Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Rooftop
Utility area
Courtyard
Location:
Architect:
Description:
Table of Contents
About the Study.......................................................................................................................................................................3
Literature Review: How do natural elements benefit you?......................................................................................4
Residential
Apartment Roof and Courtyard..........................................................................................................................10
Castillo Serralles........................................................................................................................................................16
Restaurant
Clavel Urban Park International Walk Cuisine............................................................................................22
Museum
Parque de Bombas...................................................................................................................................................26
(Castillo Serralles).....................................................................................................................................................16
Church
Parroquia la Resurreccion del Senor...............................................................................................................30
Inn
Rainforest Inn...............................................................................................................................................................36
The Gallery Inn............................................................................................................................................
..........................42
Resort
El Convento..................................................................................................................................................................48
La Concha.....................................................................................................................................................................54
Abstract
Puerto Rico is a culturally diverse country located in tropical regions
only 1100 miles north of the equator, and these conditions make
it the ideal location for a large and varied array of interactions that
transition from indoors to outdoors. Oftentimes there are specific
spaces designed to house these activities in ways that benefit both their
need for indoor and outdoor features simply by bring the indoors and
outdoors together. These indoor/outdoor spaces will be investigated
in detail in a way which shows their site specific/typological benefits,
or in other words the reason that a blending of indoors and outdoors
was called for, their psychological benefits, or how the spaces positively
impact the mindsets of the people who use them, their community
enhancing and social benefits, their functional benefits to users, and
how their combination of indoor or outdoor elements might play into
any cost saving strategies. Additionally, any positive environmental
impacts will be noted. All of the information will be organized by site,
and each site by site typology. When the various benefits of similar
typologies are compared, many interesting new aspects of transitional
space design will hopefully be revealed.
Methods
This study focuses on a sort of spacial evaluation that takes into account
the main components of indoor/outdoor space. These elements can
be sorted into the categories of typology, health, and envionment.
Typological elements are those that relate to a sites programming,
or what the intended use of the site is. An example would be a
park typology where the inteded uses may be recreation, play, and
excercise. Elements that effect heath relate to both its physiological and
psychological qualities. The physical health benefits of many activities
are rather well understood, so this research has focused mainly on those
that are psychological. A very strong emphasis is also placed on how
natural elements can be beneficial to ones mental well-being, as they
are one of the primary features of an outdoor space that interact with
a site that was meant to be an indoor space that has been brought
partially outside. A literature review is provided to help understand
what it is about these natural elements that have an effect on us, and
how they interact. Environmental benefits refer to what it is about
the site that contributes to the health of the surrounding ecosystem.
Negative environmental impacts have also been noted in certain cases.
This analysis was completed after first visiting each site and spending a
signifigant time ovserving how their spaces are used and recieved. All
of the signifigant elements were studied and recorded, and they are
discussed in detail throughout the book.
When constructing this study, I originally inteded to rely more heavily
aupon plan view photos and diagrams involved in the analysis, but as
Residential - Apartmnt Roof & Courtyard 3
LITERATURE REVIEW`:
The Psychological Benefits of
Natural Elements
The natural world is something that has a long history of fascinating us;
it is both mysterious and strangely familiar. People go out of their way
to incorporate its elements into their lives, but at the same time they try
to control or avoid some of those elements. What is it that makes up the
natural world and what about it draws us to it? Although these questions
may seem somewhat philosophical, there has been in recent times a
great deal of research addressing this subject.
The first question to ask is what exactly defines nature. For the purpose
of this research, it has been defined as the elements of the world that
can exist without interference from a human. This is not to say that a
human cannot work with natural elements, but that in their most basic
elements, human interference is not necessary. In accordance with this
definition, the natural elements that I will be looking at are water, wildlife,
air, vegetation, and sunlight. The elements of wildlife, vegetation, and
sunlight are highly complex and not very well understood, so this paper
will address research that has been done to understand how they work
to benefit our psychological well-being.
The second question to ask is what drives the human love for nature.
Why do we seek it out and choose to incorporate it into our lives? Is its
significance to us cultural, or is it instinctive. This is the simple question
of nature versus nurture. Are we raised to appreciate natural elements,
or is the love for nature something that is in our genes? As you will see
from the research that has been done, our love for the natural world is
clearly biological, but the way in which we perceive the natural world is
at least somewhat tied to our upbringing or our past impressions and
experiences with it.
It is therefore useful to know what exactly it is about the natural world
that we inherently like and benefit from, and also how our cultural
impressions of nature affect our ability to perceive these attributes.
When going through research regarding the benefits of exposure to
natural settings, one of the most outstanding is in natures abilities to
relieve stress. Not only is stress a psychological ailment, but its effects
lead to a marked decrease in our physical health. The psychological
manifestations of stress are generally feelings of depression, anger, and
anxiety or tension. These feelings have been proven to lead to such
physical ailments such as increased blood pressure, tension, release of
stress hormones such as epinephrine, and suppressed immune function.
When these two factors are combined, damaging behavioral symptoms
Animals
A key element of the natural environment is animals. Whether domestic
or wild, they are both an expression of and are sustained by natural
processes. Since strong ties between the natural world and the human
condition have already been established, it is reasonable to assume that
the element of animal life must have its own unique and noteworthy
impact on our psyche. Although animals may seem like a fundamental
element of natural systems, they have historically been ignored,
generally, in research relating to the environment and human behavior.
