Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
Definition:
The Bancassurance is the distribution of insurance products through the bank's
distribution channels. It is a phenomenon where in insurance products are offered
through the distribution channels of the banking services along with a complete range
of banking & investment products & services. In simple term we can say bancassurance
tries to exploit synergies between both the insurance companies & banks.
There are only three parties required for the provision of the products:
• The bank
• The insurer and
• The customer
1
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Features of Bancassurance:
The features of bancassurance states as follows:
Win-Win Model:
Bank Act
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Under bancassurance, banks can develop strong relationships with their customers
and sell insurance products. Insurance companies affirm that marketing ‘risk products’
through banks is a cost effective proposition. Bancassurance is a successful model for
both insurance companies and banks. Currently, insurance companies are tying up with
various commercial banks to sell their products and lure more customers. At the same
time, banks without any additional investments on infrastructure are able to earn
service-based income (commission) to augment their core lending activities.
Additional Revenue:
There are various advantages of bancassurance. For the banks, income from
bancassurance is only non-interest-based income. Interest is market driven and its
movement depends on market conditions. At present, banks are unable to get margins
as a result of acute competition and this is making it difficult for them to retain their
customers. Hence, to meet the overhead costs and to improve their incomes, more banks
are getting into bancassurance with existing infrastructure. Bancassurance helps in
generating additional revenue for the banks. By providing multiple services at one
place, the satisfaction level of customers can be increased. For example, through
bancassurance, a customer gets home loans, along with insurance as a combined
product. In the current global financial crisis many banks are looking at bancassurance
as it generates additional income in the form of fees. Financial experts say that since
interest rates have been falling and profits are declining, making survival difficult in the
current financial markets, banks must opt for bancassurance to leverage their income
levels and keep abreast with the changes and latest developments in the financial
markets.
3
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Reduced Costs:
4
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
CONVERGENCE STRATEGIES
The strategies to be adopted should be primarily revolved around the customer and be
directed towards enhancing the value to the customer. It implies that strategy execution
should lead to customer attraction and retention.
Technology adoption is one strategy that is gaining significant coverage
for varied reasons. As the level of technology is enhanced in the banks, they are able to
develop new operating capabilities, thereby offering extraordinary service to customers.
For customer attraction and retention, Insurers will also have to evolve strategies for
5
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
100%
80% DIRECT
60%
BANCASSURANCE
40%
20% TRADITIONAL
0%
TATA AIG
MET LIFE
ING VYSYA
ALLIANZ
SBI LIFE
ICICI
AVIVA
BIRLA
HDFC
6
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
GROWTH OF BANCASSURANCE
This concept gained currency in the growing global insurance industry and its
search for new channels of distribution. Banks, with their geographical spread and
penetration in terms of customer reach of all segments, have emerged as viable sources
for the distribution of insurance products. Presently, there is more activity here than
anywhere else. And every one wants to jump onto the bandwagon for a piece of the
action cake.
Concept evolution is essentially the result of certain driving forces. In the case of
bancassurance, understanding the needs of the two financial intermediaries – banks and
insurance companies that aim to develop the synergy can lead to the identification of
the driving forces. It implies that there has to be an upward thrust in the bank’s bottom
line, while the insurer gets a wider penetration into the market in a cost effective
7
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
manner. As in the case of most coalitions, attaining a win-win is much easier in theory
than in practice. It assures a win-win concept for banks and insurers.
The insurance industry has finally woken up from its long slumber to an
altogether new awakening. It is the rise of a new dawn that has brought with it
opportunities in abundance. From innumerable insurers, to affordable and quality
covers for the consumer, from increase in distribution channels to incorporating
information technology measures, from net selling to bringing about increased
transparency - its all there. The omnipresent agent is no more the only distribution
channel today for insurance products. Increase in distribution channels has among
others also seen the concept of Bancassurance taking roots in India, and it is emerging
to be a viable solution to mass selling of insurance products.
Banks have expertise on the financial needs, saving patterns and life stages of the
customers they serve. Banks also have much lower distribution costs than insurance
companies and thus are the fastest emerging distribution channel. For insurers, tying up
with banks provides extensive geographical spread and countrywide customer access; it
is the logical route for insurers to take.
8
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
The motives behind bancassurance also vary. For banks it is a means of product
diversification and a source of additional fee income. Insurance companies see
bancassurance as a tool for increasing their market penetration and premium turnover.
The customer sees bancassurance as a bonanza in terms of reduced price, high quality
product and delivery at doorsteps. Actually, everybody can be a winner here.
9
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Bancassurance is a win win situation for both the banks as well as the insurance
companies. Banks and insurance companies are the entities which are linked to each
and every individual in today’s era. Banks have been improving and progressing from
the traditional till the modern age. Insurance too provide an assurance to the every
common individual. A win win situation for banks and insurance companies is that
banks provide bancassurance to retain their existing customers as well as to attract new
customers. And for insurance companies is that to earn revenue and create a channel for
diversification.
Banks aims to provide satisfaction of more financial needs to their customers
under one roof i.e. if a customer comes to a bank to deposit a cheque he can at the same
time interact with the bank personnel about the new insurance products coming in so
van the bank personnel can do if the customer approaches to him. While for an
insurance company is to provide quality customer access.
