Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 2

IRREFUTABLE REFUTATION OF ALI MIRZA IN REGARD TO

HIS ARGUMENT BY THE THE WORDS ZIKR OF MUAVIAH


USED BY IMAM BUKHARI RH.
ALI MIRZA of Jhelum as tried to allege that Imam Bukhari did not find any S:h:i:
tradition in case of Saiyiduna Muaviah RD, so he was compeeld to write Zikr of
Muaviah instead of M-NA:Q-B of Muaviah RD.
This is the worst of allegations agreed by All the Great Sunni Scholars even by
Irsha:d Al H:Aqq Athari who was even admired by Semi Ahlul Hadis Shaikh Zubair
Ali Zai.
The word Zikr is far more general in its meaning then the word M-NA:Q-B.
But in the Shariah and Law of Allah the word is generally a more strong word then
the Term M-N:AQ-B [Virtue]. 1] To write Zikr instead of the stated above word is it
self a virtue. So writing it makes two Virtues.
The Proofs:=
1]The word Zikr is used for Qura:n even in Qura:n.
Inna: Nah:nu Nazzalna: A(l)zzikra Va inna Lahu: Lah:afiz:u:n(a)
[AL-H:-J-R^ 9]

This shews that this word is used as a virtue unless and otherwise there is a certain
evidence that it is not. Other wise to term Qura:n Shal not be among M-NA:Q-B.
2] ALLAH SAITH :=
DHIKRU RAH:MATI RABBIKA ABDAHU ZAKARIYYA: [MARYAM:2]
This is among M-NA:Q-B.
3] Vazkur Fi:l Kita:bi Musa: innahu Ka:na Mukhlas:an Va Ka:na Rasu:lan Nabiyya:
[Maryam:51]
4] Va Nzkuraka Kathi:rah [T:AHA: ^34]
These four proofs are irrefutable proofs that the word Zikr or its derivations are used
as M-NA:Q-B . So
If Imam Bukhari changed his former stile ,it is due to the reason he was
emphasizing on the M-na:q-b of Saiyiduna Muaviah RD.

5] Allama ABDUL Azi:z Frha:rvi answering the very same objection of Ravafid:
which is borrowed by Heretic Ali Mirza has said:=
The answer of the act of Imam Bukharis is due to Tafann-n Fil Kala:m.
So even the slightest possibility or probability of this answer refutes the self
designed reasoning of Ali Mirza that it was duet o the [alleged] reason that He did
not found any tradition in the Ba:b of M-na:q-b.
These are Insha: Allah sufficient for any one who wand to compare Ali Mirzas
objections and Answers of Ahlussunnah impartially and unbiased.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi