Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
threemostcommonwaystorespond:agreeing,disagreeing,orsomecombinationof
both.
Itisalwaysagoodtobeginyourresponsebystatingclearlywhetheryouagree,disagree,
orboth,usingadirectformulasuchas:
Onceyouhaveofferedoneofthesestraightforwardstatements,readerswillhavea
stronggraspofyourposition
However:Whenitcomestoanalyticalessaysaboutliteratureorart,youneednotonlyto
statewhatyouyourselftaketheworktomeanbutmakeordointerpretationsofother
readers.
Forexampleyousay:
Althoughsomereadersmightthinkthatthispoemisabout__,itisinfactabout___).
Answer: Slide 2
Disagreeing poses challenge to a person.
Although they say womens rights are improving, I say womens rights
are not improving.
Youneedtogivereasonstosupportwhatyousay.Tomovetheconversation,youneedto
demonstratethatyouhavesomethingtocontribute.
NextSlide:
Youcanevendisagreebymakingwhatwecalltheduhmove,inwhichyoudisagree
notwiththepositionitselfbutwiththeassumptionthatitisaneworstunningrevelation.
InaresearchbyStanforduniversity,thestudentsoftenlackcrucialinformationonapplyingto
collegeandonsucceedingacademicallyoncetheygetin.
Answer:Well,duh.ItshouldnttakeaStanfordresearchteamtotellusthatwhenitcomesto
succeedingacademically,manystudentsdonthaveaclue.
Answer:IfyoufindduhtoobrashyoucanalwayswritesomethinglikeItistruethat
;butwealreadyknewthat.Donotstatetheobvious.
NextSlide
Answer:Attimesyoumightbereluctanttoexpressdisagreementnotwantingtobe
unpleasant,tohurtsomeonesfeelings
Youcanalsodisagreebymakingwhatwecallthetwistitmove,inwhichForexample:
Xarguesforstricterguncontrollegislation,sayingthatthecrimerateisontheriseandthatwe
needtorestrictthecirculationofguns.Iagreethatthecrimerateisontherise,butthats
preciselywhyIopposestricterguncontrollegislation.Weneedtoowngunstoprotectourselves
againstcriminals.
Answer:youagreewiththeevidencethatsomeoneelsehaspresentedbutshowthrougha
twistoflogicthatthisevidenceactuallysupportsyourown,contraryposition.
Evenasyoureagreeing,itsimportanttobringsomethingnewandfreshtothetable,
addingsomethingmakesyouavaluableparticipantinaconversation.
templatesforagreeing
jIagreethatdiversityinthestudentbodyiseducationallyvaluablebecausemyexperienceat
CentralUniversityconfirmsit.
jXissurelyrightabout
jXstheoryof
because,asshemaynotbeaware,recentstudieshaveshownthat
isextremelyusefulbecauseitshedslightonthedifficultproblemof
jThoseunfamiliarwiththisschoolofthoughtmaybeinterestedtoknowthatitbasicallyboils
downto
Butdobeawarethatwheneveryouagreewithonepersonsview,youarelikely
disagreeingwithsomeoneelses.
NextSlide:
Ifyouwanttostressthedisagreementendofthespectrum,youwoulduseatemplate
like:
AlthoughIagreewithXuptoapoint,Icannotaccepthisoverridingassumptionthat
religionisnolongeramajorforcetoday.
Ifyouwanttostressyouragreementmorethanyourdisagreement,youwouldusea
templatelikethis.
AlthoughIdisagreewithmuchthatXsays,Ifullyendorsehisfinalconclusionthat
____.
Answer:Thefirsttemplateabovemightbecalledayes,but...move,theseconda
no,but...move.Otherversionsincludethefollowing.
Failedtointroducethequotationandexplainwhythequoteisimportant