Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 149

: .

3122

..

: ..

: .

: .

: .

:
?? =9> 8 ?
8;9=;?5= :
e.mail: mahrosa@ mahrosa.com
:

8955/5559? :

?=>-?==-959-:5?-= :


.

.

..

..

..

.. .

..

..

;5

..

;>

?55

. ()

. .

.. /

..

..

:
.

.
.

()

..

.

.
.

.
()

( ) (
) .

.

.
.

..

5 .

01

..

..

00

"

: . ".

( )

.

.

: -

- .



.

" "

02

..

.
(

.

.

) :
- " " 391 1

..

03



%39
.

( )

()

04

..

()

(/) .

" : "
" :

".

: /
. 992
: ( ) 2 :
:
. 9 992

..

05

.
""

.
" " .


.

.
: ""

( )
.

"" ( )
.

" : " : (
) ( ) .
.

OECD

06

..

.
""

.2
.

.2

.
( )

9 9 - OSCE/ODIHR
992
. 999

.
2 : 999 .2 2

..

07

) .

.9

.

.2 :
9 :


.
:

( ) ( ) .
.
:

08

..

. % 9
% 9 .

:

.

%99

.
- - :

""
.

""
.

""


.
.
(

..

09

)
(

)
" "


%9 %2

.
:

- -


.
.

)1 " "

. 3 3



19

21

..


() 211

3 9 199

. : 99
%222
22 22


.
)2 329
" "d'Hondt

.. 2
. : 9
999
2 9

2 9

29

( ) - :
9 2
.

20

..

:5-5 d'Hondt

) (2 9

) (2 9

)9( 29

() 1

() 2

)2( 99

19

) 1( 2

)3( 92

22

29

)2( 91

11

21

29

) 9( 29

d'Hondt
(

)
321

.Hare/Niemeyer

)3 Hare/Niemeyer

( )M

( )SP ( )S
( )MZ :

M x (SP/S) = MZ
(
)

22

..

Hare/Niemeyer
d'Hondt -
.

:8-5 Hare/Niemeyer

)M x (SP/P


d'Hondt

Hare/
Niermeyer

;:8

(59 X):8;/5999

;:28

959

(59 X)959/5999

9259

;5:

(59 X)5:;/5999

;52:

589

(59 X)599/5999

5289

999

)4

.d"Hondt

Andre Sainte-
Lague

Sainte/Lague/Schepers ""
993

23

..

.

K
.Hare/Niemeyer
""

/
( 99

)


:

2- 99 999

9 .

:9-5

2 9
2 9
29
9
999

99
99
99
99

2, 9
2, 9
,29
, 9




2
2

24

..

3 9

. 31,9
3 9 39
.2-

:-5

2 9

39

2, 1

29

39

,92

2 9

999

39
39

2, 1
, 1




2
2

: "

"
.


.

..

25

.
(

)
( ) .

.
"" - - .

Gerrymandering



% 9 .

26

..

;-5

..

27

( : :)9- 3


. : ()

() . 9 2

. :

.
2

2 .

28

..



23 3 2

22999999


.
.


-
.
.
2 : ""
()

""

( ) ""

..

29

( ).
:

( ) ( )
( ) :

( ).

( )
.. .
""

- " "

)3 :

31

..

( )

:<-5


( )

. 2 12

..

30

.
:

. :

299 9


22
2 () 22
() .

) .

d`Hondt

32

..

.%2
%2 .
: 2 2

% 1 % 1

% 2 .% 2
% 2 . d'Hondt

( 992 .)1-

:=-5
( )

23229
9 129 9
313321
1132 9
291 2
291913

PSOE
PP
IU
CiU
PNV
UPyD

22,3
23,3
2,2
2,9
,
,

13
92
9
1
299

22,2
22,
9,1
,3
,1
9,2


1129
11129
222312
11322
9 9
291913

33

..

PSOE

PP 11999

CiU PNV
IU
UPyD
.

