Register

Main Menu

My Stories: 25

Log in

Forums

LAW & DISORDER / CIVILIZATION & DISCONTENTS

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

pdfcrowd.com

Indefinite prison for suspect who wont

decrypt hard drives, US govt says
"This is not a fishing expedition on the part of the government," prosecutor says.
by David Kravets (US) - May 17, 2016 1:57am EDT

355

Christiaan Colen

US federal prosecutors urged a federal appeals court late Monday to keep a child-porn suspect
behind barswhere he already has been for seven monthsuntil he unlocks two hard drives that the
government claims contain kid smut.

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

LATEST FEATURE STORY

pdfcrowd.com

The suspect, a Philadelphia police sergeant relieved of his duties, has refused to unlock two hard
drives and has been in jail ever since a judge's order seven months agoand after being found in
contempt of court. The defendant can remain locked up until a judge lifts the contempt order.
The government said Monday he should remain jailed
indefinitely until he complies. The authorities also said that
it's not a violation of the man's Fifth Amendment right
against compelled self-incrimination because it's a
"foregone conclusion" that illegal porn is on the drives and
that he is only being asked to unlock the drives, not divulge
their passcodes.
"This is not a fishing expedition on the part of the
government," federal prosecutors told the 3rd US Circuit
Court of Appeals of Philadelphia.

FURTHER READING

Nvidia GTX 1080 review:

Faster, cheaper, quieter
than Titan X
CHILD PORN SUSPECT JAILED
INDEFINITELY FOR REFUSING TO
DECRYPT HARD DRIVES

Already on top, Nvidia pushes the performance

curve once againbut has it gone far enough?

STAY IN THE KNOW WITH

Man to remain locked up "until

such time that he fully complies"
with court order.

The suspect has not been charged with any child-porn

related crimes, yet he is imprisoned in Philadelphia's
Federal Detention Center for refusing to decrypt two drives encrypted with Apple's FileVault software
in a case that highlights the federal government's war on encryption. A federal magistrate has
ordered him imprisoned "until such time that he fully complies" with the decryption order. The man's
attorney, Federal Public Defender Keith Donoghue, is demanding that the appeals court immediately
release his client from prison because he is being "held without charges." (PDF)
Investigators say they know child porn is on the drives. His sister saw some of it, and the suspect is
said to have shown his family an illicit video, too.
The drives, the government said, (PDF) were connected to a Mac Pro.
A subsequent forensic exam of his Mac Pro computer revealed that Doe had installed a virtual
machine (software that emulates a separate computer within his computer). Within the virtual
machine the examiner found one image of what appeared to be a 14-year-old child wearing a
bathing suit and posed in a sexually suggestive position. There were also log files that
indicated that Doe had visited groups titled: toddler_cp, lolicam, hussy, child models
girls, pedomom, tor- childporn, and pthc, terms that are commonly used in child
exploitation.

open in browser PRO version

FEATURE STORY (5 PAGES)

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

LATEST NEWS
Robin Hood hacker strikes
again, sends stolen bitcoins to
Syria
LIVE IT UP

BitTorrent Inc. announces live

streaming TV service powered by P2P
10Gbps downloads and
uploads over cable demoed by
Bell Labs
RUN AMOK

Runkeeper acknowledges location

data leak to ad service, pushes
updates
pdfcrowd.com

The exam also found that Freenet, the peer-to-peer file sharing program used by Doe to
obtain child pornography from other users, had been installed within the virtual machine. The
exam showed that Doe accessed or attempted to access more than 20,000 files with file names
consistent with obvious child pornography... and that he used the external hard drives seized
by Delaware County detectives to access and store the images.
The defendant, who is referred to as "John Doe" in court papers, claims he forgot the passwords. The
suspect's identity is Francis Rawls, according to trial court papers.

HUGS FOR HGST

One billion hours on, and HGST still

rules the roost for hard disk reliability
Anti-piracy firm Rightscorps
Q1 financials read like an
obituary

The government, however, countered.

In fact, Doe had multiple layers of password protection on his devices, and he always entered
his passcodes for all of his devices from memory. Doe never had any trouble remembering his
passcodes (other than when compelled to do so by the federal court), never hesitated when
entering the passcodes, and never failed to gain entry on his first attempt.
In winning the contempt-of-court order, the authorities cited a 1789 law known as the All Writs Act to
compel (PDF) the suspect to decrypt. The All Writs Act was the same law the Justice Department
asserted in its legal battle with Apple, in which a magistrate judge ordered Apple to produce code to
enable the FBI to decrypt the iPhone used by one of two shooters who killed 14 people at a San
Bernardino County government building in December. The case was dropped when the authorities
paid a reported $1 million for a hack.
The Supreme Court has never addressed the compelled decryption issue. However, in 2012, a
federal appeals court ruled that a financial fraud suspect must decrypt her laptop. The ruling wasn't
enforced, as the authorities got the password from a co-defendant.
A child-porn investigation centered on Rawls in 2015 when Pennsylvania prosecutors were monitoring
the online network Freenet, got a search warrant, and executed it at Rawls' home, the authorities
said.
The court may rule on Rawls' plight at any time or schedule oral arguments in a process that could
take months or more.
This post originated on Ars Technica

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

pdfcrowd.com

READER COMMENTS 355

-

David Kravets / The senior editor for Ars Technica. Founder of TYDN fake new s site. Technologist. Political scientist.
Humorist. Dad of tw o boys. Been doing journalism for so long I remember manual typew riters w ith real paper.
@dm kravets on Tw itter

OLDER STORY

NEWER STORY

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

pdfcrowd.com

SITE LINKS

MORE READING

CONDE NAST SITES

About Us

RSS Feeds

Reddit

Advertise with us

Newsletters

Wired

Contact Us

GQ
Visit Ars Technica US

Vanity Fair
Cond Nast Traveller

VIEW MOBILE SITE

Priv acy Policy & Cookie Statement | Terms & Conditions | Contact Us | Cond Nast UK 2016

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

pdfcrowd.com