1

.

.


""
.
.
""
. "
" ""

" " " ".
.

" " .
.
.
!


.

.

.

 "
" .
.
.
. ""
.
"" .

.

.
.

.

.
.


.
.
1 " / 
# *+ %,

' & %#$" 

 

 
 

 


" 2" 
5" 
898 6
&:'  "
" DE F&G 1022 6 C'
 A
/
A / ? 2
+/
 I+/" + # #$" .
M /


' K+ $ K+ $  * & . %



"" .

": ".

. . " "
.
" ":"Sun Zi
" .
"
" . " " "
".
""
"" . ":
".
.

. ":
") . .(Lewal "
" " :

 " ) .
1814(.

":

" ) . ""
.(1955
.
""
.""

.
" " ":
".
:
.
"." " "

.
.
. Clausewitz " "
" : " 1
1815 .
Raymond ARON, Penser la guerre, Clausewitz , tom I, lge europen, Paris, Gallimard 1976, P.31.

 :
.
Puysgur
": " . 2
""
" " "
.


".3
Ernst Jnger
. . ) (
) (
.

. ": Schaumburg -Lippe
.

" .4
. .
": Julien Freund
" " 5
".6

Marchal de PUYSEGUR, Art de la guerre par principes et par rgles , Paris, chez C.A. Jombert
1748 ?P.26.
3
Mmoires de M. le marquis de Feuquire, London, chez Pierre Dunoyer 1736 ? PP. VII-VIII.
4
Comte de Schaumburg-Lippe, schriften und Brief P.158.
5
Julien FREUD, Que veut dire :prendre une dcision ? , Nouvelle cole, 41,automne 1984 ,P.54.
6
Herv coutau BEGARIE, Trait de stratgie , conomica, paris, 1999, PP.36-37.



/ . strategie
strategija . strategi ) (stratos agein
" " . stratos
agein strategos " " strateg
strategikos strategika
. 1
.
. stratos
.
. stratos
:
) (gia ) (agein .
.
"" " ".
1

L.Wheeler, stratagem and the vocabulary of military trickery , Leyde, Brill, Mnemosyne supplement 108,
1988, P. 3.

 strategia strategema
.stratagme ) De Puysgur ( ":
:
" ) . Herv coutau Bgarie ( . ) stratagme
( "" .

.

. stratge "" " " .
.


.

.
.
strategema
Xnophon Clment
Alexandrie . strategika
.Demetrois de Phalre

10

 . "" " " .

strategema
strategika "" .
strategeo Onosander " " .
" " ) :
( . " " strategema
)dolus
.(sollertia ,ars ,astutia,
) (scientia rie militaris
.

strategos stratge "
" . Syrianos
Peri strategikes .

" " . "
" Taktika .

.
Zun zi ) ( bing-fa
.
""
Zun zi .
11

 ":

.
" .1

)
(
.

. Mathey
stratge Oceana Harrington 1656
.strategns strategy 1688
Geography Morden
1810 Military Dictionary James
strategically .
Francesco Patrizi " "Paralleli militari
1594 ":
."...
.
Jean de Nassau :
. strategetica,tactica,poliorcetica
.

. 1721 Trvoux
1

- Guang Zi, les sept mthodes du gouvernement , cit dans Xu Zhen Zhou ( lArt de la politique chez
lgistes chinois , Paris, Economica 1995, P.229.

12

" " .
" " .
Trvoux ": stratagme
" . Du Cange strategus,
. straticus, stratigus, stratigotus Estienne strategus
Moreri .

13

-1 :

.
taxinomie
-.

14

 - trilogie
:
.

taktika . strategia Dietrich von Bulow :

.
.
:
:
.
- :

Clausewitz :
. :

.
.

1866

) Moltke ( . :

. .
.
Lewel

. paradigme
. Joffre
. 1915
15

 Ludendorf
. )(

:
.
) ( ) (.
Poirier

.
.
: 1830 - 1820
.

Marmont
Clausewitz .

.
.
.
.
) - Ruhle Von Lilienstern

(Clausewitz

:
.

action . acte

Blume .
16

 . Lewel

Bonnal : .
Grouard Castex

:
.
.... .
.
Castex .

:

.
logistique .
:
.

. Joly de Maizeroy

Jean de Vignay .
- 1310 1320 . mestres darmes
: - tactice - . 1570
Paul Hay du Chtelet . 1968
Furetire .1690 . 1766

Mesnil Durand : 1770

..
.

17

 Clausewitz .
. Antoine
Grouard : - - 1895

:
) (


.
: .
.
Malplaquet
. 1709 Jean Colin -
-Transformations de la guerre

.
.
Stalingrad Bir-Hakeim . Budapest


18






V%




Logistique :
. Guibert
.
logisteuo . xviii
) ( .Trvoux Jomini

.
) (
) ( .
.

. James A. Huston -
- The sinews of war

: logistics .
19

 : - -
.
: Clausewitz
Nockern de Schorn xviii
) (

:

.
- -
1870 Lewel

: Organisation rationnelle
12 .
. Partie organique
Giovani Sechi
organisation .
.

: :
- :

20

 -
.

.1813
Culmann
.
.
.
.
.

.
.


.

industrialisation

.
. :
.

- :

21

 : .
. Herbert Rosinski
.
- 1

.
.

Liddell Hart strategy

.
.

.
.

1959 1984

.
. Jacques Laurent
outil pour la pense militaire sovitique

.

.

22

 - 2
.
.
.1
:
:

.
:
.

: opratique art opratif
.
Richardo Burguete -
- -
.
.
:
.

- 1#$ !
 
 
    '  %
  : Globale ,-
*+  4 0 012 

?6  2=#;  :* % 8  %9  
6  % 022 A# #@9 9  ; *
 E
#G  % 012 022  # 
  .
. 1995 , le Glossaire interarmes

23



. )

( Alexandre Svechin :
.
.1

)
.(... :
.
1982

: 2020 vision : A Navy for the 21st Century

.
.
Beaufre - - .


. Poitier
- - . opratique
Francart Objectif 21 ) 2 (1996

9 1?M  #$ ; Jocob W. Kipp ; K The Nature of Operations of Modern V. K. Triandafillov
# Armies. 1994

24

 .
.

25

 
 



 

#$
 



  %

  

;9 %


=   

 RQ2
  %%

6  

9  



  


...
.

26


.

1. Lewal Iung ":

".

"

" 3 . :
.

. :
.
) (.
) (.
) (.
. Poirier
":
".

.
1

- Gnral LEWAL, Etude de guerre. Tactique de mobilisation. Tactique de combat , Paris, Librairie
militaire Dumaine, 1875, pp. 32-33.
2

 I
# X- Gnral IUNG, Stratgie, tactique et politique , .18 F&W
3
- Jacques LAURENT, Un outil pour la pense militaire sovitique . p. 87.
4
- Lucien POIRIER, les Voix de la stratgie .

27

 .


.
) (
.
.
. " "Sun Bin
" :
.
.
".

.

. " "
""
.
.Herv Coutau Bgarie

Blow Jomini
. . ":Jomini

. 3"..

1 
"Le Trait militaire " Sun BIN I

# X.87 F&W
2
 I
# X.132 F&W
3 /" " Henri Antoine JOMINI&
E 62F"
 % &
 Y.80 F&W

28

 paroxystique :
.Leipzig

Antoine Grouard " " . "
" " "
.

Iung

": . .
. " .2
.

Foertsch .

1 " Antoine GROURAD#$" "

 % &
 Y.18 F&W
2 " Gnral IUNG#" V"
% &
 " #
# I
# X.305 F&W
3 W  "The art of Moderne Warfare " Herman Foertsch : 1940 Veritas Press .20 F&W

29

30

.
.
:

.
.
.
Csar Thucydide .Tacite Turenne
.
:
(Verlorene Siege ) Von Manstein 1955 1958
"" Rommel .

.
.

31

 .
.
" " ) (
" " ) ( " " ) ("
") ( . :


.

.

.

.

.

" " .
.



. Grard
Chaliand " " ) lAnthologie mondiale de la
3 .(stratgie

1 \ 62 " Jean Pierre Bois :9% 2 W/F
 % &
 "D 1997 Y Herv COUTAU
M
"#$" "
I
# X.144 F&W
2 \ Jean Pierre Bois : X.I
%
3 G  
 6 
 Laffont.1990 Y

32

 .
) 2000 (

.

": Herv Coutau

" .
.

""
.
"" .
.
.
.

.
.
1 Herv Coutau
) .(146 Everett L. Wheeler

. " :

33


".

