Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 25

Tishreen University Journal. Eng.

Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


2005 (2)  (27)   


  _ 

   
Tishreen University Journal for Studies and Scientific Research- Engineering Sciences Series Vol. (27) No (2) 2005

$  "#


 !     

'%
 
 $( %
& 
*

)
* $* 
+

(2005/4/28 $(  - . )

012
   
 
   !    "  #   "
 $   "

)* +
'

$
,
 
 $-   
$
  
& .*/ 0* ( & ' 
  
. 1
 
 2   #3 4 
78 2  9 0   
) 
& : 4  ;6
< 0* '
9 
) 3
 , 36 0*

  & 
- 1
 ) ;  ) 2  ? @ '  4  *   
 ;-' = >3
.( A... 

  *'!

  *) )  ?  (0
 E$) D- B9 7 ? 1 0$ 
 9  #3 C
.   
 E,9 @-  >3 .
9 0*  D 

 ( F 
:0 

8 78 C @ 
.
  0  ;   (  
 $? @- .1
.& H
 
  0 D !  7 ? 0
 $ B9 .2

.
 .3      + - 5 6   3# *
187

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

2005 (2)  (27)   


  _ 

   
Tishreen University Journal for Studies and Scientific Research- Engineering Sciences Series Vol. (27) No (2) 2005

The Vaults of the Arab Islamic Architecture and the


Influence of the Abbasid Vault on the Gothic
Architecture in the Middle Ages
Dr. Hani Hashem Wadah *
(Accepted 28/4/2005)

ABSTRACT
With the decline of the Byzantine Empire at the beginning of the 7th century , the
Arab Islamic civilization with its different branches of sciences came to light . There
can be no doubt that it had not only taken advantage of the sciences of former civilizations
, but it had contributed to their refinement , development and molding . Therefore, it had
been the source from which all humanity learned. Meanwhile, Europe was totally
immersed in ignorance, darkness and corruption. Hence, it was quite normal to turn
towards that rich source of science and knowledge to acquire and learn from its different
sciences ( medicine, chemistry, optics, architecture, ornamentation, mathematics , etc ).
This research casts light on a considerably small influence ( the Abbasid vault ) of
the Arab Islamic Architecture on the Gothic Architecture in Europe following the
classification of the vaults of the Arab Islamic Architecture.
The research aims to find out the following :
The classification of the vaults of the Arab Islamic Architecture according to the
eras they had been through.
The influence of the Abbasid vault on the Gothic style from the structural and artistic
angles.

Assistant Professor Department Of Architectural Design Faculty Of Architecture - Tishreen


University Lattakia , Syria

188

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


:
.
9 0*    
 2) #3 B/ ? D ,  4,9  C  4
1 1
'F  2 ?
 ?
4) <  / !   B /  " : 4$ *$9 :;
    
9   $  >
6 
3  $<
3 ? C "
-/
. " 0 /
   ;  7 ?

9  $ K

 > &  - ; 
 ?  46
 3
 "
;D )* ;-'
9 -'  / 
  L36    0
 )&    ,  
? 
 78
. [ 1 ] " 7  $ ;6
< 0*
M ,
< 4! F 
) #3
;3 
! . 4  4'  *    78 P 9 
 7 ? 
 0 8

 4) 9 P  ( A      /    H 
$ 
 ) & ' 4  M


 
6< ? @ ' 

 ?Q*
  0 D-
8 *
9



$
  3'9
$<      *  -  ) 
 4$* 
 L36 ; 1

6    $

. ( A     !  

  ;   ;
BQ 7 ? 1 0$  
 L36  4
  BQ 36 - 
.     06 7  $ * 0*   
0*    
 
   !    "  #   "
 $   "
2   #3 4  
)* +
'

$
,
 
 $-   
$
  
& .*/
. 1
 

78 2  9 0   
) 
& : 4  ;6
< 0* '
9 
) 3 , 36 0*
H
  
-  1
 )  ;  ) 2  ? @ '  4  *   
 ;-' = >3
. ( *'! 
  &
. #
  & 6 F9 )  ?   B9 7 ? 1 0$ 
 9  #3 C
I
 9  29 P #   "
 $   "
9 0* 
 0 
  ! 
 38
:
   ? 
6

