Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 27

AR VMR AR+A

IGE ESI AEC IGE ESI AEC IGE


458.2 2% 220 98 2 200 575.37
451.01 8 550 164.92 6 55 1798.9
165.14 16 320 99.12 16 250 331.39
794.97 16 1500 69.23 3 200 1550.23
1100.67 15 1500 98.7 2 200 1459.4
844.04 6 350 115.25 2 230 823.02
1345.98 3 300 115.28 16 210 503.8
610.27 7 200 102.31 2 180 716.01
550.4 4 160 97.06 6 130 169.77
1005.34 8 350 87.04 5 430 173.34
483.97 7 600 137.34 3 218 953.59
591.7 9 300 133 8 60 1560.89
650.4 7 350 210.68 3 230 364.84
1256.52 9 620 97.34 2 100 350.6
828.13 3 250 85.5 8 120 560.89
243.07 8 640 100.42 11 250 550.9
963.35 6 240 89.41 6 90 257.39
266.96 5 400 89.57 2 300 1679.98
219.56 6 330 133.39 8 150 1170.1
1245.61 4 300 171.18 2 120 1789.9
324 4 348 193.43 6 100 349.9
628.25 5 600 478.98
583.28 2 425 385
1456.69 8 500 255.23
1697.11 5 800 1890.67
336.76 8 600 540
211.75 3 320 1689.98
1340 4 340 254.62
256.5 5 450 511.06
750.5 8 450 1654.5
1340 12 350 559.67
401.75 2 260 436.27
122.94 7 160 320.56
148.98 2 270 1352.65
363.8 5 100 320.6
623.8 9 620 432.14
1110.23 8 350 450.78
683.26 7 560 1186.92
1577.48 10 800 1685.6
555.3 8 660 303.53
1005.79 4 380 569.9
122.24 2 140 1657.98
250 14 450 650
633.7 14 600 786.6
750.9 9 510 359.98
704.66 7 1200 560.32
443.3 9 711 350
257.39 3 350
578.89 8 540
1100.41 6 546
445.79 12 800
777.75 5 570
1100.9 11 611
306.76 2 450
779.9 12 800
1674.89 6 900
1345.89 9 500
263.3 6 280
189 5 350
1568.34 10 600
240.6 7 500
550.91 6 400
675.43 5 250
1259.8 5 650
1123.6 4 300
155 6 450
715.2 10 860
1641.89 7 650
794.4 5 250
735.4 6 300
130.42 4 110
347.04 3 250
449.9 4 610
422.29 2 550
158.18 8 580
191.5 12 300
237.51 4 350
578.9 7 650
1010.13 8 450
669.93 10 530
236.4 6 500
255.23 9 280
800 4 650
279.96 6 350
668.96 4 450
1050.45 8 600
1078.9 12 700
576.46 2 280
305.61 7 230
630.07 20 850
128.7 4 450
237.7 4 540
526.6 14 680
112.07 6 280
1342.67 5 400
731 8 700
699.5 3 280
1267.72 15 500
499 3 160
421.89 4 250
921.73 8 300
207.1 4 210
678.16 6 200
425.3 6 430
809.4 4 350
380 2 180
1190.56 5 250
1351.09 9 500
445.19 5 580
391.02 5 250
178.9 8 290
1289.67 3 230
1090.62 3 230
363 2 120
259.26 3 150
675.43 5 250
714 6 230
470.14 4 300
897.78 6 350
627.78 8 820
614.59 6 250
1012.45 4 350
277.1 3 315
403.1 6 440
277.1 5 600
690.26 4 340
1020.32 8 840
112.4 6 690
300.59 4 260
1145.56 10 700
515.3 15 1200
297.99 6 550
298 8 640
717 5 610
598.42 6 250
486.11 8 540
111.74 5 350
195.83 8 470
431.68 3 250
715.2 10 860
712 8 540
1075.31 3 250
1162.44 3 250
410 5 320
137.9 3 250
595.5 5 420
136 3 280
373.13 3 220
294.4 6 980
213.7 6 600
213.31 3 150
497.2 9 700
257.39 3 350
319.83 7 330
381.58 6 480
253.39 3 350
249.07 4 500
470.7 12 1200
1008.55 4 250
1067.88 9 1000
497.3 3 200
598.42 6 250
222.3 4 140
306.6 4 150
374.64 3 220
1346.99 3 450
1454.98 3 300
522 4 380
499 6 550
648 16 1200
988.8 5 450
383.3 150 240
1377.66 8 800
412.5 3 600
537.4 8 700
234.7 5 440
305.97 7 250
279.19 8 800
348.9 5 450
ASP CTRLS
ESI AEC IGE ESI AEC IGE ESI
9 1200 699.5 8 580 78.3 2
9 1700 834.47 7 1300 98.5 3
13 370 1900.67 9 1800 82.8 5
16 570 2500.67 15 1900 92.34 1
10 570 2157.78 12 1120 89.76 2
4 380 1989.9 18 600 210.67 2
6 605 690.98 9 700 114.56 2
4 950 1875.89 19 800 123.64 7
6 420 900.7 12 900 115.32 3
5 370 1679.98 12 950 103.48 5
10 810 897.9 10 750 191.48 6
15 820 94.43 2
9 390 203.41 4
11 550 126.7 3
8 752 111.8 2
6 540 142.74 5
4 410 95.43 3
16 900 92.89 3
6 450 87.89 3
4 560 108.95 3
7 600 104.12 2
5 700 96.86 2
10 160 90.76 2
9 280 85.23 2
8 600 80.34 1
5 380 79.87 1
9 350 83.45 1
7 250 94.67 1
9 350 95.87 6
6 700 106.78 6
14 1500 140.67 5
8 600 167.98 5
5 1700 173.98 5
8 400 145.92 2
6 600 162.12 3
7 890 155.83 5
10 770 138.36 4
6 670 134.42 4
10 700 140 4
6 370 189 4
7 390 210 4
6 660 191.12 4
7 760 98.67 2
6 1500 81.78 1
7 1700 94.56 3
8 650 121.45 3
16 590 134.25 6
158.19 4
171.69 5
AEC
50
90
70
120
80
320
310
280
210
150
180
100
320
120
110
130
90
60
80
140
170
150
120
90
100
90
60
70
50
110
160
180
190
160
200
190
195
135
95
185
340
340
120
130
70
110
120
210
240
Anova: Single Factor

SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 179 ### 623.35 ###
Column 2 47 37333.75 794.34 ###
Column 3 11 16128.44 1466.22 ###
Column 4 21 2488.17 118.48 1436.16

ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups ### 3 ### 26.38 0 2.64
Within Groups ### 254 ###

Total ### 257


Column1

Mean 623.35
Standard Error 29.42
Median 537.4
Mode 1340
Standard Deviation393.62
Sample Variance ###
Kurtosis -0.19
Skewness 0.82
Range 1585.37
Minimum 111.74
Maximum 1697.11
Sum ###
Count 179
Column1

Mean 623.35
Standard Deviation393.62
Minimum 111.74
Maximum 1697.11
IG ESP
AR AR+A ASP VMR CTRL AR AR+A
458.2 575.37 699.5 98 78.3 2% 9
451.01 1798.9 834.47 164.92 98.5 8 9
165.14 331.39 1900.67 99.12 82.8 16 13
794.97 1550.23 2500.67 69.23 92.34 16 16
1100.67 1459.4 2157.78 98.7 89.76 15 10
844.04 823.02 1989.9 115.25 210.67 6 4
1345.98 503.8 690.98 115.28 114.56 3 6
610.27 716.01 1875.89 102.31 123.64 7 4
550.4 169.77 900.7 97.06 115.32 4 6
1005.34 173.34 1679.98 87.04 103.48 8 5
483.97 953.59 897.9 137.34 191.48 7 10
591.7 1560.89 133 94.43 9 15
650.4 364.84 210.68 203.41 7 9
1256.52 350.6 97.34 126.7 9 11
828.13 560.89 85.5 111.8 3 8
243.07 550.9 100.42 142.74 8 6
963.35 257.39 89.41 95.43 6 4
266.96 1679.98 89.57 92.89 5 16
219.56 1170.1 133.39 87.89 6 6
1245.61 1789.9 171.18 108.95 4 4
324 349.9 193.43 104.12 4 7
628.25 478.98 96.86 5 5
583.28 385 90.76 2 10
1456.69 255.23 85.23 8 9
1697.11 1890.67 80.34 5 8
336.76 540 79.87 8 5
211.75 1689.98 83.45 3 9
1340 254.62 94.67 4 7
256.5 511.06 95.87 5 9
750.5 1654.5 106.78 8 6
1340 559.67 140.67 12 14
401.75 436.27 167.98 2 8
122.94 320.56 173.98 7 5
148.98 1352.65 145.92 2 8
363.8 320.6 162.12 5 6
623.8 432.14 155.83 9 7
1110.23 450.78 138.36 8 10
683.26 1186.92 134.42 7 6
1577.48 1685.6 140 10 10
555.3 303.53 189 8 6
1005.79 569.9 210 4 7
122.24 1657.98 191.12 2 6
250 650 98.67 14 7
633.7 786.6 81.78 14 6
750.9 359.98 94.56 9 7
704.66 560.32 121.45 7 8
443.3 350 134.25 9 16
257.39 158.19 3
578.89 171.69 8
1100.41 6
445.79 12
777.75 5
1100.9 11
306.76 2
779.9 12
1674.89 6
1345.89 9
263.3 6
189 5
1568.34 10
240.6 7
550.91 6
675.43 5
1259.8 5
1123.6 4
155 6
715.2 10
1641.89 7
794.4 5
735.4 6
130.42 4
347.04 3
449.9 4
422.29 2
158.18 8
191.5 12
237.51 4
578.9 7
1010.13 8
669.93 10
236.4 6