The banks can diversify the revenue by providing both the bank products as well
as the insurance products to their customers while insurance companies can have a
quicker geographical reach to the end customers.
It is more profitable resource utilization for the banks as the banks profits can be
increased by selling the insurance products. Whereas if a bank sells insurance products
to their customers in creates a brand equity for the insurance companies.
Bancassurance enriches the work environment for the banks whereas insurance
companies leverage service synergies with the banks.
The last but not the least bancassurance establishes sales orientated culture for the
banks while for the insurance companies it establishes a low cost acquisition channel.
10
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
The opening up of the insurance sector is a reality, and the Insurance Regulatory
and Development Authority (IRDA) has licensed three players.
It is natural that banks, which deal with the public on a day-to-day basis, think of
entering this sector. In fact, in April, the RBI approved, and issued guidelines for, the
entry of banks into the insurance sector. The guidelines permit any scheduled c
commercial bank to undertake insurance business as an agent of insurance companies,
on a fee basis, without any risk participation, while banks wishing to set up joint
ventures to undertake insurance business with risk-participation have to satisfy the
eligibility criteria.
Normally, the maximum equity a bank can hold in a joint venture is 50 per cent of
the insurance company's paid-up capital. The RBI may, however, selectively permit an
initial higher equity contribution by a promoter bank, pending divestment of equity
within the prescribed period. Thus, the SBI has been allowed equity participation of 74
per cent in its joint venture.
The eligibility criteria also stipulate that as on March 31, 2000 the bank's net
worth should be not less than Rs 500 crore, the CRAR not less than 10 per cent, and the
level of NPAs reasonable. Vysya Bank has entered an agreement with the Netherlands
major ING Insurance, while Centurion Bank has tied up with Canada Life.
Financial majors such as the UTI, ICICI, IDBI, and HDFC extended the scope of
their services by opening up banks, and their performance is encouraging enough to
extend activity on similar lines. Thus, banks and insurance companies can together
create an integrated financial services group, providing customers one-stop financial
shopping.
11
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
The LIC and the GIC have reportedly approached the Centre for licenses to offer
their customers banking and allied services. When banks, insurers and financial
conglomerates come together, as is increasingly happening, exploiting the cross-selling
potent ail of the enlarged group is usually stated as the primary goal. This, the emerging
bank-insurer claims, will create lucrative revenue synergies and generate increased
profits for the stakeholders.
This strategy encourages the provision of individualized services with the back-up
of the large financial group, and makes it easier to sell different products through
different channels. For instance, a complex unit-linked life insurance product is better
sold through brokers or agents, while a standard term product can be handled by bank
branches; bancassurance can, at best, sell such simple products as auto insurance, home
loan and accident insurance cover.
The future trends point towards the banks (say, the SBI) grappling with the task of
bringing together the businesses of banking and insurance. What will be crucial is the
handling of the most important component -- the customer. As customers become more
aware, demanding and sophisticated, with fast-changing life-styles, they want greater
convenience in financial services. The emergence of remote distribution channels, such
as PC-banking and Internet-banking, was a response to just such a demand for quick k
service.
12
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
In India, the main channel for insurance distribution is directly through an agent.
The dependence on direct-agent selling may continue as life and pension products have
long-term commitment and require advice. However, possible fallout of bank-insurance
synergy could be the emergence of newer distribution channels seeking a market share
in the network.
A quick glance at the global scene indicates that more banks are expanding into
non-life business, and that insurance companies are seeking banking networks. The
formation of the huge European financial conglomerates Credit Suisse and Winterthur
could be the first of a long line of new conglomerates.
Recently, major American banks have again turned their attention to insurance for
a variety of reasons:
Many of the banks understand that they are really in a `share-of-wallet' business.
They need to get more out of their customers' financial services business before
somebody else does.
Thus far, the renewed efforts of bank-insurance access on the life side have not
been too successful. Only a paltry 3 per cent of all new life insurance premiums are
generated through banks and savings institutions, though the banks have achieved
13
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
varying success rates so far in marketing non-life business. Substantial gains have been
achieved in home-owner's insurance, while the auto insurance business is encountering
roadblocks.
Regulatory concerns
In India, insurance, banking and securities are regulated by different entities. And
with sound reason too. They are fundamentally different businesses with varying
regulatory requirements though with one common denominator -- the consumer. This
could be the main reason why several countries are moving towards establishing some
sort of integrated approach. Each industry provides personal financial services for
millions of customers who put their trust in the regulator. The regulators need to equip
themselves to handle the emerging situation.
The IRDA regulations provide for the emergence of newer distribution channels,
such as bancassurance, the Internet, direct marketing and through corporate bodies
(non-insurance players). The expansion may be advantageous to customers, but proper
checks and balances must be in place. Insurance, even when sold by banks or combined
with other products, is still insurance and needs to be regulated as such. There is a
definite need to preserve IRDA's authority over all insurance-related products.
14
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
BENEFITS OF BANCASSURANCE
15
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
And If The Coin Had A Third Side Truly We Can Say That The Customer Also Wins.
16
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
17
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Example:
There are about 18 crore bank accounts. Let’s assume a bank sells one insurance policy
to each of these account holders over a period of five years. Take a highly conservative
average first year premium per policy of Rs.5000 and an average commission of 15%
that banks would gain.
