utsrameotal we Thar arcltctral acy bead fempen, pomiy wo teucutn, atewnye ant sini hall Dt {he acteurs of dealing hose wan Icha toy pected scperels wer pase Jotaty Uy the Ancin Grate and sold tobe tingle rn of Sf This was the ane frites, with soto an dang ‘Th, one expronion'woleed to signify both, Eve when ‘nui had some to lave the prea nase of “tho arf sounds, th xpreie was il most oes we socal {ovembence dining Te wow fom suck ion ha roe ota othe sore parades lag, sch athe st enc Bat sete pefndaranee geet petsy tae the former (ts on tro seas faring nd sight) wit te lator ey Soca Waring Convery io, certain divine af art which ae grouped tonsthr by am wet then rated by eter secs Por Staple + efaman baildigg tomploe wold acter act ang te i Seat ‘Sin bom a elt Dan tubo far dae Bie der greta stiles Catrall sch set an Seat esemo wisp Btanaie 9 sdwelng-boss. Prior 19 the Heit ep, bfin the BIN"Catury BC, hye wee m0 palace Gravy Where seer orly biog of « pore tation type with no mens: [eau or deerative aoprtony sod of « evel of eareton ‘Gite dict to thu ofthe mre eon, Ta lig henaea Sere but by another etary of atin, The Work and ht Jfrolusts fsloned were iar nthe fo perf baling There war to Howd of tion between the tro type sod ft ot smge harelors at na gras copption a rca, fing the eo gzoupm arms ott tine Sila lan igo ia the Belin of spare ui a ert: ia rer (on there wan diflretntion of those rota there ate int Samer of amellr groups: thew nas w ick of cobeon Seng thom gro, hence the lane of the rgpestive genera concepts. ined fer ve, ee onions of rt bial The nor to {eiena. The diferenee was twotld Fin hte poenoras ‘bart were approached no cach other haa inode soap tion The fennnion of conrpican omar the gropi fiver pnsumona. And thi ona be dane diferent wage For fanance, spech wea aol ty the Geeks wit) may, edy with ray, and rts enploying meee, oly, ad ‘iy were costed oto rt Do an a pling pee Sloae ely or shyton alone, wat inl wths she ame Stngoy art eploying speech and tnody together, cody ‘ud tha, a pel, ley nad man oon A hos fhe extent of single concption, Ther was fr the Grek no ‘ice pup bebecen tngedy 8 comedy loamprnag 4 works Sol puly voml ni We follow noon, tat for he Ancint Greeks «ge Ss connpionaly a lovely banal up with ure aad Janeing se eh opie cr Ip pours sr tu His bre pap tat ned grote dress Teen the two ryuemt of ensayo the ld sod the ao = ar ut oy sm ke Grove for tng diepnsed wich thew ery ganere com teolons mich have fr or tose mot cuvet eae, S'S posey, sei areca and the plano att.” Ir teas ty had very bond encanta a fut apne fom thi they olf had, om te whale, congo Parner enoat, socks teat ihprambiey st: spiny ot Ismeiaying™ Te hin ist of the liars ay, nabs’ umertadtrgely, sel comely, on, apie and corpo of py, Sh Share ny oem flog toe cep ‘Soc semrone wo do ty” ewig or my dates ents i nt en pees tas owt SSL Wine in tage emenpon i ri ve Ton ape etic sy ated eng to {Tn cus oo yest pony he oat Uk onyftiy nad bys en elon Such ystems oad emt only ‘name deisel sion of werk eng thea SL's cer dpe fv fownt speach ae {by hs Giclee gol ft wa {'npdncwn, an Unt ofthe spectro brett atch pape. taal ak of on toe nog pte es 2e et wtog Dr a Remogeey fay “nega anton of leat amie the wee et a ili pn ie ccna ong igen as ra pn EMRE Ra Tae fe gn ater AMF a na i nga (pots jor mana 3 1 me tt 1 oe te ey lms ont {haven a nie 9 “fn, Pin 1 rubato des Marce vw tae lit ne Pl‘wot Ethie each of which wos eatcutedeaoogh the medina of aster me ‘Shy other manne wad by eter porns ‘re samp thir phar of as on a With ours i can te aatod thn the Ancient Groin poser the apex tl (6 benef the pra fans conenpionsy he sox ‘he commits he bse we orotate Gfvwry specie aad bartow eoneptonn Tee Orek did nt, vere, pose the Tntermetate pact wieh whisk modern Thought pamioe mot wilingly. JE wil ke atows ln, for ‘hat atin Unt the apex ofthe Grek stom diired from ‘ur pra! one, viz, Hd ot tally hare one apex but twee ‘ving to te spe tate of the clawicl wot of onepiou, soe theses which sre parwloiel wher trmed {fom the mandjict of oy atm wer hen jad dn ‘et cue nears The ee of tha wae’ what eo at tho Sow consider wr tpi! ofa mare by bo rennn conn ty the Groce an teonging to » common lat ‘This was iy the cone with posty ail he pst at. Te at ried an = opia ofa ut petty Was ot u. ‘he Conception of Art arnt lication of pty an the lati ate hy the Ania Grote appete se okingly ie ir specs ‘lsat entiation ofthe post and of de pti arti ‘eins soni sf hay of he Eee tytn suk ds f ibe somnye Ko ly i Src tne tat oer dein to heal epost ing tho Anh and oven ving th och srry, the ate att wa Irate sence ‘wis te fut a neta te ead ha tt pepe “Tho Cranks i'tove day opp yet an aria ss aaner feng tomes fr tha imple ase shat IBF Gofertcad ar wut poneysterwite, Their comprbesion war (hee bran ape thee two Kr whish ao alld foro into ih connplin of et ited I wan wo em ttrued det eembre! Ue plato st He exaded POT m st a Per a “au (gon) nas the term appa ia Ancit Gress to voy proscton Which wae ste al iro say which Wa ‘Mel cconing wo et vals abd prnsgln* The the work fon soitct oF © sealer aneware to this dition Bat eid she work efx vargotor ot 8 weaver All tne were ‘cringe Greek, fara of se a (engtep a {hair aves ant yrofucts In eqoal mama Ieoaged to oale of at Thar we nos tat the conception of arin Grose nd ancter ooiet mid wo erent extent that ene prma™ Cy ean om thie abject can o tala eo grt thet ach «comprehension of fv was "anivenl ip the simer of Anigey, Ware Asote ‘efoad ate at sibe abiity of eacentang someting will pe sapreboson,* he proved hat he rll derstand ort inthe ‘ara wy, on as soe cease ar Quintin who dened 1's “pana iat ent odie fins. © The Ste laced ‘al greater ics on thy gu and oarant yen oat she they wie gen fod ater Ta oda wo pre the ars ia hin wide sgniaon of he Gress, st wer noosa fo be walowed ie only Wilh Psd destcty but no a peimaely wich itll abe Thy. ise with knowl of eeu, Haney alta at leo ‘bmcel the carpenters nnd weavers cafe tha Gee cs (Sadi ac an intatbesnal gout. Tels ee, they tinned {etm coin and Shear, Bt thay none hf phan tee 8 on 9 apo ar scat ang ong ee ole ao hoe ray fea nse em aie mon Sa sor donae Se Seen ee Sie ae See seat EE soe SESS GS SEE ela ow mn po a are es SSS eaa Weta Beatie s hat ie ba on nowlege ants ina cet aes itll formas prt of knowlege tei yea Twas 0 spruces eoeleige™ tent tana Asst called fs ome {rolinction to tno knowedgs or eoguton, or the Gra uuivesnltc way of thiniog war oven hadley Cu ty high overs ear sonnei to wand igh tan if compecoated in ch win waa cnmplx pbeononen hich as ttm enters jonouomal soe pssoing not one Tit many se of emer! wer oppowl to ata 0 the eck ten! to poepion, ar racial sciiy to peutic, Ie pretest; 10 fratoneneny, 4b Darna Sia dens ant apt oxperoncn main more of evry cvapton of art snot foceign 10 Buti arly ‘appar tay ter thin aoe As ao andere ily ta sblvvintion fr “Bae ws ra sealer conception Be Econ of whch contitter ony» par of mt ofthe Geek {heap of are The Aacont Ores hal 0 tame fer tit Sue sope sinc we tall ey hey Al mot nage ot Teche ches of plenowmna To wht the Atciegt Gro clad hk conwerant shor some wer terms The word scat wel ty tr oly cover pact of the watt of he Ore, ‘Secopios of "us Petpet clowet oulvaent ut wee ce af “iechnboe, whic drives from the anne “te ‘The tradition of the Grask conception of “techno lasted oe lois Tarot thy Mile Agen fas Ba teeaning, With the coura of time, however, the am aft 1. mn er et eelue dine Bauer nahn Chat ‘Mea bef iy few ar a sig {i gr i ie pei Female cosa vgey wih gis we well oe with torn se ple ta ue rin ar sma ons ngage ery a he fas ‘ump ave pe apeang wt at br oho Sear eA pla hina to ase fa mi see et ty 6 spare as « spate division aad i modern ner ecoped ‘ipredominot poston asine to are ww ey ly sane ‘nomen of the aw lym a time tat soaking of “ar only the moat ingore pert of 5s farmers ates an eoviago, Th forbar bold on ‘eptna became more an sore angie ately al ne ‘ison was sopesmiod by the tarewer ones, ‘he tent a tho Grek cnceane fare me wider an ‘ant ofthe medora ene by tha Inlunon ef thot of heat ‘ich se aot new cited ac "hte, Ia abe wer he Thaomtical arts or tosses sod the huseestie Ona ther ha ab we al weit war sarower eater rnc cing to Tho exon of Yt "Dhare wesw od ramon that win dr connption of si the Gronks grouped the Soe at paintings sclpar aod ‘ebitectere tgs ish the Dante er they eve coe cad tint ce ence a sclera ecpter yo Pn eral a wasters work wan the ste; notlag ape from ikl protuton*wat the wot ofl tw eects ‘This elmo” of “aka podaecout ian wap vated math oinewise dvr vison of pratstion tn tnlpare and {intng or we sme tne so bowed em up wile the Incas, "Tho sclpor aa the patter wont Wo anther adi, wish ter tns an apie ether tach edhe Te they Eat aly thin in comton forthe reek we that ‘her proction wes tat oh kl And athe see sone vv che production of cabana work A gence conception ‘Which crac all et dvsone ofthe pate te cae bu “altaseoulylitewive embrace che cra ‘The win arts us thay ere Incr ele, wer no een 1 reporate bon ofthe rts wth toe, Gr Ty {otierotine tw ar eosin a ead Pherae se ‘ch slain was Onknowe a thow dap, Te wes tbr ousdecat That every art, he brow moe ote frye ‘ain harmony ash hence, easy tn very eee eet ‘ope fr mater to iting Bilt fom oe ay crn ee hm ti newe Wipe Saronic uo, ‘The wots sud tobe diferent in acter manner the een the serie arts, in dependence om tho Woe or py (Scat ther praon "Tair war m ore! division aad ee with yen navtellyrocngeizedakhowgh apron by ‘Deage of w ideent Yoraslogy.Latar thnory ch ws Po ‘Silos (sted by Seneca) er Galan, a tn adda to thee {ro bac types two etry Wit opm Ree rd libres nd ulperes tiny ncn emmsiod artes puoi ned falar, ot [ivtrctive and amstsing” ‘Bae toh ie tim eign two and ‘eter fourfold divin the ne ast i nat appar ae tintin dison f the sotmienton, or een ad they belong to oun single division: they were split up amongst the various Aivisins sine sows of thom, tke scalptce nl archibectre