Royaumes Combattants
.Ploponnse .
Hoplomachoi
Sun Zi .Sun Bin
2
.

.

.
3
.
.

.
4 .
.

.

1 6 "The Origins of Military Theory in Ancient Greece and China " Everett WHEELER +%/ 

+] %/ /
 5 1980 ^#.75 F&W

34


.
5 "" .

. .
.
" "
" " .rationalisation

.

.
.
saint
Bonaventure saint Thomas dAquin .
.
:

Herv Coutau ). .(150
.
1 .
.
.

35

 1. " " "Hsn Lao Zi, "Kuan

.Mo Zi

Sun Zi .
.
: " "
.
Sun Zi Sun Bin .
" " .Song
1972
" " . .
.
.
.
Sun Zi . Cao
Cao Han Li Quan
Tang He Yanshi Zhang Yu
.Song Royaumes Combattants
:
""
.
Shen Zong " "
Herv Coutau ):
(156
1 "  b/
# a+ 2*  2 % G ?/

E 6W WF 4000 6
c

" *E] 8

.1911
2 
A: " de
2
h "h G
 2 Y
/ " 


6 "h
Flammarion .1981

36

 Wu Zi Bingfa
.
Sima Fa "
" .
.
Wei Liao Zi
.
San le " " Huang Shegong
.
Tai Gong Liutao " " Taigong
.
" Tang Li Wendui Tang Taizong "Li Weigong
.

.
.

.
.
Amyot
" "

.1779
Sun Zi 1860 .1889
37


Calthorpe .1
19501957 .1950
.
2 .
.


.
.

""

) . 57
(.
Ene .
.
. Ene .
Asclpiodote .
Alphonse Dain " " 326 ":
Asclpiodote
".
Onesandros
. Elien
""
1 \ " Chinese Ways in Warfare "Frank A. Kierman and John K.Fairbank :

/



/
2.1974
2 " Flavius Vgce& 6%/".1998 Ulysse Bordeaux % &


38

 .
. Xnophon .1Thucydide
Thucydide " "Ploponnse
. Xnophon
" "
.
.
" " Reichel ":
" .2

. ":Polybe
" .3
.
.
Caton " "De Re militari . Polybe
" "Taktika .
Frontinus " " .
Arrien " "
.4

Brian

":Campbell

1 "Xnophon ,
#" " +
 M. Bizos and E. Delebecque 
 Y


/ & 1971 %.1978
2 "Daniel REICHEL
"
W  m%% l% 

k 
1984 k.38 F&W
3 War and Imperialism in Republican Rome "William V. HARRIS 327 6
F&W* 
370

/&%
.1985 Clarendon Presse
4 " "The Ars Tactica of Arrian " P .A . STADTER  6 nG +G .1987 .Classical Philology 6

39


".1

.
) Alexandrine
( .
.

.Tacite
.

.

.
.
Syrianos
Constantin Polyen
.Syrianos
.Syrianos

. " "
.

3 /.
1 G "Teach Yourself to Be a General " Brian CAMPBELL " &FG 2
# 

 " 1987.22 F&W
2 \E "Pierre LAEDRICH : 
$o #"

$
 

 

2
G % &
"Tacite 2

6 Y  Economica #$" .2001
3 \.1990 "The Military Compendium of Syrianus Magister "Constantine ZUCKERMAN :
4 \The Hellenic Studies Brookline "Some Thoughts on Byzantine Strategy "Walter E. KAEGI :
.1983Lecture

40

 .
.
) (
.

":
.
" ). Grard Chaliand "
" .(499

" " " ")
( .
.1

" " " "
" " .

). " "
484 486 519 .(522
.
.
.
") "Libro de la Guerra ( 1420

1 \Ibn al-Manqali and Leo VI : New Evidence on Arabo-Byzantine Ship " Vassilios CHRISTIDES :
.1995 LVI Byzantino-Slavica "Construction and Naval Warfare

41

 Vellena ") "le Tratado de la PERFECCIN del triunfo militar

( 1459 .Alfonso Hernandez
Robert de Balsac " "
1502 " "

Braud

Stuart ") "Kriegsbuch ( Philippe von Seldeneck

. " "Semideus liber tertius de re militari
1438 Catone Secco " "De Re militari Roberto Valturio
.

: .
" Larte della
) "Guerra ( .
"" "
" .2 " " ":
.
1546 1536 1560
1623 .3"1610 .1839
:
:
: : .
"" " "
.

1 \ 
"Philippe CONTAMINE : X
X

G
 pF
G % &
 "m 
1997K  
c/ 114
50 F&W Y& :
M
"' " F 2 W/
 % &
 "r# Y X
e

1980
% & /
F&W 356 357
"Ren Quatrefages :
M& %/   9" *+ C8sF  2 W/ F
" c 1990

#K

c.215 F&W
2 \ :+2

" Flix GILBERT:A 62F" 6
+/
"Edward Mead EALE#$" " K 
.( % &
) .23 F&W
3 X I
% 30 F&W .31

42

 .
" "
.
" "
.
" " .1
John Smythe " "
1590 Roger Ascham Matthew Sutcliffe "

The Practice,

"Proceedings and Laws of Arms .1593

:
Roger William (A Briefe Discourse of Warre, 1590).
Humphrey Barwick (A Briefe Discours, concerning the force and Effect of
all manual Weapons of Fire, 1594).
Thomas Smith ( The Art of Gunnery, 1600).
Robert Barret ( The Theorike and Practike of Moderne Warres, 1598).

.

" " 1502

1 \" :Claude GAIER :

/ l
 2d 
G "*e#  2
+%

1995 De Boeck / F&W
.331

43

 1510
" " . "
" Rmy Rousseau 1548
.
.

. "" Clves Flammand
Habsbourg 1508 " 1516
" . Reinhard Solm
1544 1549 L. Fronsberger "
) "Fnff Bcher von Kriegsregiment und Ordnung
( 1554 1556 .
Lazarus von Schwendi
) Kriegsdiskurs
( 1571 1577 .


.

.
44


.1 "" ) mercantilisme
(

.2
" " "" .1576
Mendoza ":
"cu ".
.

1 
Philippe CONTAMINE I
# X.364 F&W
2 \ " Edmond SILBERNER :F 2&
WA 2d 
%  d G % &
" 6

c 2

Y  .1939Sirey

45

 .

.
Maurice Nassau .

.
Antonio Espino Lopez
": ". 1
.
" "
/ .2
Johan Jakob von Wallhause .
Jean Nassau 1615
).

Herv

BEGARIE (.
"
" " The principales of the art
"Militarie .


.
.
: Francisco Barado
Antonio Espino Lopez .
1 " Antonio LOPEZF  2 2
dc W/F 
#$
"D

#.77 F&W
2 
Herv BEGARIE I
# X 180 F&W .190

46

 Fernando Alvia Castro Cristobal de Rojas Luis

.mndez de Vasconcellos

Francisco Melo 1638 " Politica militar y avisos
) "de generales (.

.1 Giorgio
Basta " " Il maestro di campo general
1606 "" Del governo dellartigliera .1610
.
Louis de Montgomery Maurice de Nassau
Jrmie de Billon " "
. 1612162216361641 Rohan
" " 1636
"" . 1663 " " Aurignac )
: ( .
.
Montecucculi .
Montecucculi

)
( .
" "
1 \The Twilight of a Military Tradition : Italian Aristocrats and European Conflicts " Gregory Hanlon :

G 1560-1800  2  .1997UCL Press Taylor and Francis

2 ' ? 
"' & " ?cF 2 Jean Thiriet %

 F+ F
G "Montecucculi : " +
2#""
.1995
% 260 F&W

47

1653 1693 .
1712 .1760 " Della Guerra col Turco
"in Ungheria
.
.
.
.
.

.1
.
" " 1724
" "Polybe 1727 1730
1753 1774 " 2 ."Folard Maurice
Saxe 1756 " " .
":
.
".
1770 1780
.
.
.
1 \ :

Herv BEGARIE X I
%190 6
F&W.200

2 \ " Jean Chagniot :#"  s2 % &

 "Folard #  .1997
% 2 Rocher

48


.
.
Folard, Feuquire , Puysgur .
Feuquire Folard Puysgur
.1Logistique " ".
1736 Antoine de Pas
.
. 1748 " Jacques-Franois de Chastent
. .
Roy de
Bosroger " " 1770 " " .1773
" " Grimorad 1775
Paul Gdon Herv ) .
BEGARIE .(195 "
" .2
. "
".
.
" " .
" " 1768 "
" 1746 " " 1747
1771 " " .
1 \ 62 "Henri Antoine JOMINI :F"
" A  l ]  A .
2 \ \ "Joly de Mazeroy : F"G
% 2%
2  1777Leclerc.18 F&W

49

 1Wilhelm Schaumbourg-Lippe
. .
.