Banks can earn a total commission of Rs.13500 crore (going by a simple back-of-the-
envelope calculation: Rs.5000 x 15% x 18 crore accounts = Rs.13500 crore in
commission)
Profitability:
18
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
19
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Rural penetration:
The existing wide network of banks in rural areas can be utilized for
selling insurance products. Penetration into the rural areas too becomes easier for banks.
This channel allows an insurer to effectively tap the rural sector. Selling insurance
through traditional methods in rural area is an expensive proposition. A tie up with a
bank allows an insurance company to access large customer base at a low cost.
Cost – reduction:
Studies reveal that 50% of an insurance company’s cost is directly or
indirectly related to distribution. Expenses ratio in insurance activities through
bancassurance is very low. They can solve the difficulties arising out of price
competition which has driven down the margins and increased the compensation
demand of successful agents.
Example: SBI Life finds that this channel saves as much as 40% of their operating cost
when compared to business procured through their own regular agents.
Market penetration:
Wide network of branches form the ideal distribution channel. Urban as well
as rural both markets are tapped simultaneously. Banks have an established distribution
network of more than 68,000 branches spread throughout the country.
20
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Through agents the insurer can only sell fewer and large policies to a more
up scale client. The middleclass income holders who comprise the bulk of bank
customers get very little attention. By using bancassurance channel the insurer can
capture much of its underserved market.
Facilities Growth:
Reduced costs and high premium turnover results in profitability, thereby
facilitating growth.
Example: Bajaj Allianz has witnessed a 350% growth due to bancassurance.
21
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
“One-Stop Shop” where a customer can apply for mortgages, pensions, savings and
insurance products.
Example:
Through bancassurance a customer gets home loans along with insurance at one
single place as a combined product. Another important advantage that bancassurance
brings about in banks is development of sales culture in their employees.
Reduced costs:
Bancassurance gives the insurance company the benefit of cost-effective
distribution channel, the benefit ultimately passing on to the customers in way of
reduced premiums. The customer gains as the costs are reduced.
22
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
23
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Bancassurance, apart from generating higher non-interest income, has other spin-
off benefits. Capturing of huge captive business readily available in branches by assets
financed brought under the Corporative Agency and the likelihood of branches bringing
in incremental business by insuring other insurable assets of the borrower.
Hence, it provides an option for banks to seek more stable, less volat6ile fee-based
income and to add value to their existing operations by surmounting debilitating
constraints on growth and enhanced Return on Assets (RoA). No wonder, then
bancassurance as a potent instrument of catalyzing business transformation to meet the
onslaughts of progressive liberalization is widely considered both appropriate and
warranted.
Banks and insurance companies are very different in both in value and culture. In
India, the selling of insurance through banks is yet to emerge as regular activity and,
therefore, using traditional products and systems may not be appropriate.
The bitter experience of banks in bancassurance even with innovative products in the
previous years was mainly due to poor marketing, poor publicity, monthly payments
during times of inflation and declining value of money, lack of product promotion
initiated by the branch staff to avoid manual strain in mobilizing and maintaining
24
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
accounts for bancassurance products under different heads and conventional way of
dealing with the customer in explaining with the merits of taken bancassurance
products.
25
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Life insurance products based on the insurers desires (sales driven): rather than
the consumer’s need (market oriented), in rural and semi-urban area also, similar
policies can be canvassed for sale. However, in these branches, the bank should be
proactive and innovative to suggest a proper planning for payment of premiums.
Information technology:
The banks are technology- know-how now and competing with each other
on the service front. Technology up gradation can ensure more effective utilization of
the synergies the banks posses in bancassurance. Banks should train and equip their
staff with backing of technology, to deliver the requirements. Utilization of ATMs and
debit cards act as payment mechanism.
The banks culture must be transformed to sell insurance and it must be ensured
that shelf space is adequately provided in a banks retail delivery system. It is important
to note though, that if the bank’s sales culture is not compatible with selling insurance,
then specialist insurance salesmen may be needed.
26
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
DISTRIBUTION PRODUCT
SYSTEM: DESIGN: SALES
APPROACH:
Performance peaks Tailoring insurance
if insurance products to the A proactive sales
products are sold banks need approach fuels
exclusively enhance the sales revenue growth.
through bank efficiency.
agent.
The key policy challenge, at this stage, is to ensure the financial stability of the
new insurers, while at the same time encouraging entrepreneurship, product innovation
and increasing insurance penetration especially in rural and semi-urban areas.
27
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
28
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
relationship banking of the bank but it has its challenges in terms of defining
partnership terms, learning and unlearning. Bancassurance is a format where the
insurance companies offer their insurance products through the distribution channels of
bank along with a complete
range of banking and investment products and services to a common customer database
purports to serve the interests of the bank in leveraging its infrastructure and the
insurance company in quick entry and growth.
The RBI guidelines for banks will lead to the emergence of three
Different bancassurance models:
29
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
1) A bank can act as a corporate agent (as distinguished from a corporate broker) for
distributing insurance products of an insurer. Risk participation in this model is nil.
2) A bank can form a joint venture with an insurance company for doing bancassurance
business. There will be risk participation in this model, i.e.; through joint venture the
bank can underwrite or perform the principal function of insurance.
3) A bank which is not eligible to form a joint venture, can invest in the insurance
company to provide infrastructure and service support.