 > BQ D

  0$  0* 0   
& ;
 7 ? 0
 0 !  
 "  .1
[ 2 ]. $*9 4

  " : >3 
9 .
    0*
 &  
 -
?   7 ? ) BQ .2
>
 ! 6 

 BQ H
 0
 I  2*  #
 ! #   "
 $
   6 #3 0 D !   2
.B 4) 
M '  #   ? 0
B $   78   #3
. @$ $ 0*    R F
' S $* >
 

$ 0* 
 !
 ? .  9 )  0 D  >
 ! 
*
 0 & 8
. #  ? E
' $ 7 #   "
 $      F
M   M B)9 
)
/ 7 

189

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

   D 
 >
 
? 
 * 4' / 0*  '  
  -
 8

 $ 9 )  0  - ; * 4' /


63'9 0    
  T BQ
:
 -
 78
:(  6 : =<
#
:
 *
 )3 
8
,
?9 0* R' -
 0

 ? 0* -
 L3 B)  B 9 >
6 ( U/  

$  )  4'   
* )
: 4
B  4 7 ?
9 0*  D 
  >

GADRO -,   ) > *  0* ( EXBORCH -, 0*  '  (

.

8 ,  0* 1430
.
* 0* 1200 CARCASSONE  0* + -2

.
* 0* 1196 GAILLARD -, 1186 CHATTILLON -, 0* %

. [ 2 ] (

8 ( 0
 ) EH
) ( 
8   ) EH
) 0*   > ?

:(29
@!  6 : <"
' @
'! 
 @
'!  
  )  F  
  -
    >
6
2&$  ? 4 H 78 "  4) 4 =/ ? 
! 6 "   E,/  3
 0*)
$ 
 ? 0* T BQ
 
) 0  ( -
?  A ...  / 1 / , 4) 0* T 6
)
.
9 0* 7 
: 
   F (  E,/ 7 ? 1 0$  -
 L36  
M 1

M 2

M 2

M 1

M 1

M 2

M 2

M 1

 =    $(  . '; A



B  BC ( 1 ) -+
(   $ C
  ) . [ 3 ] 

# ';  BC E
# -
D? $(

: =   C    $ 


 E D
.? F3* >3  =<
#
 
 9 
  
? 6
: 4!
E
,F 6
: ;  
*
$B U!
 8
  0*
 ,
 $-
 
 3'9 
$ 0 
  &  
&

  0*  F
: 
  
.

      
 6
& "
190

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


.
6 0 1P
   F *
$B "
. 9  *    '
  @: "
;D 9  B    L  4) 7 ? M! 
M * 
 0*   0 F 0 U
 U' 3)6
  * -
? )

) 4 
  2$
 
, 0 
  -

M H*
M H

-9 )Q 0* ! 'W 78 -?    4      ? 4-9 78  

,
 $
. *'! * 
 4-
 
 0* 0 F 0 &

:D
.?  2  
4B 

    0* E$ : .2
?   $  7 ?/  ; -    ? 
? E$
E,/ - E,9 0*
)  & E$ : , 9 @$ 9 
 E,9
 ?  0 
$ @& ) *
 4-

) 0* B " ,  ?  ) #3 #  $ #  E$  - , .
)3
. 
?
E, 1
 9
 '-    H  U3
 7 ? A
 4,
-? 3 E,/  $
7  !
'  4B R</ E,/ 
  
 -   ' , .
?   9 U 
. 
   #
) 0* E,/ 
)  '
 $ @$ 3 M-, X
7 ? #H  2 E$  '
*  " .
 7 ? E,/   49 
) 
 9 F8

 
  2 6 
 9  < 7 ? H
 $ -$ 
  4B 0
  0* ) .

:*
 7  - 1
B9 .
 0* B
 0
  0*  $    $ 0
     .
H
 0*
.
-H
-' 69   #3  #H  E$ 7 ? ;D 0* 
 . 0*  ! 