There does exist, however, a series of interesting and thorough research
into human-animal psychological relationships. This research leads to
the conclusion that animals, depending on the individual, their species,
and the environment, can serve as both inducers of fear and of stressrelief through security and attachment.
Many of this research looks at the concept of mammalian attachment. This
is the bond between mammalian young and those that care for them. It
has been shown that in both human and nonhuman mammals, there are
reciprocal systems of care giving and security seeking between a parent
or parents and their young. In this attachment system, the infants cries,
calls, smiles, and later clinging and following elicit security-providing
care from an attachment gure, generally their mothers (Melson).
This attachment theory provides a basic explanation for many observed
human-animal relationship qualities. One of these relational aspects,
specifically the stress reducing effects of pet dogs, has been observed
through multiple studies. Friendly dogs were found to significantly
reduce stress in children, adults, and elderly. They have also been shown
to initiate social interaction. Although part of these results may be
attributed to a sense of security offered by dogs and companions, other
research has also found rabbits and other small mammals beneficial in
facilitating social interaction in people of all ages. This strongly suggests
that humans are able to use animals as a sort of attachment gure. The
safety and security offered by a companion dog reduces stress, as does
likely the urge to offer these things to smaller mammals, reducing tension
and bringing people together (Melson). Additionally, in instances where
animals are considered nonthreatening, they clearly offer significant
benefits to human mental well being.
All of the above research involves domesticated animals, so it is reasonable
to ask whether these beneficial principles apply to wildlife. Even though
many people live their lives fairly isolated from them, there remains a
strong basic desire to be near wild animals.
One explanation for this is the biophilia hypothesis which suggests an
innate evolutionary affection of human beings towards other living
of how one can understand the feelings of spiritual connection that one
often gets when they unexpectedly happen upon wildlife.
Figure demonstrating the experience of Flow. (Ulich)
Vegetation
One of the most immediately noticeable and perhaps even one
of the first things that come to mind when asked to picture a natural
area is vegetation. It is strongly tied into perceptions of the natural
world, and in itself has profound effects on human behavior. One of
the most interesting of these effects are its positive influences on our
psychological well-being in how they advocate restoration from stress,
therefore benefiting our health as well.
These positive effects have been observed throughout history, being used
through providing gardening opportunities in health care institutions
as far back as at least twelfth century Europe. In the provision of parks,
gardens, and other incorporations of nature into cities, these beliefs have
been observable throughout Europe, Asia, and the America for centuries.
Conversely, scientific studies justifying these century old beliefs have only
recently begun to be performed, although several theories have been
presented. Also until recently, these theories involved a strong emphasis
on cultural and other learning-based explanations for our relationship
with vegetation, for example cultural conditioning. Others theorized
that the highly complex and sensually overwhelming landscape of a city
as opposed that of a natural area might overexcite and stress or fatigue us.
Although these two theories were once widely held, they have become
somewhat less prominent in comparison to evolutionary or species wide
theories.
These theories argue that human attraction to nature and vegetation
relates to our original development in mostly natural settings, and that
we are genetically predispositioned to prefer these spaces. This would
be especially true for vegetation and other natural elements that can be
found favorable to our basic survival needs. It has in fact been observed
in studies by Heerwagen (1980) and Orians (1993) that a broad range
of cultural groups all show a similar positive reaction to very specific
vegetational structures and shapes. This is likely because certain types
of vegetation signal the potential for access to life sustaining elements
such as water, food (which may relate to our attraction to flower blooms,
for example), and security (Ulrich).
No matter the explanation however, a large amount of data supports
the visually experiencing plant material does often have restorative
and other highly beneficial psychological and physiological impact
on the human body. The majority of these benefits are related to the
stress-reducing properties of vegetation. Towards the beginning of this
research, vegetations stress-reducing capacity was rated solely on a basis
of asking university students to rate their stress levels prior to a course
exam. The results of this study suggested that slides mainted urban
settinings lacking vegetation were far less effective at holding attention,
facilitating psychological restoration through a decrease in feelings of
fear and anger and an increase in positive feelings (Ulrich).
Other more recent studies have shown that vegetation also has a positive
effect on stress recovery. One study, for example, exposed 120 people
to a stress-inducing movie and then assigned them a random recovery
period where they were to view recordings of urban environments either
containing or lacking vegetation. With this study, not only were selfratings of feelings used, but also physiological indicators such as skin
conductance, muscle tension, pulse transit time, and heart rate. The
results clearly indicated that stress recovery happened at a much faster
rate when vegetation was present. Results could be seen in less than five
minutes time (Ulrich).
Sunshine
Air
Air is an extremely imprtant natural element as it does not only have
many positive qualities in itself, but also helps connect other elements
with those who interact with them. It takes their qualites such as scent
for example, something that is most closely connected to our memory,
and brings them directly to us. It cause cooling interactions with water,
also taking an element that may be far away and causing a direct
physical interaction. It creates the movement in the surcaces of that
water and in vegetation that we find so naturally fascination, and alters
the temperature of a space through breezes which in themselves can be
found to be restorative and desirable. For all of these reasons, airflow and
quality sould be considered as one of the key elements that determine
the success and potential benefit of any designed space.
References
Ackerman, Jennifer. The Great Sunshine Standoff. Psychology Today.
Sussex Publishers, 1 Nov. 2007. Web.
Curtin, Susanna(2009)Wildlife tourism: the intangible, psychological
benefits of human-wildlife encounters, Current Issues in
Tourism,12:5,451 474
Dixit, Jay. Soak up the Sun. Psychology Today. Sussex Publishers, 1 Jan.
