Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Level V:
Factors Affecting the Acceptance of People with Disabilities at Work: A Literature Review;
Vornholt, Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis. (2013).
This study was conducted due to the lack of social acceptance in the work place for individuals
with disabilities. This study looks at the factors that interfere with the acceptance of individuals with
disabilities. The data-bases searched were PsychINFO and Web of Science, collecting over 5,000 articles.
After downsizing based off criteria there were 48 articles reviewed for study. The three main themes
affecting acceptance are cognitive acceptance, stigmatized attitudes and performance. Studies also
showed that the type of employer and gender may also impact acceptance. A significant finding was
employers were concerned with cost of accommodations and fear of legal liability, resulting in a lack of
proper accommodations in the workplace. The main factors leading to acceptance according to the
framework used in this study are characteristics and attitudes of colleagues, employers, and characteristics
of employees with disabilities. According to this study acceptance leads to motivation, satisfaction,
quality of life etc.
Workplace accommodations: Occupational therapists as mediators in the interactive process;
Schreuer, Myhill, Aratan-Bergman, Samant, & Blanck. (2009).
This article discusses the importance of an interactive processes between the employer and the
employee to make effective accommodations. The ADA 1990 states that employees with disabilities are
entitled to gain accommodations as needed. Occupational Therapy uses an Interactive model of practice,
ergonomics, and education to improve the interactive process. There is a case study in the article that they
use as an example as to what OTs role is in the process. The Occupational Therapy Professional uses their
education in ergonomics throughout the interactive process. OTs play a role during the initial evaluation
and throughout the intervention by mediating, educating, consulting and ensuring appropriate
accommodations are made such as an elevated work space, inclined keyboard, or any modified way of
completing a task to ensure an individual can compete task functionally.
Occupational Therapy Services in Facilitating Work Performance; Ellexson, Larson. (2011)
This article discusses ways Occupational Therapy can increase functional work performance.
This article touches on various services Occupational Therapy can provide, potential problems within the
work place, and the Occupational Therapy process to receiving services. Some Occupational Therapy
services listed were wellness and prevention education, restorative and compensatory techniques, and
case management. The first step in receiving services is the Occupational profile, the second step listed in
the article was collaborating with the employer, the employee and the OT for appropriate interventions
and accommodations. There were several interventions listed for individuals that may be unable to
perform work skills functionally via seven case studies. Some of the examples of interventions listed
were ergonomic education to employer and employee, adaptations/job modifications, use of assistive
devices, improved social/emotional regulation skills, and improved functional work skills.
Qualitative:
Employer-recommended strategies to increase opportunities for people with disabilities;
Henry, Petkauskos, Stanislawzyk, & Vogt. (2014).
This Qualitative study focused on the challenges employers face when hiring individuals
with disabilities, recommendations from employers for various innovations, and advantages of
the employers after hiring an individual with a disability. The employment rate for individuals
with disabilities in the US is at a constant decrease, it is less than half of the normal rate for those
without disabilities. This study uses four focus groups via roundtable discussions to gain data.
There were 74 participants, 36 men, 38 women, who were all employees from MA, holding a
high-mid management position. There was a wide range of employers studied ranging from
heath care, to manufacturing and various professionals in-between such as education, business
and technology. This study found that employers were reluctant to hire individuals with
disabilities due to the common stigma, the unknown of their individual abilities and the complex
system involving employment for individuals with disabilities. Employers recommended
communication between business and gaining more information on employing individuals with
disabilities and its benefits.
Video Self-Prompting and Mobile Technology to Increase Daily Living and Vocational
Independence for Students with Autism Spectrum Disorders; Bereznak, Ayres, Mechling,
Alexander. (2012).
This article discusses the use of video instruction for vocational and daily living skills.
The study used a small sample size, containing three men ages 12-18 all diagnosed with ASD.
The method used was a multiple probe design, analyzing behaviors of participants. Using this
method effectiveness of study was shown. The two focus questions used in this study related to
functional performance of vocational and daily life skills via video-prompting via iPod. To
retain results they took the total number of correct responses divided by the total number of steps
in given task analysis to calculate correct response rate. Through the results there was a 100%
non-overlapping outcome. These results explain that video prompting for instruction is
responsible for positive behavioral change while completing task, skill performance was
decreased when iPad was removed or not available. Having an IPAD or instructional video
available for employees to use shows a steep incline in progress of completion.
