Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1AR
My opponent talked about the ideas of John Locke, and how the human being is born as
a blank slate. However, they completely ignore the fact that this is in direct support of my
second contention, which states that we learn things through observation, and then through
experience.
The question of this debate is over whether or not an outsider can be an expert on a
culture other than their own. These outsiders have done extensive research on the culture and
have observed it. The affirmative has successfully proven that every person first observes a
culture, and then becomes a part of it. The affirmative side has also proven that Hermann
Hesse, and other outsiders, were actually better candidates for writing about a culture than
those that are part of the culture, since it gives them an outside perspective and allows them to
compare it to their own cultures. It comes down to the method through which we learn about the
culture, which the affirmative side has won. Therefore, you must vote in affirmation.