2009. Web.
Melson, Gail F. Psychology and the Study of Human-Animal
Relationships. Animalsplatform.org. Animals & Society
Institute, n.d. Web.
Ulrich, Roger S., Ph.D. Effects of Vegetation Views On Stress And Health
Indicators. PAWA - Plants at
Work Association. College of Architecture, Texas A&M University, n.d.
Web.
Van Den Berg, Agnes E., Sander L. Koole, and Nickie Y. Van Der Wulp.
Environmental Preference And restoration: (How
Are They Related? Journal of Environmental Psychology
23 (2003) 135146. B Free University, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands, 18 Dec. 2000. Web.
Water
Water is a natural element that is highly attractive to people for multiple
reasons. First is the idea of natural fascination. As we are a species heavily
Residential - Apartmnt Roof & Courtyard 7
Library of Sites
Base Map
Rooftop
The rooftop area is a very spacious and clearly defined as a
distinct space. It shapes into its own outdoor room. that
extends from the utility area below. As of now there isnt
very much programming within, but its design offers a lot of
potential. The only notable feature present is a raised platform
near the center with a storage shed on top.
1. Courtyard
4.
3.
2. Rooftop
3. Planting Bed
Utility area
4. Storage Area
1.
2.
Courtyard
Location:
Calle Cristina, Ponce, PR
As the space that connectly direcs to the houses main living aea,
it serves as an extention of the indoor living space.
Description:
Calle Cristina is a historic street set into the heart of downtown Ponce, Puerto Rico. Space is very limited and
most buildings, including this apartment, are set tightly side by side. Since space is such a constraint in this
area, availability of outdoor space and the comfortability of living come into question.
This particular apartment solves both of these spacial issues by using indoor/outdoor spaces to make it more
than livable and actually quite enjoyable.
The spaces used include a beautifully landscaped courtyard as well as a rooftop area the size of the entire
apartment. Not only do these spaces offer many benefits for the apartments inhabitants, but they also open
up possibilities for a great many other highly beneficial uses.
Typological Functions
The extreme exposure to the elements makes the whole rooftop area feel
like the apartments back yard, but its structure is also remeniscent of a
living room, making the space suitible to be an interesting combination
of both if only appropriate shelter from the elements were to be provided.
As of now it is good for outdoor activities that require a large area of
space such as sports, sunbathing, and large scale gatherings. The latter
is especially fitting to the space at night when the area has cooled down
and guests can enjoy an expansive, uninterrupted view of the night sky
and when sitting on top of the platform, of the city lights as well.
When you first enter the space, you walk into a typical courtyard. It is
directly visable from and attached to the interior dining room and living
area, and it therefore is highly suitible to serve these functions outdoors.
The roof is expansive, completely white, and often glowing with the
intensity of the tropical sun. During the late afternoon, the brightness and
heat are so opressive that youll likely feel the urge to go back downstairs,
but the view is still intensely fascinating, causing you to surpress the urge
long enough to at least have a look around.
Although the walls on the roof, for safety reasons, are too tall to allow any
view out into the city, you can look over several rooftops if you sit atop
this platform. It truly creates a separate, defined space amongst the vast
emptiness of the roof.
The courtyards smaller scale and high walls offer a sense of enclosure
and safety that make it well suited for more intimate, smaller sized social
Apon doing so, you will notice that the roof is entirely barren of anything
at all minus a few odd grade changes on the ground plane and one raised
Courtyard.
The enclosure of the lower area can also offer some shade from the sun
and shelter from tropical storms, while the openness of the roof definitely
allows much more integration with the natural elements.
Courtyard garden and seating wall.
Negative Value
Ecological Value
This site has a very positive health value for an urban residence. It offers
the opportunity for various physical activities to take place alongside
more relaxion based passtimes without having either interfere with
eachother. For example, while some family members might be playing
on the roof, others may be sitting quietly in the courtyard below.
Barren rooftop.
Courtyard Plantings.
Museum
This small museum is located at the base of la Cruceta del Viga, a
prominent cross shaped watchtower on the property. It features
LaTienda la Mora, a replication of an old time convenience store
filled with historic but everyday items such as Flappers dresses,
coca cola bottles, and other objects that would have once been
found in a Ponce convenience store. There is a man behind its
front counter who is willing to explain the stores contents to you
as well provide as any other historical infomation in which
Location:
Ponce, Puerto Rico
Architect:
Pedro Adolfo de Castro Besosa
Japanese Garden
The Castlillo has a small Japanese garden on its grounds. This
garden integrates carefully trained plantings with sculptural and
structural elements, creating many livable outdoor spaces.
Description: Castillo Serralles was once home the Serralles family, the wealthy owners of a sugar company,
but after a charitable donation it has now been converted into a museum belonging to the municipality of
Ponce. Its location in the beginnings of the islands central mountain system gives the site a constant breeze
and amazing views out over Ponce. This makes outdoor living highly desirable throughout the castle, and it
indeed has become a main focus throughout.
The castle was built during the 1930s in the Spanish Revilal style. It currently holds many small hisorical exhibits
along with La Hacienda Mercidita, an ongoing exhibit dedicated to portraying the home as it was while once
occupied by the Serralles family.
There isnt much information available about the floor plan or interior of the Castillo Serralles as its owners
requie a fee for for photography and other information and only allow admitance to the site through tour
groups.