Following this, the RBI received 39 applications from commercial banks and RBI
has accorded approval to three banks for joint ventures on risk participation basis. Two
banks, which were given approval for strategic investment in insurance joint ventures
and investment in a distribution and service company, submitted revised application for
joint venture in risk participation basis, while 18 banks and a subsidiary of one bank
were conveyed in principle approval for agency business. Out of the three banks, which
has received RBI approval for joint venture on risk participation basis, two banks,
namely State Bank of India and Vysya Bank have started their insurance operations
30
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
under the registered names of SBI life and ING Vysya respectively. The third bank,
Punjab National Bank is the second amongst PSBs to have received RBIs go ahead for
both life and non life business.
• The ‘Financial Planning Model’ offers each customer with a prospect of full
financial planning package addressing all the individual’s financial concerns, risk
tolerance and location in the cycle of life. This process is beneficial to the customer,
bank and the insurer.
31
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
32
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Added to these positive aspects, bancassurance has also gained the requisite
regulatory support. However, the absence of the necessary technological infrastructure
and the inflexibility in product innovation can hamper the growth prospects of
bancassurance in India.
33
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
1.1. Strengths:
In a country of 1 Billion people, sky is the limit for personal lines
insurance products. There is a vast untapped potential waiting to be mined particularly
for life insurance products. There are more than 900 Million lives waiting to be given a
life cover (total number of individual life policies sold in 1998-99 was just 91.73
Million).
Our other strength lies in a huge pool of skilled professionals whether it is banks
or insurance companies who may be easily relocated for any bancassurance venture.
SBI LIFE have a good range of personal line products already lined up; therefore R &
D efforts to create new products will be minimal in the beginning. Additionally, GIC
with
4,200 operating offices and LIC with 2,048 branch offices are almost already
omnipresent, which is so essential for the development of any bancassurance project.
1.2. Weaknesses:
The IT culture is unfortunately missing completely in all of the future
collaborators i.e. banks as well as insurance companies. A late awakening seems to
have dawned upon but it is a case of too late and too little. Basic IT requirement like
networking (LAN) is not in place even in the headquarters of some institutions, when
the need today is of Wide Area Network (WAN) and Vast Area Network (VAN).
Internet connection is not available even to the managers of operating offices.
34
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
The middle class population that we are eyeing at is today overburdened, first by
inflationary pressures on their pockets and then by the tax net. Where is the money
left to think of insurance? Fortunately, banks are now a days coming out with
some schemes that get IT exemptions but their also a need to be given tax exemption to
the customers further. Another drawback is the inflexibility of the products i.e. it cannot
be tailor made to the requirements of the customer. For a bancassurance venture to
succeed, it is extremely essential to have in-built flexibility so as to make the product
attractive to the customer.
1.3. Opportunities:
Banks' database is enormous even though the goodwill may not be the
same as in case of their European counterparts. This database has to be divided
variously and various homogeneous groups are to be churned out in order to position
the bancassurance products. With a good IT infrastructure, this can really do wonders.
Other developing economies like Malaysia, Thailand and Singapore have already
taken a leap in this direction and they are not doing badly. There is already an
atmosphere created in the country for liberalization and there appears to be a political
consensus also on the subject. Therefore, RBI or IRDA should have no hesitation in
allowing the marriage of the two to take place. This can take the form of merger or
acquisition or setting up a joint venture or creating a subsidiary by either party or just
the working collaboration between banks and insurance companies.
1.4. Threats:
Success of a bancassurance venture requires change in approach, thinking
and work culture on the part of everybody involved. Our work force at every level are
so well entrenched in their classical way of working that there is a definite threat of
resistance to any change that bancassurance may set in. Any relocation to a new
company or subsidiary or change from one work to a different kind of work will be
dislike with forcefulness.
35
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Another possible threat may come from non-response from the target customers.
This happened in USA in 1980s after the enactment of Garn - St Germaine Act. A rush
of joint ventures took place between banks and insurance companies and all these failed
due to the non-response from the target customers. US banks have now again (since late
1990s) turned their attention to insurance mainly life insurance.
The investors in the capital may turn their face off in case the rate of return on
capital falls short of the existing rate of return on capital. Since banks and insurance
companies have major portion of their income coming from the investments, the return
from bancassurance must at least match those returns. Also if the unholy alliances are
allowed to take place there will be severe competition in the market resulting in lower
prices and the bancassurance venture may never break-even.
36
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
BANCASSURANCE OPPORTUNITIES
The motives behind banks selling bancassurance are the product diversification
and a source of additional fee-based income. In turn, return on asset can be increased
with more fee-based income. In addition, they can leverage their name, recognition and
reputation at both local and regional levels. Insurance companies see bancassurance as a
tool for increasing their market penetration and premium turnover. The customer sees
bancassurance as bonanza in terms of reduced price, high quality product and delivery
at doorsteps.
37
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
INDUSTRY PERSPECTIVE
Concept of Bancassurance
Bancassurance as a concept first began in India, when the insurance industry opened up
to private participation in December 1999. It is the concept used to describe the sale of
insurance products in a bank. Bancassurance, which is also known as Allfinanz –
describes a package of financial services that can fulfill both banking and insurance
needs at the same time. The features like distribution, legal, fiscal, cultural and
behavioral aspects for an integral part of the concept. Distribution is the key issue in
bancassurance and is closely linked to the regulatory climate of the country.
