Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 14

!

"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

! "#
Email: moj.babol@gmail.com

! "#

$6 2

3 45 $% &

' ( ) $* +% ,-. /0 ( 1.

Email: m_khaledi2002@yahoo.com

:% & '
7 - !% .
85 39 -:%
$& ! 8 2 ; < & 9= ( !8 2 / # 6 $%
6% $& 3
5
7( $7># %
7 & $7?2
& $@?A 3
& $# @% B5 C ( ./
&=
% /5 5 %
5
&
< 7
?#
45 &= $H I
&= ( $8? <
. & % < & 9= ( !8 2
5 & EF G 2
$7@?A
2
F$ , J
> & $ K ( % ! 8 2 L @"2 B5
%= $6% M <
%
1
V5
U %
> & U $-I %
O % B ,( $& .
9P
2 QR% S T $&
118
$ $& G % !% . $ 3 $W < & 9= ( !8 2
5 & G % !% .
& /'M % '>% 9 X 'X
> 7 7& $7@?A ( $ F !% . 6& $-I % . ,
& $@?A 9 EM
6& V5 3 % 4# $@?A
5E7 7@ " 7% 4# $7@?A
< 7 Y7P& B5 !T I Z5 .
& $?2 TOPSIS V 82
/5 5 7% [7 2\ 1.
7& 45 $% & /'M ]O % S *-M ! 8 2 " 6& V5 $@?A 3 " 62 /5 5 %
-!87 2
5 & EF G^2 !% . B5 ,'% "< & 9=
62 < & O % X" 9 EM $@?A
"
62
. $W ( !8 2 B5
5 /'M
5 ( 8( 3< 5
. *( < & 9= (
TOPSISV 82 3

1
2

U % 32

&=

- Kano Model
participatory Irrigation Management (PIM)

120

% /5 5 % 3< &9=

(!8 2 :

&()

%* +

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;


:

< 7 . $7&
7 Y7P&
7% , $& < 'M ]'% !W *%
85 H I U I
&= ]
( 2
)75 & 72 ` P2 ( ?, < ?M & 5 M ( 8( a5 8
5 & 9=
C % B5 2 ,.
7 &= Y7P& 3< % B5 /
'5 & . & 9= ,aI I (
$&
& U "% # 2
'M < %
O $& $
e & 5f & ]' K/
Ec B % 2 d? % B5 2 B0,:% B5 ,'%3 W
7T 17
7
5 E7c 7% 7T 40 I
&= $
A $& (1382 3 # e
*I )./
& 7
& . 9= /5 5 % ?'& 3 B5 . (FAO,1996)
% ]( < 'M / !& H
Y5 47 9= $7 '& C 7 %
G % ]'% % F 3 5
., M
3 : "% C ( $&
.(Burgar, 1998) .
% 9 *"%
Sf "% # 2
&= < %
U 7 72 1950 U 7 $7 < 7'M k:7
7 8(
7 &= ( $8? $6 2 J *F ;
$7
5 ( /# o-c 3/
n $& # 2
&= < % Y5 4 9= $ '& C % /'M1980
< 7
\ 7'& 9=
= d,M & 3
&= ( $8? $ f
M ( $ 54( B % 2 & EF $5 %
S % 7e $7H . < 72 / >
34 , %
SR 8 2 $ %= / & $a B5 / !8 % %
3 7 &= ( $8? / > / 3 H F
3 5 & 5 S * 2 d5 pR' . & %
&=
Y5 4 . & / f & U
] * & 4 , % /5 5 % $a 39= d& % 5 CR2 o % d5 2
75
762 $7 75 F q. & # % d& % 9= d& % Y( & < % ]( B
% O k: Y
S % 7e -"% < F
$H . $& # YP&
&= /5 5 % ( / # 0*% 2 5 , JR2 ( /#
$7 /7 B75 & ( /#
% . 5 , !@ % % % ( !8 2
#2
62 ( /
O 9=
7 # 2 /7
( e
% ! ,"2 ' = &
&= /& & $ 5 ( $ 54( &
&= /5 5 % U @
(1381 3 r*% 3 -. B& 3< 5 I) 4 ( e
&= /"2 <
< & 9= ( !8 2 T e YP& $& # SR 8 2
&= /5 5 % UR@
& !5 ,2 $ R.
$& B 2f 85 %= @5 = 3 = (
& $ a = $& 2 K & 5 % Y5 4
$& < 'M
(1380 3!
45 ' ) /
!5 ?2 -% /
V5
d7 % '5 7 7& ,( (
%
& J M e '-8 2 a5 < 5
/ %
./
& $M %
*&
&
& !8 2 V5 $ /
% /*P .
&5
% k:
< % '5
B5
/ > & <= ( / # 6
2& s
k: .
%!8 2
45
)5 C ( 5 C ( $&
!8 2 / # 6
2
5 & G % !% . $ / B5 & JR2 Y( ) B5 . & % O
%
. F
& % < & 9= (
7
& 3 ( /# $
$a B5 $& $6# :% 29
& 3 (Vermilion.1997) < - %
'&
& Y@ B5 K ( Y(
e ( $ 54( 2
'. $& <
$& ( $8?
EF
- Food and Agriculture organization of the united nations