The formal entries from the interior couryard into the rest of the house
have no windows or doors, allowing uninterrupted airflow from the
outdoors.
Typological Function
The Castillo demonstrates functionalites of both a private residence and
a public museum.
Central Fountain
is created. These rooms, depending on the size and design, are used for
many different sized gatherings with varrying levels of formality, making
the area surrounding the castle a highly social space.
There are also many social gathering spaces throughout the grounds
adjoining the castle. The dramatic slopes have been paved into many
smooth terraces. As each terrace becomes lower, a new outdoor room
It achieves this by transitioning into the other areas of the house through
open archways allowing cool air to pass through. The air is cooled
naturally as the courtyards central fountain and the outdoor air from
above. When the warm air is drawn in from outside, it must first pass
over the spray from the fountain. This cools it significantly, creating both
a breeze and a form of natural air conditioning.
Outdoor Integration
The benefits from natural elements are very strongly visable in the
Japanese and butterfly gardens.
The pergola in the Japanese garden offeres an excellent example of
how natural elements can be woven in to the frame of a built structure.
While the roof is intact to provide shading and shelter for those within,
the abscense of walls allows for the transfer of sunlight and air. Also,
vegetation and water are placed as a way to frame the space in place of
built walls, adding visual interest and other restorative properties while,
like the other sites in the Castillo, providing a natural cooling effect.
Animals
Ecological Value
Vegetation and Habitat
Although many of the castle gardens are formal, there is also much
minimaly managed area throughout the site home to many native and
naturalized plantings and the organisms that enhabit them. Even in
some of the formal gardens, the Japanese for example, the is a strong
emphasis on diversity and less on hedging practiices that reduce the
quality of habitat.
Animal Species
Throughout the propery, many species of insects includig butterflies
and moths, birds, lizards, amphibians, fish, and some stray dogs could be
seen during over a several hour period.
The fish, amphibians, and some of the butterflies were placed there and
cared for intentiaonally by castle staff.
Planted bromiliads add color and interest to areas above ground level.
Between thes large amount of wild area and the care taken by staff, there
is fairly high level of diversity on site making fairly diverse habitat options.
The only downfall of this layout may be the potential for invasive plant
and animal species to dominate the unmanaged areas of land.
Wild catarpillar living in some brush.
Base Map
Dining Area
The parks main dining area stands completely seperate from
any built structure, and yet its own form could almost be
defined as a complete buiding, if only it were enclosed within
walls. But it is not. Air and sunlight flow freely between the
colums that take their place supporting the canopy overhead,
and a seating wall accesible both from both inside and out of
the space take there place in holding the structures form.
1. Dining Area
2. Pergola
3. Concessions
1.
2.
3.
Operated By:
Description:
The Clavell International Walk Cuisine is an outdoor eating area inside Parque Urbano
Dora Coln Clavell, or Dora Colon Clavell Urban Park. Located near the center of
downtown Ponce, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience where all the comforts of a traditional
restaurant are provided except in an outdoor setting. This outdoor integration is perhaps one of the most
striking features of the restaurant as it seamelsy blends with its surroundings, a beautifully landscaped park.
Some indoor areas make such an elaborate outdoor dining area possible; there is a large kitchen and parking
area underground.
23.9
Not only does this restaurant provide all the usual comforts, but its unique design allows for many
other inventive ways to improve your dining experience. Not only can you eat in the shaded dining area, but
several stands along its lenght sell food as well, each one coming from a specific country or being of a specific
type. You can also chose to eat at or use the bar along the front of many of these stands, and if neither of those
options work for you, there are many indents along the massive pergola lining the dining area parallel to the
food stands. These somewhat sheltered spaces alow for different sizes of private gathering, whether it be just
one or two people or a very large group. These seating areas are open to the public and sport movable tables
that open them up to far more uses than just dining.
Dining - Clavel Urban Park International Walk Cuisine 23
Although there are no art installations in the park, the landscaping and
structures have all been arranged into a detailed formal garden that in
itself is a work of art.
With a strong geomeric layout, a pergola that works its way throughout
the gardens forming elaborate patterns remeniscent of a French formal
garden style. The plant selection has been chosen in t he same fashion,its
primary function being to maintain the rythym and aestetics of the park.
This site offers almsot all the normal benefits of a park setting. It is an
area for both play and restoration, and is perhaps one of the largest park
spaces in walking distance of downtown Ponce.
Unfortunately, a high level of paving and maintained plantings doesnt
provide for many soft surfaces to sit on. Also, it limits the variety of the
plant material and therefore greatly reduces their naturally fascinating
qualities.
Main restaurant space.
Typological Functions
As a place for play, the channeled walkways and highly structured hedging
limits a childs ability to interact with their environment, although it is
still heavily used. Also as a place for relaxation, the style of the garden
slightly limits its restorative potential. This park is a place to be enjoyed
for a short while, but is not ideal for spending extensive amounts of time.
Ecological Value
The parks landscaping is highly structured and repetative but still used.
Also, several bees could be seen falling dead around the benches and a
general lack of flying insecsts suggesting that the population that should
be frequenting the park may have come in contact somewhere with
pesticides.
It still should be noted that the provision of underground parking has
provided signifigant environmental benefit by replacing what would
have otherwise been a large expance of unpermiable surface with park
plantings which are far better at keeping stormwater on site.
Areas like these can house large groups and feature movable furnature.