>-5

( : )899> 5?>8

5?>8

PSOE

22,

91,1

?>?5

PSOE

23,1

99,9

19

<>?5
5??9
<??5
8999
899:
>899

PSOE
PSOE
PP
PP

PSOE
PSOE

()%

22,

22,2
22,3
29,

2 ,1
22,3

()%

9 ,1
29,2
22,1
9 ,2
21,3
22,2

22
93
91
22
12
13

2- PSOE

34

..

% 23,1 323

2 32 ( 992
%99

) .
.

.
():


""

11 2

9-2
.


( )

..

35

...

.1 .
.2
( )
.

Droop Q
( = Q : / ) +
+

.3
( )

( ).

.4

Doublin South-West

991

3- 2 19

36

..

Q
.222
?-5

( =899

)Doublin South West


8

Crowe
)(SF

9911

Davidson
)(GP

921

Lenihan

Kelly

Hayes

2221

Kelly
)(Unh
Lenihan
)(FF

292

Murphy
)(SP

929

O'Connor
)(FF

12 2

Murphy Rabitte

9+

91+

2+

9911

9 22

9 29

9 23

9111

1+

92+

1+

2+

912+

99

199

11

111

22

9-

2221

2221

222

222

222

+
222


911+

Hayes
)(FG

<

221-

221

222

222

222

222

222

2+

19+

11 -

922

193

11

11

1 +

1+

2+

2+

229+

2 91

2 93

2223

1329

2 9

37

..

Rabitte
)(Labour

22 9

1+

22 2

22 2

22 2

22

22

22+

21+

22

22

22

2 19

2 19

2 19

2 19

2 19

2 19

2 : ( )FF

( )FG 2

( )SF( )GP( )SP .

)FG( Hayes )FF( Lenihan


. ()
Lenihan ( Rabitte) 1

. ()



22

. Hayes Rabitte
( )Murphy

O'Connor

38

..



( 991
)FG
.

9-

.
59-5

FF

FG

12

293

911

292919

2 1

93 19

9122 2

11
9

211

99

9293

..

39

" "

:

)1
( )


. ""
.

)2 ""

( )
.
:

)3

41

..

.
():

()

( )

.

.
"" "
"


"" .

40

..

:55-5 (

) Sainte Lague
?899

CDU

2 2 11

12222

12

SPD

3339222

21233

21

FDP

12 1929

3 1 2

32

9 99322

19191

11

2122 1

12922

12

2 99

CSU

229 22

29112 22

*12, 39

932

993
( Sainte

.)Lague -

%9

2 (

) %9 2

42

..

. %9



(
)
.
%9
.

()

.

.

..

43

.4 :

.


""

-

.

2 . 993

44

..

:58-5

( ) .

.

( )
( )

.

..

45

)
( ).

( )
( )


( ) .
.

:
""
-
.


""

93 91 9

.

46

..

.


.
:

-
.

: 339/ 323

.1

( )
2

: //.
/ : :
. 321
2 : 33 323:
/ : 332
. 99 2

..

47


.2
:



.


.
2 " :"

"" ( transformation, replacement,

.)transplacement ""

" "


.
"

/ :
331 .21
:
.2

48

..

.
"
-
.


-
.

" "

.

.

.

.





.

( .)Replacement
/ : 1

..

49

( ) .


.

51

..

..

50


mazenhassan2@yahoo.com :

52

..

..

53

- :

54

..

""
. :

- :

" "

.
%99

%99 .

..

55

" "



". "less evil choice
.

2
( )
:

%29

%29

% 9

Duverger, Maurice (1954) Political Parties. New York: Wiley.

56

..

:
()

()

. " "
Duverger, Maurice (1954) Political Parties.

..

57

" "





.
-2 :

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering: Voting Rules and Political


Behaviour, New York: Cambridge University Press.
1

58

..



Duverger, Maurice (1954) Political Parties.
Duverger, Maurice (1954) Political Parties.

