ngWeh; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Jizj;jiyth;> jpUney;Ntyp jpUkz;lyk;> jpUney;Ntyp. ma;ah> nghUs; : Fwpj;J. -------------nrd;id rpl;b rptpy; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; njhlug;gl;l O.S.

No. 2898/2008 tof;fpd; jPh;g;ig vjph;j;J nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; njhlug;gl;l CRP No. 2527 to 2529/2008, CRP No. 2601 - 2602/2008 tof;fpy; ePjpaurh; khz;GkpF jkpo;thzd; mth;fs; cj;jutpd;gb nrd;id rpl;brptpy; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; cs;s jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; tof;F O.S. No. 2898/2008 I 6 khjj;jpw;Fs; Kbf;f Ntz;Lk;. mJtiu (CRP No. 2527 to 2529/2008)y; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s jpUkz;ly gp\g; n[aghy; Nltpl; kw;Wk; CRP No 2601, 2602/2008 tof;if gjpT nra;Js;s mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh];> NkYk; MfpNahh; gp\g; R1 mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh];> mtuth; n[aghy; jpU.Njtjh];> jpU.Ntjehafk;> jpU.utPe;jpud; Office Ntz;Lk; kw;Wk; nra;a rhh;y]; Bearers vd;W Mtzj;jpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s eph;thfk; ePjpkd;w jPh;g;GfSf;Fk; jpUkz;ly tpjpfSf;F khwhf Njh;jiy mwptpg;gJ

gp\g; vd mwptpj;Jf;nfhz;L jpUkz;ly

Elected

mUl;jpU.J.P.M.tre;jFkhh;

jpU.Njtjh];

gjtpfspypUe;J Nltpl; Xa;T

$wg;gl;Ls;sJ.(holding their respective posts as per Ex. R1 till the disposal of the suit). ngw;Wtpl;ljhYk;> R1 Mtzj;jpYs;s mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Jizj;jiyth;> jpU.Njtjh]; Ny nrayh; MfpNahh; CRP apYk; cs;sjhYk;> jpU.Ntjehafk;> jpU.utPe;jpud; rhh;y]; MfpNahh; rpdhl; cWg;gpdh;fshf $wg;gl;Ls;sjhYk; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; jpU.Njtjh]; kl;LNk Ny cgjiyth;> nrayh; nra;a kw;Wk; mUl;jpU.J.P.M.tre;jFkhh; jpU.B.n[ak; ,y;iy. nghd;idah FUj;Jtnrayh;> Mfpa ehy;th;

jpUkz;ly nghUshsUk;> Njh;jy; tprhuizf;FO fd;tPdUk; TDTA nrayUkhd eph;thfk; Ntz;Lk;. cj;juT nraw;FO kw;Wk; Jizf;FOf;fis $l;lNth> Njh;jiy elj;jNth

,JFwpj;J nrd;id tof;fpy;

cah;ePjpkd;w mspj;Js;s

kJiu btp\d; jPh;g;ghdJ tpsf;fk; jPh;g;G

ngQ;r; ePjpaurh;fs; khz;GkpF mspg;gjhf ePjpaurh; cs;sJ.

khz;GkpF uhkRg;gpukzpad; kw;Wk; khz;GkpF `hpgue;jhkd; mth;fs; W.A. No. 245.............../2010 jkpo;thzd; ,jd;gb.... 1. jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; tof;fpy; ,Wjp toq;fg;gltpy;iy. jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; nra;a ,ilf;fhy Vw;ghNl nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. 2. O.S. No. 2898/2008 jpUkz;ly Office Beares Njh;jy; rk;ge;jkhd tof;F kl;LNk. 4. gjpT nra;ag;glhj mikg;ghd jpUney;Ntyp jpUkz;ly eph;thfk; Fwpj;j O.S. No.2829/2008 tof;fpw;Fk; fk;ngdp rl;lg;gb gjpT nra;ag;gl;l TDTA mikg;gpw;Fk; njhlh;gpy;iy. 5. TDTA kl;LNk fy;tp epWtdq;fspd; Educational Agency. 6. nray;gl jpUkz;lyj;ij Ntz;ba eph;thfk; nra;a nfhLf;fg;gl;l ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb jpUkz;ly nrayh;fSf;F TDTA eph;thfj;jpYs;s mth;fs; cj;jutpw;F njspthd

Mrphpah;fspd; epakdj;ij uj;J nra;a mjpfhuk; nfhLj;jJ ahh;. 7. ,e;j cj;juT xU jw;fhg;G NflaNk jtpu epakdq;fis uj;J nra;a nfhLf;fg;gl;l ths; my;y vd;W $Wfpwhh;. ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; Fwpj;j O.S. No. 2898/2008 tof;fpy; ,Wjp jPh;g;G toq;fg;gltpy;iy. ,J jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; nra;Ak; Office Beares 1. cs;spl;l gw;wpa Njh;jy; kw;Wk; tof;F gpw ,J jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; gp\g; nra;a Njh;jy; toq;fg;gl;Ls;s xU ,ilf;fhy Vw;ghNl vd njspthff; $wg;gl;Ls;sJ. vdNt nraw;FO Jizf;FOf;fis elj;jNth> $l;lNth> jpUkz;ly Njh;jy;fis ve;jtpj cj;juTk;

mspf;fg;gltpy;iy. 2. ,uz;L mzpapdh; jhq;fNs Njh;e;njLf;fg;gl;l nraw;FO cWg;gpdh;fs; ehq;fNs eph;thfk; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W tof;F njhlh;e;Js;sdh;. ,e;j tof;if tprhhpj;J ,Wjp jPh;g;ig MW khjj;jpw;Fs; toq;fNtz;Lnkd nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;wk; cj;jutpl;l epiyapy; xU mzpapdiu $l;b nraw;FO> kw;Wk; Nky;epiyf;fy;tp epiytuf;FO cs;spl;l Jizf;FOf;fisAk; $l;b eph;thfk; elj;Jtjhf $WtJ ePjpkd;w mtkjpg;G kl;Lky;yhJ jz;lidf;Fhpa Fw;wkhFk;.