The vegetation is highly maintained and not very diverse but is still
enjoyed by park visitors like the children playing in the background.
Dining - Clavel Urban Park International Walk Cuisine 25
Upstairs Left
On this level, a temporary architectural exhibit is
displayed. Currently, the exhibit shows drawings and
information about the 19th century fortifications of
San Juan.
Upstairs Right
Location:
Description:
What was once a firehouse has now become one of the most highly visited museums in
downtown Ponce. This is true for several reasons, including its unusual, bright coloration, location in the citys
center, and unique constant opening to the outdoors. In fact, this museum has no front doors. Visitors are
welcome to look inside all day and night, although a single chain does keep them from entering when the
building is closed.
It may seem unusual that a firehall would be so well suited as a museum, but the building wasnt originally
constructed to be a fire hall. It was built in 1882 to be the main exhibit pavilion for the Exhibition Trade Fair. It
did not become Ponces official firehouse until 1885. The building was designed in a Gothic style with Moorish
influences.
Although it is small, Parque de Bombas is one of the first things that come to mind when mentioning Ponce
to many tourists, and indeed is the image most frequently associated with the municipality. Even the shortest
visit to the site will confirm this, as there is always a constant stream of tourists visiting and photographing its
colorful walls.
Museum Displays.
Museum - Parque de Bombas 27
Natural light and fresh air easily penetrates the entire museum.
Entrance to the Parque de Bombas. Note the lack of doors.
Typological Function
Education and Tourism
The main function of the Parque de Bombas is to provide residents and
tourists a chance to learn about the firehalls as well as Ponces history.
There is no charge for entrenence, as the building has been designed
to provide free education, however for the small fee of two dollars at
the front dest, one can purchase tickets for a historical trolly tour that
goes throughout the city. In addition to being financially accesible, the
museum is also designed to be simple to find and navigate and is both
eyecatching and inviting as well, leading to its success as one of the most
known areas of Ponce.
These displays are almost exclusively pieces from the firehalls past, but
some local art and temporary displays are often included. On the left
upper level, a temporary display of archtiectural drawings can be viewed.
On the floor below, sculptures done by local artists can also be seen at
times.
Rooftop
The atrium is the space that you first enter into apon arriving at
the church. It is a traditional addition that relates back to the
ancient spaces in Jewish temples outside the main central space.
The purpose of the atrium is to provide a transitional area where
people can switch from the mindset of daily life which theyve
just come from into a quieter, more comtemplative state of mind
more appropriat for what is considered a sacred space within.
Stage
Utility area
The focus of the central space is the stage. This is where the
churchs priest delivers sermons along with most other important
church activities. Its design, like that of the rest of the church, is
very naturalistic and minimalistic.
Nave
Location:
San Juan, Puerto Rico
Architect:
Description:
Parroquia la Resurreccion del Senor, or Ressurection of the Lord Parish, is a Catholoc church where services are
held in a truly indoor/outdoor space. The intention of this outdoor integration was to bring the focus of the congregation directly to God through the experiencing of his creation.
The design is very minimalistic as not to become too distracting, and so is the landscaping. Local art is integrated thoughout the structure and is not only religious, but in some places reflective of the life and culture of the
churchs congregation.
Atrium Entrance.
Church - Parroquia la Resurreccion del Senor 31
Typological Functions
Preaching/Teaching
One of the main focuses of any church is the sermon, and the Parroquia
la Resurreccion del Senor its space great priority. From anywhere within
the church, the elevated stage can be seen.
On it rest an alter and a podium, and behind it a veiw to the outside
is exposed, encouraging reflection and directing attention towards
the heavens. Although this may seem to present the possibility for
distraction, the alter which is usualy placed centrally to the stage has been
shifted sideways to allow for the placement of the podium. This makes
it much easier for the congregation to direct their attention towards the
speaker. The alter and podium themselves are made up of a concrete like
composite suitable for outdoor use.
Congregational Seatings
Not only was the congregations needs considered in regards to the
sermon, but their comfort was also a high priority. The benches were
all specially designed to suit the needs of those sitting outside in a
tropical climate for extended periods of time. Wood was shaped into a
comfortable form, with the lower back of each bench being open to alow
for a constant cooling affect from the wind. To encourage a breeze, fans
are evenly distributed throughout the structure.
Confessional
The confessional was made to be simplistic, comforting, and open. It has
the same repeating form seen in the benches. Upon entering, one may
chose to sit screened from the preist or to sit side by side with him.
Art
The most visable piece is a large painting done in the style of Pablo
Picasso and with contemporary figures. It covers the walls of the gated
section of the front stage that holds the holy sacrament
.
Throughout the entirity of the church, art has always been a main focus.
The architect has made it a point that this art should not only serve to
hold the traditional religious subject matter, but also that it should relate
back to to the local congregation in both style and display.
In fact, much of the art displayed in this church doesnt seem to have any
religous theme immediately apperent, but instead displays themes from
local history or daily life.
One such piece of artwork can be found along the walls of the atrium.
It serves to display a visual local history that is relevant to the church
members.
Wall art isnt the only type present in the atrium. This famous
reinterpretation ofthe madonna is also a focal point within church and
a frequent subject of conversation by its parishinors and congregation.
The jokingly refer to the statue as, the dinosaur, in acknowledgemet of
the unusual form of its head. This is a good sign that the artwork in this
church is not only for focused religous attention, but also can be taken
lightheartedly in a very restorative mannor.