1
2

..

59

% 9 % 9

9 .


d'Hondt
( )

61

..


.
-3 :

( ) - 19 22
1
1

. 999- 339

19

9,

2,29 3,9
.

60

..

()5-8

(
)
;288

>9

9,1

3,9

1,9
2,12

2
23

;>>2

<8

2,23

2,1

?2;8

<5

9,9
3,12

93

;=29

5=9

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering

62

..


( ) -

( ) -

) .

..

()8-8

63

= 2442
= 3454
= 4445

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

64

..




,9 ,
2
.


,1
( )%1
2.





.

- :





..

65

.
:



.




(
).
1

Powell, G. B. (1986) American voter turnout in comparative


;perspective, American Political Science Review, 80:1, pp. 17-43
Jackman, R. W. (1987) Political institutions and voter turnout in
industrial democracies, American Political Science Review, 81:1, pp.
405-24; Blais, A. and K. Carty (1990) Does proportional
representation foster voter turnout, European Journal of Political
Research, 18, pp. 167-81; Franklin M.
(1996) Electoral
Participation, in, L. LeDuc et al., Comparing democracies: elections
;and voting in comparative perspective, California: Sage Publications
Blais, A. and K. Aarts (2006) Electoral System and Turnout, Acta
Politica, 41, pp. 180-96.
2
Powell, Bingham (1982) Contemporary Democracies: Participation,
Stability, and Violence, Cambridge: Harvard University Press; Fornos,
C. et al. (2004) Explaining voter turnout in Latin America, 1980 to
2000, Comparative Political Studies, 37:8, pp. 909-40.

66

..



%19

% 9

12
.

( )2-


.
(

) .

1,1
.

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

67

..

()9-8

==

<92:

<>29

19,9

3 ,3

92,9

19,9

1 ,

11,1

9 ,1

93,2

91,9

19,3

<:29

=92:

<8

11,1

1 ,3

12,9

13,9

22

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

68

..

=929

<=:2

<5

19,9

12,2

93

22,2

2 ,1

<;29

>=92

5<:

..

69

. ( .)2-

():-8

71

..








.

.

.

,1 9,999
.


.

- :


Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering

..

70

%99


.
( )9-


Norris, Pippa (1985) Women in European Legislative Elites, West
European Politics, 8:4, pp. 90-101; Lijphart, Arend (1994) Electoral
1

Systems & Party Systems: a study of twenty seven democracies


1945-1990, Oxford: Oxford University Press; Matland, Richard (1998),

Womens representation in national legislatures: Developed and


developing countries, Legislative Studies Quarterly, 23: 1, pp. 109125.

72

..


%2,9 % ,2
% 9,2 .
5

();-8



;>2
,


?>

1,

3,1
2,9

2
92

5528
2,1
2,9

?8
2

5;2:

<:

9,1

,1

5>8

9,1

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

..

73

( )1- 2

( )9

2 .

74

..

()<-8

()8999

1,3

,1

9,2

,1


3,9

3,2
<582

,3

>52

2,1
1,2

:29

2
9

2
91



Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

..

75


" "

.

76

..

313 332

%11 %19
.2

.
331

99

Somit, Albert et al. (1994) The Victorious Incumbent: A Threat to


Democracy, Aldershot: Dartmouth.
%29

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral :
1

Engineering

Matland, Richard and Donley Studlar (2004), Determinants of


legislative turnover: a cross-national analysis, British Journal of
Political Science, 34: 1, pp. 87-108.

..

77

- :



( )

.
( .)1-

78

..

()=-8

..

79


( )


.
2





Sisk, Timothy and Andrew Reynolds (1998) Electoral Systems and


Conflict Management in Africa, Washington D.C.: US Institute of Peace
Press.
2
Saideman, S.M. et al. (1990) Democratisation, political institutions
and ethnic conflict A pooled time-series analysis, 1985-1998,
Comparative Political Studies, 35:1, pp. 103-129.
3
Tesbelis, George (1990) Elite interaction and constitution building in
consociational democracies, Journal of Theoretical Politics, 2:1, pp.
5-29.
1

81

..