.
Henry Lloyd " A Political and Military
"Rhapsody on the Invasion and Defence of Great Britain and Ireland
1790 . " The History of
the late War between the King og Prussia and the Empress of Germany and her
"Allies .1763
Humphrey Bland " A Treatise of Military
"Discipline 1727 .1762
" " .

1

" 6



"
,
a] & #$" l" l8 ?
 6%2 Curd Ochwadt 
 
?.
2 \  "British Strategy : the theory and practice of eighteenth century warfare "D. GRUBER : 
.1978 Greenwood Press

50

 .
1789 1815 .
. Lazare Carnot
.
" : " 1809
.
: " "
Roche-Aymon 1802 1804 "
" Simon-Franois Gay 1805
. Reveroni de Saint-Cyr "
" 1808 "
" .1826
Prussien Dietrich
" ) "Geist des neuern Kriegs Systms (
1799
.
"

Lehrstze des neuen Krieges oder reine und

) "angewandte Strategie (
.1805
51

 Charles Grundstze der grosse " :

) "Kriege ( Grundstze der Strategie erlutert " 1808
) "durch die darstellung des Feldzugs von 1796 in deutschland
1796 ( .1813

.
Jomini
Henri-Antoine Jomini
. .1
1779 Ney .1805
" "
Tempelhof 1783
Lloyd " ".
Jomini
.
" " 1816
1869 90 ) . Herv
Bgarie 200 .(210
" : "
" " 15.

1 \E " Bruno COLSON : c

 % &
"1797 1792 Y  hachette .1998 Pluriel

52

 . 1

.
William Duane John
Armstrong Dennis Hart Mahan West Point Alfred Thayer
) Mahan (Dennis
.
. 2Jomini
.Clausewitz
. Vom
Kriege ""
. Clausewitz .31780
. "
.von Blow 1806
1815 .
Turenne, Frdric II
. opus magnum
:
. Clausewitz
. " " .
" "
Kriegsakademie .1810 " "

1 w /
6
&: ? 
\ " : " % &
Emile MAYER ?&: "Jomini X 
" John I ALGER

G "Jomini : A Bibliographical Survery .1975 US Military Academy 6

2 \ " Bruno COLSON : 2
dc#A" 

G % &
 "Jomini 8s"
 2 Y  Economica
 #$" .
3 s" M2] ? ? .1976Princeton University Press "Clausewitz and the State " Peter Paret

53

 :
.
10 Clausewitz 1827

.
Clausewitz
. "" " "
.

.New- clausewitziens
Clausewitz
.
1832 .1837
1500 15 .
. 1880 le Spectateur
militaire . Louis de Bystrzonowski
1870 Clausewitz
. Sadowa
1866 Sedan 1870 Jomini


54

 Clausewitz .
.

. Clausewitz .
Clausewitz Vom Kriege
Schlieffen .1905
Clausewitz .
.

Clausewitz .1871/1870 1880 1905
.Clausewitz Cardot
" " Clausewitz 1884
Georges Gilbert .1887
.Clausewitz
Clausewitz
.
.1Clausewitz
1834
.Vom Kriege Graham
1873 F.N Maude
.1908
69 12.

1 \ Clausewitz in English : The Reception of Clausewitz in in Britain and "Christopher BASSFORD :

 America 1815-1945 X
e


/&%.1994

55

Clausewitz .

Corbett Clausewitz
. Fuller Liddell Hart Clausewitz
.1 Jomini
. " " 1976
":
Bernard Brodie Clausewitz ".2
Clausewitz .
Emilio Canevari " Clausewitz e la
Clausewitz ) "guerra odierna ( . 3 Banus Comas
" "Estrategia 1887 .Clausewitz
1908 .
. Clausewitz
.1970

.
. 4
.
.
Jomini Bavarois Xylander, Wurtembergeois Theobald,
Mller, Valentini, Decker, Hoyer
.Hheren Kriegskunst
Clausewitz Von Lossau
1 6
"Clausewitz, Fuller and Liddell Hart "Jay Luvaas
Clausewitz and Modern "Michael Handel
6
"Strategy.212 *E 197 F&W
2 "Raymond ARON& 
F" % &
 .347 F&W
3 w
M  $#x 
e"  *+ #  l8 Bollati
2 Clausewitz " Ferruccio Botti"

e

Stratgique +
6 78 2000 79.3/2
4 \ Carl von Clausewitz, Wirkungsgeschichte seines Werkes in Russland und der " Olaf ROSE :
] 
"Sowjetunion 1836-1995  2 C8s" Clausewitz) 1995 Oldenbourg Verlag
#
F"A .(2%

56

 .1Rhle von Lilienstern Clausewitz

.
.
. Joseph
Pougni-Guillet " " 1832 Paul
Racchia " " .1832 Enrico Giustiniani
" " .1848
Luigi Blanch
.
Scolastiques Lac
" " .

.
.2
Nicolas Medem " ) "Obozrenie isvestnjchich pravil i sistem strategii
( 1836 Lloyd,
Blow, Jomini, Clausewitz Taktika 1837
Souvorov .

M .I

1  2/ l9  ##$" 

  6/ * the Rise and Decline of Germn ": Herbert ROSINSKI DF

G Naval War College Review +
2 "Military Thought 1976 pG 2.83 F&W
2 \
G "Russian Imperial Military Doctrine and Education "Carl Van DYKE : Westport Greenwood 6
1990 Press 2 DF "Russian Military thought :the Western Model and the Shadow of Suvorof " Walter Pinter

.Makers of Modern Strategy +

57

Bogdanovich ) Zapiski strategii ( 1847

.
Astafev " "
Dimitri Milioutine
1861 .1881
Okounieff " " 1831
1812 1841 .1876
.
Marmont
" " 1845 .1865

.1 1815 1870
.2 .
.

.
.1870
" "
.
. 1870
1 '  6 


"' 2 Bruno Colson
? 
W 
& Marchal Marmont, De lesprit des institutions " %

 "militaires Y  Economica #$" .2001

2 


 
& : %
Sainte-Hlne 
^"

G
?

|
/
+
6 
\E9
" c
?%& D
c 
+
" 
# 6KG
 2
 Y .1867

58

 .1

.
.
1880
.
Colmar von der Goltz " Das
) "Volk in Waffen ( 1883
1884 1887 .1887

Wilhelm von

1882 "Die Strategie " Blume 1884 1887

.1899
"
" Hans Delbrck
. 1910 Friedrich von Bernhardi
" ) "Vom heutigen Kriege (
1912 1912 1912 1913
.1914 :
W.H. james " "Modern Strategy 1904 H. Tovey "
"Elements of Strategy F.N Maude " The Evolution of Moderne Strategy
"from the XVIII Century .1905 John Bigelow
" "Principles of Strategy 1891 Arthur Wagner "
"Strategy .1903
.
1 9c

% 2 2

" &FG+/ %/ " 
d %/" l8 " p X%/ +  "
 2 1871
 /
" w V
" X] 

+"
 2 1899"
M X%/ 
/"
 2 .1907

59

 1914
. 1

.

.



. Charles Times
. Spenser Wilkinson
1909 " "
" "First lessons in War 1914 " ."Gouvernment and the War 1918
Lucia Frost Clausewitz
. " La Revue des
. La Revue universelle La Revue de Paris deux-mondes
Ferdinand Feyler )
1915 .(1918
" " "
".

1918 .
.

1
6 C
&+ 


& Lucas %
" ^F ""e
2 
% 2 2 V 

9 F

6
1914G "1918
 2Y  .1924 Berger-Levrault

60


.1
: .
.
Visconti-Prasca " ) "La Guerra decisiva
( 1934 .1935
.
Chauvineau " "
1939 .
Wilhelm :
.Reinhardt, Alfred Krauss, Waldemar von Erfurth, Herman Foertsch

.
Azar Gat

. .

Alexandre Svechin " "Strategija

.1926 . ""
"" ": ".
Mihail Frounze
Toukhatchevski " " "
" .