3. O.S. No. 2898/2008 tof;fpy; xU I.A. kPJ toq;fg;gl;l cj;juNt ,ilf;fhy eph;thfk; gw;wpa ePjpaurh; jkpo;thzd; mth;fspd; cj;juT. ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb ,e;j tof;F KbAk;tiu mUl;jpU.fpwp];Jjh]; Iauth;fshfpa ePq;fs; jpUkz;ly Jizj;jiytuhf kl;LNk nray;glKbAk;. gp\g; Njh;jy; elj;JtJ Fwpj;Jk; gp\g; Njh;jypy; Ntl;ghsuhf Nghl;bapl cs;sJ Fwpj;Jk; vt;tpj mDkjpiaAk; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Mfpa ePq;fs; ve;j ePjpkd;wj;jpYk; thq;ftpy;iy. cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; ahNuh xUth; gp\g; Njh;jy; Fwpj;J njhlh;e;j tof;if me;j egh; jpUk;gngw;Wnfhz;ljhy; me;j egUf;F fpilj;j cj;juT ,y;yhky; Ngha;tpLfpwJ. me;j cj;juT ve;j tifapYk; cq;fSf;F nghUe;jhJ. vdNt ePq;fs; cq;fis gp\g; vd;W mioj;Jf;nfhs;tJ ePjpkd;w mtkjpg;G MFk;. khtl;l chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; uh[h kw;Wk; Ntjkhzpf;fk; MfpNahh; njhlh;e;j O.S. No. 351/2008 tof;fpy; Ntjehafk; vd;gth; ehd; Njh;jy; %yk; Njh;e;njLf;fg;gl;l js;Sgb Nky;epiyf;fy;tp ,jid epiytuf;FO mtUk; nrayh; gp\g; vdNt n[aghy; vd;idAk; Nltpl;Lk; ,t;tof;fpy; fl;rp Nrh;f;f Ntz;Lnkd;W jhf;fy; nra;j I.A. No. 1351/2008 kD nra;ag;gl;lJ. vjph;j;J kJiucah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; CRP. No. 457- 458/2008y; jhf;fy; nra;jdh;. me;j kDit js;Sgb nra;j khz;GkpF ePjpaurh; NtZNfhghy; mth;fs; As far as the present case is concerned, since the order issuing direction in I.A. No. 739 of 2007 in O.S. No. 194 of 2007 dated 30.11.2007, passed by the learned Additional District Munsif, Nanguneri, has been set aside by this Court in C.R.P. No. 1764 of 2007 dated 14.12.2007, the subsequent election which has been conducted is only a non-est in the eye of law and (as a matter of prudence, one cannot brush aside an importent fact that the revision petitioner claims only to have been elected in pursuance of the order in I.A. No. 739 of 2007 in O.S. No. 194 of 2007) and the parties are relegated to original position as on the date of filing of the suit in O.S. No. 194 of 2007 and inasmuch as I.A. No. 629 of 2008 in O.S. No. 351 of 2008 filed under Order 1 Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been allowed by the trial court whereby, the Bishop has been permitted to represent all the members of the Diocese, this Court is of the considered view that the revision petitioner is not a proper and necessary party and moreover, the revision petitioner cannot be added as a party merely because he will be affected by the judgment

or orders of the Court incidentally and indeed the revision petitioner has no enforceble legal right. vd jPh;g;gspj;jhh;. ,e;j jPh;g;gpd;gb ehq;FNehp khtl;l chpikapay; ePjpkd;wk; O.S.No194/2008 tof;fpy; I.A. No. 739/2008 mspj;j epge;jidfSld; $ba cj;juit kJiu cah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l C.R.P. PD. NO. 1784 OF 2007 tof;fpd; jPh;g;G uj;J nra;jgpd; elj;jg;gl;l Njh;jy; nry;yhJ. vdNt ,uz;L mzpapdUk; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l mjhtJ 2k; fl;l Njh;jy; Kbe;j gpd; cs;s gioa epiyf;F nry;yNtz;Lk; vd $wpaJld; fPo; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mjhtJ ehq;FNehp khtl;l ngWeh; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Jizj;jiyth;> jpUney;Ntyp jpUkz;lyk;> jpUney;Ntyp. ma;ah> nghUs; : Fwpj;J. -------------nrd;id rpl;b rptpy; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; njhlug;gl;l O.S. No. 2898/2008 tof;fpd; jPh;g;ig vjph;j;J nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; njhlug;gl;l CRP No. 2527 to 2529/2008, CRP No. 2601 - 2602/2008 tof;fpy; ePjpaurh; khz;GkpF jkpo;thzd; mth;fs; cj;jutpd;gb nrd;id rpl;brptpy; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; cs;s jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; tof;F O.S. No. 2898/2008 I 6 khjj;jpw;Fs; Kbf;f Ntz;Lk;. mJtiu (CRP No. 2527 to 2529/2008)y; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s jpUkz;ly gp\g; n[aghy; Nltpl; kw;Wk; CRP No 2601, 2602/2008 tof;if gjpT nra;Js;s mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh];> NkYk; MfpNahh; R1 mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh];> mtuth; jpU.Njtjh];> jpU.Ntjehafk;> jpU.utPe;jpud; Office Ntz;Lk; kw;Wk; nra;a rhh;y]; Bearers vd;W Mtzj;jpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s eph;thfk; ePjpkd;w jPh;g;GfSf;Fk; jpUkz;ly tpjpfSf;F khwhf Njh;jiy mwptpg;gJ