Alnatviad grat pyeial eer: and so were lacloded among ‘he seria arn in contention Uo Printing 8 tenet Incl inte vo" catgory. For tne mater war ely Inte tnt Panpiile sce in having” peeing Toad tite thy oer ary pro to tht Ue st war coasted ar one ‘fhe satel en On tho other bea, muse was wage one (ofthe fro act since the actives of micas’ were com ‘id to be pielyietulataal io the same degre the Other casaiations of te arte were abt cccaoully Mitel Avion Grose, One of eas was the dition of Sir int howe which tmnlvenscute their tasks ad tho Shick te dependant on other sactare (ale). Aaother war {ho divion ito the which are necemcy so those wich Serve for tecnatiou (Arisa). Anotee vas based on faviece su agit caleaation (Pate\* ‘hen thew was the {ENinon ine tort, reel ad pote — the paca + Kastan of ar dapendent on extern! Fcare uted by Go das ary ane ed anon, Sagal ame op dream — yr Bice stetaber eta tte einai tage A dndpons Peper Bn eerie fi ne samp 8 uy moors tamer rag Topas nanens cner ae SASL Si Wa Dent dios. ee sont oncarnan ti es Bina be Shasta edit or anaes chee a Gels SLT ees te etc ns rior ans Ree nee See emacs te Pegi eget preety soy Se iy ie ners eo Stace ae sb eee wn seen Sete carmakers ‘hoon piloopher the axtnt of Stave eit id wt cease Ye thst of in a nce om te one ao ot all “neat te Dera 1 embers sr Rum trogen ne gis ned Soups Te ating "Ea on See Peg jo se te a eH wf Gr Sere, Yaa A Ey 8 6a pe ye Ssos Winyie Suetenae 0) ax imate, anon ho other, uot al “imate ate which 1 dtguty fats, gy shear) nt oe ‘Cosieed ot al ceria om ale proton and this ‘Sue saltaneualy of star tho oenss of masy eter oiled ‘cutone, hency, the ealpor sil not fadamentlly difer oom the carpentn Thay it lifer the grou ha the fh of on arias is» ghar and owe grt be sha hat GPoow ann, Lei rus tho Goel deontated between Sidhe and slower rufa bat the cra of senl}ar wat tie father wish tt of » aryl n the Tomer ener ys hie we lacine buh elvions of prodaction rire figtca for’ — always e desing ting noriing to tbe Sncent Grea "The enon of such » comprehen of the art wos saysiom of vier concnptoae whic sec parade Gov eyue, This nstem wan mack that it gute ro tothe fle Sowing 2 the Qrvengecy Ratwsen the appa ofthe ae {cH that of his works; (the ivergenny between apt ond ‘any tthe dvngeny between the plies and poste. ‘tole happens tee ne take pleasare smn work but dpi its mater! rate Planch nh if st Poley ad wa trot undoubnly harboured anst esha ofthe lave! em Pt Te the ida f beat bt trove to dees aA FRvvace coms vow it chai tes that pty in ne fait whist te plane ase sve a ply aon ashironens, Sha see of toe Jowart at Unt ven much Inter, i Heme ine Horace. poodered ths punt whaer poet wes au art ah mL ‘The Conception oF Poetry ‘The protacin of pot, comand by ex at allie ‘oat oft gator oy a arkint id not ener within tom ‘eploa of as fornuaied by ibe Oreks” ‘They sonore 3) end Booey m9 ry tobe dpe of both thw characteris teat of ant AUichet production fo the tater seone anti 2 Cll fovemet By ele. Te the prof, aot of general rales, bt Plolivtal ea, a6 cf rane tat of oratirenen, ot of ‘AT bat ot inepinion An areibe Imo te erarente {fsoconafal work; ho can give thir proportions by the sd ‘tyros nmercl Sta pn Which he can depend. But pt Shoave fer to any tones or Weare he exertion of it Slo team cay eran othe bap of Apts tad the Mes Tuc souinn lll by the experience of past generis wat tho Grose tho wale aod warp of art but they prev ie would fatal nthe se Of poetry. Hence ey not nly lininatd” poetry ioe vt Bak evecare 1 he tae of th Ite, ‘Ont oer ban, they mite some lationship tween poery an proiy, The ator wae Hid af ati the fee's Ling bank "The ssviine af th fore ate pal oman whine show cf th last ate duped ty the Gols der alg, vad eve Ari Cnt ates thd matic of the Grosk phlowpre. eu, he ntti of hal at (ay for that matter of every oxfam) rere fecogited ty the Gra ar not nly speing anual ll ‘ts itll bay” ae in psy Uy aw 0 apa ur fa higher aoe Ps hight ray reeled in poetry ‘euler be tne fom th God The poet sag « erm igi as animate Uy he divi reentrant {tho Brus wich pet th werd aml mata onder Hoo Mo tty ote ove bay as srly 0 0 fre secre the neck of huowlege. herd fre ‘hi kuomielge at thie pple ia ya! matere tothe hashaotna ter the chant athe abit i Dv ie A,0 Wadgew Daaien a "Toe Grosks tai stn om ail anther property of psy pee it ty to ialwnce ep to tan = Grok ora! The abiley wat om the ‘avd Uy thes a Eaoal ape fo" Posty Was ‘hough a facinate te ewsh fo moor mini Some [pie tery high, av an almost rperhumas Powers thery ck wy Pato conde i on the oer of x tionally 1 ean auaterfater bering of pty fom atc as i fet ina ni tttas Om the acer bl, Gorgias omplasecl in hie Praise a Fae in propery roma fer mors and brings ows Into proximity wih pile ‘oper rary ssa wl her wh ase tw vol ee intone to fot thr spa! is of thers "hia, forthe ancient, all asvity mas tee oo Know leage: Exposing thomiines iodine fre (endo toe stent ncoresly they even ated hat all ty tame ledge. Poetry war 20! su eaception fa thin cesar) To ther ids twas even Anew of fhe high typ oe ated ‘he apn worl ant hl econren ivan age T rashes to rly geste within srk yee the Patou, the pout an the plonphorstod eat to each ‘tee: Morover voli tt ponry dol with the general exe presi of paeneny, Arnot wrote the cua, le: fophioals thes history. wach ony dries indie! is “tac powry leo Belg in comm ih aos ‘hat of knowledge, athe worl of Hnowinigeorongied on fon bik wat diaautly” oppose, wr tecaal sees Spin which ae bole. fei fatima od fren, whe sein based spon saporisor aed putin turning i tsk {o expos the ese f ting whens att Fewes Wel 9 ‘Be pheaomne and tet of Antiqits, ting sinplercatngron an he ration of Maa tafe any in ewe "erm zee wa fn pl 2p Patt otry fu Phat 3 a yh tnt Pt ee tear cet Santer Frater’ {818 8) sean ety st ret es gyi Bonita Sr arte os te Sone iiete mister rection mei Aals erst beta e e Eon oineseenerc tt gay Sia ce Pane ee aatipeeet ts Mitt i arte pe ee Ei ov area sear ei see pag sna Se carte Wil pl oe hep are Pag sw En al SIV ce inc Rast it ioe nh hina Wie be SRS aio te ator itis “ae apna ae ha RITDAIE pa ga etal ea Shh Stee re Sos noes oN cro ries SVLIIASS Shan a SEAS Beat ay creer SMUT Eau Scien San te Sige acca ey oc! ile ee ae wah pee” maa Lay ee SSE SAAE ee mmr ps BOUT peta ol py ne sine ala an a at em mob mea es 1 oe Areca aterom Wty taetoner 5) wiki» Nomogenson erp) to be lid by the Ore i Saher iin of kamu act. To factors wh dv he ‘Tere bough on ino the oregrond and conceal bir ramon {operon whic in tan ate ephadod, pera oversteugy, ff stston pom ther common proyertin whish aw I to {heir ftaion within‘ ramon anceps. The Grae Icke {ie toe af spyrachs they tar a0 onteson betwore what sro cone ind of Bd wad nt which Uy ee "Thre ny Bowever, reeaton to bs mide a8 1 the Ors teopton of pouty. The Oreck hd eo moder ef ‘compstending ptr. Ont tha alveydieuscd bores Wor govern Uy the sujet of pote; the oor hy it orm ‘coring to he firmer, pontey was uae ae bat het ‘ imprton sa su weights pect wonton. Accrdiag to ‘he mond, ae whatever press in vot form, Ty ibe Inter ene, stn for prodeton to be in vee frit to ‘called poctry The formal concepsion wes much nore tng {od ws Urlre goacally sae nore de pty ant ‘pind ot erro. Poste wrote Gorgig i the tae poy wee sompebeade ony in rch wi i¢ weed fulycxneie wth the ancien conerptng of at tk Benon ould Tasinh ao grown for sopertng it om te para ‘Thins homeren onl an enteral gouge woe by Antiquity The weigh which they lsbte toi war bed on trode wate Und — thet of is inlrnal sompreeasion. An ts on ese frocnds tat they loted wim hi oreo enspton Se Seiile wrote: ee pont ina poet mane beams of the jee of hin works then toons of thi nesta foe ‘This twotldexprnon of pouy evoked a cataln ome ‘the coneption then caene™ Ariat bast the La mi Hales, $9 eg in sl a en te ee stb sw Ee a a mp hii “ct nt fe my Aes Pa os in Pate? ven if 9 theory of welsne or physi hie oy be pt foe in mteea form, it ie art %0 cal Ue tster a pots omer and nyedeleg, Lewes, ve fethng fn contoon apart frm thle melee tab ifthe oe inte calle x poe, the eter shuld be teased pie cher than @ pots Th anther place he wrote’ #¥ou might at the weak of Haroloos fate survu sad it wold be W vpeiee of istry Th hes “pocuge aeeed tig ‘ere, tore was fo Arle no Ore arm which aiid — Toveling this eqalvoey, Astle contrbaed tothe coneptene! sewage hteun heart of verona, and postal Inspinsion* Dung the pot Aristtaan pie the ‘pinion Seems mere 43d mae conn fist inapsan nel ‘tcomariy mite to versed speech bas ea al af ‘incr donalae of huien cretion ‘The Greeks soaladed musi togtbor with posey within he aphre of lnprtin trom the recy begining,» There wat Pot gyn its fo son a a Sit Oana dvd SASL reg Mas arate as Saas Sica ae oe eee ay ana Sh Sad ew gee tattersa ‘Wipe Paton os 4 twos tnt or si, Pw a te jin rato, ens SEEN tse bora ste, peng wer tng tod si wud ‘jlo enomanity eevee {Ee'teo ara: Seth 'worcompreaded os soot pofution ‘Thay wan von shot proteus pysologiea! bond. Mass avd “Tn, so opposed to nskiadane oF scalps, ay Bove Seater: thoy say be the sowon of fey and faptare hie thru then amy foe he plato ct bt ap Prous tne ts poury. es een mene and doen, eee EePNgetter with pots, which give tin sae of maptare ol anneptity to ineion, “Tera eet can, ondeney (probably origiaating ‘hom Duaoeries ae shiny tereamstl by Phodonen) which fata mote ney goat Tos pital ‘Bae"ahe le ation of send fe phil aw fotso wordy av the exprosion of tbecght ca ialeoce the intel wate of Mans eur asin acts pepehicaly ly ‘rin ton sonnerion with posry, Nope the lem the pie Ulin ew war tht brad en irom, Piato by Thiophanas MAsnovoper: that saree tho pow of tseton aad Pent prety tat hs oral aod otal Sipifonee ‘on teal fcting with pours Te such wi pate and ie wi the Greeks were omy ate Wo ek lie ects 0 pt ary howere, toe uly semined in soreat sates of phonemenm, Dk an a ifeen tine ptey niielyWigher rel thn hn ao io On vey woh the post for ng eey dnt socal diet