(. )Catch-all parties



.






.


.
2


1

Taagepera, Rein (1998) How electoral systems matter for


democratisation, Democratisation, 5:3, pp. 68-91.
2
Arend Lijphart and Carlos Waisman (eds.), Institutional Design in
New Democracies: Eastern Europe and Latin America, Oxford:
Westview Press, pp. 15-41. Lijphart, Arend (1984) Democracies:

Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty-One


Countries, New Haven: Yale University Press.
3

Anderson, Christopher L., and Christine A. Guillory (1997) Political


Institutions and Satisfaction with Democracy, American Political
Science Review, 91:1, pp. 66-81.

..

80

.




.
9

.

- :



.


:
.

.
19

22

.
2
Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

82

..


( )%91,2

. 1


%22,2 ( -
.)2


:
-1

-2


.




.

.




.

83

..







;;:2

()>-8





>;<2


>9

29,2

29,2

9 ,3

91,

99,

91,2

23

92,2

91,2

>:<2

;:?2

<8

9 ,1

92,3

22,3

21,3

:;29

>:92

<5

29,2

99,

22,9

22,1

93

=:>2

;929

5=9

Norris, Pippa (2004) Electoral Engineering.

84

..

..

85



. .



( .(jfedtke@tulane.edu
.

86

..

..

87


.
.

( )
.
19 29

. 9

88

..

( )

.
.

( ) .



( ) 331- 339
( .) 999

..

89

( )
(

) .


.


.
( 323 392 ) 391
.
319 : 31 329 321339
99. 992

91

..

" "

. :

. " "



.
. 3- 1
.21-2

..

90

.
.

332/ 332

331 3 3
.

.
( ) ( 21) :
" ".
. 3 3

2
( )
. 321

.
.

92

..

.2 :




(!) 19
-
.

( 999

!) .

991

..

93

) 992

. 993

()
.
.


( ) (
)

9

2 . 991

94

..

.
.

.
( )
( ) .


331 .
: .19

..

95

" "

( ) .

( )

( )

(
)

.

( ) (
) ( ) .

96

..

.3 :

.

( ) .
(

)
.

321
.

.
().

..

97

.
%99

. 999 .

"" % 9

"" % 9 % 9 % 2
""

( %92

)
""

.
99

.

98

..

. 9


" " . 922

(
) 2 22

.
.

( ) 22 - 211 ( ) 232- 223 (


:

) 999- 99 .

"" " "



. 992

.

..

99

)
(

) . " "

) .

.2


" " .
. 992

. .
.
.
2 ( ) 2 3- 2 9
.

011

..

)
.

.

" "
.

)
.
99 991
.

.4 :
:

..

010

(
) .


(
) 323 9

333


) .

( ) .
.


( 332 ).
- .

012

..

" "

" " ( )

.

.
""

.
.

.
.

..

013

999
.

"" : ( 1 = %29,

( =%22,

) ( 1 =%3,2)

( 92=%2,1) ( 9 =%2,) .

( 292 1 2) .

21 12 .
- 92

( ) .
-
.
( )

" "
.

014

..

) ( :


( )
( )
( )

( )2

( )2

.
" "

299 121 (=)%99


.
%29

.
.

..

015

9 9

. " "



.


.

%9

9 9

.

016

..

.5
:
" ...

....

"

.

. .
323
.
-

%23 : % 2, % 2,
%9,2

( 29 22 22

) .

( 19

) ( 1).

.6 :


. 9 9

..

017

.

( )

.
.

() .

.
.

018

..

).

.7 :

.
(

.
.

" " .
.

%99


..

019



( )

. .

( )

. ( )
.



.
.

. .

001

..

233

% 9

233 .

.