Toukhatchevski

.Svechin 1939

1 w /
6
# E   
5+ 
 . &+k

The Sources of Military "Barry R. Posen :
.1984 Cornell University Press Ithaca "Doctrine, France, Britain and Germany between the World Wars
M
 "Military Thinker "Brian Holden Reid  .1987 Macmillan 
& d %
X La "Camon

G "Motorisation de lArme et la manuvre stratgique

 2Y  .1926Berger-Levrault
2
G "British Influence and the Evolution of the Panzer Arm : Myth or Reality ? " Azar GAT 2K.6

61

 1914
.
.
1939
.

.
.
.
.
.
.Mahan

.
: Edward Mead Earle
" "Makers of Strategy
1943 1982
.
Stephen Possony .
.
.

.
.

62

63

1 .

.

.
.
.
Jomini .
" : " "
" . Clausewitz .
Jomini
.1914

.

.
von der Goltz " " .

64

)( . 1945

.
.
2 .

.
.
Clausewitz
.
.

.1

. ""
.


.


.

1 \ 
" G #$" "
G 
& .Lucien Poirier ps" %

65

3 .

:
1
: .
.
2
.
.

. Castex Bernard
Brodie Beaufre .
3 .1945

.
.
Thomas Schelling
Lucien Poirier
.

66

.

.
.
Foch .1
1 .

.
. .
.
.

.

.
.

1
 "Des Principes de la guerre " Foch Y.94 F&W

67

 ":
.
" .1 : 2
.
.
.
. .
""
.
.
. .
/ .

.
:

" "
. ""
.
.

. Clausewitz

":

1 6
rek
"Jean-Louis SEURIN "

d
+F 

F+"
 % &
 Y  

.1989
% & /
2 " Konard Lorenz et Karl Popper 2 Karl Popper&
d%"
 Y  1995Flammarion.117 F&W

68


".1
Rosinski ":

" .2

. .
" " ": ".3

.
.
.

.
Jomini, Clausewitz, Mahan, Corbett, Castex,
...Fuller, Liddell Hart, Douhet, Beaufre, Poirier, Schelling
Caemmerer, Mordacq,
Puleston , Lepotier Mahan
.
1 " Carl CLAUSEWITZF"
I
# X.673 F&W
2 "Commentaire de Mahan "Herbert ROSINSKI.55 F&W
3 "Penser la guerre "Raymond ARONK .23 F&W

69

 .
.
.

.

2 . Doctrine
": Lucien Poirier .
") . " .(129

": Jacques Laurent
" ). " " .(47
":

70

 " .
": ".

.
)1954
.( 1963198219861993
:
.
.

.


.
.

.

.
.
.
).Foch :
.( 101
.

71

 Clausewitz
. .

.
.1789
.
.
.
""
.
Clausewitz
.
.

.

. ""

.

.

.
.

72


.
Clausewitz
.
. " "
":

".1
Mahan
.
.
":

" ) . .(179

1880 1914

Alfred T.Mahan .Philip Colomb
""

. Reginald Custance
" "Naval Policy
.1907

1

" 2 YE # \ 
G l+/
 2 % &
Y  +%+# Plon
F 2+/
 
% $ .1965

73


.
.

.
.
1 .
.
.
Scharnhorst
. Hubert Bonnal
.
.
.
.
2 .

.

. ""

.

74


. :
/
.
3 /.
"

" .1

.

. Puysgur
" " " :

".


.

.
.

1 " Antoine Grouard#$" "
I

# X.29 F&W

75


.
.
.
4 .
"
" "" .
""

Giacomo

Durando .1846
. ""
"" "".
.
5 .

.
Jack Snyder The Soviet Strategic Culture
.1977
. ":

".1

1  / p
 ^F" DF 2 " 2
dc#$" & " %
"' " +
6
Bruno Colson#$"" / 53&W
 1992.29 F&W

76


.
Jomini Mahan
Douhet .1

Gabriel Almond, Sidney Verba ) (1963The Civic Culture Lucien
Pye
).(1965 Political culture and Political Development
6 .
.
.
Castex " "
. Castex Bernard Brodie

.
7 .
.
. Sun
Zi .
.2
Clausewitz Corbett
Rosinski
1 \
G "The American Way of War " Russel WEIGLEY :  2  6  Macmillan-Collier
.1973
2 \ "The Origins of Military Theory in Ancient Greece and China " Everett L. WHEEler  6
 X
 *+/

6 X.^  $

77

 .Poirier

.
Clausewitz
.1

:

. .
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.

.

1  6/ 
*
G "Some Thoughts on Clausewitz and Airplanes "James B. SMITH Air University 6
Review .1986

78

 .




:

.

.
.

.

.
":
" ). .(188
":Marmont
. ".1

1 " Marchal Marmont 

%#: %/ " .4 F&W

79


.
.
.

.
1851 ) Foch (1929 "
"
Xnophon ":
" ) . " Foch
" 1903 .(95
Fuller
.1921
. Field Manual 100-5 1993
:
.
. .
Labouerie : .1
.

.
.

.
:
1

" Guy LABOUERIE F"" +
2 DF 
2  "o&
% % .1992

80

 .
.
.
.

1 .

. .
Clausewitz
""
. .

/
.
2 .

.
.
) (
) (.

3 .

81

 ":
" .1

.

.
.

.

" " .

.

4 .
.


.
.
.

1
6 
#

+ * 

" 2 Eugne]
% 30 
1809
2
+ / Camon " F

 "  +.326 F&W

82


":
". 1

.

. "".


.

. ""

.
.

.
.
.

. ":
".
.
1
6

d+/""
+ " K .
2 \"Knowing Ones Ennemies. Intelligence Assessment before the Two World Wars "Ernest R.May
.1986 Princeton University Press \ The Tao of the Spycraft, Intelligence Theort and "Ralph D. Sawyer
M
.1998 Boulder-san Francisco-London, Westview "Practice in Traditional China

83

 .



.1
.
.

1 \ "Bernis K 
k"G
 2 6 Y  .1934 Berger-Levrault

84

1
.
.
.1969

.

.

85

 .
.
.
.
.

. :

.
.

" " .


. " "
.
" " :

1
"" .2 .

"".
2 .
.
1 \

" 
 "c 
G % &
 " +/
 2 6 Y  .1972 Flammarion
2  / * 

"
 * &  #
% "5 
2 2
  2 /
6 6
V d X#

& "."l5

86


.
3
.
.
4
. .
.
" "
: .
.
1945
.1970

. .

.


.
.1945

87

 .
.

.
1949 Bernard Brodie
.1
.

.
.

.
.
.

.
.

.
.
"" . " "
.

1 \ 
6
"Strategy as a Science " Bernard BRODIE KE World Politics X 

.1949

88


. " " .
" "

.

)
( .


.
.1

2 .

.
Herman Kahn
Raymond Aron Henry Kissinger Bernard Brodie
Michael Howard Thomas schelling .Edward Luttwak

1 \ " Herman KAHN 

%
AF"
G % &

 2 6 Y  Calmann-Lvy Libert de
.1966 lesprit Nuclear Mentalities " Batrice HEUSER
M France Strategies and Belief Systems in Britain
 and the FRG  .1998 Macmillan

89

 .

Rand
Corporation
.
.Rand Corporation
" "
.
""
.

Centre of Naval Institute of Defense Analysis ) :
(Congressional Research Service Analysis ) :
.(American Entreprise Institute Brookings Institute Rand Corporation
""
.

P.M.S Blackett
1 Basil Liddell Hart
.2
1
6 " : ?"
&:
l
, #
% %/  
e+ "

G
 2 .1949
2
B. H. Liddell Hart, A Greater Than Napoleon: Scipio Africanus (W Blackwood and Sons, ?"
&:
6
)The decisive wars of history (1929) (premire partie Londres, 1926; Biblio and Tannen, New York, 1976

90



.

.
Erik Wolf Schneider
Panaiotis Kondylis Grawert-May .Gunter Maschke

.

.
" "
. " "
.

3 .
.

)Sherman: Soldier, Realist, American A History of the World War(1914-1918) Strategy: the indirect approach
)The Memoirs of Captain (Dodd, Mead and Co, New York, 1929; Frederick A. Praeger, New York, 1960
).Liddell Hart: Volumes I and II (Cassell, Londres, 1965

91

 1901 ) Ludwig von Bertalanffy (1972 "

" " 1 " General System Theory
. 2
David Eston
.3 Morton Kaplan Karl
Deutsch Marcel Merle .4
Pablo
Oscar Mazzoni Warden " " .

.
Ludwig von Bertalanffy 1937 " "
" " . ":

"") ( " ": " .

Systme
rgime
. systme .