......

gp\g; vd mwptpj;Jf;nfhz;L jpUkz;ly

Elected

mUl;jpU.J.P.M.tre;jFkhh;

jpU.Njtjh];

gjtpfspypUe;J

$wg;gl;Ls;sJ.(holding their respective posts as per Ex. R1 till the disposal of the suit).

gp\g;

n[aghy;

Nltpl;

Xa;T

ngw;Wtpl;ljhYk;>

R1

Mtzj;jpYs;s

mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Jizj;jiyth;> jpU.Njtjh]; Ny nrayh; MfpNahh; CRP apYk; cs;sjhYk;> jpU.Ntjehafk;> jpU.utPe;jpud; rhh;y]; MfpNahh; rpdhl; cWg;gpdh;fshf $wg;gl;Ls;sjhYk; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; jpU.Njtjh]; kl;LNk Ny cgjiyth;> nrayh; nra;a kw;Wk; mUl;jpU.J.P.M.tre;jFkhh; jpU.B.n[ak; ,y;iy. ,JFwpj;J nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;w kJiu btp\d; ngQ;r; ePjpaurh;fs; khz;GkpF uhkRg;gpukzpad; kw;Wk; khz;GkpF `hpgue;jhkd; mth;fs; W.A. No. 245.............../2010tof;fpy; mspj;Js;s jPh;g;ghdJ khz;GkpF ePjpaurh; jkpo;thzd; mth;fs; cj;jutpw;F njspthd tpsf;fk; mspg;gjhf cs;sJ. ,jd;gb.... 1. jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; tof;fpy; ,Wjp jPh;g;G toq;fg;gltpy;iy. jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; nra;a ,ilf;fhy Vw;ghNl nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. 2. O.S. No. 2898/2008 jpUkz;ly Office Beares Njh;jy; rk;ge;jkhd tof;F kl;LNk. 4. gjpT nra;ag;glhj mikg;ghd jpUney;Ntyp jpUkz;ly eph;thfk; Fwpj;j O.S. No.2829/2008 tof;fpw;Fk; fk;ngdp rl;lg;gb gjpT nra;ag;gl;l TDTA mikg;gpw;Fk; njhlh;gpy;iy. 5. TDTA kl;LNk fy;tp epWtdq;fspd; Educational Agency. 6. nray;gl jpUkz;lyj;ij Ntz;ba eph;thfk; nra;a nfhLf;fg;gl;l ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb jpUkz;ly nrayh;fSf;F TDTA eph;thfj;jpYs;s nghd;idah FUj;Jtnrayh;> Mfpa ehy;th;

jpUkz;ly nghUshsUk;> Njh;jy; tprhuizf;FO fd;tPdUk; TDTA nrayUkhd eph;thfk; Ntz;Lk;. cj;juT nraw;FO kw;Wk; Jizf;FOf;fis $l;lNth> Njh;jiy elj;jNth

Mrphpah;fspd; epakdj;ij uj;J nra;a mjpfhuk; nfhLj;jJ ahh;. 7. ,e;j cj;juT xU jw;fhg;G NflaNk jtpu epakdq;fis uj;J nra;a nfhLf;fg;gl;l ths; my;y vd;W $Wfpwhh;. ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; Fwpj;j O.S. No. 2898/2008 tof;fpy; ,Wjp jPh;g;G toq;fg;gltpy;iy. ,J jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; nra;Ak; Office Beares gw;wpa Njh;jy; tof;F ,J jpUkz;lyj;ij eph;thfk; nra;a toq;fg;gl;Ls;s xU ,ilf;fhy Vw;ghNl vd njspthff; $wg;gl;Ls;sJ. vdNt

1. cs;spl;l

nraw;FO

kw;Wk;

gpw

Jizf;FOf;fis elj;jNth>

$l;lNth>

gp\g;

Njh;jy;

jpUkz;ly

Njh;jy;fis

ve;jtpj

cj;juTk;