121

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

$7& /5 5 7% Y7 Z5 72 J 7%= O
5 C ( $& $ # I 3/ F -M
'
&
B,a ( $% &
& /*8 q. & $ ./
5 $M 2 $. 4% 9=
'& /'M <
./ $
9= C % < %
G 2 ./
< & 9=
S 7'%
; 2
&= ] *
& '&
'
& < & 9= ( B,a $ # I
&= J %= (
3
%
/5 @2 2 /
%
&= /5 5 % /'M <
(
B,a $& # % /5 5 %
' ! '*2 39= !5 "2 3 . 9= /5 5 % $ %
< & 9= B,a 1.
(lin, 2002) . ,& 5 2
% V, 3< & 9= (
$67 2 J
t2 3Y Y5 4 $& < & 9= ( B,a
5 : *5 % (Peter.2004)3
. F
$M 2 % < =
%= (
& 5 L5 A 5 & $
*& <
S '%
4
< & 9= u % 3$:& B5
7a5 2 7( J B5 2 G 7% $7-,M
7. 9= /5 5 % $ %
./
M $6 2 U I
(
e & $ 3/
%
/5 5 7% 7?'& & < 6> `
F oc2
,'% Y@ U v < & 9= u % $ ,
&
$. 4% u % / (
2 t2 & u % B5 .
% >5
&= ( ] *
$7 F 78& 5<
.
/7 5 B 72f 85 %= @5 = 3 = < & 9= !8 2 121
& & (Narayan 31995) 3< 5
9= /5 5 7% < 7 = / 7 % n 7H % 7& $7:&
d> 5` ( F ' ( F= ( S '% Y5 4 $
< 7& 9= 7(
762 / # 6
2 L %
F !8 & ?w% G 2 % $ 3<= L@"2
X
7 ! '7*2 (
62 a5
%
*&
-"% < ?( ' % /5 @2 B r,( ./ $
$7& 3< & 9= (
62 a5 5 $W
!? < =
e & $ @A % $*5 @% 3$8 5 5 $ 8 ./
T e
#
( ' ' = $ @A % ./
$M 2 <
., M
' F)5
< & 9= (
62 a5 Q ?5 @2 $ ( % <
& . & 3< ?A P% (
L5R. 3 '
$&
./
&L %
!,.
$& $ @A % ,2
] 7-62 < 7
> 7 3<
!8 2 < < %
&$ /
< Bv7-% $ , ) . & % # $* % V5 <
$- $& Y
2 $ T & 2 G % o2 % $& 5
(]*
' < & '& & R. < & 9= '( F 3B5 & & .(1377 3< 5
8(
&=
. ,& 5 2
9= /5 5 % J %=
/5 ,I $&
&=
& CR e !"% 2 % ]( $ / $%
]O2 (
62 ! 8 2 ]'% *& %
85
$7M % !87 % 7& <= 7M 7a % 1. / % . $& / B8,% /
] O 2 S T ](
7T
7
7M $7& < % ' 62 U T B S t2
%
e
t2 B r,( . 5 ,
.(Akwabi437, 1997) F
5 & '= ?
(
62 SR8 % !I ( /5 #
-Water user's schools

