APPENDIX 2

Check with software Midas

Result Table with Midas civil

Model with Midas civil

Distribution truck HL93

Distribution Cargo (Weight = 400T)

Note in STRENGTH I
cLCB3(max) : Due to Cargo +DC(beam , deck load,parapet), DW(Wearing).
cLCB1(all): Due To HL93+DC(beam , deck load,parapet), DW(Wearing).
Moment
Axial Shear- Shear-z Torsion Moment-
Elem Load Part -z
(kN) y (kN) (kN) (kN·m) y (kN·m)
(kN·m)
1 cLCB3(max) I[1] 104.25 286.12 -657.21 50.25 135.40 1821.12
1 cLCB3(max) 1/4 104.25 286.12 -540.45 50.25 3408.65 1132.67
1 cLCB3(max) 2/4 104.25 286.12 -423.68 50.25 6437.94 444.95
1 cLCB3(max) 3/4 104.25 286.12 -306.92 50.25 9175.33 142.44
1 cLCB3(max) J[3] 104.25 286.12 -190.16 50.25 11620.80 354.67
2 cLCB3(max) I[3] 70.29 70.27 -135.87 78.03 11580.82 380.09
2 cLCB3(max) 1/4 70.29 70.27 -19.10 78.03 12030.94 280.97
2 cLCB3(max) 2/4 70.29 70.27 97.66 78.03 12189.14 257.07
2 cLCB3(max) 3/4 70.29 70.27 214.43 78.03 12057.39 264.81
2 cLCB3(max) J[4] 70.29 70.27 331.19 78.03 11633.86 355.51
3 cLCB3(max) I[4] 0.00 104.00 927.91 589.00 11614.40 401.51
3 cLCB3(max) 1/4 0.00 104.00 1044.68 589.00 9148.67 171.10
3 cLCB3(max) 2/4 0.00 104.00 1161.44 589.00 6391.02 456.34
3 cLCB3(max) 3/4 0.00 104.00 1278.20 589.00 3341.47 1148.68
3 cLCB3(max) J[2] 0.00 104.00 1394.97 589.00 0.00 1841.85
4 cLCB3(max) I[5] 191.85 264.07 -603.75 49.29 249.18 1737.30
4 cLCB3(max) 1/4 191.85 264.07 -511.99 49.29 3455.62 1077.12
4 cLCB3(max) 2/4 191.85 264.07 -420.22 49.29 6841.93 423.92
4 cLCB3(max) 3/4 191.85 264.07 -328.46 49.29 9998.83 183.23
4 cLCB3(max) J[6] 191.85 264.07 -236.69 49.29 12926.32 170.83
5 cLCB3(max) I[6] 84.58 99.12 121.39 228.85 12980.50 160.09
5 cLCB3(max) 1/4 84.58 99.12 213.15 228.85 13292.80 30.52
5 cLCB3(max) 2/4 84.58 99.12 304.92 228.85 13397.39 29.71
5 cLCB3(max) 3/4 84.58 99.12 396.68 228.85 13279.80 31.95
5 cLCB3(max) J[7] 84.58 99.12 488.45 228.85 12954.26 149.71
6 cLCB3(max) I[7] 0.00 9.65 1117.74 1405.59 13012.70 165.06
6 cLCB3(max) 1/4 0.00 9.65 1209.51 1405.59 10103.64 175.50
6 cLCB3(max) 2/4 0.00 9.65 1301.27 1405.59 6965.17 421.81
6 cLCB3(max) 3/4 0.00 9.65 1393.03 1405.59 3597.29 1090.58
6 cLCB3(max) J[8] 0.00 9.65 1484.80 1405.59 0.00 1766.13
7 cLCB3(max) I[9] 17.82 574.69 -598.87 9238.93 23.14 3743.13
7 cLCB3(max) 1/4 17.82 574.69 -507.10 6263.44 4219.73 2306.40
7 cLCB3(max) 2/4 17.82 574.69 -36.30 5240.65 8525.75 882.09
7 cLCB3(max) 3/4 17.82 574.69 164.27 2928.37 9216.51 907.05
7 cLCB3(max) J[10] 17.82 574.69 1017.25 3786.14 9739.16 2281.86
8 cLCB3(max) I[10] 17.39 235.09 23.52 6035.19 9821.62 2103.96
8 cLCB3(max) 1/4 17.39 235.09 115.29 3254.33 11776.50 1779.65
8 cLCB3(max) 2/4 17.39 235.09 723.46 2695.65 13549.67 1816.03
8 cLCB3(max) 3/4 17.39 235.09 973.20 3246.44 11724.17 1891.26
8 cLCB3(max) J[11] 17.39 235.09 1855.03 6026.14 9718.14 2255.69
9 cLCB3(max) I[11] 0.00 546.96 627.22 3782.82 9839.83 2151.54
