: .

23.02.2009.

1. - ' ' ' '

2.

2.1 ?

2.2

3.

3.1

3.2

3.3 ,

11

4.

13

16

3
1. ' ' ' '

,
, , ,
( ,
). '' ''
(Science Wars), (
. Geertz 2001),
.
( , ,
)
(
),
-
.
( ) ,
, ,
'' '' .
, ,
( ),
,
, (

4
,
).

,
, ' '
(; ), ' ' (; ).
(,
), ( ) (
, , )
, , (Bent Flyvbjerg),
() ().
'

',

, '' ,
: ,
'' (Flyvbjerg 2004, : ). ,
(
). :

,
, ,
(Flyvbjerg 2001, : ).

(
),

5
1, ' '
( )
, ,
. '' , ,
.
,
, ,
('' ?''),
, .
, -, (''
'').
, ,

, .
( )

.
, .
.
,

'' '', -
. ( . Laitin 2003),
(. Schram 2006). ,

(Perestroikan movement, , .
Greenwood 2007).
1

6
( )
( ).
.

, , (
).

2.
2.1 ?
,
(), ,
,
,
- ?
, , ( )
. , '''' ,
(, ,
), '''',
( , ),
. , ,
, .
, : ''

7
? , ?
? , , ?'' (Flyvbjerg 2008,
: ).
(
) , ( )
.

2.2
, (David Laitin) ,
, -
() (
) ( )
(Laitin 2003). ( -
) (
- )
(, ).

( )
, ( )
.
() ,
(Flyvbjerg 2004). ,

8
(George, Bennett 2005)

, '''' .

3.
3.1
( )
. '' ''
( ) (
)
'', ( , )
,
, (, , )
.
)

, (

) , .
,
XVIII , '''' , ,
;
.
( ),
XIX ,

9
'' ( '' '' (physics envy), Flyvbjerg
2001). , ''''
, ,
(
) '''' .
)

( ,

, , )
,
. ,
( ),
,
, .
(
). ' '
.

3.2
,
( ),
(-
). , ,
, ,
( )

10
.
( , , ,
, .),
.

:
, , ,
, ,

:
'' '' (Flyvbjerg 2003, ).

)
. , ,
, ,
, .
, , (
9 10 ; Flyvbjerg 2003),
.
, ,
.
, ,
'' , .
(., , ''
''; Flyvbjerg 2003). ( ,

11
)
, , ,
.

.

(Flyvbjerg 2003).
( )

(Blitstein 2008).
b)

''
''. ,
( Blitstein 2008),
: '' ,
;
'' (Flyvbjerg 2003).

3.3

,
( ),

, ( 'problem driven' 'value driven')

, ('methodology driven')
(Flyvbjerg 2001).

12
. , ,
(
), , , (
), .
,
,
, .
)

, , ,

,
-, , ''''
. .
, ,
: '' ? ,
? ? , ,
?'' (Flyvbjerg 2008)
.
;
.
,
. ' '
.
)

, ,

, ,

13
, ,
, ()
'' ''
( Geertz 2001). , '' '',
,
.
,
,
''''
( Flyvbjerg 2001).

4.
,
( )
,
( ). ,
, ,

.
, ,
'' '',
,

14
, ,
, ,
, .
, ,
() , ,
,
, . ,
( )
, .
- .

.

,
- .

, ;
( Blitstein 2008).
, , ()
.
, , ,
.
, ,

15

.
- ()
:
.
'''' ,
, ,
.

16

Blitstein, R. (2008) Derailing the Boondogle (A Danish professor promotes a cure for billion-dollar cost
overruns in government megaprojects: Use past boondogles as a baseline). MillerMcCuneMagazine, , 18. .
Flyvbjerg, B. (2001) Making Social Science Matter: Why Social Inquiry Fails and How It Can Succeed
Again. : Cambridge University Press.
Flyvbjerg, B., Bruzelius N., Rothengatter W. (2003) Megaprojects and Risk: An nathomy of Ambition.
: Cambridge University Press.
Flyvbjerg, B. (2004) A Perestroikan Straw Man Answers Back: David Laitin and Phronetic Political
Science. Journal of Pollitics & Society Vol. 32, No. 3, str. 389-416.
Flyvbjerg, B. (2008) Phronetic Organizational Research, Richard Thorpe and Robin Holt (.) The
Sage Dictionary of Qualitative Management Research, str. 153-155. : Sage
Publications.
Geertz, C. (2001) Empowering Aristotle: A Review of Making Social Science Matter by Bent Flyvbjerg,
Science Volume 293, Number 5527, str. 53.
George, A., Bennett, A. (2005) Case Study and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. ,
: MIT Press.
Greenwood, D. (2007) A Rewiew of Making Political Science Matter by Sanford Schram and Brian
Caterino (eds), Springer Science, 2007.
Laitin, D. (2003), The Perestroikan Challenge to Social Scienece, Journal of Pollitics & Society 31, str.
163-184.
Schram, S. (2006) Beyond Paradigm: Resisting the Assimilation of Phronetic Social Science. Schram,
S. Caterino, B. (.) Making Political Science Matter: Debating Knowledge, Research and
Method (. 417-433). : New York University Press.