mspf;fg;gltpy;iy. 2. ,uz;L mzpapdh; jhq;fNs Njh;e;njLf;fg;gl;l nraw;FO cWg;gpdh;fs; ehq;fNs eph;thfk; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W tof;F njhlh;e;Js;sdh;. ,e;j tof;if tprhhpj;J ,Wjp jPh;g;ig MW khjj;jpw;Fs; toq;fNtz;Lnkd nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;wk; cj;jutpl;l epiyapy; xU mzpapdiu $l;b nraw;FO> kw;Wk; Nky;epiyf;fy;tp epiytuf;FO cs;spl;l Jizf;FOf;fisAk; $l;b eph;thfk; elj;Jtjhf $WtJ ePjpkd;w mtkjpg;G kl;Lky;yhJ jz;lidf;Fhpa Fw;wkhFk;. 3. O.S. No. 2898/2008 tof;fpy; xU I.A. kPJ toq;fg;gl;l cj;juNt ,ilf;fhy eph;thfk; gw;wpa ePjpaurh; jkpo;thzd; mth;fspd; cj;juT. ,e;j cj;jutpd;gb ,e;j tof;F KbAk;tiu mUl;jpU.fpwp];Jjh]; Iauth;fshfpa ePq;fs; jpUkz;ly Jizj;jiytuhf kl;LNk nray;glKbAk;. gp\g; Njh;jy; elj;JtJ Fwpj;Jk; gp\g; Njh;jypy; Ntl;ghsuhf Nghl;bapl cs;sJ Fwpj;Jk; vt;tpj mDkjpiaAk; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Mfpa ePq;fs; ve;jePjpkd;wj;jpYk; thq;ftpy;iy. cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; ahNuh xUth; gp\g; Njh;jy; Fwpj;J njhlh;e;j tof;if me;j egh; jpUk;gngw;Wnfhz;ljhy; me;j egUf;F fpilj;j cj;juT ,y;yhky; Ngha;tpLfpwJ. me;j cj;juT ve;j tifapYk; cq;fSf;F nghUe;jhJ. vdNt ePq;fs; cq;fis gp\g; vd;W mioj;Jf;nfhs;tJ ePjpkd;w mtkjpg;G MFk;. khtl;l chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; uh[h kw;Wk; Ntjkhzpf;fk; MfpNahh; njhlh;e;j O.S. No. 351/2008 tof;fpy; Ntjehafk; vd;gth; ehd; Njh;jy; %yk; Njh;e;njLf;fg;gl;l js;Sgb Nky;epiyf;fy;tp ,jid epiytuf;FO mtUk; nrayh; gp\g; vdNt n[aghy; vd;idAk; Nltpl;Lk; ,t;tof;fpy; fl;rp Nrh;f;f Ntz;Lnkd;W jhf;fy; nra;j I.A. No. 1351/2008 kD nra;ag;gl;lJ. vjph;j;J kJiucah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; CRP. No. 457- 458/2008y; jhf;fy; nra;jdh;. me;j kDit js;Sgb nra;j khz;GkpF ePjpaurh; NtZNfhghy; mth;fs; As far as the present case is concerned, since the order issuing direction in I.A. No. 739 of 2007 in O.S. No. 194 of 2007 dated 30.11.2007, passed by the learned Additional District Munsif, Nanguneri, has been set aside by this Court in C.R.P. No. 1764 of 2007 dated 14.12.2007, the subsequent election which has been conducted is only a non-est in the eye of law and (as a matter of prudence, one cannot brush aside an importent fact that

the revision petitioner claims only to have been elected in pursuance of the order in I.A. No. 739 of 2007 in O.S. No. 194 of 2007) and the parties are relegated to original position as on the date of filing of the suit in O.S. No. 194 of 2007 and inasmuch as I.A. No. 629 of 2008 in O.S. No. 351 of 2008 filed under Order 1 Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been allowed by the trial court whereby, the Bishop has been permitted to represent all the members of the Diocese, this Court is of the considered view that the revision petitioner is not a proper and necessary party and moreover, the revision petitioner cannot be added as a party merely because he will be affected by the judgment or orders of the Court incidentally and indeed the revision petitioner has no enforceble legal right. vd jPh;g;gspj;jhh;. ,e;j jPh;g;gpd;gb ehq;FNehp khtl;l chpikapay; ePjpkd;wk; O.S.No194/2008 tof;fpy; I.A. No. 739/2008 mspj;j epge;jidfSld; $ba cj;juit kJiu cah;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l C.R.P. PD. NO. 1784 OF 2007 tof;fpd; jPh;g;G uj;J nra;jgpd; elj;jg;gl;l Njh;jy; nry;yhJ. vdNt ,uz;L mzpapdUk; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l mjhtJ 2k; fl;l Njh;jy; Kbe;j gpd; cs;s gioa epiyf;F nry;yNtz;Lk; vd $wpaJld; fPo; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mjhtJ ehq;FNehp khtl;lchpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; cs;s O.S. No. 194/2007 tof;if Kbj;Jf;nfhs;sTk; cj;jutpl;Ls;shh;. ,ij vjph;jJ cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; Ntjehafk; jhf;fy; nra;j SLP No. ; 12305 and 12306/2009 kDit jpUk;g ngw;Wf;nfhz;lhh;. Mr. S. Rajappa, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner wishes to withdraw the Special Leave Petitions. Permission granted. The Special Leave Petitions are, accordingly, dismissed as withdrawn. Ntjehafk; kDtpy; We The only cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; nra;j kDit jpUk;g ngw;Wf;nfhz;l epiyapy; gp\g; jhf;fy; nra;j S.L.P. Nos. 17032 - 17033/2009 have heard learned appears to counsel appearing for the parties at length.

objection

be against

the observations made in para 29

of the order dated 15.4.2009 passed by the High Court in C.R.P. (PD) MD Nos. 457 and 458 of 2009 and M.P. (MD) No. 1 of 2009. We direct that the trial court shall decide the suit without being influenced in any manner by the aforesaid observations. With these directions, the Special Leave Petitions stand disposed of. ,jd;gb cah;ePjpkd;wk;

gj;jp

29y;

mspj;j

Observation

cWjp

nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

tof;if

fPo;