4 6 0
/ 0 
 ?  
& ) R</ 4    1
 0* E,/ 
)
#3 10 & 0* H
 

 R 0  ,  @&' 36  
P, 78 9 P$
. & L36 
! 
) 8  !
0 E,/ H    E,/  & '
M?9  $*    
    
9
.  W 0* 
  6 &: E,Y    S @ 4) 3'Q 0 >  E&   4) 3'Q
. [4] 
 0* E,/ L36  '
 E, 4) 8 .$   ?9 7 ?  C E&   4) 3'Q 0 E,/  ' >3)
T-9 7 1
/ L36 !
 4  F  
 ?    
) )3 $
 E,/
$%GH { $GH  $G  } $? ) E$ 4$* 2* 179 #3 

M  E$ 
. $ 4
)/ 0*  6
) E,/ L36 ?  
 ?& E,/  ( $"

191

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

M 1

C    

   3
2I 5@ J6 D
 [ 3 ] $%9    + ( 1 ) -+
' 6. L 26  . L 5
? B $( =   $( 
?  K % 53

(   $ C
  )

#
5
? ' 6. 
 E  K 5
? BM6 
# ( 2 ) -+
[ 3 ]  ? $%9 
$
 6  3
2I D
.? N

:
 4
)/ ? 
)* 0  E$    0 E / 0*  / E,/
*
. +-&  0B B  E$
. E& 4 E,
. +-&  E& 4 E,
. ;  E& 4 E,
. 
-$ 
 2
 !  0B B  E$
.  '   E,/ 3 E$
. +-& E,
H
 ?  & ' )
9  ,  B 9 " $
 E,/  E, 4) ?  -&  X  $
.  F 


192

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


06H $"" D


M2

1

M1

? $( 06H $"" $? D


 N  @9  B ( 3 ) -+
.(   $ C
  ). [ 5 ]  6 . $( E  DH - $? D


. DH - D
.

D
.# A.
( N
DH - D
. E /  %. B E  ( 4 ) -+
. (   $ C
  ). . [ 5 ] <C# A2
0
6H " "

193

2

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

. 06H DH - D


.

3

DH - D
. N
E& D(   
( 5 ) -+
. (   $ C
 ) . [6 ] " D
.? $( 06H

6 A% 9 $"" D


  4

[ 5 ]%: O  6. 6 A% 9 $"" D


. ( 6 ) -+

. 06H D
.  5

( C
  0  ). [ 7 ] 06H D
. N    
 ( 7 ) -+

194

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


2 66H D
.? 6

. (   $ C
  ) . [ 5 ] D?  %. B $( E  # 2 66H D
.# ( 8 ) -+

 ' 
) 0 E,/  78 4$ ;D 0*  / E,/ ?   )& L36 
'Z
? #3  0
 E$ L
  E,/   4) : C 
M $
& &
 . 0*

$ !)  
 ,  @Q )  9 ;  =  6 0
& E$
 2  

[ 3 ] . 2&- 0* L) P #H @-
M, 2 #3  
,/ ' 7 ?
: 2?   0 E,/ 0
 E$
. 2  
$ !)    E$
. 2  7 ? 
$ !)    E$
. 2 
' 
$ !)    E$
. !)    ;  E& 4 E,
. !) 9    E$
H
 ?  & ' )
9  ,  B 9 " $
 E,/  E, 4) ?  -&  X  $
.  F 

. AC  9+  
 D
 .1

M 2

M 1

P2 $( ( 
6 L AC  9+  $  D
. ( 9 ) -+
. (   $ C
  ) [ 7 ]

195

 943    


 B
 

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

. A%  '  9+  


 D
 .2

M 2

M 1

D@ -2 A%  '  9+  $  D


. ( 10 ) -+
. (   $ C
  ) [ 8 ] 861  -  
 D. ' 

. A2  9+  


 D
 .3

M 2

M 1

. (   $ C
  ) [ 8 ]. *  6 *9? B . A2  9+  
 D  D
. ( 11 ) -+

.9+  
 E  DH - D
. .4

M 2

M 1

. (   $ C
  ) [ 7 ]. D
 C @ 9+  
 E  DH - D
.   ( 12 ) -+

196

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


. 9+  #  
 D
 .5
 B
 , !) 9    E,9 9 
M &Z 
- 7 E$    B  

M   B)9
6  D-9  , @-

M9  B
 4&/ 0* ,  )  , @-
 7 ?/ 0*
A 
+ @
 %.#
# 9+ B.
  5# & D
 -+ &
./ 11 / 4) 0*
)