Bancassurance is one-stop financial service to meet the requirements of banking
services and also provide reliable protection to customers.
Relevance of Bancassurance:
The banking sector reforms are aimed at making the banks sound and competitive.
Banks are the key pillars of India’s financial system. Public has immense faith in banks.
Banks enjoy considerable goodwill and access in the rural regions. The bank network
established in India is vast and has expertise about the financial needs and saving
patterns of the customers. Apart from this, banks has enormous retail customer base.
The world over, banks have realized that offering value added services such as
insurance helps to meet customer’s expectations. Bank’s entry into the distribution
38
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Falling interest rates coupled with declining deposits are a major source of
concern banks.
Increased competitiveness has led to increased credit risk resulting in a telling
effect on the balance sheet.
Experts feel that sustaining similar growth rate is not possible in the coming years
unless there is a change in the strategy.
The margins of the banks in the banks in their core lending business are declining
sharply.
Apart from this, insurance companies are also equally eager to enhance their
geographical reach within minimum time and cost, establishing brand equity in the new
market, ensuring higher probability of success in the sales process. A tie-up with a bank
having an appropriate customer base can give an insurer a cheap access to these areas.
Selling insurance through traditional methods in rural sectors is very expensive.
Further, selling insurance to existing mass market banking customers is far less
expensive then selling to a group of unknown customers. The banks can bring insurance
service to the poor people at minimum cost. The distribution of insurance products
through banks has been beneficial to insurance and banking companies and also to the
customers.
39
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
INDIA’S PERSPECTIVE
After the Narsimham committee report, the Indian banking system had undergone
reforms in merchant banking, lease and term finance, capital markets, hire purchase,
real estate finance, etc. A few years ago, banks in India entered into the insurance
market to augment their income from insurance business. Indian rural market, which
had a massive potential, was still untapped by the insurance companies. No insurance
company dared to establish its own network in rural areas due to the requirement of
huge capital outlay. Hence, insurance companies planned to capture potential markets.
Eventually, they came out with ‘bancassurance’ as this network helped the insurers to
tap those markets that were left untapped at a much lower cost with the help of the
banks. The competitive nature of the Indian market ensures that the reduction in costs
would result in benefits, in the form of lower premium rates to the clients.
The Indian insurance market comprises 20 private players and the public sector
giant, LIC. Out of these, companies that entered first into the market benefited by
associating themselves with various other banks exclusively for bancassurance
agreements. Under this agreement, banks are appointed as corporate agents, empanelled
with one insurance company, to sell the products. Banks, with their reputation and
market share, can convert their customers into policyholders. Bancassurance is a
creative marketing approach that helps in converting bank customers into insurance
40
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
policyholders. Many private players started venturing into this new field to expand
their market operations. SBI Life Insurance Company plays a predominant role in
bancassurance. This certainly indicates a positive trend for bancassurance in the Indian
banking sector. The company plans to explore insurance business with the potential of
State Bank of India’s 9000 plus branches spread across the country and also the 4000
branches of its associate banks.
By now, it has become clear that as economy grows it not only demands stronger and
vibrant financial sector but also necessitates provision of more sophisticated and variety
of financial and banking products and services. As India is being considered one of the
fast developing economies among the emerging market economies, financial sector has
also become more vibrant with the financial reforms. In fact, in recent years, it is
surmised that even the ‘global economic growth’ hinges on growth prospects of the
emerging economies like China and India to a greater extent. Significantly, Indian
economy has recorded an average growth of over 8.5 per cent for the last four years,
with macroeconomic and financial stability (RBI, 2006) and indications are that it may
grow at even better rate in the near future provided there is good monsoon. Experience
also showed that economic growth had strongly supported the expansion of middle
income class in most of the Asian countries, and now it is the turn of India. Experience
reveals that at the initial growing stage of the economy the primary financial needs are
met by the banking system and thereafter as the economy moves on to higher levels, the
need for the other non-banking financial products including insurance, derivatives, etc.,
41
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
are strongly felt. Moreover, as India has already more than 200 million middle class
population coupled with vast banking network with largest depositor’s base, there is
greater scope for use of bancassurance. For instance, as at end March 2005, there were
more than 466 lakh bank accounts with scheduled commercial banks. In simple words,
it is aptly put that bancassurance has promised to combine insurance companies’
competitive edge in the “production” of insurance products with banks’ edge in their
distribution, through their vast retail networks.
In 2007, India has 88 scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) - 28 public sector
banks (that is with the government of India holding a stake), 29 private banks (these do
not have government stake; they may be publicly listed and traded on stock exchanges )
and 31 foreign banks. Altogether they have a combined network of over 53,000
branches and reach in urban, semi urban & rural areas of nation. There are 70324 bank
offices in India and around 16000 people are served by each bank office. It’s a huge
banking infrastructure and among the best banking network in the world.
Bancassurance if taken in right spirit and implemented properly can be a win-win
situation for the all the participants, viz., banks, insurers and the customers.