Ecological Value
philodendron vines.
Outdoor Integration
The way in which they wall in the space softens the feeling of enclusure
within, making it seem much safer and more connected with the
surrounding environment.
In this church, psycological and ecological value are closely tied together.
as the architect has given a great deal of concern to each element, often
by combining them.
This could not be more strongly illustrated than by looking to the garden
holding the statue of St. Frances. He is remembered for his love for nature,
and the architect has not let this be forgotten, as it has helped inspire
the entire design of the church. This is why the walls and roofs are open
throughout, and why a beautifully landscaped garden serves as the only
decoration on the inside walls. This building is meant to inspire a strong
appreciation for the natural world. This, of course, is to both encourage
respect for that world and to draw attention to its creator.
A positive effect of this design emphasis is that the entire congregation is
encouraged to develop a basic respect for the natural world which they
can hopefully carry through into their daily lives.
All of the gardens that comprise the walls of the church are constantly
being desinged for the same reason. Their design, however, is kept
somewhat simplistic as not to distract from the sermons and worship that
go on within.
The plants themselves are a mix of native and Asiatic non-native tropicals
that repeat throughout the space, namely palms, gingers, thai plants, and
Base Map
Main Building
insert comments
1.
1. Main Building
7.
3.
2.
2. Yoga Room
Additions
Most of the site is built on top of the ruins of pe-existing
structures that were destroyed during the storm surge
from a hurricane, but not every structure has yet been
renovated. This building is still under construction but
will soon hold additional guest housing, an aquaculture
system, and a gymn.
3. Additions
4. Upper Deck
5. Lower Deck
Guest Housing
Location:
Rio Grande, Puerto Rico
Architect:
6.
4.
6. Pond
5.
7. Lawn
72
Description:
The Rainforest Inn is a goergous, secluded property located right within the El Yunque rainforest. Its exact
location is difficult to find as its road is gated from the general public, making it truly iscolated. In fact, there
is ony room on the site for a handful of people to stay at a time, yet even with such a high level of seclusion, it
still manages to remained booked for months at a time.
Scale is approximate
Inn - Rainforest Inn 37
Typological Function
Entertainment
Living Space
There are many activities to enjoy at the Inn, and some of those activities
have spaces that are specially adapted for them. A yoga room with
thin paper walls and glassless windows that allow air and sunlight to
continually pass through extends from the main building.
On the lower level of the deck, the archery area makes an interesting use
of a buildings ruins. What was once an enclosed room is now very opn
to the elements but still sheltered enough to allow for its use in most
weather conditions.
Also, further plans for the additions being built into the undeveloped
ruins include a partially enclosed gymn.
The mian building itself extends from the deck into unrestored ruins
of the original structure. Here there are further rooms, but instead of
having walls and roofs, they are exposed to the natural elements and a
clear view of the rainforest that drops down below.
The effect of this design is rather amazing. In almost any location
througout this space, you truly are made to feel like you are directly
within the forest which is both beautiful and peaceful. It is quiet, breezy,
Rainforest Exploration
Coming off of the lower deck of the ruins where the archery space is
located is an old stone stairway that twists down to a private rainforest
path. It connects visitors to a peaceful walk that leads to a private
natural swimming hole.
Self Sustainability
One of the owners main goals is to make the Inn as sustainable as
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Snail.
Ecological Value
The health benefits offered from a stay in the Rainforest Inn are numerous,
and mostly come in the form of the relaxation and restoration that come
from its verry intentional integraion with the rainforest.
The Rianforest Inn has extrordinay ecological value due to the education,
development, and service based innitiatives undertaken by its owner.
Art
There isnt much in the way of actual atwork, but the owner of the
Inn takes personal care to craft all of his structures with materials and
designs that he finds to be viaully appealing and artistic. This same care
is also carried out within the landscaping which is done by a professional
landscape architect and additionally in the maintence of deliberately
chosen views towards the forest that drops down below the site.
One of the owners leading concerns was that he create a space that
respects and is not destructive to its surrounding environment. With the
use of preexisting ruins and a combination of doing his own construction
and managing contracters, he has been highly successfull in this goal.
Vegetation
Water
The ponds close proximity to the upper deck allows those who are using
that space to also enjoy the restorative benefits of viewing a water feature.
Wildlife
An additional benefit of this ephasis on connection and vegetation is
the close incorporation of wildlife into the site. Usually this might be
considered somewhat risky, but the El Yunque rainforest doesnt have
any large, venemous, or otherwise dangerous predators that may could
potentially become a hinderance to such an open design. Because of
this, wildlife is free to road throughout the grounds, facilitating many
positive wildlife encounter opportunities.
Not only is this reflected in the initial construction, but in on site recycling
installments such as large cistern with a 5 stage filtered used to recycle
grey-water, therefore helping to preserve the islands water resources.
Designer
Jan DEsopo
Description:
The Gallery Inn is a beautiful network of buildings located in Old San Juan just off of a road that skirts the
ocean. It has been designed by sculptor and painter Jan DEsopo who lives on the site with her husband.
She describes the space as a botique hotel but also used the space as a gallery for hers as well as for her
collection of artwork. There are also several studio galleries on site.
The inn itself consists of partially deconstructed buildings that she has joined together to make a series of
indoor and outdoor spaces. It was a goal of the artist to integrate natural elements heavily into these spaces
along with her artwork, and vegetaion therefore heavily dominates many of the areas, and animals such as
seval exotic parrots are allowed to roam certain areas. The resulting effect is the stunning creation of a highly
beautiful and enjoyable series of spaces that are highly sought after by people of all classes, even being visited
by US president Barack Obama.