%2,
.

.%9,1

) .

( ) .


.

. .
9.

..

000

( )

.
.

.
2999193 2

.2

.8:


( )Dwyfor Meirionnydd .
(.)Isle of Wright
2 3 " : 993
1 . 3

".% 1

002

..

) .

.9 :

..

003

) .

(
) .

004

..

. 1
:

.
.

) .

""
/ .

..

005

"" .

( )

.

( )

006

..

.:

.
.

.
.


.
:

.

.

..

007

.
.

008

..

..

009





/
. 2

.

mazenhassan2@yahoo.com :

021

..

..

020

. ( )

(
)

( ).




.
ACE
Project Establishing the Rules of
1

ACE Electoral Knowledge Network, http://aceproject.org/indexen?set_language=en,. IDEA, IFES and UNDESA. Accessed on
21/4/2010.

022

..

the Game: Election Laws in Democracies

Massicotte Blais .Yoshinaka



12 .

- :
. :


) 9

9
(

.2

).

Massicotte, Louis et al.(2004) Establishing the Rules of the Game:


Election Laws in Democracies, London: Toronto University Press.
1

..

023


).

.2

.9

.1

.1

).


( ).

99
( 29

).

. :

.5 :
1 93 ( )%32

2 .
1
9

024

..

(
2) .
.8 : 22 ( )%11

1 9
.

.9 : 2

) 1 (

2 .

..

025

.: :

. 2

( )% 3 2 ( )

1 ( )

; . : 29
29

2 9 2

9

026

..

< . /

.
(2

( ) ().

= . : 2

( )

. (29
)%1



1 .

..

027

- :
. :

( 9


( 9

.2

.2

.9

).

).

1 ).

028

..

23 ).
:

( 1

).


( 1

.2

).

.9

.1

29

( 1 ).

( 1

).

..

029

( 1 ).
. :

.5 :
( )

.

(
9

29 29) .

( 1) 2 ( 2
) 2 9
9 .
) 9

(

()
9 ( )

031

..

. 22 ( )%19


.

22 ()
19 .

2

.8 :


.
(
)


. 9

%19
.

.9 :

..

030

(
) .

9 (
)

( ).

.:


.


.


( 2 2

032

..

) .

( 9 2
1
).

; . :

.
(

..

033

21 .
1

).

< . ( ) :

99 9
1999 )


( ) .
1

).

= . ( )

: 999
21

.
9
2 .

034

..

:
. :

.2

.2

(
( 9

).

).


. :

.5 :




.

..

035

. (
)
. 9 (
)
22 (
)

.
.8 : 2
(
2 ) .
(
) . 2 ( )
2
( ) .



.
.9 :
( 22)

. 2

(
) . 1

036

..


( )
.

:
. :

.
.

.2

(
).
:
:


( 2
).

. :

.5 : 2
.




.

.

..

037

( )
.
22
%13 .
.8 :
(
) ( )
( )
.
( )
().
.9 : 2


9 2
( )

1 ( 19).


().

038

..

:
. :

.2

.2
.9

.1

.1

2

.



.


( ( 2
).
)

( 2

).

..

.2

.3
. 9

039

(
).

. :

.5 :
( .)%3

999 .) 999

.8 :

041

..

( )%93

( ) . % 3 ( 2)
(

) .



( ) .

( %22

) .

.9 :
1
.

.: :

.

..

040

.
1 ()

,9

; . :

+%99 ) .

( ) (
) .

. 9
2
( )

042

..

29
2.
< . :


( )

) .




.

2
(

)

.

..

043

= . :


.


.


.
21

) .

044

..

> . :

(
) .
(

)

( )
.

..

045

(
)

( )


)%

2 ( 1

22.

? . :
.

9 ( )

046

..

331


332

999 99

.

.59 :


(
) . %19

..

047

%1
.

% 9 .

.55 :
% 1
( )

% 9 .


Vous aimerez peut-être aussi