eeneen te inesslpar ands soaemaon Obs andthe ator wat W'neschoee? ho gated Hi lveod Ly sural abou ‘Grek ersnre bar once testimony skis ow Dany cecum There ate two tent a praesent nti romerble fre" the walckuows, texts of Pltreh Sta Twn te bi tof Pedy, Psa exjresed the cone ‘tan that even afer suing sachsen ste Ope {ou of Pisidine or the Aagive Hate of Folge, no wall ssw, Sie Sesto ST fis de Paty ‘8 ‘orn youth woul desi be Pein or Plyler thong eight simi tae works hin by o tea ried fhe cafnen who estat them wore worthy of rtn,® encion expressed ti il more focally: "Suppose het ou bese Pheitee or Plyltuy and that on esta neous manepscy; wil then wii your art. ba ne Sense person wil wish io resomble Yon fee youl amas te canada an anans or eutemasy aud hay wil des Sou arene who ern his ving ty Gn wort ha honda? "The coneosts of epson er rogers fut aad partiaiy one of them = Tomer ~ was tally ferent He wus the thjoa of = sein cat "Tbe propagators of kn elt the pein, wer, i oan be iy fhe tervoe of thw Baste Sorog the sine af Lyourges, Sion and Pinatas, Afr the fat svoiry AD, Hamer tngan to be trated brs theron hr peas oaks of tevon Baer ail, "dang the ‘hte of Pagan Astity Homer wan tee of rlgent fo, ae wom,» progbet sod theagans We do not Kove ‘lee he was roger wea-god at Se eny cae, Gare nd Brabo tery tha br war goes dion oaoar in Sayan, tin, Assos tnd in Alanon ‘he Conception Hoasty 1 an acowhadged fict that the Gree — or 10 bo sore pein, she average ribs of the latin ond ot gard ponery ar am art Thin i w ito of cmpooheuion fer'us that reqs same explaatog, whieh repo for ia thins thatthe Greake tated 4 Radiat dit fering fom our because thy sed nyt of eonepsnat trent rom sure T willbe sahed: Way was ar foto, Simeeet? Bowne ay regards potey and axe they” pounced Sonly'u part of thon pot ef view which molar onght hat ihe dijo. Tory pomowsed only ve wah mprate the vc “caus, Pujee «Peet rmadge ote Stns Socey af Wen ta Te i tng Sk Lint) 1, 8 2Tio tern thought tiuumesprenacaly inal comer. Teo th tne fart snes he cre Yn fet view, When wo combine joa and st win + commen ‘Scocpn hess tvofld Gon hie he ake nt ‘SFrvune dus Tw prouts f tho yout aud of heat ‘ition Wea, frosts clude 9 yoom aod bling ‘within engl category, tht Ts because we peonve boty rstve ert in eth. sro happened however, tha both thse points of lew wore frwign to tbe Anson Cav set oy Sesing the res but alo ring hw lac pte “hue Greeks, of stare) Yad thet conception af testy ‘at itso not be imaginal ate paged ay grat oe ‘sng shove who coat wo essh teaty.* Duna ho oar poo of thee Maury Gy tly 2k not aanoite at with Tasty: they pacticd rt for rlgiaue couiertiony pte Boris ovine and sagaisoone, and inourd only on Fie tenia aepots They opprased the gold sod presen tooes om a sclpemo mre highly thas it beaty. of form ‘And this was decay the epoch whisk yielded th bst an ost oneanding works of thal at? TE ie ery morta to bar in aid that the Grek cone upton of eautg 10 neldr —ildoed greatly fom ome Siough the mala Sasa dev from the aint one, The Gove connption tan dirt cates Se wae a broader ‘one i wor brader uv aa ls eenbrncd ice een 1 Mot ee, Sbenfel® sige worthy of snes or erring, and aly «slo sbade of mena anparated 5 fom good? Plat sae it eabrce sora henge = ‘unt of arctr which we scapula ezl roe esto ‘Gln, rite defied beauty 8 Hat which ir gorda rp ena Oyen of Sete aco Frm on ie Cnn, Cre, “de copa fey So be Gnd mao FR = saya get ie ey inte ed i a ‘iar eo tasty qe of oe (ae ce ose ey de ak Poy a noe pleat ach» conapton of beanty fot sore or bond aut the it 3. 'The Anciat Greeks dicount mich ot pps i ‘ct oot ino doing ade abe of th tara sapmaey” oe Inve). This ooacopion appears ta be ele to one an tenry, bur omen bare an cael erence pant, What tis ‘Grea pied in proportion as not Spon but aacwa der: Url ns to ti maa: Te pe {eelans than in those carved by sealpors Proportion hai othng specially artic in i; bn the contrary, was Jor (Sived ater im tatany al in et oply sorter we thi Spprochod to antare, The sliine steno of thinga® was heen in ti wan supped to be harmonons wad bef Sot Decent divise = and In war pron tote igh fr Hie aviity ban for is beat. The appa of Sayminteyt orfore tan inal! or 9 mynaa bine but Tot of al Teetbetina oge Tos this cancun, more eoypid wth Iwathnates ad phic than with auethein an a filed to eonasto 10 she ran of "Ese art ans mparate hepa in oat molera seme ‘eeu only afer the claicl epoch theta conception Sour our in of bowaty anor. Tie wan the conowpton of ‘aki ged) which tine woquined he sme ates ‘Symmetry Bet nigeies ender, et apmsnery dened connie rds the loreal wa vie ors of antsy, mca bion vied sansa, sisal or asoorta onl. "Burst" tated ‘itrvius in hit De reiterate venta pein, come Guage in eompoationtbu embronon acersus” ‘Syamatey sofa to abvsazo eastyy wash 10 Lniy fr he aye reat te san of ynamery i eae Saldernt whathr i iv wetually porosive or a, eso ‘urine ca als somprebnd by pce of esoung. ankptheion, however, i specinliy ale to eno the aly could a 98+ peo nn 4 a gr 2 imutn§ 4b 2 tebe oft tain SOS mn mya gna nope8 Wiipine Baeteron ms perepiva sees, ‘Thos, it thir qully snd oot eynmetsy Th i bo speialy booed up with ate Symmetey ae Christie, ot the Grote andertod thom, were ot ealy hnply tagonini to aad ote The etraing wt tn pereaived terry otto give to inpaian of symietry 3 foce be tenacrmed in aach wasoa? ue yield earhytbaic Imre "The Gowek ant in cour of tine ple foto two eonpes hoor no tok spamstyy end thow ‘who tisk en Figiknis nto eonents The sare an, the arttets pai {nlnyy morked scoring tothe inne of epmustey and (Dole lech for Sh smta cana of fant Later aes ‘leave tft town slation whisk appar bai othe Smee. The eons workers amie onl te tbat, mmc, {Tvine and suporcoesnal basty af spate, aud ie Pato {hay found ¢ powerial sappoter of Uist ar’ Op the whals bowevesy the plan arr followed the fath of eazigthnice sd fhe sind camene Lysippee eae ce at ssaltor who {ond the cvling ioe, he tated hat is geedennors bud ‘Boll thy husan figare a fi, whist ho was the Bt 2 ofl tar appears to be ‘Daring the times flor Anti, ern wus fy popular Geftionsocrding to wash teat conse Ia "pro orion ofa part to oer prt and wo the whole, provid [eine with Hence! toc (oa). Tu tit ee, ay stor agen oly snsniyy act only aly at (rancor. While he fomer Grek detain of bay ur'toes e very wile ony this ome was in ton very nero Wenlrnoed ilar mie mo osey at Meno wa escent to oln thm to pane as whi age conception so yh 8 nn sa a Mv acne ey als ee ae c+ oro ‘Stet een rit rine eo Be idray ar Beifapeanite dr enon Kanone wo det at ney so ‘The Conception of Creatine {he seond fvtr ening ap posey wi latina and mie ‘he aniais eromioumeat of oo dupe ‘hte fret sya of tix tok wes the preponderance of ‘he Sinesiot Gory ia Grok views on ark Aezording vt {hs awit ove sot ate hie woke tm reproduce fr ally. ‘The coal synpena wes the wae for canons iar wd he Salt for thws sonny whieh hay considered Baring been ‘Bosovered "Dey Ji oot poe ogi fn at bt slay a isngral erection oe thin had been attained, it ohou bw repented thot nny skaages or deviions Onighalty was atthe nn. Urtte Goeck aot, thos appeared sn thelr act wei “Were, eaninn ss willy they st to wader the Gf the develypaent of thir ovo te wl clone! epoch treionaion wat a-poverh, inl very ingovein mes considered ag ostege-? Defoe He lotr and Xenophon, noedy ad ito the ue of its ‘Bren Arnos bed aflrand het ona should arse tho tovom of hin poston from m work of rh? “anstio prdution wer somprohended at on of sootin. ‘Tho Gronks sep tint only thre factors appr fx 1! oe Chote abou no for The meters ad in ech pro {ection ve gts frm Natare the Inne doe 206 Alor fo thot ef a teas wid the farm igor at Tart sould be, loge ‘ond steal cue he ach str acct bythe Solera caeck 'y Sige nd erative individ! worker — ‘te sept Tin ivato Bouin wae goer S80 toaty wa on ge oo Pet 60 Whiten Taser ea swat ot recipi fn ery Grek timer, Thos wo provision “War ne fr the sparta ft of erosive in hi cs ntion of redncticn, Broutin udevons we a purely Txt ‘iter, ual the oooh senatons mertood vel) oes {Grey thew ace he two fr fn ngason of eet tow fa the domnin of at, Tin ro, tt the en of heures appears in Pats ory of at Bat only eyocogial, not mataraly, op [johad to srstvenea ia oar modern arose Av-aantie of ER iis au inversion of the sativa put of law ance ‘Senin not crag tat Sing and evens, act the pervenl ‘sion ofthe srs bet the eral lawe of ona peat In "Teo points of view were asprameasongst the Gris of ‘he clan! epoch: the ileal uth roepive. Theme cut in faring tgstr things wich tocar mils spoon fo'be far renewed fom ea other Hers stn sci be fEandaentally Hovwloge aud every Knowledge i receptive. All the ara were enbraced wader the Beading of thavwiedge Pat fe fae vinually tery. Mid of hatan inedlactanl oabpats Soindget was the genue whos iil nt cul Cho ontaral Stores snd phllowply, tat sho vitae (afr Seats art st pouty. "ibn the tne of this enormean rang, er could ana ig agpese gust with yotry, bet his grorp also emraced frat mony ther Hema) a within at and pony woe re opal a he gly fr whist ne bloga to the demain ‘ttecaseal knowlege, tbe oder apperaned fo Un yeti xo fe the ards ‘he sobs of cnoypions oatind hein was not What up ty ane tbe of the Greek plslonopbeers ding he ‘heel npc was oommon eopety. ewer fm general 0 (Sori ead ax spin of nue for ty ow advaneed ed IMaspendene views ofthe pilptans Te appenre dioely es in fl methlogy wad patcisy inthe aumeation of ‘he aio Bases 1) so and Poy wn ‘he Mores, daughters of Zeus and Mnemosyne, wore tho petronemor ef the ars thay Clo mun the Must of history, Entrpe that pf esi Tale iat of ome, Melpamaens Sat of tegedy, ‘Torprichow tat of denon, Erato thet of segs Plyhynai Gat of Inrio, Unie that of stom, 8d Cal ‘is group t exceedingly sharers 1. Te cours ths lack of © ner conception of pantry “iyi, eng comely raga nn ore poetry apa lames Sscodmetad yay comin ‘it betrays the amit Ick of any bond between petry sd th plas