ePjpkd;wj;jpy; Kbj;Jf;nfhs;s Ntz;Lk; vd;W cj;jutplg;gl;Ls;sJ. jpUney;Ntyp khtl;l chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; gp\g; Njh;jiy vjph;jJ ; njhlug;gl;l O.S. No 543/2010 tof;fpy; ePq;fs; jhf;fy; nra;j I.A. No 1803/2009y; toq;fg;gl;l cj;jutpw;F vjpuhf nrd;id cah;ePjpkd;w kJiu fpisapy; jhf;fy; nra;j CRP No. 1201 of 2010 tof;fpy; ePjpaurh; khz;GkpF A. nry;tk; mth;fs; mspj;Js;s jPh;g;gpy; %d;whk;> ehd;fhk; fl;l jpUkz;ly Njh;jy;fs; nry;yhJ vd ePjpkd;w jPh;g;G tUk; mij njhlh;e;J jPh;g;gspj;Js;shh;. In O.S. No. 543 of 2009, the first relier (gp\g; Njh;jy; nry;yhJ) sought for is to declare the illegal and inoperative proceedings of the Diocesan Council on 18.05.2009 as void. Therefore, the first relief has been sought for so as to declare that the entire proceedings made on 18.05.2009 as void. The proceedings made on 18.05.2009 is only with regard to election. Therefore with regard to first relief, the present suit is legally maintainable The second relief (gp\g; gjtp Vw;G nry;yhJ) sought for in plaint is to declare that appointment of the first defendant as Bishop and also his consecration are illegal and also void. The second relief is based upon the first relief. If the first relief goes out, automatically the second relief will also be defeated ............ epiyapy; 18.05.2009y; ele;jjhf $wg;gLk; gp\g; Njh;jYk; elj;jg;gl;l Consecration epfo;Tk; nry;yhJ vd;W

The using software is free version, you can upgrade it to the upgrade version.http://www.allimagetool.com
,ij vjph;j;J jhq;fs; cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; nra;j SLP. Nos. 26393/2010 tof;fpy; ePjpaurh;fs; we do not find any reson to interfere with the well considered order passed by the High Court. The special leave petition is, accordingly, dismissed vd $wpAs;sJld; fPo; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; tof;if Kbj;Jf;nfhs;s

Ntz;Lk; vd jPh;g;gspj;Js;shh;. vdNt cq;fs; gjtp vd;Wk; fhypahfg; NghtJ cWjp. 3k; cs;sd. 4k; me;j fl;l Njh;jy;fs; cs;sd. Kbatpy;iy mitfs; tof;F vd 12 tof;Ffs; KbAk; fPo; ePjpkd;wq;fspy; epYitapy; tof;Ffspy; tprhuiz epiyapy; jpUkz;ly

VjhtnjhU

Kbtile;jhy;

Njh;jYk; gp\g; Njh;jYk; fhypahfptpLk;. Vw;fdNt cr;rePjpkd;wk; ,JFwpj;j jdJ jPh;g;ig Vw;fdNt $wptpl;ljhy; ,e;j jPh;g;gpd; kPJ ve;jtpj mg;gPYk; Nghf KbahJ. mjdhy;jhd; ,e;j 12 tof;FfSf;Fk; khtl;l ePjpkd;wj;jpy; jilAj;juT thq;fp ePjpkd;w jPh;g;G tuhky; vt;tsT fhyk; jho;jjKbANkh me;j ; mstpw;F tha;jh Nky; tha;jh thq;fp ePjpia nfhiynra;J tUfpwPh;fs;. NkYk; jPh;g;G te;jhYk; kWgbAk; cr;rePjpkd;wk; tiu mg;gPy; nry;Nthk; mJtiu gaKWj;jp ,e;j gp\g;ig xd;Wk;nra;aKbahJ $wp Mdhy; vd;W xU cq;fs; Mjuthsh;fs; kf;fis $wp fPo; cz;ikf;F khwhd tpsf;fj;ij FUkhh;> Mrphpah; kw;Wk;

tUfpd;wdh;.

cr;rePjpkd;wk;

jPh;g;igf;

ePjpkd;wj;jpy; tof;if Kbj;Jf;nfhs;s nrhd;d gpd;dh; mg;gPy; nry;y KbahJ. jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; tpjpfisf;$Wk; jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;lk; mj;jpahak; 1 M tpjp 10 : jpUkz;lyr; nraw;FO Fwpg;gpLk; fhyq;fspy; Nrfu kd;wj;jpw;Fk;> rigkd;wj;jpw;Fk;> jpUkz;lyg; ngUkd;wj;jpw;Fk; gpujpepjpfs; Njh;e;njLf;fg;gLthh;fs;. ,j;Njh;jy; rhjhuzkhf Ke;jpd Njh;jYf;Ff; Fiwe;jJ ,Ugj;J %d;W khjq;fSf;Fg; gpd;Dk;> ehw;gj;njhd;gJ khjq;fSf;F Nky; Nghfhky; elj;jg;gl Ntz;Lk;. mj;jpahak; 5 tpjp 16 : fhyhe;ju Njh;jy;fspd; Njjp : jpUkz;lyg; ngUkd;wj;jpw;Fk; Njjpfisj; khjq;fSf;F Nrfu kd;wj;jpw;Fk; nraw;FO fhyhe;ju Fwpg;gpl Njh;jy; eilngw rhjhuzkhf Ntz;Lk;. Ntz;ba ,uz;L ,e;j jpUkz;lyr; Ntz;Lk;.

Njh;jy;fSf;fpilapy; ,Ugj;J %d;W khjq;fSf;Ff; Fiwahky; ehw;gj;J VO Nkw;glhkYk; ,Uf;Fk;gb xOq;F nra;a tpjpfspd;gb Diocesan Executive Committee kl;LNk Njh;jy; gw;wpa mwptpg;ig ntspapl KbAk;. fle;j 2007 Mk; Mz;L mwptpf;fg;gl;l Njh;jy; fhy xOq;fpy; ,Wjp gf;fj;jpy;> gp\g;> Jizj;jiyth;> FUj;Jt nrayh;> kf;fs; nrayh;> nghUshsh; vd 5 NgUk; ifnaOj;jpl;bUg;ghh;. ,JNt 4 Mz;LfSf;F xU Kiw

ntspaplg;gLk;

Njh;jy;

fhy

xOq;fpy;

filgpbf;fg;gl;LtUk;

xOq;FKiw.