-Farmer Field Schools

122

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

7 # 7% S 8% $ / 5 /& & & /% @% $&


#I ' 2
62 I V5
B X $& U T
. /5 @2 5 , / ?w2 &
e/6 %
& 2 &
e & f $5 %
3(
62 $5 % <
& & X !& @%
A ./ ' = , *%
; 1.
5 e3
@%
2 7 $7& 3 7( /7, 7 !& @% (
62 < 2 ] $5 % 3$
& . o2 % $& 2
.( 4-1153138035 3 62) & 5 % Y5 F
&
7e & . 7 & 7% o 7 = 5 5 7% *
5
'%
*& % 5
(
62
7 u 7 '% V5 e &
/
"% 9 c
1I $& !% . 5 %
5
(
62
.(18 3 13643< 5
>a )
, /# e
* $ F e $1?
71. d 7 % 5
\ @2 $& 1. U 6 / % / (
62
5 !8 2 &z / %
.(Defourney3 19853197)
% a%
62 ( $5 %
/67 $7& { 7& % U $M
$ /
5 tM !% . 3<
62 ( $% & ]'% !% .
85
A ?2
(
X
6T 5
( I
' = !T
( < % !,. $@: %
F 7
< 75 . /7 ( ' $& (
85 4 5
dH / 6,M 4 ,2 4 %
& ;v
7
7& { 7?2
762 ( '
B 62 $ = I $& /?* / 6,M ?, (
32 38 3< 762 )./
& 5
< 62 < % $-,M
'%
a5 !8 % B5 ,'% u @%
( 91-543 1350
/ #6
2 !8 % o2 % $&
62 /1' / # 6 3 A ?2 !5 < ?
/ 6,M F
(253 1349 3]-( ) 5 , %
& %
A ?2 !5
$ / 6,M LA %
./
5
(
62 $-,M
2% e 5
# 2 I ( a5 $6 2 $% f
| & 9= M
762
75 7& G % !% . B5 ,'% $ / 5 < 2 % $ F S T S @ @"2 S 6# :% n ,a%
%
!% . !% < & 9= (
E7F < 7 K . , M !% . K 5E V*5 6$ # $5 %
. *( 5 & 5 S % e
8% !% . K/ % /5 5 % K ( F= K @I ( /5 ,I
/5 5 7% $7& { 7& % 7%
7 P& U @
& 2% 4 %
$ EF U
X A $X F
< X S % B5 # 3$ F S T 9= < F
C % $& #
(<%
&= 9= S * 2
45 $% &
,
9= (
62
62 $ a = 2 (1385 3
V
,"%) 7. ?
.
$M %
62 - :62 I
5 . SR8 % &
!8 2< &
$7& < 7& 9= 7(
762 / # 6
2 & G % !% .
& /5 #
& C ( L @"2 B5
E#
. & % ( !8 2 B5
5 5 < & $& 5 9 -:%

6 _ Start-up Capital
./

'M

2B 5

*& $

F %

= & T 40

123

I 9= C % d5 2 3U @ !I %

9= S >-2 3/ ]-*% $r = - 2

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;


: -+

9=

7(
762
5 & G % !% . & 3< & 9= (
62
75 7& G 7% !% .
& $@?A 5
& R. .
%
$& $M 2 & TOPSISV 82
> & !% . B5 6& $-I % 3
.
7 B5

&.

$e

$% Y

$7& < & 7 S O !5 ?2


3U 7M B75

&.

&5

>

&5

5 & G % !% . & 5
& $@?A
V 82 $U % $- $& < & 9=
%
& $?2 ( 6%

$& $% Y

= d,M Z5 ;5 2 %

-T $> s . ,

31U 7M

! -"2

./ < &

(~

%
& (

( %~
6%

$@?A Y &

& $@?A }- P%

$& < &

5 & Z5 ;5 2 %

. 7, !@ % Z5 ;5 2 % V5 $& <= < & $ / ~


.