Bottom Line for Occupational Therapy Practice:
A job influences to a large extent where one lives, the activities in which one engages in and the
relationships that one develops (Orentlicher & Michaels, 2000). Occupational Therapy can play a large
role in increasing job opportunities for individuals with disabilities by addressing their eight areas of
occupation, advocating for individuals, taking part in the interactive hiring process and educating the
public and professionals on this topic. According to the American Journal of Occupational Therapy, the
overarching goal of Occupational Therapy is to support peoples health and participation in life
throughout engagement in occupations (Ellexson, Larson, DeLany, 2011).
Occupational Therapy professionals provide work related services in a variety of settings, such
as businesses, industrial environments, acute care, and schools addressing various skills necessary to
reach desired outcome for patients (Ellexson, Larson, DeLany, 2011). OT intervention is often necessary
to acquire adequate job skills, improve independence and improve functional performance at a worksite
that solely employs individuals with disabilities. (Weaver, 2015). There are also resources throughout the
community that utilize OT services, using a prepatory method to enhance job related skills for future
employment. Using a client centered approach Occupational Therapy professionals develop an
Occupational Profile addressing all areas such as job analysis, evaluation of tasks, productivity
expectations, social and communication skills, adaptive equipment needed, compensations if necessary,
clients potential for improvement, and any occupational or environmental changes (Ellexson, Larson,
DeLany, 2011). An in-depth evaluation (occupational profile) is completed to ensure adequate
accommodations are being made for each individual. There are also various skills an individual must
obtain before entering the workforce, Occupational Therapy can play a large role in this process through
intervention and education. An example of skills needed are transition/job skills such as job seeking and
retention skills. Occupational skills such as communication, problem-solving, decision making skills,
social skills, self-advocacy skills, and overall community functioning skills such as transportation and
vocational skills (Orentlicher & Michaels, 2000).
There are various barriers that individuals with disabilities face in the process of gaining
employment. The largest barrier an individual may face is stigma or negative attitudes from employers
(Henry, Petkauskos, Stanislawzyk, Vogt, 2014). There is an immediate negative reaction when
interviewing an individual with a visible disability (Henry, Petkauskos, Stanislawzyk, Vogt, 2014). Some
employers believe that hiring an individual with a disability may require more effort and cost via
adaptions. They also may have to deal with lack of performance or fear they will require more direct
instruction than others (Henry, et.al, 2014). Occupational Therapy needs to take action in altering these
false stigmas/attitudes that individuals have by educating employers on abilities and accommodations
necessary to gain a more functional and diverse workplace. According to Henry, et.al (2014) a more
diverse and inclusive work force is critical to success in todays global economy. Occupational Therapy
professionals can also not only advocate for individuals but also educate individuals on the importance of
advocating for themselves, emphasizing their strengths and what they can contribute to the company
(Henry, et.al, 2014). Based off research there are other hindering factors an individual may face while
seeking employment (Achterberg, Wind, de Boer, Frings-Dresen, 2009). Gender was a hindering factor,
men were more likely to get hired than women. Employers also looked at education levels, the higher the
individual and their parents education levels were the more likely they were to get hired. Another
hindering factor is if an individuals IQ is lower than 80, they may have a difficult time finding
employment. The last hindering factor noted was motor impairments, such as wheelchair use, functional
limitations, physical disabilities, chronic health conditions and intellectual disabilities. (Achterberg, et.al,
2009). Occupational Therapy professionals can educate employers on various modifications and
adaptions that can be made so that the individual can be successful. They can also educate employers on
the importance of acceptance of those with disabilities.
Acceptance within a work place seems to be one of the largest barriers that an individual may
face, not only in the work place but throughout the community as well. The lack of acceptance from
employees/employers is a common reason as to why individuals with disabilities do not stay at their place
of employment for long periods of time (Vornholt, Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013). There are several laws
that discuss equality for all in the workplace and the significance of acceptance, yet companies are
hesitant to hire someone with a disability. Some examples are The Americans with Disabilities Act,
stating physical and mental disabilities in no way diminish a persons right to fully participate in all
aspects of society (Vornholt, Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013). The developmental Disabilities Assistance
and Bill of Rights Act of 2000 discusses the importance of inclusion and acceptance (Vornholt,
Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013). The framework used to identify acceptance is all based off of the
characteristic of colleagues and employers (Vornholt, Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013). According to
(Vornholt, Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013) acceptance leads to motivation, satisfaction, quality of life etc. of
employees with disabilities. Occupational Therapy Professionals can address various areas of social
participation and social skills to increase acceptance within the work place. The Occupational Therapy
Professionals can also address the importance of acceptance to the employer. The employers play a
significant role in the socialization process, also serving as a role model for other staff (Vornholt,
Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013).