[ 4 ]  ? 9+  $  D


  H+   ( 13 ) -+

M2

M1

M4

M3

. (   $ C
  ) [ 5 ].9+  #  $  D
. 2 2 $(  ( 14 ) -+

  7 ?/ 0*  B
 ,  F
M * & '  ) #  2 , T- E$   B  
:
8 T-9 )  , @-
!)  
 MB)9 
M  , $ , 9
  )  ) 7 ?/ 0* 
$  $  '
.0
& E$
    F (  E, /  'W M! 
3  36 4) . E$ U
'

:$%H D
 -
? >3

-H? $( 
.
'? $( %  %2
0* , 
  ) ) 7 ?/ 0* 
$  $  ' 
&Z 0
& E$ T-9
/ 15/4) .
M   B)9
6  D-  , @-

M9  B
 4&/
197

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

M 2

M 1

%  %2


9+  
 $%H D
 ( 15 ) -+
. (   $ C
 ) [ 8 ] . $ -+  +

 & $  !)   9 ;, ; >3 ( L?9 0* (E$  0  4) ! @ '

9 
$ 
H  ) 9 )  ( 
 -& 
H ). !)  ?
 T / 15 / 4)
( ; 9 ) / 16 / 4) 0*
) R


7
5

M 2
M 1

M 2

M 1

M 1

% @ E

 @  # ( 16 ) -+


. (   $ C
  )

[ 8 ] ( E # )   3


   *9? B 
/ 17 / -+

198

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


:$%H D
 $" >3

-G2 9G+ G  H 
.
D
 >2 9+   <"+
# < .  
.
D

DG(  $( "+ A 
 *'! -
 0* 
& - 0* : E$ 36 
9 !) ",  #9 D E$ 4) D . $GH D
  A K%# ' L -
C?


. / !)  ", ; E$ 4) D T / 18 / 4) 2 )  H  
,9
M 4

M 3

7
5

M 2

M 1

M 2

6H 2 @ E

M 1

 2 @ # ( 18 ) -+

. (   $ C
  ) [ 7 ] . K  + E
# E / 19 / -+

M 2
M 1

[ 5 ] .  $( $( D
. % 2 @ ( 20 ) -+
. (   $ C
  )

199

M 1

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

:$" D

E$ ) 8 
*   H       !)    E$ 6
:  9 7 ? @, D-
. H   , @-
/ 21 / 4) 0*
) . H  L36  7 ? E$  #3 


6 $( H 3( K
( QC
&6

! $( QC
  + ) H2  $ D
   ( 21 ) -+
. (   $ C
  ) . [ 5 ] ( R 
# E
 ) O  $+
 9% <C# N
(

:H
@!    $%
& 9% ' $   "# : <"
: 2$* 
 *' 1 "  D 78  -
 4
$ . 0*  / $ 8
E& " U! *' -  0  =
 4)
M *
$B
M*
M 
 . 0* 0
& -
49 >3 :* P) 8 6 F8 !  #
 
-   $ E&  -
? H    D ;,
E$ LBQ 0
& E$
 
* 0  #3 0
 E$ :    
 7 ? 0 9 BQ
.
& E,/ P) 8

. [ 4 ] P+ R  D
. ( 22 ) -+

200

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


: @!     #
#H  E$ 7 ? ;D 0* 
 . 0*  ! 
 :*
 7  - 1
B9
) R</ 4    1
 0* E,/ 
) .
 
 +H
-'   #3
0  ,  @&' 36 
P, 78 09 P$ 4 6 0
/ 0 
 ?  
&
.& L36 
! 
) 8  ! #3 10  & 0* H
 

 R
   
6)3 [  0 E,/  & '
M ?9  $*    
    
9
. 
 0* E,/ L36  '   W 0* 
  6 &: E,Y
$G( %G G 6+ 9+  
G E  ( $H ) $  D
 
N -
# ;

!  9 
 -
'  .  ! 4)
M'
 2  ' 7
 B L 772  + K 
0* :* =   0 #
  )* 0* L  ;  2 ) 2$$ 7 ? 
, 6
 E$ 3 H

[ 4 ].   ;
 0* "$ #3 0
 -$   0*  D

.[ 7 ]   D
.? 2
K  & $  6  6 ( 22 ) -+

4, 0
 & ' ? 0* )   
 / :* $  78 2  ' 4$ B  

$ 0* D P$ L!) 06 E$ 3 ! 6Q ) 8 7 ? )Z 36 \
 -  '/
.. 
 