Paul Weiss ":
" . .

- Ludwig von Bertalanffy, General System Theory: Foundations, Development, Applications (George Braziller,
1976).
2
General- An Outline of General System Theory, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 1, p.139-164
system theory - A new approach to unity of science (Symposium), Human Biology, Dec 1951, Vol. 23, p. 303361.
3 \ 
2# +F" " \

(Analyse du systme politique ) % &
 "#
%Y  Armand
.1974Colin
4
- Marcel Merle, Sociologie des relations internationales ,Paris, Dalloz, 1977.

92

 Ludwig von Bertalanffy ":

.
.
" ) . ( .
"" Systme
.
" "

. .
"" ) (
" "
.
.
.
""
.
.

.
" " . 1977 Jacques Ellul

.

93

 Jacques Ellul .
" " . Jacques Ellul
:
1 :

.1
. .
Clausewitz

.2
2 :
.
.
. .

. "" ""
.
3 :
. .3
.


...

1 " Jacques Ellul\


G % &
"d
 2 Y  1977Calmann-Lvy, Libert de lesprit137 F&W


./
2  X I
%.138 F&W
3  XI
%.186 F&W

94

4 "" :
. .1
5 :
.2
/ .

.
6 :
.

.3 .
7 :
.4

. "
"
.
8 : 1945
.
.
.
1  X I
% 219 F&W .220
2  X I
%.229 F&W
3  X I
%.253 F&W
4  X I
%.280 F&W

95

 .


.
: .

.
.
.

.

.

.1

. .
.

.

1 \
G "The Command and Control of Nuclear Forces "Paul BRACKEN New Haven-London, Yale 6
1983 University Press.21 F&W

96


.
:
.

. )
( ) ( )
( " ".1

""
.
.
) (
.
.
.

.
)
( 2Colin Gray .
/
.

1   C 2 %

 " Castex\
#$" "
 2
/

I
# X 
 2 %K
 6
X
? 2& W. 
c
2
- Colin GRAY , The Soviet American Arms Race , Lexington, D.C. Heath, 1976; and, The Urge to
Compete: Rationale for Arms Racing, World Politics, 1974, P.207.

97

 .

18701940 .

.

.
gap .1960
Colin Gray
:1









. "" ) (
imbrication .

- Colin GRAY, The Arms Race Phenomenon ,in George H. Quester, ed., American Defense Policy , P. 146147.

98

 4 .
" ".

.
.

. "
" 1 1963 1980 " "
" ".2
(RMA ) Revolution in Military Affairs
Net Assessment Office of Pentagone
Andrew w. Marshall
doctrinales . ) (RMA
1992 .

.


.
1

- Jean-Christophe ROMER, La pense stratgique russe au XXe sicle, p.47.

- Philip A. KARBER, The Tactical Revolution in Soviet Military Doctrine , Carlisle Barracks, US Army
War College, 1983.
2

99

 .
. " "Owens "
"
.
War and Anti War
1993 Alvin and Heidi Toffler
" ".
" "
.
.
.
" "FM 100-5 " " FM
.1100-6
:



.
" ".
" "
. Edward
Warner

- Michael D. Stany and Charles W. Arneson, FM 100-6: Informations Operations, Military Review,1996.

100

 .
1 .
""
"" .2
"" :

.
"
".3
" ".

" " .
: " ."
.
""
.4 ""

.
"" .

.5
"" .
1

KE, 1997, P.32. - In, Janes Defense Weekly, 30

- Richard J. Harknett, Information Warfare and Deterrence , ed., Parameters, 1996, P. 93.
3
- Barry D. Watts, Clausewitzian Friction and Future War , Washington, National Defense University, 1996.
4 2A
F

#"

/ 
+ ""+d " Institute for National Strategic Studies
/ 2X
"
/
X#$"
" Xc  : %/  F 
.
5
- Jacob W. KIPP, Confronting the RMA with Russia , Military Review,1997.
2

101


.

.
" "
.
" "
"" " ."

.
.

.


conflictuel
.
Sun Zi ":
".1
2500

. .
1
6
#$"  6G W 62 " F" .99 F&W

102

 " ".

.
:
.
.
.
.

1  X
+ #
#  " V+ w " ^F

2 m 


 X 

" * "d
 l 6
#
  '
e+  " I/ 2 ?# C+/.

103

Europasche Sicherheit
Europasche Wehrkunde
Militrwissenschaftliche Rundschau

sterreichische Militrissche Zeitschrift

Revista espaola de defensa

Revista general de Marina
Revista militar

- Air University Review.
- Armed Forces and Society.
- Arms Control Today.
- Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists.
- Comparative Strategy.
- Defense Intelligence Journal.
- International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence.
- International Security.
- Military Review.
- Naval War College Review.
- Non-Proliferation Review.
- Parameters.
- Small Wars and Insurgencies.

104

- Strategic Review.
- U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings.

- Larmement.
- Forces ariennes franaises.
- La Revue des forces ariennes de 1929 1933, la Revue de larme de
lair de 1934 1939.
- Journal des sciences militaires.
- Revue maritime.
- Dfense.
- Revue militaire franaise.
- Revue militaire gnrale.
- Revue des forces terrestres.
- Revue de dfenses nationale.

Strategic Analysis.

Informazioni della difesa.

Rivista Marittima.
Rivista militare Italiana.
Strategia globale.

- Strategic Dialogue.

105


- Anais do Clube Militar.
- Estrategia.
- Revista Militar.
.
- Les Champs de Mars, Cahiers du Centre dtudes en sciences sociales de
la dfense.
- World Politics.
- International Organization.
- Cooperation and Conflict Resolution.
- Journal of defense and peace Cconomics.
- Etudes polmologiques.
- Cultures et conflicts.

- Etudes internationals ( Canada).

- Foreign Affairs.
- Foreign Policy ( U.S.A).
- International Affairs ( U.K)
- International Studies Quarterly ( U.S.A).
- Orbis (U.S.A).
- Politique trangre ( France).
- Politique internationale ( France).
- Politica exterior ( Espagne).
- Revue internationale et stratgique.

.
106

- Aerospace.
- American Neptune.
- Command Magazine.
- Diplomaciy History.
- Guerres mondiales et conflits contemporaines.
- The International History Review.
- The journal of Strategic History.
- The Journal of Slavic Military Studies.
- Relations internationales.
- Revue internationale dhistoire militaire.
- War and History.
- War and Society.

1- Baquer Miguel Alonso, El Oensamiento militar en la historia de la

infanteria espaola , Madrid.
2- Carles Pierre, Linfluence exerce sur la pense militaire par des esprits
individualistes jusquen 1815 , Suisse, Pully, centre dhistoire et de
prospectives militaires, 1990.
3- Carrias Eugne, La pense militaire allemande , Paris, Presses
universitaires de France, 1948.
4- Gallie W.B., Philosophers of peace and War , Cambridge University
Press,1978.
5- Gary Colin S., Strategic Studies and Public Policy ,Lexington, The
University of Kentucky, 1982.
107

6- Handel Michael I., Classical Strategic Thought, Londres-Portland,

Frank Cass, 2001.
7- Kitchen Martin, The Traditions of German Strategic Thought , The
International History Review,vol.1, n 2,1979.
8- Mordacq, La stratgie, Histoire, volution, Paris, Fournier,1912.
9- Paret Peter, Makers of Modern Strategy ,Princeton, Princeton
University Press,1985.
10- Schneider Fernand, Histoire des doctrines militaires, Paris, Presses
universitaires de France,1957.
11- Stahel Albert A., Klassiker der Strategie , Eine Bewertung,
Zurich,VDF,1996.

1. Bardin, Dictionnaire de larme de terre ou recherches historiques sur

lart et les usages militaires des Anciens et des Modernes , Paris,
Corrard, 1849-1850, 8 vols.
2. Chaliand Grard, Dictionnaire de stratgie militaire , Paris, Perrin,
1998 .
3. Chandler David G., Dictionary of the Napoleonic Wars , New York,
Macmillan, 1979.
4. Corvisier Andr , Dictionnaire dart et dhistoire militaires , Paris,
Presses universitaires de France, 1988 .
5. Davis Paul K., Encyclopedia of Invasions and Conquests from Ancient
Times to the Present, Santa Barbara-Denver-Oxford, ABC-Clio, 1996.
6. Dupuy R.E. et Dupuy Trevor N., The Encyclopedia of Military History,
from 3500 B.C. to the Present, Londres, Janes, 2e d. 1986.
7. Dupuy Trevor N. (ed.), International Military and Defense
Encyclopedia , Washington, Brasseys-Macmillan, 1993, 6 vols, 3132 p.
8. Eggenberger David, An Encyclopedia of Battles , New York, Dover, 2e
d. 1985.