rts. Grek thought porecivd « clowr amaee- tion nding yorry to tence et Dstorcal or then ata seinen, thn #0 plang or selpare 3. Gait oer an ian agar, hue separa fam plastic art, wos ot out off fom musie a ‘Doon n tw sonny war oso ip moye by ih ‘Seve than in oar mera schema of ra "The Maren, who did hot exieud ther protection ever pane art, protect music ssi dance in egen eanre av pty vI Ape, Katharss and Mimess 9 Grcks no nly di nt single ut the reine ssinyle bet ao the seth one. They OH ot ings ‘he liter from the iestignory nttases The nord “thorn feeved than to dant both investigation sud contemplation. ‘The octemplation of anal nad ine jets wan com ard tote osbing le than plnvantpeontin. The proces ff yorcption was sent enapehendsd by their piles sme hing tn ply eb, ame wm Solty nad agnin sthrn with a raonalisto bade)" bt fo gee ‘eral it wae tonsidred to be peytolgial actiy of wp Gril always tee th ‘ate cry aganom whether The Sherr win eit a nme fhe sent or oy snk Scnanae Pe ‘Ty om tn, omeve, hat the xp ond tay art thre ate some Incas of w apa type Aten ere1» ae eee ho) vce X dime sli niterompae em coseisre comme pots ie dou dae de Ie vee BU “Reman Iu rgle (ID) perms de fan es ‘oe adgaract lv ats papeoloyiges, raison fas de ce Tine oa devon cl Toms compts em debs de Psp fe ietaes que pia vezgor de amet qu Hob! ce eo ‘toes en pot de toe ae temp univer de Ines ‘So eats spy wait da ler eus ob 3 hen dew pe mines peycolgijon fas Fnerale ete dena ee, Sse nmin par i a Ss urdu sapere empress Tl Porat pare 4m Bea nuke tua Jott gor nove oon stots y 0 a ie ql ne sits parsoeune shane de toweaie a JumneuP pc t e Fone sie ae ‘Niches Je Eooaée I=IE qar les Sats pselopqaes yar Ieee ns avers pasa an sur de xe ude soe ede eet rapper tered inti avee le roe. de ace. ve ursnt, guile sot pos poster pate, si ‘cede Ill Cat parte amd Pon te rapport le boise geile de coin qa permet Walir pet des ‘oes Ste, dont sone pln a chap den appt pore eive ev phacmes en gueetinn Mais wen ‘le mbm, a ow se tent ao nei de oa ee peyeblopigee, atot per Veecainewent des stan earau tal Teude epic dn fie que Tone = {Gu pond None dlrs oe Ua furs on quan om fie leone de In degiome epi ere Jr Jods qu Tent specdvement poche ef ve, ean ae tls ace {ot tater fs Te fr ei ono oneal [er le mdidonen do Teacher den souvent sap daar lr Ins de pesos exp saw at et ‘lvoomonen perce gui existent ps ans ellens Ala fx apeonent porate Jourate Aan abet que Jo 0 rp fe slat ape jenton le jourde Bal staat salle Fost dpowver Wr mint carcritigu de arcane, Ae'ah vasa fet enna gue par hypothe guy nee (hu lee jourée A ct Bon at pot Ioan fo a percootrot jet post le pete fs. St Tae ener ‘te jnress ext pine nnd, le shangemeat eae tone wn ao aor at ate wa son ppelane que jiponre pendant le joande A yest ie Mii de a Inoue quests ente A ot ‘ne tigee E=ill exriment ue fe 6 sousiens nds onan hchaqn ists oe gu Je sins pre, als {Role pour mu oe omuprer ey youweit bes aoe ‘Glens mon ur, fe goe Set gse hes sour, BE atioemt a eins tabprie ktmver Is pour ELTSD meer mjigent no pao digo, ote a Se comelnte rosganse eu ary at mat et sor T's natarcoe ge jr aie ae cour doe! Jo 2 "sauces por ens acl drs tats en ely eat tem rappot tesGatn dean dees Jour Te Jon ‘titan. "Or ie) race sew ome aranger low Sse n't Jouaie oes Tore ae Tanase ote. Uapréy tsa rani me pars omme plo, aan® tb plus eu qoeeoor here far eaten par i? Nol near fs aoe hw dion 1) de scene diciwne hide ene fo pos. ot eprom Ie ‘ieece quliave ene Te soe ce prep OF Ton tail gue cette tfrnce et siwnpble devant tnt i Sorement oma ro, pool yds pres ees eoutnanca In anette peepton. De finer sees’ enthanda bor perp denn, un 0 sia rset at i an sh Tae ‘Se percept on tn gue repo On iw la qe st SEE" yet comarne un umd plus @igge VAs en me ‘appa peniant te foorce A se que [a dour. Feiant ePfoemuls BO, je piv consatr qv sevens ioccnnt Ce pains plow dierent ela peepeion Fron qoe cots Ge Bre oe ec gui me prety te sive EiGne Jueee Bot tors em iCute come frogs do fot soornien nee te erin silted ot Eis ‘wobh dur cor Sucre craic, en tomar that Jo eoey fn atta nos men ass eaten ‘fleet doers sew ote gaat conn tnt eater Qoe ‘oct Eogons vor, nox dpe du present gl few: “Ws ch tae, ac ch wien Wee, $e ih beset wi mie nw WislolenSi qian ous domenit ove A coup dane te det eee hast bempe am Setaementapuct ea iw dane fugues dpe noms sommes ein de rvirey [AF eh ae Era rat ihe fn TAR nous cevionstncepbis de teponire, bien yo lord even iat eGo ql sos fara, de pa ee fr ies eas Seénemouts dan I tmp eth cangeer ‘austen ete de Tatonsion tune perepicn_ pests, ‘dn gun vliecl pio srvt de tee Je somyaraion a8 {$3 Le temp Salt In perception. es eomsidentions i jaragrapbe peeat asin your tng desntror comment Pos sai Favat ee de apes, dda your congue ng Stas poseblogyues safaris apps ao de Taste pat Tasjastre de lor ory ant en'co qu'en seal dente tur cenit un souvent ian, les ede Pela dae oust bee huts peyholiges wipes par dex interval ples onl atte Sats dete Up Sande 8 te copes encore nate peat fo vues Yet opeloggoe X.mnctant {hee Y ne int es Je sound ell nen salen ‘in ler teow dat oye os Wop gr, was west fund cle et typ peste: a japemeie um meuvewat wee ther parece orp ance oti um phew USreate i woxwement weet dane Ie perpen ene [nce portent Cost lo manvenen ut eal gx oe Exe, come ane mire Je gre tomponti De mem roman un st biepti, ose spew par dea vail syle h Vinsant on douse vet promos, ost ‘Seoe Te oe ote ut perye an blot Gat. porepion ‘Cosent inpicerat aor sein soasnoeac ds propels ‘Shports ta penne porn pnw ae ining Ta Smee deo pnantnes dire Pan de Veue qe far Fey ore eget cme “esis gue Faepes gil Jon ges tempest a ste Jonna tors pen Tae notin te acon AU Te lds pe tennen que da cansov doom, 9) Pat a hi ae tne 95 ler serene & dercy 064 analyer Ie propiite dow Sguon Seoporlos Deas dee tenaes npn A Torre dos ane En appt deux tence de elven dans ua ntervalle sale Det eta on ge tempt coms Os Sou enpaience me tonite ue je poor fee aves cot {Xe oon nme dont astra fguoetomporley ais 62 {Tnguan congresses ie em ceingans ae ito ftewnducts ane sie osomdaste ot ene ule consnna) JDP tenon gue loc diver int doce ele peer Non pou ie antarian,simltnt on pasour par Epon Tee, De nombre de Sars lepotaie que je pens er ‘har ance ets on nt ann as conilrbl en eis uch lutpermnt Ie sor doa at jn Te aly Far EYatees opps topo gel into wo dont elie ont frmérn ce Tasyoce gabe So chaque Agee ge permet {cs compore de a shar. Ce easement ext done po taper lr noise Toray de Tepe Pan! ‘sient supe coup, poor trl Vanna Jos Beato os peace pita Pore cate nmigee fell? Quando ais om di aes est ton fe rate gu wet de eon w eto osteo, jo septs sontlement une suo pel, tat 00 prolongnal pr estas desl masise en apeoevast Enon psangs famine hn sree de Text. Cust done EVEATERSndowie qo jlntoteis ase otaton tempe- aos le couple de ness vides, flee Sent en pos Insole pastve ui In dai {ef der deat Ann aysalogigeer Tomas le Higare ts ors noes Voulyn fur pte am eine Ca cme {ons un sonvene de Paute poer goo cela wit won ‘Sto apont ns seas op fe anal qu fe ton lo (etal evant le ton mo ln prcption dn att wl fe {eat le ton mf pri, contenu souvenir da tn do Ges sunidlivn sntst yao dear edz tenors Aisin go evoven ace dans Todo sb em Jo i peopl et sli ty min. Le temp do fe mice cars e ansotope fondle nur In ration neptune ‘Shcnion, dia date Moos Dy La peeoplinn des Higares ‘Saperes encoe an ode trope Alps i Ton fous am38 Me mars i) sit coment de tof, ance one latent fei y Zin ae'temps en eae pry tous seat pean of ‘ax er tone so pray en meyers permit de Sir In youton tarsi ‘satel, tie new pas Taare ayer fon far af tw aru Se tn in Hoar os {Gl nin ot lnnpmart Ms Pode stop te note: tein Fess op sured eonfrtunt bot des save, aa Hoe i rma apes dear tes aa le (ite leased dae te emp pony Liana Go ot Ono het Tsien o le ive tomperio dos ats pepeholeg comparable este eoutina dea pint sr ae die i que Fun pont deans ith Yee du rapor wpa ee ch gael ic da repent pe te ‘Portada Te cae spatiah ft' tagi quo de dean en lous tte ov a sand que Se but tempore ern tres soa dase ar anion constant ert ‘Geen fac pig. Son perceptions lent rigors Wlastanéeso Senian Se waite aiseone tempor Taine {Spon pom de ns ets peyholgeten depart el Yutbtscest dex sgweic soveeatTeitenoe de re Tac dpe Le Han hf coueiec, Si nor tat aphon Sivine état er cmgasns 8 socrniy us eos {enor geen pared nagae ee oes ped we en Arno parse oes main cow dit onions quand te {Ter erte tonporl ites pars ea min tee du pret. ‘Sean deo low papebloiguan vigonrenmenst nants ‘Ratt one wet npr ene sont prota Te temps {ten nti de ce so comers do one. ‘Peneevwtae yoo te ate conmecowaiat alert edie estate por su Hie den eoosason? Ml tra ‘le de Asnir one natant ragonrese b Taide de I cen en dst pare. qe lens Xy 1 wnt ainaands, [ivout Hou gen len mumenpnowines, ou 8 tnt ose That otic Tom ants) par report Fon 3) or ee ne twp 1 sat yostven (ou eta) pa appt & ani Text aie ‘Sorte qos Ie yeoor ie nine vrais pei, par Pre onle east soe pod pceo I HST ‘crete fone po ler esx ae nal wait cox Sng eacaye ous" ion are ate da mime ona doer ‘SIRS Sete enport dea roweron. On pour ier cite Sere seein bul i to es nts Fe SAME tla ot Wyble Tn te sented drs ee he gat seston eee mai Wt lair gue la Bact ensre Pens fare fools tats direct Ia SRESNN duve aimaandse ines. Dineen yom deo EERE taogunee aut sins anenn Co Wet SNR pontine ar Topper h Tasice? eins des te asi wre Fi as Tn Fone us prphaogiocr ber saul Ajouter (orien dm dat ener ae sono 4 Tsiy at Pa SEMSASS tour temporalo gorge? Chi entaterall Seatlth, ie aniston ee dear hvurensemea ota AER's dite prsnoghuer ne wos jain goer ‘eaeomansanéy te peawent doze paw ascoiler bine dae far tmp toe a ‘Sheil Ow rvargeum tates qe dow She ae ann et lin, Cee gle Be oe repent deux yhsaominos gol wot igo OMS fence Cave site simalwalé perf ten ‘Sipclogigee st nowt part mao, danse inuivey eh co Sep ect So ge wan eT Oe ‘Nemole yout metro yas tel fgoat de te See pefondedtan,aivactarn pa ropert tl ase Ges TE Bin