  0* 2  ' 4
36

 0*  ;D 78 .  -


' 2  0* E$ 36 ;63

$ 
 H .*
:
 69   ;
/ ) L
 ? L  2  '
 0
/ ;  
* 
.*
)     
,9 0*  
) 0 *
)   @H   $  )
/ 
! 
 _1
 '  < 7 ?    & 
 
) C
9 78 ;?  =
- *
 _2
. ! =
-
.;D ;  )   
& _3

6
B9 0 *
$B 
 B
) B9 0  "    4'  0  & 

) 8 @ _4
.0  & 3& 
 7 ? C

    

201

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

E& 4 E, 


 0*   
 &   3  0 E / 0*  
 _5



 ! 4) L  E$ 36 E
, 9
*?
38 -
' . !)    ; 
. [ 11 ] $%
& 9% @?
$F

 ! B  / ^

E$" ;     E$  
M
 0 D #
  !   F "  28 4$
S*
1
9 " 
* ; 78 4$
    E / 0*
9 0* 2 : 49 
) #3 "0

( 0  (0 )   !  36  F " M38   D 
 06 ! 
 
9  )
9
>
 
? 0*
M$
  ,/
  9 "    
$ 0* D P, !) 0* ?
 #3
. / 23 / 4)
#  1
 ?    D P, 
  ; /
6
? 
    !9 4
:X
!  .$ 
M
 0 ) 
: 2 4) 
B "
$ 0* >  D P, !) "  '
./ 24 / -+ + H2(  + -+ +    HN
  JH2 +#
. A + 53 KC
%&C  $2 +
 #

[ 10 ] R


 5
. ( 23 ) -+

202

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


[ 12 ]     ?


J $( D
 E

[ 11 ]  + 5
N B%  # ( 24 ) -+

: H     E
G 
%GC G#   R $( =
% 2C  ( .;  + 

. *
 @
  
 .# " " ';  ';  
  H 2C  ?
U
 !
    
<& 14     4$B  4 $ 0* 
6 &:
M 

M ) >3  
@
 9 78 2  
$9 ) -  78 )   ' 0 E  9   )  
. / 4 Q )   '     

. [ 11 ]  +  -


C
# # 

'  C  + :H
  ( 25 ) -+

203

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?


) 9 * & >  0*
M  ' ) 0*  ' 0 
/ / 7 ?
M H
$  36 E)?
-9 4
   1
& 
,/ ; <9 0*
M ?
 -

8 B 4'   6! /
 7) )
.[ 11 ] "1 4 "  H
!*   H
$    / L36

 P 8
M9 36   0 D !  
 0 & 0* 2
,
9 R/    '
$,   "D "  D 
 8 4$
6  
    D 
 9 4$ 9 )  0
 >3 2$9 T3 

8 & >  0* ) 78 E  

' S >3 
M
  ..
M  ?
. / 27  26 / 4) 4, 
 - )  #3 #


  

 $ @ ( 27 ) -+



 $ @ ( 26 ) -+

. [ 7 ]
 6  . E  D
. C

. [ 12 ] D   

9 0
M
  ?/ 
B  ? 
B "
$ 0* D !) 9 
? F C   36
9 
? F C  36 
)
  !
  0&)  

&: 0* P'/   1! 9
E$ D !) 9   E  4'  3)6  ;  E$ 4) . ? 
    4$
[ 11 ].2H
?9  4-& )  F
M ?
M
 ; 

9+    D
.#

9+ B #    D
.#

$  D
 % O B $%
& H  H 2 
% (28 ) -+
. [ 2 ] E  9+ B #
# 9+  
 ( $H )

204

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


:%
&  $( E  $  D
 "I N "? T
12351163 D $( 
 @+

(1

D $( 
 @+ (29 ) -+
. [10 ] ($( -+
$  D
 2 > E . $%
: E
I $  D
 2   @ 
# )

