COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTS

SUFFOLK,SS.
SUPERIORCOURTDEPARTMENT
OFTHETRIALCOURT
CIVILACTIONNO.1584CV03118BLS2
NORTHAMERICANCATHOLICEDUCATIONAL
PROGRAMMINGFOUNDATION,INC.,
CHICAGOINSTRUCTIONALTECHNOLOGY
FOUNDATION,INC.,DENVERAREA
EDUCATIONALTELECOMMUNICATIONS
1
X?
CONSORTIUM,INC.,INSTRUCTIONAL
\,
TELECOMMUNICATIONSFOUNDATION,INC.,
PORTLANDREGIONALEDUCATIONAL
TELECOMMUNICATIONSCORPORATIONAND
4^TWINCITIESSCHOOLS'
TELECOMMUNICATIONSGROUP,INC.,
Plaintiffs,

fc'D

era
CJT
CD
C~7

rv>
CO

o
rv
er

CLEARWIRESPECTRUMHOLDINGSIILLC,
CLEARWIRELEGACYLLC,f/k/aCLEARWIRE
CORPORATIONandSPRINTSPECTRUML.P.,
Defendants.

PLAINTIFFS'EMERGENCYMOTIONFORAPRELIMINARYINJUNCTION
<fc!

PursuanttoMass.R.Civ.P. 65(b),PlaintiffsNorthAmericanCatholicEducational
ProgrammingFoundation,Inc.("NACEPF"),InstructionalTelecommunicationsFoundation,Inc.
("ITF"),PortlandRegionalEducationalTelecommunicationsCorporation("PRETC"),Denver
AreaEducationalTelecommunicationsConsortium,Inc.("DAETC"),ChicagoInstructional
TechnologyFoundation,Inc.("CITF"),andTwinCitiesSchools'TelecommunicationsGroup,Inc.
("TCSTG")(together,the"Plaintiffs")moveforapreliminaryreliefagainstDefendantsClearwire
SpectrumHoldingsII LLC,ClearwireLegacyLLC,f/k/aClearwireCorporation,andSprint
SpectrumL.P.(together,the"Defendants"),theiragents,servants,employeesandattorneys,
directingDefendantstomaintain(andnotterminate)theInternetservice,modemdeliveries,and

MotionisALLOWED:(seeOrder):Plaintiffshavedemonstratedastronglikelihoodof
successonthemerits.Thebalanceofharmsalsofavorsplaintiffs. ThisCourt'sintentistoput
plaintiffsinthatpositionthattheywouldoccupyundertheirexistingagreementswith
Clearwire. Itisnottoimposeaffirmativeobligationswhichcannotbefeasiblycompliedwith,
ortorequirethatSprint:a)reactivateanypartsoftheWiMAXservicewhichhavealreadybeen
shutdown,orb) provideservicewhichisbetterthanthatwhichClearWirewascontractually
obligated toprovide. AdetailedMemorandumofDecisionwillbeissuedassoonaspossible
toexplainfurthertheCourt'sreasoning.

Dated:November4,2015

COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTS
TRIALCOURT
SUFFOLK,ss.

SUPERIORCOURTDEPARTMENT
CASENO.1584CV03118BLS2

NORTHAMERICANCATHOLIC
EDUCATIONALPROGRAMMING
FOUNDATION,INC.,etal.,
Plaintiffs,
>

co
o

v.

CLEARWIRESPECTRUMHOLDINGSII
LLC,etal.,
Defendants.

t;
>

DEFENDANTS'EMERGENCYMOTIONTOSTAYCIVILACTION
DefendantsClearwireSpectrumHoldingsIILLC,ClearwireLegacyLLCf/k/aClearwire

Corporation,andSprintSpectrumL.P.(collectively,"Sprint"),byandthroughtheirundersigned
counselofrecord,herebymovetheCourtonanemergencybasisforanorderstayingthiscivil
actionpendingtheparties'completionofacontractuallymandatedinformaldisputeresolution
process.
Asgroundsforthismotion,Sprintsubmitsthecontemporaneouslyfiledmemorandumof
lawandAffidavitofPatriciaC.Tikkala,andstatesasfollows:
1.

OnWednesday,October14,2015,PlaintiffsNorthAmericanCatholic

EducationalProgrammingFoundation,Inc.,InstructionalTelecommunicationsFoundation,Inc.,
PortlandRegionalEducationalTelecommunicationsCorporation,DenverAreaEducational
TelecommunicationsConsortium,Inc.,ChicagoInstructionalTechnologyFoundation,Inc.,and

COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTS
TRIALCOURT
^^SUE
FOLK,ss.

SUPERIORCOURTDEPARTMENT
CASENO.1584CV03118BLS2

NORTHAMERICANCATHOLIC
MEKJC
EDUCATIONALPROGRAMMING
OUNDATION,INfc^etal.,

\
Plaintiffs,
V

v.

(X

CLEARWIRESPECTRUMHOLDINGSII
LLC,ctal.,
Defendants.

cc
o
.

\
p\.

4.

er
cr

DEFENDANTS'EMERGENCYMOTIONTOSTRIKECERTAIN
PORTIONSOFTHEAFFIDAVITSOFJOHNPRIMEAUANDJOHNSCHWARTZ

v)

DefendantsClearwireSpectrumHoldingsIILLC,ClearwireLegacyLLCf/k/aClearwire
Si
.
\
^^*^orporation,andSprintSpectrumL.P.(collectively,"Sprint"),byandthroughtheirundersigned

1C5

J
0

counselofrecord,herebymovetheCourtonanemergencybasRforanorderstrikingcertain
portionsoftheaffidavitsofJohnPrimeau("PrimeauAffidavit")and.JohnSchwartz("Schwartz
Affidavit")thatPlaintiffsNorthAmericanCatholicEducationalPrograihmingFoundation,Inc.,
(5

InstructionalTelecommunicationsFoundation,Inc.,PortlandRegionalEducational
TelecommunicationsCorporation,DenverAreaEducationalTelecommunications^toqsortium,
Inc.,ChicagoInstructionalTechnologyFoundation,Inc.,andTwinCitiesSchools'
TelecommunicationsGroup,Inc.(collectively,"Plaintiffs")submittedcontemporaneouslywith
theirOctober23,2015EmergencyMotionforaPreliminaryInjunction.
Asgroundsforthismotion,Sprintsubmitsthecontemporaneouslyfiledmemorandumof
lawandstatesasfollows:

5I

,1
3