Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
3d 1211
NOTICE: First Circuit Local Rule 36.2(b)6 states unpublished opinions may be
cited only in related cases.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Puerto
Rico [Hon. Hector M. Laffitte, U.S. District Judge ]
Aurelio Saliva Mattei on brief for appellant.
Guillermo Gil, United States Attorney, Maria Hortensia Rios, Assistant
United States Attorney, and Nancy B. Salafia, Assistant Regional
Counsel, Department of Health and Human Services, on brief for appellee.
D. Puerto Rico
AFFIRMED.
Before SELYA, Circuit Judge, CAMPBELL, Senior Circuit Judge, and
BOUDIN, Circuit Judge.
Per Curiam.
Milagros Sosa (claimant) appeals from a district court judgment affirming the
decision of the Secretary of Health and Human Services to deny her application
for disability benefits. For the reasons outlined below (and enumerated at
greater length in the magistrate-judge's report), we find substantial evidence in
support of the Secretary's decision and therefore affirm.
In turn, we think the ALJ was warranted in finding that the functional
restrictions imposed by claimant's remaining ailments were minimal. As to her
complaints of back pain, the ALJ found that claimant suffered from
impairments capable of producing pain, but then proceeded to discount the
Claimant first complained of vertigo in July 1988, during the middle of her
second pregnancy. Following a brief hospitalization therefor (as well as for
pregnancy-related vomiting), she was treated over the next month by a
neurologist (Dr. Scarano Garcia). Results of extensive neurological testing,
including a brain scan and an EEG, were normal except for a mild head tremor;
no cause was found for her vertigo. More important, there is no record of any
further treatment for this condition after August 9, 1988. Indeed, there is no
evidence that claimant thereafter made any further complaints in this regard to
medical personnel-apart from allegations voiced to a psychiatrist in January
1990. The ALJ thus was warranted in regarding claimant's vertigo as a shortlived affliction.
second psychiatrist (Dr. Bocanegra). And even the latter, we note, recorded a
diagnosis of only "moderate" dysthymia.
7
Affirmed.
Sedentary work involves lifting no more than ten pounds at a time and
"occasional" walking and standing. 20 C.F.R. Sec. 404.1567(a)
Most notable among these was the evaluation of one treating physician (Dr.
Quinones Soto), who in December 1987 recommended bed rest for six months
and, in April 1988, reported that claimant was totally disabled. He stopped
treating claimant in December 1987, however, giving way to Dr. Munoz. As
mentioned, the latter described a more benign condition