#

 @+ ( 30 ) -+
@% 9@+ D
 2 #

. [ 9 ]E  ($H) $  D


 % O B $%
& H 
% $2 J D
 2 E

205

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

1230 
= @+ ( 2

. [ 10 ] J  $( 9+  


 $  D
 E @ 
 # 
= @+ ( 31 ) -+

1462 1296 %; 


( @+  3

#
%; 
( @+ ( 32 ) -+

. [12 ] @+ $2 


N E .   O; $( 9+  $  D
 2 QC
 @+  . $( B% #

206

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


 1140 D @+ 4

#
D @+ ( 33 ) -+
9+  #
9+ 53 $  D
 2
Q 3 B +  6 #
. [ 12 ] <C# D
.?   @+  6 $2 E E

 1230 9 @+  5

#
9 @+ ( 34 ) -+
@% 9@+ $  D
 2 -6H  #
. [12 ] 9+  $  D
. 2   $2 
N E

207

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?

 12411212  ( D @+  6

. [ 2 ] 9+  
 $  D
 2 . ( D @+ 
( 35 ) -+

1446 + > + @+  7

E  9+  #  $  D


 % O B $%
& H 
%   @+ J # ( 36 ) -+
. [12 ] $  D
  + %H ? 2 E

208

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


 1175  + D


@+  8

. [12 ] D
@+ @ 
 ( 37 ) -+

$( $2 
N E . @+ 
$( 9+ 3   D
.U 6H  # D
@+ ( 38 ) -+
. [12 ] 9+ 3 D
.# ' 
  J $( % 
   +  6

 1375 %;   +  9

#
. [ 2 ] 9+ 3 D
.?   $2 
N E . $2 
N # %;   + ( 39 ) -+

209

I 

7  $ 0*  D 



 0
 $B9   (  
 $?


 @+ 11

 1250 ( D#  10

D
.?

 @+ ( 41 ) -+

.+  6 D# (40 ) -+

[ 9 ]  ? 9+ 3  

[12 ]   


 J E
#

   
   &   -? B
 " 4) T  R 36
-
 $ "  9 
M W  R*  R< F8 6
36   D 

 ( 0
 E$)
- I "
M 
 H
@! 
   
9 0* *  #
 
B   &
. 2 #3

:  V@
:     : =<
#
 +
-'F ;
-9
 F    
 4-Q  0$$
B $  * 

(1

C  $
 4
 /
 2& '

 #

B   7 ? :
&  
    
. (      ) #  #

(   
 )  & ? 4-& I   
    E  U
   $  

(2

.  F  


.
   
   &    ?
- 
$    ;    6
  !) C 8

(3

. ( 0*'! 0& ) 0

6 ;
78  &  L3 0H
 0&:   
:8

(4

:     : <"


. #  $ 0B "

H
? B 

 0* (
 E,/
F )  &  L36  ' ( 1
+' 1
 ?8 1
B9
 $  
     
$ 7 ?
! ., 4)  &  L36  ( 2
. Y
. 0*
$B
B 

)*9
 6
& @
' #3 4)
 - 
$  '  ? ( 3
. - I H
 B  1
  
M
  F  
  &   ( 4
210

Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2005 (2)  (27)        


:B

-9 / 
  
$ 36 35 34 
&- 81  _     1
. ( E
 ) 0 
  EH _ 0! 
< 8 _ ;
)   8 ?
. D 
 _ ;  _ ;  
_
 _ 7  - 0* 
 A
 _ 0   ? . ' 2
_   _ !! ? >  
_   _   
 0* 
 _ 
$ ? . #
 3
.  D 

www.Rowad.AL-islam.com  
 F ) 7 ? F  ", 4
5 GEOGE MICHELL - Architecture of Islamic World DAR AL- HANDASH
CONSULTANTS SHAIR and PARTNERS

B    ?
  
 Z  /  0* R/ 
? 
$ ? ( )9 6
. 1995 (
1986 7/  
 . E  0 F & @&? . 0 7
www.eternalegypt.org _  
 ) 7 ? - 
BW ", (8
www.balagh.com _  
 ) 7 ? @ ", ( 9
www.greatbuildings.com _  
 ) 7 ?  : / ", (10

09 
  //  #D //
 7 ?    
 B 11
ENCYCLOPEDIA OF ART & ? `
 12

211

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi