Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2015
Original Article
By the Book
Using Literature to Discuss Disability
With Children and Teens
TEACHING Exceptional Children, Vol. 48, No. 3, pp. 151158. Copyright 2015 The Author(s). DOI: 10.1177/0040059915618195
Memoirs of an Imaginary
Friend (2014)
So B. It (2006)
Lears
Elliot
Nuzum
OConnor
Dicks
Vernick
Weeks
Haddon
Dowd
Tashjian
Brenna
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Type of
book
Autism
Intellectual disability
Autism
Autism
Intellectual disability
Autism
Not clear
Not clear
Intellectual disability
Autism
Autism
Autism
Intellectual disability
Orthopedic disability
Autism
Type of disability
Positive / no
Positive / yesb
Positive / yesa
Positive / no
Mixed / yes
Mixed / yes
Positive / yes
Mixed / yes
Mixed / no
Mixed / no
Mixed / no
Positive / no
Negative / no
Positive / no
Mixed / no
Portrayal /
Loaded
language
Single parent;
sister as caregiver
Single parent
NC
Character with
disability
Sibling (twin)
Character with
disability
Character with
disability
Daughter
NC
Cousin
Imaginary
friend
Nonfamily
character
Sibling (twin)
Narrator
Sibling
Sibling (twin)
Narrator
Sibling
Sibling
Point of view
NC
AA
AA
Race
Single parent
Mother with
intellectual
disability; daughter
as caregiver
Single parent
Two parents
Foster family
Single parent;
brother as caregiver
Two parents
Two parents
Single parent
Extended
Two parents
Single parent;
sister as caregiver
Family roles
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Strong
Weak
Strong
Strong
Weak
Strong
Weak
Selfdetermination
Note. AA = African American; NC = not clear; W = White, non-Hispanic. Note that Race was coded in 8 categories, but only 3 categories were present in the books reviewed.
aLoaded language resolved. bInappropriate humor (humor about disability).
Author
Age-appropriate experiences.
Teachers should carefully evaluate how
characters with disabilities spend their
time in childrens books. In nearly all
of the books, persons with disabilities
spent their time in age-appropriate
activities. Examples include visiting
with neighbors (Remember Dippy),
going to the park (My Brother Sammy),
and joining soccer teams (Tru
Confessions). Teachers should watch
out for age-inappropriate experiences
as in one picture book, Keeping Up
With Roo, where an adult with
developmental disabilities waits all day
to play while a 5-year-old is at school.
Differences and similarities: Why
and how were they highlighted?. The
purpose of the book appeared to
influence the extent to which
similarities and differences among
people with disabilities were
highlighted. Picture books in particular
seemed designed to teach about
disabilities rather than feature
individuals with disabilities as equal
citizens. Differences are described in
detail, and these differences are often
embarrassing or unwanted. For
instance, in Ians Walk, Ian prefers to
sniff the brick wall of the post office
rather than a bouquet of lilacs,
embarrassing his sisters. Although
young siblings may experience a variety
of emotions throughout the sibling
relationship (Stoneman, 2005), it is
important to present a balanced view of
disability and highlight the strengths of
sibling relationships. A positive example
of how differences are mentioned but
described in a way that promote
Title
Discussion questions
Activity guide
Questions to Ask:
Notes
Copyright of Teaching Exceptional Children is the property of Sage Publications Inc. and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.