Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
AEG5137
Assessment Task 1
This research essay will address the impact of socio-economic
factors on educational outcomes. It will outline what factors are used to
determine socio-economic status and how much of an impact this status
has on the educational success of a student, things like school completion,
Year 12 results, entry into higher education and the workforce. This report
will then explore the factors that contribute to this inequality, with a
particular focus on educational opportunity, schooling along with cultural
identity and bias. The final section will then focus on ways that this
inequality can be addressed including the role of governments, schools
and the community.
There is no clear list of components that determine a persons socioeconomic status, nor is there a clear demarcation between socioeconomic groups. In Australia, to assist researchers in this and add some
context, the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority
(ACARA) created the Index of Community Socio-Educational Advantage
(ICSEA) to provide a scale that represents the influence of a number of
factors associated with students family backgrounds on their educational
outcomes. (Australian Government 2011). This index take into account
students family backgrounds such as parents level of education, income
and occupation as well as school factors such as geographical location
and the proportion of Indigenous students the school caters for.
(Australian Government 2011 & My School 2013) These factors, along with
issues such as school transience, are accepted worldwide as being the
most relevant to a students academic performance. A number is then
attached and students are able to be divided into four quartiles, with the
highest representing relative advantage and the lowest representing
relative disadvantage. (Australian Government 2011).
When it comes to answering the question of whether there is a
difference in educational outcomes between the different quartiles, the
answer is a very definite yes, with students from the higher groups
outperforming the students from lower groups in all categories. According
1
AEG5137
to the Australian Government (2011) the gap between the highest and
lower quartiles when it comes to literacy is the equivalent of three years
of schooling; the Year 12 attainment rate for the highest quartile in 2009
was 75% compared to just 56% in the lowest quartile and in 2010 the
proportion of students that attended university from higher socioeconomic backgrounds compared to lower ones was more than double.
Indeed when it comes to school completion, socio-economic status is one
of the strongest indicators of the likelihood of a whether a young person
will actually complete twelve years of schooling (Smyth & Hattam 2004).
So what is the reason for this inequality of outcomes? The first factor to be
investigated is educational resources and schooling.
The idea of education as a universal right for all children regardless
of class, race, gender or ethnicity is a relatively recent concept, one that
was instituted in the 1959 United Nations Declaration of the Rights of the
Child and one that still faces huge challenges to this day. From a socioeconomic perspective, the struggle for equal outcomes among children
from different classes suffers from some entrenched cultural biases as
well as a large power imbalance between those at each end of the socioeconomic spectrum. Education systems at the beginning of the 20th
Century were very stratified, as Connell (2007, p. 16) explains, they were
segregated by race, by gender, and by class; tracked into academic and
technical schools; divided among public and private, Protestant and
Catholic. Although the desegregation of this system was highly successful
it is often very difficult to eradicate underlying values. Technical schools
continued on, most often located in lower socio-economic areas while
university remained the almost exclusive domain of the middle and upper
classes until the 1970s-80s and as the evidence above demonstrates is
still overwhelmingly utilised more by these groups.
Today, the issue of socio-economic inequality manifests itself by the
ability to choose a school that will be the most educationally
advantageous for the student (Lynch & Lodge 2002). It is here where the
power imbalance is most evident. The most obvious example of this is in
access to private schools, with often exorbitant fees that are mostly
2
AEG5137
AEG5137
AEG5137
manifests through a proliferation of elite schools and the belief that kids
from disadvantaged backgrounds are inferior, means that it is an area
where implementing real solutions is extremely difficult. This is because it
involves a shift in mind-set at a societal and government level, and a
break with the status-quo, which is always hard. Despite these challenges
it is beyond doubt that a lift in educational and learning outcomes across
all socio-economic quartiles would be the single, greatest benefit to
society and one that is achievable.
List of References
Australian Government 2011, Review of Funding for Schooling Final
Report, viewed 17 March 2015, http://www.appa.asn.au/gonski-report.php
Connell, R 2007, Poverty and Education, in Da Silva, CD, Huguley, JP,
Kakli, Z, Rao, R (eds.), The Opportunity Gap: Achievement and Inequality
in Education, Harvard Educational Review, Cambridge
Lynch, K & Lodge, A 2002, Equality and Power in Schools,
RoutledgeFalmer, London
My School 2013, Glossary, viewed 18 March 2015,
<http://www.myschool.edu.au/AboutUs/Glossary/glossaryLink>
5
AEG5137