108

9. Flintham Victor, Air Wars and Aircraft. A Detailed Record of Air

Combat, 1945 to the Present, New York-Oxford-Sydney, Facts on File,
1990 .
10.Harbottle Thomas B., Dictionary of Battles , 2e d. rvise par George
Bruce, Londres, Granada, 1989.
11.Heinl Jr et Debs Robert, Dictionary of Military and Naval Operations,
Annapolis, Naval Institute Press, 1966.
12.Jessup John E., An Encyclopedic Dictionary of Conflict and Conflict
Resolution 1945-1996, Westport, Greenwood Press, 1998.
13.Klein Jean et Montbrial Thierry de, Dictionnaire de stratgie , Paris,
Presses universitaires de France, paratre en 1999.
14.Kohn George C., Dictionary of Wars, New York, Anchor Books, 1987.
15.Lacoste Yves , Dictionnaire de gopolitique , Paris, Flammarion, 1995,
2e d. 1997.
16.Laffin John, Brasseys Battles. 3500 Years of Conflict, Campaigns and
Wars from A-Z, Londres, Brasseys, 1976, 2e d. 1995.
17.Margiotta Franklin D., Brasseys Encyclopedia of Naval Forces and
Warfare, Washington, Brasseys, 1997.
18.Poten Bernhard, Handwrterbuch der gesamten Militrwissenschaften
mit erluternden Abbildungen, 8 vols, Billefeld et Leipzig, Velhagen &
Klasing, 1877-1880.
19.Raufer Xavier, Dictionnaire technique et critique des nouvelles
menaces , Paris, Presses universitaires de France, 1998.
20.Thual Franois et Chauprade Aymeric, Dictionnaire de gopolitique ,
Paris, Ellipses, 1998.

1. Anonyme, De lEsprit militaire , La Haye, 2e d. 1785.

2. Bacon , Manuel du jeune officier ou essai de thorie militaire, Paris,
Chez Jombert jeune, 1782.
3. Blow Dietrich von, Lesprit du systme de guerre moderne , Paris,
Chez Magimel, Anselin et Pochard, 1801.
4. Comeau , Souvenirs des campagnes dAllemagne pendant les guerres de
la Rvolution et de lEmpire , Paris, Plon, 1900.
5. Commentaires de Napolon Ier, 6 vols, Paris, Imprimerie impriale, 1867.
6. Correspondance de Napolon. Six cents lettres de travail 1806-1810,
Paris, Gallimard, 1943.
109

7. Correspondance militaire de Napolon, 10 vols, Paris, Plon, 1877.

8. Feuquire, Mmoires de M. le marquis de Feuquire , Londres, Chez
Pierre Dunoyer, 1736.
9. Frederick the Great on the Art of War, ed. and trans. by Jay Luvaas, New
York, The Free Press, 1966 (en franais, en labsence ddition rcente, il
faut recourir Liskenne et Sauvan).
10.Guibert, Stratgiques , Paris, lHerne, Classiques de la stratgie, 1977.
11.Guibert, uvres militaires, publies par sa veuve , Paris, Chez
Magimel, 5 vols, An XII-1803.
12.Joly de Maizeroy, Thorie de la guerre , Nancy, Chez la Veuve
Leclerc, 1777.
13.Le Vasseur, Commentaires de Napolon, Paris, Corrard, 1851.
14.Lederer L., Joseph de Maistre, Paris, Berger-Levrault, Les Classiques de
lart militaire, 1949.
15.Machiavel Nicolas, uvres compltes , Paris, Gallimard, Bibliothque
de la Pliade, 1952.
16.Montecucculli, Mmoires de Montecucculli, avec les Commentaires du
Comte Turpin de Criss , Paris, Chez C.A. Jombert, 1770.

17.Puysgur, Art de la guerre par principes et par rgles , Paris, Chez C.A.
Jombert, 1748 (existe en in-folio et en in-quarto, do des rfrences
paginales qui peuvent varier).
18.Rohan Henri , Le Parfaict Capitaine , Osnabrck, Biblio Verlag,
Bibliiotheca Rerum Militarium 11, 1972 (rimpression de ldition de
1636 avec une prface de Werner Hahlweg).
19.Santa Cruz, Rflexions politiques et militaires , La Haye, Beauregard,
1771, 12 vols.
20.Schaumbourg-Lippe Wilhelm Graf zu, Schriften und Briefe. II
Militrische Schriften, Hrsgb Curd Ochwadt , Francfort, Vittorio
Klosterman, 1977.

1. Brenger Jean, La collaboration militaire franco-ottomane lpoque de

la Renaissance , Revue internationale dhistoire militaire, 68, 1987.

110

2. Black Jeremy (ed.), The Origins of War in Early Modern Europe,

Edimbourg, John Donald, 1987.
3. Blanchard Anne, Les Peuples et leurs armes. Prosopographie des
militaires xviie-xviiie sicles , Montpellier, Centre dhistoire militaire et
dtudes de dfense nationale, s.d.
4. Bois Jean-Pierre, Fontenoy 1745. Louis XV, arbitre de lEurope ,
Paris, conomica, Campagnes et stratgies, 1996.
5. Bois Jean-Pierre, Lart de la paix lpoque moderne , Bulletin de la
Socit archologique et historique de Nantes et de Loire-Atlantique,
1997.
6. Borreguero Beltran Cristina, The Spanish Army in Italy 1734 , War in
History , 5-4, novembre 1998.
7. Camon Hubert, La Guerre napolonienne. Les systmes doprations ,
Paris, ISC-conomica, Bibliothque stratgique, 1997.
8. Centre dtudes dhistoire de la dfense, Nouveaux regards sur la guerre
de Trente Ans, Paris, ADDIM, 1999.
9. Chandler David G., The Campaigns of Napoleon, New York,
Macmillan, 1966.
10.Chandler David, The Art of Warfare in the Age of Marlborough, New
York, Hippocrene, 1976.
11.Chuquet Arthur Maxime, Dumouriez , Paris, Hachette, 1914.
12.Commission internationale dhistoire militaire, Linfluence de la
Rvolution franaise sur les armes en France , en Europe et dans le
monde", Acta n 14, 2 vols, 1988.
13.Contamine Philippe, Guerre et concurrence entre les tats europens du
xive au xviiie sicle , Paris, Presses universitaires de France, 1998.
14.Corvisier Andr, Armes et socits en Europe de 1494 1789 , Paris,
Presses universitaires de France, collection SUP lhistorien, 1976.
15.Corvisier Andr, Les hommes, la guerre et la mort , Paris, conomica,
Histoire, 1985 (recueil darticles).
16.Corvisier Andr, Modernit de la guerre de Trente Ans , dans Destins
et enjeux du xviie sicle, Paris, Presses universitaires de France, 1985.
17.Coutau-Bgarie Herv, "LAncien Rgime militaire : un modle de guerre
limite", Stratgique, 54, 1992-2.
18.Duffy Christopher, The Military Experience in the Age of Reason 17151789, New York, Barnes and Noble, 1987.
19.Duffy Christopher, The Army of Frederick the Great, Chicago,
Emperors Press, 2e d., 1996.
20.Elliott J.H., Richelieu et Olivars, Paris, Presses universitaires de France,
Histoires, 1991.
21.Freytag-Loringhoven Freiherr von, Die Heerfhrung Napoleons in ihrer
Bedeutung fr unsere Zeit, Berlin, Mittler, 1919.