&5

(~
>

V5 $& U

,(

( /# I

( YP&

U M

( <

&5

M%

&

F)5 B5 1

& 5 & F)5 B5 2

B%

5 & F)5 B5 2

&3
B%

%=

%4

(CR)

<= & <

e B%

& F)5 B5 1
/

%=
?

- Noriaki kano 8

124

F)5 B5 ](

B%
<= & <

!5 ?2
(~

U M): 10+ 1

F)5 B5 ](

%kM 25

&

&

% S .RA

&
$& < &
( !8 2
& $@?A

= d,M ; J B5

}- P% Sf

U M

+ .&,# /+

&3
%4

%kM 25

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

!"#
,(O) 10
>

6 7

,( M) 9

,(Q) 13=

$& f & U M

,(I) 12;+

>

$W S P %

,( A) 11 91

] *@2 ( R)14? 6

.
$ P % ! ,82

*(

( " 5 &" 5

% O

( sauerwein.1996).
3!7& @%

. 7 %

U 7 "% V75
$7 P %

91

%$

(< ,() .

7 $7W
]( &
5

7F .

(zhang.2001).

8-,.

,
7

,'>

'M 2 ' =

&p 8 %$

. 5

*( 5 ( ~
5= %

&.

M $&

% ? 6

6 7

& O % c

< &

? $ /* # I B5 .

*( 2 P % ;+

%
>

v&

./* ]'% 3

& % '=

% 4#

( $ P % & ] @ *% { ?2 3

%$
>

*(

M $&

P $& $ P % B5 < ?

5 H q. & ( $ P % B5
M

%$ /

$7& 7F)5 /7 . $7

'& ' = Y5 4

8 % !,"2

2 % #

($ P %

H ) S ?. $& /5 '

$ 54(

7I Y 7& /5 7H Y5 47 $7& 7a %
4

% a%(]*

7 % /5 7H Y5 4 q. & /

& / !5 %

&
.

& U

$W

F / 9e

& $&

2
M % S .RA

< & 169 -:% !8 $& <= /5 . . 159 -:% !8


. &$
$% Y
9 7-:% 7( ~7 dA 7@2 3 7( 7% ~7
j U $& I
$ % (f&U M
> &
.]
% !@ % Z5 ;5 2 % $&
&5 U M
9 -:%
Y7 !7 -"2 & >- P% ( , ! -"2 Z5 ;5 2 %
(~ < 2 %<
: 2 ?. ' = B5 ,'% $
M
$%
7A 7O ;78. 7& 7O

&

A+ BC

<= $7 ] 7
$7& <= ] 7

7% $ 7H grade
7% 9 P $

&

& ?

&(# -

5 M < Z5 U M / /,
'
J B5
B5
& $ <= U
( $& { & % ( ~ B & <
.] 54F % & I F)5 $& { & % $@?A < .

Must be Requirement 9One dimensional Requirement 10


Attractive Requirement 11
Indifferent 12
Questionable 13
Reversal 14
Functional 15
Dysfunctional 16

125

!"#
%

D E

A+ B

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;


6 ?

A ) &(# -

75 U 7 "% % 7,. 7( F)5 $& dM $% Y


:% Sf
F $
M @ . B5
7 P2 7' F)5 $7& dM Sf
F %K
$ ( F= P % O 3
( 3 & /% e
%
5. &I
/5 w ~ / B8,% 3 * } <= $&
/5 w $
& U "%
Q 7> 3 R 7> 23 A 7> 19 3 M 7> 18 3D > 19 3I > 25 U V5 $& ~ 85 B & Rw% $
7
&
P2 Y
% F)5 / B8,% % K & % I 3
B5
& U % L?A 3 &
7( 7
3 75 $7:& $- 7 $& 5 &
( B5
&
I ~ <= $& /?* C
. /-. $&
. , 9P
/ ~
!5 62
O+A+M > I+R+Q =max (O,A,M) F
O+A+M < I+R+Q = max (I,R,Q) F
H- +

D IC

+C

J 1 E C&&6 (& +

3<= $- 7 $7& 2 , >


5' U M
%= / $& Z5
<
7 % /5 7H < 4 % $X $& & $
M
% e 5 U "%
O
75 & B5
& . & 5 % Y(
% /5 H < 4 % $X $& & $
/7# I B5 2 7& B5 7 '& < 47 %
7 5 U%
.] 5 , B 62 3]
%$