9 cLCB3(max) 1/4 0.00 546.96 726.85 2932.42 9369.86 833.65
9 cLCB3(max) 2/4 0.00 546.96 1395.49 5245.87 8732.79 933.94
9 cLCB3(max) 3/4 0.00 546.96 1746.56 6269.18 4481.10 2286.58
9 cLCB3(max) J[12] 0.00 546.96 2693.31 9244.67 0.00 3652.01
1 cLCB1(all) I[1] 34.10 80.76 843.28 201.26 44.29 439.62
1 cLCB1(all) 1/4 34.10 80.76 726.51 201.26 2001.08 264.98
1 cLCB1(all) 2/4 34.10 80.76 609.75 201.26 3669.76 100.96
1 cLCB1(all) 3/4 34.10 80.76 492.98 201.26 5046.97 112.34
1 cLCB1(all) J[3] 34.10 80.76 376.22 201.26 6132.27 268.03
2 cLCB1(all) I[3] 17.11 43.63 273.95 37.41 6121.58 252.99
2 cLCB1(all) 1/4 17.11 43.63 157.19 37.41 6513.83 221.29
2 cLCB1(all) 2/4 17.11 43.63 40.42 37.41 6627.29 198.11
2 cLCB1(all) 3/4 17.11 43.63 156.61 37.41 6518.69 229.13
2 cLCB1(all) J[4] 17.11 43.63 273.37 37.41 6130.77 268.14
 3 cLCB1(all) I[4] 0.00 62.76 378.30 202.46 6118.30 272.73
3 cLCB1(all) 1/4 0.00 62.76 495.07 202.46 5026.59 105.63
3 cLCB1(all) 2/4 0.00 62.76 611.83 202.46 3642.97 105.79
3 cLCB1(all) 3/4 0.00 62.76 728.59 202.46 1967.44 275.10
3 cLCB1(all) J[2] 0.00 62.76 845.36 202.46 0.00 454.82
4 cLCB1(all) I[5] 64.13 85.90 870.34 363.12 83.30 511.82
4 cLCB1(all) 1/4 64.13 85.90 778.58 363.12 2067.27 298.14
4 cLCB1(all) 2/4 64.13 85.90 686.82 363.12 3895.82 107.30
4 cLCB1(all) 3/4 64.13 85.90 595.05 363.12 5498.15 154.63
4 cLCB1(all) J[6] 64.13 85.90 503.29 363.12 6871.07 366.78
5 cLCB1(all) I[6] 27.91 44.86 301.12 118.44 6879.37 330.02
5 cLCB1(all) 1/4 27.91 44.86 209.35 118.44 7083.96 254.69
5 cLCB1(all) 2/4 27.91 44.86 117.83 118.44 7097.41 209.78
5 cLCB1(all) 3/4 27.91 44.86 209.59 118.44 7087.03 277.39
5 cLCB1(all) J[7] 27.91 44.86 301.36 118.44 6887.12 372.93
6 cLCB1(all) I[7] 0.00 81.57 503.80 366.22 6873.28 344.37
6 cLCB1(all) 1/4 0.00 81.57 595.56 366.22 5499.08 148.68
6 cLCB1(all) 2/4 0.00 81.57 687.33 366.22 3895.46 115.96
6 cLCB1(all) 3/4 0.00 81.57 779.09 366.22 2062.44 296.65
6 cLCB1(all) J[8] 0.00 81.57 870.86 366.22 0.00 500.10
7 cLCB1(all) I[9] 144.01 186.51 1969.76 3138.37 187.05 1116.36
7 cLCB1(all) 1/4 144.01 186.51 1240.73 1930.44 3031.28 650.10
7 cLCB1(all) 2/4 144.01 186.51 1102.53 2034.51 6018.41 234.00
7 cLCB1(all) 3/4 144.01 186.51 600.08 1371.28 6468.21 409.31
7 cLCB1(all) J[10] 144.01 186.51 756.23 2322.15 7078.41 794.76
8 cLCB1(all) I[10] 70.34 145.78 1320.25 2416.36 7105.10 765.25
8 cLCB1(all) 1/4 70.34 145.78 686.14 1425.01 8112.39 557.80
8 cLCB1(all) 2/4 70.34 145.78 568.74 2009.90 9220.33 443.81
8 cLCB1(all) 3/4 70.34 145.78 690.96 1424.35 8097.32 584.66
8 cLCB1(all) J[11] 70.34 145.78 1325.06 2413.79 7071.84 785.72
9 cLCB1(all) I[11] 0.00 179.93 770.76 2322.15 7107.12 776.24
9 cLCB1(all) 1/4 0.00 179.93 594.24 1372.17 6535.96 406.65
9 cLCB1(all) 2/4 0.00 179.93 1087.88 2035.51 6125.34 246.55
9 cLCB1(all) 3/4 0.00 179.93 1225.07 1932.23 3177.37 645.71
9 cLCB1(all) J[12] 0.00 179.93 1959.22 3139.35 0.00 1095.19
*Value max =