111

22.Glover Richard G., Peninsular Preparation : The Reform of the British

Army 1795-1809, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1963.
23.Grverie (capitaine de la), "Larme dOrient sous Klber", Revue
dhistoire (de larme), 1911.
24.Hale John R., Renaissance War Studies , Londres, Hambledon Press,
1983 (recueil darticles).
25.Hale John R., War and Society in Renaissance Europe, Londres,
Fontana Paperbacks, 1985.
26.Hanlon Gregory, The Twilight of a Military Tradition : Italian
Aristocrats and European Conflicts 1560-1800, Londres, UCL PressTaylor and Francis, 1997.
27.Kennett Lee, The French Armies in the Seven Years War. A Study in
Military Organization and Administration, Durham, Duke University
Press, 1967.
28.Lonard mile G., LArme et ses problmes au xviiie sicle , Paris,
Plon, Civilisations et mentalits, 1958.
29.Mori Massimo, La ragione delle armi. Guerra e conflitto nella filosofia
classica tetesca (1770-1830) , Milan, Il Saggiatore, 1984.
30.Oman sir Charles, A History of the Art of War in the SixteenthCentury, Londres-Novato, Greenhill Books-Presidio Press, 1987
(original 1937).
31.Oman sir Charles, Studies in the Napoleonic Wars, Londres-Novato,
Greenhill Books-Presidio Press, 1989 (original 1929).
32.Parker Geoffrey, The Army of Flanders and the Spanish Road 15671659, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1972.
33.Quimby Robert S., The Background of Napoleonic Warfare. The Theory
of Military Tactics in Eighteenth-Century France, New York, Columbia
University Press, 1957.
34.Rothenberg Gunther E., The Art of Warfare in the Age of Napoleon,
Bloomington-Londres, Indiana University Press, 1978.
35.Rothenberg Gunther E., Napoleons Great Adversary. Arkduke Charles
and the Austrian Army 1792-1814, Staplehurst, Spellmount, 1995.
36.Savinel Pierre, Moreau, rival rpublicain de Napolon , Rennes, OuestFrance, 1986.
37.Showalter Dennis E., The Wars of Frederick the Great, Londres-New
York, Longman, 1996.

112

1. Ackerman Nordal, On the Doctrine of Limited War, Lund, Lund

University Press, 1979.
2. Allison Graham T., Explaining a Decision : The Cuban Missile Crisis,
Boston, Little Brown, 1971 (ce livre est vite devenu un classique et
continue de susciter le dbat : cf. Allyn Bruce, Bright James G. et Welch
David A., "Essence of Revision, Moscow, Havana and the Cuban Missile
Crisis", International Security, hiver 1989-1990).
3. Annual Defense Department Report (cest dans ce document que lon
trouve chaque anne lexpos officiel de la stratgie amricaine).
4. Armacost Michael L., The Politics of Weapons Innovation : The ThorJupiter Controversy, New York-Londres, Columbia University Press,
1969.
5. Aron Raymond, "Stratgie et dissuasion", Dfense nationale, janvier
1973.
6. Ball Desmond, Can Nuclear War Be Controlled ?, Adelphi Papers, 169,
automne 1981.
7. Ball Desmond et Richelson Jeffrey (eds), Strategic Nuclear Targeting,
Ithaca-Londres, Cornell University Press, Cornell Studies in Security
Affairs, 1986.
8. Becker Martine de, Muller Harald et Schaper Annette, Essais nuclaires :
fin de partie, Bruxelles, GRIP, 1997.
9. Betts Richard K. (ed.), Cruise Missiles. Technology, Strategy, Politics,
Washington, Brookings, 1981.
10.Betts Richard K., Nuclear Blackmail and Nuclear Balance, Washington,
Brookings, 1987.
11.Blair Bruce G., Strategic Command and Control : Redefining the Nuclear
Threat, Washington, Brookings, 1985.
12.Blair Bruce G., The Logic of Accidental Nuclear War, Washington,
Brookings, 1993.
13.Blair Bruce G., Global Zero Alert for Nuclear Forces, Washington,
Brookings, 1995.
14.Bracken Paul, The Command and Control of Nuclear Forces, New HavenLondres, Yale University Press, 1983.
15.Brodie Bernard (ed.), The Absolute Weapon. Atomic Power and World
Order, New York, Harcourt Brace, 1946.
16.Brodie Bernard, Escalation and the Nuclear Option, Princeton, Princeton
University Press, 1966.
17.Chassin L.M. (gnral), Stratgie et bombe atomique, Paris, Lavauzelle,
1948.
18.Cimbala Stephen J., The Past and Future of Nuclear Deterrence, New
York, Praeger, 1998.
19.Coakley Thomas P., Command and Control for War and Peace,
Washington, National Defense University Press, 1992.
113

20.David Charles-Philippe, Debating Counterforce. A Conventional

Approach in the Nuclear Age, Boulder-Londres, Westview Special
Studies in Military Affairs, 1987.
21.Dingman Roger, "Atomic Diplomacy During the Korean War",
International Security, hiver 1988-1989.
22.Freedman Lawrence, The Evolution of Nuclear Strategy, Londres,
Macmillan, 1981 (la synthse la plus sre, rgulirement remise jour).
23.Garcin Thierry, LAvenir de larme nuclaire, Paris-Bruxelles, LGDJBruylant, 1995.
24.Garvey Gerald, Strategy and the Defense Dilemma. Nuclear Policies and
Alliance Politics, Lexington-Toronto, Lexington Books, 1984.
25.George Alexander L., Avoiding War, Boulder, Westview, 1992.
26.Glaser Charles L., Analyzing Strategic Nuclear Policy, Princeton,
Princeton University Press, 1990.
27.Gray Colin S., "Nuclear Strategy : The Case for a Theory of Victory",
International Security, t 1979.
28.Gray Colin S., "Under Nuclear Gun : Victory Is Possible", Foreign Policy,
39, t 1980.
29.Gray Colin S., Strategic Studies. A Critical Assessment, Londres,
Aldwych Press, 1982.
30.Gray Colin S., Nuclear Strategy and National Style, Lanham, Hamilton
Press-Abt Books, 1986.
31.Halperin Morton, Limited War in the Nuclear Age, New York, Wiley,
1963.
32.Harknett Richard J., "Information Warfare and Deterrence", Parameters,
automne 1996.
33.Heuser Beatrice, NATO, Britain, France and the FRG : Nuclear Strategies
and Forces for Europe 1949-2000, New York, St Martins Press, 1997.
34.Heuser Batrice, Nuclear Mentalities ? Strategies and Belief Systems in
Britain, France and the FRG, Londres, Macmillan, 1998.
35.Hoffmann Stanley, "Terreur et terrier", Revue franaise de science
politique, dcembre 1961.
36.Holst Johan J. et Nerlich Uwe (eds), Beyond Nuclear Deterrence,
Londres, Macdonald and Janes, 1977.
37.Jervis Robert, Lebow Richard Ned et Stein Janice Gross, Psychology and
Deterrence, Baltimore-Londres, The Johns Hopkins Press, 1985 (ne se
limite pas la dissuasion nuclaire).
38.Jervis Robert, The Meaning of the Nuclear Revolution : Statecraft and the
Prospect of Armageddon, Ithaca-Londres, Cornell University Press, 1989.
39.Kahn Herman, On Thermonuclear War, Princeton, Princeton University
Press, 1960.
40.Kahn Herman, De lescalade. Mtaphores et scnarios, Paris, CalmannLvy, Libert de lesprit, 1966.
114

41.Kissinger Henry, Nuclear Weapons and Foreign Policy, New York,

Harper, 1957.
42.Knorr Klaus et Read Thorston (eds), Limited Strategic War, Londres, Pall
Mall Press, 1962.
43.La Gorce Paul-Marie de, La Guerre et latome, Paris, Plon, 1985.
44.Mandelbaum, The Nuclear Revolution. International Politics before and
after Hiroshima, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1981.
45.Miksche Ferdinand-Otto, Tactique de la guerre atomique, Paris, Payot,
1955.
46.Miksche Ferdinand-Otto, La Faillite de la stratgie atomique. Retour aux
tranches ?, Paris, Le livre contemporain, 1958.
47.Morgenthau Hans J., "The Four Paradoxes of Nuclear Strategy", The
American Political Science Review, janvier 1964.
48.Nye Jr Joseph S., Allison Graham T. et Carnesale Albert (eds), Fateful
Visions. Avoiding Nuclear Catastrophe, cambridge, Ballinger, 1988.
49.Osgood Robert E., Limited War Revisited, Boulder, Westview Press,
1978.
50.Overy R.J., "Air Power and the Origins of Deterrence Theory before
1939", The Journal of Strategic Studies, mars 1992.
51.Panofsky Erwin, "The Mutual Hostage Relationship between United
States and Russia", Foreign Affairs, dcembre 1973.
52.Poirier Lucien, Des stratgies nuclaires, Paris, Hachette, 1977.
53.Posen Barry R., Inadvertent Escalation, Ithaca-Londres, Cornell
University Press, 1991.
54.Rosecrance Richard, Strategic Deterrence Reconsidered, Adelphi Papers,
11, printemps 1975.
55.Rougeron Camille, La Guerre nuclaire, Paris, Calmann-Lvy, 1962.
56.Sagan Scott D;, Moving Targets. Nuclear Strategy and National Security,
Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1989.
57.Schelling Thomas C., "The Waning of Deterrence", Perspectives in
Defense Management, automne 1973.
58.Schelling Thomas C., Stratgie du conflit, Paris, Presses universitaires de
France, 1980.
59.Schelling Thomas C., Arms and Influence, New Haven, Yale University
Press, 1966.
60.Smoke Richard, War. Controlling Escalation, Cambridge, Harvard
University Press, 1977.
61.Snyder G., Deterrence and Defense : Toward a Theory of National
Security, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1961.
62.Stromseth Jane E., the Origins of Flexible Response : NATOs Debate
over Strategy in the 1960s, Londres, Macmillan Press, 1988.