A ) &(# -3

2 % J B5 ] 5 # L?A
% F)5 F $
B 62
M F & 5 % Y5 4
U M
%= / $& Z5
H U % $& $
5 M<

A+O

M+O

Better =

Worse =
M+I+A+O

(A+O+M+I)(-1)

/5 7H Y5 47 T
]( %
U M <=
C I ( M $& f & ( U %
/7
7 7& .]75 = % / $&
F)5 /5 . . S T /5 H Y(
F)5 /5 . S T
2
% /5 H Y5 4 q. &
& F)5 <= 3
Y5 4 F)5
& A 62 $X ( $ /
7% 7M $7& 5 H
&3
, F)5
& M 62 $X ( 3 U %
% K/5 H Y(
.
,
, X Y5 4 /5 H < 4 % 3 M Y5 4 S T
=
>7
%J . F
& $?2 $@?A ( !% . 5 &
J
> & !% .
& $@?A ;
17
z ( $- $& 1981 U
J B5 ./ TOPSIS V 82 L @"2 B5 !% .
& $?2
&
7% 7 F ] ,7 2 7
( F 5
$- $& $ 54F 5 !% . M J B5 . 5 F $W 18< 5
7& $-7T B5 , 5 & & P !% . ( $ /
& '>% B5 & V 82 B5 . F %
&5
Hwang Yoon -18

126

17

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

!"#
$7

(!7% . B5 72 / ,( ] ) > % U= 5 !% . & $-T B5


& (B5 2 ]'%)/?w% U= 5 !% .
% a
> % /?w% U= 5 !% . & !% . V5 $-T < 4 % 3J B5
5 S ?. $& 3 &
.( 13813 `=)/ !% .
& /5 #
& $M
6% e B5

]W 7 3 7*-& & 3!7& &


H I L @"2
.

7 9 7P
= 7F

( '7 !% 7
F %

?#

/"2 H <

/"2

( 7 % 118
7F

220 <=

$@?A

4& < . $&

,L @"2 B5

"%

F$ , J

& % ?5 M R
>

S P % $%

&

%= $6% M

&<

,(

3'

U% u

$%

&

Y( ) B5

./ F

>

% (

K A &(# + 3

U % ] 5 # L?A & ( 2U M $&) < & 9=


$- 7 $7& B5 $
& $@?A
$e

( !8 2
5
( 6% 2 /

& G % ( 6% 5
;
f (TOPSIS Kano) @ >-2
. 5E % a
U %

<% 3
$@?A
6% ( P %
a ( 6%
& $@?A $8 5 ;
7( 6% f 2 ?7 "% !7I % 7A ; 3
% TOPSIS V 82
> & '=
& $?2
./ 5 4 3 U M $& %= / $& Z5 $
& /5 #
< & 9=

( !8 2

M
62 [ 2

62 [ 2 <

LE

% 9= $&

$&

<

62 [ 2
<

$&

2< =

9= G % &

62 \ 1. $&
nRA

& G % !% . / ' :2U M

S @ @"2

20

/'M

21

1.

22

&

LE

5 $&= LI
P& L-62
62 $& $5 % B % 2
5 e & < & 9=

62 $5 %
, *%

J %=

62 B # 0*% /5 5 % \

@I !W *% J %=
62 \ 1. /
,-.

% 9= $&
&= $8? S *

<
2

%
(

2< =
' J %=

23

5E

127

F -M
/# S O

3
4

62 B # 0*% Y 54F

25

B%2
;

( $8? /5 5 % / # 0*% U @

24

26
62 /5 5 %

62 $& 9=

62 !W *%
S @% <

o5 2

/#
<

, /# e
/

%
62

5
6
7

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

!"#
27
62 /5 5 % /

%$I

62 /5 5 % (
%

62 \ 1. $&

[ 2\ 1.
< &o
<

% !?