Some of the Inns interior rooms, especially in the areas between diffeent joined properties, are not enclosed by a roof.
Inn - The Gallery Inn 43
Typological Functions
Recreation
Relaxation
The Gallery Inn is a very similar to a resort in typology, although its main
features are most suited to enhancing the quality of the activities of
daiy life. In this way, many of the areas meant for relaxation have the
appearance of rooms that might appear in a hous such as living or other
sitting rooms, and outdoor spaces are done in the style of patios. But
there is any domestic feel to these spaces as one might expect. Instead,
the atmosphere is an interesting combonation of being in a jungle, an
art gallery, and and within ruins of an unidentifiable origin. This unique
ambiance removes the visitor from thier connections to their everyday
lives and brings them instead into this interesting world of the artists
creation.
Study
Several office-like spaces are placed throughout the site. Their designs
are sophisticated as well as serene, allowing for an ideal environment for
accomplishing work.
Mostly enclosed indoor study area has doors which open in the mnner
of a large window, allowing room for a large amount of vegetation,
wunlight, and airflow.
mainly revolove around social interactions and relaxation, but that is not
at all to say that ones options are limited. There is an astonishing amount
of diversity on this sight, as each room is completely different from the
rest. Also, no two seating options are the same. This gives the space a
sense of mystery that invites exploration, another considerable activity
suited towards this site.
Outdoor bed and lounge area sits across from the formal dining hall.
Wine deck sits on the very top of the property and overlooks the ocean
and Old San Juan.
Inn - The Gallery Inn 45
In some space, direct sun, along with its many mood enhancing qualities,
is allowsed to enter, while in others, the sunlight is not. Guests are free
Upper wine deck is exposed to a strong cool breeze and overlooks both
the ocean and Old San Juan.
Two roofless rooms are located near the Inns entrance. Their walls are
heavily decorated with plantings and sculpture.
to choose what level of exposure they desire at the time, and can move
freely between various levels of light. Even at night, they can choose
between sitting under the natural light of the stars, or under one of the
many tastefully chosen lighting fixtures in the more enclosed spaces.
Even the pool is artfully illuminated at night, also extending the times in
which it as a space can be used.
They also invite a sense of mystery and play by the way in which they
separate and hide different rooms within the property and provide
habitat for many different animals, some wild and some cared for.
The animal additions themselves also enhance this space, providing
guests with unexpected but well recieved wildlife encounters throughout
all of the partially outdoor spaces.
Views
Another way in which the artist expresses her taste is throgh the framing
of views. Structures are carefully placed in ways that provide interesting
and beautiful expanses of the ocean or city to be seen in many different
areas of the Inn.
Ecological Value
Although ecological value was not a main consideration within the
space, the extent, diversity, and naturalness of the plantings invites
many wild species to enjoy areas within the site.
Also, there is quite a bit of aquaponics production that takes place
out on the rear decks to provide food for the complex and therefore
minimize use of resiources.
Resort: El Convento
Entrance and Upper Levels`
This area connects directly to the sidewalk of an Old San
Juan street, inviting people in to sit and enjoy the featured
restaurat and bar that is situated within this entrance space.
The restaurants main kitchen and dining area is further within
the complex and seated atop a balcony overlooking the lower
levels.
Lower Levels
As the streets of Old San Juan are very dramatically sloped, a
signifigant grade change is neccessary for one to be able to
enter the resort from different ends. Because of this, a partially
recessed lower level with an attached courtyard are present
on the site. The lower level is used mostly for formal events
and guest reception, while the courtyard is used as a large
outdoor lounge.
Location:
Description:
Hidden within the maze of buildings that make up the hilly streets of Old San Juan, El
Convento reveals only a small bit of its spacious and beautifully designed grounds. Its unique combonation
of indoor and outdoor space is not at all modern, but instead dates back to 1646. It was constructed by will of
the Spanish noblewoman Dona Ana de Lansos in an effort to provide the war-torn island with a convent for
women to stay. A great deal of time and money was invested into its construcion as Dona Ana donated her
entire estate, land, and sold all her possessions inorder to pay for its construction and upkeep.
It was designed by an army engineer and constructeed by soldiers of Colonial Spain. Its design provided
small rooms for the nuns along with a massive interior courtyard and domed cathedral. It remained a convent
until 1903 when its repairs were deemed too costly to continue its upkeep. It then went through periods of
vacancies and other uses including a shopping center, dancehall, and parking lot for garbage trucks until 1857
when the area was assigned to be bulldozed to make room for a new parking garage.
Fortunately, in 1959 under Operation Bootstrap, the wealthy Robert Frederick Woolworth purchased the
convent and created the expansive hotel El Convento. After two years, the addition of three floors the convent
was near finished, but not until its interior designer, photographer, and Woolworth traveled through out
Spain to find authentic furnishings from the countrys Golden Age. When pieces couldnt be found, elaborite
reproductions were commissioned.
Opening in 1962, it was an immediate success frequented by the worlds upper classes. What distinguished
it from other more modern hotels was hisoric design from the times when hotels werent were in themselves
destinations for travel. Since then the hotel has chaged hands several times, but its grand historic design and
popularity still remains.