115

63.Tertrais Bruno, LArme nuclaire aprs la guerre froide. LAlliance

atlantique, lEurope et lavenir de la dissuasion, Paris, Crest-conomica,
1994.
64.X-Dfense, La Paix nuclaire en question, Paris, FEDN, Les Sept pes
45, 1989.
65.Zimm Alan D., "Deterrence : Basic Theory, Principles and Implications",
Strategic Review, printemps 1997.

1. Armacost Michael H., The Politics of Weapons Innovation : The ThorJupiter Controversy, New York, Columbia University Press, 1969.
2. Bacevich A.J., The Pentonic Era : the U.S. Army between Korea and
Vietnam, Washington, National Defense University Press, 1986.
3. Ball Desmond, Politics and Force Levels. The Strategic Missile Program
of the Kennedy Administration, Berkeley-Londres, University of
California Press, 1980.
4. Ball Desmond and Toth Robert C., "Revising the SIOP : Taking WarFighting to Dangerous Extrmes", International Security, 14-4, printemps
1990.
5. Beard Edmud, Developing the ICBM. A Study in Bureaucratic Politics,
New York, Columbia University Press, 1976.
6. Bobbitt Philip, Freedman Lawrence et Treverton Gregory F., US Nuclear
Strategy : A Reader, Londres, Macmillan Press, 1989.
7. Boyer Paul, By the Bombs Early Light : American Thought and Culture
at the Dawn of the Atomic Age, New York, Pantheon Books, 1985.
8. Brodie Bernard (dir.), La Guerre nuclaire. Quatorze essais sur la
nouvelle stratgie amricaine, Paris, Stock, 1965.
116

9. Brown Anthony Cave (ed.), Operation World War III. The Secret
American Plan "Dropshot" for War with the soviet Union, Londres, Arms
and Armour Press, 1979.
10.Cannon Michael W., "The Development of the American Theory of
Limited War 1945-1963", Armed Forces and Society, automne 1992.
11.Charlton Michael, From Deterrence to Defense : The Inside Story of
Strategic Policy, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1987.
12.Dalgleich D. Douglas et Schweikart Larry, Trident, CarbondaleEdwardsville, Southern Illinois University Press, 1984.
13.Davis Lynn E., Limited Nuclear Options. Deterrence and the New
American Doctrine, Adelphi Papers, 121, hiver 1975-1976.
14.Enthoven Alain C., and Smith K. Wayne, How Much Is Enough ?
Shaping the Defense Program, 1961-1969, New York, Harper & Row,
1971.
15.Ford Daniel, The Button : The Pentagons Strategic command and
Control System, New York, Simon & Schuster, 1985.
16.Gallagher carole, American Ground Zero : The Secret Nuclear War,
Cambridge, MIT Press, 1993.
17.Garthoff Raymond L., The Great Transition : American-Soviet Relations
and the End of the Cold War, Washington, Brookings, 1994.
18.George Alexander L. et Smoke Richard, Deterrence in American Foreign
Policy : Theory and Practice, New York, Columbia University Press,
1974.
19.Gray Colin S., Strategic Studies and Public Policy. The American
Experience, Lexington, The University Press of Kentucky, 1982.
20.Greenwood Ted, Making the MIRV : A Study of Defense Decision
Making, Cambridge, Ballinger, 1975.
21.Hopkins J.C. et Goldberg Sheldon A., The Development of Strategic Air
Command, 1946-1986, Offutt Air Force Base, Office of the Historian,
Strategic Air Command, 1986.
22.Howard Michael, "Brodie, Wohlsletter and American Nuclear Strategy",
Survival, 34-2.
23.Huntington Samuel R., The Common Defense : Strategic Programs in
National Politics, New York, Columbia University Press, 1961.
24.Jervis Robert, The Illogic of American Nuclear Strategy, Ithaca-Londres,
Cornell University Press, 1984.
25.Kaufmann William W., The McNamara Strategy, New York-Londres,
Harper and Row, 1964.
26.Moody Walton S., Building a Strategic Air Force, Washington, Air Force
History and Museums Program, 1996.
27.Nash Philip, The Other Missiles of October : Eisenhower, Kennedy, and
the Jupiters, 1957-1963, Durham, University of North Carolina Press,
1997.
117

28.Rhodes Richard, The Making of the Atomic Bomb, New York, Simon &
Schuster, 1986.
29.Rhodes Richard, Dark Sun : The Making of the Hydrogen Bomb, New
York, Simon & Schuster, 1995.
30.Rose John P., The Evolution of US Army Nuclear Doctrine, 1945-1980,
Boulder, Westview, 1980.
31.Rosenberg David Alan, "American Atomic Strategy and the Hydrogen
Bomb Decision", Journal of American History, 66-1, 1979.
32.Rosenberg David Alan, "The Origins of Overkill. Nuclear Weapons and
American Strategy 1945-1960", International Security, VII-4, printemps
1983 (capital).
33.Rosenberg David Alan, "American Atomic Strategy and the Hydrogen
Bomb Decision", Journal of American History, 61, juin 1979.
34.Sagan Scott D., "SIOP-62 : The Nuclear Plan Briefing to President
Kennedy", International Security, 12-1, 1987.
35.Schelling Thomas C., "Les Armements nuclaires, lOTAN et la nouvelle
stratgie", Politique trangre, t 1963.
36.Schwartz Stephen I., Atomic Audit. The Costs and Consequences of U.S.
Nuclear Weapons since 1940, Washington, Brookings, 1998 (trs neuf).
37.Steiner Barry H., Bernard Brodie and the Foundations of American
Nuclear Strategy, Lawrence, University Press of Kansas, 1991.
38.Strategic Air Command, The Development of the Strategic Air
Command, 1946-1986, Offutt Air Force Base, Office of the Historian,
1986.
39.Wohlstetter Albert, "The Delicate Balance of Terror", Foreign Affairs,
janvier 1959.

118

7 ....................................................................................
3 ..........................................................................................

6 ..........................................................................
7 .......................................
9 .....................................................
10 ................................................................

119



1 14 ..............................................................................
trilogie 14 .............................................................
20 ................................................
26 ...............................................................

..........................................................................
28
33 ..........................................................
1 33 ..........................................................
2 35 ............................................................
3 /38 ........................................................
39 ......................................................
: ..............................................................
39

120

 ..................................................................
40

41 ...................................................................................
42 .......................................
43 ......................................................
45 ...................................................
........................................................... .
48
49 ...............................................
..........................................................................................Jomini
49 ..
.......................................................................................Clausewitz
50 ..
..........................................................................New- clausewitziens
51
.....................................................
53

53 .....................................................................................

53.....................................................................................

54......................................................................................

54......................................................................................
121

55..............................................

56 .............................................................
: ..........................................
57
....................................................
58

59 ..............................................................................
1

60...........................................................
2

62 ..............................................................................
3

62 ..................................................................................

63 .....................................................................
1
..............................................................................................
63 ......
2

66 .....................................................................................
122

Doctrine

68 .................................................................
1

69 ........................................................................................
2

69 .........................................................................................
3

/.

70 ................................................................................
4

.........................................................................................
71
5

71............................................................................................
6

72 .........................................................................................
7

72 ..........................................................................................

74 ................................................................................

75 .................................................................................

77 .......................................................................

123

80 ........................................................................................
1

................................................................................................
80 ....

82 ...............................................................

82 ...........................................................................

83 ....................................................................

84 ...............................................................................

86 .....................................................................................

86 ....................................................................

87..........................................................................

90 ...........................................................................................

91....................................

124

93................................................................................

"

"93 ................................................................

"

"94 ...............................................
" "................................................
95
.....................................................................................
97 .......

97 ..........................................................................
.............................................
99

...........................................................................................
100

101 ................................................................

102 ............................................................

103 ...............................................................

104 ..........................................................................

106 .............................................................

125

110 ........................................................

...............................................................................................
113.

126