Vndd;why; ,th;fs; kl;LNk nraw;FOtpw;F nghWg;ghsh;fs;. Mdhy; 2011 Mk; Mz;L Njh;jy; Fwpj;J ntspaplg;gl;Ls;s Njh;jy; fhy xOq;fpy; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Njh;jy; tprhuizf;FO jiyth;> jpU.nry;tpd; n[auh[; nghUshsh; kw;Wk; fd;tPdh; Njh;jy; tprhuizf;FO vd;W Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sNj. ,J jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;lj;jpw;F %uzhdJ. jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;l tpjp 1.B General Rule 4 (m) d;gb jpUkz;lyg; nghUkd;wj;jpd; xt;nthU eilKiw $l;lj;jpYk; jpUkz;lyj;jpy; Vw;gLk; Njh;jy; jfuhWfisj; jPh;jJitf;f ; xU tprhuizf;FO mikf;fg;gLk;. NguhaNu tprhuizf; FOtpd; jiytuhf ,Ug;ghh;. jpUkz;lyg; nghUshsh; tprhuizf; FOtpd; $l;Lduhf ,Ug;ghh;. ,jd; %yk; jpUkz;lyj;jpy; ePjpkd;w cj;juTg;gb nraw;FO ,y;iy vd;gJ njspthfpwJ. nraw;FO kl;LNk Njh;jy; Fwpj;J mwptpg;ig ntspapl KbAk;. vdNt Njh;jy; mwptpg;G nry;yhJ. Njh;jy; gpur;ridfis tprhhpf;Fk; Njh;jy; tprhuizf;FOtpd; jiyth; mjpYk; nraw;FO kw;Wk; fd;tPdh; Njh;jy; gw;wpa ve;j mwptpg;igAk; ntspapl KbahJ. epakpf;fg;gl;l jpU.nry;tpd; n[auh[; vd;gtUk; jtwhd egh;fs;.

ePjpkd;w jPh;g;GfSf;F khwhf gp\g; vd $wpf;nfhs;Sk; ePq;fSk;> cq;fshy; kl;LNk Njh;jy; Njjpfs; Fwpj;j mwptpg;ig ntspapl KbAk;. vdNt ePq;fs; elj;Jtjhf mwptpj;Js;s jpUkz;ly Njh;jy; rl;lg;gb nry;yhJ. jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;lq;fs; mj;jpahak; 1 M nghJtpjpfs; tpjp 5d;gb ,k; %yr;rl;lj;jpYs;s VjhtJ xU tpjpapd; rhpahd nghUs;gw;wp jfuhW Vw;gLkhapd;> Kbthd jPh;g;Gf;$w NguhaUf;F mjpfhuk; cz;L. mtUila jPh;g;Gf;F Nky; vt;tpj Nky; KiwaPl;L chpikAk; fpilahJ ,jd;gb %yr;rl;l tpjpfs; Fwpj;J VjhtJ tpsf;fk; Njitg;gl;lhy; gp\g; nfhLf;Fk; tpsf;fk; ,WjpahdJ vd Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ. Mdhy; jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;l tpjpfSf;F khwhf ,e;j tpjp gw;wpa njspT ,y;yhj mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Mfpa ePq;fs; CSI ney;iy jpUkz;lyj; mjpy; Njh;jy;fs; 2011 rpy Kf;fpa mwptpg;Gfs; vd Mfpa ntspapl;Ls;s cq;fspd; Kw;wpYk; mwptpg;Gfs; ,Jtiu jpUkz;ly Njh;jy;fspy; ,y;yhj eilKiw kl;Lky;yhJ Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sit mwptpg;Gfs;. mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; ,itfs; jpUkz;ly jd;dpr;irahd %yr;rl;lj;jpw;F

tpNuhjkhdit> jtwhdit> jd;dpr;irahdit. jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;l tpjpfspy; khWjy; nra;a fPo;f;fz;l eilKiwfis filg;gpbf;f Ntz;Lk;.

mj;jpahak; 1 M tpjp 8 : ,e;j %yr; rl;lq;fspd; mbg;gil tpjpfis khw;w Ntz;Lkhdhy;> jpUkz;lyg; ngUkd;wj;jpd; njhlh;e;Njh;r;rpahd ,uz;L $l;lq;fspy;> xt;nthU $l;lj;jpYk; tUif je;J thf;fspg;gth;fspy; %d;wpy; ,uz;L gq;F rk;kjj;jpd; Nghpy; khw;wyhk;. ,e;j ,uz;L $l;lq;fSf;fpilapy; Fiwe;j msT gjpndhU khjq;fs; ,ilntspapUf;fNtz;Lk;. Jizr;rl;lq;fNsh xNu $l;lj;jpy; ngUk;ghNyhh; rk;kjj;jpd; Nghpy; khw;wg;glyhk;. Mdhy; ,k;khWjy; gw;wp cWg;gpdh; midtUf;Fk; (15) gjpide;J ehl;fSf;F Kd;Ng mwptpg;G mDg;gp ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; Njh;jy; tpjpfs; Jiztpjpfs;. ,itfis rhjhuz nk[hhpl;bapy; xNu thrpg;gpy; epiwNtw;wyhk;. mt;thW Kiwg;gb jpUj;jq;fs; nra;ahky; mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; Mfpa ePq;fs; nray;. cjhuzkhf mwpf;ifapd; mjpfhhpia vLg;ghh; : ,tuJ mwptpg;Gfs; gf;fk; 3> jtWk; 27y; Nguhah; epakpj;Js;s Njh;jy; Njh;jy; ,y;yhj Kuzhf ahiu mtNu ghh;itahsh; NeubahfNth my;yJ ufrpakhfNth tprhuiz nra;J nfhLf;Fk; mbg;gilapy; Njh;jy; vd;W elj;Jk; eLepiyik Nrfuj;jiyth;> Nguhah; %yr;rl;lj;jpy; mt;thW tpjpNa nghWg;gpypUe;J tpjp tpLtpj;J eltbf;if mwptpj;Js;sJ. jpUkz;lyj;ijAk;> jpUkz;ly kf;fisAk; Vkhw;Wk;