The ADA requires employers to provide adequate modifications and accommodations as needed
in the workplace (Schreuer, Myhill, Aratan-Bergman, Samant, Blanck, 2009). Work place
accommodations enable a person to perform job skills to their highest level of functioning (Schreuer,
et.al, 2009). Adaptions also assist in overcoming various obstacles such as acceptance, performance
level, and task completion (Achterberg, et.al, 2009). Many employers are consumed with false thoughts
about accommodations and have negative attitudes about employing individuals with disabilities,
concerned if they have the ability to complete the task given (Schreuer, et.al, 2009). Employers are also
hesitant to hire due to possible cost of accommodations due to their lack of knowledge, but studies show
that the overall cost of accommodations is little to none compared to other indirect benefits such as not
having to re-hire someone that has been injured, not having to go through the hiring and training process
(Schreuer, et.al, 2009). Occupational Therapy Professionals need to enforce the importance of
accommodations using their skills and expertise in ergonomics and job skills (Weaver, 2015). It is also
very important for an occupational therapy professionals to be involved in the interactive hiring process.
The interactive hiring process involving the Occupational Therapy Professional, the employer and
the employee, determines and implements adequate workplace accommodations, it is a very demanding
and collaborative process (Schreuer, et.al, 2009). The initiation process provides services to develop or
increase the ability of the client to participate in and manage productive work, maintain health, adhere to
safe work practices and prevent work related disability (Ellexson, Larson, DeLany, 2011). An
Occupational Therapy Professionals can use their training in ergonomics and their knowledge of
disability and function to focus on social participation, well-being, job demands, and participation in the
work place, activities and the overall environment (Schreuer, et.al, 2009). A successful interaction
process including collaboration between the individual, the OT, the employer and the rest of their team
allows for accommodations to be low cost, beneficial and effective (Schreuer, et.al, 2009) . The main
goal of an Occupational Therapy Professionals during the interactive process is to address the goals of the
individual (Schreuer, et.al, 2009). After completing an occupational profile and collecting necessary data
the Occupational Therapy Professional will help define the employees readiness to work, functional
levels, and capabilities and discuss further with the rest of the team to ensure modifications and/or
accommodations are being put in place to set-up the individual for success in their work place (Schreuer,
et.al, 2009). Skilled Occupational Therapy Professionals can address areas of occupation using client
centered treatments that focus on increasing independence, task completion, increasing self-management
skills in relation to task completion, component strategies and behavioral skills related to work (Bennett
& Dukes, 2013). Research shows that using video-prompting at the work site appears to be the most
successful accommodation for individuals with disabilities. Video-prompting is also readily available and
affordable via iPhone/tablet (Bereznak, Ayres, Mechling, Alexander, 2012). Once an individual masters
the skill of using their device or PDA it can be used across a variety of skills, requiring less staff directed
instruction and one on one time (Bereznak, et.al, 2012). Video-prompting has been shown to be an
efficient and effective way in teaching completion of functional tasks and behavioral skills independently
(Bereznak, et.al, 2012).
There are resources in the community to assist individuals in job seeking such as their care
worker, a job coach, SE (supported employment), and state government programs yet they become more
streamlined and coordinated in their efforts to engage employers (Henry, Petkauskos, Stanislawzyk, Vogt,
2014). Many of these services deem several individuals too disabled for employment (Henry, et.al,
2014). This is where Occupational Therapy needs to step in and educate the importance of work for
individuals and advocate for them.
As noted through the bottom line there are several things Occupational Therapy Professions can
do to increase job opportunities for individuals with disabilities. Occupational Therapy practitioners
can advocate for the individual and promote acceptance within the work place. Occupational
Therapy also plays a large role in educating employers on the importance and benefits of
employment and acceptance, along with being active throughout the hiring process (Vornholt,
Uitdewilligen, Nijhuis, 2013). Throughout treatment it is important that Occupational Therapy
professionals are using a holistic approach and addressing all eight areas of occupation, also
providing the client with job and life skills are beneficial to clients (Bennett & Dukes, 2013);
doing this will assist in functional performance from the client within the work place. Job
Comparison
Outcome
Quality Control/Peer Review Process: The first step was coming up with a topic to use for the
CAT, brainstorming as a class to come up with options, then narrowed it down to our final two.
The second step was creating a PICO question to come up with the focus question. Once focus
question was decided the next step was to to write the clinical scenario, stating why the focus
question is an emerging/important topic, again supporting your focus question. After completing
a clinical scenario for both CATs, each student gave a 5-8 minute presentation about both of their
focus question. After presentations is when the final CAT was decided.
After deciding the topic, we then found 8 articles-determining their level of evidence,
limitations and summary of key findings. Once each assignment was completed the teacher
would grade/peer review the assignment and provide us with feedback. The next step after
finding all of the summary of key findings from articles chosen is to write a bottom line,
answering the focus question. After completing all areas of the CAT it is peer reviewed by a
classmate and presented to the class. The teacher reviewed each CAT one last time, allowing
students one last opportunity to fix mistakes. The next step is to make a poster to present our
CAT.
Results of Search:
Summary of Study Designs of Articles Selected for Appraisal:
Level of Evidence Study Design/Methodology of Selected
Number of Articles Selected
Articles
Level I
Systematic reviews, meta-analysis,
3
randomized controlled trials
Level II
Two groups, nonrandomized studies (e.g.,
cohort, case-control)
Level III
One group, nonrandomized (e.g., before
and after, pretest, and posttest)
Level IV
Descriptive studies that include analysis
of outcomes (single subject design, case
series)
Level V
Case reports and expert opinion, which
3
include narrative literature reviews and
consensus statements
Qualitative
2
Limitations of the Studies Appraised:
Level I
Effectiveness of work, activities of daily living, education, and sleep interventions for
people with autism spectrum disorder: a systematic review; Weaver. (2015).
This article focuses only on ASD, and discusses other areas beside work such as ADLs,
education and sleep. This article is based off of the design and methods of the individual studies
analyzed including small sample sizes, limited research and limited descriptions of psychometric
properties were documented. There were only 23 studies reviewed, 15 were level IV articles.
Various studies were missing important factors such as methods, long-term outcomes, and
masked assessment and scoring, making it difficult to compare based off the lack of research on
this topic.
Employment Instruction for Secondary Students with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A
Systematic Review of Literature; Bennett, Dukes. (2013)
There were only 12 studies used, resulting in a small sample size. This article focuses on
ASD specifically, not disabilities in general. There is a large gap in literature on this topic,
resulting in a lack of information available. There was no limited amount of studies addressing
job specific skill instruction nor were there studies that targeted social skills needed for
employment.
Video Self-Prompting and Mobile Technology to Increase Daily Living and Vocational
Independence for Students with Autism Spectrum Disorders; Bereznak, Ayres, Kevin,
Mechling, Alexander. (2012).
There are several limitations within this article. The biggest one relating to the focus
question is that this study focuses on vocational and life skills rather than job skills. Another
limitation is that there were two occasions where full study was not conducted. The first incident
was when participant #1 expressed aggressive behavior and elopement while performing
vocational skills task, the second occasion was the inability to collect baseline data for
participant #2 due to inability to leave classroom and lack of staff. In this study social validity
was never assessed, meaning behaviors were not tested overtime. The longer the study has been
conducted the more accurate the information will be.
Articles Selected for Appraisal:
Achterberg, T., Wind, H., de Boer, A., & Frings-Dresen, M. (2009). Factors that promote or
hinder young disabled people in work participation: a systematic review. Journal Of
Occupational Rehabilitation, 19(2), 129-141 13p. doi:10.1007/s10926-009-9169-0
Bereznak, S., Ayres, K., Mechling, L., & Alexander, J. (2012). Video Self-Prompting and Mobile
Technology to Increase Daily Living and Vocational Independence for Students with Autism
Spectrum Disorders. Journal Of Developmental & Physical Disabilities, 24(3), 269-285.
doi:10.1007/s10882-012-9270-8
Ellexson, M., Larson, B., & DeLany, J. V. (2011). Occupational Therapy Services in Facilitating
Work Performance. American Journal Of Occupational Therapy, 65S55-64 1p.
doi:10.5014/ajot.2011.65S55
Henry, A. D., Petkauskos, K., Stanislawzyk, J., & Vogt, J. (2014). Employer-recommended
strategies to increase opportunities for people with disabilities. Journal of Vocational
Rehabilitation, 41(3), 237-248. doi:10.3233/JVR-140716
Orentlicher, M., Michaels, C. A., (2000). Some Thoughts on the role of occupational therapy in
the transition from school to adult life: part I. American Occupational Therapy
Association, Vol. 7(2).
Schreuer, N., Myhill, W. N., Aratan-Bergman, T., Samant, D., & Blanck, P. (2009). Workplace
accommodations: Occupational therapists as mediators in the interactive process. Work,
34(2), 149-160. doi:10.3233/WOR-2009-0913
Vornholt, K., Uitdewilligen, S., & Nijhuis, F. (2013). Factors Affecting the Acceptance of
People with Disabilities at Work: A Literature Review. Journal Of Occupational
Rehabilitation, 23(4), 463-475 13p. doi:10.1007/s10926-013-9426-0
Weaver, L. L. (2015) Effectiveness of Work, Activities of Daily Living, Education, and Sleep
Interventions for People With Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review.