255.23 9
800 4
279.96 6
668.96 4
1050.45 8
1078.9 12
576.46 2
305.61 7
630.07 20
128.7 4
237.7 4
526.6 14
112.07 6
1342.67 5
731 8
699.5 3
1267.72 15
499 3
421.89 4
921.73 8
207.1 4
678.16 6
425.3 6
809.4 4
380 2
1190.56 5
1351.09 9
445.19 5
391.02 5
178.9 8
1289.67 3
1090.62 3
363 2
259.26 3
675.43 5
714 6
470.14 4
897.78 6
627.78 8
614.59 6
1012.45 4
277.1 3
403.1 6
277.1 5
690.26 4
1020.32 8
112.4 6
300.59 4
1145.56 10
515.3 15
297.99 6
298 8
717 5
598.42 6
486.11 8
111.74 5
195.83 8
431.68 3
715.2 10
712 8
1075.31 3
1162.44 3
410 5
137.9 3
595.5 5
136 3
373.13 3
294.4 6
213.7 6
213.31 3
497.2 9
257.39 3
319.83 7
381.58 6
253.39 3
249.07 4
470.7 12
1008.55 4
1067.88 9
497.3 3
598.42 6
222.3 4
306.6 4
374.64 3
1346.99 3
1454.98 3
522 4
499 6
648 16
988.8 5
383.3 150
1377.66 8
412.5 3
537.4 8
234.7 5
305.97 7
279.19 8
348.9 5
ESP AEC
ASP VMR CTRL AR AR+A ASP VMR
8 2 2 220 1200 580 200
7 6 3 550 1700 1300 55
9 16 5 320 370 1800 250
15 3 1 1500 570 1900 200
12 2 2 1500 570 1120 200
18 2 2 350 380 600 230
9 16 2 300 605 700 210
19 2 7 200 950 800 180
12 6 3 160 420 900 130
12 5 5 350 370 950 430
10 3 6 600 810 750 218
8 2 300 820 60
3 4 350 390 230
2 3 620 550 100
8 2 250 752 120
11 5 640 540 250
6 3 240 410 90
2 3 400 900 300
8 3 330 450 150
2 3 300 560 120
6 2 348 600 100
2 600 700
2 425 160
2 500 280
1 800 600
1 600 380
1 320 350
1 340 250
6 450 350
6 450 700
5 350 1500
5 260 600
5 160 1700
2 270 400
3 100 600
5 620 890
4 350 770
4 560 670
4 800 700
4 660 370
4 380 390
4 140 660
2 450 760
1 600 1500
3 510 1700
3 1200 650
6 711 590
4 350
5 540
546
800
570
611
450
800
900
500
280
350
600
500
400
250
650
300
450
860
650
250
300
110
250
610
550
580
300
350
650
450
530
500
280
650
350
450
600
700
280
230
850
450
540
680
280
400
700
280
500
160
250
300
210
200
430
350
180
250
500
580
250
290
230
230
120
150
250
230
300
350
820
250
350
315
440
600
340
840
690
260
700
1200
550
640
610
250
540
350
470
250
860
540
250
250
320
250
420
280
220
980
600
150
700
350
330
480
350
500
1200
250
1000
200
250
140
150
220
450
300
380
550
1200
450
240
800
600
700
440
250
800
450
CTRL
50
90
70
120
80
320
310
280
210
150
180
100
320
120
110
130
90
60
80
140
170
150
120
90
100
90
60
70
50
110
160
180
190
160
200
190
195
135
95
185
340
340
120
130
70
110
120
210
240