Moment
Axial Shear- Shear-z Torsion Moment-
Elem Load Part -z
(kN) y (kN) (kN) (kN·m) y (kN·m)
(kN·m)
191.85 574.69 2693.31 9244.67 13549.67 3743.13

Reaction table
 Node Load FX (kN) FY (kN) FZ (kN) MX (kN·m) MY (kN·m) MZ (kN·m)
1 cLCB1(max) 8.770657 27.120788 843.275085 273.086449 0.000000 219.976205
2 cLCB1(max) 0.000000 47.846337 845.359455 246.899653 0.000000 454.817941
5 cLCB1(max) 35.975888 9.368909 870.344431 464.490584 0.000000 60.877610
8 cLCB1(max) 0.000000 9.727030 870.857192 462.211781 0.000000 500.100422
9 cLCB1(max) 144.008152 186.505799 1969.756553 3262.671344 0.000000 1116.360328
12 cLCB1(max) 0.000000 179.928834 1959.220389 3259.109656 0.000000 1095.188281
13 cLCB1(max) 35.975888 85.895349 870.344431 61.461033 0.000000 511.817546
16 cLCB1(max) 0.000000 81.569313 870.857192 60.806781 0.000000 58.900492
17 cLCB1(max) 8.770657 80.764463 843.275085 50.075824 0.000000 439.616965
20 cLCB1(max) 0.000000 62.755041 845.359455 74.418339 0.000000 219.001321
1 cLCB3(max) 8.770657 76.655160 1386.864337 888.291785 0.000000 529.025261
2 cLCB3(max) 0.000000 104.004503 1394.969103 867.374895 0.000000 1841.849566
5 cLCB3(max) 140.978663 9.368909 1492.172560 1509.371998 0.000000 60.877610
8 cLCB3(max) 0.000000 9.653947 1484.799384 1475.332609 0.000000 1766.128351
9 cLCB3(max) 251.314570 574.691797 2714.979178 9979.412625 0.000000 3743.132750
12 cLCB3(max) 0.000000 546.959438 2693.314326 9948.817375 0.000000 3652.006531
13 cLCB3(max) 140.978663 264.071681 1492.172560 61.461033 0.000000 1737.300218
16 cLCB3(max) 0.000000 270.537054 1484.799384 60.806781 0.000000 58.900492
17 cLCB3(max) 8.770657 286.117809 1386.864337 50.075824 0.000000 1821.116403
20 cLCB3(max) 0.000000 268.012465 1394.969103 74.418339 0.000000 566.244606

*Value max =

Node Load FX (kN) FY (kN) FZ (kN) MX (kN·m) MY (kN·m) MZ (kN·m)

251.3146 574.6918 2714.979 9979.413 0 3743.133

cLCB3(max)

cLCB1(max)