he conse, yur comeqeent comme pestlemont Shag h fogu de Staia Dw nine qoute. Bem baannse, he inelaoie pacito sat, “wppot ree cba omee i wear limiteseat de onion, is on only lect ox yas traniive BEE Mites pevttoment seine & Ppa an Pen 2s date le top Cate cians SoEat Glen ean que ta salen pave es6 ag Mtns no) soe simulaid yates 08 at anf 0 cra cise apprnimatif de tone pute soos a sins [toe et an) rt fouite de fore de thao nt ‘te caine de Pchomines don lugele dots phemetoet Far ie Bt que le comraat do pos lat de conscience P26 ete allement a stetietion saarlle i ne 20 disor foo en cour de snsiantta Geant I fale an sre te dana fo ont Japeryoin bien ee See tn Snes yor lee meneemens dee freer base fimeltandsd de eer moarements nem aris slate ant, Feato suse qa'ane sims inten rile tut phos, 5 4 Le com On sit dour oe tone tempore das ats papel tore moe do tmp. sind or ce ans eatacé om tp tat, senent vere Tsou iin roe inert Lat [iseowtaes jnpchlogigeer Gender gui essen dann Gat de conics susie alr crparsbos bes How de lee longs Ades iveate diféte dane I did et Jur rouant. Deut poner ‘ee soa Ease yar rpyrt + emesis, me Bont cet 6 atte, lle toave plas lsd Yosouchare ie eninn de simatadts ot acon, Bed ee iin ponlderatnt en lex grote cone alone Unicon pone que Je tanga la weactre un oan Siimensomael (Chap. HE § 4 Nate i aries ‘Tier ser disnn ac oes sapere pare Sara, nym Ue si pee do ditasew Srminde per ep on nie came se 1 ‘A Pwmtoseans. Cs st que dese dor cas tout ftps {ie len motions de sielansie ve Be secouson poet poligear tals gules don bce ealre Aine wl aval {pelos dooe points atts en oe foseot eepstieenet BNLiSeme tan de Temooshre yu lr deve pinto triman assure oe, om poral eonirr as deus los ommne inal, oa ltd sea, ya os cin In simian igeorns, onan dana he po Fea poten, serait aptsyve vt transis De més, Ties tourna sha pine on blo donsd £8 lan de Tenbovehste quan. pint yudlaorgoe d'un auto He Ee journit cosines els cone soeosant= ell, criterion eet adn, qo melon gesnlest a ‘Shecutan nla sae paagrapio seat Wl aDperL ‘ymatcgee ottoman ori de Ie simahansite st ie TWPicaron oe Sah me pomierat pas Ie oi foe ‘anenale de cnneit pot yar dv ley ta er |Seegeae, Tom tt mgt do fue que foe es pacman eholoiqnes nant date te somps: ih ven sat ge [in saporiner de Fimage se courant We fotion en fie FRtioeat vile at suppose que tou lee Ulett To Tit St els jyaee hone list ls uaa lw ase Tench ss Hadoeace te ln penitent. Cale ines, rove sans done, repeal pw lemma tact {Sapo de or ds coon, Bik tee na dvienoe te ‘te nactns est Hin drete dn allen nein Bears ‘gu ce won que ar ne somtruton eoeepl app: Jide que Ton pomemit cescber up avo dinsant oo Une at toiimonsanne & Yoice inti don dat epee. Pelle xt tts consrlon? Ox drt edie lot ropes fonianeotaee in tomye pyehslogiae. oa fone Ende cel i le aramid t dol scons conse Comune Solent des tet prycologies Stent om ane rte avo Fork der poi ara Ste bate. Co rotie, gu vepomEestmmest rar In oes romp Fae fate pepeolgiquen instanton, ul wexinteat ell fart dae I rant de comsince, par es ats oem,18 Hoek anes ns) sn queue valour epposiutive, An otter wae mpd tat ploe yc or po applqhr blots dace on etooave dow h 3, Waitehead at w'ourimge_qoe dat ‘Sits ote der phénandhasdee ng To temps 0 itie Tet ieterané comes le litte 'ane oie ifine ‘Feats dont Festomlon expore ert fataines 1 Soin purist ules wf ssi qo pln fist ngtece oa ind dna tnt nae feobervable quan Encanto quit eet Cure bin conte gue Testen- ‘in tempore Suh phanoméne ppeblogque uit eres {tlie noaepemit profile dower i notion ‘Pnrnn al hsodon de eeoenon inte omens comme fetane dee denon Sandan waist le ouepsion bee Ffoue Pua sngmat, Ge Seoul, pe ha lees trod sons, peng slr gusts tamporels Eat donut, {Ens ontlgnt darent oma coms ds ens Faved fod our a somimoid d ngage ot pas? toujours te, rempuos per der cooslwcuone wpa "ho samara Ln gostion eit done soir comment toa pour nie lot ein cmsrnastapparmsns let Irondtcr wn sopment temper] ur fn Conese ote toot sur don snghentsCamsdony our fer let Hen nena tpeque de In fore Les poitomines Act 3 wn ‘Sport pr'Mnnant fH aqaiaot Aa enjoneton eu dn Froponidnn: 1) plassine A fait jst 8 Tinta Te dec B omyamoers Twas of & et Fins Jrepostion quan Phésoméor dood fait j Vinstant of ee [ine moeence ef que de cones do pbéomines ext vt jr le mie tae span a plo snp da Seoue: A it Pinta ‘ot B commen seanstras fre que A peetde Bot geil ‘ea yarn eh ste ee ctxt quince phone CRIS pce Ale weane BCom cpplition eopowuk Coutts gen Panne weaponls den pinaménes pet 06 wan) ‘tog cad eape 129 lee infiniest: Yon tps exte Ryobi, i ot pect {fone tite Ae Bh nora main tle be \Wvnoran tanta Cpe puis sy gamer On Eller ot ‘Witt, fe fieet. ation de srenaion portale. Nove (ious qeen pilcrasor St petowene powione 8%) ioe phenome psi 4 se ai ptiae & Son pesto ern "Pow get Hingis Ay arnt & By Tn kite commence ot Haas quan, Pldneutne yarn posts AA ne wt aptenur &B. EEnae au Cole do. poenomiasy ty ex ata qu fut isonae ot Tove commence dione que eo couple ot Span por toe Instant tone apons cl Ge dee {Meoutoes Bun couple te phinsntnes oop part sal Fiona asec pr rapporsb Tans lo reir 06 Then de eonple Des compen ont eas pa le iste, [separ Eline do siacan one entsinr pa more te Seite iment ds Fare Ord domme que Hasan! “hart to on © ext. entivonr Cian apa boo Beles ate premier Mine du copie Coe pelea ntscur au prio imast du omg ©: Tn snosron ete le tants papell i viens “teenie beige ane chou de edninone rfomat so {a teweanon te phiomteespapeelogiqus, et wow melon haan do alos we toate ropes Wan reno ‘On deni hconent de Fen te asi Oe Ta {etter tant Ma cette deri solaton fom yar Shyostion in Pmitn oe popeice portant dl ct Fe eGo conte gl Sermons Le erties line de Fire des Insta: Tit ere avan Pesan eote wonjure un lean gn no ayn ft ara fy ‘Dr dane tntate gononseny sade atte fo Gy Can 6 ‘or an poner tr er Fai tira, ot eet on prolougeant ‘idéalement ce sngmint hw A ge ql eras soutIoninwonts anaes & fot {one Ins onente pstinote je nous fomons Tle che ‘Sin tate Boma 29 -pie Se ew dee donne fat Cin eet sedan tmp Se notes yous pare190 Bw Meee Ge quiet steer ascenie obernatin, ce le Que SQoT aoe on cn comrade samen temporal, oe SESINE Sour proves du some ves des phones: {sve foto agers sto ee tment ($8 ta porte enews au temps Eta aus dont a pond ene ett do vi das esp sic inti ge won dass Ie peep oe Fpucr tempos ot wucare da tego devil geen peers aa an ppaiion dct ot aumplate dela dre Fite e univer Co ens pat Se prvnier we So ae Dans te fra ology lo soni 6 ste 08 WTEhat atte te Vote tsar gut appraise cov setgen bern erates Comins ous SEAMS onto etcnies v dnuarr par co mala ome ‘Sots inde neo tnt mvelté que date es mgidocs eeoyionseseat hveres qo ents Te cet, ame fie oo te Cp oe ‘Sheton penn simulate da mi erompl SEGUE fe Hea oe le contionce the come Nine ite hun aun Le vstable natane 63 Tenpr nore Jone elle una preted ces rx ‘SeELei im velo du Tweed Capty dyna cone sto comine caged ‘Sua ds Geert comigee, ue srt gaan aontinaton Sr Tenite den seo ste a sialon nttvewent ‘honda le gin ilsiale nceanble 8 espiinee ‘in Se ai que son ne pats terre oo eine wares hpyubsqen sty your tot iy, ge de ate fon de Tarps itn tmp que a conednton ‘GoMaton vn ov cones pracs sot des ee {Senne nt ces ee a a ep SSE Macreventntlnces ot ear stare, uy changnents Inrvinia et low As peoyeetiaarsineet. Sp aves ene combos pare tenet pe fateh que te eppeme ie ln vise sere downs pve Tate vei quate ate en ENRRS Sr tes prnnns Bowser sashque, qu feces Psy te kr ne dye wo ae des eninsAfavceble, wo oe anietnt ts sous SRA atte st al a ps 0m slain 7- K2ihac'ts scene Ello admes ban heb do vibrations Teyateger oresponiast wn sensations 6 sales “Trtlns el se tastent pl par do sles vi ‘Saat etine gue eel ne foment un spent nn CELA Sow tsa non deme tr etapa nce sTexpeseie amie we Come g's TOERYEanca te tongs turer. La eran ne aotge Boerne noe cnn inal des geal snails 6 ene quate gu tamales ox ones vin domme soot agement hunain qu 4 pe de sigaiention py SgeSitnae oye turpect iad temps serie SAO Relig "a ice an soe angect a gue pote ree ee NShusfngments a venti; Yordee tor TEM yr es mits sete, ql comer Te em+ Joctologans, interppebologigee,pshopbysinse 68 BY nee parent suas cal. intention gwanaterioe extention be Vor myre sett et lbs iorant SIETTERear Eaton or He sea de avant de Tages Ju erst par lesen na tute ey wneud ee PET ead simalnad ot sce TREN itjae west dane Pespieoeineitive qi moe SME tom ie go oie a SU pettnns su aes: Liesomple vue) port ft lee FEN Poetti! te terme ssoagee see comphonsbe NTU el nou ny ne fos on je ro ot est se ellie Itai ous lt wae 10 fe son doa. {Toure on ater wnat tsar rage 6 an bt ee Eited nett onaee desu stuaion on J ex Snesins See Sn erop prendan, Mate om atin cle ele EYEE hapa ihemyleie te terme ane» slienton veers ene tina ob Fob it divest, dons, BETTE we amen porter eo jogemonty pani we Te aarreeeureh, Jo cui que ot rusnoneett nest yas SEPM Siptreooe cour sbjet wnae ot 8 bot came dane non plain ban et van, 3 wea east Mane ea) ache cole nforme dase oh chu vnsel eae que 1etene grngy" ste sgaeetion Tatlin Appliqes 8 u js pond, sot dans Zerpce psi, ce terme chmage de UGententee, paige’ sigue Alpew poss spouastariee {otro ober nora, pod ae ceo Neton en matte, bs Inara jour Ge tame ove don. smpthen che yr tn avenged, gu ponte Wider par dew ‘odthotea tate ages, lee i prope de yrs ‘tyuer dats tale sttaton her ta obese seston ‘ete! dsignrn pa Io tare ronge Cot dno et ‘guia tive Sei dod ax os inasenbie bF ‘enn drt toe eigetig vowel bs rth "adieuament ha sigagoeion inesire. Je exer qu ex {Ce diaions dee didientee composes dv compe onan ‘ectront an ch evden que elural west par apuone de Tonie tempor intli'e que Veirpsnton gemini eps at et por eomniqueat, nadie "zomarynons gee mie temps pyehlaggue vo Ai jit “dmpe inti state deta do ford iti de lov stow donb tampon ee Bigs {Femployer les ies mtthodee aden get trent pon Soceesine I tats yapeelogiqnes nppestnast des Bi ‘Urata, Us méthoee sont duos potiquenet