42
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
WORLDS PERSPECTIVE
impetus by the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), 1999 in the USA. The Insurance
43
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Bancassurance has already been in force in some form or the other. For example,
banks have already been selling personal accident and baggage insurance directly to
their credit card members as a value addition to their products. Banks have also been
distributing the mortgage-linked insurance products like fire and motor vehicle
insurance to their customers. Most of these have been a part of add-on with the existing
services and products. They, however, are yet to use their information and database on
saving habits of customers to generate the leads for insurance business. In order to
implement the bancassurance mechanism the banks require adequate networking among
the bank branches. This, in turn, requires a substantial investment in IT to connect
various branches effectively. Particularly, the branches in rural and semi-urban areas
remain unconnected. Complete integration of branch network involves huge
investments for creating IT and communication infrastructure. Due to the proliferation
of saving products and emerging investment opportunities in India, The bancassurance
faces the challenge of selling insurance through the banking channel. The competing
returns from other products such as mutual funds posed a major challenge to
bancassurance. Most of the life insurance products are highly structured and have less
flexibility in customizing them to the specific needs of the clients. However, unit-linked
products fit this bill well and the banks can meet this challenge. In bancassurance
system, there are also co-branding issues and the partnership needed to ensure that they
do not give inconsistent messages and destroy value in the process. Leveraging on both
brands is challenging. The implementation of bancassurance also assumes cultural
integration between the two partners. Implementing bancassurance requires different
competencies and skills. One of the important challenges in this is managing
involvement of the bank staff. This is a challenging task as the banks are not
approaching the customers for business but executing requests of customers. For
example, the insurance companies think that target-setting is important for business
growth and, for this purpose, the bank and the insurance company need to develop an
effective sales management and an organization strategy; there has to be a joint
44
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
ownership of targets. Banks have a lot of information and data on consumers’ saving
habits and these can be effectively used for lead generation. For this purpose, the
partners need to develop appropriate mechanisms which ensure better use of this
information. While implementing the bancassurance mechanism, insurance companies
may also experience the difference in pace with which targets are achieved and tasks
are executed. The partners may move at different pace. Capturing the market is
important as the competition is high. The style of working in two cultures can be
different. Incentive systems across various channels are different and these have
implications for each channel. The gaps can become visible and reducing these gaps
may require continuous interaction and training of bank staff. The integrated model
partnerships include a whole new range of challenges such as the challenge of scale,
integration of culture, and speed. The banks experience the challenge of working with
targets and developing new performance measurements. For this, the response time in
deploying adequate resources is critical. Since in bancassurance the partners are going
to use technology and database services, there is a concern about how systematically the
relevant information on consumers interacting with banks is captured. In order to
explore
this channel, insurance companies are required to establish a strong leadership, work
closely with the bank partner and develop this partnership, and develop innovative but
simple products. Data mining and CRM approaches need to be strengthened at the bank
level through appropriate use of technology. It is observed that a customer-focused
approach that fitted in with the bank culture is a critical factor in making bancassurance
a success. The bancassurance sales are radically different from agency-based sales.
Developing an appropriate strategy of sales management and selection, retention, and
training of people involved in the bancassurance programme is also important. These
are required to be strengthened to reinforce and institutionalize the bancassurance
processes.
The incentives and rewards play a significant role to drive the behavior of people but
this has to be developed keeping in view the bank environment and sensitivities.
45
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
CHALLENGES TO BANCASSURANCE
• LEGAL ISSUES:
Statutory restrictions have forced banks to provide their customers with
limited choices. The Insurance Regulatory Development Authority (IRDA) adopted a
cautious approach before flagging off bancassurance. While on the one hand, it is an
economical proposition to sell risk products through the numerous bank branches
spread across the country, the fact that claim settlement disputes take an unusually long
time in our country is a theory issue. In such a situation, banks must be protected to
safeguard their reputation. Otherwise, they may lose their prime banking business.
• COMPETITION:
As mentioned earlier, most bancassurance ventures will be forced to
achieve optimum organization structures due to competition from independent agents.
This competition will devolve with the influx of insurance broking agencies who are
free to bargain for the most suitable products to satisfy the needs of customers.
• The shift away from manufacturing to pure distribution requires banks to better
align the incentives of different suppliers with their own.
46
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
• Increasing sales of non-life products, to the extent those risks are retained by the
banks, require sophisticated products and risk management.
• The sale of non-life products should be weighted against the higher cost of
servicing those policies.
• Banks will have to be prepared for possible disruptions to client relations arising
from more frequent non-life insurance claims.
47
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
EMERGING TRENDS
Bancassurance has been designed to target the mass market. Bancassurers have
started segmenting the market and this has resulted in tailor-made products for specific
market place. The quest for additional growth and the desire to market specific clients
made some bancassurers to switch from using a standardized, single channel
distribution strategy. Some of the bancassurers have started focusing exclusively on
distribution. In some markets, face-to-face contact is preferred as it helps in improving
bancassurance business.
Nevertheless, banks have started opting fro direct marketing and Internet Banking
as vehicles for disseminating insurance products. Emerging channels have become
48
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
increasingly competitive due to tangible cost benefits embedded in product pricing and
its convenience to market.
Finally, the marketing of more complex products has also gained ground in
some countries, alongside a more dedicated focus on niche client segments and the
distribution of non-life products. The drive for product diversification arises as
bancassurers realize that over-reliance on certain products may lead to undue volatility
in business income.
49
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
ENSURING SUCCESS
Banks are now major distribution channels for selling insurance products.