&

SR "2

< & 9=

62 S , , 2

/5 ,I

29

< & 9=

62

% B 62

10

](

11

30

& 45 $% & /'M ]O % S *-M ! 8 2


62 /5 5 %

31

8(

32

<

&

< % S % < ? P %
5
&
62 [ 2

% SR8 % !I
B # 0*% $& $6M %

< & 9=

33

62 < &

O%

62

34
< & 9=

28

62 /5 5 %
nRA
S .RA
#%

5 %9

62 B # 0*% 9 P
<

% < 62 $@&

62 /5 5 % /

!W *%

e ] @ *%

&

&

$% u
&=

&

<

(]*

?'&

12

9= / > >I

13

&= /*5 [ "% >I

14

B5

B5

9= /

Re

<

<

"%

15

X
35

% !@ % 9= & $

36

[ 2

2? S =U

16

( B % $,( Y

17

62 < 8% < ? '


M B>-2 3| &

62 < 8%

e&

< & 9= !8 2 [ 2
< & 9= !8 2

62
37

9= ]aI u

& 9=

38

<

&

XY

$ R.

% !t B % 2

EF /,
$. 4%
%

18

% 9= ]' S ?G

19

L @"2
TOPSISJ
D&"

>

& % 4# $@?A

NE

( 6%
M

0.82
0.79

62 /5 5 %
!W 7*%

7%

762 \ 1. $&

nRA

0.75
0.66
0.65

<

S @ @"2

<

&

62 \ 1. /
,-.

62 [ 2

M B>-2 3| &

0.54

62 !W *%

0.53

% !@ % 9= & $
<

$&

%
(

2
3
4

XY

% SR8 % !I
B # 0*% $& $6M %

62 < 8%

/#
M

&= $8? S *

128

5E

62 /5 5 %
nRA
S .RA
#%

< & 9= !8 2 [ 2

0.60

0.51

& $?2 :3 U M

e&
, /# e

2? S =U
2

' J %=

7
8
9

( $ 5 :Ee %

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

!"#
0.48

0.46

62 [ 2

0.43

B5

&= /*5 [ "% >I

% 9= $&

< & 9=
/

0.41

<

e ] @ *%

0.36

$. 4%

% 9= ]aI u

0.34

< & 9=

0.32

62 $& 9=

0.27

B5
&

11

/5 ,I

12

9= / > >I

13

62

62 B # 0*% 9 P

& 9=

&

&

Re

EF /,
% B 62

( $8? /5 5 % / # 0*% U @

62 [ 2

0.26

2< =

<

62 S , , 2

0.41

( B % $,( Y
9= /

&

0.21
0.21

8(

<

<

$7

O <

65

7( 7% < 7 /7
# 7% !W 7*% 7%
. < & 9=
< 7
O (( ,-.
$7& 7,-. 7(
7

%
.

14
15
16
17
18

"%

19

62 B # 0*% Y 54F

20

&=

21

(] *

L @"2
M

10

?'&

( $ 5 :Ee %

&$
% 4# !% . F
3U M !% .
'P
F % 5 /5 H . q. & <=
?, $ F (
'=
& $?2 TOPSIS J u
& $ ,| U M
%= / & Z5
62 \ 1. $&
62 /5 5 %
nRA )) (( 62 /5 5 % 5E @ ))
(
62
5 a5
% 4# $@?A !% . 5
2f & $?2 ((S .RA
(
nRA (
S @ @"2
62 \ 1. / %)) B r,(
nRA . d
/ < & 9=
62
5
% 4# !% . V5
./
( e U ? $& $OIR% !& /5 H . 3<

129

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

!"#
TOPSISJ

>

&

6& V5 $@?A

( 6%

& $?2 :4 U M

NE
D&"
0.85

M
/5 5 7% [7 2\ 1.

7& 475 $% & /'M ]O % S *-M ! 8 2


62

0.82

62 /5 5 % /

0.76

62 \ 1. $&

0.76

/# S O &

0.74

62 [ 2 <

0.67

$&

9= G %

&

5 $&= LI

< & 9=

62

&

0.59

$% u

<

62 /5 5 % /

0.35
7& < 7& o7

% !7?