nbrialoe Sauna pagar dee sta oh lo tape, ina (ouerhne itvental cocina a> intima conn) ‘Sucoume pe de lrnnn, Gn west gvene ye plas out ‘rato da aire amy oe Pan pen pole ofa wes, lat ae sre epatlee de viele tae td plan por ‘ear loor sree emer, Dare few émpenio yor oon resonances poss arr {0 ete, malo qua» forme pte Too int Ave sre {ent Tar plopped nee geopesnfsne tout fegustouswreo ioral, Nor eit que tak rlne spots ‘lv anntes sag aver hla comprare tov bat bho ‘eplongr ta aur atuapsy cat hen appt ote, 3) ae a er cae de a mat le pans ile conaeant ot prycolpigement ct {ages tenn amg te ue ee es toer diaterndinns matin tut come Toe Bats Sronlogquee rec pat mar roiain he noe soak bu peal us aide oe goto corporel “Sas fi Je emt ‘eta tntar esporlle dowry yon para ‘Sul oaijener le sare den dounier pysbeogqses, Cua ft oni deus sates In aban complo do Yas cr sar Pa on cme ret = re der pcoanes qa osm, do mime que here: Seite plgequ ayant lea dese so solsinnges Du point de opal currant but tne greet om ‘iste on artnet rings well Sut nations vision 'bcombler fr tacones Steno sta Sow Sxte ‘jrometon que eat Footie Seuo plpngne sabe noe ftv ct ue a pgsqn, tlle quale se preete tn arctan hse, os pode Emon tox, {fic yuri ws fr lt gi ise lpia st maleonay slg de raoner cl Tertion le er eafien, front nx realgnomee sek ‘vm ge te ehcamein e e ‘Dives tnt Snplomet we soi socme der Excuments sorpteet ou costar nSainoh prc, ‘nals pent fopignant ora oot par Fan deat {fi toga Te wsteage open-tmpon erp ata utero groupe sia dos ager aie tes Sus Simeon den shor pigsgun et cot nner pa eles nis pr er appre ssogieare {F compte te appre srcay laine bine age de Fiver pysaes neublomeatfgnlo hele de nsec ant ‘reste hypthie soe vit pablo er eiwe wy Mane ps) lea Ge seat quails ence ge de Patves psi Util So dso tl somplter pr lev doonasrolatoves bb Tepe dow san 8 hcaumine, em patie, I Tvoture tenor de elle ‘Mus creeds pont nei St retour on pat come ter fer dountee intron pr dew hypotines Telaies ie patois de ante be groaper ls segs tnsies tr Spee comepondast hdr shows physquee En ayer “ue fot de mon pro, jo pao hjectivr lysine ‘Beat Timge pero {stgracs brs Unger ae Sout tule bso gare, amis je us aos onjoctver foyetetoghyemeay tte raportant ou pyebuogi Bose toe produ. Ni gnenslogigement nl gxboloie (ey Ih party yale 4trencecomtieente Je Feptlon Ae coat Faye we perception dos dats po [ltocigers dart Ce et wt Sound neiatemeah ce SEh‘okony of at yeyabologase, mais ane ioage sonst, ‘Gomes sare asian em angel Jo In eae tant coma tte tprervion de Peat ppcelogigon, ase er de tte {neepeiton wet por ae sola imple se dee ‘lotion de Finag, na ts sentiment de. pce eee tn ein fenanse su question, atime Pose “rator nlgiqaeRxpatiqne An de joer Be byt ‘lsesfsves h esis dou soar pqs on on dit ‘Bev ermsjnoer iin ne concert ue Uw snéen schon, Le mime pri ont appcble wu hypothe ct [rant avin ppshlogioe ox ante, Cea gu oui ‘once alnel Indlpendanmont Hoot jerale die fren acl ovimageeappernoan de mom chap viel, Feapoal noir cerns bson corps hsnon de eso. itt toge pardons poueot sary le oda Tne nage dea mts de ou orp a slngale roe [ele dure mies Tapes fw fimage demos doit, ane ‘Sinn tae debt tenis yo les ininger Men Freie ‘he"terge esos semblalon ne sock pos welder how at ions oabes Eu armerash eee coving 2 sls St cs do tee 135, te mon curs sont rm & anne de man cat paybslx ewe tells Tage des an ki dose) Jo pst! Haat Fre tinge elmer dan ante rage eon cr Ensim pa dition, A age que Ys) ee lars (pu ee ‘on vit done ue Me hore i emp tarppcologsne no proeappone par comin sella taps poysgoe hatTon pens pr comqnen, pair Texponé de elled avast e'spnta Pompe delay sens fst In sncesin Bile {etpinoe tne krgenwe gang dt tompe #0o {ane temp pophophysigon, Quand ox ea me sant fara tam je sre ie tative instante mk fie Pg eI ane ob Foard dete elt 0 ‘xknte Asean det deus apport de sind nerpasbo- {ghee ot peychentsits Hate dns ste natn, ne yarn enniloggsnst sarin Tote. On vert pare Por tad gue net dane lv on aia ppc Jpn moar pra ivtement doyle ps ae et como a tmp Pui [Bowe oan Tee ane cas cot Toile @hypathnn auto atte pipsige que nous setone bane conan YT {bsqes a tompe eximegayaqne, Cent pours nous liom os dnan te privet Kam, (Utd cavalo 2a temp pe Sac st fenpe etry ‘on pot aeatecxpur cate pon dae de prox longer te opin ast eet pysgon test da inesrpellogianen Gast gow tomps plywyue et I fap intenprybslgines peeve dovent nti toot le dens st ‘ills ne owner ale aucune hdrvehiegnowologiaue. Be ‘Tents comet qua denn an sean i aces pera ‘esine infiate Von certain at de vey qn noel ine gn ya pe tone yr igsiaer peck tre could comme tll Ringe ve Hea kode ite de leurs pteptons. ‘Gat ep tonne uy I prepion scat de latws ar seers pe, da tour wenteaoe alle a soniwaltandié do cs ‘hebennte pgviynn Mai et lai go fo eompe physi overs gue covsimeble + iit ax ie dn ea Bdfement ommenatiy cowsedee, st Vorie teapoe {Ue Snteomencs paysiqne ita par due ceaing oat aoe Mie te Torte Soars ereplins Le" soeat ea in ‘Stuntey Tore femporel Her epoqus yoliontlogiques in (Graven bomen ai Gta Mais, Pour e020" Tex pps sul ey snp oer de Fost, ee tay trogen, dot Tog pow les changeonie eo Toes if ne crpat pus gees pes Stee wns pray Swaine ew ‘huis Gr signa de Thnloge sasonieement perce se ivisent fet dans Te tomps, iw samt image ler {ite elétoloiqnar nila rapport tempers Tees dome inane gu dans cotins mw uve To oa tn poreptonslnfey conor don dndacents ps liza (i Feber dams Deepen oda fo tmp ot impinant dar einee costae, dev dionsions top pees 08 top zronieny le sven ot ig part notte tte Ge woe chutes cole Fone tmp dor Graeme Py ‘Dhue como ane copie de Torre de lous yetencny te fata que Venton se Fit tmgoral op ashore Je ces Tinton yi speed Vad don mths aslo dant Ie fb fests asiomasgace snot Radi dane le cept evant. Le comaimmues huive te lange ot ttn baw ao Te cone faicner du tps galqee tow nas Ulan qv cele de tenpe prgbiloiae ‘phen en wml que In fonts caneoeast ee po pitts finan da tompr intl to dee pines Tepror, ne peuvent tte ina yr suoune expla, 7s (oor otat mulenant en seat on peiper que Toa Pa ESiuncr ove eapltiece qulomgon? Ox fei cust les oyanc relives nO pepsi doco tmp comme bo (lime wéihes juny pion dane am nombre bumense le {art jure pr oomiqeat, peaiqonmentindsbiales? ‘Soop qun dn epsones pourant str Tas top Tntalu yo tone aaleent agian mis, pets Eedninbion Connon param, Tenclutreat St eps page eo To hr emi ds et wr sve la taps de asia On 8 crmpent Terre tom fa Sout; py diet a ad great Yo, tod Aptos en pts po a glieonent pee do eat dm te pun dl a futon Ae eecnton done tlectonat par le sti, corapend une cesion si Strpe Quan el gar gb sea nex ere tm {Ke tes trercantujousntitonet la dean mote pepe ae ne yuvoot se dooncor wages, que Tr te Fora des one au en ene face quun ave orice (Soper suf Stn soe hora ineaontoperte dor Tounnie do nov tats pycologigen? Ox peat en ettace n vic yechelague an hostne dont chaqee per frp rade trie svi ane eae 8 perceptions ‘Now, Tre tore ooh tnt bot exist Si euuatuonnt dae sevesn Lene elle St ‘Saas Te tanpe atl de oct horse satan eootinn Som nwasoes Geamil le diwonon dv core st tata une porte tnsrjctive fst yo Sr porlogge ere le dunes sober, tnd que In ‘anneal nose xsoivenentsajetv he ae {hp insures Te toupe come. as Tom Pat Saag ee cao ownon du ton sone ‘Shraport/an temps anv tnd oe te tineasan dew SStveie we uune pt joie Un ns dont en Fouts dma do pote pon eae at in ‘on pont ou a ijl do wens ‘icmp ssn ats pyehnogqn aati ie rsre gun eopent ‘lev un fot de sooance tora Uh sae doo CES surat uve atecaton de la deusbme eoéce ‘aa tue cee tu, pmo (en min jot du crm is motile ae te ase oat tm ptt Cet Poona ds ogre que on prsr lr deaiptos free pachsbgnen ovate pat Tacon de cotine ‘Stootyutdne ens Yalieda prt vie eset {Sn patel etrnent longue pr taper ten 4 toole setae pct ome tu inosine Powe 1 Frnt tu tome trope dela people ove fe bee tape sonny qu crecise a nataze seme 00 tomsae Wayne Taonne es ‘tly made to dain thas factor Paty and Arist whine ‘Rion on art are so well Knowa tes, wee oot the ta ithe Ate oe Sargien ‘The fret atompts flown nes mainlines of approach Some ascribed the spose character of tae cxpeincen to ‘Sion ebers tan emotional shocks and sil eer ty the ‘nial nature of th objet ‘The Tuedamental compton Ah few theory was Sapte or llaniony a fhe soy "haar [SP or giving veut to Uw emotoaes aad ofthe thin, mene rrepmoduton. Thame thee Tbeoen, mich appeared it oe ‘rong in apcaio tna, an for tha make onvetense be fll the apa, katate, aed mice "Toy seem tobe vey end Spee ad to ese all forma of experience speontered when fucad yar bs ik fhe prema of the plato are a of posts. They pene to Tndiete tat the Oreck in spit of a rubaad tha atone common te toth This wosid, however te iain &mivaken ‘hor the realise experinced om Bear ony std ik farina, deumats pote, bat wet ot formulated wih any ooghtotthe plate aes hs apie thory. The spate or aso theory a 'e wonld be terme telny, flrmed hat the these ett By seoking isin (ded) it erates tho smb set es {he spetaton to ascot shinee mis voles in i ach fesing ae he monldexprience mors bs to aot thn aia woe fevnge of Otipan of Elta Th eno a olin ato, i iiakin to megie tated an the masive power of the ‘pen wordy i eft iss ifthe eprcttrs aad hnaore were Ndee'» mpl Ison inthis cen connene ap 330 agi frien a3 pale ~ any wa oa ~ theta to expraone footenly appmar gether the formalason of the wert 7 8 Potcr 0 {ei pany ota olan tht this wew we Set expr yy Gorgias Te bis Defoe of Helos the wut af hich ‘Sow no lngee quent) be presets anon a splat ‘he wafe aod ees of are! tn one ofthe frgamnteprceeed Se Plotrc's wor, be ste thy aier ftrepntnd fasedon ‘hat tragedy ie that yrtoclar predation ie which thy darver is'toce beset than be whe drwe aot deceive wht the ons Moclved iv wine thn. we fs nee * Conga opinion fe {Esq ropeted inthe wring ofthe Sophivn; alee ape fone in the works of wets other typ and with soca [eve in Palyhine wr nse when comparing history with te ty, which ncn trough he sas harboured bythe nie (itp dene war eagnor.