Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
JOURNAL REVIEW
Asep Hapidin | Aditya P Nugraha | PSIM | 2016
Joe Sanderson
Department of Management, School of Business,
University of Birmingham, Birmingham - UK
Pendahuluan
Kesimpulan
3
Pembahasan
2
Tujuan
Overview
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
Background
INTRODUCTION
Mega Project?
a) Project: Substantial physical
infrastructure or asset with a life
expectancy in decades;
b) Client is often a government or
public sector organisation;
c) Main contractor (consortium) of
contractors are usually privatelyowned and financed;
INTRODUCTION
Mega Project?
d) Contractor often retains an
ownership stake in the
infrastructure/asset after the
construction phase is completed
e) Is paid by the client for the service
that flows from the asset's operation
or use over a number of years >>
Public-private partnership
INTRODUCTION
Challenges for Project Manager
a) High levels of complexity in
various dimensions,
b) Poten6al for signicant conicts
of interest,
c) The need to make decisions and
to act under condi@ons of
uncertainty as well as risk
INTRODUCTION
Challenges for Project Manager
Results:
- Intractable Challenges (hard
to control/deal with),
- Signicant cost overruns,
- Delays in comple6on
- Failure to deliver.
INTRODUCTION
Challenges for Project Manager
Paradox:
Megaprojects have become
increasingly popular in recent
years.
PURPOSE
INTRODUCTION
PURPOSE
a) Dierent explaina6on of the
signicant performance problems
exhibited by many megaprojects,
b) Cri6cally examines their suggested
governance solu6ons.
c) To provide a broad categorisa6on of
dierent types of explana6on and
associated solu6ons,
d) To iden6fy any signicant
commonali6es between explana6ons.
INTRODUCTION
TUJUAN
a) Memberikan beberapa macam
deskripsi kendala kinerja signikan
yang terjadi di banyak megaproyek
b) Menjelaskan solusi pengelolaan
yang ditawarkan.
c) Menyajikan penggolongan
umum deksripsi dan solusinya
d) mengiden6kasi kesamaan
deskripsi yang diperoleh.
INTRODUCTION
METHODOLOGY
Examining each author's
fundamental epistemological
assump@ons about decisionmaker cogni@on and about
decision-maker views on the
nature of the future.
Snowball eect on selected
words & phrases.
INTRODUCTION
METHODOLOGY
Banyak riset tentang manajemen
proyek, Megaproyek : Tidak
banyak.
studi yang dilakukan bukan studi
teknis/lapangan. namun merupakan
studi literatur
Studi yang dilakukan bersifat
kualita6f dan merupakan 6njauan
tertulis atas suatu fenomena
RISK OR UNCERTAINTY?
Megaprojects always deals more generally with risk and uncertainty
(Mega) Project management aims:
- To remove (or substan6ally reduce) uncertainty about mee6ng
specied objec6ves.
- Megaproject management typically devote signicant aXen6on to
techniques and models that are designed to iden@fy, assess and
ul@mately manage the risks and uncertain@es associated.
RISK CATEGORY 1
A PRIORI
UNCERTAINTIES
CATEGORY 1
SUBJECTIVE
UNCERTAINTIES
CATEGORY 2
SOCIALISED
RISKS
Risk Category 1: a priori probability
Able to assign objec6ve probabili6es to a known range of future events.
Risk Category 2: sta@s@cal probability
Able to assign objec6ve probabili6es to a known range of future events
on the basis of empirical/sta@s@cal past data.
UNCERTAINTIES
Uncertainty Category 1: subjec@ve probability
No data to assign objec6ve probabili6es to each. Instead they use
expecta@ons grounded in historical prac6ce to es6mate the subjec6ve
probability of future events akin to scenario planning.
Uncertainty Category 2: socialised
No relevant data. The future is inherently unknowable, because it is socially
constructed and may bear liTle or no rela@on to the past or the present.
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSIONS
Three dis@nct types of megaproject issue : The strategic rent-seeking, misaligned or
underdeveloped governance mechanisms, and diverse and compe6ng project cultures and
ra6onali6es
Project - as- prac@ce for researchers. Benet:
First, learn micro-analy6c focus upon the day-to-day ac6vi6es of management
prac66oners and their meaning in a specic se_ng.
Second, the approach draws aXen6on to the wide range of actors involved, both
formally and informally, in crea6ng a project, and in making it happen.
Third, it emphasizes the relevance and importance of emergent, non-programmed, in
other words spontaneous, work ac6vi6es for an understanding of how a project
develops.
THANK YOU