J %=

P& L-62
62

](

% < 62 $@&

8
9

% !t B % 2

10

62 /5 5 % (

SR "2

11

< % S % < ? P %
5

12

5 7% 9 7

L @"2
7O

$ R.

< & 9= !8 2

0.33

F -M

62 < 8% < ? '

0.57

0.20

@I !W *% J %=

62 B # 0*% /5 5 % \

$7& $5 % 7 B % 72 /7'M

0.60

%$ I

( $ 5 :Ee %

; .
%
&$
6& V5 !% . F
4U M !% .
'P
. , ( e !,"2 P $& ' = M . U I B .
'=
&
'& $X ( $W
$7 7( 7% < /
& $?2 TOPSIS J u
& $ ,| U M
%= / & Z5
!7% . 7 5
2f & $?2 (( 62 /5 5 % [ 2\ 1.
& 45 $% & /'M ]O % S *-M ! 8 2))
(( 762 /5 5 % / % $ I )) !% . F . < & 9= (
62
5 a5
6& V5 $@?A
$& $@?A B5
4 2 $?2 o 2 2 $& $ ((SU S O &
62 B # 0*% /5 5 % \
F -M))
$7># % B5 7 ,'%)) $7 /7 F $7a < 72 7% ] 5 , $ H U !% . $& 4
( % e e
2 & EF G 2
.((/
62 k "T /5 5 % 6& V5 $@?A < & 9= ( !8 2 / # 6
< 7 $7& ,7 9= G 7% & 7 J 7%=)) (( 62 \ 1. $&
@I !W *% J %=)) B r,(
1. <
J %= q"& $& { & % $
*(
]a
( $?2 o 2 2 $& (( 62 [ 2
./
62

130

!"#
TOPSISJ
D&"

>

& 9 EM

NE

( 6%

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;


& $?2 :5 U M

0.60

< & 9=

0.48

62 S @% <

o5 2

62 < &

O%

<

/ %)) (( < & 9=


62 < & O % X )) $ ( % < $% Y
!T I Z5 ! -"2
/5 H ' = M
65 3 *( (9 EM) 4 !% . n4M ((
62 S @% < o5 2 <
% 5 H q. & ( $ P % B5 ? $ /* # I B5 . = % 5
& $OIR% !&
& O% X
62 / ,( < 4 % ( % <
TOPSIS J & !% .
& $?2 .
,
./
62 S @% < o5 2 / %
&<
:; E JS &

7( !87 2 B5 < &


9= /5 5 % $ %
7 7% ' 7 3L @"2
a
F $a
$
19
<
$7& S 7% -& S % 2
( $% & I A $&
75 <
/5 H k: \ @2 & $
$ F $&

< & 9= ( !8 2
- Y@ $& $M 2 &
FS T
& q"& $& $M 2 & %
?&= (
62 ?
U 0*% (
< & 9= '-8 2 L %
/'M 5
. 5, U?
(
62 B5
:;

72

$% & V5 A

F % '

$ F
% 4# $@?A $
.
6& V5 % 4# !% . %
$
.20
= % 5 <5 %
5f & 5 H
7& 475 $7% & /7'M ]O 7% S 7*-M ! 87 2 ) L7 @"2 B5 ( $
( 62 \ 1. $&
@I !W *% J %=) ,( 62 /5 5 % / % $ I
7%
62 \ 1. $&
62 /5 5 %
nRA ) ,( 62 /5 5 %
( ,-. (
nRA (
S @ @"2
62 \ 1. /

% )

A -1

-% . 62
$& $M 2 &
5 , -% . $W $&
3S %
S ?M % 3!% . B5 $W
.
5u
& !% . B5 B5 ,'%
) ,( 62 /5 5 % [ 2\ 1.
5E @ )
6& V5 $@?A
%) (S .RA
# % !W *%
.
& % % 4# $@?A
;

S(

-2

(
62 B5
$W S % e <
/5 H $& { % < & 9= ( !8 2
5 $8 5 $& $M 2 &
7A 7*5 & / 5 ( e Y5 4 < & 9= ( !8 2 <
S O 2= ( U
A
& %
$@: % 9= /

131

'M S - 19
14-4 U M $&
n M - 20

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

. 5 , < & 9=
62 S % e <
!7% . 7F $7
F
-% .

/5 H & G % !% . $ - ?'& $&


S % -& $% & V5
& 4 ,2
EF $5 % /5 #
%$T 2
B5
./
, o*
5f & $?2 $ F
6& V5 9 EM
[7 2 < 7 $7& , 9= G % & J %=) L @"2 B5 ( $ 5 u
& !% . B5 B5 ,'%
9=
762 < 7& 7O % 7 X)
6& V5 $@?A ( 62 \ 1. $&
@I !W *% J %=) ( 62
.
& % 9 EM $@?A ( 62 S @% < o5 2 <
/ %) (< &
:T S

.< '23< 5
/5 5 7 7% U 7 7@

8(
& 7 75 J

&= -% $ , 3
9=
'&3(1382) 3 # e3 3 *I
Y5 7 7 7 7, ( 3(1381) 3 r777*% 3C3 -. B& 3 3< 5 7 7 I
.< '23< 5
8(
&= -% $ , 3 3($,M 2)
&=
&= -% $ , 3 3($,M 2)3
&= S % e U @
( , ( 3(1380)3 !F
3 3 45 '
< '2 3< 5
8(
/5 5 7 %
7 / 7 % 7'M 9 7a23(1377)< 7 5 7 8(
7 &= 7-% $77 ,
.< '23< 5
8(
&= -% $ , 3
&=
Sf @% $. ,a% . 'M S & a2 9 X X 3] ( >% :
%
&= /5 5 % .(1378) .9 3 >a
$7* % :< 7'2 . 7 8(
7 &= ( $8? /5 5 % / ,(
&
,-. 5 ,( F B #
.63-79 3
45 $% & ( Y( )
S 7 3< 7'2 3 7 < 762 47 % < % 3 62 S * +%
K(1349) ;
3]-(
.< 62 < %
<7 e< 7
7. S 7 # 2 $67 2 "% 9= 3(1385)
3n 3 3n3 V
,"%
23 , 34 -M3 H < e
'M $% ?e 3 H
.< 62 < % S
3< '2 3
< 62 -% 82
K(1349)
< 62 4 % < %

.1
.2
.3
.4
.5

.6
.7
.8

9. Akwabi-Ameyaw, Kofi (March 1997); Producer cooperative resettlement projects in


Zimbabwe: Lessons from a failed agricultural development strategy, World
Development, Vol. 25, Issue 3, pp. 437-456.
10. Burger, R. 1998, Water users associations in Kazakstan: an institutional analysis.
Central Asian Republics, Harvard Institute fo r International Development USA.
11. Defourney, Jacques; Estrin, Saul; Jones, Derek C (June 1985); The effects of
workers participation on enterprise performance, Empirical evidence from French
cooperatives, International Journal of Industrial Organization, Vol. 3, Issue 2, pp.
197-217.
12. FAO. 1996, Irrigation in Asia: Water Reports. FAO, Rome

132

!"#

$ %&'()*+ ,) -. /01 2 34 56 78 9:;

13. Lin, Z. C. 2002 , Participatory irrigation management by farmers: Local


incentives for self_ financing irrigation and drainage distrlcts in china . the
environment and social development unit , WBOB.
14. Narayan, D. (1995), The contribution of people s participation Evidence from 121
rural water supply projects, International Bank for Reconstruction and development,
Washington, DC.
15. Peter, J. R. 2004 . Participatory irrigation management , International network on
participatory irrigation management, washington DC.
16. Sauerwein E., F.bailom, K.Matzler, H.Hinterhuber (1996), The kano model:how to
delight your customers, International Working Seminar on Production Economics,
Vol.I of the IX, pp. 313 327.
17. Vermillion, D. L. 1997, Management devolution and the sustainability of irrigation:
results of comprehensive versus partial strategies, Presented at the FAO/World
Bank Technical Consultation on Decentralization and Rural Development, Rome
18. Zhang P, G,Von dran (2001), Expectations and ranking of website Quality
Features:Results of two Studies on User perceptions,Proceeding of the Hawaii
international conference on system science (HICSS 34).

133