mwptpj;Js;shh;. epakpf;f ve;j

jpUkz;ly $WfpwJ. Iauth;fs;

ghh;itahsh;fis ,jd;gb Njh;jiy epakpj;J elj;j jdf;F

epiyapy; tpjpfs; Fwpj;j re;Njfk; vo vd;d mbg;gil cs;sJ. mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; KbahJ. Ntz;ba mtUf;F %yr;rl;lj;jpw;F epakpj;Js;s ,thpd; Vn[z;Lfs; ahiug;gw;wp mwpf;if nfhLg;ghh;fNsh mth;fs; gjpyhf mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; epidf;fpwhNuh egh;fis Njh;e;njLf;f

Njh;e;njLf;fg;gLthh;. Vw;fdNt fle;j 2007 Mk; mz;L Njh;jy; Fwpj;j Vuhskhd tof;Ffs; Kd;rPg; ePjpkd;wk; Kjy; cr;rePjpkd;wk; tiu njhlug;gl;L ,d;Dk; tprhuizapy; ,Ue;J tUfpd;wd. jpUkz;ly cah;ePjpkd;wKk; Njh;jy; kw;Wk; gp\g; njspthd Njh;jy; KiwNfLfs; Fwpj;J fPo; cr;rePjpkd;wKk; cj;juTfis gpwg;gpj;J

ePjpkd;wq;fspYs;s mry; tof;Ffis Kbj;Jf;nfhs;s cj;jutpl;Ls;sJ. me;j tof;Ffspd; ,Wjp jPh;g;G ntspte;jhy; 2007 Mk; Mz;L Njh;jYk;> gp\g; Njh;jYk; nry;yhjjhfptpLk; Mfpa vd;gjhy; tha;jhNky; tha;jh ,e;j thq;fptUk; Njh;jiy mUl;jpU.J.J.fpwp];Jjh]; elj;JtJ Vd;? ePq;fs; mtru mtrukhf

ePjpkd;w cj;juTfSf;F khwhf kWgbAk; Njh;jy; ele;J ,k;KiwAk; E}w;Wf;fzf;fpy; Kbj;Jtplyhk; tof;Ffs; vd;W gjpthfp KbT ePjpkd;w njhptjw;Fs; jPh;g;Gf;F cq;fs; khwhf gjtpia jpUkz;ly epidj;J

%yr;rl;lj;jpw;F khwhf nray;gl;LtUfpwPh;fs;. Kjd;ik ghh;itahsh;> ghh;itahsh;fs; vd VO Ngiu epakpj;Js;sPh;fs;. Kjd;ik ghh;itahsh; vd epakpj;Js;s jpU.,uh.N[hdj;jhd; Qhidah mth;fs; Xa;Tngw;w khtl;l mkh;T ePjpgjp ,th; jdJ Xa;T Neuq;fis cq;fsJ ,y;yj;jpy; fopf;Fk; msT cq;fSf;F neUf;fkhdth;. cq;fsJ MNyhrfuhfTk; nray;gl;L tUgth;. ,e;j 7 Ngh; epakdKk; %yr;rl;lj;jpw;F tpNuhjkhdJ. 14.06.2011 nrt;tha; fpoik 6 kzpf;F ngy; gs;sp Mbl;Nlhpaj;jpy; ngy; epWtdq;fspd; Kjyhsp jpU.Fzrpq; nry;yj;Jiu vd;gth; xU n[gf;$Liff;F Vw;ghL nra;jpUe;jhh;. ek;gp mth; jhd; jpUkz;ly Copaj;jpy; ,e;j <Lglyhk; vd;W fh;jjUf;Fs; ; mjhtJ midtiuAk; Njh;jypy; mioj;jpUe;jhh;. gFjpfspYk; n[gf;$Lifapy; egh;fshf