Bancassurance plays a significant role in banking operations. It is a much discussed
concept in insurance markets at present. It was started by banks in France and other
European countries.
A number of insurers have tied up with banks and several banks have started
offering the service of bancassurance through selected risk products. According to
Ramachandran, CEO and MD of Aviva Life insurance, “Bancassurance constitutes to
be an important distribution channel and it currently contributes more than 50% their
business.
• UNIQUE STRATEGIES
Bancassurers must do some groundwork and develop new strategies to sell
insurance products through this channel, especially in emerging markets. Through tie-
ups, some insurers plan to buy shelf space in banks and sell insurance products to
potential customers. Unless banks recruit a trained marketing force, it will be a tough
task to sell insurance products.
• IDENTIFYING CUSTOMERS
Identifying the target customers is yet another important aspect. Banks
have a large depositor base of corporate, as well as retail clients, that they can tap.
Talking of retail clients, lower end and middle-income group customers constitute a
major chunk who have, over a period of time, built a good rapport with the bank staff
and as a result, hold a big potential for bancassurance. The success of bancassurers
depends on how effectively the necessary information regarding the products is
imparted to the employees of respective branches of the bank. Bankers are not expected
50
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
to understand the intricacies of the operations of the insurance industry. They simply
have to identify customers with potential needs for insurances products.
• CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS
When compared to banks, insurance companies have ineffective customer
relationships. Customers usually trust banks and the banking system, than the insurance
companies. So, insurance companies can take help of banks in motivating the customers
to purchase products.
• OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY
51
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
The bank registered a net profit of Rs.3105 crore in the 2002-2003 fiscal. SBI’s
international business accounts for 5% of its total business income.
SBI Life Insurance Company limited is a joint venture between State Bank of
India and Cardiff of France. SBI is the largest bank in India and Cardiff is a leading
insurance company in France operating in 28 countries. Cardiff is a wholly owned
subsidiary of BNP Paribas, one of the largest European banks.
SBI Life branch network will be expanded from 60 to 150 this year.
52
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
SBI Life Insurance Ltd., India’s leading private life insurance company
announced the launch of ‘Bancassurance Online’ the first initiative of its kind with its
Bancassurance promoter, State Bank of India. Mr. O.P Bhatt, Chairman, State Bank of
India formally inaugurated the entrance.
While inaugurating the entry Chairman State Bank of India said, “‘Bancassurance
Online’ is a significant step towards integrating insurance with banking and it will
provide my staff member’s information as well as education on life insurance.”
53
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
ANALYSIS
A survey was conducted of about 50 people who did regular banking transactions.
These included several housewives, businessmen, professionals, students, etc. The
following analysis was done on the basis of the survey conducted:
No 20%
Yes
Yes 80% No
Among those who surveyed, 80% of respondents were aware that their bank provided
bancassurance. They knew with which Insurance Company their bank has tie up with;
also they were aware about various policies provided by their banks. However, 20% of
the respondents were amused with the term bancassurance and didn’t know anything
about it and the services provided by their banks.
54
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
• On your choice which mode of insurance distribution channel would you prefer to
buy the policy from?
Ins urance
co m panies Banks
20% 2 3%
Brokers
7%
Ag ents
50%
50% people preferred agents because they provide personalized services. 20% took
insurance from companies because of their trust on the company. 23% said they would
buy insurance from banks because of the brand name and their trust on banks. Only 7%
said that they would buy insurance from brokers.
• Which bank do you feel would excel in bancassurance? Rate them accordingly
55
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
100
90%
90
80
70%
70
60
50 38%
40
30
20
10
0
No,5%
Yes
No
Yes,95%
56
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
95% people said that they believe that Bancassurance has a very bright future because
there is an immense potential for the insurance industry in India. But 5% believe that
because of the emergence of the new technology such as ATM’s, Internet banking etc
the banks will soon go virtual so there is not much scope for it.
• Do you find any difference in the services provided by the banks and insurance
companies?
YES
NO
80% of the people did not find any difference between the services provided by banks
but the remaining 20% of them did find some difference in the services. As said by the
20% people they found that the bank was charging much for the services than the
insurance company.
• Does you bank provide you with some incentives in kind of gifts or hampers?
57
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Y ES
NO
75% of the people were offered by gifts and hampers for the services taken by them.it
was also seen that the borrowers who had borrowed a large amount of loan were
provided with the gifts and hampers. Rest 25% who did not borrow large amount were
not given any incentives.
• Reasons for taking bancassurance
58
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
There was a mixed response from the customers. 80% said that they took the
insurance policy because of security benefits. 65% said that since, they trusted their
bank, they took the policy. There were 40% who said that the brand image of the
company also mattered. Only 28% said that savings was a reason that encouraged them
to buy insurance policy.
59
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
90%
80%
70%
60% 2002
50% 2004
40% 2006
30%
20%
10%
0%
l
d
ia
fe
nz
ar
ife
fe
A
sy
nt
Li
ia
ir l VIV
Li
nd
de
IL
y
un
ll
V
et
ta
B
ru
M
S
aj
S
IP
IN
a
aj
C
IC
F
B
D
IC
Thus we can have a look on the chart to see the services of bancassurance provided by
the different banks to their customers.
FINDINGS
Although the concept is simple enough in theory, but in practice it has been found
to be far from straightforward.