® ‘his sheary in, howena, oly theory of pouty, eapecally «of dutaic pty Tn the aphore f Goria ore ihe ate the unknown Sophitt “Par Diao or a Plyiee even Saneh Inter i Horece srt Kyzetatns th theory i advascod foliy ta ie eppiation to tg. Thin i guile sauce Sit ll the arte, rmsiti arti proeminonty te art of ih catary ele ‘euiptare war sever ob= tioned Ss connexion with “agate Painlng war tentined, intro, ou to easing: fa the Dfece of Helen nd by ongeone "Dislsas”* Thee motion cay howe, Bsn ‘Stra ealy a comparivay, in order to pat out fat ‘Seurgy — ba a paral teewose two otherwne ding upto ool as Ye hm oe lye teks WR tans setup tte te Ice tk np tw ees, pe ee sn ge tna ete Be or a9 6 on Yor C300 81 fe 4 seri: ewan ent an ney Tene pote oe aerate ck efaos ld eto es sate “serge wt qn soto, see Boeou dpe Tooter ms Aiisionst — 4nd nt a he formation of » hom ol jimeonsat ceupoud of tgey and panting ‘Te efhrte theory. It wet popelae conviction inthe nt cncbarybtre Che hah sei a poo — ot art Seine of he ae ee se eee lost sq lao tw ed ooking stock nde) Sriie iets they rig tosoch a lo Wat eoton sod Tagnatn gin tbe oper bad ret ean ALines ante, ‘now favraching. sox es coupled with tis common cone~ Say that thaw goer gotens™ far to emt fordnsar — psy the soy tha they efoc thie purcaton Ayan ntencatign of eotone evekog oir dseerge aed "ll Unt net entice inst ng er ‘hm iste sore ofthe sere foie by pot avd min ‘thin ww apponr Avot’ fasoae tition of trae fedy. W hoe Loc omaiad, tat won the ree ato Sie sec ition nl th Pa a bogs rotor son cote tog ani ave bee wg {pAenetle fue eater dines Ia very Sct Gorgias bud rented te non of pouty au an eneoal since wich ‘Sued imagine anon yielded bp pty. Tt weve, athe shin tt dnt Co afr who ind hin ‘ow Povey the Pythegeenat somo lorie unit ‘Nowy fr them the protean of thar: prigeation we the fatal tol sapvme conepgn of the hel of pono. gas tbr cog tt the oly i ported by Meticve 2 tha ty sta” Du ae fowl, ax oer pigs he thar thie ante pian of thn concnptin tome tri Avo Me tiny have ase pace whoo, oppo Thr Pato (wo condensed parry for i ection anf "ronan ty Pa a Waited Mn sng a sete uh i es ume Seteg so tne Wik ‘TR beter tes Pet ee Be mnie Reet kame 2%, 2 est mt tet be) et and Poy a tinal actin be nuh to dfand eon {Mat los ata Shs ty ak the en Jae Ber ste tes het hat ee iy the “puritan of atone by petty would bo See einai eb se {hsogy fom! “she” sve y gee wae neler {9 ty own ose = “ “Whetier in one or the other singe was, however 4 thay ef patty aod nan, Netber Congas ot Azo for tng oe eather ero fil entry “Oreos Seated of epiging I nun aad non, nd wl en {2 titer. Por abr wint hate thy ie exancn wb feat or myth tl ita or at? “he mimi» Wry The tan ft teary. wat sbsertion tnt hoa pation i erin of sda See wot sit relay, for emate tal tan Beinn onsoms (tata Ts schism es psaton-tens Bt ddalonontrt spy? wat sjoken ats It rao cure ‘alo a thse tine ths eel eon fr the st part pdned ea thingy Hse thse ats ar no {St the nats prolate or aa on Thi tra Ss ncn tee ny re Ben ‘sri of ie tt the i the Creda wes ne i protocl wet things ewan Bao who ws “We ellan inftator bi wn poses veal hing Tus wot wecerly fon he ropreace sity madi to wa tel oie fe “Thin thay bed more chanos then othe te cating rowry with the pets ata Grigoalgy howe, bl ae Spee was adenist a et ony ad lly in jee a with dhe slow thor. Te wot every semana” Bot iy "apes which opmnte the, somo apo oe “ot arta Ie aot ante tw argc th tne crain {tut abo evoke th ion f Sel. Aperig cl TET Aes, ma tnt a pe gat an be oe Ne ms ‘Frese So 5 0. tee n= mek ‘Tete fp. De ioe Sey BA tir St,aa Wty Tsrinte (an) eojunson wth he Seon ther, he regrodeetion theory ‘Sohn ppledeeeely Yo yoy parouly i Sonar an ic sian the Theory wus extend to ‘oe dare. ‘Dosing uly toes, a Gorgas and with thn Sophity sts tve orn or soe fant ng wer th com ‘ile ionests of so naga pos) poor poe ts Shel val ean) woken ite no meat {he here wept (evoke an ematinal sack et tech of tte carn putea the hry hud dent Ste and conte of «Sian ote, caur of tm, {Sep avege end bcs ther Sere! trea Tair eae {ne wee dostor te no-sense Sisal then Suton cathe (Gout ving i Doe hn pra vu, Plato: Two type of Petry ‘The weatement hat the Greeks did aot incade poetey within tears may, however, ect wich opposition; Fema be Teint cet tht Tha oor oot apply 0 ‘be. mot sine ‘Baker of lose port, a, vo, wos works bare town wally banded dow to tar timer, It wes Pa, pestty common tosey ‘tient the mimate theory, alvadytaseioed Boren ‘ech opposition won no, hweve, be jute, Piso ‘81, our ntaebat refered ot vow ofthe average Orsk is" non ttn Gilera fromthe of ‘Send, store crf examination of Pst ‘Sznar tat fv attia views were aot foelasetally at vie nw with tone enjoying. common oaeresey” Tels oe fiat Plato ened povsy togtlae with thw lle tz aod tis Apquae with foes in tha toch ck The pai ware Iedoores om the banner fhe ew at ad ace Dosey an at gaa! fot with painting Bul ie ale toe ra Xa al ra: mdr dc a Are aot Dot ase ths ain Phare pci, Be dcr pone {ole Sma, ss auto fm the Mena oes ot Loving ing non with ination 6 ih a Ti np Jit be Unga thd Pato ws bt fa scroment wit hilt ~ het he bad ofr? ard fen oe {poo aud in rac sot Been ly app Sette tmpoin evoked By dmg oe felt ‘enter’ ht tots py ot py Pres nl fosey sod run pty ine von Paras oe ot {ee ean, to wich plese sec cama fone oes when thaw pnt Inge an take pert {Songs an thr pose Hat he eho wit cnn he dos a Sen writer into aothingten i tha oft ig ‘Radoan* Te ined dtc Tarmac move ers Shon of pny. Neely ped wal gr fave estoy nt ps aides: hee omen wre ent In hic tad nt uy essen ‘Syhing bor! nating ma, we nly th a nd Ay oni ofthe etn poey sto pigs om ‘honed ey nai) and prs sped ty ty sl (eon Maa’ or sense ty apes tthe gest Imoetoee of an, tt cutie vas ae the tana of kantionte. In Phot Pas itchy of sont ad human scopes ehh ee one fpr to ps: cones a fase ema bre {ie tomas te apo doar et ene, fs Smoot, ten of te ating lca ogee wit ek "Fe Pe BA: tik tn navon a wn rant lass Sate Bh we Sina ee te ny es pas seb we Sete ‘igs lo ove ile sf encgoa faa ate Ertstneleans cog goratnnefyavioby esha al Epnsecee aig ol intants fey tarieds fae seginipole FEELERS ie ur pen‘08 ata Tae a sashes he oe of any fen aig emis cot St Frum ie rome SETAE a oko ewe Bee earl rs oe i nt ene ea at gt ro ens ie Adal Os ne hr Sr ne pe eee ee sarah heap ia Sr aan get La pn Serer ee taste tn sie ers «rs snl eto in see Naa Eid yer Sagi atm ee thn OMAN Son omen rc a the ott of ody SOL Beare erm se ep il ls hs tne ne ie ten he ge sol man esis gs en en," ove Tees Sammon ot Se Teheran DEEDES gly spo see es Stier tuttors, aome art or some haadicra, is only an ordinary ve al and ty- ey es 2 tees hea a SERRA ect iet pte af es ee Eel Bae pety han tin nee ici Sei ny i ica Pan he me ue 0 me A ee ew mar we iat etn eee sw fo asc nig by ee hey Po “Slated cst bss Iorpivng Sra 8 se frog ne fron (85) ee at Petey 9 tnd rsoglaed elation But on the conery be ae Indian th eonwergncs of ator fa romoved — toe hes Pardoses in wich Pato dsighiad. The Tntation of the ated is lw’ dprvser the lomer-t9pe jos tothe level ff tho Juntery ardor de tae fner's mote eae ow aot simultaotly to anes te apse pots He tog, feta alae cours whon Ie diew a parle nee, cot {tn palais whn bad neared Bde, ssuy ype of pty was ii neang to Pat for that stir, ft tho Orkin gene Bek Sep poy swan sn a print coun of Hel eiveoey wit th rene way rn of mw ace The ‘ioeiceharacer ofthe Iter typo of psy cased Pat to last noor t0 th last arty Soy i pnt to Misting, This reximiy, howeve, ax a mata of comes apie {Bi ener ype wv a eer eh ge, baie sce pisng. "The contrsting tf Yonty sot ak of taskic [rotation sud the hendaratte was therefore Tally mina Ie Paws wetigs ‘he dint in ct tess een weoges, Since Be ae ‘gosh the faneton of iniaing tnval volty i ta ‘at it aos only dress the platy art tnd ieiative pet wth evel of tah, tut ron pcos tare soompi tthe lomo sg af tocnigay, omer evo thaw the werk ot Se lone and werthy bandon. "Tin demonsention af tho sense ofthe miele nes was efecio in The Reps yp seat oa anuj ofthe paitors crf. Towne hen applic to the poo Actor sudy of tu peng wl arly eat {at ctpacno af thas two Sldrof action wes nouns ‘hing daring the Ah ontry bere Choy et wes to iol asa of co's: be spare give ety ‘Sih painting sey fa seer to sompomce and gre the inter ‘he division of erosive work ino glaringly neering zm ot thle hr ot i ‘pplied by Piso to the pao sre acto pect, Ta ft ‘ltractrto for is "cont Crone ther that he 2 ‘bot doe It wen al apolar of eonjectre a pose“ ate Tatar oH silty Gat yantr of architect coud alae Yo a. fad Ra ne chven af tha Mave a ast th doer 568 PMC nk Pits eogin fo Phe Banguet tha point ttn ens snk he pl ud to egy ny ood al ed of aj bur hi appek nce pr ite te thw stati ered onl foe owas thi the My ahaion hich we acre av eoatvene propery +" fh ova ‘Moto not ony deer not np to diqrove bt even frie sue moe porefl argent support of te thee dled inthe es sn Gre oyna ek ‘staeed to been attend war ot tevted on an onl tng Soi ete forthe single neo that wea tgarded 38 Arotte: Fint Courergnee of Art and Poetry ‘Th dintzatin Yoeon_ostry of the higher ent of the Aware whic uppers in Bas concpton wan, Bowere Wyma Besse Te te mnnoe tyoa forte iter, ba Ry oft ret the ier a Bs ro degra a SUSELa‘ohe ower fue rhe he dove ini wuts wad Etro onl, In tapi Be ea and Seine Chalet Sera hinge? itt theory of wonton he Teed perp ana a frou of empiin kxowlle ein Mp charg of ar be jected tric a acpi tative poy. “ead of shia vaamy of the fais tare wa 99 own ar nag lnsioteuprobesion of pty. Once be bad redd egine thn pony finned pet! craton, only ee Eun tt fen Sipe thay si Hoe Spice of eats li oo to rca ty te os mane Si 3) bo and Boy son ee ype of poesry cout romain ~ the miata. Ten 8 mo Iemartch, Sane tet the mga aay whi Pins ‘aed tho lowest foros pat, now beat he spree Fors ofall poctey andar. N lor Compared ghee oe aia ons Sr opine tes ine mimwn shart