fye;Jnfhs;s jpUkz;lyj;jpd; gy gFjpfspYk; cs;s Kf;fpa gpuKfh;fis jpUkz;ly xt;nthU Kf;fpakhd nray;glf;$ba nraw;FO cWg;gpdh;fs;> DC cWg;gpdh;fs; kw;Wk; trjp gilj;j egh;fis ePq;fNs njhiyNgrapy; njhlh;Gnfhz;L ,e;j $l;lj;jpw;F tUif ju mioj;jh;fs;. P NkYk; cq;fsJ tyJfukhfTk; ,lJfukhfTk; nray;glf;$ba ghisaq;Nfhl;il kpypl;lhp iyd; Mya FUthdth; mUl;jpU.fpg;\d;> rhe;jpefh; Nrfu FUthdth; mUl;jpU. rhKNty;> mUl;jpU.Ntjmd;G> mUl;jpU.n[gf;Fkhh;> mUl;jpU.fpq;];yp> mUl;jpU.Vrh re;jpuFkhh;> mUl;jpU.tre;jFkhh; (FUj;Jtnrayh;)> mUl;jpU.Ntjehafk; (Nkyhsh;)> mUl;jpU.N[f;fg; nry;iyah> mUl;jpU.Rthkpjh]; (Nkyhsh;)> mUl;jpU.ghf;fpaehjd;> mUl;jpU.];Bgd; yady;> mUl;jpU.rpk;Nrhd; rpfhkzp> mUl;jpU.nfd;db cs;spl;l Vwj;jho 30 FUthdth;fs; tiu ,e;j $l;lj;jpy; fye;Jnfhz;Ls;sdh;. jpUkz;ly Njh;jiy ePjpahfTk; Neh;ikahfTk; ve;j mzpf;Fk; rhjfkpd;wp elj;JNtd; vd $wptUk; ePq;fs; %d;whtJ mzp (mjhtJ gp\g; mzp) vd;w xd;iw cUthf;fp mjw;F jpU.Fzrpq; nry;yj;Jiu ,e;j vd;gtiu Ny nrayh; Vw;ghL Ntl;ghsuhf epWj;j nts;Nshl;lkhf n[gf;$Lifia

nra;jpUf;fpwPh;fs; vd;W jpUkz;ly kf;fs; midtUk; NgRk; mstpw;F ePq;fSk; cq;fs; MjuT FUthdth;fSk; xU Njhw;wj;ij cUthf;fp cs;sPh;fs;.

jpUkz;lyj;jpy; ahuhtnjhU njhopyjpgiu Ny nrayuhf;fp mtiu jdJ njhopiy ghh;f;f itj;Jtpl;L jpUkz;lyj;ij KOtJkhf cq;fs; fl;Lg;gl;bd; fPo; nfhz;Ltuyhk; vd ePq;fs; fdT fz;LtUfpwPh;fs;. njhopyjpgh; jpU.Fzrpq; nry;yj;Jiu mth;fs; flTSila Copaj;jpy; <LglNghtJ Fwpj;J cq;fSf;Fk; cq;fs; FUthdth;fSf;Fk; ,t;tsT mf;fiw Vd;? vd;W jpUr;rig kf;fs; Nfl;fpwhh;fs;. rprhpd; kidtp re;Njfj;jpw;F mg;ghw;gl;ltshf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w $w;wpd;gb ePq;fs; xU Ntis Njh;jypy; epakd cWg;gpduhf jpU.Fzrpq; mth;fis epakpj;jhy; ,e;j Fw;wr;rhl;Lfs; midj;Jk; cz;ikahfptpLk; (gp\g; kl;LNk epakdk; nra;a KbAk; Jizj;jiyth; mij nra;a KbahJ) Vw;fdNt Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s ePjpkd;w jPh;g;GfisAk;> jpUkz;ly %yr;rl;lq;fisAk; kPwpaePq;fs; ,e;j xU tpjpia fhw;wpy; gwf;ftpLtJ fbdkhd nray; my;y. cq;fs; MjuT FUkhh; mth;fs; gzpahw;Wk; Nrfuq;fspy; Nghl;bapy;yhky; DC cWg;gpdh;fis Njh;e;njLg;Nghk; tUfpd;wdh;. Njh;jy; vd gy topfspy; Kiwg;gb Nrfu kf;fis FUkhh; fl;lhag;gLj;jp Njh;jypy; cq;fSf;F eph;ge;jpj;J [dehaf DC eilngwNtz;ba Nrh;g;gjw;fhf

eLepiyNahL Mjuthf

mjpfhhpfshf mzpf;F

nray;glNtz;ba cWg;gpdh;fis

%d;whtJ

,j;jifa jtwhd nray;fspy; <Lgl;L tUfpd;wdh;. Njh;jypy; ntw;wpngWk; mzp vJntd;W cq;fs; MjuT FUkhh;fSf;F njhpAkh? ,th;fs; nray;gLtjw;F khwhf xU mzp ntw;wp ngw;Wtpl;lhy; ,th;fs; vd;d nra;thh;fs;. cldbahf ,e;j jtwhd nray;fspy; <LgLk; FUthdth;fs; jpUe;jNtz;Lk;. vdNt cah;ePjpkd;w> cr;rePjpkd;w cj;juTfSf;Fk;> jpUkz;ly $wpf;nfhz;L vdf;F tpjpfSf;Fk; eilKiwfSf;Fk; khwhf cq;fis gp\g; vd;W mwptpf;fg;gl;Ls;s cldbahf epWj;j Ntz;Lk;. ,J Fwpj;J 7

Kiwaw;w Njh;jy; mwptpg;ig jpUk;gg; ngWtJld; Njh;jiy ehl;fSf;Fs;

njhptpf;fhtpl;lhy; cq;fs; kPJ ePjpkd;w mtkjpg;G> jpUr;rig kf;fs; kw;Wk; rKjhaj;ij Nkhrbahf Vkhw;wp tUtJ Fwpj;J ePjpkd;w eltbf;if vLg;Ngd; vd njhptpj;Jf;nfhs;fpNwd;. ed;wp> jq;fs; cz;ikAs;s>

m. Vh;d];l; ghyrpq;
M.A.(Tam)., M.A.(Pol.Sci)., M.A.(Eco)., M.A.(JMC).,M.A.(Pub.Ad.)., M.A.(Pop.St.)., M.A.(His.)., M.A.(Soc)., M.Ed., M.Phil.

Secretary
T.D.T.A. Employees Welfare Assocation Reg. No : 23/2008. Palayamkottai - 627 002.