Almost many people have a fair idea about Bancassurance and that their banks
sell various insurance products. But still few people don’t know about Bancassurance as
a concept.
It has been also found out that the banks have various opportunities to cross sell
insurance products. The insurance companies also have the opportunity to take
advantage of the bank’s network and other avenues.
60
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
It is also seen that customers have a lot of trust on the banks, and because of that
trust the customers will take the insurance products from banks.
As the brand name of the banks is important so is the brand image of the
insurance companies. So the banks and the insurance companies must tie-up with the
right partners. This will help them to create a better image in the minds of the
customers.
It has also clear from the study that the private sector and the foreign banks have
better future in Bancassurance. But the public sector banks are also trying to give them
a tough competition e.g. SBI Life Insurance Co.
The banks fail to provide personalized services as are provided by the agents. So
banks will have to improve in that area. They should provide after sales services to the
customers.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The employees of the banks who are selling insurance products must be given
proper training so that they can answer to any queries of the customers and can provide
them products according to their needs.
Banks should also provide after sales services and they should be more aggressive
in selling the insurance products.
61
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
Banks should also do the settlement of claims which will increase the trust and
reliability of the customers on the banks.
In India, since the majority of the banking sector is in public sector which has
been widely responsible for the lethargic attitude and poor quality of customer service,
it needs to rebuild the blemished image. Else, the bancassurance would be difficult to
succeed in these banks.
A formal and standard agreement between these banks and the insurance
companies should be taken up and drafted by a national regulatory body. These
agreements must have necessary clauses of revenue sharing. In case of possible
conflicts, the bank management and the management of the insurance company should
be able to resolve conflicts arising in future.
Banks and Insurance companies should apply all the skills and potential in this
area and take advantage of the same and they should improve the products from time to
time according to the needs of the customers.
From the analysis it should be recommended that banks should constantly look
out to explore new avenue to supplement their non interest income so called as
BANCASSURANCE.
62
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
With almost half of the population likely to be in the ‘wage earner’ bracket by
2010, there is every reason to be optimistic that bancassurance in India will play a long
inning.
CONCLUSION
In India, the signs of initial success are already there despite the fact that it is a
completely new phenomenon. The factors and principles of why it is a success
63
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
elsewhere exists in India, and there is no doubt that banks are set to become a
significant distributor of insurance related products and services in the years to come.
With the opening up of insurance sector and with so many players entering the
Insurance industry it is required by Insurance Companies as well by the banks to come
up with well established infrastructure facilities with good call centre service to attract
and provide information to customer regarding different good policies & their premium
pay scheme.
The success of the bancassurance business in India has been progressing at a rapid
growth since opening up of the sector. The size of country, a diverse set of people
combined with problems of connectivity in rural areas, makes insurance selling in India
is a very difficult task. But bank can make this simple as the banks have a good
distribution strength and tremendous man power to reach out such a huge customer
base.
Bancassurance is the new insurance marketing mantra for selling insurance plans
with the help of bankers by exploiting the synergies between them. Since bancassurance
is the combination of two sectors, each of the regulators has given out detailed
guidelines for banks getting into the insurance sector. Though initially, bancassurance
64
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
has targeted the mass market, of late, bancassurers have begun to finely segment the
market. This has resulted in tailor-made products for each segment.
In the field of bancassurance banks will bring a customer database, leverage their
name, recognition & reputation of both local and regional levels. If they are using
personal contact with customers and non-customers then only they can success in the
field of bancassurance.
But the proper implementation of bancassurance is still facing so many hurdles
because of poor manpower management, lack of call centers, and no personal contact
with customers, inadequate incentives to agents and unfullfilment of other essential
requirements.
The bank network- especially the public sector and cooperative bank branches are
spread across the length and breadth of the country with 6500 branches. There is
immense potential in the Indian market with only 4500-5000 bank branches currently
distributing insurance.
From the banks perspective, such a model offers a great opportunity to improve
their profitability by enhancing a fee based income. This income is purely risk free for
the bank since the bank plays the role of an intermediary for sourcing business to the
insurance company.
Finally we can say that the bancassurance would mostly depend on how well
insurers and bankers understanding is with each other and how they are capturing the
opportunity and how better service they are providing to their, customers. Let us you all
65
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
pay more attention towards the policies and enjoy the service provide by banks and
Insurance Companies by the mode of Bancassurance.
The bridge has been reached and many are beginning to walk those
cautious steps across it. Bancassurance in India has just taken a flying start. It has a long
way to go ……….. after all The SKY IS THE LIMIT!
QUESTIONNAIRE
2. On your choice which mode of insurance distribution channel would you prefer to
buy the policy from?
3. Which bank do you feel would excel in bancassurance? Rate them accordingly
66
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
5. Do you find any difference in the services provided by the banks and insurance
companies?
6. Does you bank provide you with some incentives in kind of gifts and hampers?
67
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
68
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
BIBLIOGRAPHY
• Business World
• Business Today
WEBLIOGRAPHY
• http:// www.managementparadise.com
• http:// sify.com/finance
• http:// www.domain-b.com
• http://www.moneycontrol.com
• http://sbilife.co.in/sbilife/application
69
BANCASSURANCE—PATHWAY TO SUCCESS
• www.India Infoline.com
70