war on teal pty and 5 thie far asi fr alaing femal wii sole ‘Ste “that of te Satan are Bete diss cae rt toa pce. 1 ened thanks 1 th rin af ‘ntin of poy which had bok cna before tht oe ‘Kw ie tak plea at awe leva wen act plane wi wanted tothe leva of poy, bat prey me dean (Sto that ofthe patio ar “ ‘a any com i was Uh Het Cie that wach capone geuus ayers one whish sezot Yoth divuone a wie Flaten ote i combined postey with planar an Oi tac the haat: Thea or eee the tee rng ‘our mea “tne nr Bate soto tl iret etn lan bly at tn roan ns ‘> untr. Jt mas, move, ngs he aerge vi eps fag ibe aiid of the oud ase, bot tho iw of mrs cf hacsingy who bead the vermctar pola of ew ae nah and tpplated wih hie ‘he fein of ate at ad posts within ag atogory of she inate sts by Artie fn eguierly tat Sed toby the txts of in wringer aca be ote in Poles: “The port nau mitt Jor Hn the utr ther mater of lketwee* le espestes Ue sae Song a ‘cher wonky pty fe his eon, viene wie “ittog a ngnt of oatston sal nwa pe ing of elptre aoa of pour ** or Sette: tt Be ora, "Mert Amon dere ST 95 trae dn de do rm oo, sy yp md Sears Seoe Wipe atin os ‘he natn of Arisa’ mentality Sona thi wor: the Zora eoseion of tes “Tink won sed to Keni ad eh be ma iagy ose, one Sn nproming nn win ech) ‘agit to acrier an? protic To fac be ape these ‘hoger to the phonmean of Notre and. Bese, he ore to poty. Eagreing por asoing tthe manerf wieh ‘Belplnde acs wes aivays expose, tude fe more st ‘oman tothe tar, “Ta ice of mine, bavng boos th spree sleet tn Ariel's snare "itewie to nme. exom shang ie inter Evol bed be snatana clemt he reen ‘Fatpcte which tw nora aad () ich roeb rel ‘Sjsc De Ae conttant sane var tho move ome sri Pin vandonael arb dit so sre fre ac at JLfedcn anova tha tat ths ae esti On he ‘tier ban, Atte sen ne sil eter pa “teow opty andes {Bey are tates tt es tty A th setltncton eich they feninh tnt tho anor or specter Tetoles ray topo! fe ther wok ‘statis intagndon of the arts sage ca ‘mimetinis dows not sonclarely ide: whee intatan ‘ras far hin ray the oly sure athe sles af oe ey ila of mitun lbw isp, ad) {eee vew on the imitative sabre af the ah Tas fly tn The ae date wh ad oe ho coe ‘Tasion tht 1) men ne boone inthe mall ube Sra titer horns oid ot compo fat ine ns erinry copying: (8) aot oly hs surceare but Sar Wesel Sia oomeption of ae ea {nati fone repos arson od if aya ty spe "és ol, mn bn ied ba lho hi coeapton Sher to ok ato ona abe ves aed corte 7 et a ey a ‘hay be acoptd the pleeare eva by shyt and harmony 2% mat fon ft bong iy has wntng do ‘rsh the atstuton given by the. ftorpon of ices eter’ work of art xed the rely: Te aaon, wis ‘Ne thotry of tage bo nce the mtv of hair wich Ie Yareeoved from itation, His aan nt ery ot the ate were ore plc thane ueullyacaped Mercovee Att'seasceptea ofthe tte ae wae so inital homogonene. In tre hat he lid sony on Pe Imittive Yactr in te ata bath son interpreted on ‘Tas he wre Ont she ats proce et whet Ande a wht ogee! aginst thy eat wh bat infra Si aorta mater mapa {2 ination, Tif corm wasn arn wth tne anos inemnistant wit the Shor) whieh mgt to i at ais te ec ma 4 prpate tbe wey fr tbe fener fereopat of seta, ean be sald that Avie ated the, tage ef ar solr sunepin of tt ne Sean ab he deen Ne Sint fry ne Hning” Ho trou we comet ‘ik te ence tat th rst fh asae mater Fras ner eling ely sl sae by 1s estentsm: Second Conversence of Art and ovtry ‘The fh courant of porry an plata in Atay vas voll by taring sway fit = ph ao later the wn of post frm tae ection sod by eetig it aa cr ‘Th was Intined by Pa and devolpol ty Acne Strceling gatratine af Orbe suger 8 son ‘conception etvergeas lesen there tls bet i obese sey EEG 1 8 ho dn mnwon atyaee Ba be ps) askin: ty isororting pais aon at ot «pst of ‘kin he roan f creative works Pha look plo ole Sosng the Haleostie pero ‘ho St conrergnce was bought owt by the wc of sot: cod ue fonds nig the see fs more ofouad tale. Theft was te ottoome of rina, the ‘ened af iatlonlon or, tw pot Aveta prod ‘Gance as mated by cage in ently, aa by feverish sch fr sprtaal, cesie end rie caments ~ sae ‘hich weot wo far 92 to pore thew even where Torben Sothing ot the met erinary mata wert, tahaigoe ead owt bed boom ses "Taree lec of tate expring thn now itd: his fieh stunt sng, fer aly fo w aee spc lie ad «relatively large Bomber of wham Kerry re ten pare ‘Thue Dir Christos, thtor af the Kew xstry wad ‘supper of he pimp a oe Skyy hie yg ‘ration ao al ied th souptor aso the ug oe, {ta oven among tie vine (Gayénog Pato hed se tp angry of inspira pangs which stra pons ple oer ted Ingles: tow the seuytrt snare fe group mee apow tia tei tnt the Sagone —m favourite of fostoversy_ hove tones veloed aroued chp svhthor Poti or Homer wus tha ater, It wa allow Tower tint the mean at he anpsa of tho you ar i 0 {F'n petty one in sory sind fae "em § Un Am 336} pa ave tpi ne Saints Bin nelety magn ef stmur tnt Eyes te Sn fe Rent ets tps pentose iparnne en Saisie aaa oe ee ie yee gee re Tepe te oper rie dent eto inset see fp env Soper meer SS tt in, ot Sr ‘er lpelor in sean tuainart vert ormscang ctr ‘Eafe ansepre en sw go 6 ee Ieee oe fe ete ibe Dione 7 ee tc att ne addon Saar tee 99, se and Boy ws, nin ht of he se cots, sated he sionghpitng ott tn is poe tee tot mot pn! fag tout a eset ta spe et py np in te try eager sol tiny, owiehe wor oa eal os ily ‘tet en a's pal work “sci is Drm, tak be Pia, Po Inston aed Drs to Male bet ag et Sth smn Sp ilatuy« palcr oar ho Seed ‘om ft se thin ete wee A fg th se sb wih nee {BF pt ae Scie fr te ete af hear of a which also contains wisdom, orig cee a ace Nie Sette ay Seba as 1.70 'C i on vce Srp a ny ‘ion pee ae ts on ‘eimai ti rc ot TES One a pr oye rt seroma inn toe By also 4 as: tm, i a eee oy dy tore aie a fe i Sa as Sanne ae a ev io sa ie a STDS ert ea i ng ie fn Rl a ne a sistent eT a io Be ae mar ac aC Soe ges ei a eS ie or 21 “os dn0% Waianae 1) “buccati aed Pesta rx sated that tha God ed ‘vin nie solo ha pare: the ba fe aes (che ase aio atime guided ly oviw napa, ‘Motown nv maton of cura, prt atin ill nore Inyerotie and tramcenatl fab, in wil ow aerated ‘of ano manner thes all he other were ‘the snierarne of thee nis ad poops the pnieioe wars ot ton Bak thoy woe combined th mabe {2S ey sows seguir de lade — a he eotracet of he UUpoe Hot the pinta aed welpore wor nw oie to th secfrsh. pala were constantly bang draws bate fan ented at they depot the deals tao he hes jon the ame way “The shunge i ty ate war nat, however,» ger ‘on, Fai fo ie Paidia elegant To the owe ‘itegoros of ark Cie comparing orduary.apiies wih aenten optimise catty, ineled oy posts ‘ong tbe hier Hl trod the art of arly av sori, fie ike uarion, uountwerst whore ao the str lof te ealptr should ot be sealed win the Mn caegesy.+ Search em Seed and paint into ig oy [sl ant whatneer “hove forse nitro Thin El of the fo nt Tho oly dilrace non by uma pra 2 ai sing pts eign ne git yon Saas Se Rarer an oan Poy a iravin btnuon oie and sboomaing wat inthe fester difieiien rome’ bythe Toone,” Tn stage Fated the ery ek one oly the motives were onthe tole digeen hey nee spiel Homan iain and ‘None helo, breach bi bon made sh teniiona speaial ofa Ta dion, ivan aban « tanild EECA Acoring't threw wording, te wo of the STL) nu anata wot ond et puny nan a ner ASE; hen We tadtual wrk tnd ottiehaa Sra: &) 8 erate work, in which ae deagation Weak Sry fiom neural rd ted dim ot marly inte ea ITA bene ty Aine tuprton ae ht po ‘pants arly charac) ach the oe Being and ot ony tin maven! phooomenn ca bean tt he tu te option ws occedi 1 truer fom on exten fo anor Ar war et: ‘ hae rw cr st ay a J pose. Al thew ditinsicnn sade by the Greeks wore ‘wishes as they wa bad on artery pene. Teverblant,"eten i all the eres ofthe Grohe in ‘oir theories of at ste rejected te Toast at ‘seman in fn! shat thre ae divers tgp ote td that ives ype denned crs retin op tha pat of ho sysetator ov Boner There onl even appar to ba Soe, ‘cent dierence between pty mat pate ast Pine ot depots objects what potey els aly Ja ymole Henne the fone Bas sive shurtter ich he Ther nce; ibe Yoraer in abaye conte aed ena! whilst the liter operates by alec mae This dfs it Rob Ins ota ho io the. wery his the arte inthe souebing al is tb sure of fhe expense mndeone. Ta fe caso eis frm, ad te tho shor = eotet Thon os the sore of exjernuey, emotion sr joy ithe vial word fin in cher by sana shown tty bat susly Suggested ty thn Delp of ws Hore lis the foaenta Alfeenoetebreen vial wt sed petey (coe, by the way, fein se resent sloar tinal at aod ot ty he Grae Dain 12 When re anulose cur astotic exeranat, we fa te typo of thes For we thar conceit werk ‘ete teat soul, won or eva we das Waker itt impala nome suu, the oe seu esse ef pe inthe snd 2 oly th er of oa Ts sot sry bond ap ‘ith the Made of mt for Tse a vere may etsceniate etion, ea bh rake severe, Bat the nan of the at who pom ents ‘Miler tna to evabacuentaton, what tat whi giver cing bat vein ayaeln noe relly itdvees vey. Vie ‘ala from ite very antes i bed on pererpen, dc fre of word on Snaginain. It not stung thar thet ‘Seon expences wah tush om hoagitation and tevery aoe Seon tame postal 1 saan, atte mine poe rs Bl so li eZ Sapnaa8 Watley tse 0 ‘Theo wo diforeroot ee Hoportinks They have made st Inpomitle to dover = gonceal concpson eabracog all swore of are ofall tic experi Th cnet eae tphave tamod out lo be swe tio narrow ia extent 50 eon at thay embrace pesomena aed xpos hi ave Helo if enging in couon wih ar wethto at fox When chore atte the tea of reheic’ eperones, tuhowa tothe Grek named hat eno oi th My fam hat Atty had ware Bot the ins {oth and Gent costarynohetio bus shown sha hi waa sr illinary binges The matey tod of remy ome: ‘Sis have fad to test the goat expetatons whe tey ‘rouse. It bas teflon bone mca to reser to en {Goer ad to thniare who had» grate weaning fr fe Dipl of esjernce which the are premnt atc i, Contents AL Tas Conepion hots nn EReReEgSRE 30 Pate ti Ws of ancen Sept Alatin i 19, Feb 087 uci iit ioe