Dining Areas
Dining areas are dispersed throughout the resort on all floor
levels and also in varying levels of formality. They are open at
different times throughout the day to the public or are used
for banquets.
Resort - El Convento 49
continually provides music for those who gather in that area, making
the space a socail destination.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Typological Function
Relaxation
Socializing
El Convento is a highly social space. Almost all of the public areas have
been designed with seating or other gathering areas as their primary
focous. Also, a wide variety of social activites have been accomidated.
Near the entrance, people who might prefer to be around a large
amount of people can sit at table to eat or talk at talbles set adjoining
San Juan a San Juan. Here, the ambient sounds of a city along with the
slightly vouyeristic aspects of being seated in an urban setting make
this an intensely social space, but it does seem to be more habitated at
times when the nearby food and drink services areas are operating.
The idea of vouyerism has also been drawn into the dining areas. The
upper restaurant sits on top of a ledge that overlooks the entire lower
courtyard, and the lower, enclosed dining area is lined with open
windows that also look out onto the same courtyard.
The lower courtyard itself offers a wide variety of social activites. In one
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
The lower courtyard is very well used, and this is largely due to the way
in which it provides comfortable areas for all types of socialization and
in the way that they are arranged and connected in a way that can easily
bring together diffent social groups instead of iscolating them. There
is also a level of class and history in its design that seems to invite its
acceptance as a popular meetup space.
Formal Events
The resort is frequently booked for formal events, as its highly aesthetic
and social setting as well as the level of sophistication in its service.
There are elaborately designed indoor and outdoor rooms to house
guests, very refined ambient entertainment such as the paono player
playing classicle pieces during gatherins, and also waters and waitresses
dressed professionially in full suits. The guests themselves treat the
space with a high level of formality, often showing up in elaborite suits
and gowns.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Vegetation
The specific artistic usage of vegetation is rather multidimensional as it
utilizes plants as sculptural elements, wall and edge decoration,
Ecological Value
Ecological value hasnt been a high priority in this design, but by the
nature of its layout and use of vegetation, it does have some benefit to
local wildlife. Several of the trees on site are native to Puerto Rico. Also,
the practice of providing vegetation on many different height levels
creates a several ecological possibilities.
Upper Right: warm colors and classic design used in interior of building.
Lower Right: Cooler colors along with heavy plant ornamentation used
outdoors.
Resort - El Convento 53
Resort: La Concha
Interior and Patio
Apon entering the resort, you walk into a bright, open space
that is the main lobby. It is connected to an outdoor patio or
courtyard-like area that sits between the resorts properties.
Both of these areas are very well designed and have extensive
seating and dining options.
Beach Areas
The outdoor space that connects to the loby also opens into a
lower area that leads out to the beach. Here, beds are provided
for tanning, showers for swimmers, and lounge chairs and
other accessories for beachgoers. Drinks are also served on
this level.
Restaurants
Location:
Condado, San Juan
Architect:
Osvaldo Toro and Miguel Ferrer.
Description:
La Concha is a resort built into Condado, a section of San Juan. It was originally created in 1958 during the
Tropical Modernism Movement, but had closed for a period of time only to reopen in 2008 under the ownership
of the Marriotts Renaissance Hotels brand. Apon its reopening, two more properties were added. Their
arrancement created a central, partially enclosed outdoor area that functions as a lounge space for guests.
Four food service areas are located on the property, both indoors and out.
La Concha.
Resort - La Concha 55
Typological Function
Dining
There are several different dining areas suited to invite several user
groups. The first is a modern style bar in the central indoor space. It is
in the middle of the room, very open, and has a clear view out to the
garden area. It is also very near the Casino.
Relaxation
Seating near sushi bar. Outdoor restaurant can be seen on the right.
Just outside the doors to the outside and off to the right is another
eating area, this being not only a bar but also a restaurant. Here, one
can choose whether theyd like to sit at the counter or to be waited
apon at one of several tables. If theyd wish, the customer may also
eat their food in one of the many private seating areas dispersed
throughout the decked area.
Recreation
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Upper Left: view of upper deck. Lower Left: pathway to lower deck.
Art
Ecological Value:
There is a great deal of abstract and modern art throughout the property,
especially in the main lobby. What is interesting about this art is that much
of it is very large, on a scale that allows guests to interact with it. The art
also spans across many different mediums, involving lighting, water, and
vegetation very heavily, and therefore bringing out the positive elements
of water and vegetative features.
Vetetation
Vegetation throughout the site exists for mainly sculpturl and aesthetic
reasons. They are generally placed into containers so that they can be
moved around and aranged as one would do with a piece of artwork. It is
also heavily used to section off larger areas into individual smaller spaces.
Water
Water is a very prominent feature on this site. It is used for both its
reflective qualities and also for its qualities of movement, both of which
are explored heavily throughout many installations around the property.
The most notable perhaps is the large fountain and waterfall system that
emcompasses the entrance of the resort. It explores several different
ways in which water can move and interact with itself, creating many
fascinating patters. Also, a network of channels works its way through
Both th architecture of the walls and glass railings along with the
placement of plantings serve to frave the view of the ovcean, creating a
desirable atmosphere for these seating areas.
the outdoor space, lushly edged by container plantings which help it to
section off offindividual seating areas, creating many small and highly
restorative spaces for individuals or small groups.
Views
Views throughout the site are maintained by sculptural and constuction
techniques. Framing is heavily used to maintiain these views through
sculpting of the surrounding architcture or through the use of suspended
glass paneling.